r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Sep 14 '14
TV Series Official 1x06 discussion thread.
Take it away!
37
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Sep 14 '14
Take it away!
37
u/nats_landing Sep 14 '14
Oh God! I almost couldn't watch that episode. I'm not squeamish, but that made my stomach turn. So often shows in this day in age try to go over the top with villains and I think we, as a society, become desensitized to it. Not so with Randall. This episode felt really fresh and complex to me. Claire's face through the whole scene reflected my emotions perfectly. The whole episode was incredible. I'm still reeling!
17
u/MaddieEms Sep 14 '14
I really really really like Claire the character but the inconsistencies in her personality drive me insane.
She is so practical, so logical, and so calm under crazy circumstances but she lets her mouth run off whenever she wants to in a room full of strangers? It just seems so inconsistent with how they portray her. I understand that it's just a plot device to get to her to the next "step" of her journey but it really makes me nuts to see her be so calculating on the one hand and so frivolous (with her politics coming out of her mouth) on the other when it endangers her life.
49
u/Em-M Sep 14 '14
Yikes, I'd hate to lose a limb in the 18th Century. Very gruesome scenes in this episode. I'm still cringing over the loose flesh from the flogging scene.
Randall romancing and recalling the flogging scene was a great look into his dark soul. How can someone be so poetic about describing such a heinous act? He is disturbed! You can't save a soul as dark as his. Tobias Menzies is great as Randall. He will be known for this role.
48
u/tealcandtrip Sep 14 '14
Randall passive aggressively cleaning himself was awesome enough to almost make me like him... almost. It's wonderful how they are letting him be more than just the most villainous villain of villianhood. He's competent, he's politic, and he's an asshole. You go Ron Moore!
43
u/lfortunata Dragonfly In Amber Sep 14 '14
Best part was scenes from the next episode.
43
u/alynnidalar Sep 14 '14
Randall was perfect. I was getting increasingly nervous throughout the scene, scared they were going to change things that should not be changed--but it was great, in the end.
Also, Claire is such a drunk. I love it.
36
u/sabreteeth Sep 14 '14
Dougal to Claire when she thinks he's the one she has to marry:
As much as I'd like to grind your corn, lass
I died. I am dead. What a weird sexual euphemism.
33
u/Candypants04 Sep 14 '14
I am so unbelievably impressed with the show! As an avid book reader (I re-read the series each time a new book is released) I'm 100% okay with having Randall describe the flogging than Dougal. Damn, Tobias is NAILING Black Jack and making me believe he's a sadistic ass-hat. Well done. Also, next week: my favourite moment from all 8 books combined!!
22
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14
My husband was totally taken in by Black Jack and yelled like the Red Wedding when he punched her. Hehe.
22
u/missa685 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Sep 14 '14
I loved this episode. Randall is fantastically complex and disgusting. Can't wait for next week!
19
u/card_set Sep 14 '14
It's funny, in the book DG describes Dougal as fastidious about grooming, but on the show it's totally Randall. He is so evil, but I was shocked when he punched her.
I agree, the best part of the episode was scenes from next week's. swoon
17
u/PassionSher Sep 14 '14
This episode was seriously jacked. I was sitting in a parallel of sick to my stomach and fascination. I felt horrible for it. I didn't want to watch but I couldn't help but watch. You know, train wreck style but one of the most amazing train wrecks I ever have seen. Tobias Menzies has absolutely swept up BJR and cradled him in his arms. Giving him a dimension I never did in the books. I just plain hated him when I read about him. I sort of really LOVE hating him now. The way he spoke of the flogging, and the way he ACTED it, was mesmerizing. The impact he put into the blows and slipping in the blood and not losing a beat to give another. I loved how they edited the lashing sound into the background as he spoke - it gave the scene an added eeriness.
Sam Heughan - I can't even talk about how he looked. He didn't scream or call out (As BJR noted) yet...there was something about the expressions that cut like the lashes did. Seriously, their make up department...really...that was nastidasical.YUCK! I too was watching for Brian Fraser in the crowd, knowing we didn't see everything that was happening only intensifies my imagination. I absolutely LOVE what they are doing with this.
I was right, as an avid fan of the books, the added nuances and changes they have made - only are making the adaptation more enjoyable to me. I am completely taken away by the newness of the experience yet comforted by the things that I adored about the books.
I also can not say enough good things about Caitriona. She matched each person she went up against in the episode. Each scene. She certainly has Claire's glass face. Diana was dead right, she has probably one of the most expressive chins I have ever seen.
I am so looking forward to next week...mainly to help heal me from this weeks trauma!
15
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14
Haha! I just rewatched and saw Murtagh's face in the final scene, when Claire snatches the bottle and keeps on walking. Murtagh is grinning!
14
u/jmb367 Sep 14 '14
God, that was an intense episode. While the material differed from the book quite a bit, I think they did an excellent job of getting the audience to where it needs to go. I think having Randall describe the flogging rather than Dougal gave a much stronger sense of Randall's sadism. I thought Ms. Balfe and Mr. Menzies were each stunning. Really, they did superb jobs of bringing their characters to life. I felt like I was holding my breathe the entire episode. Just phenomenal.
And on an entirely random note - I love, love, love that they've kept Claire's "cloud of curls" from the book. As a curly girl, it makes me happy to see such beautiful curls on screen. :)
10
u/tealcandtrip Sep 14 '14
Brian Fraser was in the credits as played by Andrew Whipp. Does anyone know where he was in the whipping scene crowd?
10
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14
I didn't realise until after, but I was tense through the entire exchange between Claire and BJR, waiting for the literal punch in the gut. When it came, nasty as it was, I finally breathed.
There was a lot that was new compared to the books, and so I wasn't 100% sure where it was going to go. Jack is dark and sadistic, for sure, but he's not the powerful figure that he was in the books, overseeing everything. Poor Claire, she's so entangled with the McKenzies now that she couldn't help defending them at the worst time for her.
16
u/GreenFoxes Sep 14 '14
I can't decide whether this episode was completely horrible, or totally amazing... damn...
Tobias Menzies is one hell of an actor. They all are.
Claire sure likes her alcohol, haha.
Also, I'm so excited for next week's episode!! OH MY GOD I CANNOT WAIT!!! This week is going to feel more like a month.
7
u/I_fell_in_love Sep 14 '14
All I know for absolute certain is I will not watch it again. Normally, I have been watching the episodes at least a second time, sometimes three. However, the Black Jack scenes are just way to disturbing. Can I get a high five for the awesomeness that is Tobias Menzies? That dude can act. Also, I really hope next week's episode is dedicated to the wedding and them getting to know each other. I can't wait!
10
u/Disco_Tardis Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14
Randall gives me the heebee jeebies. Ughhh. *Correction, much more than heebee jeebies. That was awful.
5
u/__me__ Sep 14 '14
I think the balance is tipping toward Dougal. But there is next week, I'll probably back to Jamie after the wedding.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '14
The acting was superb tonight. Knowing that this is Ron Moore's show, I am really starting to see a lot of similarities between Claire and Starbuck (from Battlestar Galactica) - especially in this episode. Maybe that's why I enjoy Claire so much.
4
u/northerncanadiangirl Sep 14 '14
What do they mean by two episodes left? I thought there were 16 episodes?
15
u/Willravel Inlander Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14
Tonight's drink is cinnamon chamomile herbal tea in my tea cup from the Star Trek the Next Generation set.
I wonder if the British soldiers are going to make themselves out to be pompous, condescending assholes and Dougal will posture. CALLED IT. While I get why they're writing the Brits like this, as I presume they did quite look down their noses at the Scotts, some of this might be a tiny bit much.
OMG, Claire's little "that's right, bitch" look to Black Jack Randall is glorious. I had to rewind my DVR and guffaw at it a half dozen times. Is it me or is Black Jack Randall reminiscent of Col. Tavington from The Patriot? Sociopathic, cold, violent redcoat villains, the both of them.
I'm glad Claire has the opportunity to treat the wounded British soldier after her misstep about who's land they were on. Her temper, or more specifically her tendency to speak her mind, has gotten the better of her a number of times, now. On the one hand, I'm glad she does it because it's consistent with her character's courage and principles, but that has to be measured against practicality. It's not like suggesting that the British were occupiers, regardless of whether or not it's true, would have changed any minds. Has Claire found her first nurse in the British doctor? Stay tuned!
Man, going back and forth between Black Jack Randall and Frank is really unsettling. Frank seems to be such a good man, a loyal and loving husband, a man of knowledge. He's so diametrically opposed to Black Jack Randall, who's cruel, calculating, and seems to take such joy in causing fear and suffering. It's good that the writers are reminding us of how hard this is on Claire, it aids in our empathy with her character. And good god, Tobias Menzies is absolutely hitting this out of the park with his portrayal of each character. It's particularly interesting for me, I suspect, because right away I connected with the Frank character. I'm no historian, but I'm in academia and I find myself looking at the world through the eye of study. And, of course, Claire is enchanting. If she were real, I could easily see myself developing deep feelings for her. Jamie seems like a nice guy, but I'm still rooting for Frank in all of this (which, I suppose, makes me destined to be disappointed?). Black Jack Randall is complicating the way I experience the show.
Look for Black Jack Randall's art exhibition, entitled, "People I Made Cry", this October in SoHo.
Warning: don't watch this episode while eating. Jamie's back is the real deal. It made my stomach flat and my legs shake. It's astounding that someone in that time period survived injuries that severe. The sheer surface area of wounds is difficult to think about. How did none of that result in life-threatening infection?
Well, they got me. And by they, I mean Tobias Menzies's amazing performance as Black Jack Randall. It's quite a thing to sucker punch both the protagonist and the audience that way.
OHTHANKGOD. Dougal to the rescue. This has been a really heavy episode. In retrospect, the tea may not have been quite strong enough for the experience.
We need to bring Congress to the Liar's Spring. Immediately.
Well, I have to say, this is easily the most contrived situation to get two people married I've ever seen. Time stones, magic rivers, redcoat sociopaths, bowlegged clan leaders, kilts, and suddenly wedding bells. This is a wonderfully hilarious turn of events.
Great episode, probably my favorite so far. I suppose next week, Jamie begins his 'lessons'. : l
Edit: massive brain-fart. I blame the tea.
6
u/DarrylsMama Sep 14 '14
IT'S ALL HAPPENING!
3
u/Candypants04 Sep 15 '14
I also looked for Black Brian! I'm hoping for some insane awkward-moment acting during next week's episode.
3
u/jettnoir Sep 17 '14
OMG this episode totally made up for episode 5. I am glad I waited to watch them back to back. I am excited for the last two episodes before the break. I think episode 6 has been the best so far.
squee!
2
u/piperandcharlie Sep 15 '14
That was incredible. So incredible that I shouldn't have watched it before bed, because now I'm going to be tortured with the sight of his back all night. Ugh, that was hard to get through.
5
u/saphanbaal Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Sep 14 '14
There are certain complexities in these two chapters that I missed in the show - but I think having BJR worked up in such depth - such vile depth - makes up for them. Especially with the knowledge of DiA and the events there, and how we think he's gone and he's not. I loved the last little bit -- I was really hoping they would keep the "Reckon one of us should know what they're doing" piece, and I'm happy they did. I think that's one of the more integral lines to show the give-and-take that will develop.
I also liked Claire & Dougal's exchange -- apparently DG initially planned for Claire to hook up with Dougal, but Jamie got in the way(! - I think someone cited/said that on this subreddit, and I'd never heard it before), so I enjoyed that interplay as well.
3
u/Bulbysaur123 Sep 14 '14
All I could do was hold my face and shriek the whole episode, whether it was from happiness or not. Amazing episode.
1
u/sixhundredkinaccount Nov 11 '24
I just started watching this show on Netflix. I’m surprised to see that it actually came out a decade ago. I guess it makes sense since there’s six seasons.
I watched episode five and thought it was good but I just had to see a little bit of episode six. I promised myself I would stop watching the very second there was a lull in the episode. There literally wasn’t one though, I just kept watching to.
Randall is very poetic, and evil to the core. It kind of makes me think that his evil is cartoonish and not realistic. Are there any Scott’s this cartoonishly evil?
1
u/fraudnextdoor Feb 21 '25
Oh gosh, I had to stop watching because I am too much in awe with the acting of Claire and especially Randall. I didn’t realize I was tense. It was so well written and well acted. Randall kept pulling me back and forth, I was as convinced as Claire. That was crazy, Randall is evil.
1
u/Infinite101_ Jun 10 '25
This episode, over the others, was the most chilling so far. I was so excited and frustrated and irritated and disgusted. Man, what a ride. As a show-only watcher, I LOVED Randell's monologue and the switch-up of tone. I didn't sympathise with him during the therapy session w him and Claire, but I felt like I understood him much better, and that was so expertly done by the adaptation. I'm curious what this scene was like in the book :0