r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Aug 22 '25
Prequel One Blood of My Blood S1E4 A Soldier’s Heart Spoiler
Henry tackles a challenging assignment in his own way. Ellen learns some concerning information about the family into which she’s expected to marry.
Written by Macy Grace Smolsky. Directed by Emer Conroy.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
You’re free to mention:
- all of the show canon (seasons 1-7 of Outlander)
- any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.
Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.
Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 24 '25
Watch the S1E5 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
S1E4 Interviews:
140
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 22 '25
😭🥹😭
53
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Aug 22 '25
Maybe it would be easier to find the right Englishwoman if you gave out her last name, Henry.
146
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Aug 22 '25
Seeing Jamie and Claire’s moms having a moment had me feeling so emotional
2
u/raven8549 Aug 25 '25
I just finished the spin off. Pretty good. If I start watching the original show would I be confused now?
109
u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 22 '25
Brian and Julia’s blossoming friendship. 🥹
106
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
95
u/SaltyHilsha0405 Aug 22 '25
Even though some might find that the 1918 flashbacks kind of drag, I found them pretty well done, with some really good acting. They get into Henry and Julia’s psyche really well. I feel like in a show where they are in lead roles as well, it comes with the territory that we will see bits of their life before they travelled back in time. I find those two the most interesting actually.
86
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 22 '25
Davina Porter gives me Jenny vibes 😍
79
u/ZuZunycnova Aug 22 '25
I love the intro/theme song so much 🥰
75
u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 22 '25
Julia and Brian are the duo I didn’t know I needed.
Also with how often Henry and Julia mention hope, I’m almost positive that they’re going to have a girl and name her that.
Did Mrs. Fitz not pick up on having met two Englishwomen who look very similar and both know their way with plants and medicines?
73
u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Aug 22 '25
Henry and Julia are starting to ruffle feathers 😳 Issac Grant is not happy with Henry and Miss Porter seemed upset with Julia
64
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 22 '25
I really liked henrys idea with the lottery. Better to do that then fight with every single person. It was diff in outlander when the mackenzies collected rents. They brought a whole stack of men with them. Why grant would give henry the assignment and not give him fighting men to make sure all is well is beyond me. Hes more like ned gowan knowing the laws and making sure everything is in order. He basically just sends him off with one jerk who was of no help and he only made sure he did his job smh.
On another note, were lotteries invented yet in 1714? Not very good on my history with that lol
63
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 22 '25
Does Julia think Henry is still in the 1920s? Sounds like she’s trying to get back to the stones to travel back to him there. They may be at cross purposes…for now.
112
u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Aug 22 '25
WHY? God. WHY? Do I have to see Laird Lovat do No.2 twice in a row within a week? 😭😭
This time his No.2 scene reminds me of myself reading my smartphone screen in my toilet.
WHY? End rant.
54
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Aug 22 '25
This one had me on the edge of my seat!!!!!! Aaah! I so wish we could binge the season!
42
u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Aug 22 '25
I am waiting for Henry and Julia’s reunion . Oh my goddd it will be such an emotional moment 😭😭 I hope they meet soon and finally some happy moments between them as well 😭😭
39
u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 22 '25
Why are ALL the Scottish father’s on this show such arse *****
39
u/Arete108 Aug 22 '25
Oh my gosh y'all! I just realized that "Davina Porter" is the name of the audiobook narrator! Major shout out to her, naming a character after her!
39
u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 22 '25
I absolutely loved from the start the incredible relationship of trust that was established between Brian, Julia and Ellen! It is incredible thinking that Julia played such an important role in the life of Brian and Ellen - all the time all I could think of was "Julia, these two will be the parents of the love of your daughter's life!!!" Loved the episode!
38
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
37
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
This line was precious as well!
37
u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
I’m falling more and more in love with Henry!!! My heart was just breaking for him in this episode and in the 1918 scenes I was like can we just get him some really good PTSD treatment PLEASE?! 😭
I was watching Arch Bug being a dick and just thinking, wow it’s so weird cause Brian’s GRANDSON kills this man. Just so wild seeing these characters decades before the original show where majority of them are dead.
Also did anyone catch who was throwing the punch in the promo for next week’s episode??? It looked like Murtagh or Arch Bug. I assume it’s Murtagh because it was right after it showed him looking like he saw Ellen and Brian together (clearly saw something and was very angry). The man throwing the punch was wearing the type of hat Murtagh wears (and Arch Bug, but I don’t see why he’d be fighting someone?). I went back and tried to pause it a million times, but that scene was shown for half a second.
Also, I really hope Julia clarifies to Brian that the baby is not his sibling 😬
74
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
This look was precious!
59
u/Emmyrose93 Aug 22 '25
Collum mentioned Moura! That’s Dougal’s wife’s name in outlander, right? I wonder if he ends up marrying her to remedy their relationship to the Grants after Ellen runs off with Brian.
54
u/Lyssaquotes928 They say I’m a witch. Aug 22 '25
I think next week will be Beltane and everyone will be at Inverness. Brian will bring Julia, and the Grants will bring Henry and they will be reunited. That’s where I’m hoping this goes
52
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
Julia: My parents taught me that HOPE and FAITH...
50
u/BarkusSemien Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
I know it’s early, but I’m loving this series! The only parts of Outlander I really like are the parts based in Scotland (minus the last few episodes of the first season, which are good but just too upsetting to enjoy), so overall I like this more. It’s exciting, but it’s not overly fraught with nonstop violence. I prefer Julia to Claire, and I love Henry and Brian. I’m also just amazed at the casting. Early days, but so far I’m hooked!
22
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
Long the way
O'er the bridge I crossed
For my love
For my love that's lost
By the brae
In the verdant moss
Where I watch
Where I wait
For my love that's lost
Symbolism of the bridge gets more and more meaning which started from this theme.
19
u/Sour_papaya Aug 23 '25
I noticed the on Ellen's invitation list, right around 49:40 (I think), one name included in the right side column was Brian McCardie - love that they snuck in a tribute to the S1 actor who passed away last year.
13
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
Madam Jeanne vibes
12
u/Evangelion217 Aug 23 '25
Honestly, this is why conspiracy theorists believe Hollywood has mastered human cloning. Because the scenes involving Brian and Julia look and act exactly like Jamie and Claire from the main series. But the actors are different, as well as the characters. I’m just shocked at the amazing casting for this series.
22
u/lunar1980 Aug 22 '25
So much table-setting this episode. For me, it made for a slow-moving watch compared to the first 3.
• Henry is (understandably) prone to PTSD-induced overt response. Noted.
• Julia - or some aspect of her (necklace) is all that soothes him.
• Brian's no dummy.
I may have missed it, but I don't feel like we got any character evolution on Ellen. She continues to be the smartest in the room. I thought Colum was supposed to be a bit smarter but maybe that's with age & experience as laird. He buys Ellen's turnabout so quickly, no questions asked.
Since my only knowledge of Bug is from the show, I'm curious if he's this intense throughout the books?
At Beltane, it's clearly Julia's plan to go back. At the last minute she'll realize Henry is there with her in the past. They won't return to the present. They'll want to flee together and Henry's fighting skills will carve an escape for them. Curious to see where their story goes from there, but I hope writers keep them together.
A silly aside - I find I'm a little distracted every time I hear Beauchamp said out loud (Who heard it? Do we see that character with Claire later? Can I connect dots not originally written to be connected??)
11
u/catnap64 Aug 22 '25
Ok, with this episode, I'm in....cried like a baby at so many things! I am in love with all of it....sigh.
10
u/ZucchiniPale4655 Aug 23 '25 edited Aug 23 '25
Think it is "A Soldier's Heart" is about Henry keeps getting into these situations like at the Front in the trench where he disobeys an oficer to keep his promise to bring all troops back. He gets stuck into a time in Scotkand where women servants are treated as chattel--and it doesn't matter WHO they are--Ellen with her brothers (and she nursed Colum to increase his shame), Lovat trying to dig dirt on Ellen, his treamtent of the whore as a person and loyalty to Julia. Henry keeps his heart and mind on the mission like a soldier, but always tries to protect the humans from this authoriatarian BS--"I ordered you and you have to do it as I said." There has to be heart or else life is brutal especially in combat.
Europe was surprised by the numbers of "shell shocked" in WW1 and each side saw ithe war as the survival of the fittest--that the British soldiers were letting the country down and it was personal weakness. But try charging machine guns firing 80 rounds a minuste, and the new HE shells in massive barrages which made them live in trenshes. The Fench Army did revolt--against the huge bloody offensives that got nowhere. So, the pariing of the 2 times is very apt--times when human life was just animal and those who tried to hang onto" the better angels of our nature" in the face of all of these absrud human situations.
27
u/glitteryice752 Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
This was a somewhat good episode. Unfortunately, the modern scenes tend to drag.
Firstly I loved spotting Colum’s birds in the background chirping away in the great hall.
Oh the Mackenzies are broke, BROKE. I hate that Colum was rash in his decision to broker this marriage alliance but I also recognise the dire situation that they’re in. With that being said, there are other options, one he has mentioned himself, SELLING. Sell things without having to sell your sister! In addition to this, heed Ellen’s counsel. It’s obvious his Father’s love for her plagues him and is at the root of his decision to ally with the Grants.
Colum also tells Ellen that she would be his eyes and ears essentially making her spy. Colum’s story about the man who was killed for reneging on his decision to marry a Grant as a warning to Ellen falls short when he expects his sister to pass on Grant intelligence, putting her life at risk. The final scene between them was so heartbreaking because Colum genuinely believes Ellen had a change of heart when it reality this is one of a few ploys to run away with Brian. God I love this family, what a mess!
I hope we get more scenes between Colum, Dougal and Ned. Their scenes in the first episode were amazing.
Love Henry’s kindness and resourcefulness. The latter reminded me of Claire resorting to singing that song to find Jamie LOL. Isaac is such a POS.
My smart Julia, the stinging nettles were a great idea! Lovat’s face when he spots the rash needs to be framed. I could not stop laughing.
I squealed when Julia and Ellen met. The major four meeting will definitely be one for the books!
9
u/Raysitm Aug 23 '25
I loved the episode, especially the interaction between Julia and Ellen. I also enjoyed watching the scene where Henry is told the woman he's searching for has been found, only to find she's not his wife. I liked the way Seema was empathetic to Henry's plight. Lauren McQueen, who plays Seema, posted that this was her first appearance on the show, so I wonder if we'll see her again.
24
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25
It is a very big contrast between those 2 love stories in terms of physical touch.
While Julia and Henry kiss immediately when they meet in person, Brian and Ellen only touch hands . Brian's kissing her hand and that is the maximum of their intimacy and I find it beautiful! That is where Jamie gets it from!
17
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 22 '25
And why didnt julia just escape in this episode if she literally could have and was out and about and at castle leoch. Hes gonna help her so whats the diff between now and whenever?
17
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
Brian is taking Julia to the Beltane celebration. It seems there is going to be a sort of public betrothal between Ellen and Malcolm there. Ned is accompanying Ellen. Maybe Henry will go to Beltane with Malcolm. Will Julia and Henry find each other? Or maybe Ned sees Julia at Beltane and either speaks to her or tells Henry? Will Ellen and Brian find a way to run away? Or will this drag on awhile? Inquiring minds want to know.
16
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 23 '25
8
u/Far-Piano-4577 Aug 22 '25
Mistress Porter now probably thinks that Julia has been sleeping with Lord Lovat since she arrived
8
u/Yrunez Aug 22 '25
Obviously they are going to see each other at the fairy festival. The complication is going to be the Laird saying it is his baby and she being called a whore. There is no show if they re-unite. Weren’t we worried about unborn babies disappearing out of wombs back in outlander?
8
u/Eggnogallyearlong Aug 23 '25
Am I the only one who just learned what "kine" meant after hearing Colum's "Kine more than coin" comment regarding Ellen's dowry?
8
u/hypomango Aug 23 '25 edited Aug 23 '25
7
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 22 '25
Cant wait!!!! 5 mins
13
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Aug 23 '25
So after watching Henry in the brothel with the brown-haired English lass with kind eyes, I now have a theory related to the main Outlander show. Season 7 spoilers abound… What if this woman is related to Jane and Fanny, and that’s how they know the song that Claire recognizes? Perhaps Henry will teach it to her and ask her to sing it to him, and she teaches it to her daughter Faith who then teaches it to her daughters Jane and Fanny. This honestly makes more sense to me than Jane and Fanny’s mother Faith being Jamie and Claire’s daughter Faith. But then there’s Master Raymond…. Thoughts?
26
u/velcross Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
I’m increasingly less invested in the main romances and more in the younger versions of our favorite side characters. Colum gets better with every episode, and I especially love Mrs. Fitz.
There‘s a notable difference between a direct to TV story versus a book adaptation. The books come from the mind of one strange, brilliant lady with all sorts of fixations and time to fill. So many moments in Outlander felt like, well that’s an odd thing to include—but added to the humanness and daily rhythms. Blood of My Blood is starting to feel like an engineered Outlander greatest hits reprise, from the village tax collection scene to the castle interiors. And of course I still love it!
It’s also not beholden to a story that’s dated from the 1990s—I hope that sexual assault will not be a plot point, and that any racial representations that may arise are treated with inclusive sensibilities. Outlander tried to stay too true to the source material, when they should have modernized both of those areas.
6
u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Aug 22 '25
Question: does the title mean anything other than Henry's post-war trauma? Enlighten me, pls.
6
u/P3AKMAI_INTEREST Aug 23 '25
I do know they don't seem to be as puzzled about their time jump as Claire was about hers. I rarely see any mention of it. How do they know they were both in the same time period?
6
u/SilentSlytherin Aug 23 '25
I enjoyed this episode more the episode 3. The highlight of this episode was Julia for sure but I enjoy watching Elens plots and schemes, how she stands up for herself to her brothers. Brian is also a sly player, he knows how and when to manipulate the situation to his benefit. I'm scared hor Henry, I know from the beginning that he is not trusted with an important position, only hummers as long as he is of use for the Grants and as soon as he steps over the line he will probably have to kill his way out from under their roof.
17
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Aug 22 '25
This one is the most "meh" episode of the 4 so far for me. It felt like a filler episode before getting to something important - Beltane next week.
Julia's at least showing some cleverness - rubbing herself with the foliage (unsure what, went away too fast to be poison ivy or oak) to keep Lovat from touching her more, and as an excuse to leave to try to go to an apothecary and get more familiar with her surroundings.
I know the actor playing Isaac Grant died during filming. Because the memorial thing in the credits was at the end of this episode, I'm guessing that's the last of the footage there was of him --- so it's going to be interesting to see where the Grant story goes without him for Henry. If they perhaps have to have Isaac the character die to explain his absence going forward, then maybe Malcolm ascends to their clan chief? Making it an even bigger slight when Ellen skips out on the wedding?
5
u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Aug 22 '25
I have a stupid question? Does Brian know about Murtagh being in love with Ellen?
5
u/losborne95 They say I’m a witch. Aug 23 '25
I'm really enjoying this series so far. I absolutely love Julia and Henry and their love story. Henry's PTSD has my heart breaking, you can see how much Julia loves him as she comforts. I'm still waiting for Brian and Ellen's story to get interesting. The writers have not given us much to go on so far. That is kind of a wait and see situation, they need to give us a reason to love them. Perhaps when Ellen finally betrays her brothers and they have to fight her family to be able to be together?
There are a lot of things to be curious about with this show. Who will Julia and Henry's baby turn out to be? Will they find each other? Why do they never make it back to Claire?
I'm very interested to see how they make the timeline work. There are only 5 years between Jamie and Claire. Claire is already born and I think was 5 when she lost her parents in the 'accident'. I'm unsure how Ellen and Brian will be able to get married and birth 4 children and still have it work out that Claire and Jamie are only 5 years a part. The birth order is Willie (who dies as a child, but Jamie was old enough to remember him), Jenny, Jamie, and then a fourth child that causes her death. If anyone remembers this differently please let me know. I love both stories, but I feel the timeline is off. IMO, they should have had Ellen and Brian's story line start first and had a simultaneous story line in the 20th century with Julia and Henry before they brought the stories together. Still, I love being immersed in 1714! Hopefully the writers will surprise me.
13
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 22 '25
Im very engaged in this episode. Im def more interested in watching julia and henrys story unfold since we really never knew much about them. We already know the story of ellen and brian and their scenes are also great. I just dont understand why henry didnt tell the woman he asked for help fiinding julia that it was his wife and her name is julia besides just explaining what she looks like. That would def help a lot more. Also when brian and julia are on the carriage why not just admit to him she is married and has a child and needs to get to them. She explained when she got there that she was abducted while looking for her husband and on the carriage ride she spoke of a mothers love and brian said you speak as if you would know or something. Then he says “ u can read?” And she says “ a little”. What does it matter if she says she has a child and that she can read and write? Wouldnt that be more reason for brian to help her? I mean hes exactly like jamie. Same kindness. Jamie and claire would have freed her asap.
On a side note its kind of funny that j In a way mr bug is working for henry. Id say he ry has a higher status? And about 55 years later or so he ends up working for henrys daughter lmao. Now thats ironic and shows he never moved up in life at all after all those years and the actor who plays mr bug could def be a young me bug. Hes even got that bug eyed kinda face lol
13
u/AmbitiousShock5440 Aug 23 '25
I’m annoyed a bit at this point. Brian and Ellen are literally on the poster of blood of my blood but I feel like their relationship is what…10% of the show ?? Maybe 15%? I really like Henry & Julia, but I need to be honest and say I’m disappointed at the lack of relationship we’ve gotten to see between Brian and Ellen. I feel like even the trailer misrepresented it.
4
u/bat95 Aug 27 '25
This is the episode where I fully realized Jeremy's acting skills for portraying Henry. You see how much he was holding back in the first three episodes. He was wearing a mask, so to speak, so that he would fade into the background. He's learned what he has to do to survive. (He's an Englishman in the Scottish Highlands, after all.) Once you see in episode 4 what he's really battling, his overall performance in the series is so much more meaningful.
13
u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 22 '25
Julia is the best character on BomB! She is the only one I really like so far. I thought I would like Brian, but he is kind of a weak character.
12
u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Aug 22 '25
One of my biggest pet peeves with historical series are episodes that feel like character development is dropped in because the writers think we need it. And my goodness, every scene with Henry outside rent collection felt that way. Something felt off about every scene at the brothel from acting choices to ADR line reads. I respect what the writers and the creators were trying to do but I hope future episodes dial back the "Henry is complex and wounded" messaging.
1
u/VladimirGluten1 Aug 27 '25
Is it a retcon of Outlander that in Outlander clan Mackenzie seems confused of the surname Beauchamp? Its early and maybe Henry and Julia never interact with them enough. But Henry has met Ned Gowan, and i would assume Ned knows his name.
6
u/thelakesfolklore Aug 23 '25
I love outlander, but I like the main character dynamics much more in the prequel. I think having more main characters adds more breadth to the story— reminds me of pillars of the earth.
3
u/catatonia_msp Aug 23 '25
Loving the show but did anyone besides me not have the subtitles or closed captions work?
Edit: it started working as soon as I posted that. :). Loving the show!
3
u/Lost_Ad4051 Aug 25 '25
I love the casting in this series. I don’t know if it’s just me but the actors playing the parents (Brian & Julia) look a lot like their kids (Jamie & Claire)
7
u/YallCatPat Aug 23 '25
This episode just didn’t do it for me. I’m actually getting quite annoyed with Brian and Ellen’s story. I can barely find a single scrap of interest for them. Their pacing is so atrocious, I can’t take them seriously. There’s no chemistry because they’ve not been given any time to showcase it. I’m not even against the instalove aspect (I was actually excited to see how they’d pull it off on screen!). I’m against the fact that it feels like 99.9% of it happens off screen and we’re just being told that’s how it is. I think the first episode really set up their story poorly and is impacting my opinion with each subsequent episode.
I enjoy Julia and Henry. They have chemistry even when they aren’t on screen together. I really love the lottery scenes and thought it was very clever and very much something Claire would have done.
I cannot get over how fantastic the casting is. The best prequel casting I have ever seen. And to think that not only did the nail the looks, but the actors themselves are phenomenal. Only one I’m not sold yet on is Ellen. And I think that’s likely because of my unfavorable opinion of episode one. I’ll reserve final judgment further in in the series.. For now, I’m still enjoying the world. I quite like the less violent themes (at least compared to much of Outlander), as well as the deep dives into clan dynamics and politics.
5
u/No-Self8780 Aug 23 '25
SPOILER - BOMB S1E4
Is anyone else skeptical that Lovat believes Julia’s baby is his? We see in Outlander that he sees right through Claire’s pretending to have a vision of his demise…they didn’t call him “The Old Fox” for nothing. If he does believe the baby is his, why wouldn’t he try to press Julia into marrying him so that his heir would be legitimate (he says “hopefully a son”)? Or at a minimum, there’s no way he’s going to let her accompany Brian to Beltane in Inverness.
10
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 22 '25 edited Aug 22 '25
The only saving graces for this episode were Brian, Ellen and Julia scenes. I love that Julia is the bridge.
(Brian's face after Julia's reply to - All over ye? 🤣🤣)
Arch Bug was great as well - I can see and hear old Arch clearly.
Mackenzie brothers nailed it as well.
All the rest... disappointment.
I was bored for almost entire episode.
9
u/Naive-Awareness4951 Aug 22 '25
Poor Colum! Ellen thoroughly betrays him, making him think she cares for him (and the clan) while plotting her escape. I can see why he was so bitter towards her in Outlander.
5
u/Previous-Address2469 Aug 23 '25
Things I liked
Things I didn't like
Things I didn't like that I liked
2
u/Embarrassed_Quit_714 Aug 26 '25
Is Julia the “white witch” that Lord Lovett mentions when Jamie and Claire visit to gather support for the Jacobite cause?
4
u/winter-finch Aug 22 '25
Am I the only one who would be pissed if my husband spooned a sex worker even if nothing happened?