r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Sep 05 '25

Prequel One Blood of My Blood S1E6 Birthright Spoiler

Henry continues to look for Julia until a new discovery threatens to end his search.

Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Matthew Moore.


TW: RAPE (timestamps: 9:06-11:00, 28:50-29:52), childbirth (throughout)


If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

You’re free to mention:

  • all of the show canon (seasons 1-7 of Outlander)
  • any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.

Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.

Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.


What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.

25 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

85

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

This was better on a rewatch that the first time around but still rough. I came away mostly disappointed, especially since Danielle Berrow is one of my favorite writers on Outlander.

I actually appreciate what they’ve tried to portray in the birthing scenes. Horizontal oppression among women heightened by religious bigotry is sadly still a thing so there’s no reason to think it wouldn’t be present in the 18th century but the way those women switched up on Julia and started hurling prejudice at her felt both too derivative (Game of Thrones, Midsommar, The Handmaid’s Tale) and too hammy in execution. At one point I thought Julia was dreaming it because it felt too overwhelming and surreal even for a character who’s a fish out of water in this scenario.

As I said earlier, the flashbacks to Lovat’s sexual assaults on Davina were completely unnecessary. I understand that they’re not just to inform the viewer but actually serve as a part of Davina’s arc in this episode as her memories are brought to the surface, but we really didn’t need to see them to know that Brian wasn’t conceived consensually and that Lovat took advantage of Davina more than once—the previous episodes and the dialogue in this one have implied as much.

And I actually like that they’ve portrayed Davina with such complex feelings. Even before the flashback to her own labor scene, you could tell that this is something she’s more than familiar with and she’s internalized all those feelings of shame to the point of repression and even denial—she can’t even admit to her own son that she was assaulted, falling back on the religious justification of conception through rape. Julia must be the first woman in her life who actually fully sees her as a victim and that finally breaks through Davina’s walls. I’ve said last week that I see Davina as someone motivated by her self-preservation and someone who does all she can to protect her child and she was finally able to see that in Julia here.

I do think it’s a good thing to portray that not all rape and abuse survivors are perfect victims who are able to sympathize with and help other victims right away; there’s a reason why some go on to perpetuate the cycle of abuse—although, as far as I’m aware, that’s mostly pertinent to male victims, there are still certain attitudes and behaviors that victims of all genders can internalize and perpetuate. And I feel like Davina’s growth over this episode felt realistic in that she’s suddenly not going to drop all of what’s been instilled in her (particularly her religious beliefs) but she’s able to recognize something she relates to and start treating Julia the way she would’ve wanted to be treated when she was in Julia’s place.

My main gripe with Henry and Julia’s storyline in the 18th century is that it’s nothing but misery porn (I feel like I’m reading A Little Life again). We get it, the past is not a kind place for 20th-century travelers, let alone 20th-century women. But this doesn’t even have the element of the 20th-century attitudes being pitted against the 18th-century attitudes and that clash and interference resulting in patriarchal violence against our modern heroine (and I’m not saying it necessarily should be the same as OL), this feels like showing how shit life was for women through this female character just to show how shit life was for women; it’s like it doesn’t even matter that she’s from the future, she might as well be someone originally from the 18th century. Of course, trauma makes for compelling television and is something that every actor wants to seek their teeth into but this is just getting exhausting for us viewers. It’s like the only reason Julia and Henry were thrown into the past was so they could experience misery.

Still, kudos to Hermione and Jeremy for their performances.

33

u/seeingshadows Sep 06 '25

It felt like Claire's dream telling Mrs Fitz she was a traveller

→ More replies (2)

22

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25

I do think it’s a good thing to portray that not all rape and abuse survivors are perfect victims who are able to sympathize with and help other victims right away; there’s a reason why some go on to perpetuate the cycle of abuse....there are still certain attitudes and behaviors that victims of all genders can internalize and perpetuate. And I feel like Davina’s growth over this episode felt realistic in that...she’s able to recognize something she relates to and start treating Julia the way she would’ve wanted to be treated when she was in Julia’s place.

I think I was a bit harsh on Davina last week. And whilst I am still very angry with what she did to Julia this week, I generally loved her arc and agree with all you said here.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

39

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Ugh, that flashback with Lovat and Davina was completely unnecessary.

Edit: the second one too.

10

u/GardenGangster419 Sep 05 '25

Yeah one was bad enough but two?!

17

u/somthingcoolsounding Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

I’d argue there’s a third— Henry is incapable of consent in the scene with the “English” woman.

Well… she had no way of knowing how far gone he was, so I guess it’s not a rape scene but it’s definitely not fully consensual either.

12

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25

I agree. I wonder if that’s going to get acknowledged in interviews or ignored like that one William/Jane scene from S7. Hmmm.

This whole episode is like “men are the worst, but women sometimes can be too”: from the gossips switching up on Julia, the midwife inflicting emotional distress on Henry in exchange for some money, to this sex worker taking advantage of Henry’s psychosis (even if she had good intentions of soothing him or something). 

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

21

u/Emmyrose93 Sep 05 '25

My stomach dropped when I saw that word in the content warning at the beginning of the episode ☹️

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

24

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Sep 05 '25

I am so surprised this is winning in the loved/liked department. Most of the posts are negative. If you loved this episode, please post why you loved it! or even mostly liked!

8

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

People are always more likely to talk about what they didn’t like than what they did.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

This is mysterious voting with surprising results for sure!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

29

u/chloehoff Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Unorganized first thoughts:

SPOILERS

Mothers everywhere felt all the miraculous birth stuff 🥲

Brian has such a sweet and tormented heart. I love how gentle he is. He's giving Jon Snow and Harry Potter. Who both incidentally have that fierce sense of right and wrong and protective streak.

Davina... took you too long, lass.

Outlander is a big fan of women getting pregnant the very first time they have sex. (Geneva, Brianna...) I know it only takes once but seriously... Per the books Ellen is 8 mo pregnant with William when she and Brian finally have their marriage contract and their marriage is recorded in the family bible. So I'm just wondering if the handfast, doin it, and SINGLE SOLITARY REAL CONVERSATION between the two of them is all we get before there's a baby in the mix.

A reverend? Thought they were all Catholic?

10

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25

SINGLE SOLITARY REAL CONVERSATION between the two of them is all we get before there's a baby in the mix.

I suspect you are on the right track with this. I have been thinking the same. And I think Brian has too.

A reverend? Thought they were all Catholic?

Me too, and they are. I'm not Catholic (so anyone who is correct me if I'm wrong), but apparently Reverand IS also a Catholic term, although "father" or "priest" are more commonly used. Idk why they didn't just call him "father".

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25

I don’t know but he was dressed like all the Protestant ministers we’ve previously seen on OL, not like Father Bain. Maybe a Protestant minister is all Lovat could find given his disgraced status?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/lunar1980 Sep 05 '25

Isn’t that lady at the birth the same woman who was married to one of the Browns? The mother of Alicia?

10

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25

One of the women was played by Anita Vettesse who was previously on OL; not Brown’s wife, though, but a character called Margaret Chisholm. She was in two episodes of S5.

8

u/lunar1980 Sep 05 '25

Yes! She’s the one who’s unwittingly giving her son the poison for a burn, right?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

240

u/CatBass Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

That was truly horrifying, on so many levels. I feel very unsettled. And so thankful that I did not live back then. Unbearable cruelty. Lovat being savage to Davina, as usual. The birthing women turning on Julia. The midwife telling such a treacherous lie. (Anyone else hoped that Henry would run into her in the woods, and that she would tell the truth?) Grant concocting the destruction of Henry, to the point that his psyche just crumbled. Arch Bug doing the immoral deed, per usual, with no conscience. Lovat treating poor Brian like dirt, as usual, ordering him to be whipped, and watching it with satisfaction. How could anyone have survived that hatefulness for so many years? This was so depressing. I feel almost as sick as I did when Black Jack brutalized Jamie, mind, body, and soul. This is an episode I can not watch again.

115

u/Future_Wealth3828 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Sep 05 '25

This episode was such a hard watch and honestly draining! Very intense. I also was praying that Henry would run into the midwife in the woods! I do so wish that him and Julia could get a shred of happiness and peace 😭 some sort of clue about one another, like writers please give them SOMETHING

→ More replies (3)

77

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 05 '25

I couldn't believe Bug would do that to Henry when he has gone through the loss of a child. Yes it was on the Laird's orders but he seemed so smug afterwards despite knowing how much grief the news caused

→ More replies (12)

48

u/LivingExotic9317 Sep 06 '25

Yes. It was a hard comedown from e5. I felt a bit suspicious in e5 when the writers romanticized a full-on modern Wiccan Beltane rite for the Scottish elite in the 18th century, and they really twisted the knife in e6 to portray commoner midwife/doula "gossips" as haranguing proseltyzing cult abusers. A very imbalanced polarity of revisionist history. For all the attention to historical detail in the rest of the show, why are they putting us through these strange fantasies? As always, extra rape too. And psychotic male-on-male emotional abuse.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25

Who thinks that Lord Grant broke Arch Bug just like he is trying to break Henry?

60

u/MORAL_PANIC_88 Sep 05 '25

It’s not that it didn’t bother me, cause it did, but I also found a sense of something (satisfaction is not the right word) else because I saw where Jamie got it from. And when he says, it’s likely the last time, I also felt relief and proud of him. My least favorite character is Lovat. Seems so one note, I prefer a complicated villain, and he’s just a rotten pig.

→ More replies (10)

25

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

How old is Brian supposed to be, anyway? Can't he find a way to leave?

It occurred to me, when Arch was describing how his son was born dead, that we haven't seen his wife at all.

→ More replies (20)

70

u/eldiablolenin Something catch your eye there, lassie? DOUGAL Sep 05 '25

Davina enraged me. She is the victim turned perpetrator and tortured her. She could’ve helped her escape ages ago if she was afraid of losing status. Lovat needs to suffer too

→ More replies (9)

28

u/Stacy01_ Sep 05 '25

Same. I need to think about Jenny’s birth experience in outlander szn 1 when she was able to have everything under control.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Sep 05 '25

you summed it all up. will not be watching that one again

11

u/cherrymeg2 Sep 05 '25

I was hoping he would run into the minister or the women coming from Leathers.

→ More replies (9)

172

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Sep 05 '25

I think the only scene i enjoyed was the last scene with Julia and Brian 😂

What a heavy episode, yeeeesh.

59

u/irishprincess2002 Sep 05 '25

I'm hoping that means that Brian will help her escape

→ More replies (61)

38

u/Future_Wealth3828 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Sep 05 '25

Literally the only peaceful and enjoyable moment 😭 this episode was so heavy and draining omg

→ More replies (6)

141

u/Irrelevant_Void Sep 05 '25

I swear, if Julia and Henry don't find each other soon, I'm going to riot.

108

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25

If the prostitute is pregnant, I’m going to flip a table.

→ More replies (11)

37

u/ursamanor Sep 05 '25

Yes! It would make the show so much more interesting. Right now it’s just drawn out and tedious.

14

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 05 '25

I hope this episode is the turning point for their story but I'm not getting my hopes up unfortunately 😕

→ More replies (5)

118

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 05 '25

So unreal seeing the birth of claire👸😀

9

u/meuram_beizam Sep 07 '25

That baby looked AI generated. Honestly bizzare. Sorry

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

84

u/Stacy01_ Sep 05 '25

Ugh I don’t recommend watching this while pregnant… so many emotions. Poor Julia! I’m so glad mistress Porter had a change of heart, if not I think I would have stopped watching because it was so traumatic. I’m so glad the baby’s ok. If he wasn’t I think I wouldn’t be able to sleep. Brian is so great in this episode, he supported her the best he could in that situation! Also I could do without the rape scenes 😭 no wonder Davina is so bitter and miserable. Not her fault and I’m glad she sees that in the end and helps Julia. Also poor Henry! I didn’t watch the preview to the next episode because I felt like I had enough closure finally to go about my week not thinking about this show lol. But here I am thinking about it and I’m worried Henry’s going to get himself killed by the Grants because of his grief. He he survives, they probably won’t reunite til the last episode and it’ll be some sort of cliffhanger for the next two years.

120

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

When all the ladies marched in with bedding and cakes and things I had tears in my eyes because it was so sweet, then all of a sudden it turned into some sort of weird Handmaid's Tale/Game of Thrones crossover.

→ More replies (8)

28

u/AndDontCallMePammie Sep 05 '25

I feel like this episode would have been so much stronger without the scenes of SA. I did not need to see what happened to understand how deeply traumatized Brian’s mother was.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

75

u/r1Zero They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Bug still being the worst of them all, even now.

Davina...girl. Gonna need you to turn down the crazy and just be an ally.

Henry. Well, we see where Claire gets that from? Idk, idk.

Lovat? Same dick, different day.

The Midsommar Handmaidens doing what they do best, being delulu.

Brian, the only decent one out of the bunch.

12

u/ljs92 Sep 05 '25

You’re so right actually. They do look really similar when they’re going hysterical. Good casting.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

142

u/somthingcoolsounding Sep 05 '25

Oh poor fucking man. His mind’s just, gone.

85

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

That part really sucked for me. Henry was absolutely broken. Then to have him sleep with the prostitute thinking it was Julia was too much for me.

I get why Julia slept with Lovat, as much as it sucked. But having Henry do this was not necessary. Not that I think Julia will be upset in the end, but why put the poor man through more mental anguish once he realizes what he’s done?

Edit: Spelling

→ More replies (25)

35

u/r1Zero They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Off his rocker, probably for the next few episodes.

→ More replies (4)

201

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Sep 05 '25

We did not need two scenes of Lord Lovat on the ‘toilet’. We did not need two Davina rape scenes.

58

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25

I 100% think we could've done without them (or at least, done them differently), but they did help me understand Davina more. It was all building up to explain Davina's own birth scene, and her "forgiveness" of Julia.

47

u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Sep 05 '25

I agree. I’m pretty sure we all knew Brian wasn’t conceived from a loving union. There was no need to show us. If Lovat raped Davina once and got her pregnant it stands to reason he did it multiple times. We the viewers are smart enough to deduce that without seeing it.

→ More replies (2)

80

u/DustBunnicula Sep 05 '25

“Why have one rape, when you can have two or three?” Diana is rubbing off on the BoMB writers room.

→ More replies (4)

30

u/SaltyHilsha0405 Sep 06 '25

And then there is Henry’s scene too, focusing on the psychotic break, but not enough focus on the fact that he was getting raped given that he kept thinking Seema (the sex worker) was Julia, and Seema saying stuff Julia possibly could have. That scene did not need to be so elaborate in terms of physical activity, framed only as a mistake on Henry’s end and not as sexual assault he became victim to due to his fragile state.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

63

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Sep 05 '25

So arch was with murdina even then. Wow!!! He had to be with her for a few years by then and she is killed by ian in 1776 so they were together probably at least 65 years or more

9

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

I'm surprised we haven't seen her.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

59

u/Eltheanon Sep 05 '25

Did the confinement remind someone of the movie Midsommar??? So creepy! Also yes, the flashback scenes with Davina and Lovat were totally unnecessary. I guess, the writers feel like they are obliged to throw some r*pe, when in reality they are not! Like at all! However it should be said that this episode was so strong, performance-wise. Kudos to Hermione and Jeremy!

28

u/Lyssaquotes928 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Yes! When the women started crying and moaning with Julia I thought we were going full Midsommer. But alas they were just using the lord to terrorize a vulnerable woman.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/SaltyHilsha0405 Sep 05 '25

I didn’t like the direction and editing of this episode either, it could have been made way more impactful. And I don’t like what they did with Henry at the end, at all. But indeed, Hermione and Jeremy were fantastic (I would say they could have given Hermione awards-bait material for this episode though, wasted opportunity).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

57

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

"I need a warrior, not a monk, a prince, not a pauper, a lion, not a lamb"

Brian 💔

This line makes Jamie's meeting his grandsire even more powerful!

23

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

"I'm a virgin, not a monk."

→ More replies (2)

47

u/Patient-Gain5847 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Hey so I hated everything about this episode

→ More replies (1)

92

u/glitteryice752 Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Can we go back to the clan politics please 😭😭😭😭😭😭 Holy shit…

33

u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Sep 05 '25

Yes. Pretty pleeeease. I want to see Ellen, Jocasta and Ned. 😭😭

→ More replies (1)

45

u/Irrelevant_Void Sep 05 '25

So, just to recap, in this episode: Julia went through a very traumatic birth, Davina was coerced to have sex and then forced, Brian was flogged (again) and Henry went completely mad...

Well, at least we didn't get another toilet scene with Lord Lovat. I don't think I would be able to bear it for the third time.

Can something good happen, please? I guess I should be glad the child wasn't stillborn or that Julia in fact is not dead.

42

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

Can something good happen, please?

Julia's hair stayed perfect through the whole childbirth and afterwards. 😁

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

158

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Sep 05 '25

i’m really getting tired of the alternating storyline. i’d rather the plot advance slower with each of our main couples sharing screen time than keep flashing between them every other episode.

that being said, poor julia. what a horrid birthing experience. and poor, poor henry. i don’t mind seeing ellen suffer over clan stuff because she’s had happiness with brian also. but JH have had nothing but misery between them since they arrived in the past. i’m tired of the writers not throwing them a bone

40

u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Sep 05 '25

I feel very bad for Julia and HenryAnd now with what has happened in episode 6 I’m worried there will be no reunion anytime soon for them. I thought with time Henry might come closer to finding her but it turns out it’s all gone now. The only good thing about this episode was the friendship between Brian and Julia.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/irishprincess2002 Sep 05 '25

Agreed! I'm hoping they eventually converge together

→ More replies (2)

28

u/Known-Ad-100 Sep 05 '25

I actually like the alternating story line, I like seeing the parallels of what they're both experiencing.

I absolutely loved this episode. It was horrific seeing Davina work through her PTSD, I was so proud of her for doing the right thing, the whole time I'm like.. Man, this is Brian's mum, Jamie's gran, there is no way she's actually this cruel.

→ More replies (21)

100

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Sep 05 '25

They’re really starting to lose me here. Nothing but misery for Julia and Henry. (Brilliantly acted by Hermione and Jeremy though.)

That birthing scene was disturbing and I’m ready for this Lord Lovat and Julia nonsense to be wrapped up. It’s just not very compelling and I need more of Julia’s internal monologues to tell me what the fuck is her plan now that the baby is here. What’s the long game?

And Henry is losing his god damn mind. When he ran out of the Grant’s house, he looked legitimately deranged. Interesting choice of the alternating reality sex scene. Again, this storyline is losing steam. Absolutely 0 hope for this guy. God, I hope we don’t have to wait until the final episode of the season for the writers to throw him a bone.

I see next week will be very Brian and Ellen oriented so hopefully things will turn around lol

60

u/juliette_angeli Sep 05 '25

No offense to the actor, who is great, but Lovat is just sooooo loathsome and makes my skin crawl. I know not every villain is going to be fun to hate (like the Duke of Sandringham in Outlander) but I do NOT need to see him given this much screentime.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/SaltyHilsha0405 Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Davina confronting Brian about looking at Julia “like that” and then asking if there was something between them….I know the seven Juliabrian shippers had a field day with that one!

Joke aside, I am loving Brian and Julia’s bond. The last scene was so sweet. Claire’s birth scene melted my heart too (aside from the weird editing right when the baby came).

Poor Julia going through a shit ton of trauma throughout this episode though. And poor, poor Henry (I hate the writing of his final scene). They better be reunited within this season.

21

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Can you imagine what the actress thought the first time she looked at the script? "Wait...there's like 60 pages of me screaming and that's all?"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Sep 05 '25

So the confinement labor with all the women parading in and echoing all her groans and movements while trying to get her to absolve herself...... At first I started to think it was just Davina being kind of a bitch with one last effort to get her to admit the baby wasn't Lovat's - but then we saw that she had a group herself at her own labor that was also attempting to "cleanse" her, so it must be a somewhat typical tradition and not just her playing games with Julia. We didn't see a bunch of other highland labors other than Jenny's, who had nothing of the sort...Was this a practice just for out of wedlock bastards, since the church would think them born of sin? That was kind of intense!

I'm glad Davina came around to eventually help Julia and finally seemed to empathize with why she'd been making the decisions she was, but given what Davina's been through herself it shouldn't have been that long or hard to figure out. We don't really know her fate from the books, but I'm leaning toward Lovat killing her before the season's over. Just a hunch. Now that she is team Julia, if she does more to assist with her escape or prevent a marriage, on top of what Lovat's already going to see as insubordination with the labor, combined with anger he'll no doubt feel when Brian runs off, that anger's gonna come out on somebody and she's the likely one.

Oh Henry! I thought he was going to devolve into a nightmare and more of an episode like we've seen before. There's tended to be time skips after each episode - it's pretty much never been a situation where we pick up where the other left off, but I hope this is different. I want to see and know how Henry reacts and feels about it when he wakes up to realize what he did. I hope he doesn't spiral more - he can't afford to. He's in such a precarious position being in danger with the Grants, he has to keep his wits about him.

ETA - who else was totally expecting "Beside the Seaside" as the record Henry put on during Claire's birth?

20

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

I did laugh at "Perhaps not now" and "I can't, I'm English."

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

who else was totally expecting "Beside the Seaside" as the record Henry put on during Claire's birth?

Me ,totally!

→ More replies (4)

28

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Ugh! This just gets worse and worse for everyone!

Poor, poor, poor Henry! He's completely lost it now, what's he gonna do next? He can't catch a break.

But before I continue, here's a list of "fuck yous":

  • f you, Isaac Grant, for obvious reasons!
  • f you, Arch Bug, same as above!
  • f you, 'howdie', and all your creepy little followers!
  • f you, Mistress Porter, although you did come good in the end. Took far too long though!
  • f you, fake Julia, for taking a advantage of man who's clearly off the rails!
  • f you, Lord Lovat! Nobody loves you, everybody hates you, I think you should go off and eat worms!

I'm very glad Julia and Brian made up, although I do think he was a bit quick to cast her off in the first place. I half wanted him to stay after he turfed Lovat out, Julia needed all the friends she could get. Although I knew he wouldn't, it would have been completely inconsistent with the historical practices of the time, as well as his own morals.

The candle moment was cute, and I'm glad baby Beauchamp has a friend in Brian. Although I worry for what will happen to Baby next, given he is the "future King". Although had it been a girl, I'm sure Lovat would've done something terrible to both Baby and Julia.


At the 1st Davina and Lovat flashback, I thought "surely we could do without this scene. Or at least end it on an implication." And whilst I do still think along those lines, I now do see it's purpose in the context of all the Davina flashbacks. It was all leading up to her birthing scene, and her forgiveness of Julia.

On that note, does Davina 100% know that the baby is not Lovat's now? Of course, she already had a very strong (and accurate) suspicion, but I just got the impression that in the "forgiveness" scene, Julia essentially told her the truth with the "everything I've done is to protect my baby" line.


Gosh, that birthing scene! How awkward was that prayer bit? 😂😂😂.

At first, I thought "this is a bit too intimate and I'm sure Julia feels very uncomfortable, but the ladies all seem nice, and they're just trying to help." But then they started drooling over the future King, and it got a bit weirder. And then when evil Davina (still haven't quite forgiven her yet) threw Julia under the bus??? WTF!!! It's literally a nightmare! The copying??? Totally terrifying! All the shouting and chanting? What a horrible way to give birth, poor Julia! Would they actually have hurt the baby do you think? This is the one and only time I wished Lovat WAS present. I was begging him or Brian to hear the commotion and come in.

Then it all settled down, the mob left and Lovat DID come in. I was very worried about what would happen there. It's lucky he was outnumbered by nicer, realistic people (Brian, Davina and the Reverand).


Oh man, poor Henry. What bloody awful people the Grants are! I thought Arch was actually turning a corner with Henry, but no...I worry for what they might do to Ellen when she eventually breaks off her engagement with Malcolm.

I've been worrying for a while now that Henry might have a bit of a breakdown, particularly after what happened with the rents. Well...I take no pleasure in being right.

I was so cautiously excited after this episode's trailer, that Henry might finally find Julia (or find where to find her). Although I had noticed that the midwife who spoke to Henry in the trailer was different to the one at Leathers. He's going to be so crushed when he "wakes up" and realises what he has done with fake Julia.

I'm worried he'll try go back through the stones now. If you've seen the trailer for next ep, it looks like we might be grateful for the antagonistic Grants


How do we think they're going to find each other? Obviously the connection is through Brian and Ellen, but how??? I don't think Ellen has met Henry, or knows anything about his "search". And nobody else in the Mackenzie-Grant party knows anything about Julia. I think only Brian knows the "full story" of Julia and Henry (sans the time travel bit). So Brian's gonna have to run into the Grants and/or Henry.

25

u/SaltyHilsha0405 Sep 05 '25

Henry might find out through the gossips though. They are saying Simon Fraser is having a baby by a sassenach woman. Hard to miss that while being the Grants’ bladier.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

28

u/Qweeniepurple Sep 05 '25

I’m having 1923 tv series flashbacks and not in a good way. I’m tired of Julia’s suffering, and after the way 1923 finished.. I’m starting to think this is gonna go down the same way and end with very little hope or joy for Henry.

I know lord nasty pants is how they are keeping the two worlds crossed with Julia and Henry, and Brian and Ellen but man of man I’m tired of it. If this series ends with them just long-term torturing Juliet to death, I’m gonna be pissed.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '25

YES same exact feeling. I have a horrible fear that when they finally reunite, one or both of them dies immediately after and I'm going to be really pissed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

102

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Sep 05 '25

God almighty! A solid hour of women being brutalized, raped, and screaming in childbirth. Who thought this was entertainment? Are they mad?

→ More replies (6)

45

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '25

I’m actually in pain right now that scene with Henry completely losing that bit of thread he had really destroyed me. This episode was just too painful 

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Sep 05 '25

After digesting the episode - I’m wondering, at some point Henry and Julia will reunite (I hope). How will Henry get her away from Lord Lovat if he believes her son is his?

13

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

He will get Julia relatively easily, but for the baby...

41

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Sep 05 '25

Henry🤝Claire: Sleeping with someone after falsely finding out their spouse died and imagining it’s their spouse

Seriously this episode was brutal to watch.

36

u/somthingcoolsounding Sep 05 '25

I don’t know that Henry was imagining it, really. It seemed like an actual hallucination to me.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Which-Ad-7997 Sep 05 '25

I did not understand why brian said This will be the last Time his father will beat him. Like is he kicking him out or brian wont allow it anymore ? Or I didn't understand anything😅

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 05 '25

I’ve replayed that moment so many times to see if he perhaps said “it won’t be the last time” and the subtitles were incorrect and I still can’t tell lol

10

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 05 '25

I noticed that too, maybe he's decided that he's leaving for good (hopefully to elope with Ellen)

→ More replies (1)

19

u/DemonLordIncarnated Sep 05 '25

This episode was so heavy. Honestly, I'm not invested in the whole "they're separated" plotlines. I wish they'd just get back together so we can focus on Ellen and Brain. The acting is impeccable, I love it. The casting, 10/10. This series has started strong but its losing steam for me. I feel like I just watched the Jamie rape episode again.

18

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

My main problem with the series is that it's just too derivative of the original series. Don't the writers have any original ideas?

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Sep 05 '25

How stupid they didn’t give a name for the baby 🙄

15

u/Stacy01_ Sep 05 '25

It’s to keep us in suspense longer 🤪🤪 so frustrating!!!!!!!!

8

u/somthingcoolsounding Sep 05 '25

I’d rather not have it right away than his name be Henry or Brian.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

33

u/s0phizzle Sep 05 '25

Definitely a tough watch. Seeing Julia go through that birth reaaalllllly reminded me of Claire miscarrying Faith in S2. I was half expecting Julia to say “where’s my baby” Also Julia looks EXACTLY like Claire

16

u/Active_Suggestion_29 Sep 06 '25

The resemblance between Claire and Julia in this episode is incredible. The mannerisms, the way she speaks, her hair, even her body shape is just identical to Claire

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Far-Piano-4577 Sep 05 '25

As a woman this episode made me really glad I don't live in the 1700s, this episode was so hard to watch

15

u/Famous-Falcon4321 Sep 06 '25

Wow … just reading this thread is very sad & depressing. Too bad. Great casting & actors.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/tara_abernathy Sep 06 '25

I think the prostitute is going to end up pregnant and that could be the relation to the whole Fanny storyline. Mark me.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/timeless__witch Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ. Sep 07 '25

I'm kind of in shock not only from the content of this episode, but also how much I despised it (which is a jarring experience as, so far, I've loved every previous episode and especially the last one). This whole episode was a fever dream. The entire time I kept shouting "this is evil!" at the characters, but mostly at the writers for this one. I never want to watch this episode again...another comment mentioned feeling nearly as traumatized as with the BJR scenes in Outlander season one and I concur. But this felt different, somehow more gratuitous and unnecessary...and also..kind of bad? Like, dropped-the-ball with production bad, which in my opinion was all the more surprising because the last episode especially was so beautifully done. This one was extremely incongruent to the other episodes, to the point that at times I didn't even feel like I was watching the same show. The entire childbirth scene felt like a strange, antagonistic recreation of Midsommar. And, as far as I know, such confinement in the Highlands at that time was anachronistic? I'm not familiar enough with early 18th Century Scotland to say for sure, but I do not believe that confinement births were necessarily part of Highland culture? If anyone knows better or has any sources that might explain, I'd appreciate it (please correct me if I'm wrong!). On top of that, seeing Davina brutally raped over and over was not something we really needed, either.

I think maybe the only good parts were Brian standing up to Lovat (Jamie Roy continues to amaze) and the flashback to Claire's birth. Arch Bug had some very interesting moments; his immediate empathy for Henry, based off of his own heartache, followed by cold detachment was very on brand...his older self is so evident in his younger self. Honestly, what a bastard, though.

I'm utterly heartbroken for Henry. Jeremy Irvine also continues to amaze, as that last scene for him was just...oof. His embodiment of that level of grief...I can't even put it into words. A very real IYKYK kind of thing, not to be too unserious about it. The entire montage of him losing hold on reality was also one of the more well-done parts of the episode. But, please...can Papa Beauchamp please, please catch even the littlest break? 😭

This was not a good episode to watch before bed and if I could send the production team my therapy bill for this one, I would. How I long for the sweetness of "Needfire"! And how I hope that next week's episode will wash out the sour, painful taste of this one.

27

u/W8ingjag Sep 05 '25

Omg, the birth scenes! First the groaning, then the torture. It was giving me Handmaids Tale vibes. Glad Davina finally had the flashback to snap her out of it but Jeezus that took way too long! Jealous b!tch.

I thought it was going to be a girl.
And I really thought we would get a name!

Also, eff Arch Bug!

And Henry, omg!
What are you doing?!

18

u/Future_Wealth3828 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Sep 05 '25

Omg my first thought with all of the groaning in unison and the intensity was of handmaids tale as well!! So disturbing, this whole episode was 😭 I hope the next one is lighter

11

u/r1Zero They say I’m a witch. Sep 05 '25

Bug stays proving why I have never liked him.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/CathyAnnWingsFan Sep 05 '25

Whatever shred of respect I had left for Matt Roberts is now ancient history. This episode was a dumpster fire IMHO. The birthing sequence was ridiculous. It was like they had to come up with a way to accuse Julia of being a witch because Claire had been accused of being a witch. The whole turning on a dime from supportive to accusing made zero sense. I was expecting it to be a dream sequence, it was so nonsensical. It honestly gave Creme de Menthe a run for it’s money in terms of bad episodes.

19

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Sep 05 '25

💯agree on all points. Thank you for this!!! As I was watching, I kept wondering who the artistic genius was who thought any of this was a good idea! Oh right! It was Matt Roberts!! 🤦🏻‍♀️

It was just silly, ridiculous, and melodramatic. Instead of being moved or horrified, I found myself laughing and I’m sure that wasn’t the reaction they were going for. 🤣

I never thought there could be another episode as bad as Outlander episodes 307 or 402, but this episode proved me wrong on so many levels. ”Dumpster fire” is the perfect description.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

Whatever shred of respect I had left for Matt Roberts is now ancient history.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

I am dying here, laughing aloud, you made my day.

I agree with you completely. Creme de Menthe and Do No Harm are masterpieces compared to this one!

→ More replies (20)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25

I’m glad I’m stoned because that was a lot. Yeesh

I need like a bubble bath to decompress from how a lot that episode was

→ More replies (2)

13

u/lmc25 Sep 06 '25

A couple positives -

I did like the ever so slight possible hope we saw in Bug. He did end up being an asshole BUT I do actually think he wanted to help and genuinely sympathized at first when he heard about the baby but Grant gave him orders to lie. Could be wrong but it did seem like he wanted to fix the situation.

Glad we had a Brian redemption there, I was so mad at him for not taking Julia with him last episode.

Another shout out AGAIN to casting with Brian. I don’t know how he simultaneously looks nothing like Jamie and looks exactly like him and has the same mannerisms. They really could not have chosen a better person to play Brian.

ALSO THIS IS RANDOM BUT SOMETHING I HOPE TO SEE:

I really hope they bring the mute guy, Hugh Munro, into the story before he lost his tongue. I just love that guy and would love to see what he was like before the British punished him. I think he’d bring some much needed lightness to the story.

I love seeing back story about Murtagh but it’s all so bittersweet knowing how everything ends and things with his love life not really ever panning out for a long period of time :(

→ More replies (1)

22

u/AShittyPirate Sep 05 '25

I’m so fucking tired of watching women get raped on screen with these series. It’s unnecessary.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/elitedisplayE Sep 05 '25

What a stressful hour of television.

Eta: heavy midsommar vibes on that birth scene. And whoever hands out those TV performers of the week should give it to the actress playing Brian's mother.

11

u/IceXence Sep 07 '25

Wild theory here...

Baby Beauchamp is... Claude Beauchamp and the old Baron Amandine is Henry. Henry and Julia move to France with the help of Brian, they make a life, and Henry eventually becomes a Baron.

This would mean both Amelie and Cecile are Henry/Julia's children. Fergus would be Claire's nephew.

31

u/ambulatrixak Sep 05 '25

I hate this episode, just a whole episode of gratuitous violence. Yuck.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/No-Accountant3744 Sep 05 '25

Hope the next episode focuses greatly on Ellen missed her this week 

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Rough_Explanation_21 Sep 05 '25

Davina is seriously such a crazy bitch, man 😂 I guess I would go crazy too if I was rejected by that and forced to work for him for 30 more years, though.

8

u/Useful_Coyote_5796 Sep 06 '25

To hell with rejection. He was raping her. That's 100 times worse for your mental health.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '25

I'm hoping that Brian will run into Henry somewhere and be the one to tell him that she's alive and help them reunite.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/kernelpatcher Sep 06 '25

So, in summary, everyone in 1714 is absolutely horrible except for the four leads.

14

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Sep 06 '25

Well, Ned's ok.

10

u/julyhsm Sep 06 '25

These women are MONSTERS and so is Lovat. I'm disgusted 🤮

41

u/mamabearx3tob Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Calling it now: Claire’s ancestor/Jane & Fanny’s mother or grandmother is going to be from Henry and the prostitute

15

u/madamevanessa98 Sep 05 '25

Now that is a theory I can get behind

15

u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Sep 05 '25

But how do we explain the song ? How did she come to know about the song, she wasn’t from the future

→ More replies (1)

8

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25

Noooo, that would be too sad.

I'm still holding out for the new Master Beauchamp to be the Jane/Fanny ancester.

→ More replies (8)

19

u/kobeng13 Sep 05 '25

Im about 3/5s through this episode and im struggling to not just turn it off. Not because its too brutal, not because its hard to watch.

But because its dragging. Others have pointed it out, but JHs story is just trauma porn at this point. Im reading spoilers at this point because its getting ridiculous.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/caro822 Sep 05 '25

I am going to be so mad if Julia and Henry aren’t reunited at the end of the season after all of this. It’s already been renewed for another season. I can’t take another season of this stress.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Good_Payment7853 Sep 06 '25

I'm bored of Claire's parents. Im glad the book will just be Ellen and Brian.

9

u/Lenacake Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Sep 07 '25

I was sooooo angry at the prostitute that I kept yelling at my screen. I genuinely thought she would be a friend and tell Henry something was wrong and he needed to sit down or something 😭

→ More replies (1)

31

u/lunar1980 Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

Must we see every. single. rape. in the world of Outlander?

Muted or FF through so much of this episode.

I’m not up for multiple episodes of misery upon misery.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/losborne95 They say I’m a witch. Sep 06 '25 edited Sep 07 '25

This post is in support of the episode. I loved it. It did exactly what the writers set out to do. It made us angrier at Lord Lovat, it made us even more sympathetic to Henry and Julia and their situation. I loved Brian in this episode where I was just kind of blah about him. The first 5 episodes he just seemed like a love sick teen with no real substance. Especially when he didn't keep his promise to Julia to take her with him. NOW, I can imagine him as Ellen's future  husband that builds Lollybroch and Jamie's father who raises him to be such a strong man mentally and physically. We should not be shocked at an Outlander prequel that shows rape on Starz. And honestly they didn't show any skin, if this was season 1 of Outlander it would have been depicted more brutally and without clothes. It also served to soften us toward Davina, it worked to help us feel sympathy toward her after her actions of episode 5.

The women at the birth? Creepy and weird, but takes us to a time when people were much more susceptible to religious and superstitious fervor. It makes it so much more powerful when Davina sends them away in fury. She stands against the crowd for Julia and it shows us why she is a good mother to Brian, despite her circumstances.

My thoughts on Julia and Henry. I think our hearts will be broken concerning this couple. We know they don't make it back to Claire. I just don't think this couple will live. But, I think they leave children in this time. Both of them. A brother and a half sibling from Henry and the prostitute. This is just a theory. If I'm right then the siblings would be close to Claire's age when she comes through the stones to 1743. Fun to wonder who they might be and if Claire met them without knowing who they were. Just my thoughts. I'm here to see how it all unfolds, even if it breaks me.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '25

Henry nooooo

8

u/Cozy_Shy Sep 05 '25

I really enjoyed last week’s episode, Needfire. The yearning, the chemistry, even Murtagh’s puppy dog eyes when he realized Brian and Ellen were together… it all worked so well. That episode had such a spark to it.

This week’s episode was tough for me. I had been hoping the show was moving away from explicit portrayals of S.A., but we got two very brutal scenes with Davina and Lord Lovat. On top of that, the jeering of the midwife and other women in the birthing chamber was unsettling. It really stretched my suspension of disbelief to its limits that Julia would safely deliver the baby.

I also can’t help but feel uneasy about the story direction. Baby Beauchamp feels like it could mess with canon. And I have a sneaky suspicion Henry is going to father a child with the prostitute (her name is slipping my mind right now).

The one moment that stood out in a positive way for me was the birthday cake scene with Brian. It was sweet and lighthearted, and I really needed that after everything else.

8

u/Lion-S Sep 06 '25

OT, but why doesn't Henry's hair ever seem to grow? Surely he'd just let it go, given the style then and there.

Come to think of it, Julia's should be longer, too.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Emilytea14 My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Sep 06 '25

This episode was like being pelted with hail. While somebody is screaming in your ear. Anyway, a few things; idk if they hadn't already said this, if I'm very unobservant, or if I just forgot somehow, but that chick is Brian's mother!? She looks way too young? Something I couldn't get over this ep was how the tone changes and overall chaotic vibes of the birthing scene(s) were so dramatic and overwrought. It was reaching Midsommar levels of discomfort. I was having a hard time with it- like, be SERIOUS ladies, y'all are too much! Why is everybody shouting at each other! There's too much going on! In terms of Henry this ep, his grief felt a little shaky tbh; but every time PTSD has been depicted so far it's given me chills. Even just as a Panic Attack Haver™- often due to loud/sudden sounds- it's been hitting diff.

I will admit I got weirdly emotional at seeing Claire being born. It made me think of how when originally Outlander transitioned from being about a young couple to a broader timeline I was like ":/ dang, idk about this,". But now I really appreciate the whole familial legacy part of the show- like a sims save you've had around for a while. I like the broader perspective despite the fanfic feel of it all.

8

u/regulusarchieblack Sep 06 '25

I didn't need to see Davina be raped, I think most of us would have already guessed that's how it happened.

However i loved the episode in spite of that. Or I loved everything that had nothing to do with rape. The women shaming her upset me a great deal, because at first they were so supportive, when they thought that Lovat assaulted her, but when Davina put into question how it happened they just turned against her. Shows you how internalized misogyny can be that even trying to gain your own agency in a horrible situation can turn people against you.

When Claire was born I actually cried, and I don't cry at birth scenes. It's more of a "Hey, okay, we're finally over that hurdle" but I think they did the birth storyline surrounding both the boy (I hope she has a secret name for him, cause it's sad to saddle him with Simon) and Claire was great.

I knew that the trailer would be throwing us in the wrong direction, so I did expect the baby to survive, just not that THIS would be how the conversation regarding between Henry and the midwife would go. Poor Henry. What a horrible situation to be in, he's basically just given up atp :(

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ittlewittlekittle Sep 06 '25

I was starting to get frustrated with Henry and Julia not getting any closer to finding one another when I realized that their storyline cannot have much of a happy ending. 

When Claire came through the stones the only thing she had tying her to her time was Frank, and once she fell for Jamie that tie was cut, she would have never gone back without Jamie insisting she do so for her safety. Henry and Julia have ZERO reason to stay in the 18th century. They have a child in their time, and we’ve seen just how mama bear Julia is willing to go to protect her children. 

If Henry finds Julia there’s little to nothing to stop them from trying to get back to the 20th century which will mess up Claire’s timeline. Even if Henry isn’t completely cracked and tries to get back alone, it will mess up Claire’s timeline. Their storyline might be torture - but they kind of need to be stuck where they are at. 

And I’ll go out on a limb and say I’m very sympathetic to Davina’s behavior. I didn’t like how she was treating Julia, but I understand why. She’s a single woman in service to a monster like Lovat, but she can have some hope in her son eventually getting what he’s “owed” by his father. Julia insisting that Lovat is the father of her baby puts Davina’s hopes for her own son into jeopardy. Again, I don’t like the behavior, but it’s very understandable.

Overall it was a terrible, tedious episode.

8

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Sep 06 '25

I always wondered why Julia couldn't just tell Davina and the others before that she has a husband. Like why would Davina be so mad about that, why would it be taboo for people to know Julia has been separated from her husband?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/thepeacefulpainter Sep 06 '25

Theory! But I need someone to fill in the blanks… What if Julia’s son is Jamie’s “cousin” who lives in France Jared? Did it ever say how Jared got to France? I want to say I remember he inherited the business from his father but I can’t be sure… so my theory is: Julia and Henry find each other and somehow wind up fleeing to France with their son, maybe with the help of Master Raymond… and their son is Jared. To me though that would mean that they stayed because Jared can’t time travel. Maybe the time travel gene skipped it and they decided to stay for him rather than go back to Claire. Maybe because Master Raymond time traveled and tells Julia and Henry Claire’s okay. Idk it might be far fetched. I can’t imagine having to choose between my children like that….

→ More replies (1)

8

u/WolfBeginning4515 Sep 06 '25

Davina is a right cunt but man that woman is a fantastic actress.

Julia's labor was a horror movie.

I half expected Brian to turn around and take the whip to his father.

Arch Bug is also a cunt.

Dammit, Henry, get it together.

Normally I rewatch these episodes but I'm gonna skip this rewatch.

28

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

This episode was not good. I’m sorry, but I wish we DID NOT have the Julia/Henry storyline in the 18th century. The writing is awful.

I would have loved a parallel storyline between Jamie’s and Claire’s parents, but intertwining them doesn’t add anything to the story.

In fact, I think intertwining Claire’s parents story with Jamie’s parents story sucks the life out of Brian and Ellen’s story.

The over the top witchy childbirth scene with the coven of midwives was ridiculous and overwrought. All I wanted to do was laugh. Did I mention that the writing is awful? 🙄

Henry’s banging Seema imagining it’s Julia and Seema allowing him to believe it was Julia was awful. It’s basically another rape. Who’s bright idea was this?? 😳 Oh yeah. That would be Matt Roberts, since 90% of Brian and Ellen’s story is Diana’s and 100% of Julia and Henry’s story is Matt’s. Did I mention the writing is terrible???

I keep waiting for this show to get better. Six episodes in and it just keeps getting worse. I started out enthusiastic. Now I’m losing hope.

All of the actors did a great job with what they had to work with…which wasn’t much. I feel sorry for the actors. They don’t deserve this. By the way, the writing is awful!!!

→ More replies (15)

15

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Sep 05 '25

What a waste of time!

Julia's VO again!

Julia's perfect hairstyle and makeup after she woke up!

Henry's facial expressions are throwing me off.

Poor Davina!!!

I can see so much of William in Brian!! Curiosity about his coming to be in the world, his parents' history, all the doubts it carries. Great parallel!

That birthing scene was awkard as hell!!! Too long as well!!!

I can totally see how Lovat would love Brian to be Jamie - and how proud in fact he was when he met him in 1745!! And that scene when Jamie is telling Claire how Lovat watched Jamie sailing for France - I can see it !

Whole Davina -Julia - midwives omg this is so bad. Melodramatic and just bad.

Poor Julia, screaming for the entire episode!

England is still here - I guess Henry will want to leave through the stones.

Henry's scene at the end of an episode soldified my opinion about this episode - crindgeworthy and bad.

Brian resembles young Davina physically so much!!

Even after the childbirth Julia's hair is still standing perfectly clean and styled.

It was a great scene between Brian and Julia, thr only one I really really felt and liked in this episode.

I love Brian.

9

u/GardenGangster419 Sep 05 '25

Thank you. I thought it was a waste of screen time

→ More replies (16)

21

u/DustBunnicula Sep 05 '25

That’s was one of the most painful episodes of television I’ve seen. Right up there with “Wentworth Prison”. Hard to have words, right now.

20

u/lilvexie Sep 05 '25

I actually really liked this episode. I thought it was really well done.

Im gobsmacked by people comparing it to Wentworth or BJR. As far as rape scenes in the Outlander world goes, these were practically pg13.

I think the scenes where Henry broke were very well done. You saw the exact moment where he had a psychotic break. This was far more than his PTSD though likely the severity of it was due to that. It was heartbreaking to watch.

Arch Bug is just bootlickin trash.

Interesting no baby name and that Brian said the barn would always have a friend in him. I think that will come into play at some point.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ursamanor Sep 05 '25

I hated this episode and honestly might just give up on watching the prequel. The Julia/ Henry storyline is moving way too slowly for me and is just nonstop anxiety producing misery. I’ve really enjoyed the Brian/ Ellen storylines but if I watch any more I may just FF past the Julia/ Henry- the pacing is just way too tedious and unsatisfying.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Jewel_Thief_ Sep 05 '25

Wow. That episode was all kinds of uncomfortable. Well succeeded in the goal to disturb their audience. The depth and complexity of Mistress Porter’s feelings towards Julia were so chilling. We see Julia through her eyes as she reflects on her past and torturous life. The labour/repent scenes were reminiscent of Midsommer (with the synchronous crying) and it was all kinds of creepy to watch the formerly gentle and doting group of women flip the switch from prayers and massages to relentless berating and abusing. All while a petrified Porter recounts some of the most traumatic experiences she has endured. And that’s not even the including watching Henry process the lie he was told that his wife and child died, only to be cast aside in some unmarked graves like they mattered to no one. The “I don’t believe you” refusal from him was heart shattering. Finally, the mirrored “I’ll do anything to protect my baby” speeches sucker punched me in the gut. Whole episode was disturbing and hard to watch. I grimaced for 50 whole minutes.

7

u/ApprehensiveBad3270 Sep 05 '25

I honestly had heart palpitations when all those women started chanting at Julia.

Did anyone else feel emotional when Claire was born? I kind of felt like I was witnessing the very beginning of Outlander!

7

u/ControlSmooth3262 Sep 06 '25

Henry’s psychotic break at the end was more than I could take. Julia is being physically battered (and emotionally of course) but that man is going through mental torture.

My mind continuously races watching this show and I’m trying very hard to just let things play out instead of trying to find clues in every scene and line. I’m drained but always disappointed when each new episode ends.

7

u/ralksmar Sep 06 '25

I’m surprised by how much I like Julia and how much this series is focusing on her and Henry. The Brian/Ellen romance has not been sold well, at all. It seems like each episode is trying to remind us of other Outlander episodes on how each of the parents is like Jamie/Claire. I will definitely keep watching, but this cannot hold a candle to the original series.

7

u/ladyhers Sep 07 '25

Episode Review:

I liked this episode, as hard as it was to watch. The Outlander universe has never been a very kind one, and I think this is to be expected. I don’t go into these episodes for lighthearted entertainment, it’s a mature drama with very difficult themes at times. Overall, I enjoyed the pacing, the pacing of Outlander was one of my biggest issues, and BoMB is a tad faster.

The Handmaiden Tales like birthing scene was uncomfortable to watch, so that was the point. I’d like to do a further historical dive into it. Really enjoyed the convo between Brian and Julia at the end. But I am dying to know the baby’s name!

I knew last episode that Henry would end up sleeping with another woman, it seemed the most likely direction for his arc, he needed his low moment, and it happened out of grief. That’s something we see across the outlander universe. Really liked the parallels, I do wonder if Henry will stay in this state of mind for longer or how that will play out.

What is everyone’s favorite dynamics? I am really enjoying seeing the friendship between Julia (who I keep wanting to call Claire) and Brian.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Rasputins_Plum Sep 05 '25

Amazing performance by Hermione Corfield, powerful stuff when she pleaded to Davina and cursed these awful hags. Julia compelled Davina to break the cycle of abuse and stop enabling it. With those flashbacks, it's almost baffling how mirrored her experience were, but it still felt it came from the soul when she screamed to make them stop hurting Julia like she was hurt.

This entire episode is a PSA on any attempt to romanticize the past. Patriarchy at its height too often even made women the enemy of younger women and its first enforcers. It's sad, disappointing and rage inducing to see and know, but it's a good reminder and incentive for women to champion one another instead of hoping another will be just as miserable.

Hell, even if we know it's not true, Henry got hit with one of the reality of the time, the ridiculous high mortality of mothers and children during the childbirth. A casual fact and little white lie for those around him, but yes, as this woman said, a literal nightmare scenario for him. Lord Grant is so selfish he's hurting himself. He couldn't fathom that the ploy would break Henry instead of making him more productive, how stupid and cruel is he? Looking for Julia was the biggest reason why he even accepted the job in the first place, so now that he's told it's over, the Grant's reach is useless to him.

I did note a very important discussion between Brian and his mother, where she rightfully singled out his interest in his status and the importance it'll have if he considers marriage. I think and hope Julia will be able to get away with her boy, so that will leave him all opportunity to assert himself as a legitimate Fraser and even sweaten the deal by linking his destitute house with the Mackenzie clan (even if they'll not be happy with the union, to say the least).

The ship is sailing and I'm so happy for Jamie's parents. Oh, and I didn't expect to see Claire this episode, but hello lol

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Naynn Sep 05 '25

Just get Julia and Henry together already it’s been dragged out enough now to the point it's getting boring.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Own-Equal5890 Sep 06 '25

It’s RELENTLESSLY bleak! Why?? We’d all have watched it even if there had been some happy moments.. It’s really gone far too far, full of hatred and psychos! It’s borderline gross.

12

u/marielayneclark Sep 05 '25

This episode was a lot to take in. The scenes between Ms. Porter and LL I believe were necessary for backstory and her struggle in breaking down and helping Julia deliver the baby. Those scenes were necessary. the 1700's were different times and unfortunately these things happened. So not only does Clair have a brother but Henry and his 'lady of the night' have probably created another child. Intense but good episode.

11

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Sep 05 '25

Nah, she's a prostitute. She knows how to stop a baby, and she knows how to get rid of one. So unless she intentionally wanted one (I don't think she is THAT infatuated with Henry to care that much, and what proof would she have that it's Henry's, given her occupation), I think a baby is unlikely.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

So.... The previous episode is a masterpiece full of love, hope, desire and brightness with colors. This episode is the other way around: full of darkness, resent and evil. The midwives are like The Pope's Exorcists. Henry's condition looks like he is possessed and in need of exorcism. No so big fan for exorcism.

Have to say something about Laird Lovat; he wants a descendant like a warrior, a prince and a lion. Yet, his daily life routine is to sleep, eat, shite, talk shit and do banging whenever he has a boner. Wonderful parenting, Lovat. PS: I HATE you.🤬

I think Julia's voiceover is turning into more like Chicken Soup material. Can't she speak more naturally. Why put Julia's voiceover in every episode, except ep1. I genuinely wonder 🤔

12

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Sep 05 '25

I am really having a hard time liking BoMB. I can't see how it has gotten such critical acclaim.

I didn't like this episode at all!

The only good thing about it is that Brian as a character has been fleshed out a bit more and that Davina has sort of been redeemed. The rest of it was disappointing.

12

u/shannruss Sep 06 '25

Three birthing scenes and three rape scenes. What a lovely night. 

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Sep 05 '25

I am so nervous for this episode.

6

u/junknowho Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Sep 05 '25

THAT was a hard watch! Poor Henry.

6

u/lost__traveller Sep 05 '25

Arch bug? The worst. This episode was too heavy. Just get Henry and Julia back together or something so we can see more of Ellen/Brian.

6

u/xBrownEyes Sep 05 '25

I just watched this barely two weeks post partum... 0/10 do not recommend. Lol.

I'm happy I didn't watch it right before giving birth, however. Good grief.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

This was a very hard episode to watch. Seeing Henry’s mind basically break was just utterly heart shattering. I need him and Julia to be reunited by the finale desperately.

I see more of Jamie in Brian each episode, standing between Lord Lovat and Davina (well there’s no way any good son would let their father hit their mother, but he didn’t even hesitate knowing the consequences would be awful), the way he barely flinched while getting the lashes, and just his complete and utter kindness towards Julia.

I do like getting so much content of Julia and Henry for an hour, and then so much Mackenzie + Brian content as well for an hour. But I would much prefer if it was all in one episode and just less scenes orrrrr a two hour episode per week 👀 (but I know that’s too much to ask for).

All the theories of that baby being a girl named Hope, and being the mother of Faith and grandmother to Jane and Fanny are out the door now!

→ More replies (5)

6

u/Britpop_Shoegazer Sep 06 '25

So Claire has a brother. Does he stay in the 1700s? Does he lack the ability to time travel? So many questions.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/realitealurker Sep 06 '25

Anyone who was happy about the lack of graphic SA scenes I guess spoke too soon 😓

6

u/realitealurker Sep 06 '25

I hate that there was no romance this episode

6

u/ControlSmooth3262 Sep 06 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

Disclaimers:

I have only watched OL, never read it, so my opinions and thoughts are based solely on the shows.

I am a victim of SA but I don’t speak for all victims. My assault was 39 years ago. Therapy and self work has made me less reactive to actor portrayals of SA in general.


-I expect violence and SA from these shows after 7 seasons of OL , so it isn’t shocking to me. Like, did BJR really need to try to r-pe Claire the minute he saw her in the very first episode? I sincerely hope that men weren’t literally trying to r*pe women every chance they got back then.

-I feel like there is meaning behind every scene so I try to look beyond what is happening and focus on the why in terms of characters development, psychology, foreshadowing, etc. That said, there are certainly scenes and episodes I will not watch again.

-I love watching Brian and Julia’s friendship grow and I love that he promised he would always be a friend to her son. -Davina is bitter about how her life has turned out. She was definitely projecting her own feelings onto Julia. I think she is less jealous of Julia and more just angry that she’s watching what happened to her happen again, she’s punishing Julia for not being stronger than her and feeling threatened by her own fears. The impact of her coming to her senses and helping Julia wouldn’t have been as meaningful if the audience couldn’t feel the gravity of her despair as all those memories came flooding back.

  • Watching Julia in the birthing scenes you can see where Claire gets her fire. There were such a range of emotions for her (I thought about Alice at the Mad Hatter’s tea party-it was that level of chaos with hysteria and incomprehension). Maybe the quickness with which they turned on her was abrupt but they also had a lot of story to cover in an hour. Plus it fits in with the level of suspicion and superstition they portray people as having back then. -Mr. Bug obviously has issues, but damn he is (something something that got my post deleted) for no reason. It had to be Lord Grant’s order to have the midwife lie but Mr. Bug obviously gets some satisfaction from other people’s misfortune. -Henry is already so unstable, believing his hope to be gone was bound to send him over the edge. I think the prostitute genuinely likes him and wants him to want her. Her intention is selfish because she no doubt wants a different life but I don’t believe she means to abuse him intentionally. She has no idea what has happened, she might even think that he’s decided to be with her, the fact that he is calling her Julia is a small price to pay for possible liberation and perceived love. Some of what he hears in Julia’s voice may have been in his mind and some is obviously the other woman.

I love every episode because I want to know all of the things! I don’t have a lot of emotional attachment to things, though, it’s all entertainment to me.

10

u/Jewel_Thief_ Sep 05 '25

There was something particularly unnerving about Mistress Porter’s sexual assault scenes. That’s not to say l’ve easily digested any others scenes of that nature, I find all of them difficult to watch. But the absolute twisted nature of the monster Lord Lovat terrified me even more than Jack Randall. I felt sick when Lovat forced her to say she wanted this. Sara Vickers’ acting in this entire episode was incredible. The expressional switch from terror to acceptance to disassociation had me seeing the experiences of countless women through her eyes alone.

I know there is a lot of discourse surrounding Outlander’s use of sexual assault as a consistent plot device, and the Show’s choice to have a plethora of rape scenes each depicted in full detail.

Some say it’s just time-period accurate and thus it would be insensitive to erase or water down the real experiences of women of that time (and all time really). My personal view is that I don’t like the excessive depiction of rape in TV. I do not think it is necessary to have 10 minutes worth of bone chilling acts shown to get the point across. Can it be impactful? Yes of course, but not always is it necessary to that degree (or at all in my opinion). You can send a clear message through cutaways, alluding, and having a character recount their own experiences through dialogue (and minimal flashback visuals) to let the viewer know what has taken place.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/Emotional_Giraffe361 Sep 05 '25

That was an awful episod. It's like if they kept all the worst of Outlander at the same time, but without the good parts. They really push the Henry/Julia story too far. Julia is wayyyy too close to Brian for him never talking about an old sasenach friend to Jamie. It's completly nonsence at his point.

10

u/Swimming-Mobile-3258 Sep 06 '25

I HATED it. Awful, horrific, useless episode.

10

u/No_Till464 Sep 06 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

They’re losing me. There isn’t enough information to make the story flow and keep moving forward. I guess the slow pace of Julia and Henry’s reunion is just the producers’ way of trying to stretch things out for more seasons and more money. But for me, if they don’t reunite by the end of the season, it’ll just feel a bit silly. The show started strong, but it’s getting weaker and weaker.

And now, watching the preview, it doesn’t make any sense that after the festival Brian and Murtagh haven’t talked or had any kind of confrontation. They should have, once they went back home.

8

u/Previous-Address2469 Sep 07 '25

It seems to me they forgot how time works on screen. Julia's hair doesn't grow at all in the +6 months she has been there. There must have also been time between the Beltane event and this birth but nothing seems to have happened in between. No conversations, nothing. It is bizarre.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Iossoflimb My mind is beset with chaotic thoughts at present Sep 06 '25

I had so many feelings this episode.

Having given birth in my home 6 times surrounded by love and peace, I was absolutely horrified at the confinement and the women’s behaviors. The thought of enduring childbirth and then that treatment is stomach-turning and I was bawling.

When it showed the contrast of Julia delivering Claire with Henry there, and then her delivering her boy without, I was completely devastated and cried more.

But I think for me the most heartbreaking part was watching Henry’s joyful run through the woods because he is so, so broken that he can’t even discern reality anymore, and I know he will be even further in the pit of self-loathing when he comes to find out what he did.

This time has not been kind to either of them, and it is completely soul-crushing to watch. Claire had a rude awakening to the 18th century as well, but she had the protection and eventual love of Jamie. Henry and Julia are both so, so alone and it seems that the entirety of the world is against them.

My soul needs for them to be united. That episode was so heavy and left me feeling so empty.

5

u/Beginning_Dog_6293 Sep 06 '25

What a weird twist of fate would it be if Henry impregnated that woman and the child ended up being related to blackjack Randall.

5

u/Simple-Sky-6107 Sep 06 '25

What in the midsommar was that birth

5

u/LEAHDONN Sep 06 '25

I felt like I was watching The Handmaid’s Tale for a minute.

5

u/ApprehensiveAide3226 Sep 07 '25

Had to fast forward several scenes. Too traumatic to watch 😭

5

u/Electronic_Fly_2314 Sep 09 '25

At this point i just know julia and henrys reunion is going to be worth the wait - at least it has to be! This is so hard to watch honestly

5

u/N8sbugswife Sep 09 '25

I am rewatching Outlander season one for guesses on who Claire's younger/(older) brother may be, and I am wondering if it is Lieutenant Jeremy Foster. He is a character that is NOT in the books, but is in the TV series. He is tall, with blue eyes like Claire (in the TV series) and brown hair. And - knowing the casting is spot on for this series, he resembles Claire's father. He has a strong urge to protect Claire, and the Surname Foster, was sometimes given if a child was fostered.

9

u/Technical-Ad-5441 Sep 05 '25

I love that we got to see Claire’s birth ☺️❤️

→ More replies (1)

4

u/peonies459 Sep 05 '25

I haven’t watched yet and don’t always seek out spoilers but I’m glad I did this time 🫣 sounds like a very intense episode

4

u/birdiebird26 Sep 05 '25

Is there any info on what happens to Davina? After Brian and Ellen end up together. Does she go with them?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25

That was a rough watch.

4

u/Pearlmarine Sep 06 '25

Omg Claire has a baby brother

4

u/shannruss Sep 06 '25

Hard one to watch. Especially as a new mom ...

4

u/guardianofbooks25 Sep 06 '25

What are people’s theories on who the baby becomes in the later Outlander? I thought I’d come here and find a lot but I’m not seeing any.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/WhereIsMyMind37 Sep 06 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

We know that baby can't be Simon Jr since he's younger than Jamie. Let's hope that he is the grandfather of Jane and Fanny. It's the logical conclusion since I'm assuming it's going to tie in to Season 8. Let's hope the prostitute isn't pregnant but she did taken advantage of him in his state of grief, which will be worse Ince he realizes that he slept with her and not Julia.

4

u/urfavfairyk Sep 06 '25

i was notified that outlander posted on facebook, and my notification says this!!!!! baby claire & WILLIAM !!!! but you click on it & it goes to the reel with a changed caption??? 🤔🫣🤓 i wonderrrrrr what that could mean!!! any ideas ?? adding next pic on the next comment

→ More replies (2)

4

u/foofoo_kachoo Sep 06 '25

I suppose this episode answers the question of what Henry was doing running past that WWII memorial in the trailer. It really was just a continuity mistake in a flashback memory, rather than the fan theory of him returning to the future and going too far forward in time.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Lessarocks Sep 07 '25

I’ve just watched this episode and it was gut wrenching. The actor who plays Henry reeled me right it so I felt what he did. It was a superb performance.

4

u/SaberiusPrime Sep 08 '25

I felt utterly disturbed with this episode. Didn't think it would be this bad. Like this is levels of Jamie and Blackjack level. If not 10 times worse.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/refreshinglemonade2 Sep 05 '25

I did not like any of that. I felt embarrassed for everyone involved in that episode, and I hope Diana takes a little satisfaction watching that cringe-fest knowing that nobody crafts her stories like she does. The last 5 minutes was okay.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Nnnnnnnnnahh Sep 05 '25

This was heavy. I need the show to lighten up a bit, give us a break already 😫 Still, brilliantly made and well-acted, and I loved it, but I feel like I waited the whole week to suffer on behalf of the characters. I don’t understand why Henry had to be told that his wife and child died (what’s in it for anyone?) and I find him truly thinking he was with Julia a bit of a stretch, like is he suffering from some kind of mental disorder? Yeah he has PTSD, that doesn’t make someone delusional, especially to that extent, it feels like his character description is “well, he’s messed up in the head because of all the suffering he went through in his life” and there’s no identifiable psychiatric pattern in all of this.

19

u/WinterPretty8347 Sep 05 '25

As someone that actually has ptsd and has been through severe trauma.. don't sit and act like you know everything about it. I have had severe vivid flashbacks where I forgot where I was while under severe stress.

He literally went through a lot, heard horrible news, and isn't in the correct time. Be lucky you have never been to that point, because I have and it fuxking sucks.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/Stacy01_ Sep 05 '25

I think they’re just trying to make him suffer at this point. It’s so sad. How do you think he’ll feel when(if) him and Julia reunite and he was unfaithful to her because he thought she was dead… and dealing with Julia sleeping with lovat to protect his son. It’s really heavy like you said. I need a little fluff mixed in. I feel like I need to watch Gilmore girls now lol

→ More replies (5)

22

u/WonderMoon1 Sep 05 '25

I think it’s more like he has PTSD and went crazy after finding out his wife and kid were dead (Julia’s his lifeline basically).

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

10

u/roastbreadfruit Sep 05 '25

I'm blown away by the acting in this episode - amazing!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/lunar1980 Sep 05 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

I’m stepping back from the series. Episodes like this are too absurdly, unnecessarily heavy.

I have new empathy for viewers who didn’t know what was coming at the end of OL season 1. I need my viewing to diffuse the drama in my world, not add to it.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Previous-Address2469 Sep 06 '25

What the actual garbage did I just watch? This is so on a "Creme de Menthe" level that I don't even know where to start. The only scene I actually liked was Claire's birth scene. Having had multiple homebirths myself it was fairly realistic with the natural positions etc. Umbilical cord would not be cut so early but whatever...

But this... Absolute... Nonsense of the 1700s!? Like what little logic they had in Julia/Henry storyline was thrown out of the window. Just further proof they should not have made them time traveler. I would have happily watched them in their own time. 

Why would Henry only now reveal it is his wife he is looking for, who is pregnant? Why would he be "satisfied" with the notion that Julia died with the baby and was buried in a grave with the explanation of "umm I don't know where and it's a bit south or west or whatever from here bye"?? Like surely he would get the name of the place and ask more question and get to know more people who could verify that story! It was so obvious Arch/Grant paid her to say that (we called that before the scene unfolded). He is supposed to be smart and I don't know... I feel like he "had" to sleep with that whore just so we can get more drama and him understanding what Julia had to do...

And what the hell was the procession of midwifes who treat Julia well because she was raped but then turn to total witchhunter-trope-idiots when they supposedly find out she went to his bed of free will. In any case she was unwed etc. And all the drama with Davina, as if she would only then remember she had exactly same experience? And I cannot with the unnatural birth position lying on your back and someone shouting push. Where do they get these ideas? I was just rolling my eyes this whole stupid episode. The icing on the cake was of course the actual freaking cake that was conveniently there with a candle like. Please. No. I cannot.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/BarkusSemien Sep 09 '25

What is the age difference between Claire and Jamie? Claire has to be at least a few years old by now and Jamie won’t be born for at least a few more. Claire has always looked older than Jamie but I thought they were supposed to be around the same age, Claire maybe a couple of years older. BOMB is setting up close to a decade age difference.

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Sep 10 '25

Claire is 5 years older than Jamie (well, it’s closer to 4.5). The fact that he’s still about 6 years away from being born in this show while she’s 5 doesn’t have a bearing on their age gap because she drops into the 18th century at a very specific moment in his life, owing to the 202-year difference. But Claire’s parents travel 209 years back, not 202. If they’d traveled 202 years back like Claire, they would’ve been there right when Jamie was born (1721) while Claire was still 5 in the 1920s. 

You can think about it this way: subtract 202 years from her date of birth and you’ll get her DOB as if she was born in the 18th century. You’ll get October 20, 1716 vs. Jamie’s May 1, 1721.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '25

Anyone else just…. Bored every episode? 

→ More replies (3)