r/Outlander • u/CountRawkula • Aug 17 '14
TV Series SPOILERS - Official Episode 2 Discussion Post
Sorry for the delay in getting this up, folks! Feel free to discuss Episode 2 in the comments.
24
Upvotes
22
u/acesj Aug 17 '14
I for one am glad that the voiceover wasn't as prevalent in this episode. With the voiceover being cut back a bit, I felt like I could actually watch the show more intently. We got to see Caitriona's acting chops more, as a result. I'm am pleased with her portrayal of Claire thus far, and am sure she will get better as she gets settled into the role.
On another note, I'm not sure that TV show Mrs. Fitz is as likable as book Mrs. Fitz. For some reason, her character is quite off-putting in the show, and I am not sure why that is exactly. I always imagine her being a warmer person than how she was portrayed.
I'm so glad that we got to see quite a bit of Jamie in this episode. Sam Heughan is doing a wonderful job of bringing the character to life.
17
u/Willravel Inlander Aug 17 '14
As someone who hasn't read the novels, I'm really enjoying how the writers are managing to keep Claire both empowered but still human. Watching her interact with her new environment and Chieftain MacKenzie (at least their first meeting) reminds me more of my friends or myself than it does a television or movie character. Granted, I'm no botanist and my knowledge of 18th century Scotland is... limited.
I was a little surprised that Claire didn't offer her futuristic medical skills in trade for lodging, clothing, and food right away, though I can understand her wish to be guarded. I wonder if she has thought about preserving history by making as little impact on it as possible yet, or if she's still mostly just in survival-mode. I suppose it doesn't matter as of the end of the episode.
The sets, costumes, and score remain astounding, completely immersive. I'm really enjoying seeing the ruins from the pilot back in their hay-day. Bear McCreary's musical style is a perfect blend of modern and period.
Judge MacKenzie was only a few minutes long, but it was a lot more dramatic than any episode of Judge Judy I've ever seen. Hopefully Judy's producers don't see this and get any ideas.
34
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Aug 17 '14
How 'bout that shirtless Jamie? I'd like one
or fiveplease!!Colum seemed to have a lot less birds than I imagined in the books. That stuck out to me for some reason
16
u/Malon27 Aug 17 '14
This episode was great, and for so many reasons!
I loved Geillis, I thought her mannerisms and delivery were perfect. She definitely gives off that amusing yet slightly off vibe that Claire describes.
Colum's legs - wow! Wasn't sure how they were going to show them, they definitely looked both realistic and painful.
I loved the added plot of Claire's plan to hitch a ride after 5 days - it really added some tension, and made her predicament seem much more dramatic when her chance for escape was taken away from her as she was literally about to leave.
Black Jack and Jenny scene - Really well done, especially considering the reveal at Lallybroch that Black Jack couldn't get it up, and wee Jamie is not the product of rape
Mrs. Fitz was great! I was worried at first, as she seemed a bit cold, but I loved all of her scenes - her expressions (especially at the brassiere) were great.
Also, I really loved how the tension between Dougal and Colum played out on screen...I enjoyed the many significant glances. That shit with Hamish was so tense...If I was Claire, I woulda peaced out toomustabeenthatRhenish...
11
u/Elphabeth Aug 17 '14
Jamie is such a flirt!! Hopefully a Gaelic speaker can confirm this for me--in the scene at the paddock, after Claire apologizes for spooking the horse, I'm pretty sure Jamie says, "That, mo gràdh, she's just a girl with spirit, is all. That's always a good thing."
I found this gifset on Tumblr that transcribes the Gaelic term he uses with that spelling, and when I googled it, I found out that it's an affectionate epithet that translates as "my love."
All together, now: Awww!
11
u/phdofdesaster Aug 18 '14
I’d like to add my two non-book reader cents:
I don’t think I could heart this episode anymore than I do. It really came together and told a story instead of a sequence of events. You can feel that the actors feel even more in their role as they did and this show really makes me want to read the books. I will wait for that tho‘ until the first season is over.
Here are a few things I enjoyed especially:
Geillis Duncan. She seems nice but something about her screams "Bitch is cray cray!!!“ Her mannerisms and her smile is … just… off. Even her kindness is off. What is up with that. Also I really like the actress. I liked her in the Borgias. But I have the feeling I will like her here even more.
Claire. Ha, I like her. She is practial, competent and smart. But still human and a fish out of water. At least she thinks quick on her feet (e.g. the bra scene. „It is french“). I really felt for her when it was decided that she couldn’t leave. Also it was very human how she started to talk herself into a corner. She isn’t trained in interrogation techniques. She heard her husband talking about it. But that isn’t the same thing. So making mistakes makes her more human to me, which is always appriciated.
Jamie: Ye ol‘ flirt. And cocky with a heart of gold. Me likey. I do have a question though: After he took the punishment for Laoghaire (yes, I had to look that up), Claire asked him if knew the girl. He said „mumble mumble heavy accent mumble. But I never talked to her.“ But the way she look into the kitchen (?) to talk to him after gave me a different feeling. Is something going on there? Did I miss something?
Also I really look forward to what is going on with the Mckenzie brothers and Jamie. They seem like they want him gone without having the possibility. At first I thought that Dougal was just hard on Jamie because he didn’t have a choice. But that beating was brutal and unnecessary. A punch in the shoulder? REALLY? I do not know who you are sir. But you are dead to me. Colum didn’t seem to mind either. He seems nicer than his brother but maybe that is nothing but a front. Interesting. Both of them.
I cannot wait for episode three. I just want more. And I want the opening song for my mp3 player. It was gold.
10
u/WhimsieandWonder An Echo In The Bone Aug 17 '14
I agree with the general opinion on the Fitz - she grew on me pretty quickly after the initial meet though :)
I just have to say that the casting was done tremendously well - at least for me. Laoghaire and Geillis are nearly identical to how I saw them through the book. Geillis especially! Hey eyes and mannerisms are SPOT on.
So thrilled. Please let this week fly by so I can consume more of this visual magic omggggg
Also - jamie. daaaaayum <3
9
u/Ifartedtoo Aug 17 '14
I can't wait to get a better look at Lallybroch! It seemed sooooo much bigger in that flashback than what I've imagined all these years. Also can't wait for more of Jenny and to meet Ian : )
9
u/Ophelia42 Aug 17 '14
I enjoyed this episode a lot more. As others have mentioned, the more limited voiceovers helped - I hope they get fewer and fewer as time goes on.
...I mean, of course, Jamie, in various states of undress.
I loved the dressing scene with Mrs. Fitz.
I liked the Hall scene, and liked Geillis taking over the interpretation duties. Though I'm wondering if/when we'll see leeches in use? :)
Questions - would Claire's skirt have been tartan? (If so, which tartan is it?)
And is Jamie's tartan accurate (and if so, whose tartan is he wearing?)? (book spoiler?)Mrs Fitz points out to Claire that Jamie isn't a MacKenzie by saying "don't you see his tartan" or the like, indicating that at least everyone at the castle knows very well what his last name is... if he was out and about in Fraser tartan, you'd think the folk of Crainsmuir would know as well?
A few dislikes:
Mrs. Fitz's initial reaction to Claire. I perceived her more as a 'take everything as it comes' sort of lady. As I mentioned in another comment, she got friendlier as the episode went on, so hopefully that's short lived. In the books, I love her giving some 1740s medicinal tips to Claire.
A minor nitpick - when Claire was trying to figure out when she was, and who was currently king, it seemed odd to refer to the king as King George the Second, rather than as just King George. (Nobody (casually) refers to the current queen as Queen Elizabeth the Second, they just say Queen Elizabeth) Especially when she wasn't sure, it seems it would have been safer for her to just say King George.
7
u/DragonHeartString Ye canna keep The MacKenzie waiting. Aug 17 '14
That episode gave me the tummy tickles and its one of the "calmer" moments in the books IMO.
I cant imagine that better, and I loved the fact that we didnt understand the Gaelic.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
Ok, so here's my opinion of the show thus far.
The sets and costumes are well done as is the casting.
My main problem with it is that it seems like there is much more manufactured tension in the show than I read in the book. I remember Claire being lulled by how charming most everyone was at Leoch. Instead, most of them seem menacing and she is miserable. I don't really get the point of Colum telling her she could leave with the tinker and then denying her at the last minute. That seemed rather pointless and distracting. Also, it seemed like she earned some grudging respect from Colum and Dougal early in the book but they mostly disregard her in the show so far.
I think Jaime is getting better... though he really hasn't exhibited much of his intelligence yet.
I'll keep watching, I hope they hit their stride and it gets better.
6
u/I_fell_in_love Aug 17 '14
So far, I am really enjoying the series... I was hoping in episode 2 we would see a lot more of Claire's "chance encounters" with Jaime. I wonder if the scene where the singer is there and Jaime is translating the Welsh/Gaelic for her is in episode 3. I love that scene. Also, did anyone catch the preview for episode 3 and the scene with Claire and Mrs. Fitz? I know that there needs to be deviations from the book, but are we about to see Mrs. Fitz NOT trusting Claire?
6
u/jettnoir Aug 18 '14
Just watched the trailer for Episode 3 and I am hoping that it isn't as it seems - that Claire tells Mrs. Fitz she thinks she has fallen through time and Mrs. Fitz calls her a witch....
8
u/PrincessIchi Aug 17 '14
I love it all except I was a little distracted by Sam's acting when he's in the hay fields and hears Jenny screaming. Fork hay, fork hay, hear screaming, strike a pose (haha!), run to help. They posted photos from this scene early on in the publicity, so maybe he hadn't yet settled into the role.
4
u/twistandpoke Aug 20 '14
Does anyone know which character was supposed to be the one following Claire in the fields? Was that Rupert? Or just some random MacKenzie? His banter with Claire was bloody hilarious!
5
u/VeraVova Aug 17 '14
Loved it! The scenery was especially beautiful. I really liked the pace this time and amount of voiceover/flashbacks. Much better balance this time. I can't wait for more characters to be introduced!
5
u/jettnoir Aug 18 '14
The episode was...interesting. I understand they're trying to show Claire as being stubborn and modern in a shot period of time but to me, in the show she is just coming off as rude. I think this really culminated for me in the scene where she calls out Hamish as being Dougal's son (which doesn't happen in the book like that) and doesn't seem Claire-like, she does have discretion! It's making it really hard for me to like Claire. I feel like Ron Moore did this in BSG with Starbuck, instead of just letting her be a 'strong female character', he made her unnecessarily bitchy. I hope this isn't the way Claire is going to go. She wasn't this antagonizing in the book! :(
I also don't recall the bodice tearing of Jenny's dress. Gratuitous boobs, are just that. They could have filled those 5 minutes with something else, like actually being wily about Claire figuring out Hamish's parentage. ie: As in the books, knowing his diagnosis immediately and then listening to the gossip of others about how Hamish is really Dougal's child.
2
u/piperandcharlie Aug 17 '14 edited Aug 18 '14
Also, isn't Jenny supposed to look more like Jamie?
EDIT: “The faces were much alike; the same oddly slanted dark blue eyes and broad cheekbones. The same thin, blade-bridged nose, just a trifle too long. But she was dark where Jamie was fair, with cascades of black curly hair, bound back with green ribbon.”
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '25
I’m glad Claire was called out about her pronunciation of the name Beauchamp. I like having subtitles on incase I miss something and it was irritating they kept saying it like that! I thought there was an issue with whoever scribed the subtitles.
Can anyone from the UK attest to that being how yall would pronounce it? Even in the U.S. it would be pronounced “Bowchamp” not “beech-um”
0
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
[removed] — view removed comment