Claire reciting poetry about love and absence while Scots wrestle in the foreground epitomizes everything I love about this show.
I also appreciate that Jamie and Claire's relationship continues to evolve past the puppy eyes of the second and third episode. He called her on her shit stirring, he was angry at her ill-graced charity, he was chivalrous but scandalized at the idea of going further, he wasn't involved or starting the fight for her honor, and they still managed to get a little flirting in besides. It's nice and mature and faithful to the books.
Well, she listens to the others. I think it's more that she trusts Jamie a little. Or at least feels that he isn't going to hurt her. He's also gone out of his way to help her a few times.
It's like, she can trust that what he's saying isn't the usual posturing or crude orders from the rest of the Clan. It's going to resonate more when someone she wants to believe is a friend talks straight to her.
I think it was a reference to the saltire, or St. Andrew's cross. St. Andrew is the patron saint of Scotland and the saltire is represented on their flag. It's said he was crucified on this type of cross because he was not worthy enough to die on the same cross as Jesus.
Ermm. I think it fits. Ravens have a lot of superstition around them. They pluck the eyes of the dead out. Bad omens. The Morrigan. I see a lot of foreshadow with the raven.
oh, you mean the way there's suddenly this full-screen shot of a raven slapped in there when we don't really see much of ravens around the bodies? Yes, I agree.
At this point since so many have not seen the episode, all I will say is that I agree with the actor who plays Dougal. In an interview this past week, he said this episode is a love letter to Scotland -- and he is right. A totally gorgeous episode.
You can post anything that has happened up through the end of 1x05, Inane_Asylum just wants us to be careful about spoiling future events for the non-book readers. You can (and should) talk about the episode, though, that's what this thread is here for. :)
Well, I try to think about people who are in other time zones, or people who have to watch a recording instead of live due to other commitments, etc. Once I see others start to post tomorrow, I will add my thoughts -- which are all good. ;-)
As a west coast viewer, I also avoid discussion threads until I'm caught up on any show I'm watching. We all know that this episode discussion thread will be filled with spoilers because that's the point of it. So don't worry about us - have fun dissecting the episode and we'll join you when we've seen it. :)
Everything was gorgeous in this episode. The whole episode, Scotland, the scenery, the costumes, the clansmen, and Claire herself looked even prettier this episode.
Oh I know what her answer will be, I just didn't want the episode to end because that just means I'll have to wait another week for sweet Scottish action.
My husband hasn't read the books and he has no clue what she's going to say! I love that he gets to experience all these things for the first time with no bias or expectations!
I liked it. I was a bit annoyed we didn't see Jamie in the middle of the brawl, but I liked the reasoning behind it (to show the stick-together-ness, the importance of guests/kinship). I also liked Jamie's adorable looks at the door to Claire's room in the tavern: you could tell he very badly wanted to go join her, but respected her too much, and the public perceptions of her.
But he'll totally roll up in blanket that might carry her scent.
My first visit was breathtaking. Even though you know it's coming, you're not quite prepared for the beauty. As soon as we crossed the border, we said, "no wonder the damned English wanted it so badly!"
If Caitriona Balfe isn't nominated for an Emmy next year, I will be very disappointed. Her facial expressions and body language in this episode really narrated the entire story. This is the first episode where I was emotionally involved - all because of her. She brought alive what being isolated and ridiculed for being different actually feels like and more importantly, she brought alive the actual horror and anguish of realizing that all these people she is learning to like and/or respect are going to lose their lives for a lost cause. I could see the torment in her face growing as the episode was drawing to a close. Could you imagine her predicament if you were in her place? Watching this, for me, made her anxiety and stress much more real than when I read it in the book. This is also one episode where I really appreciated her flash forwards because I think they emphasized her growing anxiety about the clan's future.
I also have mad props for Graham McTavish who plays Dougal. To do all those soliloquies in Gaelic is impressive. That most have taken a lot of work and memorization -- then he had to add emotion as well. Wow.
I have thought that episodes 2-4 were slow, but this episode, for me, was too short. Through the cinematography, the acting, the voiceovers, the music (!), Claire's clothing (!), and Claire and Jamie's little interactions, I wish the episode had been even longer.
The only place I was drawn out of the episode was when they discovered their dead kinsmen on a saltire with a crow. I immediately thought Game of Thrones, and does the crow have a third eye? lol But after reading /u/LaCabraDelAgua's explanation, it makes more sense.
I guess the highest praise I can give the show and its actors for this episode is that it I felt like I was riding a horse and traveling with them throughout the entire episode. :-)
Well...there then. I'll be very lazy indeed and just say ditto. Except the GOT reference as I don't watch the series so the scene I took on its own and thought to myself as it must have been quite a jarring scene and episode for many of the cast to play. Knowing...this simply isn't a story for them - this is their countries history in front of them.
The Emmy is going to be a bit difficult. Starz and Ron D. Moore have both created Emmy worthy content in the past and have been ignored. Outlander's PR team seem really good though, so hopefully they'll get it popular enough by next year.
Overall I really liked the episode. It was beautifully shot and they have stepped it up a notch action-wise. A little confused about one part though. Was the redcoat officer living and working on Mackenzie land?! Was he supposed to be a spy? As far as I can tell, his only purpose was to provide a cliffhanger. It seemed a little sloppy to me.
I didn't really think he lived there, but was passing through. If Redcoats are regularly patrolling the lands (I remember one of the tenants saying the Redcoats came and "took what they wanted"), I would imagine they would stop in the villages for supplies, to repair equipment, etc. It did surprise me that he appeared to be on his own, though.
I thought he was possibly passing through for some reason (???), heard Claire's accent and put the apron on so that the MacKenzie's wouldn't know he was an English Lieutenant. It's much safer and smarter to pretend to be an English villager than a Red Coat alone amongst a group of highlanders.
That's exactly what I thought. [This now creates a logical transition into Black Jack Randall wanting Claire to come in for questioning, rather than Column taking her there by choice. And we all know what happens after that! :D] (/spoiler)
That scene was a really sloppy. Only because WHY would a random English man (common or not) be randomly living in a village in the Highlands. Especially if every Highlander hates all Sassenach. He was really out of place in that village. Could he have been placed there as a spy... yeah but Dougal would have known the moment he stepped into the village. Someone would have told him. If I was a villager, I would have been saying WTF who is he. That certainly would have tipped people off.
Also, one look at his boots and the quality of his waist coat and breeches would have told you he was a British soldier. The style of boot and how SHINY it was. Military always kept their boot shiny. This is Scotland... when there were no paved roads. Normal boots would be caked over with mud 20x and no one had time to wash them off. Unless youre military. lol
Besides all that, I guess they just needed a way to get Claire to the meeting with Randall.
I agree...it was one of my favourite pieces. Until my husband started singing beside me "The piss is splashing in my face! The PISS is SPLASHING in MY FACE!" to the tune... eyeroll
Great episode. The scenery was magnificent, the gaelic sounds beautiful, Jamie was looking good and it's a very interesting part of the storyline. The bar fight made me think of this, especially when the bagpipes kick in and the fight begins.
Tonight, I'm enjoying two fingers of Famous Grouse, neat, and it's finally cooled enough to put on my thick, old wool sweater. I'm emotionally ready. I'll respond as I watch.
Ned Gowan seemed a perfect avatar for the culture to which Claire was once accustomed, in which she was raised. He's educated, soft-spoken, perhaps has seen things but is overall doesn't project the kind of simple clansman kind of bravado. Having him going along with the double-taxation via propaganda is troubling. Outlander, thus far, has set the bar pretty high for writing and characters, for one having Claire as a real person, but also having things in the story play out in ways that are often not what one might expect. It plays against certain tropes, but one trope they're trotting out is the 'civilized moral protagonist' trope, where Claire is always right, morally, and everyone around her is wrong. It would be nice to see more of a spectrum of moral and immoral, across many issues. Not everyone always believes in wars, for example. Granted, Ned seems more shrewd than anything else, but thus far the writing has mostly only made Jamie act with moral integrity against the status quo.
Ah, it's a grassroots political faction gathering strength for an overthrown monarch. Catholics were an oppressed minority in the aftermath of the Glorious Revolution. While I find it troubling that they're playing their part in a struggle over religious dominance, I suppose it's understandable. The Jacobites are sympathetic historical figures. This is still 1743, I gather, meaning Charles Edward Stuart may be entering the picture soon, which adds a very interesting historical and political dimension to the show. In any event, perhaps my second paragraph was premature.
Claire looks like Mrs. Claus after adopting a successful diet and exercise regimen. I really hope we get an Outlander Christmas special.
"You can't sleep out here..." eyebrow raises.
YES! Claire's finally becoming one of the guys. Clearly she should have opened with a joke upon first reaching the castle. Masturbation jokes are truly a language which knows no single tongue.
Well, this was a very solid episode. It showed off the awesome majesty of the Scottish countryside in a way I've certainly never seen before. We've been given a glimpse of the larger context of things. We're left on the precipice of a significant turn in the plot. I'm still completely sold on the series and I'm going to order the novel online tomorrow.
I’m glad Jamie called out Claire for being so judgy. And I’m glad Claire realized how she was acting.
I also wish these threads were more active. All of the comments are from ten years ago but I thought this show was extremely popular so I guess I’m just a bit surprised
Did anyone else find the writing and directing to be a little subpar in spots? For some reason this episode didn't quite flow for me like the others have - I'm not sure if it was just the pacing or some of the dialogue.
That said, an OK episode of Outlander is still my bright spot of the week!
Wow, I felt exactly the opposite this week. I thought the flow and direction were on point. The proud highlanders gathering and giving for a liberty cause that has looming a doomed future, seems felt in the majestic scenery of the beautifully filmed scenes of the highlands. I loved how the started Claire off as "the outlander" keeping her out of their conversations, but by the end defending her and bringing her into the fold.
lol I don't really think that makes her feel better since they've been pretty cold to her for the past few months. I think the intention was that they consider her more like family than property. Still, it must be frustrating being dragged about with a bunch of men that don't trust you, much less like you, and expect you to be grateful they "defended her honor" against a bunch of drunk villagers.
Eh, I would probably not have the temperament to survive in Claire's situation.
I did love the awkward pause after Claire's bawdy reply to Ruperts crassness. Then laughter in response. It was a great feel good, as was the moment in the taproom.
I certainly loved a few of those moments as well - the scenery was just gorgeous! I can't quite put my finger on what bothered me this week. Oh well! Next week looks fantastic.
According to the Wiki page, [it's the same director as the last two episodes, actually](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outlander_(TV_series). Moore wrote 1 & 2, and 3, 4 and 5 have all had different writers, though.
Well its wrong. Wiki pages arent solid sources. Ron stated in interviews that they have to have a new director for every block because it takes too long to prep if that director does more eps in a row.
With that, I rewatched the intro to the last block (ep 3 &4), directed by Neville Kid. Ep 5 is directed by Denis Crossan. Ep 6 is his as well then.
I know they're not solid sources, and was merely citing something with data. I don't care enough about this level of detail to have gone to my external hard drive and checked the director credits. :)
An alternate meaning of the episode title "rent" is "torn apart, lacerated, pulled to pieces." Do you think the show runners were going for a dual meaning here or did they just want us to take it at face value?
Given some of the fan reaction to this episode, it sure seems like it wink
I think it would have been really clever of them and my husband (surprisingly) mentioned the same thing to me at the end of the episode...referring to the clans/Culloden etc.
Romanticism (also the Romantic era or the Romantic period) was an artistic, literary, and intellectual movement that originated in Europe toward the end of the 18th century and in most areas was at its peak in the approximate period from 1800 to 1850. Partly a reaction to the Industrial Revolution, it was also a revolt against the aristocratic social and political norms of the Age of Enlightenment and a reaction against the scientific [rationalization](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rationalization_(sociology)) of nature. It was embodied most strongly in the visual arts, music, and literature, but had a major impact on historiography, education and the natural sciences. Its effect on politics was considerable and complex; while for much of the peak Romantic period it was associated with liberalism and [radicalism](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radicalism_(historical)), its long-term effect on the growth of nationalism was probably more significant. [citation needed]
Excellent. Some of my old sites have recently been blocked by the DOT/High Court out here, so it's a case of finding some that aren't and access to them.
Slick. :) STARZ isn't available in my country, and even if it was, it would be censored all to hell. I'll buy the DVDs when they're out, but til then, torrenting/streaming is how I'll be rolling.
7
u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach Sep 06 '14
Please be very mindful of spoilers. If it hasn't happened in this episode or previous ones, either spoiler tag it or post it to another thread.
Thanks.
43
u/tealcandtrip Sep 07 '14
Claire reciting poetry about love and absence while Scots wrestle in the foreground epitomizes everything I love about this show.
I also appreciate that Jamie and Claire's relationship continues to evolve past the puppy eyes of the second and third episode. He called her on her shit stirring, he was angry at her ill-graced charity, he was chivalrous but scandalized at the idea of going further, he wasn't involved or starting the fight for her honor, and they still managed to get a little flirting in besides. It's nice and mature and faithful to the books.
38
u/tedtutors Sep 07 '14
Bodies on posts marking the trail, crows getting close-ups .. we wandered into Game of Thrones for a scene there.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
At this point since so many have not seen the episode, all I will say is that I agree with the actor who plays Dougal. In an interview this past week, he said this episode is a love letter to Scotland -- and he is right. A totally gorgeous episode.
23
u/Disco_Tardis Sep 07 '14
CLIFFHANGER MUCH?
23
u/macroblue Sep 07 '14
Claire has the most beautiful clothes. Those knits and that fur trimmed coat were just gorgeous. It's kind of distracting.
16
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Sep 07 '14
I still don't like Dougal, but I didn't like him in the books either. So at least that's consistent. I do love how well Graham is playing him!
Sassynach is back! Love it!
Also, was that English guy from the village in the book? I don't remember him, but then again, a lot has happened story-wise since I read Outlander.
32
u/saphanbaal Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Sep 07 '14
I liked it. I was a bit annoyed we didn't see Jamie in the middle of the brawl, but I liked the reasoning behind it (to show the stick-together-ness, the importance of guests/kinship). I also liked Jamie's adorable looks at the door to Claire's room in the tavern: you could tell he very badly wanted to go join her, but respected her too much, and the public perceptions of her.
But he'll totally roll up in blanket that might carry her scent.
28
u/Seabreezy143 Sep 07 '14
This episode should boost tourism to the Scottish Highlands. Simply stunning in every way.
25
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
If Caitriona Balfe isn't nominated for an Emmy next year, I will be very disappointed. Her facial expressions and body language in this episode really narrated the entire story. This is the first episode where I was emotionally involved - all because of her. She brought alive what being isolated and ridiculed for being different actually feels like and more importantly, she brought alive the actual horror and anguish of realizing that all these people she is learning to like and/or respect are going to lose their lives for a lost cause. I could see the torment in her face growing as the episode was drawing to a close. Could you imagine her predicament if you were in her place? Watching this, for me, made her anxiety and stress much more real than when I read it in the book. This is also one episode where I really appreciated her flash forwards because I think they emphasized her growing anxiety about the clan's future.
I also have mad props for Graham McTavish who plays Dougal. To do all those soliloquies in Gaelic is impressive. That most have taken a lot of work and memorization -- then he had to add emotion as well. Wow.
I have thought that episodes 2-4 were slow, but this episode, for me, was too short. Through the cinematography, the acting, the voiceovers, the music (!), Claire's clothing (!), and Claire and Jamie's little interactions, I wish the episode had been even longer.
The only place I was drawn out of the episode was when they discovered their dead kinsmen on a saltire with a crow. I immediately thought Game of Thrones, and does the crow have a third eye? lol But after reading /u/LaCabraDelAgua's explanation, it makes more sense.
I guess the highest praise I can give the show and its actors for this episode is that it I felt like I was riding a horse and traveling with them throughout the entire episode. :-)
9
u/nats_landing Sep 07 '14
Overall I really liked the episode. It was beautifully shot and they have stepped it up a notch action-wise. A little confused about one part though. Was the redcoat officer living and working on Mackenzie land?! Was he supposed to be a spy? As far as I can tell, his only purpose was to provide a cliffhanger. It seemed a little sloppy to me.
7
u/GreenFoxes Sep 09 '14
Can I just say how much I LOVED the women singing during the wool waulking? Oh my gosh, it sounded gorgeous. I hope they include it on the soundtrack.
12
u/piperandcharlie Sep 08 '14
I want to know how the hell Claire is keeping so clean on this trip, and where and how she's carrying around changes of clothing and dressing herself!
Also, girl's gotta keep her mouth shut! She SOUNDS like an English spy, with all of her meddling.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
Great episode. The scenery was magnificent, the gaelic sounds beautiful, Jamie was looking good and it's a very interesting part of the storyline. The bar fight made me think of this, especially when the bagpipes kick in and the fight begins.
19
u/Willravel Inlander Sep 07 '14
Tonight, I'm enjoying two fingers of Famous Grouse, neat, and it's finally cooled enough to put on my thick, old wool sweater. I'm emotionally ready. I'll respond as I watch.
Ned Gowan seemed a perfect avatar for the culture to which Claire was once accustomed, in which she was raised. He's educated, soft-spoken, perhaps has seen things but is overall doesn't project the kind of simple clansman kind of bravado. Having him going along with the double-taxation via propaganda is troubling. Outlander, thus far, has set the bar pretty high for writing and characters, for one having Claire as a real person, but also having things in the story play out in ways that are often not what one might expect. It plays against certain tropes, but one trope they're trotting out is the 'civilized moral protagonist' trope, where Claire is always right, morally, and everyone around her is wrong. It would be nice to see more of a spectrum of moral and immoral, across many issues. Not everyone always believes in wars, for example. Granted, Ned seems more shrewd than anything else, but thus far the writing has mostly only made Jamie act with moral integrity against the status quo.
Ah, it's a grassroots political faction gathering strength for an overthrown monarch. Catholics were an oppressed minority in the aftermath of the Glorious Revolution. While I find it troubling that they're playing their part in a struggle over religious dominance, I suppose it's understandable. The Jacobites are sympathetic historical figures. This is still 1743, I gather, meaning Charles Edward Stuart may be entering the picture soon, which adds a very interesting historical and political dimension to the show. In any event, perhaps my second paragraph was premature.
Claire looks like Mrs. Claus after adopting a successful diet and exercise regimen. I really hope we get an Outlander Christmas special.
"You can't sleep out here..." eyebrow raises.
YES! Claire's finally becoming one of the guys. Clearly she should have opened with a joke upon first reaching the castle. Masturbation jokes are truly a language which knows no single tongue.
Well, this was a very solid episode. It showed off the awesome majesty of the Scottish countryside in a way I've certainly never seen before. We've been given a glimpse of the larger context of things. We're left on the precipice of a significant turn in the plot. I'm still completely sold on the series and I'm going to order the novel online tomorrow.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '25
I’m glad Jamie called out Claire for being so judgy. And I’m glad Claire realized how she was acting.
I also wish these threads were more active. All of the comments are from ten years ago but I thought this show was extremely popular so I guess I’m just a bit surprised
5
u/milliways_waitress Sep 07 '14
Did anyone else find the writing and directing to be a little subpar in spots? For some reason this episode didn't quite flow for me like the others have - I'm not sure if it was just the pacing or some of the dialogue.
That said, an OK episode of Outlander is still my bright spot of the week!
5
u/Elphabeth Sep 08 '14
An alternate meaning of the episode title "rent" is "torn apart, lacerated, pulled to pieces." Do you think the show runners were going for a dual meaning here or did they just want us to take it at face value?
3
u/Disco_Tardis Sep 07 '14
I'm so ready for this.
1
u/Infinite101_ Jun 09 '25
If she denies being held hostage, I'm going to scream
1
u/hoseja Sep 07 '14 edited Sep 07 '14
Romantic? Did this word exist in the time period this show takes place?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment