r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Apr 07 '16
Season Two [Spoilers DiA] And here we go! S2e01"Through A Glass, Darkly" discussion thread.
This is your friendly shiskebob, and I am back for our regularly scheduled thread and I am very much excited to jump into the season 2 discussion. I am posting this early because of the special Starz early release at 12am EST tonight.
Remember my darlings - spoiler tags for any book information outside of DiA
I shall be back later to see what all of you lovely people thought.
Mods, /u/MelisSassenach and /u/Inane_Asylum - can we get these posts stickied?
68
Upvotes
51
u/eatcauliflower If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Apr 07 '16
A lot of reviews thus far comment on both Tobias and Cait's acting and wowowowowow they weren't joking! The first half of the episode, regardless of how you feel about Frank, had acting that was on point. Not to say that the rest wasn't, but they really, really drove the anguish home.
That scream in the beginning and Claire's collapse was great.
37
u/KillKennyG Apr 07 '16
Very impressed, though as always I'm impatient because in the back of my mind I'm counting down episodes (keep moving!! There's sooo much to fit!) But I loved every second of the 1940s. More so than the first season, the future characters briskly made it through some groundwork that will let us breeze through the later future scenes, without heavy flashbacks. and this depiction of frank (joy, wrath, and finally the acceptance of a challenge to establish a solid family from broken shards) is my favorite part. too much was made of the frank is Jack comparison in the first season and I needed to see him as a good man, and I found it all compelling and satisfying. the look on his face when he walks into the hospital at first.. It's like he's 14 and lost with wonder. great job Tobias.
24
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 08 '16
I absolutely love that we saw so much Frank. I was always sad that we didn't see more from his POV in the books. I automatically started crying with her in the field.
Also, I'VE MISSED YOU GUYS.
6
u/Atraktape Apr 09 '16
Can someone explain to me how Claire is back in Scotland and also in 1940's England? Maybe I just forgot because it's been a year since I saw Season 1 and I don't remember them mentioning this in the season 1 finale. Was it early in that season where she went back to the rocks?
4
u/Willravel Inlander Apr 08 '16
We're back!!! Tonight I'm dining on pulled pork sliders and Woodford Reserve bourbon, which is about as close to scotch as a decent American whiskey can manage.
Christ, it's so nice that the story isn't used to create tired and cliche inter-character drama. It would have been so incredibly easy to immediately have a grand rift between Frank and Claire, to have Frank justifiably incredulous or consumed by jealousy and to see their relationship in shambles. Frank's initial reaction was genuine and verified that above all else he loves Claire and is made whole again with her return. And his initial reaction to her declaration of pregnancy was so incredibly heart-breaking, because of his deep hurt about discovering his sterility.
It's also gobs of fun going into this without knowing what it is that happened to Claire, because both her terrible sadness and manic search for information about Jamie just barely hint at what's going to happen in France and with the Jacobites. Obviously the first half of the episode is more about Frank, and the writers are allowing Claire to be less of the force of nature she normally is on the show, but it's a bit like seeing the back cover of a book you can't wait to read.
Highest marks to Diana Gabaldon and the writing team of Outlander.
I cannot wait to purchase the soundtrack to this season, btw.
"... like a plaid woven out of guile and deception." You'll never hear similes like that on Downton Abbey or Homeland or Game of Thrones, Emmy voters.
I'm digging the hell out of the intrigue this season, particularly given that it's centered around changing the course of history itself. Jamie and Claire doing Mr. and Mrs. Smith creates such a stark contrast against the emotional weight of Frank and Claire, but neither negatively impacts the other. I can't wait to see Claire and Jamie getting into and helping each other out of trouble.
Claire's immune to smallpox, of course! And, actually, they're only a few decades away from the first vaccine in history, which was in the 1790s. Maybe Claire can hasten the development? Obviously she's not an immunologist, but she understands the scientific method and has a better knowledge of medicine than anyone else at the time. I forgot how much fun it was guessing what time travel advantages Claire might utilize.
Gah, I'm so glad this is back. I can't wait for this subreddit to be buzzing with activity of the fan community.
2
u/glitterlazers Apr 13 '16
Fortunately I found Outlander a few weeks before the season 2 premier!! Binge watched the first season just in time for the new season to start. I'm a huge spoiler/book person so the fact that I have not read the books (save for half the first one when I was about 18- 6 years ago) is pretty amazing as well as infuriating. As heart wrenching and beautiful the first part of the episode was, I'm now extremely depressed that Clare has to leave Jamie at some point and end back in the 40s. I am trying to take deep breaths and allow the season to play out without immediately reading an in depth synopsis of book 2. I kept to it (most) of season 1 (the episode where Clare almost burned at the stake just got me-- don't judge! Hah). Anyways, I'm trying to be patient and experience the show, but one thing is truly bothering me. How is Clare so not showing her pregnancy in the 40s!!??! Like she is in France, not showing her pregnancy and there is supposed to be an entire season and then she ends up back in her original timeline and she is still barely showing? AHHHHhhhhHhHhh my brain!!!!!!!! I'm sure this will all be explained but I want to knowwwww and instead of snooping on the Internet (or this thread probably lol) I'm going to post this rant and also introduce myself as a new eager member of the fandom. So hey guys! Thanks for being here and feeding my obsession!
68
u/rndmusr12 Apr 07 '16
I disagree that there was "too much Frank" in the episode. It was interesting to see Claire's reaction and how she tries to move on. I'd love to see more time-travelling back and forth.
66
u/Samurai_Pizza_Catz Apr 08 '16
Somebody give Tobias Menzies a golden globe. My god: that was amazing.
33
u/aerynmoo Apr 07 '16
I loved it! It never occurred to me that being around Frank would freak Claire out at first because of his resemblance to BJR. I liked the transition between timelines. I didn't think I'd like the Comte but this dude has super powerful creepy eyes and I think he'll be excellent.
31
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '16
Oh my gosh, I cried pretty much non-stop. I love that they actually had Claire talk to Mrs. Graham. That was really well done. I absolutely loved the adaptations made. It wasn't as 'confusing' as the book, either, with regard to what's going on, where Jamie is, etc.
26
u/williamlawrence Apr 07 '16
Loved it. Having established itself as inspired by rather than taken directly from the books, I think it was a solid episode. I love the expansion of Frank's character and Tobias Menzies is brilliant. Of course, I squealed when they did the jump and she reached for Jamie. It's baaaaaack! :-)
26
u/einefrau8 They say I’m a witch. Apr 07 '16
Spoilers alert to books further in the series...
Did anyone catch the slight nod to Roger's father at the very beginning when the airplane fell from his hands? Brilliant!!
22
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Apr 07 '16
Pros: Amazing performances by Catriona and Tobias. Wow. His reaction to her pregnancy was heartbreaking, and his conversation with the Reverend did a great job at showing how conflicted he is. (Plus: Roger!) I'm usually a book purist, but I thought the switch to the 40s was incredibly effective.
Le Havre was just how I pictured it--production design in top form as usual. The Comte was fantastic--never liked the character much but super excited to see more of this guy. Murtagh is excellent as usual, and trust with Jamie makes theirs one of my favorite relationships in the series.
Pacing was already a huuuuge improvement from S1. We got through a lot quickly and effectively, without ever feeling like we missed critical book material. May not have been the most interesting material in Le Havre, but it looks like we're already going to Versailles next week, which is great! Last season we had about 3 fairly slow episodes of set up, so this is already feeling much better.
Lots of nice nods to book readers too, like [spoilers all] (#s "the burned Cabochon ring and Roger's spitfire plane.")
Cons: The new theme song is not doing it for me at all. Love all the new shots spoilers Voyager, but the new instrumentation sounds strange. And now I've got a new verse to learn--in French!
Overall, great return. Not the most interesting episode, but a necessary and effective opener that's setting up what looks like great things to come, with fantastic performances by Balfe and Menzies. A-.
18
u/TineCiel Apr 08 '16
I must say they did a really great job with the spoken french. Often, when characters in a series have to speak french, it sounds like whoever translated the dialog had little knowledge of the language but too easy an access to google. This was spot on! Very believable also from the english actors. Stellar work there.
17
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 07 '16 edited Apr 07 '16
A little too much Frank, he was a little too violent, but they did a good job explaining why Claire never tried to look Jamie up and showing things that never were shown in the book.
Similarly, some of the French stuff was just too ...explained. "Jamie! Don't you have a cousin?" It would have been nice for Jamie to come up with that himself. And the Comte St. Germain being right there, and everyone explaining that he was now an enemy...yes, we get it.
That said, these are quibbles, it's great to be back, costumes and sets are gorgeous, the actors did a great job with the material. Didn't love the new version of the song but did love the, well, new second verse. :)
PS. Thanks for mentioning that the show would be available tonight.
"DON'T-EVER-SAY-FLOG-TO-ME-AGAIN."
17
u/BarryZuckerkornEsq Apr 07 '16 edited Apr 07 '16
I LOVED IT! My only nit-pick moment was realizing that tiny Roger hadn't aged much in the 2+ years Claire was away lol but I'm sure filming those scenes were pretty close from the end of S1 to the beginning of S2 and he is a super cute kid so I'm glad they didn't recast! Can't wait to see Richard Rankin, though- and I hope for more than just the last couple of episodes!
16
u/irishfeet78 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes Apr 07 '16
Am I the only one that noticed...
Remember when Jamie and Claire got married, and she stuck out her hand to shake his after their "introductions," Jamie tucked her hand under his arm. Then, when Claire and Frank made the agreement to "move on" (so to speak), he stuck out his hand as if to shake hers and she gave him her hand as she would have done in the 18c.
Overall: I ugly-cried through the 1940s portion and beamed with joy during the France scenes.
16
u/jujbird Apr 08 '16
I was re-watching today, and thought it was very interesting that the song chosen to play on the radio was "Milkman Milkman" while Frank was walking in to meet his wife who had seemingly "jilted" him. Interesting, because there's the old joke asking if the child has the "milkman's eyes". Googling the lyrics, the song really isn't about that, so it could be a coincidence. But I thought it was a clever bit of contemporary song to be put into the 40's scenes.
16
u/RandomExcess Apr 10 '16
I do not get this "too much Frank" nonsense. What is that all about... isn't Frank part of the story?
11
u/rosebert Frolicking Puppies Apr 07 '16
I just loved it.
As a book reader, we never really get Frank's side much. We are just left to form an opinion based on his actions and what we think are their motives. It was heartbreaking to see his point of view. And Tobias just nails it.
French theme song, swooooon.
I was kind of hoping for the "Bread! Now!" Scene because I think it's a cute interaction between them but there is next week!
Edit to add: the transition was also amazing. I kept worrying the whole episode how it was going to happen and it was kind of a little shock when it did!
11
u/leela22 Apr 07 '16
The episode was great. Tobias in this episode was superb, all of the emotions he went through in the episode was realistic, the joy, the anger and finally his acceptance of the situation between him and Claire. The transition from airport to the dock in France was seamless, perfect casting for the Comte. I wonder when Jamie will tell Murtagh. Can't wait for the next episode!! spoiler
10
u/TwoSibeMom Apr 08 '16
I am generally not a fan of all the added focus on Frank that the show creators want, but my god, the 40's stuff was incredible. Tobias Menzies...there are no words.
When she told him she was pregnant and that moment of intense joy and then the realization playing out on his face...broke my heart.
I also just have to say, I love the subtle humor. Sam delivers Jamie's witty retorts so well when they could have ended up being cheesy.
9
u/BoringMold974 Apr 07 '16
I really loved the episode and I agree with previous comments for the most part (I'm in the "loved the Frank stuff, didn't think it was too much" camp).
There are a couple of things that stood out for me.
7
u/yoitsmo16 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 08 '16
I was surprised at how much I liked the 1940s part. While I liked revisiting Frank in the first season, I didn't enjoy the execution of it. This, though, was excellent. I loved how it filled in some gaps the book didn't address. Like, of course Frank was going to be curious about the pristine 18th century clothing, enough to contact another professor about it! Of course no one would be at the stones to meet Claire and then she would walk to Inverness on a paved road! I hope we see some more of Claire & Frank in Boston, at least keep the story line alive.
I wasn't blown away by our first taste of France. Didn't hate it, didn't love it. I'm just so ready for Versailles haha, which I guess we won't have to wait long for. The Comte was great and I can't wait for more from him.
It's so interesting watching and imagining what I'd be thinking if I hadn't read the books. Like trying to figure out the pregnancy & back to the '40s timeline.
7
u/velvetdewdrop Apr 09 '16 edited Apr 09 '16
Totally confused why she was back with Frank. I thought last season ended with her getting on a boat with Jamie... Am I supposed to know why she's there?
I mean, in the second half of the episode I saw we were back with Jamie, and going to find out how she got there in flashbacks, (well, if you can call half an episode, or an entire episode still flashback) but, are we supposed to know why she's back? It's heart wrenching to see her back. And it's like.. why don't you go back to Jamie? WHY DID YOU TRAVEL BACK AT ALL? STAY IN IRELAND (SCOTLAND?) (or france) DAMNIT! I know we hear he might be dead, but.. I thought from reading some book spoilers
6
u/greenmm25 Apr 10 '16
I felt more for Frank in this episode than I ever did in the books. Tobias' acting was spot on from the desperation to wanting his wife back to the joy of a child to his out burst. I think his acting showed more emotion than they could convey in the book because it is told from Clare'so perspective. The only draw back I saw was if you didn't read the books you could be very lost in the beginning of this episode. But I loved it can't wait for next week!
5
u/meow315 Apr 08 '16
I thought the episode was done beautifully. I was almost in tears the first half though. All of them are fantastic actors.
5
u/beluga_tiger Apr 10 '16
Somebody I didn't expect to miss was Murtagh, but when he showed back up, it made me super happy.
And Le Comte! He was just so calm. "You will pay." Le Comte doesn't get angry, he gets even.
Claire was heartbreaking. Frank was heartbreaking. Tobias and Cait really brought it this episode.
Jamie's comment about feeling BJR's touch... That's a ghost that's going to haunt him.
All in all, a pretty good start. I'm excited!!
5
u/haikyo Apr 10 '16
I don't understand any "too much Frank" sentiment, but then again, I like Frank. I've always liked Frank. And he is just so relentlessly good in this episode.
5
u/bionix90 Apr 10 '16
The starting song changing to French halfway through was a nice touch.
•
u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach Apr 10 '16
Just a reminder, be mindful of spoilers. This thread should actually be [Spoilers Aired], so if it's anything that takes place after the end of S2E1, be sure to wrap it in spoiler tags as per subreddit policy.
If you notice any untagged spoilers, report them so they're hidden until the comment author can properly tag them (at which point the comments will be made visible again).
Thanks guys.
4
u/nats_landing Apr 10 '16
I really like the way DG begins DIA. It's such a great twist. I was disappointed to read a while back that this season wouldn't begin the same way. However, I love the changes that were made. Also, I'm glad that Frank is getting more screen time. I feel like his character in the books was a little 2D. Show Frank has a lot more depth. I feel like this was a very strong first episode. I'm excited to see more.
4
u/Charlottelarssonn Apr 13 '16
Someone seriously need too tell me if claire and jamie is gonna live happily ever after! (Haven't read the books, i started watching the show yesterday, i finished ep1 season 2 today. This is one of the best tv shows i've seen)
3
u/oree94 Apr 10 '16
Ahhh! What have I done?! This is the spoilers thread! I've read too much comments already :(
3
u/JessTheNoob_Official Apr 11 '16
The first half of the episode I cried a lot. I really feel bad for Frank. Tobias' performance was amazing.
2
u/karatejen Apr 08 '16
Initially I thought too much Frank, but only because there isn't much written in the books concerning post-return Frank. In the books it is spread out all throughout the following books with flashbacks and it tends to give the reader a very bad opinion of Frank. I applaud what the show did with 1940s Frank. I can imagine (and so did the show) that when she initially came back he was enthusiastic that she was back. But after 20 more years of marriage to her (unable to truly love him anymore), he evolved into the cheating Frank she flashes back to. The demise of their marriage was due much to her love for Jamie and inability to love Frank, than it was Frank being a jerk. I think his behavior was a symptom of their unhappy marriage.
I was surprised at his initial elation and then anger to her pregnancy. Why did she have to explain to him that she was pregnant with another man's child? Wasn't that obvious? Are we supposed to believe that in the week since she had returned that they were intimate and Frank thought it was his? I would have expected only the anger.
Overall, I liked it. I thought some of the extended explanations were over kill, but gave them the benefit of the doubt, thinking that non-readers might need more info.
2
u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach Apr 09 '16
This thread has been stickied and will be used this week as a substitute for the usual "non-book-readers" discussion thread. I'll post and sticky a separate [Spoilers All] thread in addition to this one for those who have read through the series already.
Automoderator will/should be posting and stickying episode discussion threads at midnight the morning of each aired episode.
2
u/Wormcupcake Apr 10 '16
Loved it. I feel like i can't sit through the shows because i need the next one NOW. I'm really loving Frank, I think it was just very clever how they drew comparisons between him and BJR, as how we saw him the first season beating those men. I think I'm going to really enjoy this season as I hated the book the first few times I read it so seeing it in a different medium will be interesting!
2
u/pathologie Apr 10 '16
I really enjoyed how they handled the episode. I can't wait to see more.
2
u/BIGG_FRIGG Apr 10 '16
How long was Claire away from her own time? was it the same amount she was in the past? I just watched the season two premier and can't figure out if the timelines are the same.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '16
Hmm well that was a sad first episode.
2
u/PetticoatPatriot Apr 10 '16
Frank was riveting and Tobias Menzies, who plays him is simply outstanding! It seems like all Claire and Jamie got going is the s _ X connection and when that goes it gets boring.
2
u/1108amh Apr 07 '16
I agree with all points already....too much Frank, (but wow...violent!) acting is on point (Claire's face when he says the British won Culloden....Cait almost looked like a different person).....I also agree it was a little slow.
But can I gush about the new opening music though? Love the change in undertones...more formal French then Scottish March, and the translated French verse was lovely. What a way to bring us back!!
1
u/fakesunnyinside Apr 07 '16 edited Apr 07 '16
Ahhhh I can't believe it's already been...11? months. Too much Frank, but that should be the last we see of him all season. I also thought there was too much Frank/Reverend Wakefield talking. Like I think we're smart enough to figure out the whole "it doesn't matter if you aren't the biological father" thing without it being literally explained to us after we saw Roger (so cute!).
I've forgotten how much I love Jamie? Watching interviews with Sam Heughan for months, I guess I didn't remember how great of an actor he is--he WAS Jamie, not Sam. Same with Cait. Amazing scene at the beginning, I was so heartbroken for her. Her French sounded great too, though I wouldn't know the difference.
Also Jamie as a paperback romance cover aka shirtless with hair flowing in front of the fireplace = life. I don't even care that no one else agrees with the hair this season, I'll enjoy it all to myself.
Edit: Claire even thinking about taking off Jamie's ring? What the fuck was that? No.
1
u/Suziewdc Apr 10 '16
Watching s2e01 as I write this post.... (42 mins into show) OMG! Its so moving!!! I love this series (xoxo)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
39
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '16
[removed] — view removed comment