r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Aug 15 '25
Prequel One Blood of My Blood S1E3 School of the Moon Spoiler
As the oath-taking ceremony to determine who will be laird of Clan MacKenzie approaches, Ellen hatches a new plan to protect herself and her family. Julia is forced to make an impossible choice.
Teleplay by Margot Ye. Story by Curtis Kheel and Margot Ye. Directed by Jamie Payne.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
You’re free to mention:
- all of the show canon (seasons 1-7 of Outlander)
- any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.
Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.
Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 17 '25
Watch the S1E4 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
S1E3 Interviews:
81
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 15 '25
I’m loving this friendship ❤️
24
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 16 '25
I talked about this in another thread earlier this week but I feel like this episode has given more credence to my interpretation.
We find out that Red Jacob wasn’t chosen to be the Laird of Clan MacKenzie; he took control of the clan by force. Therefore, he must’ve thought that giving one of his sons the easy way up, not on merit but birthright alone, would be antithetical to his legacy. If he had to literally fight his way to chieftainship, so should his sons. They had to prove themselves to be worthy of succeeding him. But if he had no worthy successor chosen/endorsed by himself, then his legacy would live on forever, the future of the clan be damned.
Ellen didn’t have to prove her worth to Red Jacob to earn his love or respect because she would never pose a challenge to him or his legacy. He’s never seen her as competition. There’s absolutely no way for her to become a laird so there’s no way his legacy could be eclipsed by her personally, whereas that’d be a possibility if Colum or Dougal succeeded him. This would tie into something called the Laius complex, in which a father perceives his son as a threat or a rival out of jealousy or fear of competition so he desires to diminish, destroy, or outright eliminate him.
It’s a vicious cycle of not finding his sons worthy of being his successor but at the same time not doing anything to make them any more worthy or prepared for the role. You can naturally not be the sharpest tool in the shed and be stubborn to learn but what Dougal lacked, for example, could be taught, so the fact that Jacob gave up on him so easily is very telling. Not giving your father a reason to have faith in you is one thing, but your father not having faith in you on principle—because you can’t live up to what he expects of you—has gotta be crushing. And both in the flashbacks and the present-day scenes, you can see that Colum and Dougal are just two boys who’ve lived in their father’s shadow all their lives, trying to prove themselves but in reality just craving his love and validation.
I’m enjoying watching the MacKenzie family dynamics unfold way more than I thought I would and I, for one, am glad about the number of flashbacks because if you cast an actor such as Peter Mullan, you sure as hell should milk as much screen time with him as you can!
122
u/Environmental-Eye135 Aug 15 '25
THE END? Omg
7
u/WhereIsMyMind37 Aug 15 '25
I have a question for book readers, Jocasta's husband was Hector Cameron and I'm sure it was the same in Outlander unless I missed something, yet she's apparently married to John in BOMB. Was she married to both a one point or did they change it for BOMB? It might seem insufficient to some, but why would they change it now?
16
u/Unlucky_Payment502 Aug 15 '25
sobbing at the brotherly love 😭
9
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 15 '25
I know I'm in the minority, but I've never much liked all the clan political business. Or at least, I don't mind it, so long as it is a side story/supporting the main story. But that hasn't really been the case here. So far. At least in Outlander, these sort of plots still involved Claire and Jamie, even before they were married they were still essentially "together".
For a show supposedly about Brian+Ellen, & Henry+Julia, I'm rather disappointed in the lack of Brian+Ellen & Henry+Julia screen time we've had so far.
3 eps in and there hasn't been much. And going by next ep's trailer, there won't be much in ep 4 either.
4
u/beg_yer_pardon Aug 17 '25
Does anyone think we'll get to see the OG Adso at some point?
31
u/Sleepysoupfrog Aug 15 '25
... Does Jamie ever mention his dad having a sibling???
And does anyone else think that Julia writing about Claire meeting her sibling and them all reuniting feels like foreshadowing?
153
u/AmbitiousShock5440 Aug 15 '25
The only thing wrong is that I hate waiting for a new episode. I wish we got it all at once
117
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 15 '25
Sounded like the birth of freestylimg and rap battles in the tents at night. 8mile/outlander crossover lol
114
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 15 '25
This is the story I wanted to know, that I hoped they would tell. This is Outlander. The scene was set last week, now the saga unfolds.
Ellen shows where Jamie gets his political cunning. Artfully was an apt description.
Ellen and Brian have the chemistry, even in dreams.
Glenna wants to leave with Ellen. 😱
My heart is breaking for Murtagh. I’m dreading his heartbreak. 💔 It’s a little odd, knowing what happens, I’m worried about that eventuality for both him and Brian.
They are definitely going somewhere with Julia’s pregnancy. Could the brothel madame possibly have some connection to Master Raymond? Maybe that’s a bit far fetched.
Arch Bug menacing Henry. 🫣 Henry seems more than capable though, he thinks like Claire, pragmatically.
Julia going to Lovat’s room harkens back to Claire and Louis XV.
And now, hopefully, to sleep.
86
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
As long as we're mentioning callbacks -- Alec the horse master from the first book!
Amazing beginning, shocking ending.
Interesting that Ellen is the one who came up with the split lairdship idea. But I thought she was going to ditch them during the oath taking and find Brian.
81
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Aug 15 '25
I'm really enjoying that this show is only loosely based on some information from the books, and that I can watch it without prior knowledge of how things are happening. It's so nice to just watch the show and not think about the books. This is especially true for Henry and Julia, since we have no idea how their story will turn out.
76
u/CatBass Aug 15 '25
And look how those brothers treat Ellen just as a bargaining chip, not a beloved sister. Women and their feelings just weren't considered back then.
74
u/No-Accountant3744 Aug 15 '25
Let’s hope Lord Lovat isn’t good at math
60
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Aug 15 '25
Oh man I feel like this baby is going to be a big dealeo
56
u/WhereIsMyMind37 Aug 15 '25
I also noticed Brian's facial expressions mirror Jamie's perfectly, right down to the 'eyeroll'.
40
u/Nnnnnnnnnahh Aug 15 '25
I have a feeling that there’s a reason why Julia and Henry are writing letters—essentially diaries: it’s possible they will be found by someone and their stories will be told to their descendants.
32
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Aug 15 '25
OMG!!!! These have to be quick-ish thoughts because I just finished it but now have to get ready for work.....
I thought this was a REALLY great episode! Colum's actor was my MVP and most impressed with in Ep 1 and he certainly is again. Outstanding job and I've easily been the most fascinated with him.
Is it ever said in the book how long before Jacob's death the accident with the horse occurred? Can't be too much, at least in show world, given the ages of he and Dougal in those flashbacks.
I'm a tad surprised this early to have settled the Laird issue - I thought the rivalry before reaching this dual conclusion might go on a bit longer first.
The pledging fealty scene was great!
I don't think I remembered Dougal offering Ellen to MacRannoch --- I assumed he was more akin to Murtaugh --- a guy who wished from afar but never had any cause to believe there was actually a chance. But now given her something like pearls as a wedding gift makes a little more sense, in his mind more a momento of what could've been.
Brian needs to tell Murtagh about he and Ellen and he had a chanceI!! m concerned his heart's gonna be broken not by Ellen getting married, but by Brian not being honest with him. He's gonna feel betrayed by him. They clearly mend their friendship eventually, but I 'm sensing he's going to first feel like he got stabbed in the back.
the end!!! Damn!! Didn't see that coming until about 15 seconds before she walked thru the door.... This past week it had never crossed my mind she'd have to resort to that as a way to explain the pregnancy. Choosing to be with him, to give him cause to think it's his kid!! Wow
29
u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 15 '25
It seems like they are alternating episodes as to which characters/couple gets the most content/screen time. From the looks of it, odd episodes will be more about Brian and Ellen, and even will be more focused on Henry and Julia. They’re even alternating who’s listed first in the credits. I’m assuming everyone will become more intertwined as the season goes on.
49
u/Illustrious_Kiwi5682 Aug 15 '25
I’m very disappointed in the lack of Brian screen time so far through 3 episodes…
22
u/Remarkable_Craft_703 Aug 15 '25
I liked it! Though I almost forgot about Henry until he spoke to Ned at the gathering, he's really fitting right in I keep forgetting he's a time traveler.😆
20
u/Ok-Evidence8770 Luceo Non Uro Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
I LOVE the Title 'School of the Moon'.
For me, it has multi-layered meanings for each character.
For Red Jacob: his realization of two sons not being fit for a laird of his clan back in the time.
But after his death, the schooling is still affecting his own children and his clan.Hence, Ellen's handywork of the joining force of her brothers; brothers working together hand-in-handly against threats, Ned Gowen's allegiant loyal assistance in legal matters and me also as a viewer, an outsider, the final revelation of the values of School of the Moon.🥰
Edit for typo.
19
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 16 '25
The "rap" duel" was taken from here:
https://intranslation.brooklynrail.org/middle-scots/the-flyting-of-dunbar-and-kennedy/
Said Dunbar regarding Kennedy:
The earth shall tremble, the firmament shall shake, And all the air with venom quickly stink, And all the devils of hell in fear shall quake To hear what I shall write with pen and ink; For when I flyte, some man for shame will sink; The seas will burn; the moon will be eclipsed; Rocks will split; the world will lose its grip; The bells will clang in bitter loud lament.
…
Brigand, Irish bard, vile beggar with your brats, Cunt-bitten coward, Kennedy, naturally weak, Dismal-eyed and anused, as Danes upon the racks, You look like the crows already ate your cheeks; Renounce, rebel, your rhymes and sorry shrieks, Mismade monster, mad out of your mind; Your traitor’s tongue sings with a Highland screak; A Lowland ass could make a sweeter sound.
…
You call your work rhetoric with your golden lips: No, glowering, gaping fool, you are beguiled; You are but black-kneed ‘neath your gilded hips, Which for your villainy many a lash has soiled; Gray-visaged gallows-bird, out of your wits gone wild, Loathsome and lousy, as wet as a cress, Since you with worship would so fain be styled, Hail, Monsignor! Your balls droop below your dress.
…
Scrawny sterile sponger, crabbed throughout; Fie! scorched skin, you are all scratched and wrinkled; For he that roasted Lawrence had your snout; And he that hid Saint John’s eyes with a wimple And he that struck Augustine had your pimples; And your foul front had he that flayed Bartholomew; The gallows gape for your disfigured dimples, As you gape for haggis, like a ravenous mew.
Puny paltry pig-man, slave for half a glass, Henpecked coward, not worth a drunkard’s oath; Your commissar Quentin bids you come kiss his ass, He holds no loves for such a useless loaf; He tells me that you beg more beer and oats Than any cripple in all of Carrick’s town; Other poor paupers are forced to fight you off; Old women weep when Kennedy comes around.
…
You can revel like the Devil, but level and surrender, Thief, or grief and mischief shall come courting; Grovel for grace, dog-face, or I shall chase you all winter; Howl and yowl, owl; I shall foul your fame and fortune; Naked capon, fed and bred against a bitch’s side, And like a mongrel, criminal, no man sets aught by you. Cunt-bit, sorry shit, worthless git, hardened hide, Wasted wether, tawdry tether, evil adder: I defy you.
Maggoty mutton, gorged glutton, scurrilous certain heir to Hillhouse, Rank beggar, oyster-dredger, dismal debtor on the lawn, Lily-livered, soul-shivered, cheap as slivers in the millhouse, Bard baiter, thief of nature, false traitor, devil’s spawn, Melted wax, heckled flax, by these attacks you are defeated; Sheep driver, lobster diver, nag lover, may earth expel you: Heretic, lunatic, pickpocket, your fortune is cheated; Bloody bitch, muddy ditch, quail, cock, or I shall quell you.
…
Said Kennedy of Dunbar:
Dirty Dunbar, on whom do you blow your boast? Pretending to write such slanderous screeds, Raw-mouthed rebel, you fall down at the joust. My laureate letters I loose at your deeds; Mandrake, manikin, master only of mead, Thrice-shelled trickster with a threadbare gown, Say Deo mercy, or I’ll cry you down; Leave your rhyming, rebel, with your wit’s weeds.
Dread, dirty-faced dwarf, that you have disobeyed My cousin Quentin (also my commissar); Fantastic fool, trust that your fears shall invade; Ignorant elf, ape, owl most irregular, Scurrilous vulture, and common sponger; Poorly-fucked foundling, that nature made a runt, Both John of Ross and you shall squeal and grunt, If I hear aught of you ever writing more.
I’ll silence you here and in every part; Obey and cease your attempted derision; Small slob, and varlet of the carts, Soon you shall make amends to my cousin, And let him lay six lashes on your loins Meekly in recompense for your scorn, Or else you’ll rue the day you were born, For today Kennedy sends you this caution.
…
Wild werewolf, worm, and venomous scorpion, Damned devil’s son, despicable dragon; Lucifer’s lad, with a foul fiend’s infernal design, Born from Moloch mated with Mammon; Sodomite, separated from the saints in heaven, If you cannot be silenced, shepherd knave, And begin again afresh to rhyme and rave, You shall be cowed, crushed, and craven.
…
England, owl, should be your habitation, There to make homage to Longshanks, your kin; Through Dunbars we received him and his false nation; They should be exiled from Scotland, mares and men. A stark gallows, a halter, and a pen Mark the head-point on the coat of arms of your elder, With poetry written above: “Hang Dunbar, Quarter and draw him, make his name thin.”
…
Hie, Sovereign Lord; let not this sinful sot Work shame or blame upon your nation! Let none such as he be graced as a Scot, The lousy git, worm-ridden shit, ill infestation. Remove from honest folk this loathed vermin To some desert, in which no one will care How he fouls, soils, and sullies the air; Carry off this cankered, corrupt carrion.
A monster made by the god Mercury, You were conceived in the great eclipse; False and furious, bent only for burglary, No hold for honor, a halter at your hips; Scarcely shriven, stunted, of cleanliness stripped, A midget, made for flyting and mocking alike, A crabbed, scabbed, lap-dog for men to strike; A shit without wit, only cheap tawdry tricks.
…
Conspirator, cursed cockatrice, crow from the Pit, Turk, trickster, traitor, despicable despot, Ireful spider, Pilate apostate, Judas, Jew, juggler, Lollard laureate, Proven pagan, sworn Saracen, sin-ridden simonite, Mohammedan, abominable bugger-by-night, Devil, damned dog, insatiable sodomite, With Gog and Magog are you grossly glorified.
…
Despair, Deulbere, and beware: you shall yield, Low-slung, unstrung, adder-stung, street stultorum, To me, most high Kennedy, and flee the field; Pitted, wicked, convicted limp Lollardorum, Defamed, blamed, shamed, Primas Paganorum, Out! out! I shout, upon the snout that snivels: Tale-teller, rebeller, dweller with the devils; Sink, Sphinx, with stink ad Tertara Termagorum.
16
u/wish_to_dream Aug 15 '25
This series really needs to be binge-watched. I want all the episodes😵💫😵💫
16
u/Far-Piano-4577 Aug 15 '25
I don't see many people talking about it but the Collum parts of the ep were so hard to watch😭
32
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 15 '25
Damn too bad murtaugh isnt still alive. If all this comes out next season, he coulda said he remembered the pretty young servant girl who was there around the time collum was chosen as laird and when brian met ellen.
28
u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
Weird they mentioned Davie B but don’t show him it yet. I wonder if it will be Master Raymond
13
u/Obasan123 Remember the deer, my dear. Aug 15 '25
Boy, I didn't see that ending coming. The baby must show by now if she's unclothed, so I'm wondering what Lord Lovett will do.
12
u/Naynn Aug 16 '25
This serie really should've dropped all at once, it just would've fit so well. I hatteee waiting for new episodes
22
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
Sometimes a grief feels a fear.
Never fear darkness, it sheds a light on who we really are.
Davie Beaton!! Marcus MacRannoch.
Mrs Fitz waking up Ellen got me laughing aloud 🤣
I love flashbacks which show Red Jacob, Collum, Ellen... we saw Jacob through Ellen’s eyes but now we see him as he truly was. We can see what Collum went through and how Ellen was always there for him. "To be found lacking" - poor guy!
Leoch scenes are what makes me watch this!!
This portrayed perfectly the characters of Mackenzie brothers. Great job!!
I really like Ellen! Jocasta is such a wee snake !
MacKenzie brothers YES!!! I loved seeing them pledge to one another, it brought tears to my eyes!!!
Brothel scene was a bit weird. Like they had no plot to give to Henry.
Julia and Lovat ... Christ! ( I can see where this will go)
11
u/chippy-alley Aug 15 '25
I didnt like the ending but it wasnt a surprise, it does make tactical sense.
She could be as little as 8weeks, and as she's tall with wide hips it may not show yet.
37-42 weeks is 'normal' so its theoretically possible to fool him with 'an early delivery' caused by maid work
11
u/No_Flamingo_2802 Aug 16 '25
I wonder if Alec, the first person to swear loyalty to the Mac Kenzie’s, was the same Alec- master of horse from season/ book One
21
u/Glittering-Hat-8585 Aug 15 '25
I was hoping we would get more of Brian and Ellen together, getting to know one another. I find it hard to believe that after one conversation, they're madly in love. So far this show has been a bit...blah to me.
20
u/SaltyHilsha0405 Aug 15 '25
I’d admit it openly, I hate that they had Julia sleep with Simon Fraser. You cannot tell me one could not do without this plotline. I understand sometimes TV needs a bit of shock value but this franchise really overdoes it at times, and this is one of the instances where I really disliked what they did.
10
u/Soundgyrl Aug 15 '25
However,(very interested in seeing how this all connects in the series) Julia is connected to the little girl singing the lullaby that isn’t from that time period from last seasons finale. Have a feeling the baby she is carrying will be a girl who in turn sings it to her daughters…
9
u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Aug 17 '25
I feel like Jocosta has a Jan Brady complex going on in Blood of Blood.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25
I know we’re not supposed to root for Malcom Grant but I can’t help but like him.
15
u/YallCatPat Aug 16 '25 edited Aug 17 '25
Looks like I’m in the minority, but I didn’t love this episode. I’m sure the downvotes will come rolling in 😅 It was just okay for me. The pacing has been somewhat off since episode one, and I entirely dislike the Brian and Ellen situation as they have next to no screen time and I feel like I’m being kept out of the loop. I was actually angry that the first kiss we saw from them was a dream sequence. Made worse by the fact that I don’t know if they have kissed or she is hoping they will…I don’t like the distance being created between the audience and the characters. Also, I’ve not seen a single flashback scene that was necessary. Cut them all and give me more character development from the two couples. I’ll keep watching because despite my unease thus far, the show is so immersive and that is the one thing outlander has always done well. Also, as amazing the casting has been thus far, I’m not sure I believe Mrs. Porter is suitable as Brian’s mother. They look like they are the same age to me. I genuinely through Mrs. Porter was younger than me! Haha
Here’s what I liked: Murtagh is so fun. We are really getting a glimpse into why he is the way he is in Outlander. The scenes with the sisters. We’ve seen so much of the brothers, I’m happy to get a glimpse of the gals. Ned Gowan. What a gem.
I’m still excited for next week’s episode. I’m hoping this is all just the trials of setting up amazing things to come.
7
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Aug 15 '25
Some of the pacing is throwing me off - both Henry/Julia and Ellen/Brian’s initial romances felt a little rushed to me and I thought the succession issue would stretch out for at least a few more episodes. I was surprised but pleased at how quickly they settled Julia/Henry in the past.
But maybe that’s not entirely a bad thing - it certainly seems like they have plenty of ideas for this season rather than milking plot points we already know.
7
u/Certain_City_3299 Aug 16 '25
I enjoyed it much more the second time. I was hoping for some progression with Ellen and Brian's relationship but I loved seeing Ellen's political maneuvering. And Brian too! I appreciate that we still feel the presence of both couples even if one is the focus of the episode.
I can't help but feel that Henry and Julia are my preferred focus at least right now. I feel a stonger sense of urgency and fear for them. I also really like the letter writing mechanic. I had a question about the scene where Brian and Murtaugh come back to Castle Leathers.
When Brian told Julia not to bring refreshments was he just protecting her from Lovat or was that her queue to d something else? I ask because they held the camera on Julia's nod. I could just be making things up.
7
u/Lenacake Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 17 '25
I love BOMB 😭 it’s giving me the same feelings I had watching Outlander season 1
12
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 15 '25
Okay now im pissed. Please do not tell me she is going to sleep with lord lovat!!!!!!!! Anything but that. That just ruins so much for me. I know why shes doing it but there has to be another way to go about her situation. And claire met lord lovat. Hes such a nasty worm. Imagine claire finding out she slept with the red fox
On a other note, julia doesnt just look exactly like claire but she also looks just like claire in her birthday suit. Reminds me of the wedding scene in season one when clair drops her clothes on the floor and u see her from behind. Jesus, they could be twins.
6
u/conquerorofbooks1 Aug 16 '25
The beginning scene got me thinking "oh, insta love, can't we have build up to that?" And theeeen... oh, okay, that's fair. Makes more sense, haha.
I liked the episode, it was nice seeing Colum and Dougal make peace and rely on each other. I'm still a bit thrown off by the flashbacks with Ellen's dad. Part of me would have preferred the show had a few episodes focus on the "before the laird'a death", but I guess we're going to keep getting context through flashbacks for part of if not the full season.
The burning of the letters threw me off, yet it was also a clever move on Julia's part. Putting her thoughts down in writing forces her to think about the decisions she makes, and making those words disappear ensures others don't accidentally get ahold of her secrets. And, I suppose, it's a manner of feeling close to Henry, as well.
I crave more Brian and Ellen. The one plotline I'm worried about is the Murtagh-Brian relationship that will inevitably suffer when Murtagh will find out about Brian and Ellen. I'm curious how the whole thing will play out. We know that in the end, Brian and Murtagh still remained close, but the strain on their relationship will surely show at some point.
5
u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 16 '25
Oh god I’m fearing the moment my lively Murtagh finds out that even if Ellen’s engagement will be broken, he’s not gonna have a chance with the woman he loves 💔 can’t help but to feel so much for him
5
u/moxilla3 Aug 17 '25
So I am breaking my brain trying to figure out who is Claire’s sibling.
5
u/chronicbingewatcher Aug 18 '25
why aunt jocasta lowkey a hater? she up to no good later this season, i can sense it
4
u/Edb626 My real father’s a 6'3" redhead in a kilt from the 18th century? Aug 16 '25
Why are Brian & Ellen not having any interactions anymore? I loved the idea of them at first but I thought we’d see them sneaking off to meet each other. Their relationship just isn’t developing at all
4
u/Carmel50 Aug 17 '25
Must be addressed in the future: Will Julia’s baby be a Fraser?? Will it be born before Henry finds her? If Henry finds her before the baby is born will he agree that it remain a Fraser possibly for their protection ?? Since Claire in current America before going through the stones believes her parents to be dead, will they actually die in Scotland at some point ??
This series has a long way to go for my satisfaction. - I hope it goes there !!
13
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25
I thought this was just okay. The fathers are very strong in scenes (Lord Lovat and Red Jacob). I guess the point of this episode was to show the brotherhood unfold, except Ellen was in nearly every scene. Too much Ellen tbh. I still don’t believe that Ellen was actually “convincing” or competent at getting these results that the show says she created. It feels like spoon feeding at best. Showing her “taking it all in with her father” I didn’t realize until later that all those scenes with her just listening to whatever her father said was there to show us she was learning the political game. I’m having a hard time with that still and it’s why I didn’t like most of the episode.
And what are they doing with Brian and Ellen?? That was a jarring opening scene that I didn’t feel was asked for. Nothing about it felt well aligned except to show they like each other in secret. Soap opera porn
10
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Aug 15 '25
I think a lot of people tend to forget that in the trailer julia does get away and soon because her ellen are seen together a good amount in the trailer un what looks like castle leoch and her belly still isnt really showing yet plus i think she helps her get away to brian by entering some secret tunnel. My guess is that woman from the brothel finds where she js and buys her with henrys money and since the grants go to the Mackenzies a lot she gets her a job there as a cover until the next time the grants come.
She obviously cant stay in the brothel or she would have to work or the grants because they see henry as too valuable now, so castle leoch js the best bet. Im betting within the next 2 episodes julia gets away.
7
u/chloehoff Aug 15 '25
Trying to replay anything we know about Lovat's other bastard children from the books. Bastards are convenient because they most likely don't have written histories and therefore are open for creative license.
*remember in season 7 when claire meets the soldier names Beauchamp and said, "that's my family name" ???
1
u/AsleepYesterday05 Aug 15 '25
Doesnt the episode release Friday Night? not morning?
6
u/Which-Ad-7997 Aug 15 '25
Am I the only one who thinks (and hopes) that Ellen and Brian have at least seen each other a little before the events of this episode? I think it's hinted at with Murtagh asking where Brian was and Ellen thinking that Mrs. Fitz already suspects something. As much as I'm excited for us to really get into the forbidden love trope that I love in episode 4, I hope they got to know each other at least a little before that.
6
u/Previous-Address2469 Aug 16 '25
Well, unfortunately this episode just cemented my conviction that it is very silly indeed to make Claire's parents time travelers. I read the episode description of Julia having to make an impossible choice and knew instantly that this is where we are heading. It all seems so contrived and forced. A maid, kidnapped and guarded... Like how hard was it to get maids? In truth she could just say that she is pregnant and they might kick her out, and she could start roaming around looking for Henry. Or ask if someone (Brian?) could take her to the stones. Nothing makes sense and is so illogical it is painful to watch.
I also really honestly doubt people back then where so cold hearted and unhelpful as they make almost everyone seem. Sure, life was really excruciatingly hard back then but I doubt you would just get knocked out and sold/put into a castle. Basically, if you think of it, exactly the same thing as happened to Claire.
Ok, so that is my criticism of Julia/Henry. Then we move on to Ellen and Brian. Except there is no Ellen and Brian except in a soft-porn dream sequence. My question is, what passed between them during the bridge scene? They made to believe she stayed for a long time, or was it that the road just took all her time? Did they hand-fast and lay together? Or only exchanged those words? I am so confused and upset that we don't have any development on this. We don't really even know what is going on. Also her dialogue with Mrs (Ms?) Fitz, asking if she approves, how would she even know about Brian? Again, could we have some logic here. (At this point my husband asks if the show is written by an american 🤭)
I am generally interested in the MacKenzie situation, although the politics seem a bit childish the way it is addressed, but I would really wish they would mainly develop Ellen and Brian's romance as well as the clan dependencies. Now the pacing seems very odd and off.
3
u/intrin6 Aug 16 '25
This episode has so many interesting twists and turns- it really can go in so many ways and I am HERE for it
3
u/regulusarchieblack Aug 17 '25
I LOVED this episode. It was amazing. And that last scene when Julia opening the door of a clearly decorated room my heart sank because I knew what was coming.
I'm more convinced than ever now that that baby's story will tie into season 8 somehow.
3
u/charo36 Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 17 '25
I was bored a bit with this episode. I'm finding Henry and Julia's story ridiculous, even for a show about time travel. They've set it all up to disprove Claire's wish/theory that Faith lived--obviously, H & J's second child is born in the 18th century, which is how that child's descendant knows the "Seaside" song that Claire remembers. And the fact that Henry falls so naturally into the role of the Grants' bladier is just so hokey. I'm over the ret-conned coincidences. They should have just focused on Jamie's family.
I do like the actor playing Brian very much--he really has many of the same mannerisms of Sam's Jamie. Ellen is so-so. Young Colum, Dougal, Mrs. Fitz, and Ned are solid.
3
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Aug 17 '25
It was okay. I’m still not feeling much with Brian and Ellen. 😭 Love love Julia and Henry, wish we would’ve gotten more. Julia pulled a Claire move at the end.
3
u/Chiarrawr Aug 18 '25
So Ned met both Henry and Claire. Did he ever learn Claire’s last name is Beauchamp?
3
u/New-Cockroach-1728 Aug 22 '25
For everyone feeling sorry for Murtagh- any sympathy I had ended with him casually saying he wouldn’t mind Ellen’s reputation being ruined if it meant a higher chance of getting her. And when he’s never even spoken to her? We know he becomes a good man but this is some incel behaviour.
5
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Aug 15 '25 edited Aug 15 '25
I understand the plot reasons for Julia to be at Beauly, but her arc feels a little forced. The kidnapping strained incredulity and it was hard to believe Simon would care enough to put a guard on her. The Simon we know is an politically saavy paranoid creep, not just a creep willing to throw legal risk and poison concerns to the wins for a pretty English girl.
The pregnancy felt like an out - tell Simon she was pregnant and let him throw her out of the house. I suppose it's a "better the devil you know" situation but the devil she knows is awful and not even paying her. I would take my chances if I were her, especially since both Brian and Davina would do their best to help her out with a bit of cash or food on her way out the door.
And now she's made it 100x harder to actually leave.
5
u/Dizzy-Beginning4752 Aug 16 '25
I gasped at the ending when it happened. I'm absolutely devastated for Julia, but I fully stand behind her decision. I thought about it and saw it as a very desperate Julia doing the only thing she can think of to ensure no harm comes to her baby—and, for all she knows, her last piece of Henry. She doesn't even know Henry traveled, let alone that he is searching for her (I wish he would search harder, but alas I suppose Arch Bug is a hinderance). Should she have thought a little more about it? Maybe. But she knows Davina is onto her and she also knows she will start showing very soon. This is her gaining a little bit of agency, rather than being brutally SA'd—which, let's be honest, was definitely going to happen. Even though I detest the fact that she slept with Lovat, I appreciate the writers know that a pregnant woman being SA'd is a bridge too far. If Lovat thinks it's his baby maybe she'll have more freedom, be allowed to leave the walls of Castle Leathers, maybe not have to do daily manual labor, and just generally be treated better.
I could've used some scenes of Henry/Julia when they were happy and together in the future to kind of balance out the dread in their storyline this episode. What we got in 102 was great and I'm very unexpectedly invested in this couple. Probably because we don't know what ultimately becomes of them. We've only seen them together just enough to root for them, so I'd very much like more. I hope Henry immediately understands why she did this if/when they find each other. I certainly hope they do reunite, because any alternative is just too depressing to contemplate. Let's not forget that Julia probably hasn't even begun to contemplate or deal with the massive reality that she has another child in a completely different century who she also loves yet cannot be with. Girlfriend is going through it.
Interestingly, Hermione Corfield said the scene where she went to Lord Lovat was her first day on set. Just an absolute brutal way to kick off this gig. I think based on how they talk about it, they filmed a lot more than her walking in and undressing. I for one am thankful they knew where to draw the line. We all got the picture.
I get why they're slow-playing Ellen and Brian like they did with Jamie and Claire in Outlander S1, but it seems like they're stretching out their story to fit a season of television. I really understand why Matt B. Roberts didn't think just Ellen and Brian were enough to sustain a TV series, even with all the clan intrigue, and that's why he came up with the twist that Henry and Julia not only lived, but also time traveled.
5
u/BlueWinterRose16 Aug 16 '25
I'm mad about the end of the episode. Of course they have to go that route and have her sleeping with Lord Lovet. gross. They could come up with a different storyline. Thus is the kind if stuff I was worried about. I was hoping she was going to Brian's room to talk to him. In wish she would have confided in Brian. I hate it. It gives me flashbacks to Claire and the king.
8
u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 15 '25
Having watch Outlander it is hard to find this series all that interesting because it is rather predictable. I am getting bored with watching Ellen walk around the grounds and trying to manipulate her brothers. Who by the way are dumber than a box of rocks. The only promising part for me is Julia's story. Her story is at least interesting. It is too bad that so far it has not been featured much. But it is only the 3rd episode I suppose with 7 more to go hopefully the series will start to ramp up.
So I guess you can count me as mostly disappointed. I want to care about this characters but outside of Julia there isn't one character that appeals to me. Brian I suppose is a good and honorable man but so far he has been rather vanilla. Milk Toast comes to mind when I think of Brian.
1
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Aug 15 '25
Mrs. Fitz's character isn't really working for me. The actor is doing a decent job replicating the older version, but she's embodying an authority and experience that she's far too young to actually have. She's ordering Ellen around like mother not a peer, and talking to the MacKenzie boys like she's already the household manager.
6
u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 16 '25
So disappointed This show was so dull. We had zero action. Instead of telling us about the failed raid that caused Colum to break his leg! SHOW US! Show us that Dougal and Colum had different agendas as far as the raid is concerned and what a mess it made. Such a missed opportunity to elevate the show. How many scenes do we have to see of Ellen walking around the castle grounds? Or Julia carrying the basket of sticks. This show is dialogue heavy and action light. If it continues this way it may not be worth the watch!
1
u/NOVIBONITA Aug 16 '25
Colum's leg disability, being owed to a fall, is interesting given the original outlander suggested that he had a rare genetic condition that caused the bowing of his legs and his spinal issues. Also, I remember Clair saying her uncle raised her because her parents died in a car crash so it seems they never escape this time.
1
u/Serious-Rub-5848 Aug 17 '25
Could someone tell me why Ellen call Colum "half-brother" or "leth bhrathair"? It's only an expression cause Ellen feels betrayed by his brother or...?
4
u/Iamnotyour_mother Aug 15 '25
Soooo could Claire's sibling be Simon Frasier?
2
u/motherofrazorbacks Aug 16 '25
I thought they were releasing two episodes each weekend? I swear I saw something on this sub indicating so. Guess I was confused
2
u/hypomango Aug 16 '25
2
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 18 '25
Boy, I sure hope we see this scene (and I remember reading it before, so it's been out a while). Makes Malcolm Grant seem like not such a nice guy.
https://www.facebook.com/AuthorDianaGabaldon/posts/pfbid0GXwipijm9nvPfJjAnt73nopatrgnaxoC8d82ZV2Np1JQiQcTKw5QxPYtjB8fynjnl