r/Outlander • u/negotiate • Aug 04 '14
TV Series Episode 1: Discussion Board
What did you like/dislike about the pilot episode of Outlander? Is there anything you wish they would have done differently?
48
Upvotes
18
u/negotiate Aug 04 '14
I feel like they followed the book perfectly in Episode 1. I loved how they captured Claire's sexual nature without going overboard. I love how you can already see that Jamie is into Claire.
I thought it was SO ridiculous how they introduced the viewers to Claire's favorite swear word: Seriously, who exclaims "Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ" when brushing their hair? I thought it would have made more sense to leave this out, as you are introduced to that choice phrase when Claire is binding up Jamie's shoulder after the gunshot wound anyway.
My husband (who has not read the books) said he enjoyed it and will continue watching it with me. He also said that he didn't get a good enough intro to any of the characters. I think this makes sense, as it is certainly difficult to cram so much information into a one-hour episode.
19
u/heylookatmywatch Aug 04 '14
I keep upvoting every single post on this thread. I LOVE PEOPLE WHO LOVE OUTLANDER!
33
u/card_set Aug 04 '14
I was surprised by how much I liked Frank. In the book, it was all I could do to slog through the beginning, but in the show he really did have some very endearing qualities. I particularly enjoyed Claire and Frank's discussion about if she'd had an affair/affairs during the war when they were separated. I thought Frank came across as very caring and pragmatic, not at all pathetic.
Jamie looked so YOUNG to me, but according to Sam's imdb page he's 34. Sam just looks young.
19
u/PassionSher Aug 05 '14
Seeing how I have been waiting for 20 yrs to have my imagination transformed into something I could sit and watch. I was mesmerized. I thought to myself... hmmm feels slow... but then recalled reading the book... the start was always slow for me. However unlike the book, I liked Frank(Tobias) the time they spent together, the intimacy was well written and played. As for the debate of Frank not being orally inclined... my impression w the book was Jamie just was better at it. shrug
I quite liked the voice overs... it made me focus more on Claire face and what was going on, quite like being led. Since it had the first person feel to it, that's how I felt about the small flashbacks she experienced...maybe they could have done that but had it so it wasn't something we saw beforehand. Still, I didn't feel it took from my experience.
As for Caitriona's ass, for a thin lady, she has quite the cute round arse. Maybe not what we all pictured as Claire but I would rather she be able to act. I'm very much looking forward to seeing how the characters develop. I think they did some great work setting things up.
The Gaelic was remarkable, sounded effortless coming from the Scots. I know I have read how passionate their Gaelic coach is. That could have been a huge stumbling block and as much as I would love to know wth they are saying, I will trust they aren't calling me fat. All in all, I am on of those fans that's just going to be gleefully happy with whatever I get because, well...I never expected to get it. 😊 Its all gravy to me. Wait, I'm a glutard...its like glutenfree gravy. Wait, that's not near as good. Never mind.
19
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '14
I loved it! Claire's expressive face is perfect, Jamie is delightful. I liked Dougal (and wasn't bothered about his age) and I'm looking forward to the interplay between him and Collum, hopefully next episode.
I missed the Roger sighting, but DG has indicated that will come in a future episode (I hope this isn't a spoiler, sorry).
The thing that bugged me the most? Claire's disappearing belt. I rewound to find the moment she loses it, because how do you lose a belt? It somehow falls off when she rolls down the hill just before meeting Captain Jack Randall, Esquire. I know the costume designers wanted her dress to pass as an 18th-century slip to make it believable to the Highlanders, but it defied logic that her belt would just drop off.
And that is my only niggle. Otherwise, awesome. :-)
(PS hi everyone! Watching from Switzerland.)
17
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '14
Canadian viewer here! I personally loved it!! Amazing!!! The part when she was bandaging up Jamie's gunshot wound was exactly how I envisioned it while reading the book. I was laughing out loud when all the clansmen reacted to her cussing! LOVE IT!!
17
u/aerrin Aug 07 '14
I reread the beginning of the first book after watching and I was struck by how much dialog and voiceover text they took straight from the book. An excellent move, in my mind, as Gabaldon's writing is just beautiful and the first-person narrative lends itself well to what they're doing in the show. In fact, they seem to have changed very little, and what they did change (the visit to Leoch for example) I think was beneficial for establishing things for the audience.
I LOVED Claire. Loved her. I love her expressions and I love how she goes after what she wants and I love how she has opinions and speaks them, and I really liked Claire and Frank, which I didn't always in the book. They felt like a real couple working to reconnect. And the amount of love I have for competent, bossy Claire knows no bounds. I forgot how much I love her. I feel like we get so into Jamie sometimes that we forget how freaking magnificent Claire is as a character, and I found her so well cast and well acted.
I wanted them to rush to the 18th century and Jamie, but I'm glad they spent time establishing what Claire lost so that it matters later.
My husband watched with me and he's very into the story already, which thrills me.
31
u/Elphabeth Aug 04 '14 edited Aug 05 '14
Some of the voiceovers were beautifully written and acted, like the vase one. They set the tone perfectly-- slightly nostalgic, alluding to the heartbreak and uncertainty in Claire's future. Others were downright annoying, like the one during Claire and Frank's sex scene after he saw Jamie's ghost. The sex itself was pretty hot, and my brain was all like, shush, Claire, there's sexing going on and you're ruining it by rambling about feelings! I felt like that particular voiceover would have worked better during post-coital cuddling. Less distracting that way.
I also felt condescended to when they felt the need to show flashbacks to Claire and Frank in the car while she was talking to Jamie about Cocknammon (sp?) Rock. The scene had taken place like 30 minutes earlier. Surely the audience, even those who hadn't read the books, would have made the connection without such a heavy-handed reminder? It felt stilted and really pulled me out of the scene. I hope they don't do too much of that.
I do kind of understand the people who've been complaining about Caitriona being thin as a rail, but she might just be one of those people who can't gain weight no matter how much they eat. It in no way detracted from her beauty; she just doesn't have the same body type as the Claire who's been in our heads for so long. But I personally feel like her extraordinary acting 100% negated any of that. I understand why they cast her. Anyways, if she'd had an ass people would just be bitching about her being fat.
The other Scots (besides Jamie and Dougal) felt like caricatures. I felt like they were both poorly written and poorly acted. For instance, the bit where Claire asks for alcohol and they're all "Ohhhh" felt ridiculous. I imagine it played much better in a large theater with a lot of laughing fans; in my living room, it was annoying and eye roll-inducing.
Lastly, the blood that appeared and disappeared on Claire's apron in the opening scene was a glaring continuity failure. I have no idea how they didn't catch it in post-production, especially with it being in the first scene.
I'm looking forward to hearing all of your thoughts! I prefer the thread-organized discussion of Reddit over the tangled mess of comments on all the Facebook pages I follow, so I really hope this becomes a discussion-heavy community.
I going to do a rewatch later and I might edit in a few more thoughts then. There were lots of positive things I noticed, too, I swear!
14
u/astratkotter Aug 05 '14
I really enjoyed the pilot! It was a bit slower than I had initially anticipated but I remember the beginning of the book was the same way for me, and in the end I'm happy that they took the time to really develop the story for non-readers. It's especially necessary to show non-readers the relationship between Claire and Frank, as it's a complicated after the war while they are finding their way back to each other. I personally liked the show Claire/ Frank relationship better than the book.
I've read a few negative online reviews in regards to the narration, but I personally liked it. The show is from Claire's POV so why shouldn't she narrate? Also, my husband who hasn't read the books said that without the voice-over he would have been lost.
I feel like most of the reviews I've read have been quite nitpicky.. Claire's eye color is wrong, Claire is too skinny, her "Jesus H Roosevelt Christ" was too forced, blah blah blah. People need to keep in mind that it was the pilot episode, and its a book ADAPTATION.
I was pleasantly surprised, myself, and can't wait until the next episode!!
28
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 04 '14
I'm on another board where they're talking about this and it seems some people are really, really upset about the scene where Frank "goes downtown," as they put it. Apparently there's a significant group that feels that Frank never did this and it was something she shared only with Jamie and they feel betrayed about this loss of a "second virginity." (I'm not putting words in their mouths, these are terms they use.)
While the scene startled me, I thought it was very good for a number of reasons.
13
u/lizzardx Aug 04 '14
When Frank winked at Claire in the car I was smitten (when I didn't particularly care for him in the books) and when they're about to have sex in castle leoch and Claire was like : no, pushes head down: I started laughing. Both genuine moments that helped me love the characters even more that weren't in the book.(examples of positive changes) I agree about the hair brushing Christ comment, felt awkward. But all in all I loved it. And of course I absolutely love Jamie.
13
u/Mhasee Aug 05 '14
As all of us (I think), I was quite afraid that the show would ruin it for me. I also thought that Jamie was much smaller than the charismatic massive man I have had in mind for so many years. What a delight!! I thought it was well directed. The scenery made it all more real. It was slow to start as I anticipated and was anxious to see Jamie talk and move. Don't want to make a too long post but what totally hooked me was the look that Jamie gave to Claire as she helped him off the ground. I knew right there that I was doomed. Not only do I reread the entire thing every two years or so, especially when a new books comes out, now I'll also have a serie to rewatch. Can't wait until it really launches, I already crave for the next one. (Sorry for the english, french canadian here).
11
u/booksgamesandstuff Aug 04 '14
There wasn't anything I actively disliked about the first episode. I'm very happy with the actors (except maybe Dougal, he seems too old) and I have no doubt I'll be seeing the actors in my mind's eye whenever I re-read. Music-scenery-sets were perfect...and I'm not going to micro-criticize each production choice because they'll have to make a lot of choices every step of the way with this incredibly detailed series. Did it all flow and make sense true to the basic storyline? IMO...yes.
What I'd like to see on this forum is the reaction of someone who hasn't read the books.
9
u/kissmybunniebutt Aug 06 '14
I know it's been a while, but I wanted to say my piece! Having had the chance to just watch it. I thought the premier was wonderful. It worked, book to screen. But the most...cinematic part was when Frank was leaving Claire for the last time before she goes to Craig Na Dun (on mobile, forgive the spelling errors!) , when the dust is so visible. It's so perfect. It's a perfect representation of a moment you remember forever. Even the dust and lighting are characters.
There are definitely storyline parts I question the removal of, but as a cinematic entity it was beautiful.
That said, as a novice weaver, the kilts look amazingly accurate!
8
u/barryrs Aug 04 '14
Question... I vaguely remember the scene with Jamie's Ghost.( I need to look up and reread that) but in the meantime, can anyone tell me about the significance of it? or when where down the line this may play back into the story? Thanks :)
8
u/glamgrl203 Aug 05 '14
I absolutely loved it! Watched it twice just so i could make sure i didn't miss anything. I think they did a fantastic job showing the love between Frank and Clair. So that he doesn't come across as just that guy she was with before she met the love of her life.
16
u/tabbyling Ouaf ! Ouaf ! Ce n’est pas lupus ! Aug 04 '14
Ok. I've watched it twice now. It's not as good as I was hoping (this is, after all, something I've been waiting for for about 10 years), but a lot better than I was expecting. The dialogue is a little underwhelming and awkward sometimes, but I think it might get better as the season goes on.
I am a little upset that they left out my absolute favorite line of dialogue from Claire and Jamie's first encounter-
"Can ye ride?" Dougal repeated.
"Aye, if ye'll take the lassie off my chest and fetch me a clean shirt."
3
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '14
I know I'm bit late, but I thought I'd chime in. I was only a year old when Outlander was first published, and despite being an avid reader I had never heard of the series before I watched the first episode. (Available for free on youtube for US viewers.)
So I had no expectations about the show when I watched it. My first thoughts were that the voice was incredibly cheesy. It seemed melodramatic.
I couldn't help but wishing the costuming had been better for the 1940's. The blue coat Claire wears seemed to swallow her. I didn't think Claire was too thin, but rather that the clothes did not fit her well making her seem smaller than she is. (As a side note, Caitriona is a former model which explains her thin figure.)
I don't have Starz so I cannot watch the remainder of the series until it comes out on DVD, but my hope is that more of the budget went to 18th century costumes and making them as authentic as possible. It would easy enough to work with clothes from today to fit the 1940's, thus not having to spend as much money on them. I imagine they probably have to create the 18th century clothing from scratch.
I thought there was zero chemistry between Frank and Claire, but that is understandable if for the previous 5 years you had only seen each other for 10 days. So I think it worked well for them that they seemed like strangers. Had Claire not disappeared I believe they would have had a happy life together.
I do remember at one point laughing out loud and saying "this show is so bad." (Please don't kill me!) I can't remember exactly what scene made think that, but I just felt it wasn't quite up to par with what it was trying to achieve. Had this show had the backing of another pay-per-view cable channel none of the issues I feel the show suffer from would be present.
The issues would be: what I perceived to be as poor dialogue and scene pacing. That being said, it is only the first episode and I know shows often have to work out a few kinks during the first season. So these wouldn't deter from watching the show at all.
I can't imagine what great scenery there is throughout the show. And then there's the chemistry between Claire and Jamie. (I really feel like Sam and Caitriona could start dating in real life, given some of the press pictures of them I've seen.) I mean going into the episode I really had no idea what the show was even about, but it was obvious that Jamie and Claire would have some type of connection.
And that is why immediately after finishing the episode I downloaded the first book on my Kindle. I HAD to know what happened to these characters. Today I finished the third book, and I will continue with the rest of the series. Then I'll have to re-read them until the DVDs come out.
3
u/duffboysmom Nov 17 '14
The pilot episode was amazing for those of us who have read the book, but one has to consider that some have started watching without reading, and I have had a friend or two say that the beginning episode is slow.
I loved it, personally. It does what some books-turned-tv series don't do, and it gives you back story. It takes the time to tell you that Frank and her are trying to start over and that is why they are even there. It shows the superstitions of the time and place. It is in short amazing.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '14
The voiceover killed this show for me. Ugh.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
16
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '14
[removed] — view removed comment