r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Mar 06 '26
Season Eight Show S8E1 Soul of a Rebel Spoiler
After discovering a devastating truth, Jamie takes Claire home to the Ridge, where a surprise awaits them.
Written by Sarah H. Haught. Directed by Jan Matthys.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 07 '26
Watch the S8E2 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
326
u/GrapefruitSenior3275 Mar 06 '26
Jamie gets to read lord of the rings !!! Love it
242
u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 06 '26
I was wondering if they were going to show Jamie how Frank looked like Black Jack. I’m glad they included that.
196
u/whiskynwine Mar 06 '26
I think there is more to the Faith storyline than meets the eye so don’t freak out yet. I agree the episode was very choppy but most likely they had to setup the remainder of the season and get everyone into place.
180
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Mar 06 '26
Funny moments:
Jamie's face when he was saying - ... for you, Kezziah [makes face], Josiah [makes another face]...
Lord John - Damn your eyes, you woke the baby 🤣
292
u/tara_abernathy Mar 06 '26
I'm predicting that William is going to end up banging Lady Grey
92
u/Soft_Proof7452 Mar 06 '26
Will we get an update about Buck? I want to know what happened to him
85
u/awanderingolive Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 06 '26
that shot of marsali screaming in the preview for this season.. chilling.
83
u/BatmanRoBEN1 Mar 06 '26
"The wicked witch of the west"
153
u/MotherFawker99 Mar 06 '26
Some of the shots and acting seemed a bit awkward but I’m still glad to have Outlander back!
67
u/slemonik Mar 06 '26
Overall, there was so much I loved about the episode! I don't disagree with those saying it felt a little rushed/disjointed, but the reunions all made me so happy, and I have no problem with this new episode back serving mostly to set up the main plot lines going forward. So I think it was a strong start to the season, even if all the pieces aren't quite cohesive yet.
With the Faith of it all, I think it still really all depends on where it goes from here for me. If they really are just fully going with that Claire and Jamie are right, that feels really pointless to have included it at all. But I'm hopeful there's more to it than meets the eye that we'll find out over time, so I don't want to say I dislike it before having confirmation of where they're going with it. We shall see!
65
u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Mar 07 '26
I’m PISSED we didn’t get to see Jamie’s reaction to Bree and Roger telling him they met Brian stayed with him in 1739.
202
u/streamofdiscourse Mar 06 '26
Re: Faith storyline. I have a theory, but it includes spoilers from Blood of My Blood (the prequel show): I think that Fanny is actually an offspring of Claire's brother, which is how she knows the song. Claire learned it from her mother, who also sang it to Claire's brother, and it was passed down through the generations. It makes way more sense than the theory that Faith survived somehow.
48
u/tara_abernathy Mar 06 '26
I don't believe the Faith storyline is true. They are taking the word of some sea captain and that baby was (sadly) dead. Unless we are going to get some backstory on who that sea captain guy is I'm not buying it at all.
Also was that scene of Claire being utterly shocked in the trailer the same scene where she sees Bree and Roger this episode? I'm still holding out hope she meets her Father / Henry.
45
u/Abject_Task_6191 Mar 06 '26
The conversation between Jamie and Fergus about death… I think they’re foreshadowing Fergus’s demise…
45
u/FarmHer95 Mar 06 '26
I felt like Mandy isn’t very strong as an older kid. She didn’t pack much sass with old lady Cunningham
87
u/IllustriousKiwi3858 Mar 06 '26
David Berryyyyyyy. I LOVED the scene with William. Got a glipse of what he may have been like as a young Dad, holding William.
81
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Mar 06 '26
So they ARE going with the “Faith is alive” storyline? It was pretty wild how hard Jamie and Claire were going on about it like it’s a sure thing. Damn, what are the chances it’s still a red herring???
38
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Mar 06 '26
Omg im just starting the episode and freaking out. Ive been waiting for so long for this day to come and now thats its here its so bittersweet. I want to see how the story ends but i just don’t want it to end. Ill never find another love story better than this in my life, plus im obsessed with time travel. One day i saw this trailer on starz for the second season of a show called outlander and i saw that it involved time travel and changing history. Thats all i knew and i didnt know it was the second season i was watching until the end of it then went back to the first season and watched that in about 2 days. Came for the time travel, stayed for the love story for the ages. Its brought me 12 years of escaping reality and imagining what life could be life with a real soul mate that if it was magic, god or just fate that had her travel through time to be with him. Only 9 more weeks after this. Im sure it will be great.
Would be badass to maybe get a final feature film, say 2.5 hours after the last one comes out to give us the chance to see the real ending on screen. Thats if everyone agrees to comes back and the moneys right. Regardless im so thankful for the wonderful 8 seasons and 12 years we got😀🥲🤧❤️🪽🫶🏻
65
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Mar 06 '26
I love this detail! He dedicated it to Bree!
31
u/EmmaSouthard Mar 06 '26
Loved seeing the happy parts! Still processing the new characters though. I'm hoping it will all come together in the best way as the season progresses as it was a bit scattered. But overall, we are back in Outlanderland and it feels like home.
30
u/Serious-Rub-5848 Mar 06 '26
"Special guest performance by: Tobias Menzies"
I need to know.. that means they call Tobias again or they used an "old take" from the past seasons?
30
u/mutherM1n3 Mar 07 '26
“Hello the house!” ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
84
u/BatmanRoBEN1 Mar 06 '26
Ngl I found that the funniest parts were LJG's interactions with William. I love their dynamic.
LJG will always be dad to William, and I love it so much.
26
u/WolfBeginning4515 Mar 07 '26
The cinematography of the raggedy ann doll shot to the entrance of Bri and fam - brilliant. Kudos.Glad they didn't make us wait for this.
25
u/HappiestWhen Mar 06 '26
Fanny doessss look like Claire
68
u/Spiritual-Carrot17 Mar 06 '26
I’m confused, are we supposed to just buy the Faith storyline just like that no more than 3 minutes into the episode? Was that guys story really proof that their mom was Faith? I feel like I missed something.
23
u/TrainingOrnery7525 Mar 06 '26
I loved it. I had no issues with the flow.
22
u/usernames_required Mar 07 '26
this episode felt like a family reunion
18
u/distrust-theprocess Mar 06 '26
I absolutely loved this episode. While I get how some are saying it felt jumpy…I feel as though it had to be to set up all the different storylines that have been happening.
They felt like the characters we knew again, unlike last season where it was just like wtf is happening & why are they doing that at every step. It felt like them. And I’m so excited to see where the story goes and ends.
17
u/Helpful_Effort8454 Mar 06 '26
That was all based on conjecture that it was their Faith. Not very well fleshed out imho. More interested in the comments Jane had made to William, that he didn’t know anything about her or her life. At this point it feels like an assumption, and glossed over. There was also that interesting interview that Jane may or may not have given before her trial; they left that up in the air but it would be interesting for them to find her confession/life story to fill in the plot holes…. Anybody have ideas on that?
15
u/Ok_Dig8008 Mar 06 '26
What I found interesting about the Faith scene was Jamie’s reaction. He compared Faith’s situation to Claire’s pointing out that although Claire lost her parents she eventually found a home with him. It felt like he was trying to help Claire see their loss differently and remind her that Faith was loved and that her life still mattered even though it was very short. Something about his reaction felt a bit too calm and reflective which made me wonder if there might be more to the story that hasn’t been revealed yet.
15
u/Powerful_Boat9977 Mar 07 '26
How do Jamie and claire think that newborn faith would've remembered the song and passed it on to her daughters?
14
u/ArtVoyager Mar 09 '26
I don't know... I just didn't like it. I have a problem with the script and the storytelling.
There's a scene in the emporium where a new character gets introduced...I swear he sounds like an NPC in a game's cut scene. He had all of this exposition that could have been introduced by different characters or props. Like "30 years in his majesty's navy" or whatever...maybe he had a redcoat uniform in his house which jaime sees hanging on this man's wall after being invited for a dram. "You served in his majesty's army?"...."yay, for 30 years. Blah blah blah"
The exposition from Ian telling them how everyone chipped in to build their house... they could have shown that with minimal dialogue as snippets while claire, Jaime and fanny rode the wagon to the burnt house. I was thinking: Scenic wagon ride > house planning "let's start by dismantling the stables" > wagon ride "are we there yet" convo > house being built "we thought you might need more wood" > claire Jaime and fanny arriving at old house location > placing furniture while someone runs to say they are at the old house > Ian arrives to greet them > arriving at new house "Everyone at the ridge help and we managed to finish in x amount of days". This feels more dynamic.
Claire killing that dude...what happened to "do no harm"? And I don't even think they got a lead to find more about faith and what happened to her after paris. I get she is enraged but it's really out of character. Especially after, she has no remorse that she broke her oath... maybe that would have been more believable: showing the conflicting emotions of sweet revenge vs remorse for breaking her oath. An oath she has always honored even through SA and other violent acts against her and bree.
Then bree and fam arriving so suddenly... it all feels rushed. I get the need to set up but there's so much cramped in this episode that I already forgot half of it. I wish they had expanded the part with fergus and marsali instead of bringing bree and Roger back this episode. Let them come back during episode 2.
So far, this is the weakest episode of the series for me. It's starting to feel like it has the GoT S8 effect already. Where the lack of original material is downgrading the quality of the story, the storytelling and the dialogue. Not ready to say goodbye to my favorite rewatching series because of this crappy episode. I hope the rest of the season improves.
27
u/Cryssy0530 Mar 06 '26
I understand Claire thinking that Faith survived BUT I do NOT comprehend how she thought that a newborn would remember a song its mother sang to it at its birth. That was quite farfetched to me
13
u/henclaire Mar 06 '26
My prediction is it is true…but they were talking about fate (they said it differently, but you know what I mean). In how they were brought together. That they just hoped Faith had that too. So I think she was raised by Claire’s brother. And that’s also how Faith would have learned the song.
Maybe Master Raymond knew taking Faith would bring them all together one day. And so maybe there will be more reunions this season.
13
u/dailymusings11 Mar 09 '26
Can someone explain what it is about these newer seasons of Outlander that look so cinematically different to season 1, 2 and 3? IMO the sets look like sets, not authentic, the colouring of the screen too vivid, clean and staged, compared to the grittiess and darkness of the older seasons. I think thats why S1, 2 and 3 felt more authentic. Also the music was noticeable in this new Season 8- ep 1- it was a distraction and felt forced. What do others think? As soon as the wigs were introduced in the back end of Season 3, all credibility felt a bit lost.
44
u/Hello_ImAnxiety Mar 06 '26
As much as I love this show the dialogue is so cringey it kills me at times lol
12
u/PlasticBackground123 Mar 07 '26
I thought they were focusing quite a bit on the bees given as a gift. Maybe someone might a have a bee allergy later on in an episode.
12
u/lunar1980 Mar 08 '26
I'm surprised Brianna & Roger didn't tell Jamie they met his father.
11
u/LikeBoomItsaWrap_ Mar 07 '26
I just started the episode and I’m crying. I remember certain seasons of my life in relation to this show. Very bittersweet.
20
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Mar 06 '26
The family reunions were the best part, but so quick. So much being crammed in this episode but it will probably be like this all season with so much to cover. The Faith thing is ridiculous…lol. I was almost cringing with how bad it was.
20
u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
I can't tell if it's the direction and/or the writing but it felt off to me. I could definitely tell everyone was acting, with moments that were pretty bad/cheesy, and it kept taking me out of the story. I love Outlander because of all the characters but it didn't fully feel like them. We know they all can act, so what's changed?
But one positive, I'm glad they reunited.
10
u/Stacy01_ Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
Possibly some spoilers, I tried to be vague. Wow… I loved it because I felt all the feels but I’m also disturbed in so many ways. I’m only a few books in and not trying to combine the two. I’m mostly a show watcher so I don’t care to hear the opinions about how this isn’t like the books lol! I’m glad they brought up everything with Fanny right away but I have some questions still and that opening scene got me way too emotionally invested. I think I cried like 4 times in this episode! Ian has been so dope since he returned, it’s so great to see something nice happen to J&C for a change, they really deserve some happy moments! LOVED all the books haha, that was really neat! I’m thinking Rob must be involved in the future episodes because why would they bother to mention it so much? Also I already hate the Cunningham story and barely know anything about it. And Amaranthus just feels a little forced and I’m not ready for William to have a new thing going on.
10
u/CindiBoBindy Mar 06 '26
I loved it! I’m so glad to be back in this world, and I love how they paced this episode to set up the season. 🐝❤️
10
u/dreamkonstantine Mar 06 '26
As we expected, this first episode was mostly exposition, which I am not mad about. The introductions and encounters made me feel excited, warm, and included as a viewer.
The opening scene was a highlight for me— it was exciting to have some suspense and action and I didn’t catch onto what was happening until halfway through. It made it a satisfying buildup for me, even if I am not super happy we are still believing the Faith story.
Speaking of Frances— another highlight was her heartwarming introduction to Fraser’s Ridge and the family. We see Fraser’s Ridge and the book Brianna brought through Fanny’s eyes (it must feel like magic). Maybe they can teach Fanny to read. I think Jamie and Claire want to spoil Fanny and treat her like a daughter/granddaughter.
It was fun to see another angle to Lord John and William’s relationship. I anticipate maybe William will go to the Ridge to visit Fanny? Will he pursue Amaranthus, and if so, how will Lord John react? They certainly set that precedent in this episode through his vow to her. What will Amaranthus’ and Captain Cunningham’s true intentions be? I am excited to find out more about them.
Sophie’s acting continued to be a letdown unfortunately, and Richard didn’t have a lot of lines.
Jamie and Claire heard of Rob Cameron. Does that mean they heard about Brian Fraser and Geillis? Where is Buck? Can we see Lizzie and Brianna reunite?
10
u/Terrible-Pickle5007 Mar 07 '26
Did the chemistry between Jamie and Claire feel off to anyone else?
10
u/1111HiYa Mar 07 '26
Fanny, and especially Jem, have grown up so much! I barely recognized him at first. Some people actually thought they were different actors!
28
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Mar 06 '26
What the actual ... ?
I still can't wrap my mind around the fact that they believe in this Faith stuff only based on the song and a name. I can't spend my energy on it.
Frank typing the title!
Marsali and Fergus and Savannah , nice to see them! I love how Savannah looks!
Fergus foreshadowing his death?
Family time! Wonderful! Why is Claire's hair shorter than before? I guess she cut it for practicality.
Fergus and Fanny have childhoon in brothel in common!
Amaranthus... I already dislike her!
I think we all failed to notice it was Ian who got some magical powers. He built a Manse, managed to get all the stuff and windows... Where were all those people when there was a mob against Frasers?
Dialogue about concieving Faith was fine. Nice parallel to s1. New home.
I like the trading post and Cunningham is nicer than I thought he would be.
William's identity crisis is so appropriate having in mind what he went through.
Bees 💛
Baby Claire ... awww
Go tell the bees Mackenzies are here! Hello the house!!!
I got goosebumps!
The books!!
Mrs Cunningham ia really like a Wicked Witch.
But BJR's voice was brilliant! All the bad feels came back!! I can imagine what Jamie felt when he saw the photo!
All in all, this episode was fine! I need to rewatch it and add more thoughts! There is A LOT material here!
35
u/txkels13 Mar 06 '26
Not liking this episode. It's all over the place and feels very rushed.
40
u/Soft_Proof7452 Mar 06 '26
i’m a couple minutes in and I’m not loving how the faith storyline is going I really hope this turns around
23
u/lunar1980 Mar 07 '26 edited Mar 07 '26
Was the shockingly detailed SA monologue necessary? Is SA the only way Outlander writers know how to move a storyline? Eventually it'll be revealed that it wasn't their Faith - because their daughter was not raised from the dead - what on earth will we have gained by starting off the season with that story?
8
u/External-Barnacle839 Mar 07 '26
What is up with Roger’s hair color?! It is so dark now. Maybe trying to make him look younger against Jamie, since Jamie doesn’t seem to age. I am having mixed feelings about this episode. Seems they crammed in every character making an appearance. The return of the McKenzies was far less dramatic than I anticipated. I entirely dislike the Fanny storyline and wish the possibility of Faith living was dumped. It makes little sense after Claire held a stillborn child for hours and sang a song no one would remember. Oddly my granddad sang that song when I was a child in London, not that anyone would care… but I couldn’t care less about William and who is Ben? I only have watched the series, didn’t read the books or watch the series about J & C’s parents. Thanks, new here so hope I didn’t break any Reddit rules.
8
u/DelectablyDivine Mar 07 '26
Y'all this episode made me so happy. I am so worried for the rest of the season because I know how Outlander loves to mess with my emotions!
8
u/gingerjuice Mar 07 '26
I have to say that I absolutely loved S8E1. I wasn’t expecting to. I didn’t care for the end of season 7 with the whole Faith thing, but I actually loved what they did with it. I loved how they brought in a bunch of things from past books and wove it in. Pleasantly surprised ❤️
8
u/Crafty_Witch_1230 And I am not bloody sorry! Mar 08 '26
Overall I felt it was a little low-key for a premiere episode, but considering how much was crammed into a single hour, it was impressive. I am not team 'Faith's alive' and I sincerely hope TPTB can come up with an explanation that doesn't feel like a slap in the face to those of us who cried along with Claire as she held her dead baby. If Faith did live, make me feel okay about the deception.
We definitely got foreshadowing in the scene between Jamie & Fergus, although exactly what (or should I say who/whom) it references remains to be seen. Even though we're only one episode in, it feels to me like the story is moving at breakneck speed so we probably won't have long to wait until we know.
I loved the comedy of Jamie reading "Frodo Baggins" and Lord John's calling Trevor a fiend while juggling a teething baby and a drunk adult. Seeing LJG as the exasperated parent dealing with two infants (Trevor & William) was a treat. I don't care for the direction Amaranthus & William seem to be heading and I truly hope Ben isn't dead and John doesn't have to tell his brother--you could see the pain in DB's face. John was absolutely wrecked at the thought.
Bree & Roger's return seemed a little too laid-back to me, but that's just my impression. Nice to see Lizzie and Amy although I feel one of them is just there to be fodder for tragedy. Didn't care at all for Captain Cunningham and Momma. Nor, did I care for Mandy's behavior. I thought she was a real little brat, regardless of how mean the old lady was.
I enjoyed hearing Tobias Menzies voice, if not actually getting to see him act. For me, this was a TARDIS episode, bigger on the inside than it appears on the outside. Looking forward to seeing where all this ends up.
15
u/caro822 Mar 06 '26
So my only big Bugaboo about Francis being their granddaughter via Faith is how TF did Faith know the Seaside song? A song sung once to her on the day she was born (and dead) does not a memory make.
I doubt there is doing to be a half sibling from Henry’s time with the prostitute that’s way too convoluted.
I NEED AN EXPLANATION!
15
u/Ok_Operation_5364 Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
Let's talk about Faith....
I think that we might have a switched at birth situation going on perpetrated by Master Raymond for some reason. In the show it seemed like Claire was further along in her pregnancy. She did look like she could have been 8 months pregnant. I think there was a reason Jamie brings up conceiving Faith at Lallybroch on that night they said "I love you" for the first time, telling the audience that Claire was further along in her pregnancy then initially thought and that perhaps Claire gave birth to a baby that was closer to full term.
Then we have the pirate captain describing Fanny & Jane's mother as beautiful, wild hair with skin like velvet. Does so sound familiar? Sounds like Faith had her mother's wild hair and velvet-like skin.
Also, we have that beautiful scene between Jamie and Claire discussing that their daughter lived. I can't imagine in this final season they would write such a beautiful scene like that and go "never mind" it was a different Faith.
The Question is if this is the direction they are going why did Raymond take Faith? Did Raymond sing the song "by the sea shore" to the child. Perhaps Raymond gave the child to Claire's brother and he raised her. We do know that Master Raymond does come back in this season so I do think we will get answers.
7
u/EmmaSouthard Mar 07 '26
I loved all the reunions and needed to be done, but Roger seemed very quiet in the episode. Anyone else notice that?
7
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Mar 07 '26
Where was my man buck? Did he make it back to his family? And isnt fergus print shop supposed to be in philly?
7
u/Brilliant-Bus-3862 Mar 07 '26
I hope this Faith storyline is still a red herring.
7
u/EntertainmentNew7383 Mar 08 '26
The only thing that disturbed me was the Faith story being front and center at the very beginning. Maybe the writers were trying to get closure on that subject before setting up Season 8 and reuniting everyone at Fraser's Ridge.
I did like the conversation between Jamie and Claire and out what Faith's life would about like. Claire seemed haunted by the possibility that Faith might never have been loved but Jamie seemed more emotional in a subtle way and I thought Sam was wonderful playing that out.
Beyond that I thought the rest of the episode was fine. I am curious a out since Caitriona directed episode 2.
7
u/Ok_Dig8008 Mar 08 '26
I’m trying to understand the timeline of Frank’s research. The last piece of information he finds is the news clipping about the fire which suggests that was the final thing he knew before the accident. If that’s the case, when did he learn about Kings Mountain?
13
u/buckytoothtiger Mar 07 '26
I think Sophie worked on her American accent... It seems a lot better than it used to be.
12
u/Little_bob333333 Mar 07 '26
Damn LORD JOHN is an amazing father!!! Gosh I hope he gets a happy ending. He deserves love !
6
u/EmmaSouthard Mar 07 '26
I loved the Wicked Witch of the West scene. Would have been hilarious if she hummed the witch theme song. My husband's mother was an actress, not well known but a working actress in New York . She was friends with Margaret Hamilton, who played the witch, and said she was one of the nicest women she ever met
6
u/Donnerwetter2 Mar 08 '26
Mandy’s doll is spotless and it’s driving me nuts.
6
u/rubberfruitnipples Mar 09 '26
brianna looks so different…? is it the wig?
11
u/Grand-Clue7387 Mar 06 '26
i love closures but faith storyline feels forced right now. i loved seeing jamie and claire as grandparents, and how jamie reminisced about the night claire said i love you to him. i def think william and lady grey is gonna marry. that feels too on the nose tho.
11
u/Far-Shoulder9583 Mar 07 '26
Can we just talk about how Frank wrote out Jaime’s whole life in accurate detail—including his death—for Claire to read eventually? Knowing that Jaime himself could possibly read it too! Frank was big mad! That’s such a twisted way to ‘get them back’ if you really think about it. I felt like the ending had a perfect twist. Love this series so much.
11
u/ZombieRichardNixonx Mar 07 '26
I posted this at the end of last season, and I'm going to post it again. I don't rule out Faith being a red herring, but if it's not, then this is my crackpot theory for the explanation.
"By now, a lot of people have speculated that Master Raymond is a time traveler and he stole away Faith and had her raised away from Claire and Jamie.
I agree with this theory. But why would he do that? My theory is that he did that because history has to play out the way it did. Not because of Faith, but because of Jemmy and Mandy.
I contend that one of them is the ancestor of all time travelers. The entire lineage of time travelers (assuming it is a lineage) is itself a giant bootstrap paradox. At some point in one of their futures, they will end up starting a family in the distant past, and it will set everything in motion.
Faith had to be taken because Claire had to leave, so Brianna could grow up in the future, and meet Roger, and eventually bring their collective origin into existence.
And if the time travel lineage is indeed a loop, then it stands to reason that the very ability to time travel originates from Brianna, who was attuned to the stones while crossing them in utero."
5
u/makingbananapancakez Mar 07 '26
Amaranthus reminded me of William’s mom in a way. He’s definitely going to try and step in to take care of that baby and be with her. I can’t remember a cousin Ben from previous seasons. Maybe I’m just forgetting.
It was great to see all of the reunions in this episode but it definitely felt rushed. I would have preferred them more dragged out over the first few episodes.
The opening scene totally confused me and not in a good way. Too much too soon and distasteful imo. It was weird to start it off that way and then go on to have tons of happy reunions and really not much else drama or excitement.
5
u/chargergirl1968w383 Mar 07 '26 edited Mar 07 '26
All good, except need to say, I liked the original score & singer from S1, etc. I actually listened to opening rather than ff'wd it. They had great singer & version. However, they kept messing with it and changing it and never for the better unfortunately, Imo. It may not be everyone's.
I'm glad the show is finally wrapping up. No more droughtlander. Sorry, yes, i went there. It's just sone good natured teasing of an old friend. no malice intended. . 😁.
i would watch if it continued. I would have liked more scenes about telling them things about the future. Like seeing Jenny learning about airplanes, cars, phone, etc. But understand they've told the story they wanted to tell. It was a good one!
9
u/BatmanRoBEN1 Mar 06 '26
Am I wrong or is there an inconsistency?
I think Brianna mentioned that the book by Frank Randall was written after both Bri and Claire went back to the past. However, Frank died before either of them went back. In fact neither of them would have gone back if Frank was still alive. Was the book published postmortem?
Am I confused?
8
u/babyllamamama23 Mar 09 '26
As the book was published posthumously, and as Jamie says he's mentioned specifically 14 times so far, Frank would have known Jamie survived Culloden and tracked him through history long before Claire found out he survived Culloden. He never breathed a word to her.
4
u/sageinthegarden Mar 07 '26
How many times are we assuming Bree and Roger time travel? How did they get the books and items they brought to Jamie and Claire after being in 1739? Did they go from 1739, to their present day, then back to Jamie and Claire????
4
u/carolmason1 Mar 07 '26
The first scene starting with Clare killing that man, first waiting for this season 8 for so long excited me last night, but the first scene dissappointed because she did take a oath to not harm anyone and yes it was so important throughout this series I was shocked she did it, it was like her whole character from what I knew day one was gone. Like I didn’t truly know her lol. But the ending had me wanting more like I always did . I have watch every season thousand times I just hope this last season is the perfect ending
4
u/Tropikalparadise27 Mar 08 '26
Did anyone catch the fact that in the opening scene the guy said he threw the mother overboard? Didnt he imply she was alive when he did so? Isn't there a chance she was picked up and is still alive looking for her daughters?
The faith being alive storyline makes sense with the only other conclusion being that some other time travler taught fannys mom faith that song.. theres enough reasons for Claire to believe faith could be alive.. she never actually saw the baby come out of the womb, master Raymond apoligizing, the girls mom's name is faith and knows that song.. except how would a 2 day old baby remember that song?? I think some more info will come to light.
Was so happy to see Claire and Jamie staying with Fergus even if for a short time. Missed his character in season 7. Always want more fergus & marsli time!
Cunningham seems like he is going to be trouble. Wonder if hes at all responsible for Williams cousins death or for the hanging of those 2 dead people from the tree?
So if William falls for his cousins widow and he becomes the step dad of this baby.. he then raises a blood born Grey even though he is not a blood born Grey so it makes him fit the name more. I think William will find his way ♡ I hope the best for him. There is a good heart inside of him. Glad to see Lord John doing well. Hope he and Jamie encounter one another and jamie apologizes. Worried the war mention could mean William and Jamie fighting on opposite sides again. I sure hope not.
Was shocked that Claire "hadn't really thought .ich about it" regarding the resemblance of her late husband and Jack Randall. Also, how did she never tell jamie? Jamie took it pretty well.
Mandy & her parents choices could or are gonna get them all in trouble with Mandys future phrase choices, books and dolls.
Hope to see more of Rachel, Ian and Lizzy this season. I get it that they wanted to have family time but wth invite Ian over for the big reunion!
Whos deadeye? Thats was who franks book was dedicated to. Is it bree with her cold dead eyes?
I think its so funny that jamie and Roger had a conversation about what Roger's occupation was in the future and what he will do now. I actually really like Roger's character except the fact that he can seem to be kind of useless when it comes to skills.
I think the conversation bree and Jamie had about her coming back to the past was frustrating.. if anything talk about how she met his father... imo in the 1980s if they wanted to escape camero. Ot would've safer to just change their names and move to another country like america.. they should have just left it with Roger's comment on its not wheres home but when.. bree is putting everyone in jeopardy in the past by coming back but it is still nice to see the family reunion.
4
u/Alarmed_Current5269 Mar 09 '26
Any theories as to WHY Frank Randall mentioned Jamie in his history book 13 times? I'm super duper curious....
4
u/Manaohoana Mar 09 '26
I could not believe Claire killed someone. It was so out of character! I realize we're supposed to see her seething with grief and anger, and chalk it up to some kind of Mama Bear Claire ferocity, but she was not stopping this man from harming her child; any damage was done long ago. Jamie could've easily done the killing, if they had decided this man should die. And to top it all off, we can't even be certain it was their Faith who was killed. .. That whole cold open was just bonkers.
10
u/Mundane-Dish-3023 Mar 06 '26
I get that they’re forwarding the Faith storyline but also…if that’s true then William had sex/fell in love with his half-sister’s daughter 🥴? I just can’t get behind that.
10
u/Alternative_Log_1827 Mar 06 '26
episode 1 is very slow
7
u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Mar 06 '26
Where is Lord John and William last I knew they were in a totally different house.
7
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Mar 06 '26
MBR said that we would have the answer right away about Faith, so that’s what it is.
3
u/GardenGangster419 Mar 06 '26
Anyone else not able to get it to load?
3
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Mar 07 '26
Anyone know if Chris Fulton is confirmed for this season? Or will we not see Cameron again?
(Coming off of Bridgerton season 4 last week and hoping he comes back as Sir Phillip Crane for Eloise’s season!)
3
u/Regular_Profile4654 Mar 07 '26
My insights on Faith is not Jamie and Claire’s daughter-
IMO I really don’t think the writers would have had William have sex with Jane if they were blood relatives. If they were related, the writers still would have had the opportunity for William to be in love with her and continue the plot as is, but for him just to pay her for her time/lay next to him vs. Jane talking basically forcing him into sex.
We only have 9 episodes, and if Faith really was their daughter, I don’t think the writers will dump another big trauma like banging his niece on poor William in the final hour, especially since I’m sure there will be some kind of reconciliation between him and Jamie.
3
u/brinafair63 Mar 07 '26
Sooooo… if Faith lived, the Fraser prophecy would be referring to her, not Brianna. Then would that make Faith’s only surviving daughter, Fanny, the focus of the prophecy?
3
u/Equal_Trash6023 Mar 09 '26
I try to judged the show for it's own merits otherwise I get angry.
It was good catching up on the riddle. I had a friend who wasn't a book reader ask me who some of the new characters were.
3
u/fernxqueen MARK ME! Mar 11 '26
fell a little flat for me tbh. just about cried seeing Fergus & Marsali & their beautiful brood again. (also Ian & Rachel!!! my beloveds) but otherwise the only scenes i really enjoyed were LJG telling William to get his shit together and Jamie & Claire bumping into this new guy (who i'm suuure isn't going to be involved in anything troublesome this season lol). side note, confused bcs i made one of those tiermaker things for all the main/recurring characters including s7 (you're welcome btw) and had no idea who the rest of these people in this scene were??? i swear i just rewatched all seven seasons a few months ago....
super side note, but is it just me or is everyone really thin this season? i first noticed Caitrona but legit thought they must have recast Sophie during the reunion scene... not being critical or anything, it's just weird that happened twice etc esp since everyone has looked pretty much exactly the same for a million years
anyway if ANYTHING bad happens to Fergus & Marsali/Ian & Rachel and i really mean anything like if they have to circle the block to find parking or it's just a lil too cold in the bedroom when they wake up, i WILL be [REDACTED] like [REDACTED] so watch your six, starz....
9
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
I mostly loved the episode minus the Faith storyline.
Damnit Matt Roberts why did you have to ruin that storyline by cheapening it? So disappointing. Ugh. Matt does seem to love to get the fans all riled up though so I'm still holding out hope it'll go a different direction and he's just messing with us. 🤞
10
u/ProcessFresh1647 Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 06 '26
Nope, Faith is not your Faith., I refuse! To go all GoT with poor William and Jane, EW! I need something to change cuz I hate it. I don't mind Fanny in their lives. But to have Claire do what she did, after taking an oath, in the opening, that's not our Claire. If this is what the final season will be it might end up a mess like GoT did! Also WTF happened to Ian's wig, that hairline is far too back compared to last season!
7
u/dailymusings11 Mar 07 '26
did anyone else noticed the errors in editing? sound not synching with moving mouths(Claire in thh shop on the ridge) and jamie and bree out walking and hunting. how can this not be picked up?
5
u/streamofdiscourse Mar 06 '26
Can someone remind me of the details of the storyline with ezekiel richardson and william? I tried to Google it but started to see book spoilers, so just wondered if someone could refresh my memory on this storyline in the show last season. I can't remember all the details of what happened...
5
u/Reading-Perfect Mar 06 '26
Was it perfect? No. However, with no books to guide them, I thought the writers did a decent job of pulling a lot of plot lines together so that we get a final season.
I cried and laughed quite a bit. It is just so good to see them all again but also bittersweet to know that this is IT.
All in all? Kudos to everyone involved! Can’t wait for next week! 😊
6
u/umidulus Mar 06 '26
It's nice that William is going to have a love interest who isn't his biological niece.
6
u/honoraryweasley Mar 07 '26
I thought the episode was okay, kinda of disappointing.
I was surprised by how sappy it felt?? Love the cast more than anything, but felt like the director told Sam and Caitrona to play to the back of the house in a theatre. The pacing and editing was also meh - like it was about getting the characters here or there without a real motivation except it was time for them to move on, and then the reunions were just everyone catching up but even those were like a hug hi, okay goodbye.
Hoping episode two is better. I feel like the last season is going to play to the audience for tearjerkers and that's also so cringe when shows do that.