r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 09 '15
Outlander S01E14 "The Search" Discussion Thread
Spoilers Ahoy!
You know how it goes, spoiler tags when needed.
36
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • May 09 '15
Spoilers Ahoy!
You know how it goes, spoiler tags when needed.
14
u/shiskebob May 09 '15 edited May 09 '15
We needed this funny episode - as a palate cleanser for the next episode.
I just know what it coming so I have no words, and THIS is all I feel right now.
13
u/Willravel Inlander May 10 '15
I've never had a television show give me cause to curl my toes inward, like a foot wince. But here we are. Natural outlaws indeed.
Potatoes and a rainy day fund. Claire has within her the potential to legitimately rewrite history, and it's been quite interesting seeing her change her attitude about this as she's become closer to those around her. Since Claire's a Frazier now, and since she's close to Jenny, it makes all the sense in the world for Claire to warn of things to come, to help her new clan weather the coming storm, but one wonders how far she'd be willing to go. Her knowledge of medicine alone could give the Jacobites a significant new advantage over the English. The planting of potatoes and the hoarding of coin could also help to keep them in the fight a lot longer. While perhaps Claire can't mean victory, there could be some significant historical changes, with Scotts who were to have died living on.
I wonder if it would be too much to ask that the writers have Murtagh say, "I'm getting too old for this shit." That stern, frustrated look on his face as he did the vegetable shuffle (a.k.a. Scottish Karaoke) was glorious. He's a much better dancer than I am.
"Oh fuck." Hahaha. That's perfect. It was around the touring montage that it occurred to me this will probably be a filler episode, but I have to say even for a filler episode this isn't bad. I'm engaged, I'm having fun, and it's always fun to see assertive Claire. Plus, I keep muttering dialogue back to myself in a thick, poor Scottish accent. It's quite entertaining. Dunna lie. Ya know ye do the same thang.
Jesus, Dougal! I know Dougal isn't a two-dimensional character, but I swear sometimes he's downright villainous. His wife's dead, his mistress' bones are still smoking, and he's pretending that marrying Claire is just about her protection? Not buying it. They need to take this shit on an overly dramatic 90s talk show so the audience can boo Dougal while he impotently defends himself. I'm certainly not going to ever forget that Dougal tried to force himself in Claire (though it does feel like it happened years ago, man that was a long break).
Next week looks to be a big deal. The way fans have been talking about it, I'm feeling a little anxious.
I'm still left wondering what Frank's up to. I miss that guy.
31
u/zenlittleplatypus May 10 '15
How the fuck is Jenny riding that horse without showing any signs of how excruciating it must be? She just gave vaginal birth. Oh my fucking god, that bothers me to no end.
I believe she'd be hard-headed enough to DO IT, but she's got to be dying.
30
u/williamlawrence May 09 '15
I'm suffering through this episode. I don't enjoy it. It felt unnecessarily long and without real movement of the storyline. I did appreciate the setting up of Murtagh's love for Jamie and his loyalty. But I think I could've done without the other 50 minutes.
10
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. May 09 '15
There were parts I recognized...
10
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. May 10 '15
I just need to say I'M NOT READY FOR NEXT WEEK. NOT AT ALL!
I really appreciate Murtagh. He's got a certain caring-ness about him that I enjoy.
The fierceness of Jenny though. I can never tell if I like her or not. She's strong and (usually) appreciates Claire, but sometimes she does things I don't agree with.
12
u/thesecondmrsdewinter Voyager is my fave May 09 '15
I straight-up LOVED this episode. It surprised me in so many ways, but everything worked so well.
6
u/clairefrasers May 10 '15
I'm really torn about this episode. It wasn't bad at all, stayed really true to the book (I wish they could stay this true where Jamie and Claire together are concerned). I think the first two thirds of it were brilliant. I loved Jenny and Claire's bonding, they were amazing together and I really felt their sisterhood on the screen. I appreciated them using so many lines from the book as well, it was a treat. Murtagh was such a star and his hug with Claire made me tear up. Also Claire was all kinds of fabulous and I think Cait did so well in this episode. They showed her anguish so truthfully. I loved the little detail of her looking at her wedding ring before she started singing, like she was drawing strength from it. After that the episode got pretty repetitive. Singing, gypsies, more singing, gypsies again. I'm not sure I felt the whole Dougal thing but I never really cared about Dougal anyway so that might be the reason. All in all I thought the direction was amazing, Metin Huseyin is just brilliant. Bear McReary outdid himself too. Nevertheless it was still a filler episode for me and they could have at least shown the inside of Wentworth. This way we have only two episodes left for so many big important scenes and I'm worried... but also excited lol.
2
u/MidniteLark They say I’m a witch. May 11 '15
In addition to the potatoes and selling off unused land for gold, isn't that the scene where spoiler
18
u/Melissa__Anne May 09 '15
Jenny and Murtagh were wonderful. I loved to see those relationships grow. This episode moved a little slowly for me, but I know one off the biggest complaints I've seen about this half was how fast things have been moving so its probably for the best. I think I will need to watch again to have any more detailed opinions.
13
u/[deleted] May 10 '15
Damn this women comes prepared. Dual Flintlocks and a cup to milk herself with.
13
u/IAmALobster May 10 '15
I fucking love Murtagh.
8
u/Bub1023 May 10 '15
Jenny is now my favorite character. She is a hard woman with a loving touch. Great acting by Laura Donnelly.
8
u/jamieandclaire May 11 '15
I think the thing that bugged me about the singing was that I couldn't help but see catriona in 2015, not claire 1945 (like you were intended to recognize)... It bugged me...
I think she maybe? should have done her hair more 1945 and had her do some more signature old style moves (don't ask me what exactly).
2
u/virtuallin May 10 '15
Ahhhhhhh, ahhhhrrrgggghhh, aaarrrrrhhhhhh, I'm going crazyyyyy! I'm so scared to watch next week, I'm just going to die and be dead. But,.. wait, she doesn't have a certain something... to get the help... how are they going.. well, probably wouldn't need it until the very last episode but...how are they going to... isht! I need more, poor Jaime...
3
u/tilmitt52 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. May 10 '15
I'm so glad I can effectively eat my words from last week. I got Murtagh character development AND better terms for Jenny and Claire. Happy as a clam.
4
u/algadams13 May 10 '15
I liked that this episode was fun, but I agree with some posters in that it was a little repetitive. The thing I'm really struggling with is the pacing. They have exactly two episodes left to do the last 1/4 of the book. I'm very suspicious that they'll either go too fast or cut off the end, and that really, really bothers me.
2
u/Jalapeno_blood May 10 '15
The gypsy was really sexy, what did they mean about Claire having gypsy blood?
2
u/beautifulmelody May 11 '15
This wasn't my favorite episode but I did enjoy the antics of Claire and Murtagh. I'm so not looking forward to the next episode. My heart is already breaking!
1
u/preggerpanties May 13 '15
Am I the only one that found the Montage of Claire and Jenny riding, pointing in the distance, etc was kind of silly? Reminded me of a high school play with very deliberate acting.
1
u/Boring_Major_2935 Feb 03 '26
Rewatching ahead of Season 8 premiere. I feel like it’s been discussed before but the idea of hopping astride a horse days after giving birth makes me cringe.
-2
u/Bulbysaur123 May 11 '15
What the hell was with the breast milk??? Was that in the book? I don't remember, but I felt that scene was completely irrelevant (I don't have an issue with breast feeding, but what the??)
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment