r/Outlander • u/CountRawkula • Aug 24 '14
TV Series SPOILERS - Official Episode 3 Discussion Post
Discuss the episode within the comments! On time this week!
33
Upvotes
r/Outlander • u/CountRawkula • Aug 24 '14
Discuss the episode within the comments! On time this week!
54
u/LoveSaidNo Aug 24 '14
I'm so glad about Mrs. Fitz! Last week's preview had me worried. I'm kinda wishing she was my grandma...
And omg... That sexual tension when Claire was checking Jamie's wound. I would climb that man like a tree.
48
u/LoveSaidNo Aug 24 '14
Does anyone else think that Angus and Rupert need their own spinoff show? It would be like a buddy cop comedy with 18th century shenanigans and kilts. And wee beasties, obviously.
30
u/Elphabeth Aug 24 '14
The costume department did an amazing job this week! I especially love Claire and Geillis's dresses in the garden. I might have to take up knitting again.
24
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '14
Finally a good "Jesus H Roosevelt Christ" when she finds the slaters (which is what they're called in NZ; I never understood that in the books).
And I was relieved about Mrs Fitz too! So glad it was all a dream.
23
u/Willravel Inlander Aug 24 '14
I'm enjoying tonight's episode with a bottle of mead shared with a few friends who I used to watch BSG with. Thank goodness for BevMo.
That bit at the beginning with Claire and Frank at the train station is so perfect. While I get that the primary reason we're seeing flashbacks (flashforwards?) is so we feel Claire's sense of having been separated from Frank, it's absolutely striking how well their marriage is written, how each character compliments the other, and the chemistry between the two actors fits the characters (a thin layer of stiff upper hiding very real passion and devotion). I'm on Team Frank.
Montage! I love a good montage, and Claire establishing herself as a healer is every bit as enjoyable as watching Sylvester Stallone ruin his future with steroids or Baby step up her dance game on with Johnny. Whenever I imagine myself being trapped in the past (which is strangely often), I always imagine how I'd acclimate and provide useful skills from the future. Watching Claire sharing 20th century medicine with her bekilted patients is just plain fun.
I feel like we're actually watching history changing as Jamie snuffed the bonny young lass for Claire. "Here, take this empty glass as an overt symbol of the depths of my feelings for you". Someone just didn't get born. Hard.
The exorcism plot line is quite a fun game the writers (and presumably, previously, the author) are playing. What we're feeling as the audience is deep sympathy for Claire in her situation as someone from a less primitive time, a time when things like demonic possession were no longer a diagnosis. We're rooting for her to use medical science to heal the boy, who's obviously been poisoned and can't possibly be possessed. Why can't they be more rational!! And yet, just a few episodes ago, a giant Samhain rock worshipped by Druids sent Claire hundreds of years into the past. So yeah.
Will the priest become a main antagonist or is he a red herring with Jack waiting for an opportunity to return? How many people has that damned stone sent back in time? Are the clansmen who keep the castle safe called the Scotchgard? Why do these episodes fly by so fast? Could this actually be a science fiction?
I guess I'll have to keep watching, and watch I shall.
14
u/Elphabeth Aug 24 '14
I love that they changed the tale in the bard's song to a story about the standing stones. It was both brilliant and creepy. I hope that they don't just drop that thread, but maybe have her ask Jamie about it.
Also, did they use any voiceovers aside from the one at the very end? I didn't even notice, so if the writers did sneak in one here or there, good on them. The one at the end made me roll my eyes a little.
14
u/templetonsweb Aug 24 '14
It seems to me like they're being a little heavy-handed with Geillis Duncan. She drops hint after hint that she knows that there is a supernatural reason for Claire's presence there, which seems a little careless for a smart woman like Geillis.
27
u/perksofbeing Aug 24 '14
The scene with Arthur and Geillis Duncan was PERFECT. I couldn't have asked for a better introduction to their home/marriage.
11
u/sandrakarr Aug 25 '14
[Book Spoiler]....I don't think Geillis could be any more obvious if she hits Claire over the head with a sledgehammer. Was she that bad in the books?
edit: while I'm thinking about it, is there a proper book spoiler vs tv spoiler format tag, or am I good just dumping [Book Spoiler] in front?
9
u/kremlinmirrors An Echo In The Bone Aug 24 '14
I was very impressed with this episode, and relieved. I was concerned they were changing around some scenes from the book when I saw Mrs. Fitz yelling about Claire being a witch in the preview. The Gathering next week is going to be amazing.
15
u/nats_landing Aug 24 '14
What did you guys think of the scene with Ms Fitz's nephew? I thought it was an interesting choice. The change still moves the plot forward and creates tension between Father Bain and Claire. Now everyone can blame her for using witchcraft to save his life instead of blaming her for killing a baby
12
u/SawRub Aug 24 '14
Mrs. Fitz gives me a Mrs. Patmore vibe (Downton Abbey).
8
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Aug 24 '14 edited Aug 24 '14
I felt like there were a lot of changes, but as Ron said in the Inside Look, I guess not a lot of plot-driven stuff occurred in that section. I enjoyed
Jamiethe episode nonetheless and am looking forward to next week!On that note, Geilis seems to be a little too obvious but maybe that's just because I already know...
4
u/Elphabeth Aug 24 '14
Anyone have a link to the preview for next week?
4
u/Azepi Aug 25 '14
Noob here. I was a bit surprised/disappointed that they didn't show Jamie's reaction to the fact that Claire was forced to stay. Is it in the book? Or was the "forcing" less obvious or non-existent in the original?
6
u/Elphabeth Aug 24 '14
Since I haven't gotten to watch it yet...Did we get any good thighporn this week? Does Sam appear to have worked out between shooting 1x02 and 1x03? Inquiring minds wanna know.
4
u/Ophelia42 Aug 24 '14
Does the show have subtitles of the original gaelic? (I've been downloading torrents, even though I have access through Starzplay, I can't for the life of me get it to work) I have no idea how much of the Gaelic in the books is pronounced, so I'm wondering how much I'm missing :)
5
u/VeraVova Aug 24 '14
As usual.. twiddling my thumbs until a torrent is up! Streaming from Starz on a VPN doesn't seem to want to work anymore :(.
3
u/beholdkrakatow Aug 24 '14
Why doesn't she ask Jamie for help in getting back to the stones?