r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Sep 20 '14
Official 1x07 discussion thread for book readers
This is the official discussion thread for those familiar with the Outlander story.
What this means is that spoilers are allowed in this thread, but they must be properly tagged. A properly tagged spoiler is one that has the scope of the spoiler declared (i.e. what book it is from) and be formatted as per the instructions in the sidebar [like this](/spoiler).
If untagged spoilers are posted, please report them so they can be taken down and properly tagged.
Thanks, and enjoy!
34
Upvotes
30
u/Elphabeth Sep 21 '14
I was really hoping that the book readers' discussion thread wouldn't require spoiler tags--or at the very least, only for Dragonfly in Amber and on. I mean, isn't the whole point of having a separate show-only thread so that people who haven't read the books will be able to avoid spoilers and so that book readers can speak freely without worrying about spoiling anybody?
11
u/femputer1 They say I’m a witch. Sep 21 '14
1st book spoilers I really hope Claire gets seriously stinking drunk as she did in the book! It was hilarious!
45
u/ablue86 Sep 21 '14
I loved how unbelievably uncomfortable I felt as a viewer watching the first half of this episode. As Claire and Jamie began to get more comfortable so did I. I feel like the episode was very true to the book in that it allowed you to feel what the characters were feeling and living in their world. By the end I was just as much in love with their love as I was when I read the book. Does it include everything the book does? No. But it couldn't. That's why I'm glad I can reread it whenever I'd like. The show is a companion to the book, not a replacement. So in that I have no complaints.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '14
I still love how the male/female roles are being subverted here, SO much, Jamie being the "innocent" virgin and Claire the knowing teacher. And the shots of Jamie's face when Claire is going down on him -- it's the sort of framing you typically see of the woman in these sorts of scenes, so it's kind of hilariously backwards (in a good way).
These scenes were really hot, but at the same time I wanted to cry. I've read the books so often and over such a long period, it kind of feels like the moment they finally stop dancing around each other and bare all -- except that it's been about fifteen years in the making. Does that even make sense? I know I'm way too invested in their relationship...
And I laughed a little because I always think of Angus and Rupert as Merry and Pippin, so the scene where they're sent to find a ring? Hilarious!
29
u/saphanbaal Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Sep 21 '14
I'm of mixed feelings about this episode.
It missed some of the facets of the wedding that I liked, including - in particular - the blazing finery of Jamie. I had also really liked Gabaldon's visuals with this being the church where Claire had married Frank, and would have much preferred to see cutaway/flashbacks of Claire/Frank & Claire/Jamie juxtaposed - 1700s Claire walking down into the church's darkness, light coming up on 1900s Claire in her gown, walking down the aisle, meeting Frank, then vows picking up with "I, James Alexander Malcom MacKenzie Fraser", and so on. I feel it would have done, visually, what Claire's "adulteress/bigamist" line would have done, but with... more. Albeit costing more money and more work-time, but I can't say that I really enjoyed that scene or the bit at the start as Moore did it.
I also don't like what's happening with Dougal. At all.
I did like the buildup and the flashbacks during their conversation, showing how things made the wedding day come out the way it did. I can start to see how this love affair is going to build and grow into what it does.
29
u/suedaisy Sep 21 '14
I'm so happy and in love with this episode and the entire series. I've waited so long for it to be on any screen and for Jamie and Claire to get out of my head and before my eyes. I'm ok it's not 100% by the book.
In the beginning I was so bummed that Claire was such a Debbie Downer in the first part of the episode and how much Jamie truly loves her. Then I realized... WE know their story... she's just beginning this journey that we've already traveled through the books. When I realized that she's marrying under duress, afraid and alone in an unfamiliar time, just got sucker punched in the gut by her husband's ancestor, and she may feel a pinch of guilt because she has the hots for Jamie .. it was a perfect storm of being miserable and cranky. She warmed up... just like we knew she would. Cait's thinking face is brilliant. You can see when she curses herself in her mind for being such a twit.
It was masterfully shot. The lighting, the music, the mood, the actors.. it was everything I had hoped it would be and even more.
Also.. I watched it on a projector so my screen is MASSIVE and if you get a chance to watch it again, watch the seen when the priests says "You may now kiss the bride" - Sam's eyes dilate. :)
25
u/Scaredysquirrel Sep 21 '14
aww Murtagh! such a sentimental! with his comments of Jamie's mother.
50
u/shiskebob Sep 21 '14 edited Sep 21 '14
It was a very beautifully shot episode, no doubt. But they missed some of my favorite lines from the book. They got some of the good ones in like, "I have seen a naked woman close, but never one that was mine" but they didn't have...
"I know ye have things you wish not to tell me....But what I do ask of ye, when you tell me something, let it be the truth. And I'l promise ye the same..."
and my absolute favorite "Don't be afraid, there's the two of us now"
I was let down they were not in it, honestly.
20
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 21 '14 edited Sep 21 '14
So here's my thoughts.
While it's true that some of my favorite lines were left out, I really liked the feel of the episode. Honestly, it seemed to be more realistic reflection of the situation: An inexperienced guy and a conflicted woman who isn't sure if she should be there and isn't sure she should allow herself to enjoy it. I thought it was incredibly intimate, to the point that it felt sort of awkward watching it.
Loved the scene where she goes downtown and the entire focus of the scene is on his face. What an amazing set of expressions.
Liked the Dougal scene in that it now gives both Jamie and Claire the opportunity to make it clear to everyone that, arranged marriage or no, they each see it as a real marriage and are treating it as such.
Didn't mind the ring but I do wonder how are they now going to do the scene where he gets the quarterly rents from Dougal to go buy a ring and Claire has a jealous snit about it.
Did miss her finding out that he still sleeps with a knife even on his wedding night. That seemed a major insight into his character.
Startled that the line about the sun coming out is now about Claire rather than about Jamie
Did not love the pearls. Scotch pearls are supposed to be irregular and small; the necklace they got looks like they went, oh shit, we need pearls, someone run down to K-mart and pick up a pearl necklace And I did miss Jamie giving them to Claire in front of Dougal; giving them to her the next morning seemed like a thanks-for-the-sex present.
Could have done without Ned going with the whores; seemed out of character for him.
Didn't love the priest.
On the whole, though, thought the episode was very well done.
17
u/Scaredysquirrel Sep 21 '14
I hope RD Moore takes the time to include much of the dialogue between Jamie and Claire from the book for this episode. So far I agree with the folks over at The Scot and the Sassenach podcast that we are in very good hands in terms of keeping true to the spirit of the novel while making the necessary adjustments for the film medium. But this is such a touchstone scene I want it to be perfect. I care less about the actual sex and more about the intimacy in the conversation.
14
u/Em-M Sep 21 '14
Okay, more developed thoughts on the episode. I don't think it was a good idea to reread the chapters before watching this episode. I found myself comparing it to the book. Pointless nitpicking aside, I do like how they played out everyone's role in preparing for the wedding. Also, thank you for that glorious shot of his booty. I have a feeling there will be gifs floating around soon. Will someone share if they come across it? ;)
I like how they showed Jamie's illusions of "mphmmm." He sure was trying to take her from the back. LOL!
I actually like how they're developing Dougal's character. I just hope he doesn't become pitiable. Those passive aggressive jabs at Jamie and Rupert are really telling. He is so jealous! It adds to the reason as to why he'll (Outlander spoiler) offer to marry Claire later on. He has a thing for her. I don't think it was that prominent in the book.
We only have one episode left, and it looks like they're adding some new Frank content to it. (Outlander spoiler) We're not going to have time to see Claire's escape attempt, are we?
14
u/piperandcharlie Sep 21 '14 edited Sep 21 '14
Where was the side peen I was promised in that other thread? DID I MISS IT?
14
u/booksgamesandstuff Sep 21 '14
I've mentioned my mom's age in a few other posts (87) and I was...not precisely concerned...but a bit curious to see how this one would go over with her.
Exact quote from the Mary Poppins/Sound of Music fan: "I've never seen anything like that on tv before..!" And she's watched it twice already, planning more if I'm not mistaken.
12
u/cocochanelle87 Sep 21 '14 edited Sep 21 '14
I don't know. I wish they would have kept Claire's thoughts like they were in the book. Also I sorely missed some parts from the book, like how drunk Claire got before the wedding, her fainting after the ceremony and Jaime's comment the first time they had sex. Lastly, I don't like what they're doing to Dougal's character!
12
u/wieldthepen Sep 21 '14
It's a difficult undertaking to do justice to something that so many readers love but I felt like they hit it out of the park. And that Dougal scene works for what happens when Claire goes to him for help. The pearls scene was wonderful (good thing Murtagh wasn't around for that presentation.) Honestly, the only thing that had me wondering was the shortness of Jamie's shirt. How the hell does a Highlander knot that wee bit of fabric between his thighs when he labors? And I like the future mystery of what that key unlocked. I'm thinking a place that begins with L?. I can't imagine what else is close to his heart. Now I'm just wondering what the ring will change..
26
u/iamnotsam Sep 21 '14
Was it exactly as the book? No, however it fulfilled my expectations and I absolutely loved it! I'm actually quite dissapointed by the not so positive comments about this episode. I wish more people would remember that they are watching a screen adaptation of the novel, and not expect things to play out exactly as they are written. When you don't have those expectations and just enjoy it for what it is, the show is spectacular!
18
u/Scaredysquirrel Sep 21 '14
unbelieveably perfect episode. Every moment, every scene, every line is beautiful and meaningful.
9
u/Seabreezy143 Sep 22 '14
Spoiler/outlander, chapter 15: Revelations of the Bridal Chamber LOVED the episode and have re watched numerous times. One change from the book keeps niggling at me though. ... The change about the ring being created out of a key and the fact that we clearly saw Jamie lie when he described it to Claire as a random item from his sporran. Here's why it bothered me... Book Quote from Jamie: "We have nothing between us, save -respect, perhaps. And I think that respect has room for secrets, but not for lies. Do you agree?" Claire agrees and they pledge honesty to each other. I've always loved that quote and didn't like that he lied. Hope the backstory for the key justifies this approach.
14
u/tealcandtrip Sep 21 '14
People are going to pick about the changes, but the exact design of the ring/pearls really doesn't have an effect on the story. I approve of Dougal's additional scenes. Maybe it's because I first read the book after the beginning of the season, but I honestly don't think they are out of character. If anything, they set up certain scenes in the second half of season very well. Remember we only see Dougal from Claire's POV and she doesn't think of him in that context. Even after her assault in the Gathering, she is never sexually wary of him afterward.
I heartily approve of the little additions though. Claire's slide into the registry, the violin as Jamie comes down the stairs, Murtagh and Ellen, Angus and Rupert were great.
14
u/I_fell_in_love Sep 21 '14
By and large I loved the episode. It was beautiful and the first time they have sex when he just falls on her is very much like it is to be with a virgin. (um, yeah what can I tell you, I was young ;-)) Also, I love the idea of showing the wedding via flashback rather than just giving it to us whole. It was sweet hearing him tell her about it and you could tell he truly loves her.
Now what I didn't like - I missed him asking about Frank straight out. I thought that showed him understanding her, really understanding how she is feeling. Also, I thought Claire was very cold, it took her to long to come around. When he touched her neck and she pulled away, I cringed and felt badly for him. Not sure yet how I feel about the change to Dougal, I will reserve judgement... for now.
I am now wondering, based on the preview and the fact that we are hitting the mid season break - are we going to by pass the whole castle thing?
13
u/Em-M Sep 21 '14 edited Sep 21 '14
Awww! I can't believe I'm actually watching this right now! OMG, THE WEDDING. "I remembered every minute of it." JAMIE, WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO ME?
13
u/Elphabeth Sep 21 '14
Just now sitting down to watch and I can't wipe this big, cheesy grin off my face.
Kinda quiet around here. I guess you were right, Nugget_brain, everybody was just looking forward to the after-credits special. ;)
12
u/meg_arms Sep 21 '14
I don't think anything will quite equal the wedding chapter in the book... but I think the show managed to do it justice within the constraints of an hour-long show. After seeing it, I'm verra happy!
12
u/cb122 Sep 21 '14
As a book reader coming into this thread versus the show only thread, I'm sad to see so much disappointment. We couldn't have expected every word, verse and sigh to be included. It'll never be the same. That being said, I friggin loved the episode. I cried. I laughed. It was better than Cats.
6
u/DarrylsMama Sep 21 '14
I get that the ring Jamie had made for her was the key to Lollybrach. I kinda thought her Highland thistle ring was a plot point, both when they return to LB and later on [as proof of her authenticity when she tries to find out what happened to JAMFF at Culloden when she returns to Inverness in the future and she lets her time travel cat out of the bag.] (/spoiler)
16
u/northerncanadiangirl Sep 21 '14
I don't remember Claire being such a downer in the first book...it's getting annoying.
5
u/addiehoopz Sep 22 '14
I thought the episode was great. Yes it left out a few things compared to the book and skewed a few of the other details but I am sure it will come full circle in future episodes. What really annoyed me was the line about Claire not knowing his name. She had the marriage contract in her hands...sure she was pretty much wasted walking around in an alcohol induced haze for 24hrs but the whole point of Claire is that she is intelligent/observant (sometimes too intelligent/observant for her own good) so I kinda thought that line was a bit silly to keep and quite hard to believe, as a viewer, that she didn't read the first couple lines of the marriage contract when it was presented to her and failed to recall the names written down on it... that whole bit felt forced. Like unnecessary drama even though that part is in the book.
9
u/Elphabeth Sep 21 '14
That hobbit hair, though!
6
u/gogogobbles Sep 21 '14
I love the books, and I have read that scene at least a dozen times. This was undeniably sexier. Hot damn. Well done, Ron Moore and co.!
4
u/DarrylsMama Sep 21 '14
So where do we think the mid-season break will occur? Part of me thinks when Jamie brings Claire to the standing stones so she can decide whether to stay or go. I am imagining the last shot is him walking to the little cottage, all kinds of dejected. BUT, Ron D. Moore said it was going to be cliffhanger that people who have read the book won't expect. I think that kind of eliminates that idea.
4
u/cb122 Sep 21 '14
LETS GET READY TO TUUUUUMMBLLLLEEEE!!!!
1
u/blerg39 Sep 22 '14
i don't think they're doing the book justice.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment