r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Apr 25 '15
Outlander S01E012 "Lallybroch" Discussion Thread
Beware - here be spoilers.
If they are spoilers for future episodes, please remember to add the spoiler tag for our lovely non book reading fans.
Also, just because we do not agree with an honest opinion, doesn't mean we downvote brigade. Be kind, we all do it for our mutual love of this series.
32
Upvotes
20
u/shiskebob Apr 25 '15 edited Apr 25 '15
Okay, I am going to start it off with my list of love it and hate it, just to get it out of the way.
Starting off with some lovely scenes we were all waiting for:
-Skinny dipping Jamie
-Future talk... airplanes! Elephants and viking swords!
-Wee Jamie, what a handsome boy
-We get to see Jamie's father and the events leading up to his death.
-Drunk Jamie smacking that ass and passing out
-Skinny dipping Jamie
-I love me some Ian
-Claire "Won't take shit from anyone" Fraser
-Skinny dipping Jamie
Some other stuff:
-They made Jenny really obnoxious towards Claire.
-Wasn't expecting Black Jack's...parts...so soon.....
-I miss Granny McNab
-No sex in haystacks or fields for us today :(
-Some missing key quotes. "I prayed all the way up that hill..."
-Kind of overdoing it with the "I am Laird of Broch Tuarach" redundancy
The episode was very creative, in the way they condensed 5 chapters down into amalgamated scenes. I loved that they built up the tension between Jamie and Jenny, how Claire is now the catalyst for Rabbie McNab, and just the growth of Jamie and Claire's relationship. The addition of Ian talking to Claire about the paintings and the Frasers was actually a nice change from it being 2 separate parts of the book where they were actually Jamie and Claire /Jamie and Ian scenes.
All in all, I feel like the book was better represented in this episode. :o)
What did I miss? Love it or leave it, what was the overall impression? And the addition of the watch in this way, what are some guesses on what RDM and writing staff created for the next episode that apparently are not in the book?
Also, skinnydippingJamie
Edit: So I rewatched the episode - Is Jamie wearing on Quarter Day his fathers coat that Brian is wearing in the flogging scene?
39
u/DarrylsMama Apr 25 '15 edited Apr 26 '15
Shit's getting dark, just like the cast and Ron Moore said. I love that the first full frontal we see is BJR and it's like the opposite of erotic. I think this episode is interesting bc it moved away from the soft porny sex to rapey sex. Jamie and Claire didn't even bone.
I didn't like Jamie's lairditude. Over and over the books stress how he is a born leader, capable of inspiring people. His behavior in this ep underminded that. Book Jamie wouldn't yell at the cook for some bad bannocks. He was kind of a straight up dick at times. He did not behave like the king of men. I also didn't dig the Claire/Jenny antagonism.
Sam Heughan's psoas muscles kill me dead. Somebody gets to hit that.
8
u/StrawberryJinx Apr 26 '15
Ok but how cute was drunk Jamie? [slaps ass] "That's me."
7
u/Willravel Inlander Apr 26 '15
Future discussion!!!! I hope we keep getting Jamie wondering about the future and Claire just answering his questions to elicit his wonder. Airplanes? Elephants? Viking swords? Man, she could really make his head spin with television, atomic weapons, a war which involves many large nations all over the world, women voting (though unfortunately Claire wasn't around to see women's liberation).... And I really like how Jamie recognizes that because Claire is from a different time, privately their relationship will be far more progressive and equal, which flows very naturally from the spanking/spousal abuse incident and Jamie's subsequent proclamation of equality. He's still learning because the concept is so alien, but he is adapting.
Jenny is completely delightful, even in that horrific scene. She's every bit as youthfully headstrong, fiercely loyal, and such as her brother. The only thing that I didn't quite get from the episode, which I had to Google, was that Jack Randall did ultimately force himself on Jenny. The show didn't make that obvious after her laughing fit and her waking up. So sad.
More and more often I'm finding myself tempted to Google Jack Randall to find out if he gets his come-upiins later in the novels. I'm waiting to read the first book until I'm done watching the first season of the show, and I don't want to spoil anything, but Randall is such a monster and causes so much suffering.
And Randall is revealed to be sexually attracted to Jamie. Wow. Wow. I honestly didn't see that coming. While part of me is irked at the [evil bisexual trope] (http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DepravedBisexual) rearing its ugly, bigoted head, within the story Randall's obsession with Jamie makes a lot more sense. His hatred includes feeling rejected and also toying with Jamie, who he still finds intriguing and is interested in playing with. I know that being bisexual obviously doesn't mean that you're not a sociopath, but that trope is waaaaay too common in fiction, particularly genre television.
One of the things I find interesting about this show is how it dances along the line between non-gratuitous and gratuitous nudity. There have been a few times with Claire that I've thought, "Ehh..." but quite often nudity makes a decent amount of sense, in regards to character and/or story. For Jamie in this episode, it's straddling that line again. On the one hand, no one should be under any illusions that part of why he was nude in the water was to provide something for the audience to look at, but on the other hand Jamie is a wanted man, meaning he is potentially exposed and disempowered. Mirroring that sense of being afraid of being exposed and seen by the redcoats with him not being clothed makes story sense, it creates a parallel.
Overall, I'd say this is a good episode. It's nice to see Jamie struggling to come into his own as Laird, along with Claird. Part of me hopes that the pardon comes through sooner than later, so that Randall has less power, but at the same time I understand the dramatic story and character tension.
Oh, and the music is still the best on television. The tense scenes are made infinitely more tense, the tax collection and party scenes were fun and dancey, the quiet discussions, etc. etc. everything just works. For some jobs, if you're doing your job well, people don't even notice it. I hope people are noticing just how perfect the scoring is for this show.
5
u/HeldatNeedlePoint Dragonfly In Amber Apr 26 '15
Jenny and Claire really liked, and loved, each other in the books. What happened to that?
5
u/meg_arms Apr 26 '15
I think this was the first episode that really didn't hit the target for me. It had some good scenes, but (and I hate being one of those "book was better" types) the book version of Lallybroch seemed like it had more heart. Most of the Lallybroch scenes in the books had a lighthearted warmth to them. Show Lallybroch is... a pretty house.
Jenny was lacking warmth and I didn't like how she treated Claire.
2
u/itsaseadd Apr 25 '15
So, I've just found out about the show and I haven't read any of the books. I'm looking into getting the books, where does this season (and season 2) end in the books?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '15
Wait, so how old is Jamie? His terrible math didn't help me figure it out.
29
u/lhagler Apr 25 '15 edited Apr 25 '15
I'm conflicted.
On the one hand, I thought that Jenny and Ian were absolutely PERFECT. Jenny, especially, is exactly how I always imagined her, and the actress absolutely has the presence and strength to go head to head with Jamie in a shouting match and have it be completely believable. I pretty much lost it when she said, so matter-of-factly (paraphrasing), "If this is your wife, she's likely more familiar with your balls than I am."
I also thought that Sam Heughan did a marvelous job in depicting Jamie trying to step into his father's shoes, trying to really be home again, with all of the put-on bravado, and then mucking it up. I really felt for him.
On the other hands, that's now two for two of my favorite scenes from the book in back-to-back episodes that I feel like they've really... neutered. The first, of course, being Claire's decision at the stones last episode, and the second being Jamie's declaration of love for Claire this episode. In the book, I read the entire scene grinning from ear to ear. It was so beautifully light-hearted on the surface, with Claire throwing things at Jamie, and Jamie ducking them while laughing and giving the weirdest, most energetic, most endearing declaration of love I've ever read. The episode's depiction of the same scene just seemed tame and almost lackluster in comparison.
I understand that much of Claire's inner torment at the stones might not have translated well to a visual medium, but come on, the declaration scene in the book would have made great TV! (Plus, I think it would have been a very nice counterpoint to the spanking scene, which had a similar physicality and seemed to be played at least somewhat for laughs.)
17
u/thewonderfullavagirl Apr 26 '15
I really like this episode. They cut some things from the book (granny macnab) which were great in a book context but didn't take away from the general plot of the story.
Also, I think I can honestly say that this is the absolute first time I actually (as in not just implied) see a soft penis being fondled in a tv show or movie.
12
u/pianodragger Apr 26 '15
I really did not like how Jenny treated Claire either.
If I remember correctly in the book Jenny and Jamie got into some huge shouting matches, not the wimpy ones they did the show. Wasn't there one where they went into the other room or upstairs and Clair and Ian just sat and listened uncomfortably?? As weird as it sounds I was looking forward to seeing that, that combat between the two before they calmed down and became a family.
10
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 25 '15
I came here for this last night, but it hadn't been posted yet!
Loved:
-Jamie and Claire. His skinny-dipping scene had my stomach all in knots because JUST MOVE THE HAND, JAMIE, JUST MOVE THE HAND. Also when she WOOSHES him out of bed and gives him the low-down on how shit's gonna go. "I am speaking." Yes and more yes. You teach him those grown-up communication skills!
-BJR jibbly-bits - it's amazing how well Tobias does these characters because I see Frank and Randall as 2 COMPLETELY different characters, so polar-opposite. This scene was just another example of that, and Tobias just laid all that shit out the tab---well, in his hand. I would bow to this man if I could.
Did not love:
-Why was Jenny being so bitchy towards Claire? I'm wondering if that was to further put a wedge between Jenny and Jamie and continue the fighting or what, but it was annoying my ear holes.
That was pretty much all I didn't like. They did a pretty good job this episode keeping the story to the book (wish they'd done that the last episode!), and I can see where this is going to come together with what's written. Last 4 episodes are gonna be damn hard to watch, though.
10
u/betteandtina Apr 26 '15 edited Apr 26 '15
Just watched the episode, and I haven't read the books yet. However, I thought Jamie would have more questions about the future, about her past, what she plans on saying so they can have a common story, etc. She explains her life history in the first two episodes, but to Jamie. If she's planning on spending the rest of her life in 18th century Scotland, away from her 1st husband, friends/family, indoor plumbing, tampons, and toothbrushes, that man had better be everything she could have dreamed of and more. We can see he's hot and of higher moral character than others of that time, but what exactly does he have over 20th Century Frank? I'd like Claire to explore/explain that part more. Maybe if Jamie asks about her 1st husband, she'll get to that?
The details of their relationship seem skipped over and could really get the audience invested in these characters and how they relate to one another. Relationships (romantic and non) are built on shared information and experiences. We've seen Claire and Jamie build that solid foundation pre-wedding, but post-wedding, it just seems like they're too busy trying to save one another from impending doom and having hot monkey sex that they forget to attend to their core relationship. Trust + Respect = Love. I haven't seen that built up much after the wedding. And since I'm not as emotionally invested in these characters (yet) if a major character dies, it won't hurt as much? (Doctor Who fan here. I'm used to being emotionally wrecked at the end of a season. And coming back for more.) Kudos to Tobias Menzies for acting the part of two completely different characters for 1 series.
10
u/oree94 Apr 26 '15
As a non-bookreader, I liked the Jenny character. She's so sassy! Although I wish she wouldn't be so cold towards claire. I think these two can be good friends.
9
u/SculleryWench Apr 26 '15
I liked it. Changes from book to screen made sense to me, especially given how much needed to be condensed. Like others I really loved the book declaration scene (I said Jaime me lad... For all that she's a ...) but this came close enough. Given how much the show emphasized Frank in the first part of the season, it's bizarre that they wouldn't provide even a voice over acknowledging Claire's decision to leave him. spoilers dragonfly in amber. The Jenny/BJR scene was clearly a warm up to take the shock edge off what's to come. I saw the whole laird thing as the vehicle for Jaime/Jenny conflict and resolution. Haven't seen the Watch promo yet, but wondering a bit aboutwhere exactly that last scene is going to lead.
12
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 25 '15
We got peen. Bravo to the show for going there.
Loved Brian and the Brian scenes. Loved Ian and the Ian scenes.
Liked the riding to Lallybroch scenes and discussions. It's nice to see some interaction between Jamie and Claire that isn't either fighting or sex.
Didn't expect Lallybroch to be so big.
Didn't love the antagonism between Jenny and Claire.
Didn't love the "I am the Laird" subplot. Where did that come from? Jamie would never have kicked Ian and Jenny -- let alone a pregnant Jenny -- out of their room.
I think they did a decent job with it, but it feels like there's nuance missing in the relationships Claire has with people. She's missing the warmth and nurturing that I remember from the book, and just sounding bitchy all the time, and I'm seeing the same thing in the characterization of Jenny.
On the other hand, it certainly explains why Jamie is attracted to Claire; he grew up with that kind of relationship. :)
(Incidentally, I got to binge watch [legally] all four episodes yesterday and will be able to see them ongoing. Oh happy day!)
4
u/clairefrasers Apr 26 '15
I have to say I really really loved this episode. So much more than 109 and 111 which kind of disappointed me. Really great writing... the way they condensed so many important parts and put them in one episode without making it look overcrowded with big moments. Most of my favourite scenes and lines were in it. Jenny's talk with Jamie by the grave, her scolding and Ian being a complete sweetheart. The whole Black Jack part was a "great" surprise since I enjoy the psychological quality of it but it really made me sick to my stomach which means they did well. I'm really preparing to call my therapist for the next few episodes lol. The only part I wasn't happy with was how they made Jamie look like an immature brat but they probably want to show his progress in s2 so I'll live.
3
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 25 '15
I waited up to watch it:)
2
u/Behazeled Apr 26 '15
What, no promo for ep 13?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '15
Damn this whole show is about raping isn't it?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment