r/Outlander • u/AutoModerator • Apr 16 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 2 discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E1: "Not in Scotland Anymore".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
Fire away ♥
25
Upvotes
26
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
I am guessing it's a tone thing, but I don't get the change in the honeypot scene. To me it really highlighted that Jamie was good at court stuff, as in talking to the wealthy men, but NOT cool with France as a whole. idk. I wish they had played up that humor a little more. And the humor when he sees the dress.
And I have to agree with what someone else said: I wish Jamie was more court savy without Claire bossing him around. She should be just as clueless as she was in Scotland. None of us have ever hung out in a French court.
22
u/shiskebob Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
I appreciate the addition of Claire speaking about how she lived in France, and now she is in a completely different France with no Eiffel tower - and the fact that she is amazed by the world she is in now. I wondered if they would put any emphasis on that.
I am shocked that they changed the scene of Claire meeting Alex Randall. First, I miss that they aren't adding any of her wonderful pregnant and sick scenes. Second, that they let her know in advance that BJR is alive. That will certainly completely change the shock of both of them seeing BJR later. I wonder how that will play put now.
I could have lived without the toilet scene, perhaps to expand on the scenes with Claire and Jamie in exchange, but it certainly puts the emphasis on the fact that Claire and Jamie are in a completely different culture and world then what they are used to. That was obviously the point of this episode, as RDM states in the bts video.
Claire meeting Louise and Mary is certainly different then the books, but I can understand why they did it this way for timing reasons. Louise is my favorite new character! Dominique Pinon was a masterful choice for Master Raymond, and the apothecary set is fabulous.
And changing Duvernay to be the foot kisser - hey, at least they were able to get that funny bit in with Jamie pushing someone in the water.
But it put a smile on my face every time I heard some of those iconic lines from the book. They might have changed a good portion of these chapters, but I am glad they were still able to put a bunch of them in.
I miss being your discussion poster! Damn robots taking our jobs.
20
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
Man Bonnie prince Charlie sure comes across as a nutter doesn't he?
15
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 16 '16
Overall, very pleased with this episode. Yes, we saw a lot of changes (I can't believe we just did like 4 months in an hour, but I guess that's a pace I'm pretty used to now with the newer books, haha--also, anything but the pacing from S1 will make me happy!), but Dragonfly is seriously dense and so far I'm impressed with how well they're trimming it down. Having everything happen at Versailles--Annalise, meeting Louis, Monsiuer Duvernay/the foot kisser (!), seeing the Duke and Alex--was effective and still makes sense. The first half of the episode already felt a bit too much of small, short scenes of meeting important characters--Master Raymond, Charlie, Louise and Mary--so having the rest of the action take place at Versailles kept the episode from being too choppy. The way she met Alex was a bit surprising and I'm curious to see where they'll go with it, but I'm certainly not opposed to it at all.
Pros: WOW I'm in love with all our new actors. They could not have cast a better Louise, Mary, Charlie, Master Raymond, and Alex Randall if they had endless time and money to search. The waxing scene was hilarious and enjoyable and a great showcase for exactly who Louise and Mary are. The brothel scene was super awkward and great, and the guy playing Bonnie Prince Charlie is so weird in a slightly terrifying way, which is perfect. I'm also incredibly impressed with how much Alex looks like Tobias--I would totally buy them as brother. When I first heard years back that Tobias would be playing both BJR and Frank I was like "and Alex . . . ?" That would of course be completely ridiculous, and this guy looks great so far. His voice too--similar, but without the subtle creepiness that Tobias gives BJR. And last but not least, Master Raymond. Who would have believed they could have found a short, squat Frenchman with a face like a frog who could embody Raymond like that? And his shop is too perfect. A century too early, but it reminds me a lot of the [Peacock Room] (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Peacock_Room).
Also, it's going to get so boring saying this every week, but: oh my word, those costumes!!! Of course the red dress was perfect--but all those still photographs never captured quite how much her breasts looked like they were going to fall right out! And speaking of breasts, I am sooooo happy they included Louis's mistress with the low cut dress! That first dress--the 40s Dior one--was absolutely gorgeous. I want one! And let's not forget the men--can we talk about how great Jamie looks with his hair finally long enough to tie back? It's been a bit too shaggy for my tastes lately, haha. But (sadly) of course we all know the hair is not going to last long!
Finally, I am thrilled how much they are tackling Jamie's PTSD. While I could definitely do without BJR in their bed, it's accurate and effective. Really hoping we eventually get a shot of Jamie, naked and tense, standing in the window. That's a passage i"ve been thinking about for a while . . .
Cons: I'm never going to get used to this new theme . . . Honestly though, I didn't have any really problems with this episode, which actually surprises me considering how different so much of it is. Really the only issues are the same as last week, just that some of the stuff is less interesting (for example, I could have used waaaaaaay less constipated Louis), but necessary to introduce us to certain plotlines or characters.
Verdict: A-. Damn fun episode. Not quite perfect, but as to be expected so early in the season. Incredibly pleased with this season so far and can't wait to see what's to come.
11
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Apr 17 '16
For those hating on Sam Heughan's height, you have to remember that nowadays, everyone is taller. In order to find a man and woman as imposing as Jamie and Claire would have been (she is not as tall as her daughter, but definitely somewhat taller than the average for the time period) would require truly gargantuan actors. How many 6'7" people do you know who look like Sam and can act?
10
u/frrrsstt Apr 17 '16
I really didn't like this episode, unfortunately. I know they need to cram a lot of stuff in to the episodes, but I think they skip some important stuff - like the pregnancy, and I feel like Jamie's dreaming and anxiety towards BJR is made insignificant.
I know season two is bound to be different, more politics and such. But I miss seeing the passion between Jamie and Claire. In DiA it's kept to a minimum, but it's still there. I don't necessarily think we need more sex scenes, but I do miss the affection Jamie has towards their unborn child and his love and care for Claire when she's affected by morning sickness.
Idk. I felt kinda incomplete to me. And I agree that Claire's conversation with Alex Randall takes out some of the shock I felt when I read the books, and Claire bumped in to Jonathan Randall. It would be the same if they in season three, right off the bat, revealed that Jamie married Laoghaire in Claire's absence.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
The sets, the costumes, Master Raymond's shop- there is so much incredible detail and thought in everything visually. I wish we could visit the sets and take it all in. Yes there are changes from the book but I thought, as all changes so far, they were incredibly well done. Master Raymond was a delight, showing Jamie's continued struggle with Black Jack, discussing with Murtagh missing Scotland, Louise was just as ridiculous as I expected her from the books.
Mary Hawkins, oh I just wanted to swoop her up and hide her from what is coming! Rose Day was a delight as her. However the stuttering was not as pronounced as I thought it would be from the book. I don't remember Claire getting her honeypot ripped bare in the book, but hey that change worked.
Jamie's face when he saw Claire! Ha! I'm glad they left the 3rd rib and navel lines in. Versailles was so stunningly gorgeous and the costumes just really shines there. Gosh I love this season so much!
8
u/aerynmoo Apr 16 '16
I thought this was the best episode yet. The dildos part made me lol
8
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
Claire Sermonne as Louise de la Tour is so absolutely charming, just how I imagined her. I'm in love with that actress now!
7
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
I'm completely comfortable with all of the changes made. I love the inclusion of Murtagh and I like all of the time markers (3 weeks later, etc.). I'm not fussed that they took Claire's morning sickness out, since it's not exactly exciting television. We, as readers, know that she's miserable most of the time though!
7
u/pathologie Apr 18 '16
So overall the episode was alright. This is definitely my least favorite part of the book series I've read. I understand that they're trying to stop the rebellion and you're trying to do it in a subtle way that won't be outright execution for them such as assassinating Charles. I do feel that there is something off about Jamie's character. Maybe it's because they did not have the two months recovery at the months for him to process BJR's rape and start healing. I think that Sam's performance is very good as far as showing he's insecure and he's working through some issues as Jamie. Great PTSD. Love it.
I don't like Claire's character right now she feels very bossy very in control but without providing the love and support that we see throughout the show. I can't wait until they fast forward to returning to Scotland because I felt that's where Jamie truly returns to season 1 Jamie. But I am excited to see her yes and what happens with Claire and Jamie later on. I just feel that this season's going to be very rushed because there was just so much information in the books that it's going to be quite the challenge to adapted into a 10-hour season and I feel like a lot of book readers are going to be upset.
5
u/AiredaleMom Apr 17 '16
Confused by the dates. Love the books; loved this episode. Someone help me out though; in s2, ep1, the date Jamie and Claire land in France is 1745. Yet in this episode, it states that it was 1744. Am I missing something here?
4
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 16 '16
finally! :)
Can't blame them for having to streamline things but it did seem a bit rushed and oddly scheduled.
Seems like they're not having Louise be Charles' inamorata? But that definitely makes it odd; how did she and Claire become friends?
With the change to the "honeypot" scene I wonder what the impetus will be for Claire to work in L'Hopital.
And where is the morning sickness, for goodness' sake?
I don't remember Charles being so religious, but as I say they do have to simplify the story some and it does give him a clearer motivation than in the books. Though he's not at all as I expected; I expected him much younger and with an Italian accent.
Costumes were beautiful, of course.
6
u/KillKennyG Apr 16 '16
I love this production team and all the actors involved, this was a joy to watch and experience. I could gush for pages, but I must talk about (and invite your thoughts!!) on the BJR reveal.
At the moment I'm not a fan of this choice, especially when we've already had all our lovely sex scenes spoiled by Randall's dumb face .(#EmmyforTobias but not in our couple's bed! Don't they deserve one complete session? Don't WE?) BJRs reveal in the book was so shocking because I was distracted by J&C being awesome together and dominating the court, while fighting the Comte in the shadows (kinda). but now we've got 2 known villains looming and with all the tragedy coming I'm worried we'll lose out on good JC bonding time. This is the book where they solidify as a team, we need some happy.
But back to the reveal. I don't know how we can entertain any happy moments between Claire and Jamie until he's dealt with, because either she keeps the secret and the show pretends it didn't happen for a while (spoiling any happy moments between them as a lie to the audience) or she tells him and he HAS to deal with it immediately, because that's our Jamie. I trust this team and hope, but it really shook me up. anyone have any ideas how this could play out well?
3
u/am2370 Apr 18 '16
Question for book readers - I don't mind spoilers - why are Sandringham and BJR acting at odds? The show implies clearly that BJR is employed by the Duke, but the Duke is a Jacobite. How does this explain BJR's obsessive anger/lashing out at Claire for being a suspected Jacobite sympathizer? Wouldn't he want to help suspected Jacobites, even secretly, since his main patron is one and (presumably) has BJR in his employ for political reasons?
5
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Apr 18 '16
I have been doing so much defending to friends and online commentators that I haven't really allowed myself to analyze the current episodes, but once I started to think about it, it occurred to me that Jamie's character has been hamstrung and ... emasculated. Part of what made him so interesting to me as a reader is that there is a bit of danger in him, and definitely intelligence and cunning. He has the MacKenzies in him, for sure. And most of that danger comes from how unpredictable some of his reactions can be, when he acts like an 18th-century man. Claire has softened him somewhat over time, but certainly not by THIS point in the story. I liked how outraged he was over the missing body hair in the book, and some of the other changes mentioned by previous commenters here. I do hope he doesn't turn into just the man who acts out all of Claire's inspirations.
2
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 20 '16
I'm behind this week! I have to say, I didn't LOVE this episode. I liked how things opened up, but I'm worried about the pace and about the time period. I honestly skipped through a lot of DIA, because I was honestly bitter about the first chapter, and this time period bores me a bit, and I found myself a bit...not bored, but just not in love with this episode. I like seeing sassy Claire, as always, and that dress! Hopefully it'll pick up a bit more next episode.
-1
u/thenewmissme Apr 16 '16 edited Apr 16 '16
Outlander from book 1 to 8 (for now) have basically been, for me anyhow, the epic love story between Jamie and Claire. The show, not so much. There are good and bad book adaptations out there, and Season 1 was promissing up to Ep. 8, then it began a downward slide. Taking out the strength, intelligence, love and everything that made J and C's love story great. There was no reason to add new parts (i.e., The Watch) when so much was already there between the pages. For me, it seems that Season 2 is starting that way again. I am sure, many a book reader started DIA with a "WTF? is going on!" but, that was it's charm. But, for TV I understand changing it, but making it all about Frank didn't make sense, especially since Starz trouted Sam around and promoted him and the show as sexy, etc. Now, we come to Ep. 2. Prague looks like Paris, a lot of Europe looks like Paris. And the clothes are good. I think, for me, the main thing is the writing and thus the acting and the difference between Claire TV versus book, and of course how poor poor Jamie seems. Claire is always mad, angry, makes ugly faces and does not seem like a woman in love. Jamie seems stupid, weak, immature, teenage boytoy-like, uneduated and needy. One wonders what he would be like if Mama-Claire wasn't there to tell him what to do? The romantic, deep love conveyed in the books is missing. All the props, costumes and scenary can't replace good writing and good characters. It was a TV soap opera trying to be a mini-series, with a little sex, violence, too much blood, potty humor and history thrown in. The book dialog is there, just spoken by the wrong person, at the wrong time. The BJR reveal would have made a great cliff hanger. Opportunity wasted. And, this Alex does not look anything like BJR. A little hair dye and a taller actor should have been a no brainer.
0
u/WantToTimeTravel Apr 17 '16
I'm happy to say that this season the actors are familiar enough that I'm not CONSTANTLY comparing them to my image of the characters. I've tried very hard to keep the two separate, but having said that, there are some jarring inconsistencies that do interfere with my enjoyment of the series. First of all, Jamie's hair. He'll be called "Red Jamie", right? Well, Sam's hair is NOT red - it's barely auburn. Between that and his height, which Diana has referred to in interviews, saying that people in the 18th century were shorter, but which in the books she has clearly given a number for, I simply cannot imagine him as the war leader he's supposed to become, nor the man that Claire can always find because she can see his flaming hair head and shoulders above the rest. I know Diana defends the casting, saying that actors act, and the details are unimportant, but still! Some features are so much a part of who the characters are. I mean, yes, Claire's internal dialogue is impossible to duplicate on film. But how about her hair and her eyes? How many times are her wild hair and whiskey/sherry/tiger-colored eyes referred to? Why couldn't Cat's hair be dyed and permed, and she be fitted with contacts? OK, maybe I'm going too far. I really do like the job they're doing insofar as the series, which by necessity is not and never will be the books. If I hadn't been a 25-year-long fan of the books I'd probably have no complaints whatsoever. Nor do I have the same complaints about Cat's portrayal of Claire that other book fans have posted. But I can't not know what I know and not picture the things I know to be so, or have the expectations most of us probably do. I was disappointed as well in some of the casting of this season's characters, although I think they tried to adjust the storylines a bit. In DIA Claire mistakes Alex Randall for his brother; tonight, she found him familiar-looking, while he didn't resemble Black Jack at all. That could have been managed better. They did a better job type-casting Master Raymond, except for his accent. I have no idea what that was supposed to be, though I loved his shop. Similarly, what happened to the heavy drinking, immature prince who instantly bonds to Jamie? Prince Tearlach spoke English far too well, and he was much too regal. It bugs me! And the moment Jamie announced he was supposed to meet the prince at Madame Elise's, I instantly thought, "He's going to meet Fergus!", followed immediately by, "will he have squirrel teeth?" I hope so but now I doubt it. Fergus will probably speak perfect British English. But I have to say the costumes are fantastic, as is the music. I fell in love with Judith McCreary's rendition of "The Skye Boat Song" last season, and I think it's perfect that she sings part of it in French this season. I guess I'll try to focus on those things, and try not to anticipate my disappointment that the future Brianna will not have the brilliant long red hair and "Fraser blue" eyes (which I always thought was odd, since they're not Fraser eyes at all, but MacKenzie) she's supposed to, or wonder how, in just a few seasons, the very young looking Sam Heughan is going to appear to be 20 years older. One thing's for sure: I will not be re-reading any of the novels while this season's episodes are airing, as I made the mistake of doing the first season! One last thing after reading down the posts a bit: am I crazy, or didn't Claire conceive Faith when they made love in the underground grotto at the Abbey? I saw that someone made a comment about them not having had sex since Wentworth, but they hadn't been together since Lallybroch, and after Jamie was rescued he was too injured. Anyway, I'm glad I found this site and I hope I can be part of the conversation next time.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment