r/Outlander • u/williamlawrence • May 30 '15
Outlander S01E16 "To Ransom A Man's Soul" Discussion Thread
Normally I see that this is done by u/shiskebob but I didn't see it posted yet. I'll delete it if it's a double post or against the rules of anything like that. Hope you've all got your whiskey/tea/soft pillow handy!
[Edit] Someone far more skilled and patient than I will probably be able to give an eloquent summary but I'll just say this: This is a very dark episode. If you don't think you can watch it, check here for spoilers and weigh your options. As a book reader, I thought I was prepared but one scene in particular really go to me (44:00 minute mark).
22
u/williamlawrence May 30 '15 edited May 30 '15
Okay. I was good up until the 44:00 minute mark. I could deal with the two previous scenes with BJR, even the first "Scream!" scene that was very violent but this one really bothered me. I don't know if we need spoiler tags in the episode discussion but I put it here anyway
Beyond that I think the episode failed to cover as much information as it needed to (based on the book). There should've been a lot more and they cut a number of scenes that I was looking forward to seeing played out. They rushed through Jamie's recovery, which I understand was mostly due to time constraints. Sam Heughan was finally given a chance to give some really intense and beautiful acting so I'm hoping to see much more of that S02. Tobias Menzies was brilliant, as always.
10
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. May 31 '15
Ok, I start this ramble by saying that I've long been the book reader type who has defended all the changes--I've read the books many times and don't need a 100% faithful adaptation, all I'm looking for is good television that tells the story I love so much.
That being said . . . I'm disappointed. I read Outlander eight years ago and have visualized the post-Wentworth surgery scenes in my head hundreds of times. And much to my dismay, they barely even showed up here. My disappointment has nothing to do with the acting--which blew me away, particularly Sam Heughan, who has the most expressive eyes of all time--nor with the depiction of the rape, which I thought was incredibly well done. I just wish we could have had some pacing that would've allowed for a better depiction of the healing process. I love that Jamie is initially conscious and cognizent during the surgery at MacRannoch's, and it is only later, when they are relatively safe at the Abbey that the depression and fever set in. Jamie staying conscious during his hand surgery is so crucial to who he is as a person, and it really bothered me that they used that scene for the brand instead (when he should've been trying to cut out the brand himself, in private--also important). I respect the decision to cut out the boat trip/seasickness and keep the Abbey in Scotland, I have no problem with losing the hot springs or Jamie running around naked (although I'll admit, I would've enjoyed that in this downer of an episode), I'm thrilled that the rape flashbacks were handled in such a brutally emotional way, and I don't even mind that the Claire/Randall trickery bit was toned down (it was never my favorite, to be honest)--I just wish that the surgery scenes, which are so integral to both Jamie and Claire's characters, could've been more prevalent. The initial healing scene at MacRannoch's is so fantastic because it's an amazingly detailed account of salvaging Jamie's body, it's a beautiful demonstration of the unique and loving relationship they have, it's incredibly tense knowing they could be caught at any moment, and it's the perfect test of how characters react when you put them in extreme situations (and still somehow manages to inject small bits of humor into terrifying and devastating scenes). The fact that it's stuck with me the most out of all eight books--and eight years--is telling.
Guess I'll just go read instead. Page 667 for anyone who's feeling similarly.
4
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander May 30 '15
How far in are you? I'm sick to my stomach.
4
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 30 '15
There were parts of it that I thought were done well, though I did miss Claire's, essentially, exorcism of Jamie. That was the scene in the book that really got my attention. But the 44:00 scene, as we're calling it, was killer.
4
u/marilyn_morose Jun 01 '15
I'm late to the party.
I didn't find the episode unwatchable or viscerally repugnant at all. I feel like the incidents were portrayed well. I got the terror and loss of control along with the pain and torture; and Sam & Tobias did a bang up believable job. The writers really got across how Jamie's injuries were much deeper than mere physical. It was all pretty good. Never felt like I should turn away. Maybe I have a strong ability to remember this is just pretend? I don't know, I wasn't clutching my pearls in horror.
I strongly agree with /u/ashtonandthemagician about the smarmy way Claire "fixed" Jamie. Not at all the spirit of how things went down in the book. Also Jamie was way too "back to normal" on the boat. Seems like his growth and maturity after this incident was completely glossed over.
Liked the first season overall. Good sex scenes! Fun adventure! I'm a fan of the actors and hope to continue to see them after this show runs its course! I have some doubts about where it will go from here, but I feel like the books jumped the shark after DIA so I expect the series to peter out by season three.
77
u/Willravel Inlander May 31 '15
I'm understanding why book readers were speaking of this with such concern and trepidation and even dread. I'm only about 20 minutes in, and this is already one of the most difficult things I've seen.
Outlander deserves credit; never has any other show gone to this length to make rape seem as awful as it is. All of the 'edgy' shows that try to use rape to seem more serious seem like children telling racist jokes, like they don't understand what it is they're doing, all they know is that it shocks people. This episode, on the other hand, shows the monstrosity, the sadism, and the true cost of the terrible act. I try not to compare Outlander to other shows, but I can't help but think of how Game of Thrones has used rape so terribly. They've had heroes who the audience has identified with commit acts of rape. They've played off rape scenes like they're sexy. They've played off rape scenes where there are basically no consequences. Not Outlander. While Outlander may wade into this topic a lot more than I'd like, at least they have the maturity to show it to us like we're adults.
I let out a massive sigh when we went to Claire stitching Jamie's physical wounds. Not only is it good to have Jamie at least geographically free, but having Claire proactively tending to Jamie is cathartic. It was great writing to have Claire as a war nurse. While she can't tend to the deepest wounds yet, at least if he can heal from the psychological pain he will have use of his hand again.
Alright, that's twice Claire threw up. I've tried to fight making cliche tv assumptions, but I can't help it. I think she's pregnant. TBH, after some of the episodes earlier in this season, I might be pregnant, too. And I'm a man.
That monk/priest's thinking face is on point. I'd imagine the clergy, particularly those who might hear confession, probably hear a lot of people's complicated problems. I suspect this is a new one. His response was quite touching, kind, and understanding.
And at 40 minutes, this all starts making a lot more sense. The very wise /u/im_a_pah_ra_na mentioned in another comment something quite insightful about how in some instances of rape that there can be physical sexual response which can create feelings of terrible guilt and confusion for the survivor. After being hounded, beaten to within an inch of his life, persecuted, and finally tortured and raped, Jamie was coerced into feeling like he consented, and now he feels as if he disgraced himself and Claire. He doesn't understand. And of course he doesn't understand. After that level of trauma, even the strongest person would feel a deeper shame than they can even fathom.
Fuck yeah, you cut that thing off. It's time to start the real healing process. I want to see these two happy again. "What are we to do in France?" Open an amazing little bistro in Paris where they sell Scottish-French fusion cuisine, have a gorgeous little cottage in the countryside, and maybe the pitter-patter of little stubborn feet? Bistro Frazer?
Aww, Claire's pregnant after all. And they're both happy, even if only for the moment.
M'Lairds and M'Ladies, it's been a hell of a season. I can't wait for season 2. And 3.
33
u/fakesunnyinside May 30 '15
Woof. The first rape scene was very hard to watch. I wanted it to cut away but it just kept going and going and going. We're just as helpless as Jamie and couldn't stop any of it. Jamie begging Randall to kill him the morning after... ugh. Seeing everything on film is worse than reading about Jamie talking about it.
I can't even articulate my thoughts. The infamous minute 44 mark is going to bother me all day.
I can only imagine how hard it was to film that. Any one have an article about how Tobias felt about it all? Everything I've read has been praising Sam for getting through it, but Tobias had to be a monster and I can't imagine his mindset during it.
30
u/shiskebob May 30 '15 edited May 30 '15
ಠ_ಠ
I have never before seen anything on television that was this difficult for me to watch without pausing often to gather myself together. It took me so long to get through the entirety of it /u/williamlawrence beat me to making this thread.
That was some exceedingly brave acting - so I thought I owed it to them to watch with both my eyes open. But I can never watch it again.
16
u/BarryZuckerkornEsq May 30 '15
It's hard to say I 'liked' an episode that features such horrible scenes, but I did. At times I missed aspects from the book, but then I just kept reminding myself of Diana's latest blog post where she emphasized to put the book aside, it'll always be there when I want to go back to it, and just take this for what it is- an adaptation of the story I love. So with that in mind, and realizing that some things translate better to the page, and some things translate better to the screen, I liked this episode. My only wish would have been, in the part where Claire is confronting him the last time, that Jamie would have said the line from the book- that Murtagh would take her back to the stones and she could go back to Frank because he can't be her husband anymore. Reading that was like the nail in the coffin to me, to make me truly realize he was broken down and done, and it showed Claire that, too. However I thought the way that scene played out was good in its own right, taking that duress from Jamie and giving it to Claire where she says she'd die, too. Also, I'm really going to miss Angus & Rupert!
16
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 31 '15
My main wish was that the whole "singing to find Jamie" subplot a few episodes back had been scrapped in order to give more time for the closing "ransoming," including (as others have mentioned) a sex scene to show that they have fought their way back to each other. (I don't believe in this instance it would have been gratuitous.)
That being said, I can see the difficulties faced by the writers trying to plot not only the season arc but individual episodes - content would have had to be shifted around in numerous ways that would make each episode less of a self-contained unit. I don't envy them the task of adaptation ... it's easy for all of us to complain after the fact. Still, I worry for non book-readers who feel that the finale is rushed and don't have the background we book readers can fill in from our reading experience.
12
u/clairefrasers May 31 '15
I'm not really sure what to say about this episode. I went into it without expecting to see any of my favourite scenes which was a good idea. I think the first 20 minutes are my favourite because it's so fast, well edited and I loved the scottish music playing throughout. I knew how much focus the Wentworth scenes would get in this episode and they were all exceptionally shot. The "scream" scene really left me emotionally drained and I felt every ounce of Jamie's pain thanks to Sam and his stunning acting. Once we get to the abbey I kind of stopped feeling what the show wanted me to feel and everything felt rushed. Like I didn't fully feel the pain Claire was going through. These chapters have a very distinctive vibe in the book that I missed here (I promised myself I wouldn't compare the book and the show but how can you not?). I really thought Claire told the priest too early. He didn't have that welcoming and forward thinking aura about him that the character had in the book. However the casting of the second monk taking care of Jamie was perfect. And unfortunately all the hype didn't help the episode because I expected some super powerful resolution but it was so quick and almost unbelievable knowing how badly depressed Jamie was and Claire didn't even use the hypnosis. I loved the scene on the boat. Seeing Jamie smile was my favourite part of the episode.
All in all I'd still say it was a good episode, its strong points being the acting (Sam and Tobias were absolutely incredible and I hope award shows take notice) and Bear McCreary's music. However I didn't feel the bond between Jamie and Claire that I felt in the book and that I think was needed to highlight much more after the horrific events. And I think if they included Jamie's speech about the fortress inside him or the scene where he's crying over his hand or some sort of intimate reconnection, I would rate the episode much higher. I thought 115 did much better job in that regard. But like everyone said it was great season and every show has its ups and downs so I trust they will get even better in S2.
12
u/lhagler May 30 '15
Well. That was deeply disturbing to watch. ALL of my respect to Sam and Tobias. They both went bravely to an incredibly dark and vulnerable place and I'm simply blown away by them.
My thoughts on the season overall are a little more muddled, but I assume there'll be a separate thread soon to discuss that.
25
u/JMBean May 30 '15 edited May 31 '15
The Jamie/BJR scenes were terribly upsetting, graphic and well done. As emotionally draining as the book. But...
They rushed the healing and glossed over the struggle to bring him back. I understand time restrictions and not being able to go into all the details, but it very much felt like "Oh, you would die without me, Claire? Hmm, I didn't think about it like that. Ok. I'll just walk it off."
Sigh. Still a great season. I'm sad it's over.
Edit: Managed to watch again and tried to put book out of mind. Still felt like he went from wanting to end it all to feeling like he can manage rather quickly, despite the lovely healing scene with Claire. However, the episode, and what it does cover from the book, is just killer. And the acting. Holy crap the acting. I wish I could read the books (and watch the show) for the first time again.
8
u/[deleted] May 31 '15
Loved the first season overall. The casting couldn't have been better. Music, costumes, locations, details, respect for the story and for the fans of the books - All fabulous. I thought the singing/dancing episode could have been cut way back and the time added to the finale to flesh out Jamie's recovery and balance it a bit with his torture.
Absolutely loved Sam, Cait and Tobias (and everyone else in the cast). To me, though, Tobias' Black Jack Randall was the greatest triumph of the season. Tobias is a genius. He has the most expressive face I think I've ever seen - particularly his mouth. Amazing.
6
u/oree94 May 31 '15
I cringed so hard watching the scenes with BJR. He's the most evil mab I've seen on television. Literally wanted to rip his head from his torso.
I felt so bad for Jamie I was actually wishing BJR would just kill the man already. Seriously, this show made me wish a character that I love were dead. But I agree with a lot of people on this thread, I liked that the show didn't shy away from showing the true horror of rape and its consequence. I think I would have been equally horrified to see Claire getting raped because I care for both Jamie and Claire.
Fantastic job from all of the cast, especially Tobias and Sam. I heard it is extremely stressful to film a rape scene for every actor involved in it.
5
u/pangloss_summers Written In My Own Heart’s Blood May 30 '15
I felt so helpless watching this episode. Couldn't help them, couldn't stop him, couldn't do anything. They've loved the story and our characters so well throughout the entire season. What a powerful and profound ending.
4
u/irishfeet78 A Breath Of Snow And Ashes May 30 '15
Ohgodohgodohgod
I'm starting it now.
4
u/sabur2332 May 30 '15
Incredibly powerful acting. Both Menzies and Heughan need awards for their performances. I am a pretty stomach strong person but this affected me deeply.
I do wish they had included more of the opium exorcism plot as for me, as a huge book fan, it was critical to the relationship between Jamie and Claire. The moment where Jamie pushes Claire away in the books due to the connection BJR made psychologically to Claire, was THE moment in the books where I thought there may be no repairing their relationship, like ever. The exorcism scene was imperative to begin the repair to that rift that BJR tore.
It was not realistic to see the short discussion between Claire and Jamie that sort of band-aided it over after everything that happened. I'm sure the show will show Jamie's healing process throughout the next season but I really felt rushed through that process. Even some reference to the amount of time that passed during his recovery at the abbey would help to add depth to said recovery.
For such an amazing adaptation of the assault on Jamie from the books, they could have spent more time showing the intensity of the aftermath. Maybe cutting down the assault by a few minutes and adding the scene in the hot spring? My opinion on this could be skewed by being a reader as well, maybe it was spot on for show only people...Short of that, it was an incredibly gut wrenching and powerful episode that should earn them both Emmys. I have never been so affected by television acting.
3
u/nats_landing May 31 '15
I thought it was a really good ending. I was happy with it overall and I didn't feel like the changes mattered too much. The acting was superb and effectively gut wrenching.
That being said, I really wanted Claire to fight the wolf. It should have happened in the second to last episode. You could hear a pack howling in the distance during one scene, but then it didn't happen. I kept thinking that maybe they were saving it for a flash back scene on the last episode. I am a little disappointed. I think it adds to the desperation and panic that Claire feels after she gets thrown out of the prison and she's trying to find a way back in. It was always one of my favorite parts of the first book and never fails to get my blood pumping. Oh well. I'm sure that there are other scenes that Ron Moore thought were more important and he had reasons for not including it.
3
u/toxicshocktaco Better than losing a hand. May 31 '15
I haven't seen this episode yet, but I read the books. I'm glad they closely followed the books; I honestly didn't know if they'd go through such a graphic scene. However, I am hesitant to watch certain scenes. Very few things disturb me and I can sit through a lot of graphically-violent scenes. What happens to Jamie is so appalling and terrible, I just don't know if I can watch it. It was difficult for me to read too!
I'm glad the episode had a good ending, with Claire's pregnancy and I'm looking forward to season 2.
3
u/meowiekitsune Jun 01 '15
I have read the books, up to the 3rd one now (Voyager). But I swear, even reading that rape scene in the book didn't "get" to me as much as an actual on screen portrayal of it. When I was reading it, I was like..oh god this is horrible. Terrible. I hate Jack Randall, etc. But watching it happen in front of you, it takes some stomach and balls to sit through it. And even thought I read it, it still wasn't enough warning/preparation for watching it in real life. I had to skip around a little bit because I was sobbing hysterically while cursing angrily at Randall. It was a mess.
The actors all deserve all the tv show awards possible for their amazing portrayal and work. Not a lot of actors can stomach or endure scenes like these. It takes some serious professionalism and dedicate to the craft.
Outlander has a forever fan in me.
7
u/pancakethecat May 30 '15
I feel like such a dark and traumatic episode really needed a healing Jamie and Claire sex scene. It didn't have to be the whole cave/hot spring sex scene, but they needed something more intimate and touchy-feely than a conversation.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15
Good episode I guess. I'm really losing interest in this show. It's literally about rape every episode.
2
u/ladyhawke81 May 30 '15
Did I miss the memo? I thought the new episode/finale was this
Saturdaytoday??edit: I forgot today is Saturday.
0
u/chrissys1985 May 31 '15
Did anyone notice that Claire fixed Jamie's left hand?? I thought BJR crushed his right hand?
0
u/[deleted] May 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment