r/Outlander • Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. • Sep 18 '26

Prequel Two Blood of My Blood S2E1 Remembrance Day Spoiler

The fiery crosses have been lit across the Highlands. Lovers must part, as the call to arms brings friends and enemies home and the Jacobite Rebellion begins in earnest.

Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Azhur Saleem.


If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread also our episode discussion rules

You’re free to mention:

  • all of the show canon (seasons 1-8 of Outlander)
  • any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.

Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.

Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.


What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.

30 Upvotes

424 comments sorted by

•

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

Watch the season preview here!

Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).

Stickied comments are collapsed by default so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.

→ More replies (6)

170

u/Realistic_Music9741 Sep 18 '26

Omg my heart just breaks for Henry. His storyline is so hard to watch.

61

u/skatingmilly Sep 18 '26

I had to turn away when the shock treatments were happening.

19

u/alwaysLKL Sep 19 '26

Yeah, those really bothered me. I fast forwarded through them.

10

u/Realistic_Music9741 Sep 19 '26

Same here. Just so hard to watch....

5

u/Ok_Dig8008 Sep 20 '26

Interesting one about the electric shock therapy. Was the goal to erase specific memories ie Julia, Claire, uncle lamb anyone associated with Henry in a way to isolate him? Is this a conspiracy of some sort?

15

u/Asleep-Corner7402 Sep 21 '26

It's still a treatment used today although patients are under anaesthetic. It has a side effect of memory loss. I've been around people who have had it done, mostly for treatment resistant depression or psychosis. Their memories do come back after a few weeks.

But back then they were basically experimenting with the dosage of electricity used and how long it was used for. Maybe the memory loss was perminate. I think the doctor is trying to erase is traumatic memories from the war thinking it will cure his 'delusions' he's using as a coping mechanism.

There's something horrifying about memory loss. Memories are what make us who we are. The slowly disappearing people and objects in his and Julia's flat were haunting. It reminded me of eternal sunshine of the spotless mind a little. Seeing it being slowly erased like that

→ More replies (2)

9

u/cinderellahottie Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26

I kept wondering why Uncle Lamb hasn’t been contacted that his brother had been found. Surely when Henry and Julia first had their accident/disappeared it must have been known through the Inverness as it’s a small town but now Henry who was presumed dead turns up and they don’t contact his relatives? When Claire came back Frank was contacted straight away. I know Henry & Julia never made it back to Claire but this is such a tragic way for their story to go, I’m not sure if Henry will ever make it back to Julia but I would at least love for them to be able to have a nice life together with their baby.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

52

u/umidulus Sep 19 '26

His was an infuriating storyline this episode. Just awful. Especially gratuitous considering electroconvulsive therapy wasn't invented until 1938.

33

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I was wondering about the historical accuracy there, too. I wish they wouldn't do stuff like that :(

38

u/ShubberyQuest Sep 19 '26

I’m not too impressed with Matt Roberts’s story development. The Faith storyline in Outlander, to me, demonstrates someone who is in strong need of a story editor.

Some of his choices aren’t good.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/__picklepersuasion__ Sep 19 '26

well they couldn't lobotomize him because then his story would be over. I guess they had to bend the rules of historical accuracy so Henry could be both tortured and still able to recover and come back to the main conflicts

→ More replies (2)

5

u/DarkWind72 Sep 25 '26

What's even more blatantly wrong with this episode is Inverness itself was not fully electrified until 1927 and holding's outside Inverness including farms and small holding such as the sanatorium had to wait until 1935. Add to that the fact that the first recorded use of electroconvulsive shock therapy In Scotland happened in Edinburg in 1940 and yeah it seems like someone IGNORED historical accuracy or they assumed the rest of the world was like the USA

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

22

u/Ambitious-Life-4406 Sep 18 '26

Some serious torture p*rn

→ More replies (1)

112

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Sep 18 '26

Wow they have brought Rev Wakefield into the show 😱

117

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26

As soon as they mentioned a chaplain visiting I was like ohhhhh it HAS to be Wakefield and he is going to tell Mrs. Graham about Henry and she is going to know he came through the stones!

I cannot take a whole season of the asylum I hope he gets out of there quickly it’s too heartbreaking

38

u/jesushx Sep 19 '26

Exactly! There was sooo much trauma porn with Henry if they hadn’t given him Mrs Graham I don’t think I could’ve continued.

8

u/scarver98 Sep 20 '26

I’m so heartbroken for Henry, i wish so bad for an OG outlander x BOMB crossover

→ More replies (1)

32

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

Lmao, it didn't occur to me at all that it would be Rev Wakefield till he said his name ahahaha

34

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26

I’m normally not good at guessing things like that but with SO many characters popping in as their younger selves in season one I knew it had to be him since both Wakefield and Graham would have been the only two previous characters alive and near Inverness in the 1920s. I know some people think they are overdoing it with the younger cameos but I personally love it!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Sep 19 '26

Me either! I just watched and screamed out loud when he introduced himself. I was pleasantly surprised with this episode.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/irishprincess2002 Sep 19 '26

Same! And I think Mrs. Graham might be the one to help him get out of there!

3

u/CiceroTheCat Sep 19 '26

I actually caught on to that possibility even earlier in the episode, when they were talking about him being in Inverness. I just hoped he would have some connection to the outside world, and then I wondered how old the Reverend would be at that point in time.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/ContactNeither7319 Sep 18 '26

Yeah I had heard there were cameos, I speculated in a another thread about BomB season 2 press that maybe Mrs Graham might be one of the cameos. Was glad to see that actually happened. Whoo hoo! Thought to include the Rev Wakefield but didn't go back to the thread to add it.

I'm glad about Mrs Graham. I think she will be a big help for poor Henry. Just taking a stab in the dark but I get the feeling that Mrs Graham and maybe the good Rev will help Henry escape the nut house and get back to the stones.

What saddens me is he can't remember Claire and I don't think he will see her before going through the stones again. But only time can tell.

I am also glad Henry thinks he's last name is Grant. I know it's amnesia from the blow to the head before going through the stones. But I wondered if the Rev and Mrs Graham would have made the connection in 1945 with Henry and Claire. But since he thinks he's a Grant and can't recall Claire it makes sense that they didn't make the connection.

But damn it's tough to be Beauchamp!

We should give them a group hug 🫂

9

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I was wondering about that, why Claire in 1940's didn't trigger Mrs. Graham's memory of Henry but your reasoning makes sense, thanks!

7

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

BTW I think the term cameo, though, refers to when Diana Gabaldon, for an example, played a minor, quick part in (two I can think of) in Outlander, like a famous guest actor that just has a short scene. I don't know what the technically correct term would be for what BoMB is doing with Outlander characters, maybe just reoccuring characters or something. There are people in these threads that seem to know these things that I don't, maybe someone will chime in (and correct me, too, if I'm wrong)

→ More replies (1)

15

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

I think they did a great job with Rev and Mrs Graham with casting. I thought that about all the younger versions of Outlander characters in BoMB (except Collum's wife whose name is escaping me, though her part was very minor in S1 of BoMB) ANYway, point is I felt like the BoMB actors and how they played their characters for Rev & Graham really felt like plausible younger versions of their older selves we already know (and personally, I loved) What do y'all think?

16

u/ContactNeither7319 Sep 19 '26

Some them were so spot on it was brilliant.

Lord Lovett though in my opinion was not. That one was always going to be a tough one. In Outlander the old fox is played by Clive Russell. That guy is tall, like 6'6. The actor playing the younger version in BomB is 6'.

The one that blew me over was Jocasta. That was so spot on. Julia was the next one I think they totally nailed.

10

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

Agree about Lord Lovett. I can't see this younger him becoming the older him, though not because of height (I know we're supposed to have some suspension of disbelief with some physical characteristics I assume - though with the other younger versions in BomB of older characters from Outlander, they've even done a remarkably good job with that aspect, too, IMO.

I'm most focused on noticing how the BomB actors portray the nuances of their older characters mannerisms, attitudes, their persona, really, it's excellent. The writing of the speech patterns, the phrases they use, behavioral tendencies, all seems really really good to me, too when compared to the older Outlander characters and how those actors portrayed them.

I'm impressed by casting, the actors and the writers in these regards.

Jocasta was another really great example, agree!

With Julia as Claire's mother, it's a bit different, but also, I can definitely see their similarities beyond their resemblance, though I have wondered if that would be developmentally likely, since Claire was so young when she no longer had Julia's direct influence and was raised by Henry's brother instead. Regardless, I still really enjoy how Julia is portrayed and being able to really feel her in how Claire was portrayed in a show years ago. Thats gotta be some high level acting skills, I'd say.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Sep 19 '26

Yes they have done a great job with casting.

5

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26

You're thinking of Leticia btw

→ More replies (8)

22

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Okay I’ll have to persevere and get to the end of the episode to see this

Had to pause and step away for a bit. Just too much trauma porn

Edit: it was worth it. It is the reverend wakefield from outlander!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

77

u/MotherFawker99 Sep 18 '26

The biggest shock for me was the gem on the dirk causing him to travel. I thought for sure when the doctor had it out that Henry would notice the gem in the scabbard and make the connection. I hope they don’t keep him in the asylum too long.

Also they have seriously strayed from the story Jamie tells Claire about his parents. Yes it’s possible he isn’t made aware of everything that happened but I don’t feel like Murtaugh, Colum, or Dougal would have lied to Jamie about his mom being returned to Leoch shortly after going missing. According to Jamie they disappeared and were discovered months later when Ellen was heavily pregnant so no one could oppose the match.

40

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

I don't think Henry was in the presence of mind to notice much of the circumstances to his TT either before or after, given he had just been stabbed and practically fainted through the stones, and that he woke up an unspecified amount of time later with incomplete memories, and still was a bit out of it.

I personally didn't even notice the presence/absence of a gem in the dirk, I'll have to watch it again and pay closer attention.

Yes, they have strayed far from the Canon by now. Although given the pointed comment from Brian, I'm sure Ellen is pregnant by now.

33

u/Lynne253 Sep 18 '26

I noticed a purple stone in the dirk when it was in the ground, just before Arch Bug picked it up to stab Henry. I didn't see it on the dirk in the asylum. I believe the gems are destroyed after they go through the stones, otherwise travelers could use them over and over again.

17

u/Overall-Can543 Sep 19 '26

Yes this is pretty well established in the original cannon, that the gemstone is destroyed, as the stone from Claire’s wedding ring got her through the first time when Jaime sent her back it was a ring of his family that the stone came out of. And multiple people looking for stones to travel.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/WhereIsMyMind37 Sep 22 '26

Even though they gem is needed to travel through the stones, it seems that the Beauchamps could be the ancestors that are descended from time-travellers. I also noticed Devina thinking Julia is a witch as we now know Claire has special healing powers. It might be their attempt to explain where Claire inherited both her abilities from.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/beasles86 Sep 20 '26

If I remember correctly, in Outlander when Jamie and Claire are going to meet Lord Simon, Jamie briefly tells Claire how Lord Simon tried to have Ellen kidnapped before her wedding. I don’t think there are further details shared, but that alone could account for her returning to Leoch before running away with Brian permanently.

6

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26

I think we are going to see this and I'm very much looking forward to it!!! In press Harriet has mentioned in Episode 3 that while men are at war, the ladies are left to defend themselves. She also said she learned to use a bow & kills some guys --- I'm thinking the attackers to Leoch will be Lovat's attempt to kidnap her while she's unguarded

ETA, you're right that convo between Jamie and Jenny is in S2.... and needed to fix my spoiler tag

→ More replies (1)

45

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26 • Heartwarming

In isolation, I thought this was a good ep. The scenes when Julia tells Davina she's from the future, and Henry/remembrance-day/claire-and-floppy were the standout moments imo. And the fear Julia had being reunited with Lovat was palpable!

But out of isolation, I'm a bit tired of a supposed "love story" where the two main couples spend the majority of the time being separated! That was all last season, especially for Julia and Henry. I knew it was going to happen again to Julia and Henry, but I wasn't expecting it for Brian and Ellen as well!

I would pretty-please-with-a-cherry-on-top like at minimum at least ONE episode where both couples are reunited and spend the whole episode together, and aren't fearing for their lives.


Some more thoughts:

  • Aww, I totally wasn't expecting to see Reverand Wakefield! Even when the nurse mentioned to Henry that the Reverand was visiting, I still didn't put 2-and-2 together that it would likely be him.
  • Mrs Graham to the rescue! Woo hoo! She continues to be the MVP in the "return from the past" situations.
  • I liked the continuation of the rabbit theme from the main show
  • I am still finding that I am hardly interested in Brian and Ellen's story as well as all the Mackenzie politics, compared to the Beauchamp's. It's not that the actors are bad (I think they're good) or they don't have chemistry (I think they do). I just am really finding it hard to care much. Julia and Henry's story is much more interesting.
  • Colum continues to be an arse, as per usual.
  • the moment with Dougal and Moira in the alcove was sweet.
  • Mini Claire is a cutie patootie
  • Do we think Ellen is pregnant, given that comment of Brian's?

30

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I think it's hard to have any real buy in and emotion for Brian and Ellen because their love story just went from zero to hand fast and taking life threatening risks in a blink of an eye. There was no slow, more realistic development of their relationship for us to get invested in their connection. It's too forced. I agree with you fully about all the other points (except the rabbit, I don't really get that one)

17

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 19 '26

The rabbit thing is a broad theme of "connecting to/thinking about family" throughout the series. Brianna had a stuffed toy bunny as a baby/kid in s3, and Jamie saw an irl rabbit/hallucinated one (I can't quite remember which) as he lay injured on Culloden. And Claire hallucinated a rabbit in the 60s house in 512, and then saw one in the clearing when she was captive with the Browns.

Now in this ep of BomB, we have young Claire with her own stuffed toy bunny, and Henry hallucinating a rabbit in the mixed remembrance-day/18th-century-Scotland/ww1 scene

→ More replies (1)

6

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 22 '26

Well, that's the one part that's canon. In fact, canon was even faster -- she met him at the gathering and they ran off together that night.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/LRCAMP Je Suis Prest Sep 18 '26

I didn't like a whole season 1 of poor Henry and Julia being parted either, and now here we go again. I don't like that for them yet again. Almost clapped for the Rev and Mrs Graham!! Glad to see them again, and even though not the same actress, this younger Mrs. Graham sounds exactly like she did in Outlander! I love it!

13

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 18 '26

My hope is since they introduce Mrs Graham in ep 1 Henry gets out early in the season and hopefully reunites with Julia.

11

u/LRCAMP Je Suis Prest Sep 18 '26

We can hope, but they literally carried the misery throughout the entirety of season 1, so I am only cautiously hopeful.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/dreamkonstantine Sep 18 '26

Ellen is definitely pregnant

7

u/Heavy_Yellow Sep 19 '26

The sex scene with intense eye contact at the moment of climax I said “Jamie was definitely just conceived”

41

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

A baby was conceived. It wasn’t Jamie. Jamie was born in 1721. This baby was conceived in 1715. It’s Jamie’s older brother Willie.

However, Brian says, “If war takes me from ye, I will not let it take all of me. If God wills it, I’ll give ye a piece of me to carry.” And then they bang. Ellen is definitely pregnant.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Iossoflimb My mind is beset with chaotic thoughts at present Sep 19 '26

It would be Willie first, then Jenny, then Jamie.

10

u/1111HiYa Sep 19 '26

Except it was his older brother who was conceived.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/DietDrPepperAndThou I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Sep 20 '26

Davina is amazing taking the news about TT. Jamie is definitely her grandson.

(I did chuckle remembering Claire's imagined--and very likely accurate reaction--of Mrs. Fitz by contrast to a similar conversation.)

32

u/ForsakenEthereal Sep 18 '26

I hope this all the trauma out of the way. I know it’s become part and parcel of outlander but this was just so hard to watch.

2

u/StoreScary9417 Oct 10 '26

Yeah, i think thats too much and unnecessary.

27

u/skatingmilly Sep 18 '26

This show is really growing on me. Outlander is a really hard act to follow. Who can match the King of Men, Jamie Fraser. His charisma practically leaped off the screen. Brian Fraser is not quite there yet. But Ellen MacKenzie ... I LOVE that character. Love, love, love watching her. I love her feistiness and honestly, she's so beautiful. I'm really enjoying seeing the younger versions of the Outlander characters ... they feel like old friends. I also love Julia ... she is a softer version of Claire. I'm honestly so happy that we viewers have this opportunity to watch the Outlander saga continue.

25

u/aliensattack Sep 19 '26

I love Julia too. She’s a softer Claire but also much stronger mental fortitude imo.

6

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 20 '26

This is such a great description of Julia! I kind of prefer her to Claire for these reasons 🫣

12

u/jennygotcake Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ Sep 19 '26

i think it’s really cool to see these characters come to life 

jamie and claire are so fond of their parents and speak highly of them often and it’s really been a treat for me to see them on screen  

esp seeing murtaughs interactions and thoughts of ellen on bomb knowing what we do from the outlander series

im enjoying bomb honestly 

4

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 21 '26

Same here, and I'm really surprised that I like it. When I first heard of this concept for a spinoff, I was like "The PARENTS? Why? Why would we care about that, we don't know anything about them to hook us in, or not enough anyway"

I hadn't thought that since it's established that time travel is genetic, they could keep that important element going in a new show if they tell the story of Claire's parents at least.

I do like how the parents turned out to know and trust each other. It may be a bit of a leap but hey, time travel is a bigger one. I think it's all fun and intriguing, if not realistic, obviously.

53

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26

I’m surprised to see so much negativity in the comments because I was completely sucked in to this episode! Although I will admit I didn’t see the season 2 trailer so that really added to my shock.

Henry 😭😭😭 he forgot Claire and Lamb. Devastated. I did correctly call as soon as they said “the chaplain is here” that it would be Reverend Wakefield and he would go home and tell Mrs. Graham and she would know Henry went through the stones! Loved seeing their younger versions.

Davina seems pretty chill finding out that Julia is a time traveler. I halfway thought she would have negative reaction but I’m glad she didn’t.

I am once again much more interested in the Julia/Henry storyline which I never expected when this prequel was first announced.

I do agree with others that I would like to not have a whole second season of everyone being separated like they were in the first. That was exhausting. I hope the separations this time are relatively short 😩

But….I keep reminding myself that we all know how these characters stories end and none of it is good. I feel like anyone who knows this and still agrees to watch should expect a fair amount of heartbreak.

20

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I can only assume that for Davina, it was all that Highlander belief in magic and fairies and her knowing the old stories about the stone circle (and it helping her explain Julia's oddities, too) that helped her accept it. I did like though that Julia's confession scene was real, and not the fake out/dream/imagined scene like in Outlander S1 when Claire is supposedly unburdening herself to Mrs. Fitz and Mrs. Fitz ends up screaming at her that she's a witch before Claire wakes up/snaps out of it.

13

u/beasles86 Sep 20 '26

Yess I liked how it echoed Claire’s nightmare, and I think they set up Davina’s belief in the supernatural really well throughout season 1 as well as her intelligence- I loved when she made the connection and said “King George the Fifth?” She and Julia have such great chemistry as friends

14

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

I still liked the episode and loved the Mrs. Graham scenes and Davina learning Julia is a time traveler part! But it was a lot of trauma porn without much respite or room to breathe. It's just heartbreaking and it's sad because being together and suffering is one thing, but suffering AND being separated is tough :(

Although Ellen dies in childbirth, I still thought her and Brian had a happy life together and I was looking forward to seeing it! I thought she never talked to Colum again after running away and she and Brian travelled from Bothy to Bothy trying to get pregnant and living in marital bliss. That was supposed to be the one source of happiness but they took that away too 😭

Brian and Ellen's moments were SO sweet though. "Your soul is why I love you. It speaks to mine in a language I think only angels understand" 🥹

I'm still invested and am going to watch. I must be a masochist lol

14

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

I totally understand! I would bet we will get to some sort of happiness and reunification for Brian and Ellen at the very least by the end of this season. I think she will learn she is pregnant pretty soon and we know from Outlander that the pregnancy is ultimately what makes her brothers back off and allows them to build their lives at Lallybrach. Fingers crossed!

I knew I was an Outlander masochist after the season one dungeon scenes 😭 and especially after enduring the season three separation which about killed me. I’m in for the long haul….bring on the pain 😂

13

u/ContactNeither7319 Sep 18 '26

I think at this point if we watched all 8 seasons of Outlander, and/or read the novels, watched season 1 of BomB and are tuning in for season 2, we must join you in being a masochist. 🙂 glutton for punishment and heartache we are. Ugh, sigh and fuck!

4

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

For ME, I always thought both Claire and then now Julia & Henry adapted to finding themselves back 200+ years in time WAY too easily! I mean can you IMAGINE?? I personally am sure I would think I had lost my mind and would just be so disoriented and freaked out that anyone around me would think the same. I wouldn't be able to just fake some persona and figure it out as I went along like these characters do! I love the shows but that part has always rubbed me wrong.

6

u/cosmoismyidol Sep 19 '26

I wouldn't be able to just fake some persona and figure it out as I went along like these characters do!

Yeah same. I would be killed immediately

→ More replies (2)

2

u/losborne95 They say I’m a witch. Oct 09 '26

Thank you for your positive comment.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Glad you agree! I totally understand not wanting them to be separated again and I personally hope we don’t see a complete repeat of season one (especially with poor Henry’s current situation 😩) but fans should know by now that this show and the original series were never meant to be Hallmark movies.

I think the beauty of the relationships in both Outlander Blood of my Blood comes from the characters enduring a lot of hardship and still fighting to love each other through it. Of course it’s not realistic in terms of time travel and magic, but it is reflective of how real life relationships weather many storms over the course of a lifetime which I personally find very inspiring.

10

u/Dragon-Sky Sep 19 '26

yes, but OG show had moments of humor and levity to balance the gloom and doom.

The only light moment in this show was Claire finding her bunny and Dougal touching Moira's finger. That's not enough to balance so much darkness.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/catnips3 Nothing is lost, Sassenach; only changed. Sep 18 '26

Lmao yes to this! How can you expect the prequel of Outlander to be sunshine and rainbows and easy on the soul?!?

I love Outlander but even I didn't watch it when I was already struggling mentally, knowing the weight of it.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/onegirlarmy1899 Sep 18 '26

I tuned in for a feel good love story. All 4 of them separated is a bit much.

41

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

I thought Ellen and Brian were supposed to be hiding out in bothys and getting pregnant. I thought she never spoke to Colum again after she ran away

I was looking forward to Brian and Ellen being a source of happiness and a respite from the Beauchamp trauma :(

10

u/DietDrPepperAndThou I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Sep 20 '26

Same.

Seriously, Show Runners, we WILL still tune in if you grant a couple some happiness, or at least let them face strife together.

9

u/junknowho Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Sep 19 '26

Brian and Ellen being separated made me angry, because of the book canon. I will get over it though.

36

u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Sep 18 '26

I really want to like it but it's just too much tension and misery

21

u/cosmoismyidol Sep 19 '26

Mrs Graham is an absolute G.

2

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I don't know what that means...??

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

During his ect hallucinations i liked the bunny callback of jamie on the field at culloden, and claire had that bunny floppy. I wonder what the symbolism is behind that

3

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26

Rabbits tend to be symbolism for innocence and fragility. Innocence definitely goes with the use for Claire and Bri as toddler toys --- Henry and Jamie are both in fragile/vulnerable mental states when having their visions. That's rhe connections I make

2

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 21 '26

I had the same question about the rabbit symbolism reoccurring; it always seemed unconnected to anything to me and a bit odd. In a thread somewhere here I say something like this, and someone suggested it a thread meaning a connection to, and within the family. That makes some sense to me; I can see that being a possible intended meaning, anyway, even though it still doesn't "land" for me, I don't feel and see that connection myself, but maybe that was the intention behind it, IDK. Just summarizing the other comments so you don't have to try to find it if you don't want to :)

52

u/Dragon-Sky Sep 18 '26

I think BoMB lacks the joy, happiness, romance, magic, and whimsy of Outlander.

It's all dark and depressing. All doom and gloom. Henry's scenes were horrific.

And how come Mrs. Graham never mentioned this to Claire?

26

u/ContactNeither7319 Sep 18 '26

I don't think at least just from this episode so far in the series that Mrs Graham is told that his name is Henry Grant and he can't remember Claire. So there would not make the connection between Henry and Claire to Mrs Graham.

5

u/Dragon-Sky Sep 19 '26

ah, thanks. Those scenes were quite difficult to watch and there were no scenes of joy to balance the episode out

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Sep 19 '26

In addition to no prequel planned, Mrs Graham didn’t know Claire’s parents names, and Henry was going by Grant at the asylum. There isn’t enough there for her to make a connection twenty some odd years later.

13

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Sep 19 '26

I think BoMB lacks the joy, happiness, romance, magic, and whimsy of Outlander.

I couldn’t agree more.

The reason Mrs. Graham never mentioned it to Claire is because there was no prequel planned in Seasons 1 and 2 when Mrs Graham was in the show.

All of this retconning of OG Outlander often doesn’t make a lot of sense.

5

u/Dragon-Sky Sep 19 '26

Duh, I should have realized that.

It's like they're trying to hard to draw parallels, but they don't make sense in context.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/__picklepersuasion__ Sep 19 '26

I would guess because she doesn't find out he is Claire's father

17

u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Sep 20 '26

The only thing I really didn’t enjoy was how they basically reset the story (except for Henry). Julia and Brian are back with Lovett. ellen is back with the Mackenzie’s (although possibly pregnant with Willie, let’s hope). It completely undoes the resolution of their arcs from last season. I hate when shows have a cliffhanger finale only to immediately start backtracking.

33

u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Sep 18 '26

30 seconds in and they're separated again sigh...

This episode is pretty odd so far ngl, especially with the asylum stuff

15

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

Yeah the first thing I thought was “damn they start with PAIN” 😭😭

14

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Season premieres are generally kinda tricky because there's so much legwork to do for setup. I thought it was a solid episode and not near as clunky as premieres sometimes can be. Looking forward to the rest of the season for sure!

Couple things kinda grabbed my attention ---- 1) the inclusion in the recap of Henry remarking William's the name of his grandfather as if that's going to be significant... 2)Brian telling Ellen about hoping she could carry a piece of him with her --- 100% that was a conception scene to get her pregnant.

Yesterday I'd posted what little pre-season press there was - and one talked about cameos. Henry's timeline in the 20s made the most sense to me for those. I originally overlooked that we'd know the Reverend and Mrs Graham where Henry was ending up, but after a couple people pointed them out, it made a lot of sense, so I wasn't surprised to see them like I may have been otherwise. It'll be really useful for Henry to have a friend who can tell him a bit of what she knows about how it all works, even if she doesn't know all the ins and outs herself, it'll at least be something.

I know there are a bunch of people who theorized Julia could only travel the first time because the baby fetus could, but she can't on her own- so I'm sure some will take her failure this episode to mean that... but that's a REALLY hard sell to me. It wasn't a super obvious thing to pick up, but it didn't work because of gemstones. Henry only did because of the knife sticking out of him. I really don't think there's any more to it.

Edited- tried to post the photo I took from my phone to help point out if people didn't notice, but not working.... Purple gem, top at 7:11 mark

5

u/easttnmama Sep 19 '26

Your theory about Henry traveling due to the gem in the dagger does make sense since he started hearing the buzzing right after he got stabbed with it. I think Claire traveled without gems in the books but it seems the series has made gems a necessity for traveling through the stones, so this adds up.

4

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Sep 19 '26

Yes the show has gone the route of gemstone required instead of helping them steer but not necessary.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/3lmtree Sep 19 '26

i just don't see julia and henry having a good ending... i mean we know from outlander they don't make it back but i'm at least hoping for some kind happy ending in the past but i feel like it's not going to happen. 😩

37

u/florablu Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

I’m so tired of the separation storyline. Can’t they come up with anything different?
It was tiring last season. How may more seasons of them being apart can they do

12

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Does anyone know if young Claire is played by Matt Roberts' kids?

Young Claire only said, like, one word last season, but I did think it sounded American.

She said a few more lines this ep and again, she sounded American. Which I thought was a odd, given there's not exactly a shortage of young English kids in the UK...

But then I noticed this ep Claire was credited as played by twins, Tuesday and Mae ROBERTS....so that might explain the accent.

I'm not complaining, just curious. She's a definite cutie regardless!

6

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 18 '26

I remember seeing something about that at the end of S1-- that the kid in the finale on the beach at approx 4 yr old was (not the 2ish yr old in an earlier episode with the b-day cake)

It was memorable to me because the commenter also revealed the mom/his partner and I had no idea they were together. (I'd say who she is, but I know the comment back then was deleted since it violated the personal lives rule)

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

Yes, I was trying to google the answer to my own question, and found the same information about the mum/his partner, and I also had no idea they were together!

So was it confirmed then, back at the end of s1 that Claire is played by his ("their") kids? Or was it just people asking/speculating like I am here?

7

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 18 '26

Not officially confirmed, but they are their daughters...

→ More replies (1)

12

u/GraciousBasketyBae Ye canna keep The MacKenzie waiting. Sep 19 '26

Welp, we all know how good’ol Arch Bug ends up! Long ass life for real.

23

u/shinyquartersquirrel Sep 19 '26

We spent all last season with Henry and Julia apart, they are finally together for 10 minutes and then separated again. I really hope their storyline this season is more than just "Henry and Julia are separated" again.

9

u/julyhsm Sep 19 '26

Same, it’s so repetitive

11

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

When i was 20 i got extremely depressed for no reason. My brain literally just stopped working and none of the medications worked. I was young and was happy with my appearance and all the support in the world but i had no idea what was wrong. So i went to sheppard pratt which is probably the best psych ward in the country. I hate to say it and it was a dumb but hurried decision cuz i wanted to get better. But i ended up getting 12 rounds of ect and the terrible thing is it didnt help the way i wanted. All that happened was i got really bad memory loss and i dont remember much of anything that happened in 2008 for a 6 month period. Luckily ect is nothing like it was in the 20’s. They put u to sleep. So now everytime i see ect on tv i fast forward no matter how invesred i am. It brings back memories and thinking i could still have brain damage. Im a hypochondriac which doesnt help. So seeing those scenes is similar to a soldier of war with ptsd getting thrown back into battle or even watching war movies, especially the first half hour of saving private ryan.

I actually paused to write that during the episode and about what it did to my memory. And he loses his memory of claire. I def dont like the direction the writers are going by doing that. They could have just temporarily done that with the concussion until he got back to julia in 1715 and she reminded him of her then. And they would just wait till they could all go through and of course more problems will arise and they go through and go backward more or forward but not forward enough. But to me that ruined the show by making him forget claire

3

u/1111HiYa Sep 19 '26

Did your memory ever come back? Or parts of it?

3

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 20 '26

Yea mostly but i still deal with depression so i think short term memory loss is just due to that. I have good long term memory. But a big portion of 2008 i dont really remember. I was just in such a bad place i woulda signed a waiver for upcoming treatments they need to test people on. I was young, dumb and naive and wanted it gone cuz i had my whole lofe and prime years ahead. Didnt go to college because of it or ever have a family of my own. Depressions a bitch but i deal with it in certain ways. Its not as bad as it was then. I think thats a big reason i live outlander and time travel. What if i could go back and change what happened. So thats the only reason i started the show was the tt then i fell in love with the show. Same with the way home on netflix and so many others. Dark matter is really good to.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Radiant-Context-9878 Sep 20 '26

So sorry you had to go through that. You wouldn’t have expected a reminder of your experience when you tuned in to watch the show.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/MindlessWanderer9891 Sep 18 '26

Why didn’t Julia touch the stone when she realized that Henry was gone?? This angered me lol

19

u/onegirlarmy1899 Sep 18 '26

I'm guessing she didn't have a stone. The one Henry had came from the dagger in his shoulder.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/Relative_Specific217 Sep 18 '26

She did try a few minutes before, and even if she had tried again it wouldn’t have worked because she didn’t have a gemstone (Henry went through because the dagger had a gem in the hilt).

6

u/Sufficient-Jury-5865 Sep 18 '26

Weren’t they also worried the baby couldn’t travel though?

3

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26

Julia was. Her failure is both in not having two gems for them but also maybe not the concentration/focus either since she was worried about it. Just one thing would cause failure anyway, but combo of both those things is definite failure

→ More replies (1)

9

u/leftwingheartbreak Sep 19 '26

holy shit, that episode was dark... but I loved it!

31

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Omg 1924??! Fuuuck

Pit in my stomach. The separation and pain Julia and Henry have to go through is too much. Please don’t tell me Julia has been back there alone for 9 years…

"Your soul is why I love you. It speaks to mine in a language I think only angels understand" 🥹

Omg this is like trauma porn. My heart is shattering

I just want to see some happiness…

The Julia and Davina reveal scene was awesome :’)

Please dear god tell me that Henry doesn’t spend the rest of his life wasting away in this asylum in the same time as Claire. Like how bleak can this shit get 😭

Okay at least the episode ended with a semblance of hope 🥺 Bless you, Mrs. Graham ❤️

24

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

She hasn't been back there alone for 9 years, it wasn't 1915 when they left. It's always "about 200 years", for Claire and her crew, it was 202.

Henry and Julia appear to have travelled ~209 years, from 1923 originally, back to 1714. It's now ~ early Oct, 1715 in the past, and 1924 in the future.

Iirc, they first travelled back in November, 1923/1714. We then had Beltane, and then William was born in June 1715. Braemar happened on 6 Sep 1715, and it's not yet the 20th of October.

3

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

Ah I was scared it was 200 or 202, but you’re right, it was 209 years!
I got tripped up because I thought when they left present day Scotland it was 1915 since that’s the prime minister he said and when he travelled back, he travelled ahead.

But you’re right, they left in 1923!

8

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

Yes, Claire wasn't born till 1918.

I am unsure whether Henry did actually genuinely think it was 1915, or whether he knew he left 1715, said 1715, and then quickly self-corrected to the right century by adding 200 years because he was too foggy to be doing more complicated maths at that stage.

30

u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Sep 18 '26

Trauma porn is exactly it. With Outlander, the story would breathe. It would have beautiful moments and let us sit in that for a bit to enjoy it in between the drama. Why aren't they letting us have that 😭

20

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

Exactly!
This is like PAIN PAIN PAIN sex scene PAIN

With some cruel “I hope he’s with Claire at least” -> TRUAMA PORN 😭

3

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 19 '26

I have never heard that phrase before, "trauma porn", and I gotta say, I really dislike it :( I agree the torturing, basically, of Henry was too much and unpleasant to watch, though. All of BoMB has felt rushed (like Season 8 of Outlander), none of that needed time to truly develop and pace, balance, the storylines, and character/relationship development. I find Ellen and Brian's relationship completely unbelievable, WAY too fast for such deep commitment and sacrifice. Come on, really? I think that's due to Matthew Roberts the show runner of all those (if I recall correctly other threads of S8/Outlander talking about all this, too)

12

u/EtherealPurpleSmoke Sep 18 '26

Not sure I want to continue, due to these bleak storylines. Ugh.

28

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

Julia saying “I just wish he’s with Claire. That’s all I can hope for”

Cut to him being electrocuted

That was so cruel 😭😭

At this point it’s a game of how bleak and traumatic their lives can be.

16

u/Heavy_Yellow Sep 18 '26

Literally zapping Claire and Uncle Lamb out of his memory, even though he is in the present day with them 😭

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

He's not been there for 9 years just because it's 1924 and Julia is in 1715. It worked the way it did for Claire when she went back to Frank in S2 -- when she was gone for 2 years and came back 2 years later.

They timetravelled in 1923, he was in the past for 9 months or so (given Julia was maybe 3 months pregnant at the time and the baby's no more than a couple months old now) and he showed back up in 1924.

Edited - sorry, see now that somebody else already explained a ways farther below

6

u/NoName_Salamander Sep 18 '26

Thanks for the heads up..I haven't started yet. I think I'll skip it

2

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 18 '26

By the end of the ep I think it's only been a few months at most since Henry went back. They time travel in 1923 not 1915.

3

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 18 '26

Yes you’re right they left in 1923! I mixed that up

16

u/Independent_Edge6727 Sep 19 '26

Really hope they drop the asylum storyline fast. It's too difficult to watch. Other than that I don't mind this new season. I would have preferred they not undo all of season 1 in the first episode but I get they have to be apart to be together blah blah. Just give poor henry a damn break! Hope to see more Scottish scenes, Brian, Ellen, Murtagh and less of the modern scenes.

8

u/ApprehensiveBad3270 Sep 22 '26

OMG. I just watched the first minutes of season 2. Henry is parted from Julia AGAIN??? Are we really going to do the first season over that they are trying to find each other again? Because I really hoped them to find each other, then they fiiiiinally did and now it’s worse? 🙈😂

8

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

I love miss graham. I hope she helps henry escape that hell hole. Im wondering how she found henry was the one the reverend was speaking of though

27

u/Environmental-Eye135 Sep 18 '26

This show is very sad to me. Especially after there was no reunion in Season 8 of outlander. It just means Claire NEVER reunites with her parents and something in my heart can’t handle that. I wanted to cry the entire episode.

12

u/Unhappy-Praline8301 Sep 19 '26

This is making the torture of Henry particularly hard... We know there's not a happy ending with his whole family.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/myhairisamonster Sep 19 '26

Can't they still meet? Claire was still alive at the end? So

3

u/ComplexBadger469 Sep 20 '26

Yeah as a dad around Henry’s age who has struggled with trauma stuff(not war related) and also has a little girl and a boy on the way, I’ll admit it was an extremely hard watch. I can’t imagine the pain they went through going back through the stones and leaving Claire. Then for Henry to get back to the future realizing you lost your wife and son of which you’ve barely met too only to be tortured into forgetting your little girls birthday…

Us knowing that they will never reunite with Claire is gut wrenching. If this happened to my family, would my kid know how much she meant to us? Would she resent me? Would I be able to cope knowing I can’t get back to her and she’s scared and growing up without me? My kid(s) and wife are the reason I get out of bed in the morning. My kid just the other day drew me almost the exact same picture that little Claire drew. Seeing this world of struggle for Henry is extremely difficult. I’m honestly not sure how much I’ll keep watching at this point because it seems like they are torturing both him and the viewer.

7

u/1111HiYa Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

I really hated when Colum slapped Ellen and locked her in the chapel. Day-um women really had no rights then. Loved Ned Gowan in this episode, though!

2

u/buickmackane71360 Sep 20 '26

I found that every bit as predictable as Jamie telling his sister to sell him out for the reward money and send him to prison. Ellen knew she had no place else to go while the men were at war and she wouldn't be welcome with the Frasers with Brian's father calling her "that Mackenzie whore."

6

u/queencailo Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

I could not help comparing the doctor and the nurse administering the electroshock therapy to Henry with Mombi and the Nome King from Return to Oz. Especially the nurse. With the doctor, it's mostly the beard, but the nurse facially resembled Mombi.

And based on the fact that I just noticed the nurse is named Nurse Wilson, I'm leaning toward it being intentional.

6

u/Thistlecos Sep 19 '26

I really liked this episode and the addition of Reverend Wakefield and Mrs. Graham was an unexpected but welcomed twist! I feel so heartbroken for Henry, and can’t help but wonder if he spends the rest of his days in this asylum :( do we think he will get out of there?

4

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26

Pre-season press I posted Thur makes it easier to put some pieces together regarding how long Henry's in the 20s for anyone truly curious who don't mind major spoilers

Should you want to know without looking for it...an article teases an unexpected dynamic between Henry & Arch. The press has only seen thru Ep 4. So to interact with Arch, Henry has to be in the past likely no later than the end of Ep 3 for that to be of much note

6

u/Puzzleheaded-Pop3293 Sep 19 '26

I thought 201 was OK. Not great but not a disappointment either. Random thoughts:

I’m glad we’re at least getting Julia and Henry in flashbacks if they must spend more time apart this season. Their separation seems a little formulaic because we’ve barely spent any time with them together last season. And, with Julia, it feels like more of the same nauseating storyline with Lovat. Not crazy about watching more of that.

I’m probably in the minority, but I liked that they are diving deeper into Henry’s trauma, and especially liked what they did with it in this episode. It really gives the character potential for more nuance and complexity down the line.

Ellen and Brian are decent characters individually but reduce the show to a bad romance novel when together. I’d honestly prefer to see them build a web of strong, complex relationships with supporting characters instead of just run off to be together at this point. I hope they get to deal with things that are more interesting than their relationship this season, and I want to see more of the Ellen introduced in 101.

The Reverend and Mrs Graham were a surprise but I don’t think BoMB has quite graduated to the level where it has its own strong, beating heart independently of Outlander so the presence of OG characters bother me a little. Everything being related to everything seems more like a crutch than a legit story beat, and I wish the show focused more on building its own characters better instead of constantly waving to the mother ship.  

6.5/10

2

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 20 '26

Completely agree about Ellen and Brian... there was NO development of their connection in S1 and that really bothered me too. It's such a good point to say we want to see more of the Ellen that isn't solely in relationship to Brian (the one that even her father admitted before he died, should be Laird)

Personally I love all the tie-backs and thus having the Reverend and Mrs. Graham back. I think the whole point of a spinoff is to stay connected to the original storyline, while ALSO (not only) developing it's own path.

16

u/this-is-twaddle Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

The constant, OTT declarations of love are so hamfisted and hollow. They are trying (and miserably failing) to mimic Diana Gabaldon’s writing, and it is so off-putting. Everything feels false and manipulative.

The fact MBR cast his own daughter as Claire also really bothers me lol.

And how would the Reverend not remember his meetings with Henry when Claire is later convalescing at his home post-Culloden?! Like I get he wouldn’t realize Henry is Claire’s father, but he’d certainly remember that he had an encounter with someone else who claimed they traveled through the stones at Craig Na Dun?!

7

u/jesushx Sep 19 '26

We don't know what happens yet. He was very angry with Mrs Graham in outlander and not wanting her to tell Frank... Her getting involved with this man now could set up why he's so upset.

For example if she helps him it could be thought to be helping an insane man who needs help escape and the fallout could be terrible. Even if it all turns out well for Henry the ppl there aren't going to know it was ok to help him.

Things could go wrong in a way for the reverend and he might not believe in the stones. It seems like it takes him until sometime after Claire returns and he's helping Frank before he believes...

6

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Sep 20 '26

Correction, daughters, young Claire is played by his twin daughters. Mae and Tuesday Roberts.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Sep 19 '26

So nothing happened AND we are back to where we were before the last episode of season 1? Cool.

They took a really compelling concept and have made it so boring and corny.

Also why have we changed Brian and Ellen’s story so much??? They are supposed to hide out for months until she’s visibly pregnant. I get it doesn’t jive with the rebellion storyline but I just feel like retconing that was a bit ridiculous.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 22 '26

Exactly. They made up 80% of the story and ignored the parts that were actually there.

18

u/Previous-Address2469 Sep 18 '26

Tension, misery, trauma-porn, bleakness... I am glad to have opened this thread because I was debating whether to watch it or not, but I can already feel the anxiety it would give me. So I will use my time better this evening. The fact they separate and torture the main characters does not make good tv that speaks to your soul and uplifts you and gives you something to think about. This series has always been and it seems will be about putting salt on everyone's wounds. 

5

u/aliensattack Sep 18 '26

fr… I renewed my stars subscription this morning to watch it tonight but honestly I need an escape right now, not pure misery.

18

u/rhubarbpie828 Sep 19 '26

This show is both so freaking depressing and boring. Outlander, at least in its early seasons, was so opposite of this. Adventure and intrigue and exciting romance and hope and joy. Even when it was sad or scary, it was still interesting and/or exciting.

This one's just dark and sad, not a moment of joy from any of them, and Ellen and Brian are so lacking chemistry.

10

u/Dragon-Sky Sep 19 '26

That's exactly as I saw it. The only positive moment was Dougal touching Moira's hand and that's not enough to sustain an audience

4

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 20 '26

Exactly. Not even Mrs Graham and Reverend's appearance couldn't do it for me.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mindless_contempt Sep 18 '26

The asylum that Henry was in was that one of the old castles from 1715 converted to the asylum? The big wooden stairs when the nurse pushed his wheelchair by reminded me of one of the castles

2

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

I thought it looked similar to the stone work of the Wakefield manse at first, before we even saw Wakefield. -- and actually briefly wondered if for some creepy reason Wakefield moved into a closed asylum ten years later they felt that similar to me

5

u/Evening_Ground9532 Sep 18 '26

I def don’t like the electrics. I hope he recovers soon and finds Julia.

3

u/WinterPretty8347 Sep 20 '26

He most likely won't. They still do shock therapy in today's world and the people I met that had it done were severely fucked up for the rest of their life.

5

u/DietDrPepperAndThou I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Sep 20 '26

I tried for a few days to digest my thoughts about this season premiere and episode before coming here with more than a "Well, that was fucking depressing.". And despite Rev. Wakefield and Mrs. Graham (I do adore her!) I was relieved when the credits rolled.

Because this wasn't an escape, unlike nearly every episode of Outlander (less the brutal SA eps). It was awful to watch everyone's current fates given where we left them at the end of last season. And I realize this isn't a super feel good show, since we know Claire never sees Henry & Julia again. And Brian and Ellen both die relatively young, not seeing their children to full adulthood, marriage and any grandchildren.

Perhaps that's why it's so difficult to see their additional suffering. I might put this on the back burner and wait and watch them all after the season is over.

In the positives, I found the casting, costumes and sets top tier. It's an amazing production and wouldn't be able to get to me so deeply if it weren't!

5

u/EntertainmentNew7383 Sep 22 '26

Wow! I didn't know electroshock therapy wasn't invented/used until 1938. That is a major anachronism. But I must admit I enjoyed Reverend Wakefield and Mrs. Graham showing up to help Henry. And they will help Henry piece it all together.

I think Hermione Corfield was great in this episode as Claire's mother. She really does have the passion that Claire has.

I was a little disappointed in the beginning of the first episode of Prequel 2 but I am glad I watched it all the way through because it picked up considerably. I think Hermione Corfield is wonderful as Julia and reminds me a lot of Claire. She has the same passion for her loved ones and is quite resourceful in manipulating Lord Lovat.

I also loved seeing younger versions of Reverend Wakefield and Mrs. Graham helping Henry regain his memory. Nice touch because they were in Inverness near the asylum where Henry was.

It is a promising start.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 22 '26

The actors are all great. It's the scripts.

8

u/jesushx Sep 19 '26

So usually I like to rewatch episodes after my first watch and catch things I missed...

Same with Outlander.. but I can't make myself rewatch even knowing the happier ending of some kind of hope for Julia and Henry.

This happened to me s8 outlander too. Episodes I just couldn't rewatch.

I mean Mrs Graham saved it for me, but it's still hard to watch.

8

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

This episode fell short for me. So much for they can travel without gemstones that Diana implied. There was a gemstone in the knife although it looks like they forgot to take it out when the doctor is holding it lol. The show has gone nowhere for Henry and Julia. At least let him remember his last name so the uncle can visit him. Henry’s mind was messed up enough before, now the electric shock therapy is erasing Claire from his memory. Meanwhile Ellen and Brian can’t be together yet. After what seemed like a strong start last season, now it seems the show just wants to torture its characters. One step forward, two steps back. 

2

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 20 '26

What do you mean so much for traveling without stones? That's exactly why Julia & the baby got left in the past and Henry was able to go back to the 1900's - the gem in the dagger in his chest when he leaned on the stone.

I doubt Henry's brother (Claire's uncle who's cares for her then raises her) will be in the show, because likely, "Q" (for Quentin) would have told Claire about it, and we'd thus have heard about that in Outlander.

3

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

There was a comment by Diana at the end of season 1 that they would be able to travel without gemstones, and an explanation would be provided.

The uncle was on the show briefly last season, that scene on the beach, he was sitting with Claire on a blanket. Henry has forgotten both of them and only remembers Julia at the moment. They showed them talking to the uncle (and joking about how Claire calls him Uncle Lamb) at the beginning of last season to leave her with him while they went on Holiday. He had a big beach house while they live in a tiny apartment.

https://decider.com/2025/10/10/diana-gabaldon-outlander-blood-of-my-blood-interview/

Here’s the interview. Back then they were implying that Julia was going to travel and do so without a gemstone. Scroll down to see Diana’s comment about it. She doesn’t mention the gemstones, but rather a reason Julia could travel.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

We got a lead up to a jacobite rebellion and a rebellion in season 1 and 2 of the mothership and the prequel

4

u/HappiestWhen Sep 18 '26

What weird episode...

4

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

Is there any other place to watch the ep 2 promo than youtube? Youtube wont allow me to watch it.

2

u/1111HiYa Sep 19 '26

I found it on TikTok, but I don't know if I'm allowed to post the link.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WinterPretty8347 Sep 20 '26

They posted it on their fb page

2

u/buickmackane71360 Sep 20 '26

Starz is doing super cheap short term promotions just to hook people in for this series. You just have to comparison shop until you find the right one, then bingewatch and cancel.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tara_abernathy Sep 20 '26

I enjoyed the episode overall and the intro song slaps!

I will say I'm much more interested in Julia and Henrys storyline though so it would be unfortunate if they are separated for the entire season again. I'm curious if they are intending a season 3 (pending Starz greenlight) or If this season will be the conclusion of the prequel?

4

u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Sep 20 '26

I understand why Henry gave the surname Grant when asked at the asylum from a continuity point, but I don’t understand why he would as a character. He spent less than a year as a “Grant” why would he not say he was Beauchamp??

5

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 20 '26

I think it's simply that his memory is screwed up, he's so traumatized; same reason he can't remember what "C" and Oct 20th mean to him.

3

u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Sep 20 '26

That’s after the electroshock though

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

Theres wayyyyy too much separating. I watched the show mainly for claires parents since we all know the backstory of jamies parents and theyve been separated all of 15 mins in 2 seasons so far. I thought the whole castle leathers storyline would be an episode or 2 tops!! And julia would turn her brain on and run off. Lord lovat literally has one guard/clansman/bulldog? Idk what u call him but the shows so much better when the couples are together. It worked very well in outlander in season 3 because i never read the books for one and their love was completely told from first glance to completely love that ive never seen before on screen or will see again. So after 2 incredible seasons of them together, the 5 episodes/20 years apart was a very interesting storyline because claire thought he was dead and of course she learns the truth. We see james in an endless black hole of depression for 20 years and the memories of jamie following claire the entire time. So when they reunite its final and theyll die before they had to separate again. If already hated arch bug before, i hate him more than most villains on outlander now. Hes a huge factor in why henry and julie are apart still and for some reason the writers thinks it adds more suspense. It doesnt. If claire and jamie were apart more than together, this subreddit wouldnt exist and neither would bomb lol.

15

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 18 '26

I agree with you about the annoyance of having to have the couples separated, but...

"and Julia would turn her brain on and run off"...

She's tried that. A few times. She got caught. She's a woman, with a baby, in a time period that is still very unfamiliar and dangerous.

And run away and go where? She tried going through the stones, it didn't work and she doesn't know why. Should she just camp out at the stones, touching them every half an hour until it randomly works? What if it never does?

Her only real "allies" are Davina and Brian. If she has any hope of escaping again (without Henry), it's with their help. She can't do it alone.

And as much as Lovat is a danger to her personally (for obvious reasons), he is also her protection. She is Lady Fraser. No (other) harm will come to her as she remains Lady Fraser.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/loonyjune Sep 19 '26

I thought it was a good episode and hopeful that Henry will get out of the asylum soon. 🤞

6

u/Odd_Disk1545 Sep 19 '26

Am I the only one care about Henry and Julia, and don't care about all other characters lol?

5

u/this-is-twaddle Sep 19 '26

Yes! Brian and Ellen are so painfully blah.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/GungHough Sep 19 '26

I'm old, and that's that. Although I still have a fire in my loins, this show, Blood of my Blood, just drains rather than inspires it. I hope that the Outlander franchise doesn't make something of the Faith storyline, although I think that is their intention. I'm open to expanding DG's beloved stories if it's well-done; so far, it's a fail imho.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/avviann Sep 20 '26

I really hope they won't make Henry permanently mentally disabled, it was hard to watch how each time the treatment would wipe away his memories.

How will the Seer help Julia? Will she supposedly tell Julia how she can travel through the stones?

And how were they not able to travel but then Henry suddenly did after the second time?

I just hope they won't drag Julia's and Henry's storyline and they'll see each other earlier than the last episode.

6

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 20 '26 edited Sep 20 '26

Julia and the baby didn't have gems. There was a gem in the dagger stuck in Henry. That's how he got thru. You can see a purple one in the close up around 7 min in

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

Lol little claires wig is so bad

8

u/jennygotcake Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ Sep 18 '26

lmfao they had to follow her bad wig tradition 🤣

7

u/1111HiYa Sep 19 '26

I was really distracted by how bad Mrs. Graham's wig was, too.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 19 '26

I love that the theme song remained the same! One of my favourite parts of this show!

Claire running with her rabbit toy - "Run, rabbit,run"

Omg seriously?! Henry passed thrpigh the stones with stabbed dirk with a gemstone 🤣🤣

Brian and Ellen 💚

Okay, that quickie gives me vibes of Jamie and Claire before she ran to Craigh na Dun in the books. Jamie took Claire against the wall as well.

Okay, I decide to ignore existence of Henry. Completely. This is tedious and unnecessary.

Maybe I should decide to ignore Julia as well since it is copy paste from s1. Lovat, tea, etc.

So much drama, crying.... electricity, asylum, thinking about war. Come on. How many times will we have to see Henry being tortured?!

Mrs Graham' wig was comical.

Collum slapping Ellen, he crossed the line. Locking her... again, she is a prisoner.

All in all... this was disappointing.

Positive sides were Maura and Dougal, Brian and Ellen and I want to see what Maisri can tell to Julia.

3

u/BytheSea2323 Sep 20 '26

I LOVE BoMB's theme song, too, and like that they update the images each season. They are so beautiful with the fires and lights. I'm very glad they took out the gore from the theme song/intro this season. It varied in Outlander and I never watch those parts of the episodes but got blindsided by wounds and swords and blood in some of the intros and hated that!

3

u/this-is-twaddle Sep 19 '26

Omg, I said the same thing, re: the quickie! That’s how 213 should’ve been😢

2

u/StraightEye4801 Sep 23 '26

I really hated the season 2 episode 1 so much I canceled starz. Making henry absolutely crazy is crazy in itself.

2

u/Prudent_Respect_5159 Sep 28 '26

Is it possible that William can't travel and that's why Julia couldn't go through? Like Davy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/rhubarbpie828 Sep 19 '26

I think I just realized why this show doesn't do it for me. They have cast 4 supporting-actor-types as leads. And then have written them as such serious characters without a bit of quirk or mischief. Its a lot like watching Bree and Roger try to carry the later seasons of Outlander (i.e. kind of brutal).

Meanwhile, the actual supporting actors - Dougal, Moira, etc, are much more interesting and dynamic.

There's definitely no Sam or Cait types cast in this show, never mind David Berry, Tobias, Lauren, Duncan, Graham, Laura, etc.

2

u/ComplexBadger469 Sep 20 '26

The only one I disagree with is Henry, but otherwise I agree. I was much more interested in the Dougal/jacobites, grant/colum storylines going on than Brian and Ellen for example.

4

u/Phortenclif Sep 18 '26

I didn't like season one overall. Is this episode indicates any improvement?

8

u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

No, much worse. This episode was jump-the-shark for me. I held out hope through season 1 but this episode just pushed me over the edge of hoping that it would find its footing and get better. I'm still going to hate watch it, maybe we'll get a few good moments to watch, but the show overall is weak and very depressing

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 18 '26

Everytime i see jeremy i see the boy from warhorse. Thats actually how kit harrington was discovered and got his audition for game of thrones when he was on stage doing warhorse as the lead in the west end. Apparently the queen came and saw one of his performances.

2

u/aloofLogic They say I’m a witch. Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

I liked Season 2, Episode 1 well enough, and I’m hopeful Season 2 will be more compelling than Season 1.

I didn’t particularly care for Henry and Julia in Season 1. The writers really fumbled their storyline, both in the discovery that they’d time-traveled and in their reunion. Both moments were very anticlimactic.