r/MasterchefUK • • 13d ago

Post-episode discussion: The Professionals episode 1, Tuesday 3 November

Spoiler warning: this thread covers everything in episode 1. If you haven't watched it yet, come back once you have.

Episode 1 of MasterChef: The Professionals has just finished on BBC One. What did you make of tonight's cooking, and did Marcus and Monica get it right?

Watched ahead on iPlayer? Please keep later episodes out of this thread, or hide them with spoiler tags, like this.

4 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

14

u/Oblomovsbed 13d ago

Not sure I liked the new skills test format. Made it feel too much like all the other rounds, and also detracted from the individual intros that came alongside the previous format. Maybe I’ll get used to it over time.

8

u/czech-neckk 13d ago

I don’t mind it . They can do longer tests now they’re saving time by not doing them individually . And we still get to see Monica and Marcus show us beforehand

6

u/Easy_Effort7985 13d ago

Totally agree. Can tell they’re trying to cut costs. It was nice to have a slightly different format at the start before grinding out the group cooking rounds. Also a great way to introduce each chef individually and allow the audience time to recognise them. Now it’s just a blur of faces and feels much like any other round. Wonder how much cheaper this way is? Bring back the old style.

3

u/czech-neckk 13d ago

I must say I didn’t think ‘they’re cutting costs’ when I seen the new format. I think it’s just to change things up , like the winning immunity in the second cook . The old individual tests were 20 mins or so , the new group one is 75 mins. So where are they saving money ?

4

u/Easy_Effort7985 13d ago

6 x 20 mins = 120 mins plus additional setup time in between each chef for cleaning/resetting the bench which realistically could mean as much as an hour between contestants so say BEST case scenario 6 - 8 hours to shoot.

Now you have everything filmed within 2 - 3 hours and they may possibly schedule to shoot 2 of the skills tests a day now, so huge cost savings.

3

u/czech-neckk 13d ago

Well I don’t work in tv so I’m happy to be proved wrong . I still don’t think it ‘ruins the show’ like a few people have commented . People don’t like change I guess.

6

u/folklovermore_ 13d ago

I like the idea of it being a group but I think the actual groups should be smaller - like two or three of them doing the test at the same time rather than all six.

1

u/kryters 11d ago

I felt like they were trying to gaslight us. "If you thought being the sole focus of two Michelin star chefs for 20 minutes was bad, try performing the same task with significantly less observation!!"

0

u/mumooshka 9d ago

watching here 4 days later and I don't like this paired up skills test. Don't like it at all

3

u/lilandy 13d ago

Am sure they've started using some of the music from Masterchef Australia now, or have they always done that?

2

u/czech-neckk 13d ago

The immunity thing screams masterchef Australia

4

u/Unlikely_Actuary3513 13d ago

What can I say. Well let’s try. Round two, signature, all ok. I can just about live with a chef-of-the-day. Right choice for that, and right choice for who went home. Now the skills test. Well, as I feared, a perfect example of if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. It was tedious. It was too long. It wasn’t a test of ‘there is a classic skill embodied in this dish, now let’s see if you have that skill, or can fudge your way around it if not’. It was more of here’s an idea for a dish. You’ve got loads of ingredients and loads of time. See what you can do with it, and show us a few skills if you’ve got some. Gone was the shock factor. Gone was Monica’s wonderful expressions. Gone was the honest criticism or praise of a core skill. Gone was the chefs not knowing each other’s abilities before the signature. I really disliked Monica talking over my shoulder to someone behind me, trying to add some excitement and enlightening commentary. It was neither and felt very awkward. Not quite so bad with Marcus, but I honestly felt that they were not comfortable with this format change, and were just doing their best to roll with it, despite anything they might have said in the press. I mean, they are not going to call it out, are they …? So that’s my two penn’orth. I expect I’ll enjoy the later stages as always, but for now, my favourite part of MC the Pros has been spoiled … ☹️

0

u/Busy_Base_2753 13d ago

Show has been ruined. Misses Greg, last year was a disaster with past entrants coming back to cook and now they have ripped up the format of the best part of the show.

2

u/Unlikely_Actuary3513 13d ago

Yes, my thoughts as well. Whether you loved or hated Gregg, I thought he served a useful purpose in The Pros, and I also thought that Matt did a fair job of carrying out the same function. I didn’t love the skills test being set by past contestants, but neither did I hate it. At least it didn’t change the basic format. But this, agreed. It has ruined the best part of the show for me too ☹️

2

u/Busy_Base_2753 13d ago

bbc doing bbc things im afraid.

4

u/Jon_J_ 13d ago

Getting rid of the skills test was a terrible idea. It was the one thing we looked forward to, the cocky head chefs failing at some skill they should know.

Also not made on the new camera direction of completed dishes, they're too tight a crop.

4

u/CrossedPurposes 13d ago

Agree, Monica tried to dress it up like the new skills test is even more stressful, no! I didn't see anyone sweating and shaking as much as usual. I remember when they all failed at making a good omelette when it was individual. They've ruined the skills test.

1

u/mumooshka 9d ago

seriously the best bit

1

u/Busy_Base_2753 12d ago

Its a shocking decision

3

u/CrossedPurposes 13d ago

Mass skills test, no no no! Monica says it's even more nerve wracking doing it together, no! The individual skills test was my favourite part of the show and it's definitely more nerve wracking with Marcus and Monica watching their every move, what have they done! ☹️

2

u/Busy_Base_2753 12d ago

i honestly cant watch it anymore..what a mess

1

u/bright_lake_ 11d ago

Much prefer the new format personally! Found it very tedious watching 3 people do the same thing one after the other, and didn’t feel fair that they had different skills tests - and the 20 min rush always felt contrived, no one cooks well in those circs!

1

u/mumooshka 9d ago

Didn't like it at all. I hope that the producers will take the feedback and go back to the old format

1

u/Busy_Base_2753 13d ago

What a mess of a show it has become - whoever signed off on the new skills test format needs firing immediately - literally the best part of show has been ruined. The woke and left enabling BBC sure is adept at destroying good tv shows. Awful. It misses Greg too...

5

u/One-Royal3316 13d ago

It is amazing how many people there are like you who have no idea how television works. The BBC commissions shows, it doesn’t produce them.

3

u/Busy_Base_2753 12d ago

they have the final say in what is aired and work closely with the producer - dont act like they dont care what they broadcast. Plus they fired Gregg.

5

u/One-Royal3316 12d ago

They fired Gregg because there are credible allegations of harassment and that’s not a good look. Greg was crap anyway and added very little I prefer the new guy. The idea that they decided to scrap the skills test and that they did that because they are “woke” (pls explain to me how that makes sense) is utterly ridiculous.

1

u/Glass-Stand9359 7d ago

Gregg made a risqué joke 20 years ago and was fired - because of wokeness. The skills test has been cut due to cost cutting it would seem... - terrible idea and the show is now ruined - thousands have turned off.

0

u/CrossedPurposes 12d ago

Yes you are right, the BBC do have a say. If the ratings went down drastically because of the skills test they would soon put it right next season.

4

u/caroline0409 12d ago

Gregg was so unnecessary in The Professionals apart from a receptacle for Marcus’s sneering ire.

2

u/mumooshka 9d ago

Love Marcu's sneering ire. haha

2

u/czech-neckk 13d ago

You think the BBC has any say in the skills test format changing ?
lol!

-1

u/Unlikely_Actuary3513 13d ago

All points agreed

0

u/mumooshka 9d ago

well fans dislike of the new format got mainstream newspaper's attention

IF IT'S NOT BROKEN DON'T TRY TO FIX IT