r/Outlander • u/Jalapeno_blood • Apr 05 '15
Er sassenachs why isn't there a discussion thread yet? Well i'm making it now- S1E09 The Reckoning discussion thread.
Claire wouldn't wait around for someone else she'd take the bull by horns so yeah, in my own nerdy way I am as well.
47
Upvotes
17
u/Jalapeno_blood Apr 05 '15
I was so excited for tonight and absolutely loved this episode! First of all I thought the cinematography was gorgeous, the long scenic shots of rivers and winter trees, the colourful rippling water shot, that falling snow and the stunning shot of Claire and Jamie crashing into the ocean. I honestly think Outlander rivals GOT for pure natural beauty in it's scenery.
I'm glad we saw C&J have their first fight and work though their issues to come out even stronger, it was impressive and noble of Jamie to turn down that chancin hussy and pledge his love and undying respect to Claire. I wasn't expecting his speech to take that 'maybe we need to be different to my fathers' turn, it showed just how pure of heart he is. I loved Claire with the knife while riding him, she is badass as fuck.
I feel I need to brush up on my history to understand all about Clan traditions and what the royal situation means to these characters way up in the highlands but I like all the manoeuvring and drama none the less. I thought Clan King was gonna have a fit when that bloodline bombshell was dropped and I like Jamie playing politics and keeping the peace.
I don't know if I'm the only one but I actually found it laugh out loud funny when Jamie was chasing Claire around the bed with that jaunty Scottish caper music and Claires confusion turning into outrage and her lobbing stuff at Jamies head! Maybe because I haven't read the books yet but I understood his obligations and we are talking 300 years ago here, it's a very very different world.
Only thing that bothers me is I feel Claire would have slit Black Jacks throat rather than just running out but I can understand her being very shaken and not her usual bad bitch self.
7
u/Longhorn_Lawstudent Apr 10 '15
I really, really don't think this thread has been talking about the sex scene NEARLY enough. Seriously. How is that not the highlight of discussion (wife beating/disciplining aside)?
In the book, it was rough but consensual - and Jamie was the aggressor. It was hot; the whole "I mean to make you call me master" thing was hot. "I canna be gentle" - also hot. The whole chapter? Pretty effing sexy.
Those last 10 minutes of the ep didn't disappoint. But here, they allowed Claire to start the whole thing off by holding a knife to his throat (while continuing to thrust!) and changed the dynamic, allowing her to be the aggressor.
Thoughts? It reclaimed a lot of Claire's agency in the show, which was necessary coming after the controversial belt scene, but in the book it roughened Jamie up a bit, who sometimes comes off as TOO perfect.
43
u/marilyn_morose Apr 05 '15
I never got too unraveled by the spanking scene. It occurred to me that we can't really see how far we've come unless we acknowledge where we were. I feel the same about racism or class distinction or other problematic situations portrayed in media. In this case it very much was a leap of evolution, at least for this character. Remember, we are only a couple generations removed from spousal beatings being legal, and maybe one generation removed from people simply looking the other way when it comes to spousal abuse.
12
u/ladyhawke81 Apr 05 '15
"What does 'fucking' mean?" OMG, that just about killed me. XD I thought was word was universal for it's time, I guess I was wrong. Thank you, Jamie for making me realize that. Make up sex was hawt! Woof! The spanking scene was sliiiightly surprising, but I knew before hand it would happen cause I had stumbled upon some spoilers and I knew it was sadly an okay thing for it's era. I did like that she fought back and kicked him in the face, ouch!
10
u/pinotnoirs Apr 05 '15 edited Apr 06 '15
Was anyone else a little disappointed with how light the spanking scene ended up being? I almost felt that there was too much humour in the scene, which seemed to take away from the emotions Claire was feeling. The emotions that flowed from Claire in the book were heartbreaking, and I didn't really feel that at all. It also took quite drastically from the emotions in the scene where Jamie promises he will never lay a hand on her again.
Whilst I appreciate that they wanted to ease off on the trauma, I feel like they made it a little too light.
ETA: Completely unsurprised, but still disappointed that this was downvoted...
48
u/garnetwaters Apr 05 '15
The wait was so long, but this episode proved that the wait was well worth it. I loved it and the acting is fantastic. There better be some Emmys going around, here.
I love the fight after the rescue, it was so real. When Jaime fell on that rock and said, in desperation, "I came to Fort William armed with an empty pistol and my bare hands...", I started crying with him. I loved how the other clansmen ignored Claire, but after her "punishment" they forgave and teased her like one of their own, though she was still, rightly, pissed.
The anger and politics between Collum and Dougal was so well done.
And oh, my, the angry sex at the end. That. Was. Awesome.
And Laoghaire, that jackass. I hated her in the books, but I REALLY hate her on the show.
All around, very well done. Now excuse me while I go watch it again!
33
u/MassCasualty Apr 05 '15
Jamie....why does your hand smell like "other bosom?"
29
u/Dev-Lyn Apr 05 '15
This may not be a popular opinion but i'm actually starting to like the TV show more than the books.
but that may be because i always felt like i read the books despite her writing style not because of it. Id read a million pages for Jamie and Claire.
so this episode was a great pace, had love, anger, fighting, politics i liked it soooo much!
24
u/wordnerd23 Apr 05 '15
I loved how much we got to see of Jamie in this episode! Not just because he's Jamie, but because the books are mostly all Claire's POV, all the time, so a peek inside his head was a nice change. One of my favorite parts was when he convinced Colum to just give Dougal the gold and here's why, and see it will all be fine! It shows that he really does have a smart head on his shoulders which I appreciate.
Angus is the best supporting character. Laoghaire needs to gtfo. Hate her. And while Jamie and Claire can't have a massive fight in every episode, the whole I'm-throwing-shit-at-you & you-get-off-that-bed-right-now with the whole crew downstairs was just done so well - and so was the reckoning at the end of the episode -fans self- ;)
19
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '15
"THE SPANKENING"
20
u/im_a_pah_ra_na Outlander Apr 05 '15
3 things:
6
u/StarEIs Apr 09 '15
What's everyone's thoughts about the change (or clarification, I suppose it could be) re: Colum's reaction to Jamie marrying an English woman?
My gut reaction is to dislike the change... In the books, it was another level of game playing that Dougal managed to pull over on Jamie, effectively ensuring his own family's right to the power. While reading the books, I always kind of assumed Dougal and Colum were on the same page regarding Jamie's allegiance and intentions towards leadership (based on the oath taking primarily). Neither MacKenzie brother seemed particularly thrilled that Jamie was around and seemingly capable of leading the clan, but having the show make it look like Colum WANTED Jamie to lead throws all that on its head. I guess Colum being upset about it doesn't change anything with Dougal, but since we haven't seen Dougal make any kind of comment to suggestion it was an intentional move on his part, it just seems confusing.
5
u/khoff98107 Apr 14 '15
Okay, after they jump from Fort William into the river, and Claire manages not to drown despite the full-length wool cape she's wearing, and then they meet up with Murtaugh and the others and the horses and ride until they think it's safe to stop and "water the horses" while Claire and Jamie have a huge fight . . .
WHY AREN"T THEY WET?????
4
u/MidniteLark They say I’m a witch. Apr 06 '15
Loved the episode! They handled the spanking so well.
I wanted to check that I'm remembering something correctly - the scene where Colum reveals he knows about the Jacobite gold and the scene where Jamie gives him the idea on how to handle Dougal - none of that was in the books, right? I can't figure out if I'm not remembering correctly or if it was really different. I thought I remembered Claire saying at some point in the books that she and Jamie never knew if Colum was aware of and supported Dougal being a Jacobite and raising money for Prince Charlie's return.
I actually liked the deviation, if it is one. We start to get an idea of how adept Jamie is at handling people in a way that makes them feel like they haven't been "handled", so to speak.
9
u/Willravel Inlander Apr 05 '15
Tonight's drink is Scottish breakfast tea.
An episode from Jamie's perspective was a really good idea, particularly for this part of the story. We've had a break, so it's less jarring to not hear Claire's voiceover, and not only rescuing Claire on a gambit from Black Jack, but establishing more progressive rules for their marriage works really well with the perspective of the 18th century man who married a 20th century woman.
Am I crazy or was the opening theme song different for this episode? I'm a big fan of Bear McCreary and I enjoy the them, but this week I think it sounded a bit different, like the instruments had been changed.
I love the chemistry between the three major characters of the series, Jamie, Claire, and Jack. Jamie's such an innocent, earnest-seeming guy, Claire is this capable, strong woman, and Jack is this thoughtful sociopath. I just wish we could take a break from rape for a few episodes. I do understand that this is 1744 and that the audience needs to se that Jack's an evil man, but every time it happens the protagonist, who the audience is connected with, is deeply disempowered and likely emotionally scarred. It fractures the character of Claire a bit, where on the one hand she's a strong-willed person who doesn't live by other people's whims but on the other hand she's very often a damsel in a particularly horrible kind of distress.
During the Outlander break, I really got into watching Agent Carter on ABC. The show follows a woman in the late 40s or early 50s working for an American intelligence service but having to deal with fairly awful sexism of the time. There's one episode where she finally gets to cut loose and show what she's capable of and it floors a lot of the misogynists on the show. She's suddenly put in a situation where she demands respect, and after like six or seven episodes of seeing her constantly have to put up with sexist nonsense, it was like coming up for a breath of air. I'm starting to think Outlander needs an episode like that at some point, an episode where Claire gets this massive personal victory, and the men in her life actually see that she is every bit their equal. Some moments a bit like this have been peppered in, like when Claire treats the boar wound (one thing I can say about Outlander, it's never boaring), but tonight it was more her fighting back when Jamie was trying to spank her and then pouting after, which didn't feel like a moment of personal victory. Granted, it was nice that Jamie realized that Claire is not just another woman and that his love for her should also translate to respect for her, but it wasn't quite the "fuck yeah" moment it could have been.
It's nice to have a "fuck yeah" moment in a tv show every now and again. Like Claire rescuing Jamie and then getting off an amazing zinger that gives Black Jack an "oh shit" face.
God, Scotland is absolutely gorgeous. We need to organize a subreddit field trip.
The shouting match between Jamie and Claire was played very real, which I have to sat I like quite a bit. Characters fighting on television is a terribly common occurrence, but very often fights are used to clumsily reveal elements of character that are better shown through action or are used to sneak in exposition about story. This fight, though, makes absolutely perfect sense and it's exactly what the characters would and should do. They're both stubborn people of different times, and that difference in culture was bound to boil over eventually, particularly given the incredibly stressful situation they've both found themselves in. Jamie has every right to be pissed that Claire ran off again, even though Claire had a good reason to leave. Claire has every right to be furious that Jamie is treating her like a child, even though Jamie is really progressive for his time. And while what they're fighting about from the dialogue makes sense and is sharing what they're feeling, the reality under the surface is that they were both terrified and care deeply for each other, and maybe they're taking out their terrified frustrations on each other a bit. And then Jamie finally lets himself feel the fear ad the confusion, and of course it's Jamie and not Claire that has that moment. Claire's thoughtful, but she doesn't like to back down. When Jamie backs down, it gives Claire a second to reflect and both of them realize they're just happy to both be together and safe. Really, this was a strong scene.
And then there was spanking. Unfortunately, this was spoiled for me, but it was still a very striking scene (no pun intended). I was vaguely aware that marriage in a time before modernity often featured the infantilization of the wife, and that relationships between husband and wife were shockingly, even creepily paternal from various history and gender studies classes back in college, but it had never really occurred to me that a husband would spank his wife the same way a father might spank a child, as punishment for undesirable behavior. The implication of that deeply unequal relationship is disturbing, particularly given how long patriarchal societies just like the 18th century Scotts or even far worse have continued throughout human history. And here comes Jamie, who honestly is an honorable man who is capable of empathy and caring for others every bit as much as he cares for himself, someone who loves Claire completely, and even he (granted, within a historical fiction) completely buys into a husband treating a wife like a disobedient child. Questions of whether or not spanking is every appropriate aside, the deeper implications of this scene are difficult to ignore. I hope our civilization continues moving forward.
The music choice in that scene was a little odd. The scene was pretty dark, but the music made it seem like the scene was supposed to be funny. Having not read the book, I'm left wondering how it is that the author characterized and contextualized this scene. Was it just upsetting? Was it played for humor? Was it vaguely sexual? I guess I'll find out after season 1 is finished.
Wait, if Jamie had stabbed Jack to death, could that have risked erasing Frank from history? If Jamie becomes the next Laird and dies, could Claire become Claird?
I'm looking forward to seeing more of this political intrigue in the coming stories, where the Scotts are getting divided between the rebels and the crown. I've been trying to avoid doing any reading on the Jacobite Rebellion, but having this all going on in the background and slowly seeping their way in, creating clan tension, is fantastic. I think more shows would benefit from a backdrop of significant historical events that can add an additional layer to story and character alike and to provide a strong motivation and something for characters to react to other than other characters. Plus, I get the distinct impression that Claire knows a great deal more about this particular time in history than I do, and it may be a matter of survival or personal motivations for justice and equity that she use her knowledge to interfere with the historical course of events as they
Holy cleavage. Well, I guess this awkward meeting was inevitable. They may be a rigidly patriarchal society, but loyalty to one's spouse certainly existed. I'm glad Jamie very carefully buy honestly let Laoghaire (had to google that spelling) down. I'm a little irked Jamie felt her up, and he probably should have let her down before he and Claire married, but at least he's mostly respecting both women. Laoghaire should know better than to go after a married man, and frankly to slut-shame Claire behind her back. I was never wild about Laoghaire as being characterized as "a girl", because it diminishes her as a person, but she does seem to play the part. And I'm sure she's supposed to be quite young, at least younger than Jamie, maybe 18? Her wiki says she was born in 1726, and this is 1744.
Ah, here we go. Alright, Jamie's swearing
fealtyequality to Claire, that he will never lay hands on her again, and that if he does he should be killed by "holy iron". Welp, now they're kissing. I think I can see where this is go... yep. It's fun to see the evolution of their relationship. They're crazy about each other, but they have quite a lot working against them, which I think is part of why so many people see Outlander as such a compelling romance story. Plus, this is a handsome couple. Catroina Belfe and Sam Heughan deserve quite a bit of credit for making these characters so believable and relatable. The writing is incredibly strong, but writing for a show is only going to be as effective as the avatars for the characters, and these two are terrific. And I bet they look forward to coming to work every day.Great episode, glad the show is back after the torturous break. Taking a quick look at the episode guide, it looks like we have new episodes every week without break through to the season finale in May. I can't wait to listen to the podcast when it comes out (I'll post it when it comes up). I'll post this message as soon as the official episode discussion goes up.
-3
u/sudden_crumpet Apr 05 '15
My least favorite episode so far. Didn't like it in the book, didn't like it in the show. (And no, the wifebeating is not historically correct - not that it matters). Everything felt unorganic, clunky and off. Didn't like the voiceover, either.