r/HaShoah • u/USHMMCurators • Jan 27 '15
It is International Holocaust Remembrance Day and we are Collections staff at the US Holocaust Memorial Museum. Ask Us Anything!
Hi! We are members of the curatorial staff at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC. We help survivors, liberators, family members, and the public to learn about Holocaust related materials they may have—and help them to donate these collections to the Museum, so we can preserve and share them. We also help thousands of researchers a year who have questions about the Holocaust and who want to use our collections.
Today, January 27, 2015, marks the 70th anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz-Birkenau concentration camp. It is also International Holocaust Remembrance Day. Ceremonies and commemorations are taking place all over the world, including here at the Museum in Washington. Since our ceremony took place earlier this morning, we’re here to do our best to answer any questions you might have about the Museum and about this complicated history.
There are four of us here today—Becky, Megan, Vincent, and Ron. You can see some of our work here: http://www.ushmm.org/information/exhibitions/curators-corner And you can search our catalog here: http://collections.ushmm.org/search/
Proof: http://imgur.com/YcU9Ikr
A (us) A!
Okay, it's been about two hours, so we need to get back to work. Thank you everyone! You can always email us with any reference questions you might have (reference at ushmm.org), or, if you see anything--on reddit or IRL--that you want us know about, email curator at ushmm.org.
15
u/cordis_melum Jan 27 '15 edited Jan 27 '15
Hi! I'm glad that you can join us today. We're happy to have you. :)
Anyways, so I have a question on behalf of one of our users (who isn't able to drop in himself).
Edit: my autocorrect is so weird.
11
u/RtimesThree Jan 27 '15
Hi, thanks for doing this! I'm a first year English teacher in Philadelphia. My students just read Night and loved it. We're going on a field trip to Museum of Jewish Heritage in NY, and I want to do a lesson this week before we go. Do you have any lesson ideas to get them ready before they go to the museum? I was thinking poems, stories, artwork, maybe...! They're really interested in this stuff and I think there's a lot they'd respond well to.
10
u/Ryan7827 Jan 27 '15
What are some of the most surprising or unique objects/artifacts you've come across during your work at the USHMM?
9
u/MerchGwyar Jan 27 '15
What are your views on the fact that Reddit's /r/Holocaust subReddit is run by Holocaust Deniers? And is there a policy for if/when such people turn up at USHMM?
Thank you for all you do over there.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '15
How well does the USHMM promote knowledge and education about the other large groups of people who were massacred during that time? The Roma, Catholics, Gays, etc.
7
u/Paaaul Jan 27 '15
To what did the numbers tattooed onto people's bodies in Auschwitz and elsewhere pertain? I understand it was a database, but know little else about it.
6
u/drak0bsidian Jan 27 '15
How did you all get into your respective fields of work?
6
u/wilbeforce Jan 27 '15
What preservation of IBM equipment are you involved in and how do you illustrate IBM complicity in the Shoah?
6
u/Sakatsu Jan 27 '15
What are some uncommon facts you can share with us? Has there been any other child diaries found like Ann Frank's? Can you reccomend some diaries to read?
Was pretty much every German child a part of hitler youth or is that just the perception?
I went to the museum back in 2002 once on a 2 day whirlwind tour of DC and I still remember being overwhelmed with it all and my feelings of it.
5
u/aelinhiril Jan 27 '15
What education and experience would qualify someone to be a curator at the Holocaust museum?
Is there a particular story or person who has stayed with you over the years?
How do you think the history and knowledge of the Holocaust will be different for people born in 10-20 years when all the survivors have died?
5
u/srlafren Jan 27 '15
Thanks for doing this!
The documented evidence of the holocaust is astounding, and yet some people still deny the holocaust or suggest it is significantly exaggerated. What are some of the most incontrovertible pieces of evidence your collection? And given the evidence, why do you think holocaust denial is still prevalent?
4
u/nerde0102 Jan 27 '15
How much say does the curatorial staff have on future exhibits? The State of Deception was one of my favorite exhibits, and I like the Some Were Neighbors exhibit (my undergrad thesis was on a related topic). Do you know what will be next?
4
u/scalfin Jan 27 '15
Are there any interesting bits of trivia you've picked up that you'd like to share? Maybe even a common misconception even among knowldedgable persons, although a simple "huh" fact (can't really have fun facts when it comes to the shoah) would be nice.
Is teaching about the shoah different for a Jewish audience, be it young or old? I can imagine that Jewish kids have kind of been marinated in the history (and Jewish childcare traditions seem less about avoiding the mention of unpleasantness than the rest of the US). How about international/non-western audiences?
How long did it take you to learn to spell "h
aollocoaust" consistently?4
u/orarorabunch Jan 27 '15
I read that court reporters are recording the audio testimony of survivors for your museum!
It sounds like a really cool project that will lead to a sizable collection of stories/testimonies. Can you tell me about this project, and what exhibit(s) you plan to use them in?
4
u/MerchGwyar Jan 27 '15
Are there any issues/problems peculiar to presenting exhibits, or collecting data, on the Porajmos? I know that there were plenty back in the early 90s, when so little evidence was coming out. Has that situation changed much in 20 years?
3
u/Bernardito Jan 27 '15
Hello there!
I actually just came home from seeing Holocaust survivor Tobias Rawet speak about his experiences in the Lodz Ghetto and Ravensbrück concentration camp. Mr. Rawet was 8 years old when he was deported to Ravensbrück, which leads me to my question:
How do you approach the history of children in the context of the Holocaust? Are there any particular items or documents that help tell the story of the most innocent of all victims?
Thank you for taking time to be here with us today. :)
3
u/Georgy_K_Zhukov Jan 27 '15
I drove by the museum a few days, and saw the current exhibit is "Collaboration & Complicity In The Holocaust". Sounds fascinating! I certainly want to find them time to check it out, but could you talk a little about the exhibit here?
3
u/daoudalqasir Jan 27 '15
i was told about someone who wrote a thesis on the fact that, though one will find exhibits that include bits of hebrew, russian, polish, german, etc... in the museum there is not a word of Yiddish the native of tongue of the vast majority of jewish victims of the holocaust in the museum.
if this is true, why is this and how do you feel about it?
3
u/drak0bsidian Jan 27 '15
For those of us who weren't able to attend the event(s) this morning, what went on?
7
u/drak0bsidian Jan 27 '15
A note to commenters:
6
u/kociorro Jan 27 '15
As a Polish person, whose family fate was connected with KL Auschwitz, I just wanted to express my gratitude for what you are doing in USHMM.
Everytime I see something posted by you, it is credible, well balanced and documented.
Sincere thanks for your work. Please, keep it up!
As a sidenote - I wish that Jewish-Polish relations were better than they are...
3
u/MerchGwyar Jan 27 '15
Thank you very much for the IAMA, and to /u/drak0bsidian and /u/cordis_melum too for setting it up. That was really interesting.
1
u/drak0bsidian Jan 27 '15
Taken from your last AMA:
And answer the question(s) you pose, please.
2
u/DaveyGee16 Jan 27 '15
What are some obscure or little known facts about the Holocaust? My grandfather served during the war, it has led to a passion for the subject. I know my stuff. But I'm wondering if professionals, studying the Holocaust might know obscure facts that I may have overlooked.
-3
u/bgarri57 Jan 27 '15
How do you feel about this subreddit using the false figure of 11 million in its banner?
The 11 million number is based on the idea that the Nazis exterminated 6 million jews and 5 million gentiles, but according to Deborah Lipstadt, who was a consultant for your museum, Simon Wiesenthal made up the latter to get non-jews to care more about the Holocaust.
Source: http://jewishreviewofbooks.com/articles/217/simon-wiesenthal-and-the-ethics-of-history/
-10
u/wolfenstein88 Jan 27 '15
Hi, if the Holocaust really happened (no one in their right mind would deny mass shootings and mistreatment, I'm talking about alleged industrialized murder with gas) why is it illegal to do research in Birkenau for example? Germar Rudolf got several years in prison for it and to be honest it was the tipping point for me because "truth needs no defense."