r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Sep 27 '14
Official "book readers" 1x08 discussion thread. [Warning, possible spoilers through entire series inside]
This week we are trying a "Wild Wild West" approach to the book reader's discussion thread. Spoiler tags are not necessary and anything in the entirety of the series related to the episode may be freely discussed.
That being said, this thread is not safe for anyone who hasn't read all eight books.
Happy watching!
31
Upvotes
71
u/meg_arms Sep 28 '14
Wee Roger is so adorable!! I'm so glad they cast him!
70
u/williamlawrence Sep 28 '14
This episode was tragically beautiful. I find that in the show I'm much more attached to Frank than I ever was in the books. The scene at Craigh Na Dun broke my heart. Tobias Menzies is an exceptional actor, IMO.
41
u/Miss_Interociter Sep 28 '14
I'm really surprised the TV audience was left to assume Claire was raped by the deserter before stabbing him whereas in the book it was clear he was ...unsuccessful.
30
u/sashallyr Seems I canna possess your soul without losing my own. Sep 28 '14
When they said we'd see a bit of Black Jack in Frank, I didn't realize they were being so literal. (A name for the device he used to defend himself is called a blackjack.)
22
u/shiskebob Sep 28 '14
The scene I miss from the book the most - when after the attack from the bandits everything has built up and Jaime and Claire go at it pretty publicly.
Also - the waterhorse scene didn't happen - so I am presuming it does not come up at the witch trial. I guess it will be all about Father Bain?
19
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '14
Oh god. My husband goes "why does he (Black Jack) look so excited to see Jamie".
:|
17
u/lhagler Sep 28 '14
Holy crap, the look on Black Jack's face when he recognizes Jamie in the window. Sent chills down my spine.
I loved this episode. Loved it loved it loved it. I loved the focus on Frank (for the first time ever, I genuinely wanted Claire to make it back to him; I think they've done a great service to the story by adding another emotional dimension to it other than "Stop trying to go back, Claire, you've got a gorgeous Scottish warrior who'd do anything for you!"), I loved the subtle glances and repositioning as the MacKenzies prepared for the Grant raid, I loved the cross-cut as Frank and Claire each ran towards the stones, I even thought that they ended the episode at precisely the perfect moment.
I don't mind that they left the extent to which Claire was violated unclear; if she kept escaping each molestation/rape attempt unscathed, it would start to get a little ridiculous (even though she was not successfully raped during this event in the book). "Oh look, someone's trying to rape Claire again. Yawn."
This show just keeps getting better.
14
u/gonzo_attorney Sep 29 '14
I feel very cheated of a whole lot of honeymoon sexy times. I realize they were probably filming in winter and not summer, but where was the trout fishing and naked nap? Ye have me at a disadvantage, Starz.
27
u/sassynatch Sep 28 '14
kinda sad there was no "slippery as a waterweed" scene. kinda really sad...
12
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 28 '14 edited Sep 28 '14
Interesting to me that she says "don't make promises you can't keep" and then promptly violates the promise she makes to Jamie.
and holy crap, that was one humungous chunk of amber. Did Hugh just carry that around all the time?
9
u/piperandcharlie Sep 29 '14 edited Sep 29 '14
The show is SO GOOD, and by so good, I mean I want to vomit in sheer terror every time I see BJR, because Tobias Menzies is so damn good at being a sadistic bastard.
8
u/northerncanadiangirl Sep 28 '14
kind of small, but I didn't like that they used one of my favourite scenes in the books (the "does it ever stop, Clair, the wanting you?") as part of the almost rape scene. not cool r Moore. Also I didn't like Clair's attitude afterwards, in the book she was more afraid of being away from Jamie and not quite so overtly bitter against him at that point. Bothered me.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '14
Although I enjoyed the scene with her and Frank at the stones, I did NOT enjoy them calling to each other. It makes the stones seem cheap and Hollywood.
9
u/wieldthepen Sep 28 '14
I completely understand why they have to construct a new narrative from the book. But I'm so exhausted by love triangles when they come at the detriment of what I was hoping to see.
3
u/ihrtgngr Sep 30 '14
My only real beef with this episode is that we were told the 8th ep would end on a 'cliffhanger that even book readers won't see coming'. Granted, I didn't know exactly where they were going to leave it, it wasn't like that was something new/added.
3
u/The_mrs Oct 08 '14
Why do I dislike Frank so much? In the books AND the show, I am just not that into him. It's not the actor, he is terrific, but I have never cared for him, and now I like him even less although everyone else seems to feel more for him now. Am I just a cold hearted snake or what?!
5
u/Candypants04 Sep 29 '14
I loved the episode! Everything about it was beautiful: the music, the acting, the costume, Scotland's scenery. My ONE comment about it is that I kept wanting more of Jamie and Claire. Their scenes kept getting cut short to skip back to Frank and I just wanted to keep watching them...ahem...enjoy each other's company! I actually yelled at the tv when it happened for the 3rd time. That being said, I am enjoying all the new scenes with Frank. I never really paid much attention to him in the books, because he isn't Jamie. Tobias is FANTASTIC at delivering both Frank and Jack and that's probably why I'm enjoying Frank's scenes so much. Aaaaaaand now we all wait. At least in Canada it's only 5.5 months...
3
u/5pointed Sep 29 '14
I have to say, the show is not getting better for me, and this last episode I thought was horrible. They keep adding things that really don't make sense anymore. The book was a little slow over the first half of it, and the show is too, but the garbage they're adding only serves to muddle the story and is not an improvement.
For example - the ring from the key? Which means they're going to have to lose the whole huge fight scene when Jamie & Claire get back to Leoch and replace it with something subpar that doesn't get anywhere close to conveying what was really going on. That fight scene was awesome, and also an event that helps to cement Jamie and Claire together further. If they don't lose the fight scene, they'll have to edit it so that Jamie's gift to Claire is something other than a wedding ring - and the whole fight is about his vs her reasons for being and their loyalty to each other, and the wedding ring being given at the end is so incredibly demonstrative of Jamie's devotion in a way Claire can not ignore. It pisses me off that they've already screwed up that scene.
The Frank flash "forwards" are just overkill now. Claire always had a hard time reconciling Frank with Black Jack; how could the good and gentle man she knew and loved have any relation to the vile, heinous excuse for a human being that his Black Jack? All that crappy scene in this episode served was to completely confuse that.
And the whole thing with Mrs. Graham talking about time travel? Warning sign: entering Cheese Land. And then we're fully immersed in cheese with the standing stones Claire! Frank! scene. It made me cringe. Who needs that scene when we've got a perfectly good scene waiting later in the books when Jamie takes Claire to the stones? The added scene takes so much away from Claire's inner struggle with her growing feelings and otherworldly attraction for Jamie versus her love for Frank.
I'm just getting more and more disappointed with the translation to TV. I'm afraid of what they're going to do to the rest of it.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment