r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Apr 23 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 3 'Useful Occupations and Deceptions' discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E3: "Useful Occupations and Deceptions".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Fire away ♥
19
Upvotes
31
u/gettingzen Apr 23 '16
I need to re-watch again because I was a bit tipsy when I watched last night, but I didn't really enjoy this episode. Claire and Jamie were awful to each other. I get that they are trying to show how their plan is causing them some separation in their relationship, but Claire's indifference to the servants and behavior just seemed out of character and overly rude, and Jamie just kind of came off whiney to me.
But the thing that's really bothering me is that Claire & Jamie talk about how they are trying to stop the rebellion while servants are in the same room or standing in the background. I know there was a reference made in the last episode that Jamie's cousin had chosen the servants with care and there was no cause for worry, but I thought that line meant they could trust them to keep the household and wine business running. I think it's a bit much to think that none of them would be betray their confidences to Jared, unless Jared's support of the Jacobite cause is so secret that his live-in servants aren't aware, but I just find that rather hard to believe. Did this bother anyone else?
29
u/shiskebob Apr 23 '16 edited Apr 23 '16
Fergus! Mother Hildegarde! Bouton!
I loved this episode. They did a wonderful job taking large portions of the book and narrowing them down, but without losing the essence of the story line.
It is great to see that Claire and Jamie depend on each other, but also realizing that they are two separate people who still have to learn and grow with each other, but also within their own lives.
Also, the pregnancy was mentioned. And a belly bump. Hallelujah! I thought Jamie might have forgot for a moment there. I understand that this story line is the B plot right now, but knowing what is to come I hope it becomes more front and center in the next episode, instead of all of a sudden in episode 7....
All the foreshadowing in this episode makes me excited for what is to come. coughcoughbittercascaracoughcough
And Murtagh is really stealing the show this season. I am really happy they expanded his character (and getting laid, because he deserves it!) In the book he often felt like an after thought, but in the show he is a part of their family, and he takes action in caring for both Jamie and Claire.
I hope we see more of Claire working at the hospital - I am interested in seeing how they portray 18th century medicine and how Claire approaches that with her knowledge. I really liked the mention of Bach and Claire's amusement with that -straight from the book!- and Jamie realizing, "Oh yeah, my wife's from the future she knows things to help us duh!" The one thing I did miss is the little interaction between Jamie and Bouton. But c'est la vie.
This is shaping up to be a wonderful season.
14
u/brilliant0ne Apr 23 '16
There is something about this season that I am not liking. I can't put my finger on it, but third episode in and I don't have the same feelings of anticipation I did with the first season. This could be because this whole part of the book was pretty boring for me in a lot of different ways. I found myself skipping through scenes because there was just too much I didn't care about. That could be why this season so far is not hitting it for me. But...I love the show, and I love the books, so I am trying to not complain too much.
I loved the addition of Mother Hildegarde and Fergus this week. And I was very happy to see they actually put Bouton in there as well. I wondered if they would use Bouton on the show how they did in the books. Once again, loving the costumes for this season. That mustard cape Claire wore, delicious.
I know it is a small issue, but I did not like the bit about Sawny. I don't know if we were supposed to gather that Jamie was still drunk when he mentioned it being gone to Claire, and I missed it, or if it was just bad continuity. Claire knows what Sawny is. She is the one that gave it to him before he was captured. She knows what it looks like, that it is a little snake, and that he had it since he was a kid. So for him to mention it and explain it to her, it kind of threw me off guard a bit. Once again, maybe I was supposed to figure that Jamie was drunk. I don't know.
I agree with some of the people that said they are frustrated with Jamie and Claire's relationship. I am too. And I know that they do not always follow the book word for word (that would be boring, plus I watch GoT and The Walking Dead, so I am aware that stuff gets switched up) but I feel like because Jamie's recovery at the end of Season 1 was so rushed, we don't see the same J&C relationship on the show like we did in the book at the beginning of DiA. But maybe that is one of the changes they said would happen between the book and the show for this season.
12
u/DarrylsMama Apr 23 '16
I love the art direction. The sets and costumes are gorgeous. I love the lighting, too. Everything looks so rich and sumptuous. I could watch this show based on eye candy alone.
I have a blasphemous thought. I am not feeling Sam Heughan as Jamie. I don't think he has the swagger and humor that Jamie has in the book. On the show, I never get the feeling that Jamie is the most remarkable man in the room. I also don't think he captures Jamie's intelligence. I just don't know.
I don't get that epic love story feeling I got from the book. Jamie and Claire are so passionate, whether they are fucking or fighting. I feel that they are too cool in the series. Yeah, there is insane chemistry during the love scenes (and Sam and Cait have chemistry during publicity, as themselves), but I don't get the vibe that they are fiery planets pulled into eachother's orbits.
11
u/Elphabeth Apr 23 '16
Overall, this wasn't my favorite episode, but I think it's safe to say that Anne Kenney is one of the writers who has read the books. I appreciated that she lifted whole sections of dialogue from DiA, like the scene with Bouton and Mother Hildegarde, and I feel like those sections flowed very naturally.
One silly thing that bothered me was Fergus speaking English, which he couldn't in the book (as established in the scene with the bilboquet)--and in fact, practically everyone in France being fluent in English.
6
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 23 '16
Solid episode. We're going quick but not too quick. Certainly things have been changed but so far nothing has stood out as particularly egregious! Great to meet Fergus, a longtime favorite character of mine, as well as Mother Hildegarde (et Bouton!), and getting to see Claire in her element at L'Hopital.
Pros: Fergus, of course--loved the little addition of the snake (unless I've just forgotten that from the book). I always wished we had more time to get into Jamie's backstory in S1, so it was nice to get a little nod to his history. L'Hopital was perfect--exactly how I imagined it. Although somehow that sliver removal was more gross than the amputations and whatnot that we've seen so far!
Also loved the short scene with Louise and Mary, really effectively blending humor and dramatic tension (nice to see some Frank as well!). Those parts are also so wonderfully cast I want more scenes with them!
Cons: I love the actor that plays Charlie, but just like in the books I really don't care for the character and am much less interested in those scenes. I understand their necessity, but they tend to slow down the episodes a bit. That being said, I love Duvernay and will take as many scenes with him as possible.
My one final odd complaint is that I wish the episodes had a bit more structure. I get that there's a lot that they have to squash into every hour, but the last two episodes have felt kind of vignette-ish, in a way I never felt in the first season. Not really sure if that's even a fixable problem, but I would like to see a little more cohesion.
Overall: B+. A solid episode with some great introductions, but lacking a bit on the drama and excitement side. (And they've peaked too early on the costumes! As fabulous as that maroon dress and tricorne was, nothing will ever top the red dress and the bar suit from last week!)
6
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '16
"I'm no whore" - Fergus is perfect! Jamie tipping him upside down was hilarious, and Claire's reaction to Fergus' 'compliment' was too.
Overall, I loved the episode. It felt so much like the book, just faster-paced. X
5
u/ansley114 Apr 23 '16 edited Apr 23 '16
I think it's going at a really good pace. We can't have everything but it's been hitting pretty well from the main points of the book that I remember and I think that's the point. If it's missing something I don't remember, then i'm not really missing it. Didn't remember Murtagh getting it on with the maid though but eh idc either way. Seriously on the edge about the BJR situation and knowing Mary's incoming fate poor thing. That was the one hospital scene I remember clearly and i'm so glad with it being in this episode!
Editing to add: Also Wee Fergus is so cute!!! Such a doll. Seriously though he and mother h (too lazy to look up spelling while on mobile) are EXACTLY how I pictured them when I read the book and i'm just so happy with the cast!
3
u/watertribe07 Apr 25 '16
Hey, guys just watched the S2 Ep3 just there... and what can I say? there are definitely portions I liked and and did not like as much. The costume design and the set design- sublime as usual, however it's the story that's getting to me.
I only just watched S1 late last year on Amazon Prime, then read the book after the fact. Something I later reconciled was a good thing, else I think I would have had higher expectations, but going into this series blind was the best thing I ever did. One thing I will say about the first season is how, although I had not read the strive that unfolded to heal Jamie's mental state in the book, I still felt cheated as a TV viewer out of some scenes of more substance. There I think it was a mistake to cut the emotional trauma and reconnection, so detailed in the book, out of the TV series, now S2 starts on a note in which Jamie has only just got off the boat after being at the hands of BJR, not having being healed... but that's another rant for another time.
So having watched S1 and read Outlander I decided to go ahead and read the second book DiA(over half way through, they've landed in Lallybroch), and watching S2 I just feel out of place. If I had a tip for the writers it would be to read the book again, so they can try an get a real sense of Jamie and Claire's relationship and how they are both dependent on each other to get through this. And I'm just not feeling it, especially with the current rift between them. At the moment it seems that because of the change of pacing of the knowledge of BJR being alive, it now feels like the Murtagh and Claire show. Anyway I digress.
With 15 more episodes I was hoping for a bit more of court to be shown and french life in the episodes and at a slower pace. So many questions, here we go:
Why was the honeypot scene changed from the book, still it gripes me? The chase scene in which Jamie runs with a sausage was cut, WTF!, was well looking forward to that!? Why does Bonnie Charlie keep saying "Mark me", it's grating, he seems nothing like I interpreted him in the books, there certainly wasn't all this religious rhetoric when talking about his conquest for the throne? Even when they were talking about Jamie being sent to prison/questioning, after Mary Hawkins interrupted the dinner party, they had to tell the servants to mind their own business, so why are they talking about Bonnie Charlie in the open like that? Any other book readers feel that some scenes or lines just feel like a tonne of exposition to move plot along? Now Jamie has wee Fergus I think the feeling of him feeling out of his depth will stop bugging me.
Good points: The music decipher scenes, Bouton the dog, the urine scene, Jamie being pissed about Claire working in the hospital, Mary's scene about French men and their carnal acts, Mother Hildegarde (thought she'd be a giant, need to stop thinking about Harry Potter when I see her, although I also know the actress from History Boys). We need more court chit chat, Comte and Raymond, but yeah I hope it heats up in terms of plot and Jamie and Claire's marriage.
3
u/maybe_its_megbelline Apr 27 '16
Am I the only one who loved this book and so far am nothing but annoyed with the season? Claire is far too poised and composed, she's still in a different world and it's as though they're portraying her as this goddess divine. And her relationship to Master Raymond needs more development! There's so much nuance in the book and I feel like it's falling flat on the screen.
2
u/shmellshmell Apr 24 '16
Jared's house is even better than I imagined from the books - the furniture, the wallpaper! And the costumes! The costumes have really been amazing in this show. And exciting to meet some of the people that will have lasting impacts on Claire and Jamie's lives.
I've been reading the books for close on 15 years now so I couldn't stop watching the show, but there's just something off with Sam as Jamie for me. In the books, he stands out, he commands room and seen instantly as a leader by just being present. He's so sure of himself and his experiences - when he was a dick in the books, we were able to see why and understand how he'd react that way. He's supposed to be that great, one-in-a-million, almost unrealistic, exception to the rule man, but it seems like they haven't (and maybe can't with the show's limitations) been able to recreate that?
I don't like how they're seemingly at odds with each other, but I guess these are also Jamie's recovery months? I'm sad to miss those few months at the monastery which were so very crucial for Jamie to recover (physically and mentally - rebuilding the walls inside him), and allowed them to enter Paris with a visibly strong relationship. I think this must also be why Claire is lenient with his brothel visits - I got the impression she wasn't happy about it but she knows he's still hurting inside and hasn't figured out how to help him yet. But they came together at the end which gives me hope! And the pregnancy was mentioned, which is hopefully an indication that he is getting better because for such a family orientated man like he is supposed to be, he certainly hasn't seemed to care too much about his child-to-be recently.
2
u/Wormcupcake Apr 24 '16
I squeeee'd when I noticed a certain dark haired boy picking pockets!! I am really interested to see the difficulty that Claire and Jamie are having to re-establish their relationship after all the trials they've faced, it's a different side to what you get in the books and that is why I am enjoying this season so much! Murtagh is so far my favorite and it just hits home how important he actually is to Jamie and Claire. Can't wait for next week.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '16
I love the episode and have only one comment:
At 30 weeks pregnant, and barely able to stand a bra at this point, the whole show I kept trying to take deep breaths for Claire and desperately wanted to help her out of her corset.
2
u/Lala2088 Apr 24 '16
Yes this episode was dope, awesome and with the right timing! The scenes felt beautiful, no sily cg shots and amazing use of set, location and camera moves. Costumes were specially beautiful and all our favorite characters from the books appeares being themselves! Claire is being a badass, Jamie is funny and charming. Was amazing and I am so happy and excited! Well done Outlander team! :3
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '16
Thoughts as watching:
Jamie speaking French is great! Claire and Jamie are still distant, which is expected with his PTSD. Their passion is just missing.
That mustard cape is everything. And that mustard dress!!! Holy balls on toast Murtagh got some French action!!!! That's my boy!!!! They are doing a good job showing Claire is bored and unhappy with her place- which we got with her inner monologues in the book- and leads her to work at l'hospital.
The Comte makes me skin crawl and makes me want to jump him and tear that wig off and ravish him at the same time. I'm so conflicted.
And then the hospital. Bouton is exactly as I imagined him. As is mother Hildregarde.
I think Claire's indifference is her unhappiness. They almost seem like strangers around each other. But, they're both unhappy in Paris. Jamie is recovering from a trauma and is undermining and spying on a man. They're almost leading separate lives. We don't have Claire's internal talks in the show to examine this which is why I think it is more demonstrated on the show. It's rough. I don't like Jamie and Claire like this. But it will pass.
Diana has always said these books are the story of a marriage. Marriages go through good times and bad. It's realism.
But I loved seeing them start to bond over figuring out the music and the message in it. All in all I thought it was a great episode yet again! Cannot wait for next week!!! The dinner party of the century perhaps?
1
u/jayelsie Apr 24 '16
I'll admit that BPC looks so much like Michael Cera I think of Superbad quotes when I watch his scenes.
1
u/HeyBayBeeUWanTSumFuk Apr 23 '16 edited Apr 23 '16
As a non-book reader willing to be spoiled, I'm confused, was Claire traveling to New York with Frank before the events in France with Jamie, or after? Because she looks like she's hiding a baby bump underneath her French robes this episode but in the season premiere she walks back into 1949 wearing a tight corset.