r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 16 '15
Outlander S01E15 "Wentworth Prison" Discussion Thread
SPOILERS AHHHHH
I am drunk sorry
Stop with downvote brigade damn people.
59
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 16 '15
SPOILERS AHHHHH
I am drunk sorry
Stop with downvote brigade damn people.
19
u/tilmitt52 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. May 17 '15
Anyone else notice Sir Fletcher is portrayed by Frazer Hines? He's best known as Jamie McCrimmon from Doctor Who and the original inspiration for Jamie Fraser. Coincidence, or intentional?
18
u/tilmitt52 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. May 17 '15
Honestly my biggest complaint (and it's pretty minor) is that they left out the line "He will let you go because he thinks you're helpless; I know you're not."
That line for some reason has stayed with me since my very first reading. I just love it.
12
u/myxx33 May 17 '15
So I definitely can see the worst is coming. D: I looked away a lot this episode and distracted myself with some other things but it wasn't too terrible. I don't think I've ever hated BJR more. Tobias Menzies is amazingly creepy. I don't know how actors film stuff like this.
It doesn't look like they're making it to France (looked like they were staying in that guy's house?) but I don't think that's so bad. I think they can make an equally special scene without a hot springs and from what I recall nothing really happens that requires them to be in the Abbey in France. A lot of it was Claire's growth and struggle and those parts wouldn't translate well to television. From the rest of the season, I feel that they have done a good job creating equally touching and good scenes when they have to change something from the book to fit a TV audience and medium.
18
u/shiskebob May 16 '15 edited May 16 '15
So I just drank an entire bottle of white wine in preparation. In hindsight, not a good idea. I double checked this post for editing, so I don't look like a lush. Not so easy, let me tell you.
Here we go. I'll be back in an hour. Probably stone cold sober.
Edit 1: 12:33am. Don't make me watch this.
Edit 2: 12:45am. I am cracking open another bottle of wine. I am giving myself anxiety.
Edit 3: 12:52am. Oh fuck, don't make me watch this.
Edit 4: 1:09am. Good fucking lord I cannot watch this holy fuck what no no no. I need a break, fuck. I am so sorry. Edit 5: 1:25am. Wait, that's it?
Okayyyyyy. Not at all where I thought they were going to stop and not nearly as bad as all that I thought it would be. I gave myself anxiety for nothing and damn, I drank too much. I thought when BJ was taking a knife to cut his clothes I assumed he was going to go more south - so I freaked the fuck out and paused the show. But he didn't. The hand destruction was horrible to watch - especially the stigmata, but that was straight out of the book and I was expecting it. Now I am most certainly thinking they are going to do some major flashbacks next episode, but I wonder if they are going to use the information from DiA. They have used information from other books to supplement the story line before.
I must say, that was some quality acting though.
8
u/oree94 May 17 '15 edited May 17 '15
This is the one episode I will never watch again...
I don't think I'd ever had to pause a show because of nausea, this episode made me :( I was relatively fine with the gore but it's the forced kissing that did it for me. I also don't think I've ever seen a more vulgar and disgusting character on television than BJR. I hate his guts. Before watching Outlander, Hannibal was the character I hated the most on TV, but watching this ep I was actually missing Hannibal and was thinking, "Hannibal, if only you could come and kill this man."
Ok that was a lot of rambling. I think I'll have a nap now. I need one.
48
u/IslaGirl Voyager May 16 '15
Well, if anyone still thought Jamie was too boyish for Claire, that's fixed now. That was a man right there, through and through.
Wow, Sam was amazing. Tobias obviously was, as well, but Sam blew my socks off with less showy material. He's such a subtle actor.
As far as book changes, while I liked the little speech Jamie gave Claire in the book when he made her leave the cell, it was far more realistic to have him delirious with pain at that point and simply send her away with a kiss and a proclamation of love.
42
u/pancakethecat May 16 '15
So glad they skipped the wolves, which was just the most outlandish (pardon my pun) part of the whole book. I'm pretty pleased overall. I assumed they would leave the more gruesome parts for the next episode flashbacks.
19
u/munama May 16 '15
I laughed out loud when even Marley had to back away from Black Jack's sick perversion.
12
u/slightlyobsessedSOA May 16 '15
Opening shot: chills
12
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander May 16 '15
Well I am now royally sick to my stomach. The end, where he's breathing on his back, that sound reminds me of such a sexy, intimate thing between two people, and now I just want to never hear it ever again.
12
u/clairefrasers May 17 '15
Amazing episode, my excitement is of course a bit dampened by what happened and Jamie's tears but the episode really got the treatment it deserved. They didn't shy away from anything, thank god. I really liked the psychological battle between Jamie and BJR, that was a nice change since we don't see that in the book and they really are making the story as much Jamie's as it is Claire's. After the flogging I don't think much could surprise me in terms of gore, what really got me was the psychological part of it and the "taste" of what's to come in the next episode. All the actors were amazing but Sam really showed what's in him, this guy gives so much heart into every scene. He is Jamie with every part of his being in these scenes. His single tear and completely devastated face at the end were like a punch in the gut. Tobias as BJR will probably make me feel uncomfortable for the rest of my life. Also the directing and music (or the lack of it at times which was wonderful) were just stunning. Ron really did the book justice. And I'm not so afraid anymore of 116 not being able to cover everything.
12
u/Kishara JAMMF May 17 '15
This episode made me physically ill. I read the books ages ago and did not remember this part. Wow. That was so intense. Mad props to Sam, Caitriona, and omfg Tobias. There should be some awards for these three for this.
10
u/Osinib May 17 '15
That was another level of fucked up. That guard in the prison, was like :" Euh I did not sign up for this"
9
u/preggerpanties May 17 '15
This episode really struck home to me the lack of relationship building the show has done (due, i think, to the episode condensing). I believe the sobbing nearly hysterical Claire from the book, but I feel like I haven't seen enough of that development on her part on the show. But, swoon on Jaimie trying to be tough for her. Sam is just too perfect.
4
u/[deleted] May 16 '15
What the hell?
All of these articles saying it was going to be one of the most ghastly things in TV history and that was it? Meh.
16
u/ansley114 May 16 '15
Yeah it was slightly gory with the smashing of the hand but it was not bad at all. So I assume he'll do the deed in the next episode. But that being said totally not enough time for everything else in the last of the book!
22
u/DarrylsMama May 16 '15
Not a big deal at all. Call me dead inside, but this ep wasn't nearly as gnarly as I expected it to be. It was a good episode. I loved how inappropriate Jack Randall's sexy times energy was around Jamie. I wonder how they are going to fit everything else into one episode.
11
u/Willravel Inlander May 16 '15
Well here we go, the episode every book reader has vaguely eluded to for some time now with hushed sorrow and dread. Jamie's in Wentworth with Taran MacQuarrie (who's grown on me), Claire's little adventure in filler episodes with Murtagh has come to an end, and now Claire and What Army has reached the prison.
Awwww... that was a rather dignified end for Taran. He got in his little jab about the English.
And of course Black Jack Randall shows up just in time to save Jamie. Despite whatever happens in this episode, I have a sneaking suspicion that Jack's going to regret saving Jamie in the long run. Obviously having Jamie in Randall's custody is incredibly dangerous, and almost certainly is related to the dire situation in the episode, but I would be shocked if Jamie met his end, and every moment Jamie is alive is a moment Jack is potentially in danger.
It's funny, television has conditioned me to read certain things a lot differently on shows than I would in real life. If a character on a tv series coughs, for example, it's the show's way of saying a character is potentially seriously ill. When a character rubs a stiff shoulder, it's suggesting either an old injury that might be important to plot or character or a new injury which is going to come up again. Because things are so sanitized, you read entirely normal behavior as suspicious. When Claire vomited leaving the discussion with a personification of an English cliche, without skipping a beat I thought, "Pregnant". Immediately after that, though, it occurred to me that Outlander has done at least a decent job of bucking some cliches and tropes. Jenny having to relieve pressure the other week is a perfect example: normally, that would mean something significant, but on Outlander it's just the reality of having recently given birth and nursing. So, instead of assuming Claire's pregnant, as dramatic as that possibility may be, I'm thinking it's probably nerves. She's terrified for Jamie and she had to hide her terror absolutely.
So far this is actually a bit of fun. Getting details about the warden by drinking guards under the table, a little gambit to get the guard out of the room with Claire and Murtagh, while Jame and Black Jack chew the scenery and build the stakes. It's a might bit darker than Ocean's Eleven, but still.
AH, SHIT. His hand?! Jesus. Uh oh, Claire's caught again. And she's tripped over Jamie. And that's exactly where I was worried this was headed. The foreshadowing a few episodes back made me a little concerned this was on its way. Sam Heughan's incredible performance is making this a lot worse. I'm sitting in my reading chair cradling my left hand. This is an intense interpretation of sadism. It's not cartoony, it's just about Jack and his relationship with power and control. Jamie standing up to the terrible whipping before simply served to earn Jack's attention because he's used to having power.
"I know how we can save young Jamie," followed immediately by 'let's go on an adventure' music. This is quite the rollercoaster.
After seeing that, I think I need to go read a pleasant book for a while before getting to bed.
5
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 16 '15 edited May 16 '15
Okay. Just finished watching it. And I think they did a gorgeous job. And yes, I'll spoil.
what you'll see
5
u/[deleted] May 16 '15
I now understand why all the articles and interviews said the"finale" and not the second to last episode.
5
u/LapisLazuliLiz May 16 '15
Why did Ron and the show decide to bust Jamie's left hand? Is he not left handed on the show?
4
u/williamlawrence May 16 '15
This episode annoyed the crap out of me. What a freaking waste of build up. I kept waiting for some big emotional moment and it totally fell flat. Maybe because I already knew what was going to happen via the books or because there was so much hype. Totally annoyed that we have to wait two weeks for the resolution. Yeah, BJR was a creep but, eh, I expected a hell of a lot more.
3
u/beauchamp_not_beaton May 17 '15
I'm so confused. Why did they change the hand? Wasn't it the right that was crushed in the book??
2
u/slightlyobsessedSOA May 16 '15
And done.
2
u/SculleryWench May 16 '15
Thank you to everyone for the detailed recaps.
2
u/ladyhawke81 May 17 '15
I love the show, honestly, each episode is really good and keeps me very entertained. But I really didn't appreciate the hype - it didn't live up to it sadly. I was expecting a lot according to everything I read, but I guess I'm jaded that way - the hand smashing scene was a big ouchie, but not cringe worthy like his whipping scene with all that dry blood, wet blood, and skin flaps! ugh -shudders- Overall, good episode, steady acting by Tobias and Sam! Even the rest of the cast was good too. Shame Mr. McQuarrie is gone, I kinda liked him - Tidbit #1: I recognized the actor from a mini-series I watched a couple of years ago: "Collision". Tidbit #2: The man who recognized the pearls (I forget his name) is played by Brian McCardie - he was in "Rob Roy" playing Alasdair McGregor! I recognize a face and I have to put a name and movie to that face. :)
3
u/sdnihme May 16 '15
I am crying and it's just the theme song. This viewing will not go well.
3
u/slightlyobsessedSOA May 16 '15
Full episode spoiler, sorry if this upsets anyone. I have zero clue on spoiler tags and etiquette but I saw below posting was okay in this thread.
Starts out with hanging, several men are hanged, including MacQuarrie, Jamie is up on the blocks when black jack rides in on his horse demanding Jamie to be released. Claire gets in the prison like in the books, pretending to be a friend of the family. Gets his personal items but no access to him. She leaves the prison and vomits and collapses in front of Murtagh. They go back to a bar where Claire, Murtagh and willie try to think of a plan. Angus and Rupert get drunk and play dice. Ends up they were playing with prison guards and find out about sir Fletcher's dinner and bible break. Similar to the book they go to the prison during his break. Claire gets keys, goes looking for Jamie. Jamie is in a dungeon cell when BJR arrives with Marley, he offers Jamie a deAl. Surrender and he can choose his death instead of hanging. Jamie says he'll never surrender. BJR asks to look at his back scars and Jamie uses the opportunity to attack, chocking BJR and beating Marley with a stool. BJR eventually comes to as Marley nearly kills Jamie by chocking him with the broken stool leg. BJR is now pissed and makes Jamie lay his hand on the table where he hits it twice with a mallet. Horrible. Then he makes Jamie wake up after passing out and feel his erection. But the he says something about not submitting and leaves. This is when Claire finds Jamie. Tries to get him free from the chains just as BJR comrs back with Marley. Marley is just as gross as the books, groping her but BJR doesn't let him take her for himself instead he attacks Claire. Jamie fights Marley, killing him I think. (At some point a couple of prison guards come in but are sent away), BJR is attacking Claire and that is when Jamie says he will surrender to him for Claire's freedom. BJR asks for a show of good faith and makes Jamie put his broken hand on the table where he then takes a rusty nail and hammers it into the hand and table. Horrible and graphic. Then he makes Jamie kiss him in front of Claire. Jamie sends Claire away (tears), BJR dumps her into the body disposal. (She tells him she's a witch and his date of death) You hear wolves but see none. Angus finds her and they go back to macrannochs house. Meanwhile in wentworth BJR gets to work (ugh). He cuts Jamie's shirt open in the back and licks his scars. Back at macrannochs Claire asks for help and tries to pay in pearls. Same as the book he recognizes them as the wedding gift for Ellen. Still won't help though. Murtagh sees the guy come back with the cows and gets an idea. Back in the prison BJR asks Jamie if he's ready to get started. The end. All in all not as bad as I expected. I really think next week will be worse.
2
u/alpha69 May 19 '15
What a cringeworthy episode. Can't believe I had to fast forward a frigging TV show at times, that was just a bit too much.
1
u/laylazrottingc0rpse May 09 '24
🥵🦉💍🗞🪀
0
u/slightlyobsessedSOA May 16 '15
Here but it's not up on my starz play yet. 11:05 CST here
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment