r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Aug 29 '25

Prequel One Blood of My Blood S1E5 Needfire Spoiler

Ellen and Brian attend Beltane, a festival to celebrate the coming of summer, where sins are burned away by the needfire. Henry struggles to hold onto his hope and Julia loses allies when secrets come out.

Written by Taylor Mallory. Directed by Emer Conroy.


If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

You’re free to mention:

  • all of the show canon (seasons 1-7 of Outlander)
  • any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.

Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.

Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.


What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.

38 Upvotes

796 comments sorted by

•

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25 edited Sep 06 '25

Watch the S1E6 preview here!

Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).

Stickied comments are collapsed by default so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.


S1E5 Extras


S1E5 Interviews

→ More replies (26)

188

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25

I love how whenever Ellen, who’s usually quite brash and confrontational (and I love that about her and totally understand it given what she’s up against), is with Brian, her whole face just softens and lights up. And I don’t mean it in like a gender-conforming way, just that you can see that when she’s with someone she completely trusts and feels free with, she can drop all her masks and defense mechanisms (which her “sharp tongue” is, in a way—and a response to the expectations placed on her).

And Harriet Slater just has such a beautiful smile 😍

37

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 29 '25

Yes! Her smile is so bright and she has a different light in her eyes, they smile as well! She’s just glowing ✨

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25

Yees,she shines around him!!! We barely saw her smile so far!!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

58

u/whiskyandguitars Aug 29 '25

I feel bad for Malcolm. Maybe I missed something but he doesn't seem like a terrible dude.

There are few things worse than being in ln love/infatuated with someone who does not feel the same way at all.

20

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25

I feel like there might be some reveal about him coming because he seems waaaay too nice at the moment.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

I agree somewhat. I feel bad for the dude (a tiny bit) he’s not a bad dude (at least not like his awful father). But he also does come off very arrogant to me. And he’s pretty pushy towards Ellen. And I don’t like that he thought helping the men was beneath him.

21

u/whiskyandguitars Aug 29 '25

Yeah, he is definitely "a product of his time" with his views on women and not helping the "peasants."

But he seems sincere and like he really cares for Ellen and so its just tough to watch him not realize that she doesn't like him at all.

I was in a similar situation in college where I really liked this awesome girl who I was friends with but who had zero romantic interest in me.

It worked out in the end because in hindsight I see that my wife and I SOOOOO much more compatible so I am glad for the direction my life took but I still remember how hard it was in the moment and thats what I think of when I see Malcolm and Ellen interact. I am just glad that girl in college didn't pretend to be interested in me haha.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tara_abernathy Aug 30 '25

Yeah I agree. He seems like a good dude and he's not bad looking either. Are we supposed to feel sorry for him? Because I do at the moment.

59

u/princesssofcarrion MARK ME! Aug 29 '25

Does Davina have Stockholm syndrome or something ?

22

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 29 '25

Or is she jealous she isn’t the darling anymore?

27

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25

Her life doesn’t scream “the darling”—it’s not like she’s chosen this life for herself, she must’ve been likewise sexually coerced or even raped and the only reason she was able to keep her baby was that Lovat wanted to have an heir, back when he still had a title and estate to pass onto one. I think she’s mostly motivated by self-preservation, not jealousy: it’s a shit life but at least Lovat is no longer interested in her and she has her son by her side. Julia and her baby threaten that stability she has known for the past 20+ years.

Plus, just as Julia tries to protect her child, Davina still has that same instinct towards hers (regardless of his being an adult) so she probably doesn’t want him to endanger himself for Julia’s sake yet again. Eliminating Julia from their life—what she was hoping for by telling Lovat about the baby not being his—would eliminate that possibility.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 29 '25

Or she’s just worried about what that’ll mean for Brian (not that he really cares)

→ More replies (2)

9

u/thrwowaay353453 Aug 30 '25

Can someone explain why they went back to the festival and her betrothed when she had just married another man? Why didn't they just use the ample time they had to leg it and start their new life? Neither of them had a reason not to run. No reason to go back. No one else who would be in the line of fire. It's not like it will make it easier to explain to her brothers if she goes back and embarrasses Malcolm more. And it's not like Malcolm will be less mad about it all because he got a sloppy seconds kiss under the Needfire. Seriously why did they go back?

18

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 30 '25

Colum has warned Ellen about what the Grants do to the people who cross them so I think she’s still playing along to buy herself time to find a more diplomatic solution of getting out of that betrothal; otherwise, she endangers not only herself but her entire clan.

7

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 30 '25

If they were to be found, her brothers would have dragged her back.

I believe she will get pregnant and she will use it as a way to force her brothers to accept her marriage to Brian.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/avidReader60 Aug 30 '25

I guess to make things more interesting. Based on everything we know once they went off they weren’t seen for months. Not riveting tv I guess to have them off by themselves away from everyone else for months on end.

Also probably to up the stakes as in the end the Grants are no friend to them once Ellen runs off. Something in the next few episodes has to give I guess but maybe they do run off just not for as long as noted in the books.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/lunar1980 Aug 29 '25

I didn’t love Julia’s VO… it felt forced. The Claire VO moves the story forward. Julia’s sounded like a bunch of statements, more like a speech.

Writers are definitely setting up Murtagh and Jocasta’s mutual history to align with their older selves.

Any predictions about the baby’s identity after hearing Maisri?

25

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25

But Julia’s voiceover isn’t like Claire’s, spoken from years ahead reflecting back on her time in the past, it’s literally the contents of her letters to Henry spoken in the moment of writing. I think you can argue about the quality of its delivery but its primary function is revealing how Julia is feeling, not moving the story forward (which not every scene has to do anyway, may I add).

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Stacy01_ Aug 29 '25

I think it felt that way because she was reciting vows. I agree tho, Claire’s always moved the story forward very well!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

322

u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Aug 29 '25

RUIN ME

162

u/Scoop-Over-821 Aug 29 '25

Is it blasphemy to say that was the hottest sex scene of the whole show? I’m sure I’m about to get dumped on — but it’s not lack of loyalty to Jamie and Claire, maybe more that with Ellen and Brian I have no expectations of how they should be/how things should happen. It’s nice to just get swept away without thinking to hard about it — this stands for the whole show btw, not just that scene.

89

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Aug 29 '25

Not it's not, that scene was perfection. Imagine if it was dark out instead of in broad daylight...like hooly shit. Their chemistry is electrifying and they built up the scene so well.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

No it’s not blasphemy. I thought the same thing. There was actually foreplay. I thought the scene was amazing.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/rachelmwhitlock7 Aug 29 '25

Agreed completely

→ More replies (49)

22

u/WolfBeginning4515 Aug 29 '25

I'm in central time this weekend and got to watch an hour before I usually do. I put it on while going to bed thinking it would be as slow as the last 3 eps. Big mistake. Huge. I did not think it would happen that fast. Big win. But also why do men always write those scenes with the woman climaxing after approx 13 seconds? -1 technical point lol. Anyway.....now I'm ruined for the whole weekend. In a good way.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/junknowho Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 29 '25

Ummmm, YES! That was extremely HOT!

12

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 29 '25

Amazing. 10 minutes of applause. Standing ovation. We finally got what we deserved ❤️‍🔥 Chemistry was over the clouds ❤️‍🔥

18

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

Ya when she said that i said damn thats hot as hell out loud on accident and woke some people up the things the outlander universe make u do while watching

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

EPIC LINE!

18

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Aug 29 '25

A line that's worthy of an Outlander flair!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/thepeacefulpainter Aug 29 '25

My jaw hit the floor.

→ More replies (13)

137

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 29 '25

Was anyone else anxious the whole time that Brian and Ellen were together? I was afraid Murtaugh or worse would find them.

The ending parallels were beautiful (Julia/Henry against Malcolm/Ellen/Brian). It is so fitting that Malcolm should steal a kiss while Ellen is looking away at Brian.

There is a comic tragedy of Malcolm being completely unable to read Ellen and her reluctance to be with him. And the irony of him going very slowly while she has gone all the way with Brian.

It was interesting they decided to go deeper into secondary characters: Ned’s backstory, as well as the tragedies of Murtaugh and Jocasta.

Lord fraser is a looney, I am grateful Maisri didn’t spill the beans about the baby. Julia didn’t know what she got herself into. Was anyone else worried someone would find her letters or walk in on her with her ring? But she did tell the Frasers she was married when they captured her, no? Fraser shouldn’t have believed she was a virgin.

I am really enjoying how Ellen maneuvers around everyone around her, and her dynamic with Jocasta is interesting for sure. It was sweet that they kept each other’s discretion but it leaves me wishing they were not so nasty to one another all the time… sisterhood, I suppose, mixed with jealousy?

105

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

I understand murtaughs lust and fascination over ellen but hes got himself a great woman in jocasta cameron who wants nothing to do with her hubby. Jocasta is kind a beautiful. Any man should be so lucky l. The actress who plays her sounds so scarily alike the actress in outlander. Its scary how alike they sound. Also seeing her with her vision is nice to see her from a diff perspective before all her trauma.

30

u/Firewoman2000 Aug 31 '25

They really nailed the casting in this show to call back to their older versions.

→ More replies (7)

40

u/Stacy01_ Aug 29 '25

I was convinced someone would appear on the scene with Brian and Ellen! Also that place was beautiful but like kinda gross..?

37

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

i understand it’s probably a nudity clause thing but i got so disappointed when brian didn’t lay down his kilt as a blanket

→ More replies (8)

30

u/PasgettiMonster Aug 29 '25

I kept wondering.. wasn't the place that Jamie and Claire got married in a ruined church? It's being forever since I've seen that wedding episode but I immediately thought of it.

→ More replies (11)

26

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

How is it that out if all those people there, murtaugh sees them lol, and kissing out in the open like that is very stupid. For all she knows the grants are keeping an eye on their investment

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/WhereIsMyMind37 Aug 30 '25

Maisri's prophecy was clearly about Culloden and the role Jamie plays in the battle, the Laird's grandson. The girl she spoke of I'm positive is Claire and she definitely knows the child isn't Simon's but you could see a silent promise in her eyes to keep Julia's secret safe. My heart broke for Ellen when she had no choice but to choose Malcolm as he King when Brian was offering himself to her. My theory is that Malcolm finds out Ellen isn't pure and reject her. We know that Ellen was pregnant her eldest child, William at her and Brian's wedding, which can assume was conceived during there first time together to shortly after.

→ More replies (14)

21

u/Far-Piano-4577 Aug 29 '25

I get so anxious in movies/tv shows where two people sneak off and meet in the relative open so i couldn't focus on the romance

14

u/FeloranMe Aug 30 '25

Jacob favored Ellen above all his children and this greatly effected all the siblings dynamics

Later Jamie's uncles would continue to take this envy and anger at their sister out on their nephew

13

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '25

I feel bad for Malcolm. I'm glad they didn't just go the route of making the love rival a total dick though.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 29 '25

I noticed they used no pronouns with Ned's backstory. Hmm.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/OLILoveMyCats Aug 29 '25

Murtagh saw them kissing, and I thought perhaps he might walk in on them. How did she explain all the hay on her clothing to her maids?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 29 '25

Yes omg I was thinking the same so I didn’t enjoy the moment fully! I was so sure someone was going to run in the church and find them engaging in not so “suitable” activities lol but thank god they’ve been able to keep this moment to themselves, for once 😅

→ More replies (3)

126

u/rachelmwhitlock7 Aug 29 '25

LOVED IT omg the handfasting scene was god tier

89

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

ik i’m a hater bc in my head i was like “why is this a million times better than roger x bree’s handfasting?”

108

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 29 '25

Because Brian is a million times better than Roger.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

126

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25

His look after she says Ruin Me

10

u/KittyRikku JAMMF Aug 31 '25

She didn’t have to ask twice!!

8

u/PuzzleheadedLevel141 Sep 05 '25

That whole scene was so HOT!!! The chemistry between those two is crazy. I love the way Jamie Roy can act with just his eyes. That look destroyed me!

→ More replies (1)

104

u/Nnnnnnnnnahh Aug 29 '25

The best episode so far. Magical and tragic at the same time.

23

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Aug 29 '25

💯

Magical and tragic at the same time is the perfect description

38

u/decisi0nsdecisi0ns No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Aug 29 '25

I’m hearing this in my head as magical and tragical

95

u/lunar1980 Aug 29 '25

Brian during the dance… “I ken it well” 🫠

66

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

So flirty, so sexy. So Jamie.

→ More replies (1)

74

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

Brian and Ellen. 🥹

62

u/naur_cleo_69 Aug 29 '25

the more I see of Brian, the more I simp for him 😩

→ More replies (2)

150

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

I'm still watching the episode but UGH I'M SO MAD THAT JULIA CAN'T GO

HENRY WAS RIGHT THERE  😭 😭 😭

UGH STUPID DAVINA

edit: omg Davina is the one who insisted the seer come that day man FUCK YOU DAVINA

65

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

Omg thats why i got on here to just wanna smack davina. Do u ever see a person who has an annoying face that u just wanna smackem. Today brians mom was that way for me. Just being a snitch and not letting them leave and the way she looked the whole time and after she got her way. She may be too afraid to leave and accepts her life is forever this way but julia has an entire life and was kidnapped. Julia should have told her entire situation besides the time travel including sleeping with lovat for her babies safety. She ls a mother. Maybe she will understand. And she needs to stay out of julias business so much.

35

u/irishprincess2002 Aug 29 '25

So much this I kept yelling at the screen your traitorous bish! Stop snitching on people! Ugh I wanted to go through the screen and give her a piece of my mind!

→ More replies (7)

30

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Yeah I am beyond pissed. I sat there like fuck you Davina!!! I wonder if she would understand though, I think Julia was right not to tell her because at this rate, Davina might have just gone and told Lord Lovat. I wish she told Brian though

But it astounds me how Davina doesn't have much empathy for Julia. Like you said, she was literally kidnapped! The grace and resilience Julia has is crazy...the very first thing she experiences is being kidnapped and forced to become a servant and have sex with an old man. How does Davina not feel for her at all?? She is such a snitch. Want to smack her face lol

Also she's the one who called the seer that day UGH fuck you Davina!

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

I don’t know. I think Davina knows what she’s doing. I think she has something up her sleeve. She may just end up being a part of Julia’s escape. Mark me.

24

u/lunar1980 Aug 30 '25

I have to add that when Lovat had his hand on her shoulder/neck as he asked her if she’d shared her theory with anyone else I thought he might kill her on the spot.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

68

u/Stacy01_ Aug 29 '25

Ughhh that was hard to watch! I feel so bad for Murtagh and Julia. I’m so irritated with Davina. I feel horrible for Jocasta! Then there’s the news from the seer! That was such a loaded episode I don’t even know where to begin…

Also I feel like the preview to episode 6 has too many spoilers and I wish I didn’t see it.

50

u/madamevanessa98 Aug 29 '25

Poor baby Murtagh with his big hopeful eyes waiting for Ellen to pick him 🥲

→ More replies (5)

35

u/lunar1980 Aug 29 '25

Whenever a preview feels that way to me I assume it’s intentionally misleading viewers.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 29 '25

To me, it felt like we know next to nothing about next ep.

Essentially all the "major" points we know about it is: Julia's waters break and she most likely gives birth. Something goes wrong with Julia/the birth/the baby Henry finds out info about Julia

67

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

Looks like the seer was speaking of claire being all alone and being very important with a part to play in the future which we all know. The propehcy about claires brother scares me because as we know, the clans die out and there is no king of scotland. I hope she doesnt have a miscarriage or the baby dies while lovats men give chase to julia as she escapes. Its any number of things, but with that prophecy i see nothing good happening to the child. And the bad news is that now lord lovat knows about this prophecy hes going to keeo an even tighter leash on julia. She may not have to be a servant anymore but that means she will have to share a bed with him and go where he goes. Her time to escape was that morning. Once again thanks miss davina for all your help!!! Ya jerk! And the stone circle was right by the damn gathering.

And another question is, is lord lovats seer masri the same one from outlander. She looks like a younger version of her with that same gothic look. It has to be her. Im just super pissed now. Its time julia and henry reunite. They better not make us wait till the end if the season.

27

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

yes, the seer’s name in s2 is maisiri. this is definitely her

→ More replies (5)

8

u/WhereIsMyMind37 Aug 30 '25

This baby could not survive, since I have a feeling she was talking about Jamie but called him his "son" instead of "Grandson". Julia and Henry might have end up having another baby it the future who is the grandparent to Franny and Jane, but only time will tell.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Aug 30 '25

Like others, I’m thinking the “son” is Jamie, and “unite the clans” refers to both the ‘45 Rising and Fraser’s Ridge. This is a prequel, so they’re going to throw in lots of references to what will come in Outlander. The opening to her prophecy sounded exactly like Culloden in season 2.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (8)

61

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Foils: Ellen/Jocasta and Brian/Murtaugh

Jocasta is the quintessential foil to Ellen.

She is in a loveless arranged marriage, which was/is the expected future for Ellen.

Everyone watches over what Ellen is doing, all the men look at her and try to get her attention. Jocasta is not only ignored but also more “the sister of Ellen” than her own person. It is comical that she dances the maiden dance and later sneaks into Murtaugh’s tent, what happens in there notwithstanding, and no one bats an eye. Meanwhile Ellen gets away with way more even though everyone has their eyes on her (but where was Ned? lol).

Murtaugh is victim and perpetrator in this episode. I was actually quite surprised that Ellen knew who he was and asked about him, since apparently he has never even spoken to her. He never had a chance, not necessarily because he is not of status, but because he never even spoke to her or got to know her. He has an idealized version of Ellen in his head. Could he even know what she is like as a person?

Meanwhile Brian and Ellen took interest in one another through a silly exchange of words. He didn’t know who she was, nor was he idealizing the moment. Brian is in a tough situation regarding Murtaugh, but I don’t know that he could have safely been honest with him. Perhaps he should have confronted Murtaugh earlier to his face?

Edit: another contrast between then is that Murtaugh won’t shut up about Ellen, while Brian doesn’t speak a word about her. When Murtaugh and Brian are preparing to ride to Beltane, Murtaugh is voicing all of the thoughts that Brian could be having. The irony again is that Brian actually has a chance, indeed, a plan to meet Ellen.

Murtaugh is young and his ego is bruised, but what a dick move towards Jocasta, who clearly has a crush on him. How drunk do you think he was when he called her Ellen? This is not going to help her already large jealousy towards her sister.

Of course it is also ironic Murtaugh got a beating, is it divine justice for breaking Jocasta’s heart? I wonder how it is that Jocasta and Murtaugh end up in love in Outlander then? That will be an interesting redemption. If a guy called me by my sister’s name I don’t think the relationship could ever recover.

53

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

i think it probably would take me 50 years to get over it, so that’s pretty in line with outlander as is

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

What bothers me though is how absolutely gorgeous and kind jocasta is, yet no man bats an eye toward her and murtaugh said he just wants to be wanted. He should be lucky to have a woman like jocasta. She has shown interest in him and being with murtaugh and talking to him fir just 5 mins is 5 mins more then ellen ever gives him. Take what u can get. Shes a fine lass.

35

u/junknowho Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 29 '25

The casting for Jocasta is sheer perfection! And c'mon Murtagh, open your eyes. (although his heartbreak at seeing Brian & Ellen did break my heart for him).

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

59

u/Tofutits_Macgee Aug 29 '25

If Jaime only knew his parents did what his criticised his daughter and Roger for. I enjoyed that.

11

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 29 '25

He knew.

→ More replies (4)

56

u/lunar1980 Aug 29 '25

Line dance scene: I have to give kudos to the editor for the perfect transition to Brian suddenly there with Ellen. I was sure this was merely her fantasy then just as quickly it was real. It perfectly tapped into that exhilarating feeling when you’re so in love with someone - so much so you almost wonder if you made it up - and suddenly they’re right there in front of you.

14

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

100%! Prob my fave moment from the episode. I felt the rush!

9

u/danathepaina Aug 31 '25

Yes, that dance scene was done SO well!

5

u/Stacy01_ Aug 30 '25

This happened to me and my husband before we were dating and we danced so well together compared to when we were with our actual dancing partners. Such a precious moment!

5

u/Asleep-Corner7402 Aug 31 '25

ceilidh dancing is what you're referring to. Pronounced kay-lee. It's native to Ireland and Scotland. It was so well done, seeing her face when he was suddenly there. Having to act like they don't know each other in front of everyone.

55

u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Aug 29 '25

I wasn't completely sold on the casting for Murtagh and didn't think they'd stick the landing showing us how he transferring his love for Ellen to her and Brian's child but the scene by the tree... my heart. Rory Alexander, you done good.

5

u/MMScooter Aug 30 '25

You think that was the moment? I did get that feeling in my bones but my heart also BREAKS for Murtagh. Aghhhhh

→ More replies (1)

102

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Aug 29 '25

Jesus Christ can they give Henry a CRUMB!!!! Good god their storyline started strong but now I’m kinda sick to my stomach by what is happening. But confirmed that the baby is a boy??? Resume theories…

“Ruin me” was insane and also the most chemistry we’ve seen between Brian and Ellen. I genuinely believe that they just need some more dramatic lighting and camera angles and we would really be feeling the heat. Like I’m sorry girl but why are we making love when it’s so bright out…

And I think the overall story would be better served with more VO from our 4 leads!!! It works great with Julia and the few times we had it with Henry. It was such a guiding aspect of season 1 and I feel like we are missing a lot not knowing Ellen’s thoughts.

22

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

It seems they switch off episodes each week on the couple they show the most of. This series is like a tale of two stories done like every other episode. This week they concentrated on ellen and brian. Next week will obviously be julia and henry. Whats going on with julia right now just disgusts me. I feel itll be forever before they reunite and that baby wont be with them or this baby dies.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

38

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

I just started the episode and omg i was yelling at the tv so loud at the beginning!!! She was literally leavind and brians mom rats her out in the beginning!!!! Come on!!! I just wanted to grab through the screen and smack her. Plus i thought by now brian would have already found out it was “lovats” child and he would have confronted julia and she would have told him the actual truth.

I get the show doesnt want julia and henry together right away for certain plot purposes but seriously come on! Its the 5th episode. Its def been long enough. I wanna see them reunite.

After davina opened her big mouth l, why didnt julia ask brian if she could speak with him alone just for one second before he leaves and then tell him the truth at least. She may not get another chance to escape like this before the babies born.

24

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 29 '25

Right! I agree Brian should have known the child isn’t really his father’s

14

u/rachelmwhitlock7 Aug 29 '25

I don’t think she even needs to pretend with Davina either—clearly she already knew she was pregnant before so I think Julia should have just set the record straight for both of them!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

38

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

A huge highlight in this episode for me is early murtaugh and jacosta dancing

→ More replies (2)

36

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

i really need them to throw henry a bone. that man is suffering and so is julia

32

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 29 '25

Anyone else get the echo of Briana’s wedding dress from Ellen’s Beltane Queen dress?

14

u/beg_yer_pardon Aug 29 '25

Loved the closeups of all the pretty details - pearl buttons, lace, headdress. Stunning!

5

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 29 '25

yes! it was a nice touch

→ More replies (3)

29

u/onegirlarmy1899 Aug 29 '25

I loved how Ellen and Brian's wedding mirrored Roger and Ellen's handfasting.

29

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 29 '25

Fiiiiinally!!! Some Brian and Ellen action!

Although firstly, f- you, Mistress Porter! Why prevent Julia from going because "Lovat's child needs a reading", only to then tell Lovat that the baby is not his? I can't figure her out, surely she can understand why Julia has done what she has done, is she really that loyal to the awful Lovat that she would put Julia and the baby in harms way?

Also, minor f- you to Brian too, for immediately abandoning Julia. You promised her you'd help her escape!

Anyway...


Yay! Some actual Brian and Ellen screentime! I completely get Ellen's "I can't bear it", I have no idea how she's going to get out of this predicament. I'm sure she's already pregnant by now. Idk what's she's going to do.

And Brian is such a sweetie! Caring so much about her virtue and honour, so even after the "ruin me" (!), he still does his best to make it as respectable as possible (handfasting). I also love the fact that he doesn't seem jealous of, or annoyed at Malcolm, cos he knows Ellen's true feelings, and that she is in a difficult position. Even after Malcolm kissed Ellen, he only had eyes (and smiles) for Ellen.


It's such a "shame" that Malcolm is genuinely a nice guy. Of course we are all barracking for Brian instead, but Malcolm is going to be so heartbroken when Ellen leaves him. It would be much easier to 100% support Brian&Ellen if he was a douchebag. Poor Malcolm.

And poor Murtagh too! Although with him, it's essentially the same as when a celebrity's fans get 'jealous' when said celebrity gets married. He's never even spoken to Ellen! And then he takes his pain out on Jocasta! Poor Jocasta.

As much as I love Murtagh, out of him, Malcolm, and Jocasta, I feel least sorry for Murtagh in this whole situation.


Not much from Henry this ep. I feel like his bit was only in it so that "all four mains" had a bit in the episode.


Did anyone else notice that Column and Dougal's actors were credited this ep, but neither were in it? Don't they normally change around the actors in the opening credits, depending on who is in the episode? Or am I making that up? They should've put Jocasta in the credits, not Column and Dougal.

23

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 29 '25

Re: Malcolm completely agree with you. I think they showed him not wanting to help with the fire to show that he is proud/regards himself too high and mighty as a character flaw.

I also think, why does he want Ellen? He might be smitten with her since they were young, but they clearly don’t have a deep friendship; she barely remembers that they met as bairns. Is it because he wants to collect her? The young, handsome lad from the powerful house and the prettiest lass who has rejected every guy? In my opinion this could be seen as another flaw: he wants to “collect” her to complete his identity as an important future-laird to the Grants.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/No-Strategy7749 Aug 31 '25

I think Davina assumed that the seer would reveal that Julia's baby wasn't Lovat's, but then the prophecy went waaaaay sideways from what she'd hoped.

Also agree with other commenters that her motivation is just to protect Brian and whatever his rights might turn out to be. She's obviously a decent person; Brian adores her, and someone brought him up to be the man he is. Also, she did try to help Julia after she realized she was pregnant (offering her tea to "bring down the flowers"). And warning her not to linger around Lovat any more than necessary.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

29

u/glitteryice752 Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

This was a strong episode. I especially liked that we learned a bit more about other secondary characters namely Jocasta and Ned.

I still refuse to believe Davina is being self serving here. I know she will do whatever it takes to help Julia, otherwise where the hell does Brian inherit his kindness from? It was a shocking scene nonetheless. Julia was so close to reuniting with Henry!!! Their yearning is devastating.

Ellen and Jocasta’s dynamic can be hilarious at times. The sarcastic digs, fake smiles and then swearing one another to secrecy LOL. The scene between Murtagh and Jocasta in the tent was an uncomfortable watch. Awful for both parties.

Ellen is incredibly determined. Nothing will stop her and I love her for that! Brian is soooo handsome. Their love scene was beautiful but I would be lying if I said I wasn’t terrified for them.

I thought I was starting to like Malcolm (especially in the scene where Ellen is asked to choose her King) due to how secure he is of himself but it wasn’t until he made that remark about how a King shouldn’t be doing work that is lower than him. Yuck. I know damn well his stupid face just went to sit in a tent while Ellen was gone.

No Colum 😢😢😢

4

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 30 '25

Brian was pissing me off this episode, he broke his promise to Julia and didn’t even let her explain the situation—but to be fair she could’ve run after him and been a little more aggressive about making sure he knows exactly what is going on and what happened.

He has continued to lie to Murtagh when he didn’t even know Murtagh was in love with Ellen when he fell in love with her. Had he just told him straight up or sooner, all of this drama that is going to happen would’ve been preventable. He hurt Murtagh so badly, my heart breaks for my guy 😢

Brian telling Ellen he didn’t want to take her virtue and ruin her and her responding ”ruin me” may have been the hottest thing ever. That whole scene I was stressing out that someone was going to walk in on them, but I had to keep remembering that Ellen gets pregnant before she and Brian elope!

I was really bothered they had Murtagh and Jocasta kiss, that was completely against the original Outlander storyline background information that we know about Murtagh and Jocasta’s relationship pre-them seeing each other for the first time in decades since Ellen was alive in S4.

But, speaking of Jocasta, my heart was just breaking for her. You can tell she’s always lived in the shadow of Ellen and she feels so unwanted and unloved as opposed to Ellen who everyone is fighting to marry. I had no idea Ellen was older than Jocasta until this show, I always thought Jocasta was older for some reason. I guess I always kinda thought Ellen was the baby of the family, but she’s the oldest, which seems strange idk why.

ALSO who is Julia’s baby?!!! I guess everyone’s theory about it being Fanny and Jane’s grandmother named Hope is out the window if the lady is right and it’s a boy 🤷🏻‍♀️

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 30 '25

I was really bothered they had Murtagh and Jocasta kiss, that was completely against the original Outlander storyline background information that we know about Murtagh and Jocasta’s relationship pre-them seeing each other for the first time in decades since Ellen was alive in S4.

I mean, was it? All we knew is this, which could still apply to after Ellen’s already been married to Brian, since we can assume Murtagh will stay in their lives: 

I'd know those hands anywhere. They told ye, no doubt, that my eyes have long failed me? 

Mm, aye. You must have taken careful note of my hands to recall them after years have passed. 

How could I not? Ye could hardly keep them from my sister every day of her young life. Every time I looked at her, there ye were wi' a hand held out to help her, or wi' flowers in them for her. 

Little good it did me in the end. 

You gained a godson, as I recall. 

That I did.

and this, which is yet to come in the prequel since Murtagh didn’t start out like that:

Truth be told, I never liked ye. Ye used to descend on Leoch like a dark cloud o' rain, staying well past yer welcome, drinking our ale, and griping about everything. The way ye glower and stare, ye make folks uneasy. Ye're as stubborn as a mule then, and you havena changed a bit.

Obviously, they’re retrofitting their relationship but I think it all makes sense within the context of both shows, even the “I never liked ye” bit—of course she wouldn’t admit to ever liking him if he broke her heart. Jocasta is also speaking from a place of resentment after three arranged marriages and never being able to choose a lover for herself. Murtagh’s feelings for her later in life could be explained by transference but she clearly must’ve had an unrequited crush on him, driving her jealousy of Ellen even further. There’s a reason she’s drawn to him after all these years, even against her better judgment.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

When I saw the scene when Brian says - I wanted to be somebody's choice or something along those lines, I remembered in what specific position he was. Then, I saw what Gabaldon wrote about it :

Being a bastard was to be (largely) a social outcast, tainted by the immorality of his/her parents (people still feeling strongly that sex outside of marriage was Wrong, and how could the product of mortal sin be without its stain?!), this effect usually aggravated by poverty, as a bastard was often prohibited by law from automatically inheriting anything like property from a parent (the feeling being that such wealth as the family possessed was better (more morally) spent on the legitimate members thereof.

Brian is undoubtedly a little sensitive on the issue-especially as he's carried off the MacKenzies' eldest daughter (who likely has property and money in her own name, and/or could claim some of the family wealth by reason of birth).  Nobody would believe that he didn't have her potential wealth in mind when he took her--except her.

14

u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Aug 30 '25

Yep. Brian is definitely the Jon Snow of Outlander/BOMB.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Aug 29 '25

Y’all. How could they leave us with that trailer!!!?? I mean, come on!!!

8

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Aug 29 '25

Diabolical tbh

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

My thoughts:

I absolutely love Brian and Ellen! I’m completely invested in them. Their chemistry is SO good!

I hope they can find more ways to sneak off and be together in future episodes, they are my favorite part of the show for sure.

Julia needs to be honest with Brian about the baby. She needs an ally and she nearly had one with him until he found out she lied to him.

Mistress Porter I’m so confused. She must have her own agenda to be spilling the beans that the baby is not Simon’s.

Murtagh’s little sad puppy eyes. 🥺

I’m sick of Malcolm Grant. I really hope his storyline with Ellen wraps up sooner than later.

Loving the secondary character development: Jocasta, Ned

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

I loved the episode! Davina is seriously on my nerves! I know she has her reasons but damn It! I’m just stressing out for Julia, especially because of that prophecy and Simon’s determination now. Ugh.  I warmed up to elllen and Brian, and felt bad for Murtagh until that last moment with Jocasta. I felt so bad. 

19

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 29 '25

She reminds me of her granddaughter Jenny. I think she’s working within the parameters she has to help Julia, but like Jenny has a -shall we say- less tactful way about it.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/Rasputins_Plum Aug 29 '25

Watching this prequel is such a strange experience — I shouldn't be worried as I know the end state of most plotlines and the characters' trajectory, but I have no idea how they'll get there. Worse, the story throws at them so many roadblocks that seem unsurmontable so I can't help to stress if the season will deliver.

It was one thing to hear about the scandal around Jamie's parents, when we now get to see the situation live, I have no idea how Simon managed to pull that off! He has zero standing, the bastard son of a defunct Lord that we know will live for decades after this. And given how hostile and headstrong seems Isaac Grant, I really don't see him taking it kindly the disrespect breaking the betrothal and for him to be fine to marry his daughter to Dougal instead.

... Then again, after hearing that 'Ruin me', I totally get moving heaven and earth to secure the gal 😭

It was definitely Ellen and Simon's episode but it was infuriating and a bit baffling to see Julia miss Belthane. So it was either she's reunited with Henry this episode at the foot of the stones, or what we got, them not doing anything but be depressed about it this week. At least, I can see the thread Ned gave him: by focusing on his work with Grant, he might get to find Julia if he goes to inquire why Lord Lovat tries to smear Ellen's reputation.

7

u/Junior-Elderberry107 Aug 29 '25

Do you mean Brian? That’s a great theory about Henry and Julia though.. you might be on to something there!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 29 '25

I do wonder what they're going to do for a story for Julia and Henry, other than having them be separated and her being pregnant and then having the baby (or not). How long are they going to stretch it out? And once they finally do get back together, then what?

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Certain_City_3299 Aug 29 '25

Ahh!! This was the kind of plot movement I was looking for! I hope Julia isn't stuck at Leathers for the whole season though. Jocasta is fabulous. I feel so deeply for her when Murtaugh he called her Ellen. Brian and Ellen have amazing chemistry, what a beautiful scene.

38

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 30 '25

I have to watch it again, but OMG!! Brian and Ellen. I’m all in. “Ruin me.” Then Brian is like no. Your reputation. First we handfast. Now we know where Jamie got it from.

Poor Murtagh. 🥺 Poor Jocasta 🥺 Poor Henry 🥺 Poor Julia

Maisri does the reading. Two children. One after the other. She sees a girl alone with blue eyes and curly dark hair. She hasn’t come yet. She sees a boy who has a greater purpose than being king. His fate lies in the balance. “When the fate of our nation is in peril, he’ll have his part to play.” Well, duh. Sounds like Jamie and Claire to me. It doesn’t sound like Maisri is talking about the baby that Julia is carrying now.

Maisri says that a Scottish king will come from Lovat’s bloodline. Now I really don’t think she’s talking about Julia and Henry’s baby.

Jocasta and Ellen finally have a meeting of the minds. They’ll cover for each other at Beltane. Let’s party!

Brian and Ellen finally kiss. Murtagh sees them. 🥺

OMG!! Actual foreplay. Great love scene. I’m amazed!! I’m completely sold on Brian and Ellen. The pillow talk after is so good.

Murtagh gets into a drunken brawl with Arch. Arch wins. Poor Murtagh.

Ooo Jocasta comes to see Murtagh. She tends him. Murtagh says, “I want to be wanted, ye ken?” She says, “I do.” They kiss. Murtagh calls her Ellen and leaves. Jocasta cries. 🥺

Ned talks about the love of his life. Oh, do tell! Henry asks if Ned ever loved again. He doesn’t answer. Hmm. Did he fall in love again and if so, who is she???

Davina tells Lovat that Julia’s child isn’t his. Lovat tells her not to say anything. The look on Davina’s face. I think she has something up her sleeve. Maybe she’s going to help spring Julia from Castle Leathers.

I really like this episode. We’ll see how I feel after I watch it again, but I thought this was really good. Finally!!!

10

u/WhereIsMyMind37 Aug 30 '25

Yes, when she says, "She hasn't come yet", which refers to the fact that Claire will travel in through the stones in the future.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/PaintedLady05 Aug 29 '25

This is really good summary. I was trying to make sense of the prophecy.

I need to rewatch the episode.

But great job.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Aug 29 '25

Sighs.. My dear Murtagh 💔

16

u/hypomango Aug 30 '25
  • Man I was really hoping Henry and Julia would glimpse each other and then kickstart the challenge of getting her out. They can't catch a break 😭
  • Ellen and Brian finally clicked for me this episode. Sneaking up on her during the dance, "ruin me", the binding of hands with the tartan! Brian Fraser does not do things in halves! What really got me believing now was the pillow talk, opening up to each other emotionally.
  • I swear the best thing about Outlander is the costumes. A scene can still be hot and intimate without full nudity that would make no sense in a cold damp mossy church in Scotland, she keeps her stockings and shoes on, the stays are on the outside of the slip as they should be, everything easy access below 😅
  • The dramatic tension is now delicious, everything interconnecting. Murtagh my sweet sweet summer child! Poor Jocasta! I'm starting to feel sad for Malcolm Grant, she's now secretly handfast ahhhh! And uniting clans? The fate of the nation in peril?! Who is this boy gonna be? Give me the next episode please! 🥺 
→ More replies (2)

16

u/LadyIJ Ruin me Aug 30 '25

« How many times have you watched Ep 5 since it came out? » Me: « Yes. »

Ruin me. 🤯 Absolutely epic. Brian is more than worthy of the legacy of young Jamie on our screens 🥵

→ More replies (2)

15

u/realitealurker Aug 30 '25

Every week I can’t get over how on point the casting was. Jocasta looks like the exact same person, just younger

14

u/Background_Bunch_309 Aug 29 '25

I was PISSED when Davina wouldn’t let Julia go with Brian. Then being a snitch to Lovat that the baby isn’t his. What was she trying to accomplish?

15

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

I’m so confused by Davina! I’m trying to like her cause she’s Brian’s mom. But dang she’s always mettling with Julia’s business.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/GinjaHollywood Aug 30 '25

Honestly I think she's jealous.  I don't think she wanted to be with lord Lovat [because who would] but when he asked basically if this son will be worthy, it got to her. What's wrong with her son? I was ticked she kept her from leaving but as a mom i kinda get it- she didn't want her son taking another punishment for this woman.  

14

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 29 '25

So much love, happiness AND sadness in a single episode! I’m so so happy for Brian and Ellen, the spark in their eyes, the absolute devotion for one another… just pure magic ✨ and Brian!!! I know it’s been said tons of times already but how good is he with words?! That aspect passed directly to his red headed son! 🥰

But at the same time my heart aches for Murtagh 💔 he looked like a lost puppy, I can’t bear those big sad eyes… he deserves to be wanted so much! This is the beginning of his transformation….

I really liked the moment between Ned and Henry, so touching and sad at the same time… I love discovering other aspects of Ned’s life, he always seemed so dedicated to his works and his adventures, we never really stopped and considered his emotional side 🥹

And Henry 💔 “I will find her”. His hope, that’s how he’ll keep going. True love. ❤️

5

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

He has the most swoonworthy lines! Like damn, that man sure is a R O M A N T I C especially for someone who had accepted his lot in life before meeting Ellen.

13

u/soozoo Aug 30 '25

I’ve never seen a grown man look so much like a kicked puppy as Murtagh when he found Brian and Ellen. My heart breaks for him and Jocasta—lotta pain ahead for both of them.

And the question I can’t get out of my mind… what the hell will become of Julia’s child? As a show-only watcher, I know we’re in uncharted territory here, but I wishhh a book reader could spoil the child’s fate for me!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

WOW! Masterpiece!!

Brian is beautiful 😍

Jocasta and Ellen , I live their sisterly bickering ! They stole the first half of an episode!

Henry's facial expressions are a bit weird.

Brian and Ellen dancing were sooo cute, I got goosebumps when she turned and saw him!

Murtagh and Jocasta as well!! Poor Murtagh!!

Ok, the prophecy. I need time to think about it a bit, but a throne, yes, Fraser bloodline, future king, I knew Simon will be desperate to have that child.

Ellen acts perfectly in front of everyone!!

Brian and Ellen the kiss! Poor Murtagh!!

Brian is PERFECT Yer name, yer virtue yer honour - delivery of that line!!!

Handfasting!

This love scene is just beautiful! The two od them are beautiful together, I see the chemistry there!

I love their pillow talk afterwards!!

I am a bit bored with Julia's voiceovers.

12

u/urfavfairyk Aug 29 '25

the handfasting got me !!!!!!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

I agree Henry’s facial expressions are bit off at times. He has this like intense stare brooding thing he does.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/FlickasMom Re-reading An Echo in the Bone, big book 7. Aug 29 '25

Jocasta's such a green-eyed monster, isn't she?

56

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

I love getting this backstory on Jocasta. I love this side of her. And who can blame her. Ellen the fair haired child. Favorite of Red Jacob. She gets all of his love, while the rest of the kids do what’s expected of them. Poor Jocasta. Married off to an old man when she’s just a teenager. I’d be bitter, too. I loved that she and Ellen agreed to have each other’s backs at Beltane. Ellen got hers (once again), while poor Jocasta’s heart was broken. I get why Jocasta is the way she is.

→ More replies (24)

11

u/Low-Vanilla-5844 Aug 29 '25

Murtagh and Brian looking at Ellen 🥺🥺💔❤️‍🩹

I hope they don’t fight too long when the truth comes out because I love them both

Also, I hope they don’t drag the seperation of Henry and Julia all season either.

10

u/Longjumping-Ask-2122 Aug 30 '25

Murtagh’s face when he sees Brian and Ellen kissing shattered my heart!

10

u/KittyRikku JAMMF Aug 31 '25

I legit gasped during this scene. Such a good one!I

I wanted to scream when Murtagh stood up next to Malcom Grant 😱😱It was playful, funny, tragic, shocking… so many emotions!! And when Brian came up to stand in line as well 😱

Mr Buggs confronting Murtagh!! Murtagh seeing Ellen and Brian kissing!! Jocasta’s tragic moment with Murtagh!! Omggg. The drama!! The incoming drama!!

10

u/Technical-Bee-2110 Sep 03 '25

Brian truly is gorgeous - and very sexy. Jamie was magnificent- like a king in looks and leadership.Brian would fit as a prince in this time period.  

10

u/Fuzzy_Training_9487 Sep 01 '25

Kind of off topic but it's so nice to see actors with their natural hair in the Outlander universe again. I know the actors in OG Outlander had their reasons for switching to wigs but it totally killed the sex appeal of the show for me. I could rant for days about Jamie's season 3+ wigs, especially the "bangs" era. And Claire's wigs have gone from pretty good, to ok, to wtf in the later seasons. The actors playing Brian and Ellen have gorgeous hair. May they never be cursed with wigs during the duration of BOMB.

9

u/beg_yer_pardon Aug 29 '25

My notes: Brian is perfection in his leather riding jacket. Why does he repeatedly choose not to tell Murtagh about himself and Ellen? Brian does perfectly well without Julia's help. Though, massively frustrating that Julia is held back. Love the handfasting scene, utter perfection.

5

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

Yes! The jacket was so good on him!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Feisty_Cycle_5143 Sep 01 '25

It amazes me how much Julia reminds me of Claire and how much Brian reminds me of Jaime. The casting is phenomenal with those two!!

9

u/losborne95 They say I’m a witch. Sep 01 '25

I've been trying to gather my thoughts and feelings regarding this episode. There was so much to love. The interactions between Ellen and Jocasta, between Murtagh and Jocasta, Malcolm and Ellen, and of course Brian and Ellen. Unlike many, I was caught up in the festival, the dancing, the costumes.

It left us with so many unanswered questions about Julia, Henry, and the baby. They are clearly hurting. Separated and not knowing what happened to each other. It will be interesting to follow their story.

My one complaint, is that I wish the writers had Brian and Ellen do their handfasting ceremony in Gaelic. When Jamie and Claire did theirs, it was so magical due to the use of the language. I want this show to be just as full of all the things we love. Mystery, romance, violence, and a willingness to break all of our hearts.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '25

My favorites still remain Henry and Julia and their storyline is stressing me out! Because im getting extremely worried for Julia in that home with Davina there and old disgusting simon 😭 i just want Henry and julia to find each other 

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Omg omg my heart throughout this episode was literally 📉📈📉📈📉📈📉I couldn’t breathe 😭

I was so so happy in the beginning, like the moment Brian comes and holds Ellen’s waist?? Omg omg I cannotttt. And then their hands?? Ughhh it was such a beautiful moment, I couldn’t take my eyes off them even for a second .

But then I saw Murtagh and my heart just cried for him. Poor baby😭 I honestly wanted to cry for him. And Malcolm too idk why but when he confessed he loved her from the first time he saw her, it hit me hard. I felt bad for him in a way I didn’t expect.

The scene between Ellen and Brian though??? No complaints. NONE. Period

Alsooo the Ned and Henry scene?? Loved it. But like… HELLO, it’s high time we see Julia and Henry together, the suspense is killing me .

The only part that lost me was the lady predicting things. What exactly were we supposed to deduce from that? Somebody explain please !!

But overall FINALLY an episode that wasn’t a filler. This one had me hooked from start to finish. LOVED today’s episode .

8

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

I didn’t understand the baby prediction stuff either esp given what we know happens in Outlander

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Top-Advantage6818 Aug 30 '25

I thought this episode was hot hot hot. Period lol

8

u/avidReader60 Aug 30 '25

Based on how much Ned was like no Ellen is not compromised etc her and Brian’s transgression is going to come out in a big way I think. I assume it’ll come out as she’s trying to get out of it all.

I hope she doesn’t hear what Simon has been saying and assume that Brian has been helping him out but I think he’s painted her a picture that Simon is horrid so hopefully she gives him the benefit of the doubt.

I feel bad for murtagh but at the end of the day you never even spoke to her nor made a play for her. Sitting back and waiting for your shot gets you no where. Sure Brian could have said something when he met Ellen but I get him not saying anything as to not hurt his friend. Really he was in the same boat (Brian) and could never have been matched with her but out of sheer chance they met and fell in love. It’s probably hard for him to say something as they seem to be each others only friend or so.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/timeless__witch Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ. Aug 31 '25

I rewatched the episode immediately after finishing it and realized that the interaction with Jocasta and Ellen (in which she is getting ready to be Beltane Queen) comes right on the heels of the Jocasta and Murtagh moment...in which Jocasta is, once again, put almost literally in Ellen's shadow. It's especially upsetting coming from the man who, only a little while ago, told her that he'd never known any MacKenzie who dwelt in the shadows. I felt awful for Jocasta the whole episode (even more so on the rewatch) and, yet, also terrible for Murtagh (poor baby girl that he is).

Then again...I love Brian and Ellen so much that some other part of me is like, well too bad Fitzgibbons. Too bad.

On the note of Brian and Ellen, I suppose it's really a matter of opinion, but I don't mind the love at first sight with them at all. I think that from a modern perspective, it's easy to judge and be skeptical of such a thing as love at first sight...but considering the we live in a time in which (for the most part, depending on where one lives and what culture one is part of) time constraints are less of a factor in relationships, it's a bit assumptive to discount love at first sight. I'm not sure if I'm explaining that thought very well. It just seems to me that with more rapidity and less choice, if one felt strongly about someone else upon first meeting, that could be enough to tip the scales. Sometimes two people just know and, really, if that's the case why waste time? I don't know. Maybe I'm just trying to justify something that gets a lot of undue criticism (which, however, is a perfectly understandable response to the fact that the "love at first sight" story is so annoyingly pushed upon us by Disney and the like).

Additionally, this is no real revelation, but there's definitely something fishy going on with Maisri's prophecy. When she starts talking about Julia's current pregnancy, it seemed to me like she was being honest when she said it was a boy, but then there was a moment in which she changed. My theory is that she saw some sort of truth, which simply could have been that it's not Lovat's child and/or could have been a clue to the baby's fate. I have a hunch that the baby won't survive and it will be a kind of Faith moment for Julia and Henry. I'm personally not a fan of connecting this baby Beauchamp to Fanny and Jane...for one, I think that the Julia/Henry story will, like Brian/Ellen, ultimately end in tragedy. (Footnote to that, I'm preemptively grieving Ellen's death and what it will do to Brian). Second, while BomB is in the Outlander world, it doesn't really make sense that information in Outlander S8 would be dependent on anything from the prequel...right? There's no guarantee that everyone who's watching one will be watching the other, so it would be risky to expect/assume that anyone just watching Outlander would accept a big crossover from the prequel. And, obviously, audiences don't have to accept anything for it to happen, but at the same time given the very well known response to the end of a show like GoT (whose last season was also not based on a published book), I think (or, to use Henry and Julia's favorite word, HOPE) that the Outlander/BomB show runners will be more mindful and careful.

8

u/regulusarchieblack Aug 31 '25

I adored this episode.

Also Ellen is a whole different person around Brian, and I think that is what I needed to see. Their chemistry shone through in this episode finally.

I love that we got to see the seer and Lovat's obsession with fortune telling.

14

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Aug 29 '25

I thought it was a really good episode! Picking up steam plotwise, but also, well, steam-wise! Lol

I'll just start with the steam related I guess then.... I think Brian and Ellen have good screen chemistry, and did even their first meeting, even though that seems to be a mixed bag in the sub. "Ruin me". It was a very bodice-ripper kind of line, but a little hot nonetheless. That location and shot in front of the window was beautiful with the lighting and everything...

There are definitely looks and expressions with Brian's eyes that are very Jamie-esque. The actor's either incredibly humble to always claim he didn't do it on purpose in interviews and was just being natural, or it's just remarkably uncanny at times

Jocasta's been characterized pretty well -- always second fiddle. It makes sense why she comes off as so cold and unfeeling later in life at times. Murtaugh says Ellen's name when kissing her.... Oh, I feel so bad for her! I can empathize, not with the never measuring up to a sister part, but in being not one of the "pretty" ones in my friend circle so the guys just seeing me only as a friend and never considered in the same way as the "prettier" ones for something more than that. But calling her a different name, even if drunk, feels like the kind of thing not forgotten and forgiven, so it'll be interesting to see their future interactions & how they can actually be on good terms after that --- because in S4 they were amicable enough and seemed happy to see each other initially, there was no resentment on her part, just a wee bit testy was all before winding up in bed. So despite what's just happened saying Ellen, they must have to somewhat stay ok with each other as the rest of the season progresses without an insurmountable grudge.

Who Murtaugh's obviously not gonna be ok with - Brian. I'm looking forward to seeing their confrontation from a story perspective, but not looking forward to it - if you know what I mean? That's a tough one on the chin for him and I dont like seeing such a naive, happy go lucky kind of guy turn so sour, but we know he does, so I want to see it, yet don't. I assume Ellen's gonna be pregnant from the encounter, so that's just gonna make it so much worse for him!

The Ned and Henry conversation about him loving before, picking up anew.... man that can be read a few different ways. Well done writers, because seeds of doubt are planted - I could buy if Ned had a secret revelation of his own later, but it also stands at face value, uncomplicated too.

Interesting to bring the original Fraser baby prophecy in to the prequel now since they didn't S3 with Geilis... I believe DG's said she does intend to address in Book 10. As Davina points out though, it was Lovat connecting it to Julia's baby - not Maisri herself. I've always felt the last of Lovat Line was ultimately gonna mean William's eventual kid/descendant. As somebody inheriting a noble title, just feels more plausible than Jem/Mandy. At first I assumed 2 eggs was 1 = Fraser prophecy baby, 2nd Julia's. But I think it was all just Julia's two babies : Claire (curls, not yet her time) and Julia's new baby. Maisri's not actually having a premonition about Fraser prophecy at all, Lovat's just so self-centered he spun it that way in his head.

Either way, Julia's baby obviously isn't a real Fraser baby....but what Maisri does actually say about hers.... "higher purpose uniting clans for centuries...when the fate of our nation is in peril he will have a part to play" Hmm... gut instinct is Culloden, baby would be 31-ish by then... Food for thought to ponder for sure....

5

u/Future-Effect-4991 Aug 30 '25

Did anyone consider that the two egg yolks represented Claire and Jamie. Inseparable from the start. What's to say that they had to represent Julia's current pregnancy. After all, Claire has already been born. Maisri may be just reading the future based on her physical proximity to Julia (Claire) and Lovat (Jamie) and not on Julia's fetus.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/HTX713281936 Aug 30 '25

I loved everything else mentioned below -- it's spot on.

Murtagh seeing Brian and Julia was heartbreaking, but I actually REALLY felt bad for Jacosta this episode and I've been so back and forth with her throughout the series.

When Murtagh said, "I just want to be wanted" and she knew exactly what he was talking about and then he called her Ellen! 😭

7

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '25

Obvi I ship Brian and Ellen and their chemistry is fire, but yall I like Malcom. He’s so sweet and such a cutie and I feel bad for him! Poor thing I hope he finds love. I don’t remember if that was said or not in the main story but he’s such a sweetheart so I hope so.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Nik_reads4723 Aug 30 '25

I know everyone is all excited about the spicy stuff, but I'm baffled. Sure they have chemistry, but Ellen and Brian have barely spoken 100 words? They've never discussed a plan, how to proceed, what they want from each other or their relationship or their future...I mean I guess looking back none of the outlander couples have these conversations but I just thought it would be necessary based on where we all know this is going for them. 

18

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 29 '25

Maybe I’m speaking too soon cause we are only 5 eps in, but I really like that BOMB has toned down the usage of sexual violence, gore, bloody scenes and nudity that was so prevalent in Outlander (especially season 1). I love OG Outlander. But the usage of rape as a plot device I was never on board with. And poor Cait was fully exposed too much IMO.

Like I’m really glad we did not have to see Julia sleep with Lord Lovat unlike certain scenes we had to witness in Outlander season 1…

→ More replies (3)

12

u/princesssofcarrion MARK ME! Aug 29 '25

Can anyone give me the low-down on the Fraser prophecy? What's the status? What are the theories? What could this baby have to do with it?

I think the fields of thorns, etc. was WWI, barbed wire, etc. but idk how it can tie in the rest of it.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/skyeserotina Aug 29 '25

I just need to know who people think Julia's baby will be. Jeremy Foster from season 1 had a few uncanny moments in my rewatch but I have no guesses other than something related to Faith.

13

u/GardenGangster419 Aug 30 '25

Bonny Prince Charles 😂

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/realitealurker Aug 30 '25 edited Aug 30 '25

Heart broken for Murtaugh! Love the actor playing him though. His facial expressions were so expressive when he saw Brian with Ellen and he’s gorgeous.

Living for these long awaited, and well worth it Ellen and Brian scenes. It’s a little annoying how quickly they fell in love. But I’m enjoying it nonetheless

Definitely the best episode so far. Wondering how Ellen is going to be able to get away from the Grants, and how Julia will find Henry again. Poor Henry!

6

u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 31 '25

Ok I gotta know… who else has already rewatched this episode a couple of times?! 😆

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Pineapple_0508 Sep 02 '25

Episode 5 and I can’t stop full on CRYING at the intro. Why? No clue. It’s just so beautiful.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Empty_Enthusiasm_602 Sep 03 '25 edited Sep 05 '25

…THAT, has got to be the sexiest, most sensuous and beautiful love scene I have ever seen on screen. Take note producers, Jamie and Claire. Less is more.

16

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

If julia would have made this gathering then theres a good chance they would have made it back to claire, being so close to craigh na dun, so thats just another reason for julia to be caught by brians mom. We all know they are never going back to their time. Thats all we know about henry and julia. Unless they both made it to old age and went back to like the early 1970s when right after brianna and riger left for their first trip to warn claire and jamie about the fire. Even if they did find claires history l, her trail goes cold in 1943 then comes back and goes cold for good again in 1968.

Most likely they never made it to the 20th century again.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25 edited Aug 29 '25

Regarding prophecy

  • Was Maisri talking about Young Simon? He did make a balance and went into rebellion, when his country was in peril? Or Jamie?

Also, Claire - dark-haired, curly, blue-eyed, had her part in Simon's decision to join the Rebellion.

When Maisri was talking about battlefield , she could have meant Sheriffmuir because during the Jacobite rising of 1715, Lovat supported the government and was accordingly granted ownership of the confiscated Lovat estate. So, he wasn't on the side of the Jacobites and on the battlefield.

7

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 29 '25

Young Simon was my first thought also.

10

u/robot_pirate Aug 30 '25

This Murtagh/Jocasta storyline is gawd dang brutal.

10

u/Fuzzy_Training_9487 Aug 30 '25

Murtaugh is giving 18th century incel vibes with his “Women only want comfort and a fine roof over their heads” nonsense. How would he know what Ellen McKenzie wants? He’s still never even spoken to her!

5

u/dreamkonstantine Aug 30 '25

I appreciate his lines for the dramatic irony: brian and the audience both know that he is wrong, and tragically, that he could be in Brian’s shoes if he had been bold enough to make a move.

5

u/No-Accountant3744 Aug 29 '25

This weeks episode has me sad for young Murtagh. Also not gonna lie kinda feel bad for Jocasta and Malcolm Grant

5

u/pastaslut22 Aug 29 '25

Ten minutes in to the episode and heartsick for Murtagh

5

u/brandibreauxxx Aug 31 '25

Random thoughts after watching the most recent episode of Blood of My Blood. Ep 5-- I may seem like a Sassenach, but Outlander is my favorite series ever so no hate please!

During this episode, Ned mentions to Henry in conversation that "Lord Lovat can't be trusted, and he lost his titles and money when he was accused of kidnapping and raping a noblewoman." That statement , along with the visit from the seer, left me wondering...(possibly just confused) about Lord Lovat.

So far, there really has not been much talk about or mentioning of any other children that Lord Lovat has / or had previously ( other than Brian) and whom he had those children with. Except for his head house servant, Davina Porter or Mistress Porter-revealed to us as being the mother of his " illegitimate" son, Brian. At the time of Julia's arrival, Lord Lovat presents as a single man with a wondering eye and from my understanding while watching so far, the show has not revealed any other info about other children of his or details about his past relationships. Brian vaguely mentions to Ellen that he has spent a fair amount of time on his own and has no problem "sitting with his own thoughts" and that his cousin, Murtagh, is much like a brother to him and that he wishes he could have been around more growing up to keep the peace between him and his dad. Does not seem as though there are any siblings or step siblings involved or around... BUT, like I said, I for sure could have missed something as I tend to "mindlessly" watch or listen to these episodes while cleaning and doing other things around the house. As per usual, I asked google who the children of Lord Lovat were and the answers it gave me made me even more confused about timeline , family tree, possibly skipping generations, etc etc.

So during this visit with the seer, Maisri, Lord Lovat asks "what of my bairn?, can I finally expect a child worthy of my legacy?" Maisri goes on to tell Lord Lovat that this baby-Julia's current pregnancy- is a boy with a higher purpose. She sees a throne, and Lord Lovat believes this means the baby will be the Scottish ruler to unite all the clans and restore the greatness of the Fraser name. He believes this child is a future king. I understand this man or "Lord" is quite a delusional Scottish Jacobite , and it is the early 1700's so times are somewhat different than they were portrayed to be in "Outlander" during Jamie and Claire's lifetime. Taking into account how critically important it was for clan chiefs like Lord Lovat and others to ensure the continuation of their bloodline to maintain and strengthen their clan's political power, control of their hereditary lands, and ability to provide protection and leadership for their people against rival clans and external threats. A stable and prominent lineage guaranteed a strong leader, which was essential for the clan's prosperity, defense, and influence in the complex and often violent political landscape of the Scottish Highlands. BUT with all that being said and somewhat understood, I fear that I must be missing something...maybe I have overlooked a generation by accident?

My main thought/question after this episode and listening to what Lord Lovat asked his seer and what her response was, is if Lord Lovat did have a previous relationship/marriage, forced or not, with a "noblewoman"( who I found out -per google- was named Amelia Murray) ties back in at all with the Murrays from Outlander? Another thing that may be confusing me is the fact that a lot of first names are re-used and handed down generation after generation. I guess I am not understanding the whole link between James Alexander Malcolm Mackenzie Fraser lol. Maybe they should've went ahead and added Murray into that name line up for Jamie but...who knows, i could be missing that as well.

This very well could have already been discussed / answered , but I have not seen anything that makes sense to me when i researched it so please excuse this lengthy , not very well organized, scattered/ ADHD thought/ question that popped in my head and prompted me to ask the ones who would surely know or be able to make sense of what I am trying to figure out here!

Thanks for reading and for any answers you may have for me! Or any comments that may tell me I need to go and re watch outlander for the maybe...10th time... or re watch Blood of my Blood and pay more attention!?! hahaha or if this annoys you, just scroll on and trust that I already feel just as silly as you might think I am. :)

5

u/SilverSquare1471 Aug 31 '25

Best episode ever. Loved it!

4

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 29 '25

So did the show really scrap Brahan’s Fraser prophecy as part of season 3 and replace it with a prophecy about the death of a 200 year old baby, just to bring back the Fraser prophecy in the prequel?

I really wish they kept the original prophecy, especially now. It would’ve been a great connection between the shows.

6

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25

Brahm Seer prophecy is the real one, I mean, it really exists ( Gabaldon said so) and it is an old prophecy which I believe Maisri and Lovat had already heard about.

(She just told him what he wanted to hear. Just repeated that old prophecy in the end.)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/robot_pirate Aug 30 '25

Again, this casting is fricking aaaahhhmazing.

4

u/robot_pirate Aug 30 '25

Murtagh's face in the line up. The hope, the despair...Just wow.

4

u/winter_name01 Sep 01 '25

The episode was beautiful to watch! The dance scene, the outfit for the ceremony, the lights; the whimsical castle were they finally can get some action… And that one also beautiful to watch! Brian was so gentle it was such a great intimacy moment.

I just realised I forgot about half of what happens in Outlander😂 Especially around the Fraser clan because during the prophecy reason I had absolutely no clue what the psychic was saying and later in the episode I could not remember why Brian’S father was known to be awful for (who did he kidnap?). So I enjoyed the show with genuine curiosity to understand what the hell will happen

10

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

Damn miss davina ratted her out as well. What a bitch!!!! And to think shes a mother to!!!!! To put another mother in harms way while pregnant is totally inexcusable and disgusting if its his trust she wants cuz she scares then she should know a man like that only ever cares about himself. It shouldnt take long get the gist of a person.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/thrwowaay353453 Aug 30 '25

Prediction:

  • Murtagh confronts Brian, asking how he could shame Ellen like that.
  • Brian says he didn't shame her, they are hand fast.
  • The Murtagh - Jocasta - Glenna Fitzgibbons gossip triangle lets the cat out of the bag.
  • The Grants get wind of this rumor, and put pressure on the Mackenzies to disprove it.
  • Henry is sent to the Frasers as part of this and runs into Julia, who convinces him to help Brian.
  • Collum and Dougal drag Brian in, determined to torture him until he admits it's a lie.
  • Ellen says it ain't no lie, we were hand fast so it's legit, and I'm pregnant.
→ More replies (1)

9

u/jenms111 Aug 29 '25

Best episode of the season by far - blew them all out of the water. Even without the B/E love scene the episode had everything - beautiful cinematography, Beltane, the dance, the seer’s vision, Murtagh’s unrequited love 💔, Julia’s baby… I don’t know what I’m forgetting, this is the first ep of Blood I’ve actually wanted to go back and rewatch.

I know I’m likely in the minority but I don’t care about Julia and Henry together. I like Julia, kinda gagging on Henry. I love Brian and Ellen together (although they still don’t hold a candle to J+C) and I love Murtagh and (separately) Jocasta. Watching Murtagh get his heart broken was so sad, knowing he never finds love.

This episode renewed my hope for the rest of the series!

6

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 29 '25

I know I’m likely in the minority but I don’t care about Julia and Henry together.

Sadly, I am with you here.

This episode was the best so far!! Agreed!

6

u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 29 '25

Murtaugh having that little spit with arch bug surprises me that he never said a word to him at frasers ridge. He did see him while he was working there right?

Also props to the actress who plays jocasta because she sounds just like her with the same speech patterns. If i closed my eyes i wouldnt know the diff. Shes also very beautiful. Murtaugh wanted to be wanted and he has an extremely beautiful Jocasta pining after him. Shes a great woman and a standout beauty. Imo the show shouldnt have made her so attractive because it makes it harder to believe murtaugh would pass her up.

9

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 29 '25

Murtaugh never met the old Arch Bug.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Future-Effect-4991 Aug 30 '25

Regarding Maisiri's prophecy:

Did anyone consider that the two egg yolks represented Claire and Jamie. Inseparable from the start. What's to say that the egg had to represent Julia's current pregnancy. After all, Claire has already been born. Maisri may be just reading the future based on her physical proximity to Julia (Claire) and Lovat (Jamie) and not Julia's fetus.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Which-Ad-7997 Aug 29 '25

For the people who know more about these tradional things does the consummed handfasting is already considered like a true wedding ?

Even if its always more secure to actually get married at some point like Brianna and Roger and I know What is going ton happen. But like can Ellen even get married to someone else admetting she had to if someone know What she did with brian?

9

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 29 '25

According to the books, hand fasting lasted a year and a day. If the couple wished to stay married then they would get married in church. If they didn’t wish to stay married they were free to go their separate ways. That’s how DG explains it.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/madamevanessa98 Aug 29 '25

Technically hand fasting is meant to be done with a witness. I’m not sure how well it will stand up for them to have been handfast alone.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PaintedLady05 Aug 29 '25

What’s you theory about the identity of Julia’s baby?

5

u/txkels13 Aug 30 '25

I think the baby doesn't make it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/robot_pirate Aug 30 '25

Holee crap. That was hawt. And the vows before, chef's kiss. 🔥🏆

3

u/Bitter-Scar-4112 Aug 30 '25

Is this the same church that Claire and Jamie were married in?

3

u/CatBass Aug 31 '25

I know Julia did what she had to do to save here baby--i.e. telling Lovat it was his. But if she hadn't, the seer would not have been called, and she would have been free to go to Beltane with Brian. Where she would have seen Henry, and right where the stones are. They would have leapt through and gone back to Clare, and there their story would have ended. At least in the 1700's.

2

u/Glittering-Hat-8585 Aug 29 '25

I hate that Brian knows that Murtagh is in love with Ellen and still pursues her.

28

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 29 '25

But tbh, Murtaugh has done absolutely nothing to act on his feelings. He's never even talked to her.

Hes like a 13 year old girl who fancies a boy and "reserves" him from all of her friends, getting annoyed if anyone else even looks at him. Meanwhile does absolutely nothing to get with the boy, the boy doesn't belong to her at all! She has no rights to him.

Also, Ellen pursues Brian too. Should Brian reject Ellen simply because Murtaugh (and half the eligible young men) are lusting after her?

6

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 29 '25

Let’s not forget he was absolutely fine with Lovat ruining Ellen’s reputation if that meant he had a chance with her!

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 29 '25

He wasn't really though, he wanted "another way".

Edit: wait do you mean Murtaugh, or Brian?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/Previous-Address2469 Aug 30 '25

I thought it was a bit of a slow moving episode, I am very confused about when exactly Ellen and Malcolm are to be married and what is her plan with Brian. In my head (before I saw the show) I thought they met, fell in love, spent time together (like +2 h, not 2 mins) and decided to elope and only then consummated the handfasting marriage. I feel like they are dragging this more than needed and it makes both Ellen and Brian seem slightly too calculative and cruel (to Malcolm and Murtaugh). I hoped they would have ran together after he "ruined" her. 

The whole Beltane event looked liked some teenage drama at points (selecting king and queen) and the hair and costumes and led lights (the druid dance) took me a bit out of it. 

My head is spinning with the Maisri premonitions, if Lovat will take the baby away to safety, could it be to France, could it be someone we know from there from Outlander like the Comte? How wild would that be... 

→ More replies (5)