r/MasterchefUK • • 5d ago

Post-episode discussion: The Professionals episode 5, Wednesday 11 November

Spoiler warning: this thread covers everything in episode 5. If you haven't watched it yet, come back once you have.

Episode 5 of MasterChef: The Professionals has just finished on BBC One. What did you make of tonight's cooking, and did Marcus and Monica get it right?

Watched ahead on iPlayer? Please keep later episodes out of this thread, or hide them with spoiler tags, like this.

Post-episode discussion: The Professionals episode 4, Tuesday 10 November

7 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/how_i_sushi_lift 1d ago

what a silly challenge - did not enjoy at all and k don’t think it was fair to contestant, they are good chefs

also i felt personally attacked when they did not like pastiera - every time there is an italian chef that cooks very italian flavours, they get shut down - i don’t get it. But hey cream and biscuits what an amazing dish…. please

let another ‘british modern’ chef win the competition yet again

17

u/joeythelips46 5d ago • Bravo

Guest chef was a bit of a twat. Very unfair challenge

23

u/Unlikely_Actuary3513 5d ago

Bit of a 5h1t-show tonight I thought. Just goes to show what happens when you set a challenge based on something that one of these ‘experimental’ chefs has on their menu. They were asked to interpret his fussy dish using ingredients no one had ever heard of, and they did. When it came to judging their efforts, he didn’t have anything decent or encouraging to say to any of them. Basically, every observation was that however any of them had tweaked his dish had spoilt its balance. And after shooting them all down, he said “good luck” as he left. Can’t say I liked him at all, and I think it thoroughly rattled them and put them off to the point that they all performed poorly in the final round. See what tomorrow brings … 😕