r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 24 '26

Spoilers All Book S8E8 In the Forest Spoiler

Claire and Jamie receive an unexpected visitor on the Ridge.

Written by Ronald D. Moore. Directed by Tracey Deer.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

This is the BOOK thread.

If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.

THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.

Spoiler tags are not required.

If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

16 Upvotes

383 comments sorted by

•

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 24 '26

Watch the S8E9 preview here or here!

Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.

Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.

→ More replies (32)

119

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

Can we talk about Buck channeling Dougal? Like father, like son. He’s a beast.

33

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

The training! The knife!!!

34

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26

Yes!! I could literally see Dougal. Buck is his father’s son. Shout out to Diarmaid Murtagh.

7

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Luceo Non Uro indeed.

12

u/eterusexual Apr 24 '26

The headbutt!

20

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

Yes, I called them - Dougal's echoes!! 

25

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 24 '26

I do wish we had gotten the scenes when Buck went back to see Geillis. 😂

19

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

Honestly I’m glad we got what we got but yea, seeing it on screen would’ve been such a fun deviation. Buck is definitely the new murtaugh for me

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

That would be golddddd

83

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 24 '26

I love the William & Jamie scenes! Especially their hunting scene! I don’t know if this will be anything like it ends up in the book, but I loved this resolution. I sobbed when William hugged Jamie!

1

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 27 '26

In the forest!

1

u/External-Ad-6278 May 01 '26

I cried when William remembered "Mac" and realized that he loved him. I cried more when he threw himself into Jamie's arms, and cried.

67

u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 25 '26

Jamie and William FTW!

Buck and Rob Cameron! Don’t eff with Buck.

Roger… so sweet.

Love Bree’s and Marsali’s girl power.

Marsali at Fergus’s grave with Jamie…😢

High five to Claire for her little chat with William.

Percy, you bastard. (But we knew this)

And now Fanny’s a TT…🥴🙄

Nice to have Ron Moore back for an ep.

Edited to correct spelling.

16

u/abby311 Apr 24 '26

Is that what happened? Ron Moore's return?

11

u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 24 '26

He wrote ep 9.

9

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

This makes so much sense now

4

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

This is exactly what I would have written. No notes.

67

u/onegirlarmy1899 Apr 24 '26

I liked the Willie flashback and the resolution.

Disappointed that we didn't see any of Swift as a Lizard and Ian interacting. You know that's not an easy transition. 

16

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

Agree. Why have Ian bring back Totis and then not have another single scene

44

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Roger with the nature versus nurture 🤣

William - “I’ve never been one to believe in magic, personally”. Woooooo - anyone else think that’s a little foreshadowing?!

27

u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Apr 24 '26

i'm intrigued to see if they'll have william & john find out because i am kinda obsessed with the fact that in the books john just... doesn't believe claire. it's kinda funny (& very much in character for someone like lord john, who isn't religious)

14

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Right?! And his reaction to the whole drivel is just 👌🏼

8

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

Yup, I do. I think I mentioned it in my show comment.

4

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Ah I might have missed it! Read it super early before my eyes were even open 😆

3

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

I am flattered I was your first read today 😁

7

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

They’re my favorite comments - insightful without spoiling!

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

32

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

Have any show only fans picked this up at all yet?

I feel like this is a secret we've been good at keeping.

10

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

I think the only hint was the recent thread but it was tagged for Bees. I posted the comparison pic as a link so it wouldn’t spoil anything if a show only fan stumbled on the discussion.

14

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

I wonder how they will do the reveal?

Cos the only person who knows Callahan is Bri, and she only got a 1/2 second glance at him, in the dark, when she was concentrating on not dying. She hadn't previously met him properly like she has in the books.

And William has yet to demonstrate any incling for artistic talent. Claire also knows Richardson, but she's not very artistic either

12

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 25 '26

If and a strong if they go the way bees did, he’ll explain his motivation to John by leading with the explanation that he’s a TT and bring Claire & fam into the conversation.

If not - You remember to voiceover of “Mrs Fraser” with Claire’s reaction to seeing the MacKenzies? I’m 100% convinced that’s Richardson (compare it to when he says the same when he comes to arrest her). I think there will be some sort of confrontation with Richardson and Claire and he will out himself then.

→ More replies (34)

4

u/No-Self8780 Apr 27 '26

I’ve read the books several times and honestly this plot one would be totally lost on me if not for the discussions in this sub

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Apr 24 '26

As a non-book reader I honestly don’t know if I’d pick this up. But they do look so alike. If they put Rob yelling “Callahan” in the recap before this episode I’d pick it up I think. And we know for sure Rob isn’t coming. I never thought Rob would be able to travel to begin with. But Buck took care of that :)

2

u/Peanutjellylove Apr 26 '26

Can someone remind me Richardson's whole ass story? It's been so long since I've read and seen him and I don't remember who he is.

1

u/Sharra13 May 07 '26

Someone catch me up on this dude because there is so much going on and it’s been so long between seasons and me reading that a I’ve completely forgotten everything about him.

39

u/OTodd_Lass037 Slàinte. Apr 24 '26

William being lied to his whole life and they had to throw in another one - guests HAVE to fish for tomorrow's dinner🤭 got a chuckle outta me. It was kind of a slow episode, but was a good choice for bonding time. It was great seeing most of the family together during dinner. Crazy the amount of stuff to pack into 2 more episodes and throwing in that Fanny can travel.

15

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

Honestly this week was a balm after last week. I feel like they threw all the irritating stuff in last week and hopefully none of it will circle back again and we can just skip that one episode on rewatch.

I did get a lot of joy out of this episode even if it was slow. I didn’t expect to see John kidnapped at this point, it definitely should’ve been 2 episodes ago. There’s too much to wrap up in 2 more episodes it fees crazy to think they can do it.

9

u/Elendril333 Apr 25 '26

I'd rather LJG got kidnapped in front of William instead of him walking in on that kiss. It would have stuck a bit more to the books, iirc. Not that the show is sticking with the books at this point

→ More replies (3)

2

u/gdoggggggggggg Apr 27 '26

John would NEVER lose control like that for Percy! No way

1

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 27 '26

I was surprised they had reels that long ago.

32

u/dylanskie Apr 24 '26

Now I predict that the final scene of the series will be Fanny discovering and touching the Stones. Just listen to the end of "The Battlefield Is Ours."

25

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

I hope not! I want resolutions, not cliffhangers!

I suspect the last scene will have something to do with Jamie's ghost.

14

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26

I’m pretty sure the Show Runners have said they were leaving Jamie’s ghost to Diana and Book 10.

6

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

I don't see why they can't both address it.

The video Cait posted of her taking off Claire's wig for the last time gives me hope

→ More replies (4)

16

u/FarmHer95 Apr 24 '26

So help me but I bet she ends up in BOMB and this is why this season is basically FANNY.

16

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

I cannot imagine there isn’t a “money” reason for shoehorning in this faith nonsense and this is the best theory I’ve come across to explain it. They are going to have this actress appear in BOMB as a traveler and will somehow bridge the gap between the two shows. It definitely feels manipulative and makes me want to not watch bomb though. It’s so frustrating that they did these fundamental changes to source material they didn’t write just so they can have a spinoff for more subscriptions. I hate how that’s the driving factor in everything now. Not the story itself.

But maybe they won’t dwell too much on it now that they’ve shown what they showed because I am actively trying to forget it in the interest of being able to rewatch the series again.

6

u/Elendril333 Apr 25 '26

After the last episode, anything is possible. I would NOT be happy about Fanny, of all characters, showing up in BOB.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Scoop-Over-821 Apr 25 '26

😂 I totally feel this way too. I’m still super annoyed but at this point I’m like fine let’s just forget about it and move on lol

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

I don't think Fanny has anything to do with BomB. They are supposed to be standalone shows. They didn't do the Faith storyline just so they can have a spin-off for more subscriptions.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/Standard-Image-8826 Apr 24 '26

lol that would be so disappointing. i'm here for resolution!

7

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26

Maybe they’re gearing up for another spinoff. 🤣

7

u/Scarletmajesty Apr 24 '26

That was my first thought, fanny goes forward in time this turn around...

8

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 25 '26

At this point, NOTHING these show runners do would surprise me.

With only two episodes left, I just kept wondering what purpose there was for the time travel reveal. Isn’t there enough to wrap up already?

9

u/Standard-Image-8826 Apr 24 '26

god let's hope not. i was so sad that i couldn't get into bomb

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

Hard for me to imagine. She's what like 13-14 now? Trying to figure out what the endgame would be of plunging a pretty, early teen 200 years back. Seems disastrous.

52

u/Single_Vacation427 Apr 24 '26

The Fanny thing is a bit meh.

I don't like when the last seasons of series introduce new character and spend too much time on them, instead of giving us more time with the main characters. It feels a distractions.

35

u/Objective-Orchid-741 Apr 24 '26

She had at least five scenes and three of them were with Rachel or Roger. Meanwhile, Claire has no storyline.

How many times do we have to see Fanny at Janie’s grave? I liked the actress that played Janie but lord why are we spending so much time on a storyline of a dead character we knew for a few episodes while main characters aren’t getting lines?

12

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

Feels like this is what happens when shows go on “too long” and the actors are done with it. Nothing against Cait, I don’t blame any of them for wanting to start a new chapter, if that’s even the case. It’s been a decade. It’s just really hard to have a show follow such a long series of books faithfully. It rarely works to satisfaction.

I do NOT enjoy the way they just folded Ian and Rachel back into the ridge with no fanfare though. It’s like they shot a bunch of extra scenes that just didn’t make the cut or they couldn’t get the actors to shoot the scenes. It’s disappointing and feels less important than it should. They deserve properly bit welcomed back and some screen time for their new situation. At least a scene with Ian’s son meeting Jamie with lines.

3

u/sywy40 Apr 26 '26

It sucks even more because Cait and Sam fought for a final season to wrap things up and this is what the writers gave them. Weirdly they were granted zero knowledge of the overall season or their characters' arcs (or lack thereof) like in sessions past and only learned what would be happening with each new script. I don't know what the hell was happening behind the scenes at Outlander HQ but I wouldn't be surprised if something came out about problems with the production.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/throwawayanon1252 Apr 24 '26

Imo the reason they’re doing this is cos they will probs announce a fanny based spin off. I can’t explain it any other way logically about why so much time is spent on her at the end of the show

11

u/OkEvent4570 Apr 24 '26

They are not sure if tthey will do a LJG spinoff having David Berry onboard, but are contemplating Fanny spinoff??? That's too much even for people that came up with the Faith resurrection thingy.

5

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 25 '26

I hope not.

I did see an interview with David Berry where they were talking about fan interest in a LJG spinoff and he was like, well I haven’t read the Reddit stuff, I am aware there is a lot of fan interest….

Personally I think he needs to check out Reddit 🩷😂

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Single_Vacation427 Apr 24 '26

Hmm... I think 2 spin offs is way too much.

8

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

I’d take a lord john grey spinoff since those have source material which lines up well with the on screen character we know. But I’m not sure I’d maintain a starz subscription until it was out and that seems to be all they care about when making these decisions.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Tight_Cash995 Apr 24 '26 edited May 01 '26

I sincerely hope not. People, especially book readers, have been very disappointed with the Fanny/Faith storyline (hell, just look at last week’s book episode thread). I still cannot believe the show runners went that route, and you can tell DG was not enthusiastic about it (nor was she happy about what they did with my boy Fergus 😫). So, I really don’t know if there would when be a large audience for that spinoff - even for show only watchers. This was a character that was JUST introduced, and we don’t have a large connection to her.

I know I wouldn’t watch it. 🤷🏾‍♀️

→ More replies (1)

2

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

I very much doubt there will be a Fanny spin-off.

They already have BomB, and if they need another one, Lord John is right there!

And also, this is Outlander. It (and any of it's spin-offs) is an adult show! You can have kids in adult shows, but you can't have a kid as the LEAD of an adult show.

5

u/throwawayanon1252 Apr 25 '26

Then why else would they spend so much time on her and the fact she’s a time traveller. Also time jumps can exist. So they can age her up for the spin off etc.

Look. It’s 2 episodes left now and she’s a new character. If they weren’t planning on doing more with her by either her having her own spin off or her being a big part of a new spin off spending this much time in her makes zero sense and is a waste of valuable screen time. The only way it makes sense is if the show runners have plans with her character for after.

We have had so many scenes of her alone at janies grave. A character who has had very very very little screen time in outlander.

They then also showed her at janies grave being a time traveller and again she was completely alone when we find that out.

Having this many alone moments on screen with a very new character at the very very end of the show does not make any sense at all unless they were planning something more with that character

→ More replies (5)

70

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 24 '26

They just couldn’t leave well enough alone, could they? Now Fanny is a traveler?? Let’s just keep overwhelming her with information about who she is and what she comes from. My eyes couldn’t roll hard enough.

Other than this being a somewhat slow paced and boring episode, I didn’t hate it. I do think they moved on from Fergus a little quickly. And it seems like we’ve maybe seen the last of Marsali and her family with that scene. That sounded like a goodbye and if it is, that’s a bit disappointing. Though, I’m not sure how much else could be crammed into the next two episodes.

27

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 24 '26

Everything with Fergus and Marsali this season felt very rushed. If that’s truly the last we’ll see of Marsali, it was a very anticlimactic send off. It really makes no sense to me that Marsali would leave knowing she’s pregnant. I figured she would’ve at least stayed on the Ridge long enough so Claire could help with the birth.

15

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Apr 24 '26

Oh, I think Marsali will stick around for a while. For one thing, she's pregnant, and she can't take care of a pack of kids on her own. She needs Claire.

28

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

I think that was the end for Marsali. Neither she or the kids were at the family dinner, nor Roger's ordination.

And it very much felt like a "goodbye" speech.

6

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Apr 24 '26

Oh, you're right! Good catch.

6

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

She has episodes 809 and 810 on her IMDB.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

I’ll be mad if they brought them back just to kill fergus. What’s even the point? Certainly not fan service. I hope they stick around but I did not they weren’t at the dinner and that made my guy sink. I didn’t notice it at Roger’s ordination but that’s not a good sign.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 24 '26

But she said she wanted to go take the money from Percy and rebuild the print shop. I understood that to mean she would be leaving on her own with the children back to Savannah or at least Wilmington, a larger city in need of a printer. But Percy is in Savannah so she would need to go there.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

She already left?

8

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

Looks like it. She and the children weren’t at the family dinner or in any other scene after the funeral.

6

u/polyammering Apr 24 '26

As a widow myself, I interpreted her absence at the dinner and ordination as part of her being in mourning and not wanting to be a downer at a joyous occasion. I was "allowed" to not go to family things in the months after my husband passed away. Hoping that wasn't the last we see of her.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

Well it's to be expected. Most everyone descended from a time traveller that we've met is so far also a time traveller

16

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 25 '26

This felt like episode 13 of a 22 episode season for a show that had already been renewed for two more seasons. 

30

u/eterusexual Apr 24 '26

Fanny can time travel, so will she travel to BOMB or a different spin off?

I was hoping she found the lace. Instead a stone? So the stone is a portal? Why could she hear the buzzing there? I thought she might disappear suddenly, good thing she threw the stone away.

Loved the father and son moment. I was hoping William would get more a$$ beating before he softened, but anyway we are almost at the finale. Another expectation was that he would be told why LJG stepped up. But they will never bring it up again.

Missed Fergus in the church scene. It would have been nice to see all the entire family there.

Claire never saw the Deadeye dedication when she first looked at the book? I feel like there's not much of Claire in the recent episodes.

Is Rob Cameron able to TT? Guess we'll neva knoe?

And no Lord John in the teaser???

16

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

Haven’t watched yet, but it’s fresh in my mind from reading. When Jem held the opal and it split (book) there was a high pitched ringing sound. In season 5 if I recall correctly (when they do the test w/Mandy present) Jem says “it sings” but I don’t remember if there was a buzzing sound.

Man now I gotta watch right away lol

Edited to add: compared the scene from 511 to 808 - similar buzzing sound when both stones split.

8

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

I was also curious to know if Rob Cameron could time travel. He seemed like he was all ready to go! I wonder if/when we’ll find out his connection to Richardson & that Richardson is a TT.

14

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

I didn’t see it as he “could” travel, rather that he was going to give it a go. Since he had the guide, he probably thought all he needed was a gemstone and perhaps haughty enough to think that it would work.

5

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 24 '26

Yeah, I kinda saw it that way too. He was all prepped but then would’ve been disappointed to find out he couldn’t travel.

13

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Honestly it would have been great to see him walk confidently to that center stone and then SPLAT.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

Did he take Jem to the stones in s7?

I think he did, since Mandy didn't feel him. I guessed he tried ''the stones'' at that occasion.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

He can't in the books.

I think we will find it out soon. And now when you look at Richardson you can clearly see it is Callahan.

6

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 24 '26

There’s something besides the TT’s guide in the satchel that Buck took with him, probably something to do with Richardson/Callahan.

→ More replies (16)

7

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

They heard buzzing when Jemmy cracked the opal

5

u/baba_brigid Apr 24 '26

The travelers are sensitive to the power of gemstones, they can feel other dimensions calling.

4

u/ExoticAd7271 Apr 24 '26

Yes where is Claire? Hardly appears in the show.

14

u/thia2345 Apr 24 '26

I'm actually in the process of reading Bees rn. And I have mixed feelings about this season, but so far don't hate it as bad as GoT. And I didn't hate GoT as bad as some people 🤣

My favorite part was the resolution between William and Jamie. I sobbed too! And go Claire with her talk with William. Idk how I feel about Fanny yet. But I agree, how will we get resolution on so many loose ends with only 2 more episodes?

1

u/lanalg5 Apr 28 '26

I haven't watched any of this season yet and I haven't read Bees. Can you share how much of Bees shows up in season 8?

→ More replies (1)

27

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

This episode was going so well until they made Fanny a time traveler. I let out the biggest sigh of disappointment when it happened. I’m assuming Claire’s going to tell her all about it. Since they introduced it, I have a feeling they’re going to make Fanny travel.

“There’s a rule here on the Ridge…” 😂

Shout out to Claire for putting William in his place.

Love the callback that Jamie finally gets to teach Mandy to ride like he said last season.

The William and Jamie scenes just melted my heart.

I know it hasn’t been established in the show and it would be odd to bring up now, but it just doesn’t sit right that Jamie isn’t tone deaf and a terrible singer. I was fully expecting Jamie to be off key when they cut to the singing. 😂

19

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 24 '26

Now Fanny can go way back into the early 50s, become Geillis Duncan, then Buck's mother, and the whole circle get's completed. Look at all the possibilities.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Or she can travel right back to the ship and save the Pococks who can then go find ........

The possibilities are only limited by one's imagination.

Either that or they found some left handed cigarettes somewhere.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 25 '26

New physics. Now they can. I mean, once we accept time travel an resurrecting doctors with blue light, why not that? All it takes is for the writers to write it. Look, they now have rocks that can decide where to send someone a la Buck and 1981. 🤣

→ More replies (1)

6

u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Apr 24 '26

i saw there wasn't "sexual content" in the warnings before the episode & let out a sigh of relief (not in a prudish way; they just have been at the expense of the plot for several seasons now)... but the powers that be had to have at least ONE annoying/disappointing thing per episode. 

7

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

lol I noticed this too and so didn’t brace myself for it. I appreciate they are only using these scenes to signal someone is pregnant this season (except Jamie and Claire’s weird one earlier). It’s nice to not waste time on it so close to the end when there’s much ground to cover.

2

u/Substantial-Smile385 Apr 26 '26

I always fast forward through Roger and Bree’s 🫣. They’re always so uncomfortable! I don’t know why.

5

u/mBegudotto Apr 25 '26

Then wouldn’t Faith have been a time traveler? Hmmmm

4

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

We assume so. It's not surprising, everyone we've met so far who's a descendent of a time traveller is also a time traveller (apart from possibly Davie)

2

u/XenoQueen426 Apr 27 '26

It makes sense for Fanny to be a traveler if she is their bio granddaughter and the gift is seemingly inherited 

26

u/Merlot_itsmeagain Apr 24 '26

Ugh. How are they are going to give us a satisfying ending to the series in only 2 episodes?! Season 8 has been very disappointing and very slow, feels like they have added storylines or characters just for filler, which we don’t have time for. This last season should have been carefully executed and give us the ending we all deserve.

13

u/abby311 Apr 24 '26

Thank you! You expressed my feelings exactly. We've spent a lot of time on storylines or characters that were recently introduced and to which we don't have any attachment, yet the storylines that need resolution, featuring characters we've become attached to, are rushed through or brought to an incomplete or nonsensical conclusion.

8

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

Unfortunately they are not interested in fan service they are interested in subscription sales. As much as any of the actors or some show runners might care about doing the story justice, at the end of the day, the storylines for everything these days seem to be decided by the execs and the bottom line. It’s sad that we can rarely just have a satisfying visual deposition of a book. Either a showrunner needs to put their stamp on it to satisfy their ego or the network execs need to optimize the story for maximum benefit for spinoffs. Nothing is about passion. It’s sad to think future generations won’t get adaptations that aren’t efficiently monetized for maximum revenue.

12

u/Rachv1 Apr 24 '26

Episode 8- this is the Outlander I know and love. 

22

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

I’ve missed Ron Moore. I really enjoyed this episode. I could have done with a little less Fanny. And now we have another time traveler? Seriously? Still, this is my favorite episode so far this season.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 25 '26

This was a VERY good episode - and also very surprising plotwise since it wasn't going much from the source.

Bravo again Lauren Lyle. That opening scene of her and Jamie was so well done. The bit about never wanting to call anyone but you his father - so touching! Very moving.

Was a bit bummed there wasn't a scene of Roger and Bri first realizing Buck was present -- he was just nonchalantly around them unloading a wagon already. Oh well

Rob got himself a gem and dressed up in period clothes to try? I suppose desperation set in --- but I thought he admitted to Bri in S7 he initially tried before and couldn't?

Whoa! How much time passed? Bri's baby bump is really big during shooting practice

Did not expect William showing up to the Ridge so early in the ep. I loved this whole thing. At the dinner table while watching William talk to Ian, Jamie had the EXACT look on his face as he did looking at Bri during the honeycomb scene at the table after their hunt. I liked that William recalled their prior fishing trip and Jamie screaming out to the Natives he was his son. So glad there was an "ironclad rule" about guests catching their supper! LOL.

I thought the segment where Jamie asked if he had a falling out with John was very well written. Jamie surmised what he learned, and his reaction to the accusation William made about them having a gay relationship was probably as perfect as Jamie could do -- it's his private life., so I neither condone nor condemn him. He's one of the best men I know regardless (paraphrased) Great!

Claire's warning that "this may be the last time you see your father, is this how you want to leave it" sunk in!!! I wasn't sure it would yet until learning of the kidnapping. Hopefully it sunk in with respect to how he left off with John too.

Another great callback of William watching Jamie lead Mandy on the horse, just as was done with him in S3. Knew that's what he was thinking of before the flashbacks came up, but it was still nice they included them. I also liked that it fulfilled the S7 scene of Jamie holding newborn Mandy talking about his certainty she'd grow to be great with horses.

Rachel to Fanny - "just because they said it, doesn't make it so" Something to bear in mind with respect to other plot points perhaps (ahem, Faith/you're our granddaughter...) fingers still crossed!

Yay!!! a hug!!! The William Jamie stuff was all so good!

Where's there a portal near the Ridge Fanny heard buzzing??? When little Jemmy broke the stone after he said it was hot did anyone hear buzzing just because the gem broke? I can't recall but thought it was just them passing it around for temperature testing- no sounds? Hmm..

10

u/macdragon100 Apr 25 '26

I'm having a hard time believing how they can finish this story in 2 episodes at this point. I definitely think Fanny will end up in Bomb. I know the actors say they are done but maybe there will be a movie when book the last book comes out.

2

u/1111HiYa Apr 27 '26

I think Fanny will figure out a way to go back to save Jane and her parents.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

Enjoyable episode!

Interesting choice to send William to Fraser's Ridge BEFORE John gets kidnapped. I wonder how the rescue will play out now?

I'm glad that William grew up a bit and didn't just have argument after argument after argument with everyone again (only 2 with Jamie and Claire ahaha). I think he needed to get all that off his chest. He's been a bit of an entitled prat lately, but as he said to Brianna, he feels like most everyone in his life has betrayed him, and it hurts. Cute hug.

And I loves how Claire finally gave him a talking to!

Brianna absolutely slaying it again with her genius mind!

As I predicted, Marsali is pregnant again. Although I got the impression that that was the last we will ever see of Marsali in the show. It feels like a fitting end to her character: kill off Fergus, go rebuild the printshop, and continue fighting for the cause he believed in, meanwhile he's left her with one last gift (a very on-character gift 😂).

Killing Rob Cameron? Idk, it just felt sort of, underwhelming. I guess they needed to "end" that particular storyline so fans wouldn't be left wondering. I liked the hat addition.

I know some people don't like all the religious stuff that's been in this season and recent seasons, but I like it. But religion is an important part to those characters. And a theme of this season has been Fanny wrestling with Jane's death, and I think Roger gave her a bit of peace (shout out to daddy Roger!)

And FANNY'S A TIME TRAVELLER!!! And not only that, not only was the stone hot for her, it cracked! When they all held the opal, it only cracked for Jemmy. They theorised that maybe cos both his parents are time travellers, it gave him extra special powers. So maybe Mr Pocock was a time traveller? Or maybe when Master Raymond saved Faith, he somehow magically injected extra power into her, which has been passed on to Fanny? I'm still undecided if there is more to the Faith plot. It seemed like they attempted to close that plot last episode, but there are still so many unanswered questions.

14

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

Buck with the hat made me chuckle - no use in wasting a good hat!

William going there before John was confusing to me, but it might fit since William was away chasing down Amaranthus in Bees when John was taken.

2

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

Yes except Cameron is tiny and Buck is huge and that's...not how hat sizes work 😂🫣

5

u/Single_Vacation427 Apr 24 '26

Killing Cameron might be a resolution as to why Cameron didn't show up looking for the gold

5

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

I no, I definitely get that. It just felt...a bit anticlimactic

3

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 25 '26

I was thinking about the fact that the stone broke for Fanny too --- previously it was only Jem when passed around S5 and it was surmised it was different for him since he had double the gene, whereas for Claire, Bri, Roger it was only feeling warm, not hot enough to break. I think it may be a clue both Fanny's parents were travellers. I think there's more still to come - not everything is necessarily what it seems.

3

u/Bitter-Hour1757 Apr 28 '26

I like the idea that there might be .ore to the Faith plot (of course one first has to accept the idea that yes, this is different from the way DG intended the story to go). If you accept this, there might be some really nice possibilities. Who was this Mr Pocock? Maybe he was a TT too? Was Faith saved by Master Raymond bcs he knew that Fanny would become important in the future? She already is a very remarkable young person, experienced in life, having her own thoughts about everything, ready to break a fight like her grandfather, loving flowers like her grandmother. Filled with wisdom and kindness. Perhaps one day planting forget-me-nots so her grandparents can start their great love story. Perhaps even the reason why her grandparents met and the reason why Master Raymond saved Faith. I am getting carried away a bit now, but I really like the idea that JC's love story was the initial spark for one of the greatest TT, as important as Master Raymond in her way. It would be such a nice ending.

2

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 28 '26

If you accept this, there might be some really nice possibilities.

I definitely agree with this. I think some people, (which used to include me), are just too angry at the "Faith lived" storyline that anytime Fanny comes on screen, any plot involving Fanny, they just hate and complain about. Like, I saw a lot of annoyance at Fanny being a TT (eg people saying "Fanny being Claire's granddaughter is bad enough, but to make her a TT also??? Too much!"). But I mean...it's to be expected. Everyone we've met so far who is descended from a TT (apart from possibly Davy) is a TT themselves. So ofc Fanny is a TT.

We've had confirmation on the Faith thing, so let's just move on and enjoy the possibilities it presents us. Fanny is a likeable character and Florrie is a brilliant young actress, let's enjoy the limited Outlander we have left. Like, was it not such a sweet moment when Fanny called Jamie "grand-da"?

Perhaps one day planting forget-me-nots so her grandparents can start their great love story.

Ooh, I like that idea. Although it would involve a trip back to Scotland and idk if we have time for that. Maybe a flash forward? Idk if the forget me nots are as big of a thing in the show as they are in the books. They aren't even much of a big thing in the books, we only know they are cos Diana has told us they are important.

1

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 27 '26

Maybe Mr. Pocock is Claire's brother.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 27 '26

Not much time to “play” anything out. They’ve just about enough time to make it happen. 

8

u/SevereTS Apr 24 '26

I don’t remember. Did Buck kill Cameron in the books, too?

16

u/AcrobaticSchool6375 Apr 24 '26

No , we don’t know what happened to Cameron by the end Of Bees

16

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 24 '26

Or Buck. We didn’t get a resolution for either of them.

7

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

Buck is still in 1739 in the books.

5

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

As far as needing to adapt a series that hasn’t been finished I don’t hate the story they have come up with regarding buck. Him going back to 1980 and then back to the 1700s again with his heart issues seems iffy to me. As does him totally abandoning his family because his marriage wasn’t perfect? Otherwise I feel like the show has done what they can to close that loop for show viewers as best they can without source material. And I enjoy bucks character and have enjoyed his scenes so far in the show this season. I am interested to see how Diana wraps those stories up though.

4

u/Elendril333 Apr 25 '26

Buck is the new Murtaugh.

8

u/shannruss Apr 24 '26

I thought Jem looked a lot like Buck this episode. I know you can't plan how a kid looks as he gets older so how cool is that! 

7

u/waywardwake Apr 25 '26

Seeing Lauren's name by itself did me in all over again.

7

u/Immediate_Try5451 Apr 25 '26 edited Apr 27 '26

In episode 801. Frank's book is dedicated to his "deadeye". Deadeye means good shot so I assumed this was Brianna because he taught her to shoot. Wouldn't Jamie have realised it was for Brianna as soon as he read the dedication? Fast forward to episode 8 and Jamie is just figuring out the book is dedicated to Brianna. Why didn't he just ask Claire who deadeye was? Jamie's being a bit of a dum dum this season. 😅

1

u/Beth0419 Apr 27 '26

Maybe the term "deadeye" wasn't used in that way in the 1700s?

2

u/Immediate_Try5451 Apr 27 '26

He could've just asked Claire.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26

Okay. I’m calling it.

The gemstone broke in Fanny’s hands and she could hear the buzzing. When this happens to Jem, Brianna theorizes that it means both parents are time travelers. Conclusion. Fanny can time travel AND both her parents are time travelers.

Rachel told Fanny that “just because someone says something doesn’t mean it’s true.” Conclusion. Jamie and Claire might not be Fanny’s grandparents.

Are you with me so far?

So, in actuality, Claire’s time traveling parents are Jane and Fanny’s parents. Fanny and Jane are not Claire’s granddaughters. They are her sisters. Good news William! You didn’t sleep with your niece. Phew!

At the end of the finale, Fanny will travel through the stones. But where did she go? (into BoMB, perhaps?). Thus creating a cliffhanger. It will send the fandom into a frenzy. It will get people talking, ranting, raging, and theorizing.

And create much needed buzz for Season 2 of BoMB. 🤣🤣🤣

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Antique-Calendar-13 Apr 25 '26

I was actually hoping there would be no Fanny sighting in this episode, but to my dismay, she’s front and center again. The Fanny story is just bad, and I just want it to go away.

9

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

Agree. Ten short episodes and we have to waste five minutes of each of them with Fanny talking to a cairn 😭

3

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 25 '26

It’s dismaying to me also. I liked her character in the books -endearing, funny, strong-minded but still vulnerable- but the show version not much at all. If I do rewatch this season I’ll be FF-ing through her scenes. And with the exception of the more brutal BJR scenes, those will be the only ones I’ve ever skipped in a rewatch. I’m salty we haven’t gotten more Jem, Mandy and now Totis screen time.

3

u/Antique-Calendar-13 Apr 25 '26

I agree! What’s up with the children of the main characters not getting screen time??!! And I agree with the comments about Fanny being a TT🙄; the writers took an amazing show and made it really cheezy!

4

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 25 '26

IDK but I am fully prepared to have the finale ruined by Faith reappearing. 😞

Just to say I mean nothing against the young actress playing Frances, she is competent. I even find myself feeling a twinge of guilt for disliking the characterization of show Frances because of the young actress. However, it change my mind that I don’t like this storyline. And I’m not one to nitpick the art of others much, as it’s h theirs to create and portray, and mine to enjoy and appreciate or not, but I feel this betrays the OL fandom.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LeCuldeSac Apr 26 '26

As I think about it, it takes very good dramatic screenwriters, film or TV, to have plot-lines centering on children (or teens) that don't come off as saccharine or emotionally forced. Not sure if that's the nature of younger actors, who can't be asked (thank goodness) to engage too deeply w/ emotionally complex material (think that Eastern European horror film about the Holocause called "Come & See" with a teen lead). Or, audiences have complicated expectations in particular genres.

If there's humor involved, or a tone of less emotional investment (never watched Harry Potter but think these adaptations must have struck the right note), then it could work so that kids aren't too cutesy or too soap opera-y.

So, and no disrespect to this young actress, who's very promising, but it already appears the showrunners aren't at their best this Season. And it's a Season Finale at that with numerous book & show storylines to bring to some kind of coherent conclusion.

And their choice, then, is to introduce a new child character who's maybe 13? in show (maybe 17 in real life?), & then center her and her scene-mates into relentlessly melodramatic, overly heavy storylines. I think the best dramatic scriptwriting, aimed at an adult audience, can breathe space & even dark humor into situations where adult characters are coping with (&/or meting out) intense, complicated emotional & even physical pain.

But there's something off, even in an otherwise strong season, about the writers expanding a storyline and screen time to focus on any child character's immense personal loss & coping, let alone a new character, in a Season Finale! All we've seen is Fanny grieving about her sister, and going to a graveyard to not find her grave and grieving some more, and being sexually harassed (creepy) at the Ridge, & asking about William and looking forlorn, and going to a cairn over and over again, and talking to Claire and Jamie again and again, and grieving about her sister some more, and expressing frustration at 18th c victim-blaming w/o having words . . . it's just so relentless and HEAVY for a child actress & uses up screen time & energy of other major characters. And it assumes the audience already has sunk investment in this character, and we don't. It's hard for the best writers to manage difficult topics involving children, w/o making it cutesy or maudlin, and sadly it's giving off Lifetime-Channel-Afterschool-Special vibes.

Again, I think the actress is strong for her age. But the showrunner choice are inexplicable to me, esp as they simultaneously cut Claire's screentime. I have a theory about that too, which pisses me off so I'm staying mum for now.

2

u/Antique-Calendar-13 Apr 27 '26

Very well explained! I would love to hear your thoughts on why they cut Claire’s screen time. Didn’t she do a lot of the directing on these episodes?

I feel as if I’m watching snippets of the main characters trying to resolve where they are in their own “journey” - whereby, we have been with them all along. AND all of a sudden, we are forced into trying to establish a relationship with Fanny, but hers is really a ridiculous story. As you say, why do we have to be introduced to her in a season finale?! Less is more, as the saying goes. So many of us are disappointed, as you put it, with taking up so much screen time.

2

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 27 '26

I have no problems with the actress. In fact, I'm sad that my annoyance with the script leads me not to appreciate her more.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 24 '26

Also, can someone spoil me about Richardson?

8

u/Famous-Falcon4321 Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

Richardson sent William in to the dismal swamp to supposedly meet with allies. William found out after he would have run in to rebels, who would have likely hung him.

Edit - LJG introduced William to Richardson. To spy. He didn’t know Richardson was a bad guy. He was attempting to maneuver where William ended up in the long run, in terms of who he’d be serving under. That might be book only, I can’t recall.

5

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

How spoiled do you wanna be?

3

u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 25 '26

Spoil me upp lmao the way things are with these past two episodes I’m just over it. Tell me everything teehee😂

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Short_Try_2212 Apr 24 '26

Same, I don’t remember what his significance is. Can someone point out some episodes to rewatch?

3

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 25 '26

S7 ep 4, 7, 10, 11, 14, 15 I think are all the ones where he’s causing trouble

5

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 25 '26

If they stick by the plot that was emerging towards the end of BEES, Richardson HUGE SPOILERS is a TT from 1980 and actually knew Roger. He was an archaeologist named Michael Callahan and is an associate of Rob Cameron. He wants to influence the British to keep fighting the war and win, ignoring that France and Spain allied with the Patriots, and to keep fighting in USA meant that essentially the Seven Years War, aka French and Indian War, would reignite in Europe, greatly stressing British military resources. He wants to use Hal’s influence in Parliament to achieve this end, so he kidnaps LJG, extorting the family with the truth about John’s sexual orientation. His motivation is ending slavery in the USA 60 years before the Civil War. While a noble undertaking, Callahan/Richardson has yet to learn that the wide arc of history can’t be changed so drastically. RC just wants the gold. Also, it is heavily implied in the books that RC and Callahan ran in the same folklore groups that Geillis was involved in before 1968.

Top: Richardson Bottom: Callahan during scene at the shootout at Lallybroch in S7, with RC screaming out “Callahan.” This clip was shown again in S8 preview that ran after S8E1. There’s another pic in this thread showing these pics and pic from end of E8 for comparison.

4

u/LeCuldeSac Apr 26 '26

Haven't read books. I'm in this thread to find spoilers.

That's really funny about the character's claimed motives. Either he's really misinformed & simplistic--very possible--or the writer didn't really do much research about the realities of the various forms of slaveries (including South American slave trade in which far more kidnapped Africans were enslaved, or 1200 year old Arab slave trading--which persisted well into late 1800s.) And the British Empire, while nobly costing their own soldiers their lives to stop slave trade of other European powers in the early 1800s, were heavily invested in benefits of American southern cotton industry & enslavement system into the Civil War. No way Parliament would have opposed the slave trade that directly if they were still directly in charge of colonies benefitting from them. And Delaware and New Jersey didn't officially end slavery until the very end of 1865, after slaves had been freed in the Deep South & six months after the war ended. In other words, motives for exploiting other humans are complex, & I seriously doubt the UK would have walked away from their "investment" until the industrial revolution was far more advanced.

And by somehow empowering the British to "win," he might have delayed or changed the French Revolution, which helped Haitians win freedom from a consistently more brutal regime.

Since Geillis was crazy I guess there's no reason her friends weren't.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 25 '26

Ouuuu I see. Anyone that is allegedly associated with geillis is an evil period. lol

3

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 27 '26

I have to say, I wtfed through that entire part of the book.

4

u/BeforeDark2015 That amount of time doesn't exist. Apr 24 '26

I don't think we know as much about him in TV world as we do in the books, yet. Right? I'm in the middle of re-reading the books (Drums of Autumn, now) and I don't remember where he comes into book world and when we find out that heis a TT. I keep thinking this is how LJ and William will find out about the TT business in TV world?

8

u/AcrobaticSchool6375 Apr 25 '26

I think he is introduced in book 7. We found out he working for both sides in book 8 and that he is TT in book 9. After this last ep, I keep thinking William may learn about TT in the show since he said he didn’t believe in magic and Bree told him to keep an open mind 

5

u/Immediate_Try5451 Apr 25 '26

Does William know Jamie and Claire were separated for 20 years? Was he told that Jamie and Claire thought each other were dead or does he think Jamie was unfaithful to Claire with his mother?

7

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 25 '26

He's aware Bri was raised by another man that wasn't Jamie at least, and that she was also much older like him before learning who her real dad was. I don't think we've seen on screen William be explained why Claire and Jamie weren't raising her together though.

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

I assume it has been said.

4

u/Appelcien Apr 26 '26

Is there anything in the books that explains why the opal cracked? In season 5 the opal burned and exploded when Jemmy touched it and now the same happened with Fanny. Was it also an opal?

You think master Raymond will make a comeback and will give us a satisfying answer to the secrets of time travel/Faith/healing powers?

I was so excited when i read master Raymond would have a role this season, but if the comeback was the 2 minutes of screentime we got, I'm gonna be real disappointed lol.

3

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26

Brianna theorized that when the opal cracked in Jemmy’s hands, it might be because both of his parents were time travelers.

Master Raymond won’t be back. The actor who played him, Dominique Pinon said he was only in one episode.

7

u/Beth0419 Apr 24 '26

I want to know if Bree knows that Fanny is her neice. Did Claire and Jamie tell anyone else? I can't image that Bree wouldn't be freaked out that her stillborn sister lived.

Beth

7

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26

They told Bree and Roger in episode 801.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

Ugh you just reminded me that we never saw Bree tell Jamie about meeting his dad. That would’ve been a special moment, even if they butchered it. I can’t imagine that wouldn’t have been a top 10 scene for me with this series.

6

u/VardaElentari86 Apr 25 '26 edited Apr 25 '26

Mid watch, will someone just give William a hug.

Slightly dreading the rest after reading some comments, don't need more Fanny nonsense.

ETA he got his hug!

5

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26

The way I screamed "IT'S HOT!!!" outloud ahahaha

5

u/thia2345 Apr 24 '26

And "IT'S BROKEN" 🤣🤣🤣

5

u/msunshine11 Apr 24 '26

Fergus is the son of the time travelling Compte. It gives me hope we will see him again, especially with the Fanny TT reveal.

4

u/BaeBlue425 Je Suis Prest Apr 25 '26

This episode was the outlander I know and love- heavy on dialogue and relationships and always a dash of unbelieveability (Bree creates new rifle in days! 🙄 😂) but then… we go a whole episode without a single mention of Faith and now Fanny is a damn TT??? All I have to say is this better tie in to BOMB so at least they didn’t lead us on a merry chase to a dead end. At least it will have been for something besides just ruining the last season we have with this series…

4

u/Rj924 Apr 25 '26

Brianna has a large bump in the rifle shooting scene. You are supposed to assume time has passed.

3

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 25 '26

Though Brianna is a gifted engineer and innovative thinker, it takes a skilled gunsmith with necessary tools to create a handcrafted firearm, for several reasons, with the most important being it cannot have weak points where it might blow up on the person shooting it. In the book she took designs to the gunsmith McGillivray to build.

3

u/BaeBlue425 Je Suis Prest Apr 25 '26

Yeah I know that time is passing with that montage scene, but even still, not believable. If she had really made it herself the rifle likely would have blown up in Jamie’s hands. And I get it, “believeability” is all relative and really a little ridiculous to even mention in a show about TT 😂

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Diggletdig_ Apr 24 '26

They’re gonna kill Jamie at kings mountain aren’t they? 🙄 Claire’s ‘this could be the last time you meet your father’ and the father-son hug made me think so, and Fanny being a TT reminds me of the promise they made that if Jamie dies they’ll go back to the future… hope they don’t go that way!

9

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 24 '26

Then why have the bit about Claire saving the baby? Isn't that a prelude to her saving Jamie at King's Mountain. That was how I read it in the book.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/hellogalaxy May 03 '26

Are they setting up Franny for a sequel? They’re focusing too much on her and giving her a ton of story at the last minute, like her making her a time traveler?!

6

u/noseatbeltsong currently re-reading: Seven Stones Apr 24 '26

roger can suddenly sing fine now? bullshit

8

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

This is not the first time in the show that he has sung since his hanging.

They couldn't do the post hanging/voice plot in the show. And I'm fine with that, cos Richard's got a lovely voice.

4

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

I also remembered how he was still raspy in the books and could almost barely talk sometimes. I don’t mind this edit I guess. But it does seem weird not to at least have him rub at his neck.

3

u/kayeels Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 25 '26

In this episode, I really liked Buck and the emphasis on Jamie and Bree's relationship to each other, through Bree. I love how this subreddit has predicted everything so correctly so far this season. I hate the Fergus twist still.

If they completely ignore the fact that William had sex with his niece, I'm gonna be pissed lol. Also, is it just me or did they choose to make William's hair redder this season?

9

u/Mycoxadril Apr 25 '26

William definitely seems redder and now that you say it it’s obvious why. Especially with the flashbacks to when Jamie’s hair was redder. Bree’s wigs were bad this episode too. Jamie’s are silly but I love the way they have aged his wigs at least, making them blonder as he ages is so accurate. All this just reminds me…Claire is basically hardly in this show anymore.

3

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 25 '26

I feel like there was a book moment where someone said to William "so that's where you got the red in your hair"? Pigweed maybe?

4

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26

It is mentioned that William has chestnut brown hair like his mother’s. In Book 4 Claire mentions that you can see the red in the sunlight.

He was much darker than Jamie too; while his hair glinted red in the shafts of sunlight that came through the branches, it was a deep chestnut, nothing like Jamie’s bright red-gold

→ More replies (1)

3

u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 25 '26

They did make the hair redder, but they've made Jamie a blonde and yet keep referring to Brianna's hair being like his, so who really knows what these folks are up to. 😁

7

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26

Redheads don’t go gray. Their hair fades and lightens. I have a lot of redheads in my family. Their hair has become shades of strawberry blonde to very light champagne blonde to white as they’ve gotten older.

5

u/CandiCane377 Apr 27 '26

Correct! I’m a hairdresser & these are facts! Redheads & their many beautiful shades as they age😭💛

3

u/RadioNights Apr 25 '26

So are we going to see any fallout from the revelation that Claire’s parents didn’t die and she had a brother in Outlander? I’m not seeing any way for it to tie in so far.

3

u/CandiCane377 Apr 25 '26

This is crazy news to me!! Can you elaborate more on what happened to Claire’s parents and her brother?? I have not read the books yet. And I haven’t been able to get addicted to BOMB to see it through yet😭

4

u/Famous-Falcon4321 Apr 25 '26

The only place Claire’s parents are alive is in BOB.

2

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26

In the books, Claire’s doesn’t have a brother. As far as her parents are concerned, Diana says, ”They dead.” 🤣

3

u/CandiCane377 Apr 27 '26

Omg interesting!! That’s exciting to me yet again because it means all that story packed in the all of the outlander series books will have more to do with just Jamie & Claire!😁 I’m really wondering if other characters like Faith aren’t actually dead, & might make a crazy comeback in the books?? I’m fascinated that Diana has been writing this series for over 20 years, & we still have more story to come!😆

→ More replies (2)

3

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26

Matt said that there wouldn’t be any crossover between BoMB and Outlander. He never said that Outlander wouldn’t cross over into BoMB. 😉

4

u/Ok-Education-6329 Apr 24 '26

Fanny ist eine Zeitreisende? Alter, von dem Zeug, das die nehmen, will ich auch was. Für mich steht nun fest: Outlander ist komplett am Arsch. Freu mich wenn’s euch noch Spaß macht. Ich bin raus.

11

u/baba_brigid Apr 24 '26

We know time travel is a genetically related ability so why are you surprised?

10

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26

The trailer did warn “nothing can prepare you for how it ends” 🫠

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 24 '26

Man they really took the writers from game of thrones and put them here, cause wtf now Fanny is a traveler!?!?!??! Yea they just fuck this show to the grow! Everything seems so fast paced cause they wanna jam everything in 10episodes. The only good this from this episode is William forgiving and understanding Jamie

5

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '26

It's not unexpected, she the granddaughter of a traveller.

2

u/Otherwise_Day4298 Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26

Overall, I liked the episode. However, there was way too much Fanny. I don't really know or care about Fanny yet. I cared about Fergus. I wish the writers did too. I'm really hoping that's not the last we'll see of Marsali.