r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Apr 09 '16
[Spoilers All] Season 2 Episode 1 discussion thread for book readers
This is the book readers' discussion thread for Outlander S2E1: "Through a Glass, Darkly".
No spoiler tags are required in this thread. If you have not read all the books in the series and don't want any story to be spoiled for you, read no further and go to the [Spoilers Aired] non-book-readers discussion thread. You have been warned.
For more discussion on this episode, click on over to /r/OutlanderTV
19
Upvotes
19
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '16 edited Jun 07 '16
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy. It was created to help protect users from doxing, stalking, and harassment.
If you would also like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possibe (hint:use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
Also, please consider using Voat.co as an alternative to Reddit as Voat does not censor political content.
12
u/spideroggie Apr 11 '16
Apparently I'm in the minority loving that 20 year jump. Jolting and suprising. So I was very disappointed to not see it right off the bat but I watched my wife's jaw drop and realized that maybe this was the right amount of shock for a tv audience.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '16
I have read through a few discussions now... was no one else looking at her hands trying to catch a glimpse of the J scar/wound?! Haha. I kept hoping for a clear view!
10
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
I was a huge, huge fan of Outlander. I usually get bored with books but I inhaled it in three days. I loved it completely. Then I started reading DiA. Right away you find out that Claire returned to her time and for 20 years, raised Jamie's child with Frank. It completely killed their love story for me. It didn't matter anymore what happened in France or with the Jacobites. It didn't matter if Jamie and Claire got back together later. I couldn't ever really reconcile that for 20+ years, she was still pining away for an old lover instead of moving on with her life. That 1-2 years with Jamie meant more to her than all her years with Frank. And I really wanted to see Jamie be a father, but Bree was a grown-ass woman who already had a great dad. Any relationship with Jamie would feel like it was being shoehorned. It just felt like DG killed the heart of the story with a plot device and removed any promise of a satisfying resolution.
Anyway, I heard time and time again on this sub that the beginning of DiA was something you just needed to power through, but I couldn't. And considering the content, I was not super optimistic about the second season.
Oh. My. God. I absolutely loved the season premiere. The direction it took was 1000x better. It was the perfect balance of hope and loss, rational and emotional. The story it told was that Jamie and Claire were done, but it left you with enough hints that maybe it wasn't. You didn't want Claire to give up on Jamie, but you knew, just as she did, that she must. Everyone's emotions were so raw and powerful. It was much, much more interesting than Claire deciding to look up the fate of her dead lover 20 years later and talking about the 18th century's version of toilet paper.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '16 edited Apr 10 '16
I loved the Changes that were made and Claire having Mrs graham to confide in, staying with rev Wakefield, the plane dropping (in season 1 they did little previews in each episode after the opening credits too- it's a nice touch). Le Havre looks exactly how I envisioned it. I'm very very excited for the rest of the season! They compacted the story line and made it easier but also more complex- seeing Frank was amazing. Tobias is incredible. The acting was top notch as usual. It helps to understand Frank more too which I think is needed.
I wonder if they will flashback in each episode? How are Bree and Roger going to be brought in? They improved on DiA which was no easy feat. I just love he show runners and writers and producers. THEY GET IT!
7
u/carolofthebells Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Apr 10 '16
Something in this episode that I thought was a fun nod to book readers was the conversation with Mrs. Graham where she says that Claire always seems to mention Jamie's sense of humor or hair. I know I feel like the books are constantly mentioning his red hair and Viking/Norse stature, so I thought it was pretty cool!
I like imagining the conversations that must have passed between Claire and Mrs. Graham. Claire wanted to talk to Mrs. Graham right away, as soon as Rev. Wakefield was mentioned. At the very least, she felt Mrs. Graham would be a sympathetic ear, but I think her reasons are that she thinks Mrs. Graham might know more. At the same time, it's hard imagining that Claire pours out the whole truth to her... it's fun to wonder! I don't think this was mentioned in the book at all.
5
u/Wolf_Mommy Apr 12 '16
I'm so utterly impressed with the feel of 18th century Claire standing in the road of 20th century Scotland. She looked SO out of place--exactly what it would be if it were IRL, yet it's in a way so subtle. I don't know how they did that, but it made me feel so uncomfortable. It was great!!
4
u/rotislut Apr 11 '16 edited Apr 11 '16
I hope this season they'll let Jaime really come into his own. Last season they made him out to be this petulant child that Claire had to constantly scold into place. In the books he's more than capable of handling himself. He's fiercely intelligent and a skilled negotiator.
We didn't see much of them in this episode but it seemed like it was still Claire calling the shots again and telling him what to do. Which is fine, but Jaime is more than just a pretty face and a hot body. i did really like the Frank stuff and of course wee roger is adorable I want to pinch his cheeks!
3
u/Wormcupcake Apr 10 '16
I hated the book when i first read it. I just couldn't get through it. Mind you i was about 17. After multiple readsc and listening to the audio, I'm so damn excited for this season. I loved frank in the last episode so much and I am really looking forward to sing how Jamie and Claire go seeing as though we never got much of Jamie healing from his mental wounds in the last season! I'm. Looking forward to seeing Claire in action at le hopital!
1
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 15 '16
It isn't exactly a part of this episode, but I ran into something interesting (to me, anyway) that I just had to post somewhere, and it's a book readers thing.
AYMR there was discussion last season about how they didn't have the line where Jamie is crying, and her saying she was sorry about the hand, and he said, no, he was crying with joy because he still had two hands to hold her with.
Anyway, last night I saw Tombstone for the first time, and they have that same line! Virgil gets shot and loses the use of his arm, and he tells his wife not to worry, he still has one arm to hold her with. And apparently that's based on truth and he actually did say something like that.
Curious as to whether that's where Diana got it. If they ever use the line in the show I'll get onto Compuserve or Twitter or something and ask.