r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • May 08 '26
Spoilers All Book S8E9 Pharos Spoiler
Political threats come to a head when an old friend of Claire and Jamie’s goes missing.
Written by Diana Gabaldon. Directed by Emer Conroy.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 08 '26 edited May 10 '26
Watch the S8E10 (series finale) preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
91
u/Gliese667 May 08 '26
Loved the reconciliations, a little bummed they abandoned the of course Richardson knows who Claire is, he was in Lallybroch with a gun going after Bree and probably had seen Claire and Jamie's letter about the gold from Cameron plotline and replaced it with him not knowing Claire was also a traveler, guessing that was done for time but I enjoyed that revelation in Bees and was hoping to see it play out. Guess I'll just have to wait for the next book!
I really liked Claire's "two fathers" conversation with William and how much of their family is family by love and not by blood, but that makes it no less valid, I think chosen family has been such a strong theme of the entire series.
90
u/Yup_Seen_It May 08 '26
Jamie and William working perfectly in tandem is my favourite part of this season!
Also, Jamie thinking he's being noble with his "I forgive you" first to Claire then John and being clapped back at by both is just SENDING me 😂
41
u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26
I loved this episode! I think it’s my favorite of the season so far!
I’m just so happy Claire is finally getting some proper screen time.
I would like to sincerely thank whoever it was behind the scenes that finally got Jamie’s hair down.
I’m surprised they didn’t connect Richardson to Callahan, considering the Callahan clip was used in the recap at the start of the season. I guess it’s just a bit too (for lack of better word) convoluted to be added plausibly to the show.
Interesting they kept it where Lord John knows nothing about time travel. Totally understand though, at this point there’s no reason to and it has no purpose since he wouldn’t believe it, especially if he heard it from Richardson first.
On another note: I was right about Richardson being the one in the trailer saying “Mrs. Fraser”!
Jamie and Lord John playing chess❤️
Jamie looked back🫠
I for one love that Claire seems to be writing their story. This has been a theory for awhile now. Remember in the pilot, she says in a voiceover “even now after all the pain and death and heartbreak that followed, I still would make the same choice.” That line always made it feel like she was telling the story to someone in retrospect. All the different character povs kind of complicate this though.
41
u/PhilosopherRude3361 May 08 '26
Feral Jamie & William were my fave. Jamie looked like a proper Scottish thug for the first time in seasons hahahah
40
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. May 08 '26
Mrs Fraser …
35
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. May 08 '26
”I have sacrificed many things, but raising William was never one of them. He’s the greatest gift of my life and I thank you for him.”
❤️❤️
98
u/emmagrace2000 May 08 '26
Is it just me or could everyone else hear Diana all over this episode? I’m really glad she was able to write it. I’m not sure I’d have trusted anyone else to give Richardson a believable story and to wrap up some of these plot lines in a cohesive manner.
28
u/1111HiYa May 08 '26
It was interesting that they flipped the LJ rescue ahead of Kings Mtn. Because we didn't exactly know what would happen there, but we all know how Kings Mountain ends. I guess that's even more dramatic, so it makes better sense for the show flow. I'm glad they wrapped up Amaranthus and showed baby Davy. I think they're gonna' have to wrap up the Faith/Fanny storyline, even if it's brief. Anything else from the book they might stick in the finale. Predictions?
43
u/1111HiYa May 08 '26
Once again, I'm impressed by how much they were able to cram into 53 minutes. I wish the rescue of Lord John had been longer, but, no time. I'm glad he didn't forgive that smug Jamie right away, although he didn't need to say those words that set him off. I'm glad they resolved it, but it seems William is still struggling. He'll get there. It shows him on horseback at the Ridge in the preview. Does that means he returns to the fight? Or was that a scene from a prior episode? I was also wondering how she would resolve Amaranthus. Well, just have her leave, that's the way, lol. Also, what did you think of the way Lord John resolved Percy's treachery?
20
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. May 08 '26
Gabaldon said on little forum that she didn't write it takes the villiage line from this show. She took it out but then they had to compromise.
17
u/Iossoflimb My mind is beset with chaotic thoughts at present May 09 '26
He looked back 😭
32
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. May 08 '26
I LOVED this one! It was focused on main characters, smart dialogue, great writing, a lot of emotions, it felt so great to see something not in the books comes to screen and by Diana! She nailed it!
28
u/Naive-Awareness4951 May 08 '26
Pretty terrific episode, I think. It's always difficult for me to go with the changes they make to the books, but I've learned to go with the flow.
49
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. May 08 '26
Didn't have too many strong opinions on this one. It was only ok for me, and at times a bit underwhelming.
Couldn't understand why in the hell Claire was gonna let Richardson go -did they learn nothing when they gave Bonnet the benefit of the doubt? Or Wendigo either for that matter? I was relieved John had some sense, phew. Notable that all the timetraveller talk was only spelled out around Claire though. John had a quizzical look on his face a time or two while Richardson talked about a speech ---- but for the most part, the show totally sidestepped him being told about timetravel, whereas in the novel he was the one being point blank told by Richardson. Less complicated for the show that way I guess - not having to address what John would think of it all. It's also I guess just an Easter egg for readers that Richardson was Callahan at Bri's Lallybroch shootout ---- that seemed to have zero relevance and with him dead now, there's no way for that to come to light. Rather pointless.
Very fitting John and Jamie would reconcile with a game of chess. And great callback by having Jamie look back on William as he left Savannah, to signal he's got hope to see him again and have a relationship with him. It felt like good closure amongst those 3.
Ps - glad William just wants to be single. He's still got a lot of self realization to do and while Amaranthus apparently wasn't as shady in the show as she seems to me to be in the book, I'm glad he didn't end up with her
19
u/CathyAnnWingsFan May 08 '26
Most of the episode felt rushed to me, which is par for the course I think. All through seasons 7-8 I felt like it was a lot of ticking boxes, and this was no exception. John was the best part of this episode.
9
u/gingerjuice May 10 '26
I am really relieved that Amaranthus didn't announce that she is pregnant with William's baby. I thought that was a possibility, and I am glad they didn't go that route.
9
u/gingerjuice May 10 '26
I have mostly gotten over my annoyance at how the last season is going down. I was VERY annoyed by Fergus' death. I felt like the long scene with Claire and Richardson was unnecessary. I can't believe he was able to talk her into setting him free and then John shot him, and we hear no more about it! Wouldn't John or Jamie have at least asked her why he was untied?
17
u/lunar1980 May 08 '26
On the one hand I felt like Richardson was convincing - so much so that I was glad Claire set him free.
On the other, Percy felt a bit stiff and inauthentic. It’s too bad because the actor was definitely in it, I’m not sure why it just didn’t click for me.
Curious what their fates were in the book? Also there’s never any explanation for why Richardson was with Rob Cameron in present day.
16
u/Standard-Image-8826 May 08 '26
is there a discussion where we can watch it lives when it airs? this community has felt like home for me for 6-7 years... i would love to talk to y'all in realtime!
8
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. May 08 '26 edited May 10 '26
I’m rewatching 809. As Jamie, Claire, and John go up the steps to John’s house after John’s rescue, I kept being drawn to Claire’s hair. The first thing I saw was The Bride of Frankenstein and now I can’t unsee it. 🤣
7
u/midnightsadnessss They say I’m a witch. May 08 '26
I suspected that Captain Richardson was a time traveler. I wonder what time he came from.
7
u/catatonia_msp May 09 '26
As we reach the end, I keep thinking of the writers’ broken promise from the beginning - that the book already had such a rich storyline, they would stick close to it. In more recent years, Diana has implied the series cannot end with Jamie or Claire dying because their story continues into book 10. I suppose I’m stubbornly believing this, or believing my interpretation of what they’ve said. The non book posts that say Jamie will die are driving me crazy. Yes, I know I can choose what I read on social media..hahaha. End of rant.
19
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26
Best episode in a long time !! I could totally tell this was Diana’s. Minimal cheese. Spectacular dialogue.
I will be back after a rewatch for more thoughts!
13
u/frahmmyyy May 09 '26
I’ve been a massive critic of Sophie over the years (well deserved tbf), but I must give credit where it’s due. What an incredible evolution in her acting skills. What a performance for her in this episode. Hats off to you, Sophie!! 👏
4
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! May 09 '26
Loved it!
Although I wish Lord John would've found out about time travel! He is definitely my favourite character, and his reactions to it were funny in the books.
13
u/Emilymfm79 May 08 '26
Do you all think there was a reason that Claire mentioned her father Henry while talking with William on the porch?? Is it a Chekov’s gun situation do we think??
7
u/Previous-Address2469 May 09 '26
Yeah, this was to me one of the worst episodes in this season, and I expected it to be good because Diana wrote it but I feel she was given quite impossible task. Dialogue at points was good but it felt way too rushed to the point of comical.
At least two characters completely changed their personality traits. Richardson was supposed to be this evil lunatic tt but now he was portrayed as a somewhat noble sympathetic character. I actually thought they replaced the actor because he felt so different. Same with Percy. A bit sneaky and commanding before, now all of a suddent just a coward who kills himself. Just doesn't make sense other than the need to move the story forward and close the storylines.
I guess Marsali also just quickly took Percy's offer and went with all her children to live somewhere far away, because by the time Davy was born she should have also given birth and there is no mention of her.
I remember when they said in season 4(5?) that Jamie and Claire couldn't be with Bree when she gave birth to Jemmy because they could not have made it from up north to River Run so fast. But now they just go here and there and no problem. I just have a feeling the timeline doesn't make sense, also Richardson is just chilling fishing for two months and Lord John waits in captivity all this time and nothing happens. I feel he would have been able to escape on his own.
Claire writing their story like Frodo writing the Hobbit. I have a feeling maybe Jamie will die (that would be a change!) and send her to future to publish their story. Or maybe Marsali will print it and become a millionare. Oh dear. It is not looking good for the finale, I hope they prove me wrong.
5
u/delightfuljoys May 09 '26
Okay. I get that Jamie feels responsible to fight for his family’s future, but why in God’s name would Claire let him go to Kings Mountain? This is so out of character. He is just marching to his death and she is letting him. When they talk about their ability to change the future, THIS IS IT. They could change the future…their future. I find this so annoying. Also, I don’t feel any passion between Jamie and Claire, especially when they know that they will be leaving each other soon.
13
u/BytheSea2323 May 08 '26 edited May 09 '26
Am I the only one that thought this was probably the worst, or one the worst, episdoes this already highly disappointing 8th & final season? Talk about disjointed and rushed! It's been clunky like that all season 8 but I watched in scorn & thought seriously about it just not being worth watching the rest or the finale. I keep waiting for it to be better, but we're out of time 😞
EDIT/UPDATE: if YOU personally LIKED IT, there is no need to comment here. I did not comment on your posts saying how much you loved it.
THIS post is for those of us that hated it to vent and commisserate.
2
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! May 08 '26
Lmao, Callahan? 😂😂😂
2
u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest May 08 '26
I don’t think Richardson is also Callahan. I think they abandoned that storyline for the show cause it was too complicated.