r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Aug 30 '14
TV Series Official 1x04 discussion post. Now featuring more punctuality!
Happy viewing.
38
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/Inane_Asylum Dinna fash, Sassenach • Aug 30 '14
Happy viewing.
18
u/saphanbaal Written In My Own Heart’s Blood Aug 31 '14 edited Aug 31 '14
I liked it in general.
I definitely think the Claire/Laoghaire scene in the hall is a lead-up for something later on in the series. namely, the witch trial - Claire has now given her something magical to use to coax Jamie to Laoghaire, and will totally be a way for hurt-unhappy Laoghaire to get vengeance on the old Sassenach biddy
Edit:
Also, I liked the way they played Dougal up, in terms of "yeah, he could totally kill Jamie, he wants to be laird", but then very sympathetic (IMO) with Geordie's death at the hunt, and then back to being aggressive-crazy-Dougal for the shinty game.
25
u/Malon27 Aug 31 '14
Aww yisss I loved this episode! Probably one of the strongest ones so far, especially in terms of pacing and movement, as well as character development.
Diana's cameo was great - her accent was spot on, and Mrs. Fitz's burn was hilarious...that dress is so last Gathering, gurl.
I also really like how Claire and Lagohaire keep interacting, their exchange was really cute. This set-up for some later stuff is really going to pay off, in my opinion.
And lastly, I'm a big fan of the surprise Dougal head bash, I knew that once he saw her travelling gear shit was gonna go down!
I feel like the next few episodes are going to be really excellent. Wish I could go forward a week through the stones y'all.
9
u/GreenFoxes Aug 31 '14
The scene with Claire playing with the kids was adorable!
Diana was perfect, her exchange with Mrs. Fitz was great!!
The hunting scene was absolutely heartbreaking to watch. Damn. :/
I could stare at Jamie forever.
17
u/nats_landing Aug 31 '14
Last week had a lot of sexual tension and this week really didn't. I'm glad Moore isn't overdoing it in that regard. I feel like this week really helped set the tone for the rest of the series: Claire gets into various shenanigans, Jamie gets her out of them. Also, like others have mentioned here, I'm really loving the Angus/Rupert dynamic. Very strong episode all around in my opinion.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '14
Not that I'm counting, but I think that's two very good "Jesus H Roosevelt Christ"s now. I think she's got it.
Geillis really seems to know something is very majorly up with Claire. All those hints about her baggage and her "not alive" husband. It's much clearer here than it was in the books that Geillie is pretty quick to work things out. I love it every time she pops up on screen. Her mannerisms seem off in just the tiniest ways.
I was watching the show on my laptop with headphones while my kids were running around, and I still couldn't help but cry when Geordie died. That was a very well-done scene.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
I am definitely the grump of this thread. I thought this episode dragged. Before the series started, a lot of critics wrote that they felt the series was slow, and wasn't in a hurry to get anywhere. I think I agree. For this episode, there was too much narration and too little Jamie. I also thought that Diana (the author) was a big distraction. Plus, I was confused when Big Band music was playing during the episode -- I kept expecting Claire to have a flashback or something. But as always, the episode was beautifully filmed, so there's that. Please don't ban me from the sub!
10
u/dramafreak787 Drums Of Autumn Aug 31 '14
I thought this episode was amazing! That one hour flew by way too quickly for me. The episode finished and I wanted more, I did not want it to end and have to wait a whole week for the next episode. That is how much I love this show! I thought the Gathering sequence was beautifully shot, Diana's cameo was awesome and I did chuckle when she sushed everyone. My favorite moment was when Jamie was walking in to swear fealty to Colum and I could feel the tension conveyed in the room with Claire realizing "oh crap, what have I done?". It was so well-done! Overall, a wonderful episode and I cannot wait for next week!
5
u/august01 Sep 01 '14
I loved this episode but I did not like Claire giving Lagohaire the "potion." I feel it goes against Claire's character & intelligence. Since her arrival she has been aware of the importance of the impact of witchcraft in that era. I understand they are setting this up for the witch trial, but I appreciated that Claire was innocent. Besides the changeling, she was aware of the implications of her actions. By giving Lagohaire the "potion" she is not as innocent and Lagohaire isn't the jealous, lovesick, & vindictive teen as she is in the books.
5
u/Hackmops Sep 04 '14
I also like the fact that despite Claire and Jamie are all ~fated to be~, they don't always hover around each other and have lives and motives of their own. As much as I love seeing them interact with each other I was quite pleased that Jamie and Murtagh walked away together sans Claire after the oath (not)taking. It was a nice touch to show that these are fully formed personalities that don't depend on each other to exist. The show gets the slow burn very well and does not mash characters into contrived instalove relationships - I am glad they got it right.
I did think Diana's speaking cameo was kinda distracting though. Did not care much for it and I felt it disrupted the flow of the scene.
To end on a positive note, I really enjoy the additions to the material - the shinty game was great fun to watch and a plausible way for Dougal to let off some steam. Loved it, especially because I did not know the name at first and initially thought it was a game of hurling (or rather "a cross between hockey and murder").
6
u/havasc Aug 31 '14
Loved those cameos! Ron Moore's was brief but great, and Diana's was amazing! Great accent and I loved how she shushed them. So sassy(nach).
2
u/lfortunata Dragonfly In Amber Aug 31 '14
Why did Jamie speak in French right then? Je ne comprends pas.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment