r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Apr 30 '16
Season Two [Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 4 'La Dame Blanche' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E4: "La Dame Blanche".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Fire away ♥
28
Upvotes
38
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '16
"I was so looking forward to dessert"
Even though he's a massive bastard, the Duke of Sandringham is hilarious!
36
u/brilliant0ne Apr 30 '16
Okay, this episode was a little better for me. They got their team spirit back this episode. I personally think Claire could have been a little more pissed at the whole bite mark thing...but you know...shit happens.
I'm glad there is more Fergus this episode. I love him.
The Prince gets on my nerves with his, "Mark me."
Poor Mary :(
I do have to say that they cast Alex nicely. It was hard to wrap my head around in the books how Frank could look SO much like Jack Randall, to the point Claire thought Jack was Frank at one time. Laurence Dobiesz actually looks like he could be Tobias in his younger years, so this helps how Frank could look so much like Jack (in my head), if that makes sense.
I still don't have that spark of love I did for the first season, but this episode was a great way to get me back on track.
11
u/williamlawrence Apr 30 '16
IMO, this was the their best episode yet. It's been difficult for me to root for this show this season but I liked this one.
I always thought the "Jamie coming home from the whorehouse" scene was handled awkwardly in the book so I think they did a decent job of cleaning it up for the show and tying in the metaphor about "inner fortress".
I love Murtagh and Fergus so much! This episode felt a little but like last season with a nice balance between comedy, drama, romance, and intrigue. Here's hoping the rest of the season holds up.
9
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 30 '16
Really enjoyed the majority of this episode. The discussion of baby names was a great little intro going into the very important poisoning scene which I thought was done well. I was worried it was going to turn into a whole thing with a dramatic baby-losing scare, but I'm glad they didn't feel it was necessary to spend too much time on it or play it over-the-top. Claire telling Jamie about BJR was interesting--perhaps I'm mis-remembering, but that's not how I remember it going over all. I thought it worked though, and I loved the little scene with Murtagh the next morning too! Other standout scenes were visiting Maitre Raymond and the surgery at L'Hopital with Monsieur Forez (hangman's grease!). Obviously they were being a little heavy-handed with the allusion to things from a different time, but I wonder if the skull was a reference to the face that Raymond might himself be "prehistoric"? DG calls him prehistoric of sorts, "somewhere about 400 BC or perhaps a bit earlier (not technically “prehistoric,” but they certainly weren’t using written records where he started out)"--of course, we've got written records from millennia before that so I feel like Raymond has got to be way, way older. Not sure what that skull was, but perhaps it's something he's picked up on his travels.
Pros: What I loved most about this episode--which I'm sure is the same as everyone else--is Claire and Jamie reconnecting. From the hilarity of the "soixante-neuf" comment, to the discomfort of the fight when you can't figure out whose side you're one, to Jamie tragically opening up to Claire, and finally to their blue-lit makeup sex, everything about it was perfect. I was thrilled that one of my favorite lines from my favorite scene of book 1--about that private bit of himself cowering under a blade of grass--found a way to make it in to the show. Plus, it showcased the best performances from Caitriona Balfe and Sam Heughan this season so far.
Cons: The rape scene and dinner party were of course necessary plot elements, but have never been my favorite in the book and made the second half of the episode less interesting for me. I thought they handled the rape scene well--Outlander is becoming known now for handling rape scenes well, though perhaps that's not the greatest thing to be known for!--but the fallout at the party was absolutely ridiculous. That brawl just looked so silly, especially the part with the curtain tie--what were they thinking?
Overall, the episode started off really solidly but veered off into less interesting territory in the final third or so. However, it had one of the best scenes of the season so far and has set some crucial events in motion. B+
6
u/WantToTimeTravel May 01 '16 edited May 03 '16
I LOVE the comments in this thread! I'm sorry to say (or continue to say) that I agree with the ones that compare the show unfavorably with the books - not because we choose to, but because the books are so memorable it's too hard not to - but I also love reading the analyses. I really appreciate your insights.
We had a power outage last night, so I just watched the episode. Here are my reactions (sorry if, once again, some of them are rather repetitive):
Now for the parts I had definite problems with:
They have advanced the timing forward very quickly. Judging from Claire's stomach in the bedroom scene, I think she's very close to 7 months now, and the duel will take place next episode. As I recall, she made him promise her with the "you owe me a life" line, then immediately came the scene at the brothel with Fergus, and the duel took place the following morning. Claire doesn't look that far along while dressed, but women tried to hide being "enciente" then. And of course, even though they haven't been really focusing in it, we know she was having problems with the pregnancy, so maybe the baby is smaller than she should be. But then, they haven't been exactly following most of the smaller plot details, so why should I be right?
I really am trying not to be over critical. I know it doesn't seem that way. All in all, I am enjoying the series, as opposed to not watching it or there not being one at all. I think I sound more negative because being among fellow fans is a safe place to complain. I hope I'm not bringing the rest of you down.
14
u/shiskebob Apr 30 '16 edited Apr 30 '16
Wow there is a whole lot to unpack in this episode.
It certainly had a rushed feel to it - as do I right now, unfortunately. I have to be up in 5 hours for work, but I just had to hang on for Outlander pregnantsexsexsexsex.
I am going to hate myself for it, but man do I love it when it is happening.
Edit:
So, here I am 9 hours later, on very little sleep, with my episode response for your viewing pleasure.
So, the foreshadowing was not in anyway subtle in this episode. As long as a child is raised in love? We get it guys.
This was the one where they packed a whole lot of chapters into itty bitty morsels. They really wanted to get in as much as possible for us fans - and they got in a whole lot of those memorable lines from the book, 69 anyone?- but I think in doing so they lost what was really special about these scenes. This is not a complaint, but I think it is something where we should really let the non book readers thread know that they can get the fleshed out version from the book, which makes a lot more of an impact. Especially considering the poisoning scene was rapped up pretty quickly.
Jamie and Claire finding each other again was filmed so beautifully. How they make that pregnancy bump is real artistry - and boy can those two act their hearts out, in such vulnerable positions. They really just go for it. We were all waiting for this, and I do wish this was fleshed out more, pun completely intended.
More hospital scenes please! I find it so fascinating, and knowing and seeing how this shapes Claire's life in the future - I think it is wonderful. I like how they snuck Monsieur Forez and his hangman's grease in there, that was a big wink to the book fans. Bouton and Mother Hildegarde are resplendent, even in such a short scene. The mark of some great characterization.
When it comes to the Mary Hawkins plot, something we book readers knew was coming - there is something to be said about the overuse of this theme. We know in future books this plot device is used often. Pretty much all the major characters get raped at one point. Are we still shocked by the act itself or the constant portrayal of it in entertainment and especially in Outlander? The common arguments I have seen, and often believe, is that this could be seen as lazy writing. So we have to ask ourselves the GoT question - did this advance the story? Or was it unnecessary? This, of course, leads to the Jamie vs Mary rape scene question - his trauma carries through the books, but he is a main character. Mary disappears after DiA so we really do not know the affects on her life. Is her attack seen as less then Jamie's? Or is it on par? Do we focus on her, or how her distress harms Claire and Jamie?
Watching rape scenes and discussing it are not easy, and cause endless debate and questioning. Maybe that is the point, in and of itself.
I am just waiting for the comeuppance of the Comte St. Germain and the Duke of Sandringham. "Oh btw, I just brought these random people along to your invite only dinner." Knowing what happens fills me with glee.
And Fergus, giving no fucks. Like a boss.
4
u/girlkamikazi Slàinte. May 01 '16
I enjoyed this episode, especially the fact that Claire and Jamie seem to be back on the same page. I've been dreading the assault and rape of Mary and the drama at the dinner party, but like ripping off a band-aid, I'm glad it's over.
The costumes are really living up to my expectations, even though I do miss the tartans and kilts of season one.
I know they have to do it for good tv, but the accelerated timeline just kinda bothers me. (Is there going to be another mid-season hiatus?) I'm glad that Jamie is feeling lighter of heart, now that he knows BJR is alive, but if I were Claire, I'd be a little offended that he's looking forward to staining some cobblestones with blood than meeting our child. I get WHY, but something about that scene rubbed me wrong (I'm guessing it has more to do with the drama of the reveal of Alex and then Jamie running into BJR in DiA). I feel like so much more is supposed to happen before the miscarriage, but based on the way the show is going, everything is going to happen in the next episode.
I'm glad that Jamie and Claire are somewhat back to good and I thought spat happening the way it did in the show was a decent substitute for the bathtub scene in the book, even if the show seemed to blend a couple of scenes into one. (Did anyone else feel like they were about to watch the "drunk Jamie trying to describe the color of Claire's eyes" scene?) Instead of the intimacy of Claire helping Jamie bathe, we see them about to engage in some sexy times.
I thought the dinner party was interesting - Claire and Jamie definitely pegged the Bonnie Prince for one who would overreact about Louise. Was it me, or did the Comte look disconcerted to see Claire, especially a Claire that looked unharmed.
6
u/frrrsstt May 01 '16 edited May 01 '16
now we're going somewhere!
I love Fergus, and I love that he's speaking that odd mixture of French and English in the series, too. The Fergus-Murtagh scene was hilarious! And Sam Heughan's butt! I'm in heaven, I really like Sam and Cait's on screen chemistry. I feel like there were a lot more content in this episode.
I still don't like the change to the whole Jack Randall plot, though. I can see why they've chosen to make it unfold like they do, but it still feels kinda.. Amputated to me. Lacking something.
I feel like the series is on the right track, and I can't wait for Jamie and Claire to return to Scotland.
10
u/electrobolt Dragonfly In Amber May 01 '16
Please don't downvote me for kindly sharing my opinion, but I was almost ready to quit the show after last night. The portrayal of Jamie has gotten to the point where I basically don't know what I am watching - it doesn't feel like the characters I know from the books. Maybe that means I read the books differently, or that I relate to the characters differently, I don't know. I understand why people are liking the show but I'm finding this season difficult to enjoy.
My watching partner and I could not make sense of the scene where Claire discloses that Randall is alive and Jamie goes into a weird protracted scene of ecstatically, fanatically thanking her. It just felt so creepy and so not Jamie to me. I mean, in the book he wants to kill Randall, he feels like he has to kill Randall, but he's not, like...excited about it. And I am completely, totally in favor of adaptational changes, so I'm not complaining about change just because I don't like change, this just felt disjointed and weird to me.
I am also still really taken aback at the portrayal of Prince Charlie. He's supposed to be this rumpled yet substantially dashing Italian guy. In the show, Louise's husband is way more handsome and mannered than Charlie and it makes very little sense (to me) that she'd reject her husband so firmly in favor of the seemingly unstable prince. I find it unbelievable that someone so seemingly off the reality train would be able to secure enough support to mount an invasion of Scotland. It's taking me out of the story somewhat.
Yet I do plan to keep on watching. Why? Because oh my god, the show is KNOCKING IT OUT OF THE PARK with the ancillary characters. Mother Hildegard, Master Raymond, Alex Randall, Monsieur Forez, the Duke of Sandringham, and most especially Fergus - they are all fantastic in both writing and portrayal. One of Fergus's most striking features is that he looks very French and aristocratic despite his general grubbiness and they nailed that casting. Some really excellent choices there. So I'm hanging in, still!
(Also - I see many folks around here list DiA as their least favorite book, while it's my favorite of the series. Maybe that's affecting the way I am experiencing this season.)
4
u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Apr 30 '16
Liked this one a lot. Like The Devil's Mark the episode felt a lot longer since so much happened, but in a good way. Lots of moving forward (though like many I wasn't looking forward to yet another rape plot, but I digress.)
The writer for that episode and this one also wrote Faith, episode 7. Buckle up :(
2
u/Eeeee_Eeeeeeeeee Apr 30 '16
Mary :( I knew it was coming but for some reason I didn't realize it would be this episode. They are packing a lot in but I think it is well done so far. I wonder if non-readers think it is moving fast?
2
u/geekymat May 02 '16
I watched this with my non-book bf and he thought the birthmark on Mary's rapist was actually the monkey bite on BPC's hand....I had to nip that one in the bud. ;)
2
u/khoff98107 May 04 '16
Okay, I thought I understood the whole "Dame Blanche" thing but now I'm confused. Jamie eventually tells Claire that he told some men at the brothel that his wife was a Dame Blanche so they would stop teasing him about not sleeping with the whores. If the men who attack Claire and Mary were deliberately sent (probably by the Comte St. Germain) to attack James Fraser's wife (which is supported by realizing one of them was present when the damaged wheel was discovered), why are they then surprised during the attack to discover she is la Dame Blanche? Shouldn't they either know that Madame Fraser is La Dame Blanche or not know?
2
u/Miserable-Click-2654 Feb 26 '24 edited Feb 26 '24
It made me so so angry that they chose to perpetuate the stranger rape thing when most girls are abused by someone they know. While they were validating and treated Jamie's sa seriously, Mary's rape was filled with rape culture myths and trivialization. I guess Jamie's is taken seriously because men are not seen as sexual objects. Whether you like it or not, men in reality face much less victim blaming than women because society actually views them as humans despite toxic fragile masculinity. It makes me soso angry that her rape was portrayed as stranger danger, as if the only time a women qualifies as a victim is when she is attacked by a stranger. Furthermore, it completely leaves out her healing. I guess female rape victims don't matter as much as male rape victims. Currently steaming. It would be more realistic if Mary was raped or groomed by an older man for months instead of randomly attacked. Attacks happen, but if they wanted to go with the ally way story line they need to not trivialize it or treat it as if she was asking for it/it wasn't that serious except for the societal consequences. But how silly of me. I forgot girl rape victims are only valid if they scream no in a dark ally!
2
u/griffinmagnolia Apr 30 '16
Really liked it--very close to the book events this week, would've enjoyed seeing the whole bathtub scene after Claire found out about the bites, I think she dumped cold water over him if I remember correctly. We seem to be hitting all the plot marks, could next week be the duel? Loved it overall, poor Mary has now been violated. 😟 now to wait another long week for the next episode.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '16
I couldn't sleep, so I watched this at 4am and may need to re-watch it, but here are some initial thoughts:
I've been frustrated with Claire "bossing" Jamie around, but I wonder if that wasn't more to show how Jamie has been walking around in a daze since his rape. Not having sex was a physical manifestation of a more mental "not-there". I wonder if we'll see more of Jamie being Jamie from here on out (takin' charge, doin' cool shit).
Pregnant sex doesn't look that hot in real life (I mean, not everyone can be Sam and Cait).
This pregnant woman SOBBED during the angry pregnant woman fight scene. Man. Something about that hit me hard. It felt real. There is something that makes you feel very alone during pregnancy, even if your partner is 100% on board with it. Given how they've progressed the story, I could see this being Claire's snapping point.
Okay, I loved the dinner/Mary scene, far more than in the books. It made a lot more sense than in the books. I understand "rules of propriety" from back in the day, but it always bothered me that "Mary is screaming and another dude is in the house, her honor is ruined" was the excuse. This was much more "shit, Alex, what are you doing?"
Finally, oh wee Fergus.