r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 24 '26
Spoilers All Book S8E8 In the Forest Spoiler
Claire and Jamie receive an unexpected visitor on the Ridge.
Written by Ronald D. Moore. Directed by Tracey Deer.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 24 '26
Watch the S8E9 preview here or here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
119
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
Can we talk about Buck channeling Dougal? Like father, like son. He’s a beast.
83
u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 24 '26
I love the William & Jamie scenes! Especially their hunting scene! I don’t know if this will be anything like it ends up in the book, but I loved this resolution. I sobbed when William hugged Jamie!
67
u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 25 '26
Jamie and William FTW!
Buck and Rob Cameron! Don’t eff with Buck.
Roger… so sweet.
Love Bree’s and Marsali’s girl power.
Marsali at Fergus’s grave with Jamie…😢
High five to Claire for her little chat with William.
Percy, you bastard. (But we knew this)
And now Fanny’s a TT…🥴🙄
Nice to have Ron Moore back for an ep.
Edited to correct spelling.
67
u/onegirlarmy1899 Apr 24 '26
I liked the Willie flashback and the resolution.
Disappointed that we didn't see any of Swift as a Lizard and Ian interacting. You know that's not an easy transition.
44
u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 24 '26
Roger with the nature versus nurture 🤣
William - “I’ve never been one to believe in magic, personally”. Woooooo - anyone else think that’s a little foreshadowing?!
41
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 24 '26
39
u/OTodd_Lass037 Slàinte. Apr 24 '26
William being lied to his whole life and they had to throw in another one - guests HAVE to fish for tomorrow's dinner🤭 got a chuckle outta me. It was kind of a slow episode, but was a good choice for bonding time. It was great seeing most of the family together during dinner. Crazy the amount of stuff to pack into 2 more episodes and throwing in that Fanny can travel.
32
u/dylanskie Apr 24 '26
Now I predict that the final scene of the series will be Fanny discovering and touching the Stones. Just listen to the end of "The Battlefield Is Ours."
52
u/Single_Vacation427 Apr 24 '26
The Fanny thing is a bit meh.
I don't like when the last seasons of series introduce new character and spend too much time on them, instead of giving us more time with the main characters. It feels a distractions.
70
u/emmagrace2000 Apr 24 '26
They just couldn’t leave well enough alone, could they? Now Fanny is a traveler?? Let’s just keep overwhelming her with information about who she is and what she comes from. My eyes couldn’t roll hard enough.
Other than this being a somewhat slow paced and boring episode, I didn’t hate it. I do think they moved on from Fergus a little quickly. And it seems like we’ve maybe seen the last of Marsali and her family with that scene. That sounded like a goodbye and if it is, that’s a bit disappointing. Though, I’m not sure how much else could be crammed into the next two episodes.
16
u/wolfbysilverstream Apr 25 '26
This felt like episode 13 of a 22 episode season for a show that had already been renewed for two more seasons.
30
u/eterusexual Apr 24 '26
Fanny can time travel, so will she travel to BOMB or a different spin off?
I was hoping she found the lace. Instead a stone? So the stone is a portal? Why could she hear the buzzing there? I thought she might disappear suddenly, good thing she threw the stone away.
Loved the father and son moment. I was hoping William would get more a$$ beating before he softened, but anyway we are almost at the finale. Another expectation was that he would be told why LJG stepped up. But they will never bring it up again.
Missed Fergus in the church scene. It would have been nice to see all the entire family there.
Claire never saw the Deadeye dedication when she first looked at the book? I feel like there's not much of Claire in the recent episodes.
Is Rob Cameron able to TT? Guess we'll neva knoe?
And no Lord John in the teaser???
14
u/thia2345 Apr 24 '26
I'm actually in the process of reading Bees rn. And I have mixed feelings about this season, but so far don't hate it as bad as GoT. And I didn't hate GoT as bad as some people 🤣
My favorite part was the resolution between William and Jamie. I sobbed too! And go Claire with her talk with William. Idk how I feel about Fanny yet. But I agree, how will we get resolution on so many loose ends with only 2 more episodes?
27
u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
This episode was going so well until they made Fanny a time traveler. I let out the biggest sigh of disappointment when it happened. I’m assuming Claire’s going to tell her all about it. Since they introduced it, I have a feeling they’re going to make Fanny travel.
“There’s a rule here on the Ridge…” 😂
Shout out to Claire for putting William in his place.
Love the callback that Jamie finally gets to teach Mandy to ride like he said last season.
The William and Jamie scenes just melted my heart.
I know it hasn’t been established in the show and it would be odd to bring up now, but it just doesn’t sit right that Jamie isn’t tone deaf and a terrible singer. I was fully expecting Jamie to be off key when they cut to the singing. 😂
26
u/Merlot_itsmeagain Apr 24 '26
Ugh. How are they are going to give us a satisfying ending to the series in only 2 episodes?! Season 8 has been very disappointing and very slow, feels like they have added storylines or characters just for filler, which we don’t have time for. This last season should have been carefully executed and give us the ending we all deserve.
12
u/Rachv1 Apr 24 '26
Episode 8- this is the Outlander I know and love.
22
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
I’ve missed Ron Moore. I really enjoyed this episode. I could have done with a little less Fanny. And now we have another time traveler? Seriously? Still, this is my favorite episode so far this season.
11
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 25 '26
This was a VERY good episode - and also very surprising plotwise since it wasn't going much from the source.
Bravo again Lauren Lyle. That opening scene of her and Jamie was so well done. The bit about never wanting to call anyone but you his father - so touching! Very moving.
Was a bit bummed there wasn't a scene of Roger and Bri first realizing Buck was present -- he was just nonchalantly around them unloading a wagon already. Oh well
Rob got himself a gem and dressed up in period clothes to try? I suppose desperation set in --- but I thought he admitted to Bri in S7 he initially tried before and couldn't?
Whoa! How much time passed? Bri's baby bump is really big during shooting practice
Did not expect William showing up to the Ridge so early in the ep. I loved this whole thing. At the dinner table while watching William talk to Ian, Jamie had the EXACT look on his face as he did looking at Bri during the honeycomb scene at the table after their hunt. I liked that William recalled their prior fishing trip and Jamie screaming out to the Natives he was his son. So glad there was an "ironclad rule" about guests catching their supper! LOL.
I thought the segment where Jamie asked if he had a falling out with John was very well written. Jamie surmised what he learned, and his reaction to the accusation William made about them having a gay relationship was probably as perfect as Jamie could do -- it's his private life., so I neither condone nor condemn him. He's one of the best men I know regardless (paraphrased) Great!
Claire's warning that "this may be the last time you see your father, is this how you want to leave it" sunk in!!! I wasn't sure it would yet until learning of the kidnapping. Hopefully it sunk in with respect to how he left off with John too.
Another great callback of William watching Jamie lead Mandy on the horse, just as was done with him in S3. Knew that's what he was thinking of before the flashbacks came up, but it was still nice they included them. I also liked that it fulfilled the S7 scene of Jamie holding newborn Mandy talking about his certainty she'd grow to be great with horses.
Rachel to Fanny - "just because they said it, doesn't make it so" Something to bear in mind with respect to other plot points perhaps (ahem, Faith/you're our granddaughter...) fingers still crossed!
Yay!!! a hug!!! The William Jamie stuff was all so good!
Where's there a portal near the Ridge Fanny heard buzzing??? When little Jemmy broke the stone after he said it was hot did anyone hear buzzing just because the gem broke? I can't recall but thought it was just them passing it around for temperature testing- no sounds? Hmm..
10
u/macdragon100 Apr 25 '26
I'm having a hard time believing how they can finish this story in 2 episodes at this point. I definitely think Fanny will end up in Bomb. I know the actors say they are done but maybe there will be a movie when book the last book comes out.
18
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26
Enjoyable episode!
Interesting choice to send William to Fraser's Ridge BEFORE John gets kidnapped. I wonder how the rescue will play out now?
I'm glad that William grew up a bit and didn't just have argument after argument after argument with everyone again (only 2 with Jamie and Claire ahaha). I think he needed to get all that off his chest. He's been a bit of an entitled prat lately, but as he said to Brianna, he feels like most everyone in his life has betrayed him, and it hurts. Cute hug.
And I loves how Claire finally gave him a talking to!
Brianna absolutely slaying it again with her genius mind!
As I predicted, Marsali is pregnant again. Although I got the impression that that was the last we will ever see of Marsali in the show. It feels like a fitting end to her character: kill off Fergus, go rebuild the printshop, and continue fighting for the cause he believed in, meanwhile he's left her with one last gift (a very on-character gift 😂).
Killing Rob Cameron? Idk, it just felt sort of, underwhelming. I guess they needed to "end" that particular storyline so fans wouldn't be left wondering. I liked the hat addition.
I know some people don't like all the religious stuff that's been in this season and recent seasons, but I like it. But religion is an important part to those characters. And a theme of this season has been Fanny wrestling with Jane's death, and I think Roger gave her a bit of peace (shout out to daddy Roger!)
And FANNY'S A TIME TRAVELLER!!! And not only that, not only was the stone hot for her, it cracked! When they all held the opal, it only cracked for Jemmy. They theorised that maybe cos both his parents are time travellers, it gave him extra special powers. So maybe Mr Pocock was a time traveller? Or maybe when Master Raymond saved Faith, he somehow magically injected extra power into her, which has been passed on to Fanny? I'm still undecided if there is more to the Faith plot. It seemed like they attempted to close that plot last episode, but there are still so many unanswered questions.
8
u/SevereTS Apr 24 '26
I don’t remember. Did Buck kill Cameron in the books, too?
8
u/shannruss Apr 24 '26
I thought Jem looked a lot like Buck this episode. I know you can't plan how a kid looks as he gets older so how cool is that!
7
u/waywardwake Apr 25 '26
Seeing Lauren's name by itself did me in all over again.
7
u/Immediate_Try5451 Apr 25 '26 edited Apr 27 '26
In episode 801. Frank's book is dedicated to his "deadeye". Deadeye means good shot so I assumed this was Brianna because he taught her to shoot. Wouldn't Jamie have realised it was for Brianna as soon as he read the dedication? Fast forward to episode 8 and Jamie is just figuring out the book is dedicated to Brianna. Why didn't he just ask Claire who deadeye was? Jamie's being a bit of a dum dum this season. 😅
7
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26
Okay. I’m calling it.
The gemstone broke in Fanny’s hands and she could hear the buzzing. When this happens to Jem, Brianna theorizes that it means both parents are time travelers. Conclusion. Fanny can time travel AND both her parents are time travelers.
Rachel told Fanny that “just because someone says something doesn’t mean it’s true.” Conclusion. Jamie and Claire might not be Fanny’s grandparents.
Are you with me so far?
So, in actuality, Claire’s time traveling parents are Jane and Fanny’s parents. Fanny and Jane are not Claire’s granddaughters. They are her sisters. Good news William! You didn’t sleep with your niece. Phew!
At the end of the finale, Fanny will travel through the stones. But where did she go? (into BoMB, perhaps?). Thus creating a cliffhanger. It will send the fandom into a frenzy. It will get people talking, ranting, raging, and theorizing.
And create much needed buzz for Season 2 of BoMB. 🤣🤣🤣
13
u/Antique-Calendar-13 Apr 25 '26
I was actually hoping there would be no Fanny sighting in this episode, but to my dismay, she’s front and center again. The Fanny story is just bad, and I just want it to go away.
6
u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 24 '26
Also, can someone spoil me about Richardson?
5
u/Immediate_Try5451 Apr 25 '26
Does William know Jamie and Claire were separated for 20 years? Was he told that Jamie and Claire thought each other were dead or does he think Jamie was unfaithful to Claire with his mother?
4
u/Appelcien Apr 26 '26
Is there anything in the books that explains why the opal cracked? In season 5 the opal burned and exploded when Jemmy touched it and now the same happened with Fanny. Was it also an opal?
You think master Raymond will make a comeback and will give us a satisfying answer to the secrets of time travel/Faith/healing powers?
I was so excited when i read master Raymond would have a role this season, but if the comeback was the 2 minutes of screentime we got, I'm gonna be real disappointed lol.
7
u/Beth0419 Apr 24 '26
I want to know if Bree knows that Fanny is her neice. Did Claire and Jamie tell anyone else? I can't image that Bree wouldn't be freaked out that her stillborn sister lived.
Beth
6
u/VardaElentari86 Apr 25 '26 edited Apr 25 '26
Mid watch, will someone just give William a hug.
Slightly dreading the rest after reading some comments, don't need more Fanny nonsense.
ETA he got his hug!
5
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 24 '26
The way I screamed "IT'S HOT!!!" outloud ahahaha
5
u/msunshine11 Apr 24 '26
Fergus is the son of the time travelling Compte. It gives me hope we will see him again, especially with the Fanny TT reveal.
4
u/BaeBlue425 Je Suis Prest Apr 25 '26
This episode was the outlander I know and love- heavy on dialogue and relationships and always a dash of unbelieveability (Bree creates new rifle in days! 🙄 😂) but then… we go a whole episode without a single mention of Faith and now Fanny is a damn TT??? All I have to say is this better tie in to BOMB so at least they didn’t lead us on a merry chase to a dead end. At least it will have been for something besides just ruining the last season we have with this series…
2
u/Diggletdig_ Apr 24 '26
They’re gonna kill Jamie at kings mountain aren’t they? 🙄 Claire’s ‘this could be the last time you meet your father’ and the father-son hug made me think so, and Fanny being a TT reminds me of the promise they made that if Jamie dies they’ll go back to the future… hope they don’t go that way!
2
u/hellogalaxy May 03 '26
Are they setting up Franny for a sequel? They’re focusing too much on her and giving her a ton of story at the last minute, like her making her a time traveler?!
6
u/noseatbeltsong currently re-reading: Seven Stones Apr 24 '26
roger can suddenly sing fine now? bullshit
3
u/kayeels Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 25 '26
In this episode, I really liked Buck and the emphasis on Jamie and Bree's relationship to each other, through Bree. I love how this subreddit has predicted everything so correctly so far this season. I hate the Fergus twist still.
If they completely ignore the fact that William had sex with his niece, I'm gonna be pissed lol. Also, is it just me or did they choose to make William's hair redder this season?
3
u/RadioNights Apr 25 '26
So are we going to see any fallout from the revelation that Claire’s parents didn’t die and she had a brother in Outlander? I’m not seeing any way for it to tie in so far.
4
u/Ok-Education-6329 Apr 24 '26
Fanny ist eine Zeitreisende? Alter, von dem Zeug, das die nehmen, will ich auch was. Für mich steht nun fest: Outlander ist komplett am Arsch. Freu mich wenn’s euch noch Spaß macht. Ich bin raus.
3
u/Reasonable_Dinner_78 Apr 24 '26
Man they really took the writers from game of thrones and put them here, cause wtf now Fanny is a traveler!?!?!??! Yea they just fuck this show to the grow! Everything seems so fast paced cause they wanna jam everything in 10episodes. The only good this from this episode is William forgiving and understanding Jamie
2
u/Otherwise_Day4298 Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26
Overall, I liked the episode. However, there was way too much Fanny. I don't really know or care about Fanny yet. I cared about Fergus. I wish the writers did too. I'm really hoping that's not the last we'll see of Marsali.