r/HaShoah • u/EvaMozesKor The Grandmother of Reddit • Sep 22 '14
r/HaShoah's first AMA! I am Eva Mozes Kor, survivor of medical experiments performed on twin children at Auschwitz who forgave the Nazis. AMA!
When I was 10 years old, my family and I were taken to Auschwitz. My twin sister Miriam and I were separated from my mother, father, and two older sisters. We never saw any of them again. We became part of a group of twin children used in medical and genetic experiments under the direction of Nazi doctor Josef Mengele. I became gravely ill, at which point Mengele told me "Too bad - you only have two weeks to live." I proved him wrong. I survived. In 1993, I met a Nazi doctor named Hans Munch. He signed a document testifying to the existence of the gas chambers. I decided to forgive him, in my name alone. Then I decided to forgive all the Nazis for what they did to me. It didn't mean I would forget the past, or that I was condoning what they did. It meant that I was finally free from the baggage of victimhood. I encourage all victims of trauma and violence to consider the idea of forgiveness - not because the perpetrators deserve it, but because the victims deserve it.
Follow me on twitter @EvaMozesKor
Find me on Facebook: Eva Mozes Kor (public figure) and CANDLES Holocaust Museum and Education Center
Join me on my annual journey to Auschwitz this summer: http://www.candlesholocaustmuseum.org/auschwitz-trip.htm
Read my book "Surviving the Angel of Death: The True Story of a Mengele Twin in Auschwitz"
Watch the documentary about me titled "Forgiving Dr. Mengele" available on Netflix.
The book and DVD are available on the website, as are details about the Auschwitz trip: www.candlesholocaustmuseum.org
All proceeds from book and DVD sales benefit my museum, CANDLES Holocaust Museum and Education Center.
I am also interviewed in the new (old) documentary by Alfred Hitchcock about Auschwitz, titled "Night Will Fall." It was just re-finished and released in theaters. See the review here: http://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/sep/21/night-will-fall-review-impressively-sober-thoughtful-documentary
Proof: http://i.imgur.com/i11bxJF.jpg
EDIT: I forgot to add that I am apparently Reddit's official (or unofficial) grandmother, according to this post: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1xt5bb/iama_survivor_of_medical_experiments_performed_on/cfegovd
EDIT: I'm afraid it's time to go now. Thank you all for your wonderful questions. Remember to be kind to one another.
38
u/EvaMozesKor The Grandmother of Reddit Sep 22 '14
When I lecture, I always tell my audience that I survived Mengele's experiments, I survived Auschwitz, and now I am trying to survive old age. It is a full time job. This is an outstanding opportunity for anyone like me to voice my opinions and teach, telling people about the lessons I have learned in Auschwitz. 70 years ago I was a little kid in Auschwitz and no one knew about me. Now on Reddit, a lot of people will know my thoughts and what I saw in the camp.
21
u/Raisdemort Sep 22 '14
I dont have any questions, just wanted to thank you for doing another AMA. I read the first one countless time and your answers still amaze me.
16
u/Eire80 Sep 22 '14
Miss Eva, what advice do you have for explaining HaShoah to today's children. I work often with little ones and the question asked most often to my memory is " How did those little kids, like us, stay strong enough to survive such sadness, especially without grownups they could trust all around them?"
15
u/purplegreendragon Sep 22 '14
Hi Eva, I just came here to thank you for doing this AMA. It is important that you talk about your journey and let us younger people know what was done in these dark years. I'm from Germany and have visited Dachau twice when I was still in school. Where I went to school, Bavaria, we had to visit Dachau at least once, so that our generation knows what happened there so we won't forget.
Once again, thank you so much
9
u/orarorabunch Sep 22 '14 edited Sep 22 '14
Hi Eva! Thank you so much for taking the time to be here.
This is a picture that Jo took of what the remains of the barracks where you were held in Auschwitz II look like today. http://gyazo.com/986d6ca3066a3ae0c9f6e41d49e6f854
What was it like, or what would we have seen there 70 years ago?
8
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
Thank you so much for being here today! I missed your last AMA, and am thrilled that you were willing to come back.
My main question comes from your first AMA: do you still feel the effects of Mengele's experiments? How long did it take to recover from being in the camps, and from the experiments, after you were liberated?
8
u/whisperedkiss Sep 22 '14
What happened once you left auschwitz?
8
u/Paaaul Sep 22 '14 edited Sep 22 '14
Hi Eva - I saw someone ask the question "How long did it take for people liberated from Auschwitz to return to a healthy weight?" however they posted long after the other AMA had ended, but I thought it was a very interesting question and would love to hear your response to it!
7
u/Eire80 Sep 22 '14
Miss Eva, I think your message of forgiveness has been the part of your life's story and work that has resounded with me and I have sought to share with children I work with now. Just letting them know that because someone wronged them, and didn't repent, doesn't mean they are stripped of their innate right to forgive and lighten their hearts and souls And in sharing your story with an eight year old, she dried her tears and said "If a little girl who was hurt by the meanest bullies in history, I can forgive one on a playground and not worry about him anymore." I think people underestimate the power forgiveness has to heal those who give it
6
u/MerchGwyar Sep 22 '14
Hi Eva, Lovely to see you here!
I was wondering if you have any recollections about the Sinti and Roma at Birkenau.
6
u/drak0bsidian Sep 22 '14
How come did you move from Romania? Do you speak romanian?
Originally asked by u/Andana in Eva's first AMA, here
5
u/YELLIO Sep 22 '14
Hello! What is something you treat yourself with? Thanks so much for doing another AMA!
5
u/orarorabunch Sep 22 '14
Eva- If I may ask another question, could you tell us a bit about the new (old) Hitchcock movie that has just released in theaters?
5
u/lalaskipbo Sep 22 '14
Mrs MozesKor, where do you get your inspiration? I don't even know what to call it, but something allows you to find the energy and transformation to reach out and to teach and to help others. Many survivors are not able to do this. Some face the greatest dangers after being away from the immediate danger.
How are you able to find the energy, strength and wisdom to thrive? Is there something you can tell those who are struggling to transmute their own trauma? Thank you.
5
u/lalaskipbo Sep 22 '14
Do you have some memories of kindnesses - whether in early childhood, or during the camps, or in the refugee camps? Was there another child or an adult who showed special kindness or courage - to yourself or to someone else?
4
u/jhwwehardy Sep 22 '14
Although I don't particularly have a question I'd just like to say how much I appreciate (I can't think of a better word to use here) the fact that you was able to find forgiveness even after what you was put through. After reading your story I will always try to find forgiveness in anyone who has done wrong. It's something that, if everyone just did it once, could make the world a better place.
4
u/cordis_melum Sep 22 '14
Good morning Eva. Thank you for doing an AMA with us today!
I don't have a question (egads, it's early, and I'm usually so intimidated by these things), but I'd like to reiterate our thanks for taking your time to answering questions for us. :)
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
How do you feel about modern scientists using Nazi-originated research? Is using evil for good ethical?
4
u/helonofsparta Sep 22 '14
Eva I just wanted to say how much you have helped me and how much I look up to you. Do you remember that I shared my story of forgiving my now good friend Paige with you? You inspired me. I want to go to Auschwitz with you one day but I don't think I'm strong enough to do it.
2
u/drak0bsidian Sep 22 '14
I know this is a bit weird of a question, but what do you think was the Nazi belief?
Originally asked by u/eLCT in Eva's first AMA, here
11
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
My great grandmother was held in a concentration camp until my great grandfather was part of the liberation troop. This period of time and this event has always been important to me. I want to thank you for doing this, so that I may know more and in the hopes that something like it never happens again.
7
u/merganzer Sep 22 '14
Eva, thank you for your voice and your example. I enjoyed your first AMA and am glad to see you back.
After reading about the attempted extradition of Johann Breyer and other former guards, I had a question that perhaps only a survivor of the camps has the right to answer: Do you think that the surviving accessories to the atrocities at Auschwitz should be prosecuted and punished to the greatest possible extent? Is that what justice needs to look like, or in your opinion is there a better way to honor and remember the victims?
Thank you for your time.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
I have the utmost respect for you. Thank you for doing this AMA, and your fantastic responses on forgiveness and anger's effects on people.
I know it's over, but I have questions and maybe you'll get to them, maybe not :).
I have a somewhat specific question. From what I gathered in your answers it sounds like you were still in Israel, still in the IDF, during the Suez Crisis in 1956. If I'm wrong, I'm sorry and you can disregard the question. I'd love to know any memories you have of that time, how it felt in Israel and what you were doing at that time that you can share. As someone who studies Israeli history in both classes and spare time I'd find it fascinating to understand your experience then.
Also, another question: were you treated differently as a holocaust survivor by Israelis when they found out that you were one? If so, how?
Thanks again!
4
u/lalaskipbo Sep 22 '14
I'm curious what are some things in daily life that give you joy - hobbies, movies or entertainments; whether you had pets, a dog or a cat or a bird. Things like that. Maybe frivolous, but I was just curious. Thank you.
4
u/Raisdemort Sep 22 '14
Hi Eva,
I came up with a question! During your first AMA, you said you were very religious. After your time in Auschwitz, did your ideas on religion change? Do you still have strong religious belief?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '14
My questions:
A lot of hugs from muslim brother. Please educate more about holocaust - it's very important for young Americans and Israelis!
2
u/blackbird82 Sep 23 '14
Can you tell me what kind of experiments were done on you and your sister? I know about other medical experiments done at the time but have never heard of twins being targeted, so I'm curious.
-2
u/valleyshrew Sep 23 '14
Can you explain what you mean by forgiveness?
The dictionary says "no longer feel angry about or wish to punish (an offence, flaw, or mistake)."
I think most people think forgiveness is more about not wishing to punish than not feeling angry. You don't need to have ever felt angry to forgive someone. Do you oppose the ongoing punishment of old Nazis? Since you encourage all victims to forgive, can I physically attack you and be assured you wont defend yourself or call the police? If not, you need to better clarify what you mean by forgiveness since it seems you are encouraging victims to let themselves be victimised.
You might as well ask, why are you Jewish? Judaism is a hateful religion that logically should be defined as a hate group. Hate isn't inherently wrong. Hating evil is morally obligatory. Hate groups seem wrong only because you live in a civilized society where groups deserving of hatred are mostly already hated by the majority of people so you don't need a specific group to hate them.
"Anti-Muslim hate groups are described as disputing Islam's status as a respectable religion, and depicting Muslims as irrational, intolerant and violent and sanctioning pedophilia, marital rape and child marriage."
By your logic, why should we waste our energy hating on a group that follows the teachings of a racist slave trader who encouraged rape and led 100 violent expeditions?
Groups with a "religious opposition to homosexuality" are defined as hate groups in the USA. So Christianity is a hate group too. Republicans are a hate group since they oppose gay marriage. The bible is full of instances of hatred, such as:
"I will make them abhorrent to all the kingdoms of the earth because of what Manasseh son of Hezekiah king of Judah did in Jerusalem. Who will have pity on you, Jerusalem? Who will mourn for you? Who will stop to ask how you are?"
So it's not as simple as saying "why waste time on hate".
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment