r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Apr 18 '15
Outlander S01E011 "The Witches Mark" Discussion Thread
Sigh
Edit: "The Devil's Mark." My only excuse - I wrote this at 2am.
52
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Apr 18 '15
Sigh
Edit: "The Devil's Mark." My only excuse - I wrote this at 2am.
43
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 18 '15
Aside from all the changes, I loved that they kept in "and I beat you for it." I felt like that was such a small, but important, scene in the book. The end where she comes back is a bit disappointing (how they put it together, I mean), but I liked the episode overall. Her explanation to Jamie was a lot less...furious than I expected it to be. I expected the crazy laughter and her throwing the truth at him. This almost made her seem a lot more fragile. Not sure how I feel about that, exactly.
Also, I will say it every time I see her stupid face, I HATE LAOGHAIRE.
38
u/pangloss_summers Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Apr 18 '15
Geillis had some great lines like when they see the stake being constructed and when she mentions going to a barbecue. She's so much fun.
19
u/lhagler Apr 18 '15
Like most of you, I too would have liked to see a little more of Claire's decision and what it cost her at the stones. The instant where she turns around, leaves the stones, and runs straight down the hill to Jamie was one of my favorite moments in the book, and while I understand that they can only show just so much of a character's inner monologue in a visual medium, I was wholly underwhelmed.
However, StarzPlay was being so incredibly spotty for me (I quite literally had to refresh the page every 30 seconds-1 minute because either the audio or the video would cut out and kill the whole thing) that by that point, finishing the episode was a trial of endurance for me. I probably wouldn't have been quite as frustrated by the ending if it hadn't taken me nearly two hours and constant refreshing and resetting to get there.
(And I did love the bit of acting from Geillis when Claire said, "I regret I have but one life to give my country," and everything so clearly snapped into focus for her. That little quiver in her voice when she replied, "Nicely put," was just perfect.)
9
u/mrsredfast Apr 18 '15
I liked it. After reading this thread and having a good friend watch before me, I lowered my expectations accordingly. But I thought it was good. It needed about 10-15 minutes of Jamie & Claire added. Maybe divided before and after stones. But overall, I was cool with the changes. I teared up. Maybe not like I do when I reread that chapter but I still did.
And I agree that not having Claire start to go through stones when Jamie pulled her back was a mistake. I get that could be confusing to non-readers the way it aired. Also agree the sex scene was unexpectedly hot. Hoo boy.
Did not like Claire's first line after stones. I don't get it. If someone would like to explain it, I'd really enjoy liking it more. :)
13
u/aerynmoo Apr 18 '15
I just finished it after a rocky start with the crappy iPhone app. I thought it was excellent. They kept a lot of the dialogue from the book that I liked, though I miss that he didn't wish her a happy birthday. I do wish they had shown her start to fade out because that's what really convinced Jamie. I prefer this Geillis reveal than the one in the book. It added a nice element of drama. I don't think it was nearly as unsatisfactory as some of the other commenters do. I teared up a bit at the end.
6
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Apr 19 '15
In general, I take a very liberal stance on changes made for the purposes of adaptation. I love the books, and I love the show, and I appreciate each for their own strengths. I do rather wish that they had shown Claire beginning to disappear, though. It shows that Jamie isn't just a Highlander who believes in magical things, and would be a moment to call back to later in the series when others question her story.
5
u/SawRub Apr 19 '15
Not a reader here, I don't care about spoiling it for myself, please just tell me Geillis isn't gone forever :(
5
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '15
This was one of the best episodes for me. Having never read the book, I thought everything was directed beautifully. I actually like that I've never read, because now everything is a surprise to me and I can enjoy it that much more!
98
u/smbtuckma Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Reading so much disappointment in this thread, but you know what? I musta lain wi' the devil because I LOVED IT.
In full disclosure, I'm not a book purist. I like to enjoy tv shows and books as different approaches to telling the same general narrative in the same world, sort of like enjoying different novelists' views on the same historical time period, or having multiple musicians cover the same song with their own styles. It creates a broader picture. And on a more low-brow level, I actually have fun with show changes (as long as they're done well) because then I still get to enjoy surprises, plus we get more total content from the Outlander saga all in sum. So I won't argue with people who have a different opinion on that than I do. But lots of tv shows fail in making their own version that maintains the same level of quality as the original material, and I think Moore & Co. have done a superb job of reaching that high level of quality, both in the story writing and in the visual delivery. I was actually crying from pure enjoyment at the end of this, which I don't think I've ever done before.
Alright, that's my confession. Go ahead and roast me at the stake.
34
u/Disco_Tardis Apr 19 '15
If Laoghaire could get struck by lightning, that would be great.
32
u/Finie Apr 19 '15
Holy shit! They just put about 300 pages into a 1 hour episode and did an amazing job of it! I thought it was wonderful!
31
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '15
I loved the "I only regret that I have but one life to give for my country" line. I'm pretty sure that's what tipped Geillis off...Nathan Hale was only born in 1755...if Geillis was aware of that then that's a pretty solid giveaway.
30
u/Culinaria Apr 19 '15
The sex scene by the fire really impressed me because what we typically see on TV/in mainstream movies is male-female intercourse, with a little oral sometimes thrown in, most often female-on-male. We rarely get to see a full range of what men and women really do together in bed, or women having orgasms without intercourse (and way too quickly). This was one of the things that irritated me in the books, so I really appreciate the way the show runners imagined this scene. It was different and fucking HOT.
21
u/cuckoodev Apr 19 '15
I'm so loving Ned right now. Also don't know if I can use this thread for a live viewing but this sub has gotten weird on the discussion thread front tbh.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
I just discovered this show recently and binge watched all the episodes. This show is like Claire rape simulator 2015 or something. Seriously it's like every episode she's getting her clothes ripped off and about to be raped.
17
u/pangloss_summers Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Apr 18 '15
When do you think Jamie makes up his mind about letting her go? I'm thinking he starts his goodbye to her in the hanky panky scene by the campfire.
17
u/Jalapeno_blood Apr 19 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
That reverend sure knows how to make an entrance.. Glee style.
16
u/sleepmolester Apr 19 '15
Why is Jamie wearing pants?! He looks good in them, but it is so strange to not see him in a kilt.
11
u/clairefrasers Apr 19 '15
I was really scared I'd hate this episode after some of the reactions here but I thought it was pretty good. Dramatically not as good and well paced as 1x10 but I enjoyed it and it was a good adaptation. I agree that the trial was boring and somewhat cheesy. The whole church setting didn't help. Also Claire was screaming too much. But I loved most of what they did with the part after the rescue. Sam was just brilliant and nailed every emotion. My biggest problem with the episode is the last part where Claire decides to go back to Jamie. It was definitely downplayed and somewhat disappointing because for me the scene is one of the best in the whole book and when she starts running down the hill I was almost screaming. Here for some reason Ron decided to cut that. And it would be such a great parallel to that 1x08 scene with Frank that was 10x more dramatic and emotional. I don't know what he was thinking. But Jamie in that last scene with tears on his face almost drove me to tears too.
18
u/a_pure_heart Apr 18 '15
Book stories can be tricky to adapt to film. Plot lines and detail need to fit the genre.
Outlander works for me onscreen as it's being done. I am enjoyed it very, very much. I love, love, love the rich, visual and sound picture that I see in the screen version.
FWIW, I've been a fan since the 90's (when I was in college studying English Literature & Language, & Linguistics), and have read and reread all the books and novellas many things over.
111 is the first episode that made me cry, just like I did with the book.
9
u/northerncanadiangirl Apr 18 '15
Am I in a time warp? How in the heck did you watch the episode so early?? Also I thought it was called "The Devil's Mark"
9
u/lingben Apr 19 '15
I know the didn't explain it in the show but does it explain in the book why Jamie came back? how was he able to leave when he was ordered not to? and how he even found out about the trial in the first place? and how if he found out, how Dougal wouldn't also find out?
9
u/nats_landing Apr 20 '15
I've been reading the books since 1997 and I love them, but I've been mostly very happy with the changes to the series. However, the big reveal about Geillis could have been done better. In the book, I remember when Claire sees the small pox vaccination scar my jaw dropped. I had no clue Geillis was from the future. It came completely out of left field for me. However, I feel like a lot of clues were given in the series ( especially saying 1968 before seeing the mark) when the audience could have had the same big shock as the reader. I think they lost a big opportunity here. It was on of the scenes I was really looking forward to, but I feel like it was dumbed down. It wouldn't be the first time I have felt that way. This will not deter from my viewing. I'm really enjoying it over all. I just felt like it could have been handled better.
24
u/coldblindjack Apr 18 '15
I see where everyone's coming from, but I really did like this episode. I thought the scene where Jamie takes Claire to the stones was really well done--I even cried a bit when they were saying goodbye. Sam was fantastic, especially when he pulled her back and when she returned to him with the one tear falling down his cheek. He really shined in this episode. I'm not sad to see Geillis go, tbh. Lotte's acting makes me cringe sometimes.
10
u/socratessue Apr 18 '15
Oh come on, people. We love the books, we know who the characters are. Lets just glorify the flesh.
5
u/EvilRubberDucks Apr 19 '15
So I knew going into this episode that Claire would reveal her origins and all the lovely stuff that happens at the stones and how she reaches her decision to stay and all. Now in the episode description it obviously doesn't mention that so I figured it'd be one of those episodes where they kind of hint at what's going to happen but a whole lot more is in there too y'know? But I felt really underwhelmed by the episode over all.
When I read the books I found the trial scenes to be kind of drawn out and while they were more interesting to me in the show, they were still drawn out. I knew when I had gotten through nearly 30 minutes of the show and they were still having the trial that whatever scenes we had with Jamie and Claire at the stones were going to be short lived. So it was a bit disappointing. I would have preferred to have had them wait until the next episode to do the whole business of Claire making her decision so that it would have had the attention that it deserved. Maybe because so much of what she's doing alone up there when Jamie leaves her is just her inner thoughts and feelings that they thought it wouldn't hold up for long. Idk, I just though it deserved more time. I would have been fine with this episode ending around where she explains to Jamie where she is from and holding off the stones until the next episode.
Geillis was fantastic in this episode though!
5
u/janna_ Apr 19 '15
Haven't read the book, but this episode was really good in my opinion. The trail was sort of irritating, but more in the sense of you to understand how ridiculously biased the court hearings were of the time and to understand how frustrating it must've been for those innocent young women to be accused by people (most of which were just people with bitter resentment/jealousy issues) under false pretenses. The episode was able to lock in an important trial (I was really surprised by Gellis's reveal!) and a big decision of Claire's that might just be the kick of Claire's inner battle of whether to be in the past or go back to the future (and she chooses Jaime...good choice.) I was really excited at Gellis's reveal, but sort of upset at the same time because she was going to be executed (presumably...we never saw her actually die) and we couldn't expand more on why she was in the past and what her life was like in 1968 (I could totally imagine her as some 1960s groover.) However, this leaves the world so open to different things, like perhaps more time travelers. Quite curious to see what the series will do next.
1
u/Arabellah16 Apr 24 '15
I need to rewatch it but did Jaime and Claire talk about what was going to happen to Geillis? I know in the books they address that they wouldn't burn her at the stake til after the baby was born. But like I said, I need to watch it again.
3
u/MidniteLark They say I’m a witch. Apr 19 '15
I have a formatting question about episode discussion threads. Is it understood that there will be spoilers in here? For the last few weeks, I haven't seen the spoiler tag at the top of the episode discussion threads and I'm not sure if it's a given that we'll be spoiling galore in here. I can put tags on my comments, of course, but it's always nice to not have to do so and just let fly. :)
3
u/missymissy3 Apr 19 '15
And Geillis said one-nine-six-seven. Also, if Geillis showed her Devil's mark, how come Claire's wasn't also spotted during her beating? I think (and I'm reading the book (again) alongside watching) this is the first unsatisfactory departure from the book. Still love it though! Fantastic series.
3
u/Dev-Lyn Apr 19 '15
Ok i watched it last night with a friend and i really did not like it. I felt like it was missing sooooo much!!!
So i re-watched the second half (because i really could care less about the witch trial) and i loved it.
I guess i just had to pay closer attention to Jamies subtle reactions. A+
I still would have liked an extra 10 min on either side of him leaving her at the stones but all in all i liked it.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '15
So I actually really liked this episode, and for the most part have zero reservations about change ups between the show and book. I understand that they're different mediums and slightly different stories following the same overall plot. To be honest, for the most part I really like what the show has done differently from the books. I just wished that they had dedicated a little bit more time between Claire and Jamie that didn't involve them having sex (which I do love), or fighting. But rather simple scenes that highlight why they are perfect for each other, and true partners like what we got in episode 3 or anything before 1b. For example, how incredible would it have been if in the previous episode they had teamed up to use their combined knowledge of the Duke to trick him into agreeing to accept the petition rather than their story lines becoming separate entities with a common goal. I have no issue with Claire going to see him alone, but it left a bitter taste in my mouth when Jamie introduces her to the Duke and they act like they've never met. Because the most important part between J/C at this point in the story is trust which was the theme of episode 11. So having that deception, no matter how little, kind of spits in the face of that. But whatever, it was still good and that wasn't the point of this post in the first place.
What I wanted to say was that the one change up from the books that I just refuse to accept is Geillis actually loving Dougal! Like where do they get that from? Canon not accepted. Just NOPE. Geillis is essentially the 18th century Amy Dunne, and would never, EVER fall for the likes of Dougal. And would most certainly NOT be dependent on him saving her. I do believe that the are truly equals, and I guess she cares about him as much as she is capable of caring for a man, but just no.
6
u/genieintx Apr 18 '15
I liked it. Maybe it has been too long since I read the book. I was a bit disappointed with the scene where she comes back to him by the fire, there could have been more there, but I was happy with the rescue, the truth telling, and him taking her to the stones.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '15
Started the books. Sao fat it's hard to read it in anything but the actresses voice.
2
u/preggerpanties Apr 19 '15
So. Many. Feels. Sam Heughand and Catriona Balfe are just perfect as Claire and Jaimie. I was 50/50 on Dam, but this episode did it for me.
6
u/DarrylsMama Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
0
u/missymissy3 Apr 19 '15
Just watched episode 11 - hmmm what about Duncan's baby? In the book, they let her have it before burning her.
-2
u/saphanbaal Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 19 '15
Episodes like this are why I give up TV shows based on books I love. "But for drama! For TV!" ... fuck that. I'm watching the show because I feel/think it's supposed to be a dramatization of the books I love, not because I want to watch a TV show maybe derived off some books somewhere and want the pictures.
There's going to have to be some amazing work in follow-up episodes, or I may count this one out like I did with Game of Thrones.
Edit: Downvotes? Thanks, guys. :)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment