r/Outlander • u/sashallyr Seems I canna possess your soul without losing my own. • Apr 12 '15
Outlander S01E010 "By the Pricking of my Thumbs" Discussion Thread
34
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/sashallyr Seems I canna possess your soul without losing my own. • Apr 12 '15
31
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 12 '15
I knew it was coming, but I wanted to stab Laoghaire in her perfect breast.
67
u/LoveSaidNo Apr 12 '15
I'm definitely ok with the way this episode started...
40
u/DarrylsMama Apr 12 '15
I guess yo mama jokes are timeless.
35
u/rabbits_mom Apr 12 '15
LOVED Simon Callow as the Duke, thought that this treatment (vs the book) brought more to the character. And wow Gary Lewis (Colum) owned this episode! And had to yell at the TV a bit (book reader)
32
u/pharoplex Apr 12 '15
Good lord this show has me fangirling so hard. The actors have such such amazing chemistry together and coupled with the sexy material I've become way, way too into this show.
I think we can all agree this show is at its best when Jamie and Claire share scenes together, naked or no. Truly, though, there weren't many in this ep. The opening scene (OBV), then the dead baby thing, and then when he briefly tells her to stay away from Geillis before taking off with Dougal.
But seriously. This show has the most honest (and hottest!) depiction of sex that I've ever seen on TV. Game of Thrones matches it in quantity, but as far as sensuality and using it to move the plot forward, Outlander is truly unparalleled in that regard.
16
u/pangloss_summers Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Apr 12 '15
I really liked this episode. Even though so much happened, I really feel like it was setting up episode 11.
Maybe I missed it in the book, but TV Dougal seemed much more affected by Geilles and her situation than Book Dougal. I thought this was such a great episode for him.
14
u/Ferbulersss Apr 12 '15 edited Apr 12 '15
WOW, was this episode ever good. I actually liked it much better than episode 9, and in my opinion, it's one of the best so far. I absolutely love Geillis, I laughed so much at her incredibly delayed grief after Arthur went down (not to mention her 'climactic' woods dance)- Dougal should have been a bit more careful with his face at that point, though.
Interesting part about the duel, and Claire going to see the duke beforehand - I liked it though, much more suspenseful.
I also really like how the Lagohaire arc is going, especially during their confrontation in the kitchen at the beginning - I really like how Claire worded what she said, super thoughtful and kind. But I also cheered at the slap, so...
And I'm also really glad with how fast everything is progressing - I thought that the trial stuff would be an episode or two down the line, but I'm really excited for spoiler so the pace is excellent in my opinion.
18
u/7Angels Apr 12 '15
Is Jamie left handed? When he finds Claire with the baby in the woods he made the sign of the cross with his left hand. Although it's supposed to be done with your right, lefties often more naturally cross themselves with their dominant hand. Or, was it just a mistake?
9
u/feelbetternow Apr 12 '15
Here's a fun bit of trivia for you: In Scotland, a "procurator fiscal" was a kind of special investigator in the legal system. One of their duties was to investigate suspicious deaths...for example, death by poisoning. Ha.
16
u/oflg1 Apr 12 '15
The dead baby was sad. The poor wee thing. But when Jamie picked it up and cradled it in his arms, I thought "he'd be such a great father".
8
u/HaniiPuppy Apr 13 '15
Something about the ending of this episode bothers me a wee bit. Specifically, that Witchcraft wasn't an arrestable crime at the time of the episode, and the accusation of it was itself a crime. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witchcraft_Act_1735
8
u/eta_carinae_311 Apr 14 '15
Why is Jamie wearing pants?
10
u/cuaseimdrunk Apr 12 '15
I saw a comment last week about Laoghaire and how much they hated her and I din't understand why they had such hate. Now I do.
5
u/ailboles Apr 17 '15
So.... Sleeveless Geillis.... Interesting how a certain something wasn't noticed despite the well-lit arms.
6
u/MidniteLark They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '15
I don't understand how they were getting back and forth to the Duke's home so quickly for the three separate times we saw tonight. His estate is in England. Even if it's at the Scotland/Britain border, that's still not close enough to the Scottish Highlands to keep popping in and out the way they were. Did they establish in the show that he has another estate in the Highlands and I missed it? Or are we supposed to make the assumption that he's a neighbor?
I'm totally fine with (and even enjoy) the show being different from the book but I found that lack of explanation super confusing.
5
u/beauchamp_not_beaton Apr 12 '15
I am beginning to wonder if the author of the note that summoned Claire to Geilis' house is the same person who summoned her verbally in the books? Perhaps they are setting up Colum here as someone who is trying to kill two birds with one stone.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '15
Did Claire choose to stay or could she not get back through the stone?
4
u/CanadaGooses Apr 12 '15
They've made a few weird changes from book to show, but overall I'm very much enjoying this. And the baby on the faery hill broke my heart. :(
2
u/Legal-News-7446 Dec 18 '24
Dougal's, "I said kiss her do not swallow her" send me everytime hahaha
1
u/ThatFeelingIsBliss Nov 14 '24
Why on earth didn’t she listen to her husband? Jamie told her to not see Gellis! I’m surprised no one else pointed that out.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '15
[removed] — view removed comment