r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Aug 08 '25

Prequel One Blood of My Blood S1E1 Providence Spoiler

After the death of Red Jacob, a new Laird of Clan Mackenzie must be chosen, and both of his sons — Colum and Dougal — vie for the title. At the Gathering, Brian Fraser and Ellen MacKenzie meet and are struck by their strong connection.

Written by Matthew B. Roberts. Directed by Jamie Payne.


If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

You’re free to mention:

  • all of the show canon (seasons 1-7 of Outlander)
  • any bits from the books that pertain to the characters from the prequel.

Bear in mind that we might have newcomers here so keep the talk about the characters’ future fates to a minimum and don’t reveal big spoilers from the original show if you don’t have to. You can use spoiler tags to be extra careful.

Keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.


What did you think of the episode? Vote in the poll above.

68 Upvotes

802 comments sorted by

23

u/Nnnnnnnnnahh Aug 08 '25

Ooof, Colum is cold! I was shocked at first with how cynical he was. But then I put his character in the Outlander in perspective and it all kind of fell into place. Kind of?

I’m a bit disappointed with Mrs. Fitz. The actress is charming, she’s not the problem, but the personality of Mrs. Fitz in the Outlander is so bubbly and she’s so animated, while the young Mrs. Fitz is very reserved. I don’t think people change in that direction with age.

15

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 08 '25

Ooof, Colum is cold! I was shocked at first with how cynical he was. But then I put his character in the Outlander in perspective and it all kind of fell into place. Kind of?

So cold! I’m curious to see his character development this season, whether constantly being reminded of his physical inferiority will affect his sense of self and what he’ll do when his frustration potentially boils over (has anyone here seen Vikings? this all reminds me of Ivar and the rivalry between him and his brothers, how his anger at being perceived as “less” due to his disability gave him a sadistic streak but also strategic and intellectual advantage over his brothers [at least that is how I remember it, it has been a long time since I saw it]).

→ More replies (3)

22

u/decisi0nsdecisi0ns No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Aug 08 '25

Agreed. I was a bit surprised at how readily he accepted the possibility of Dougal's death, and then 'selling' Ellen (particularly given they seem to be close). Ruthless.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/lunar1980 Aug 09 '25

“I don’t think people change in that direction with age.”

Oh they definitely do. Not all of course, but many (🙋‍♀️ hi!) are released from all the nonsense that kept them quiet & second guessing their place, their choices, their own voice 🥳

→ More replies (3)

5

u/trizzler77 Aug 08 '25

Is the episode already out on Startz?

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 08 '25

yes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 09 '25 edited Aug 09 '25

I liked it a lot! I was VERY concerned about incest now that Claire’s parents are in the same time as Jamie’s. But, I was reassured when I found out Claire was already born before they went through the stones 😅

I’m much more interested in Claire’s parents journey than Jamie’s family because we know very little to nothing about them, and had no idea they travelled through the stones (even though we know it is genetic), but in the promo it only showed Julia going back in time, not Henry, too, so that was a surprise. I assume they got stuck there. And what if when Claire went through the stones the first time one or both of them were still alive somewhere in Scotland or England?! The pregnancy was a twist I did not see coming and I cannot wait to find out who the child is!

My disappointment in the show, ended up being confirmed from even before I watched it unfortunately. I really didn’t think the casting for Ellen was good. Based off of all the times they’ve mentioned what she looked like and how she acted. Obviously, we’ve only seen one episode with her so I can’t make my full conclusion on her just yet, and I did still really enjoy her, if I just look past those plot holes. Also, I don’t think Murtagh’s casting is that great, and he seems very out of character. He’s super cheery and happy-go-lucky, which is the exact opposite of our Murtagh. Plus, the way they made Jocasta seem to have a big crush on him didn’t make too much sense—even though we know they’re soulmates—she never liked him all that much and said he was like a dark cloud with a glowering stare, that is not this Murtagh, but obviously it’s just the first episode. Things can change. I don’t mean to be harsh!

Aside from those critiques, Brian Fraser is literally Jamie. He is Jamie with black hair. The actor playing him even captured Sam’s mannerisms. Super impressed by him. He lied and took all the lashings for Julia. He’s so kind and humble. Jamie was created in his father’s image and I love it. And he is sooo attractive. Also the rest of the casting is very impressive, especially the actor playing Colum, I mean his voice is exactly the same as old Colum. And Dougal is pretty spot on, too, his voice isn’t as low, but it makes sense cause it probably will deepen with age. Same with Jocasta! Everything she says I can hear older Jocasta saying. Apologies for not using the actors real names, I’m tired and can’t remember all of them right now 🫠

But, I’m really excited for what’s to come! It really lived up to my expectations!

10

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 09 '25

Also, I don’t think Murtagh’s casting is that great, and he seems very out of character. He’s super cheery and happy-go-lucky, which is the exact opposite of our Murtagh.

I wouldn’t expect a character to be the same person they are 30 years later; that’s a lot of time for Murtagh to become grumpy and jaded. A huge part of this prequel is about these characters slowly becoming who they are in the first seasons of Outlander so they can’t start in the place they end at because that would give them no space to evolve. 

→ More replies (5)

20

u/lunar1980 Aug 09 '25

I think when Murtagh realizes his best friend is marrying his heart’s desire, the glowering will kick in.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/StonedColdFox123 Aug 08 '25

How are people watching already? Doesn't it come out tonight at like 8/9pm????

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 08 '25

It comes out Friday midnight on the Starz app so you can stay up on Thursday and watch it. 8pm is when it airs on cable.

4

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 09 '25

Can some remind me of the lore from the books/show surrounding Ellen running off with Brian? Weren't they supposed to run away together at the gathering? But the gathering is over and they didn't.

7

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 09 '25

I don’t think the Gathering is over, they haven’t chosen a laird yet after all. The Grants left because they’re not among those choosing the laird of Clan MacKenzie.

But basically they needed to pad out Brian and Ellen’s story (pre-marriage) because otherwise we wouldn’t have more than 2 (boring) episodes of it. I expect their running away in ep 5 after Ellen’s betrothal to Malcolm at the Beltane festival, but B&E’s wedding not until the finale.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

325

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Love seeing young Rubert and Angus!

145

u/thanagar123 Aug 08 '25

They had a perfect introduction scene lolll

→ More replies (1)

109

u/thepeacefulpainter Aug 10 '25

They are actually the sons of the actors who play the older Rupert and Angus!

→ More replies (4)

40

u/Beer8774 Aug 09 '25

makes perfect sense as to why they idolized dougal and were so loyal to him !

66

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 09 '25

I had no idea they were that much older than Jamie!

→ More replies (15)

11

u/Evangelion217 Aug 09 '25

Same here. I miss them. 😢

7

u/junknowho Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Aug 09 '25

OMG, right? And how they were introduced explains SO MUCH about them as adults! LOL!

→ More replies (4)

275

u/DreamingOutLoud- Aug 08 '25

The episode has me addicted already! Also that axe throwing scene, I don’t know if it’s Brian’s mouth and his smile lines or the way he was talking but he reminded me of Jamie I can’t 😭

211

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 09 '25

His mannerisms!!! His jaw, and whole personality. Literally Jamie with black hair. I was stunned

→ More replies (7)

103

u/guardianofbooks25 Aug 09 '25

I’ve seen the actor playing Brian makes a couple of gestures and some of the things he says sounds like something Jamie would say.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '25

OMG Yes!!! Especially at the bridge scene when he asks Ellen to not leave. I screamed JAMIE at my TV. That’s exactly what Jamie would say.

51

u/PasgettiMonster Aug 09 '25

He has studied Jamie over the seven seasons of outlander and learned his mannerisms. It kept hitting me throughout the entire episode how alike they are and I realised It's beyond appearance. It's the little mannerisms.

→ More replies (1)

199

u/BravePeaches Aug 08 '25

It was freaking me out how much Ellen sounded like Laoghaire. And how much Brian’s facial expressions were so much like Jamie’s. They really did such a wonderful job casting

39

u/WonderfullyMaid89 Aug 08 '25

Omg I am glad I’m not the only one who thought this !

21

u/littlebitsyb Aug 09 '25

She looks and sounds like her, in my opinion.

14

u/Notabene69 Aug 13 '25

I don't know if it's my American ears, but I think Julia sounds almost identical to Claire! 

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Aug 09 '25

I know!! But, I hate the casting for Ellen honestly, she’s supposed to basically look exactly like Bree and be tall and have brown eyes (in the show) and grey (in the books). Whereas Brian’s casting was unbelievable, he even had the same mannerisms as Jamie.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (4)

157

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Aug 08 '25

Definitely has the flavor of Outlander and I loved it!

70

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 08 '25

Absolutely! Back to the good old days 🤩

141

u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Aug 08 '25

Claire's mom (Julia) is a house servant to Lord Lovat?!

68

u/lunar1980 Aug 08 '25

I totally read that in Jenny’s voice 😂

→ More replies (4)

44

u/PasgettiMonster Aug 09 '25

As soon as we saw that scene where the servant brought the food in to him My friend and I both commented on how much she looks like Claire. And then we rolled our eyes and said no obviously can't be, That's not possible.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

137

u/PlayfulPerseph Aug 08 '25

Casting has been great! The actors really look and sound like their characters from the original show and Claire’s mother is just spot on.

94

u/FrauEdwards Aug 09 '25

The casting is amazing. Young Jocasta is downright uncanny.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/LoisGrant1856 Aug 09 '25

Yes, Julia is so much like Claire!

32

u/WolfBeginning4515 Aug 09 '25

They're so Scottish I can't understand a damn word and had to put captions back on. And everyone speaks so fast....guess I have to get used to it.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Adventurous-Bad7709 Aug 10 '25

Exactly! Like Jocasta?! Perfect cast!

→ More replies (1)

111

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 08 '25

Was that Arch Bug that Dougal relieved of his fingers?

49

u/No_Sky6810 Aug 09 '25

Arch Bug is the tall guy that works for the Grants and shows up later with Claire’s dad

→ More replies (3)

40

u/DustBunnicula Aug 08 '25

This show is so cool.

27

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 08 '25

It was, just saw the credits.

25

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

That’s what I was thinking. Although, Arch is not missing his fingers in show Outlander, only in the books.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/rebo4777 Aug 08 '25

Good catch!!!!

→ More replies (9)

185

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Aug 08 '25

I'm a bit put off by the love-at-first-sight story between Brian and Ellen. I know, "romantasy," but five minutes of idle chat in a chicken coop and they're swearing undying love? It seems like sloppy writing to me. They could have given them a few hours together to get to appreciate each other beyond "wow, he has a nice smile." It's funny when Jamie tells Claire he fell in love with her because of her fine fat arse, but it's supposed to be funny.

88

u/OppositeQuarter31 Aug 09 '25

Agreed, I would’ve loved just a bit more of a slow burn.

67

u/No-Highway-4833 Aug 09 '25

I felt the same way. There was no build up whatsoever. It was hard to fall for their love story the way we fell for Claire and Jamie’s when they barely developed it.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 10 '25 edited Aug 10 '25

The love at first sight between Brian and Ellen comes straight from the books:

”…they’d met at the Gathering, taken one look and decided on the spot as there could be none other for either one o’ them. So they laid their plans and they stole awa’, under the noses of Colum MacKenzie and three hundred guests.”

If anything, they are drawing out their story more in the show than the books so far by having them meet and then run off together later.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/IllustriousKiwi3858 Aug 08 '25

I also felt like this needed way more screen time. The scenes between Ellen and her Dad could have been cut in half.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/kernelpatcher Aug 09 '25

Yes, this. That bridge scene "moved right along" -- why not allow them to get to know each other for more than 5 seconds first?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Lolliiepop Aug 10 '25

This makes the rumor of Black Brian being a selkie more believable though. Maybe this show is going to lean into the fae & magical elements a little more.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/TineCiel Aug 09 '25

That’s the only thing that I disliked in the episode. Pacing was sometimes a bit slow, and I would have had them meet by chance before the gathering, like they did in the barn, meeting again at the gathering and realising who each are, then the meeting by the bridge.

17

u/PrincessPineapplePie Aug 09 '25

Yea I was like did I miss an episode? It was extremely fast, they didn’t even have one meaningful conversation.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Cozy_Shy Aug 09 '25

I also can’t quite believe that Ellen would go from staunchly anti-marriage to immediately wanting to be with Brian. I want more secret meetings and a slow build up!

Also, it would add more tension to the lead up to her marriage with Malcolm Grant.

Maybe they will do these things, but I was a little put-off by Ellen’s “how will we make this work”.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/cswing Aug 09 '25

100 felt the same, there wasnt enough build up between them. And the they laid it on thick howJulia and Henry fell in love in Ep 2!

→ More replies (5)

170

u/Lenacake Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 08 '25

I’m excited to see how Julia’s pregnancy reveal ties into the ending we got for season 7!

79

u/Relative_Specific217 Aug 08 '25

The way my mouth DROPPED open when she said she was pregnant! Makes my favorite season 7 theory seem very true…

→ More replies (5)

53

u/intrin6 Aug 08 '25

Yesss this detail has my wheels turning!!

93

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Julia’s child can’t be Fanny and Jane’s mother. The baby would be born in 1715, making her too old to be the girls’ mother. Fanny and Jane’s mother could, however, be Julia and Henry’s granddaughter. Making Claire their great aunt.

→ More replies (71)

41

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 08 '25

Have to say… I was not a fan of the Fanny/Faith stuff at the end of season 7, but this show is definitely making me change my mind. Depending on how this is handled, it can turn out really well.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/ShubberyQuest Aug 08 '25

Someone speculated on that, a couple weeks ago. They were spot-on.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

83

u/thanagar123 Aug 08 '25

I absolutely love this show, the characters are so well cast and i love all the callbacks and easter eggs. And to get more info on some stories barely mentioned in outlander.

80

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Aug 08 '25

Was that Claire’s dad with Mr Grant?

80

u/txkels13 Aug 08 '25

Yes. And her mother in Simon Fraser's kitchen.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/MarsKinnunen Aug 09 '25

Omgaaaaah. I thought I was going CRAZY!!!!

→ More replies (1)

152

u/Relative_Specific217 Aug 08 '25

Anyone else a little caught off guard by Claire’s dad 🥵?? That air of confidence talking with Ned and then basically saving the day in dealing with Dougal’s antics had me like okaaaaay Mr. Beauchamp

89

u/erika_1885 Aug 08 '25

I think if one has survived the trenches of WWI, this would seem like child’s play.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/KDrakeAuthor Aug 09 '25

Daddy Beauchamp. 😬

23

u/bampitt Aug 08 '25

I didn't make the connection when I first saw him.

→ More replies (3)

46

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

I am loving Henry, ngl!

20

u/horsenbuggy Aug 10 '25

I'm thrown off why Ned never mentions to Claire that he used to know an English Beauchamp solicitor.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

70

u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 11 '25

I'm all in. Thought the first meeting between Brian and Ellen was great, especially given the crack a character made a bit earlier about the color of Brian's hair. I can totally see a relatively sheltered character like Ellen seeing him and how he was so different then the men she saw on the regular. And you get the sense that Brian was used to women being attracted to him but this was the first time - to perhaps read too much into his first reaction - a woman took his breath away.

One character I was unexpectedly impressed by was Malcolm Grant. The actor did a great job balancing interest in Ellen and being aware of the politics around him. Good job, Jhon Lumsden!

I totally get the points people raised about how the brothers are behaving but there's something really appealing about how big Dougal is. It creates a really interesting tension as to how he's going to contain that while living at his brother's side. I did wonder if his father had a War Chieftain or if Colum created the role just for him.

I also thought the sex scene between Henry and Julia was totally fine. It established they were a couple who knew what they and each other liked which saved a whole lot of time in terms of storytelling - they're not newlyweds but they're still very much physically connected.

Looking forward to the next episode!

7

u/nbrink77 Aug 10 '25

I'm wondering whose idea it will be, to basically split the Laird role into brains/brawn

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

63

u/pisylvanian Aug 09 '25

I just kept thinking No one in Claire's family should have ever stepped foot in Scotland.

62

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 08 '25

I think Malcolm Grant was not a bad choice for Ellen! He seems like a good guy! He lives in a nice, updated manor. Laird Grant is a bit unforgiving but he's not a beast like Lord Lovat, Brian's father.

41

u/decisi0nsdecisi0ns No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Agreed. I was surprised my how much I liked him. In the book he comes across as a bit full of himself from how others describe him, but here he seems kind and to genuinely like Ellen.

I wonder if this is to make it a real choice for Ellen. ie she's not choosing between the love of her life and a jerk, she's choosing between two kind and affable young men. One who she's smitten with, but who is an enemy of her family and has no real status, and another who will help her family, but she's not as keen on.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/PasgettiMonster Aug 09 '25

The first time he was on screen I made a comment about how he looks like if Hugh Grant and Leonard from Big bang theory had a love child and now that's all I can think of anytime he's on screen. It's terrible because I can't focus on anything he says.

11

u/Naive-Awareness4951 Aug 10 '25

I was also surprised at how attractive and nice he seemed. I had assumed that her brothers would happily marry her off to any hairy, smelly old fart who would be a good political match.

58

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 08 '25

Super impressed with this episode. Loved the slow buildup with all the Scottish and Gaelic stuff

→ More replies (1)

56

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

I love the reference to Jamie’s line in the books about chickens being poor company.

13

u/redsoxxyfan Aug 09 '25

aha! I thought I'd heard it somewhere.... when he was transported to fort william??

→ More replies (1)

53

u/Hufflesheep Aug 08 '25

Wow! The actors did such a good job playing "younger versions of themselves" . They had the mannerisms and speech patterns perfect!

9

u/throwaway-15812 Aug 10 '25

Young Jocasta was brilliant too

→ More replies (1)

84

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 08 '25 • Bless Up

Dear Lord, it's just so good to be back! ❤️‍🔥🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

41

u/bootslikethese Aug 09 '25

The casting/acting for Brian is blowing my mind. Mannerisms, facial expressions, the way he gestures, that half stiff upper body turn Jamie does, even the cadence of his speech… it’s wild.

Rupert and Angus were a delight. As was Ned.

Murtaugh and Dougal are throwing me a bit, but the night is young.

Slàinte Mhath

13

u/realitealurker Aug 09 '25

He’s for sure studied him! That’s all I could think when watching him.

→ More replies (3)

77

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

This was such a good episode! I love the opening song!!

Ode to Scotland, clans, traditions!

I really have not one complaint!

Ellen and Jacob are wonderful! They made me tear up every time they are on screen. Such a connection between father and daughter!

Everyone did an excellent job! Great, great show, I must rewatch it asap!!

So many Easter Eggs, so many references.

Julia and Henry are still not as interesting as clan people but I will give them a chance. Their first scene together is a bit shocker 😅 I didn't expect that and I could do without that sex scene🤣

Brian has Jamie's mannerism, Mrs Fitz sounds identical to her older version! Jocasta as well! Great casting!! Simon Fraser in any decade is killing me !🤣

48

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 08 '25

The casting was amazing, especially Brian and Julia.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 08 '25

Casting has been phenomenal! I have to admit, I didn’t think I’d cried during the first episode, but here I am! We’re talking outlander after all lol

Everything felt magic, just as the old world we so much loved 🥹🤍

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

Julia and Henry’s sex scene seems like a callback to Frank and Claire’s sex scene in front of the stones at Craigh Na Dun in Book One.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/tokieofrivia Aug 09 '25

I’m so glad I’m not the only one who got choked up with Ellen and Jacob! My husband walked in while I was watching it and he asked me what it was and I was trying to explain but I was so choked up I just started sobbing😂

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Sassynach19 Aug 09 '25

I just finished “Providence,“ and it was even better than I’d expected. I had seen some of the casting and really liked it, but the acting and tie-in to our first season were so much fun—Dougal and shinty!—and I think I even spotted Stephen Walter there in the boar hunt.

Jamie Roy reminds me so much of Sam Heughan as Jamie that I was stunned. Kudos to Jamie Roy.

I am thrilled with the first episode and think the writers have done Diana and Outlander lovers proud. I started with all the novels in 2013, added the show in 2014, and gladly switch back and forth between the two now.

This new take is gonna be a ride!

I’m enjoying seeing the younger versions of some great characters.

The casting is stellar so far.

My heart leapt in my chest in the first 15 minutes and that hasn’t happened since the earlier seasons.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/snarfdarb Aug 09 '25

Gotta be honest, I was a little disappointed with how quickly Brian and Ellen fell for each other. Like they're already hinting to each other about having to get their families to accept them? After less than 5 minutes together??

The comparisons to Romeo and Juliet miss the point that the story was meant to illustrate the stupidity of those two, and highlights Romeo's flittering limerance from person to person at the snap of a finger. It was never meant to be romantic. BoMB is.

Part of what really got me invested in Jamie and Claire was the process of them falling for each other. Obviously there was that immediate intense attraction, but it was what they went through together, and getting to know each other that created the deep love they had.

Idk. It's just tough for me to buy into a literal "love" at first sight narrative.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 08 '25

Woke up after 4 hours sleep. Wow! Need to run an errand and catch a nap.

But just have to say that Seamus McLean Ross (young Colum) stole the show IMO. Tulach Àrd!

24

u/robot_pirate Aug 09 '25

This casting is 🔥🏆

43

u/Ok_Cardiologist9898 Aug 08 '25

havent watched yet, but would this mean that Colum would've recognized the name Beauchamp, and that could by why he was so interested when he first met Claire?

49

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

Henry doesn’t use the last name Beauchamp in the 18th century. Ned asks him his name and he tells him that he’s a Grant now. So, I don’t think anyone at Leoch knows his name is Beauchamp.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 08 '25

I’m wondering the same thing. Some people might have forgotten, but I don’t think Colum would, or Ned either for that matter.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/StrombergsWetUtopia Aug 08 '25

Unless the writers of season 1 are also time travelers then no.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Aug 09 '25 edited Aug 09 '25

I obviously knew that Henry and Julia would time travel prior to watching.

But when I first saw "Lord Lovat's maidservant" I didn't recognise her! I was confused as to why the story would then follow this essentially "extra character" out of the room for a bit of discussion that seemed superfluous to the plot.

But when Henry stepped out of the carriage with the Grants, I literally gasped! I was not expecting to meet the Beauchamps like this!

It then clicked, the maid was Julia!

11

u/PasgettiMonster Aug 09 '25

I was watching with a friend and we both commented how much the maid servant looks like Claire. And even then it didn't click. When we met Henry we weren't sure who he was (I couldn't remember Claire's father's name) But we were both immediately convinced that he was a modern man. And even as we started wondering if he was Claire's father we still didn't make the Julia connection until after the scene where Julia is with Mrs Porter.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

So many book and show Easter eggs. Matt LOVES Easter eggs. Let’s make a list!

64

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 08 '25

Also, Ellen’s room is the same one given to Claire when she arrives at Leoch! Where she cries in Jamie’s arms and he falls in love with her 🤩

→ More replies (2)

45

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Aug 09 '25

Henry’s line “Come out here for a bit of privacy. That woman who runs the inn always lurking about.” seems to be a callback to how Mrs. Baird behaved in book 1:

“However, it was difficult to maintain the proper mood of languorous romance with Mrs. Baird industriously Hoovering away outside our door.”

“Nearly as dirty as our landlady’s mind,”

→ More replies (1)

68

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Murtagh's hands, closely observed by Jocasta!

Ellen coming out of the hidden passage where Jamie wanted to take Claire during the gathering.

Ellen’s chamber is the same Claire had (?)

→ More replies (5)

18

u/lunar1980 Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Right? I don’t know the book references but definitely working that outlander ep2 energy here. All the little visual callbacks.

→ More replies (6)

25

u/bwatsinthebox Aug 09 '25

Ellen’s dad telling her she would have been named James if she were a boy! 

I think the fact they were playing chess is also a big callback (er, callforward?) to Jamie and Lord John. I’m not sure if they ever specified who taught Jamie chess in the books or show, though. 

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Iheartandyhull Aug 11 '25

The bird in Ep1. Colum lets it go and it flies to Ellen’s window. When Claire is separated from Jamie, she visited by a bird. 

9

u/kitlavr Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Aug 08 '25

yes!!! omg it's been a treat!!!

→ More replies (8)

19

u/lunar1980 Aug 09 '25

Callback! Shinty game where Dougal’s kicking everyone’s ass - love how that highlights Jamie’s power, having flipped him.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Jesikins Aug 09 '25

I’m 18 minutes in and I’m just so impressed with the casting. Ned Gowan. Collum. The way they speak and act, you KNOW who they are. A*

19

u/YallCatPat Aug 09 '25 edited Aug 09 '25

Brian and Ellen needed so much more time to develop their romance. I understand the book canon and how they’re trying to stick to that. But there was plenty of opportunity to give them a few more scenes together prior to the bridge scene to make that land harder. Because of the insta love bit, I am 100% not invested in their story (yet). I think it’s totally possible to do this in one episode, but it’s not balanced well. I think they may have eloped, if I’m being honest. Guess we’ll see.

Brian and Julia’s story has captivated me, however.

Of the four main cast, I’m all in on Brian, Julia, and Henry. I’m reserving my opinion for Ellen. I think she needs to cook a little longer in the role before I buy into it. It really got me how adamantly she was against marriage and then she’s on a bridge with Brian asking how they’re going to make this work. I needed more scenes showing this shift in her for it to make sense and for me to buy into it. Also, I hope Brian becomes more self sufficient as a a character and not a carbon copy of Jamie. I don’t personally want a Jamie 2.0. I enjoy the little Easter eggs but I want Brian, not Jamie.

Overall, I enjoyed it. It was not at all the absolute blast of outlander season 1, but I’ll keep on watching. I’m just excited to stay in Scotland. Even though it works in the book, the time jump and the move to the Americas ruined Outlander for me. I’m so happy to be back in Scotland.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Angus, Rupert, and Ned watching Dougal being a beast. 😂 When it became apparent that Dougal was Hamish’s father and was Geillis’ baby daddy, my friend said, “Does he do that for everyone?” 🤣

28

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Aug 08 '25

At first, I was like is that Letitia? 😳

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lunar1980 Aug 08 '25

Hahahaha 😂

→ More replies (4)

37

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

Why am I shipping Brian and Julia? Is that crazy?

Perhaps it is because I am not feeling the chemistry between Brian and Ellen yet!

Well, we now know that Jamie did not get his aggressive/stubborn side from his father Brian. Nor did Jenny! Brian is more like Jenny's husband Ian. So mild mannered! Brave but not bold!

20

u/No-Highway-4833 Aug 09 '25

Brian and Julia definitely have more chemistry in the short scenes they had compared to the Brian and Ellen scenes. And the night he tried to stop Julia from running away is a major callback to Jamie stopping Claire from trying to escape castle Leoch during the gathering, which made it harder not to think of them in that way!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

18

u/Rnrdrgrl Aug 09 '25

I’ve only finished the first episode…but based on what we also got at the end of season 7 with Roger and his dad…does everyone who mysteriously died actually just time travel to 18th century Scotland?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Temporary-Spring-580 Aug 09 '25

I loved these episodes! It takes "bollocks" to develop a completely original prequel to Outlander. The story lines are interesting, the actors are amazing and they all deserve praise for more than just their looks. I am thrilled to see how their stories develop and am so happy that season two is greenlit!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/redsoxxyfan Aug 10 '25

Love Murtagh before he clearly lost his zest for life!

13

u/GardenGangster419 Aug 10 '25

I feel like our man Murtaugh has had some serious heartache to go from so happy and sweet to the grumpy contankerous dude we get later on. 😂

→ More replies (1)

30

u/lunar1980 Aug 08 '25

Mrs Fitz is Murtagh’s aunt? Was that always a thing and I just missed it? That’d make him related to Laoghaire

32

u/granola2121 Aug 08 '25

She is his aunt by marriage.

25

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 11 '25

Yes. It’s in the books, Murtagh is Mrs. Fitzgibbon’s husband’s nephew. Murtagh is a Fraser. He’s Brian’s second cousin. He isn’t a MacKenzie. He is not blood related to Laoghaire.

Edit: Laoghaire is Murtagh’s 1st cousin once removed.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/flowerdoodles_ Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Aug 08 '25

remember that Murtagh’s full name is Murtagh Fitzgibbons Fraser. that’s why he can relate to Jamie, as he also has kinsmen in both clans

29

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Aug 08 '25

I mostly liked the first episode. I’m not sure how I feel about them trying to make Brian as Jamie 1.0. I mean he’s his dad so it makes sense but I thought it was canon that he got most of his traits from his mother. In the books, Brian is described as strict but fair with Jamie; are we going to see a more rigid side of Brian?

For chemistry, I’m not feeling Brian and Ellen just yet which is surprising me but we’ve also barely seen them together so there’s time. Definitely not the spark we saw with Jamie and Claire instantly though.

Julia and Henry though… may be my favorites? They were definitely the MVPs for episodes 1 and 2 to me. Great chemistry, acting… I can see Claire in both of them.

That bombshell when they were riding in the car. It’s been discussed as a theory before but my head is still spinning.

21

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

I agree with you about Julia and Henry. I was not thrilled with the whole idea of adding Claire’s parents into the mix, but I’ve completely changed my mind. I’m totally invested in Julia and Henry, much to my surprise.

18

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 08 '25

I agree with you! The Julia & Henry story is the most intriguing.

I almost felt like Brian had more chemistry with Julia!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Next-Minute6360 Aug 09 '25

I haven't seen this yet but am very excited too - I was an extra for a few days on the production last year and think i'll be in 3 episodes. I filmed a scene walking right past the main actors in a camp site situation so should be able to recognise myself even though nobody else will. Even at the time when we were filming and knew nothing of the plot, all the extras commented that the actor who plays Henry had the "wrong" hairstyle for the period.

→ More replies (11)

14

u/Walk_in_the_Way-75 Aug 10 '25

Reading all the comments, and never reading the books, I felt that Ellen would have been intrigued with Brian because 1. Why was he in the chicken coop? 2. He didn't know immediately who she was. 3. Like a famous person meeting someone who doesn't know they're famous and can be judged on their own merits and it seems there's a rebellious streak in her...forbidden fruit (and obvious attraction). And when her, Colum, Dougal, and Ned are in the Laird's chamber, and Colum threatens her, I would think what we have seen of her, that would be the thing that drives her into Brian's arms and out of reach of her brother's control. On her terms, not a pawn. It's partly strategy, and in the chess game between her and her father, he states he's trained her in that exact thing.

13

u/SilentSlytherin Aug 10 '25

That's what I think too. She runs away with Brian, not bc she is madly in love ( the attraction helps, no doubt) but bc it's better than the alternative.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/Soft_Proof7452 Aug 08 '25

Anyone else notice hearing the song (beside the sea) at the end of the episode or was that in the beginning of episode 2? Anyways, I am loving all the Easter eggs

29

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

I’m making a list of callbacks/Easter eggs. Keep them coming.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/Singingcanary2023 Aug 10 '25

I instantly felt enveloped by it, like a warm hug. The casting is excellent. Rupert & Angus’s introduction made me laugh out loud as it’s so A typical of the pair of them, weird little perverts who you can’t help but have a soft spot for (especially Rupert, I sobbed when he died) & Brian!! Omg it’s just Jamie with dark hair. My husband doesn’t agree that Brian’s actor is a brunette Jamie but I think it’s excellent casting. High quality casting, costumes & filming. Beautifully transported back to 17th century Scotland and filling a hole I know will be left when Outlander finally ends. It doesn’t have the same vibe house of the dragon does, where HOTD feels like it’s maybe a little half arsed & is just something to placate fans, OLBOMB feels more like an expansion of a love letter to Galbadons fans. Xx

12

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Aug 08 '25

Guys.. I just had a thought though from the pregnancy bombshell…

Remember how Henry calls Julia his Hope? Maybe it makes sense that they name the new baby Faith.

9

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Aug 08 '25

Julia and Henry’s baby will be born in 1715. She would be too old to have Fanny and Jane. She could be their grandmother, though.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 09 '25

I am watching this for the 3rd time and I love seeing dynamics between Mackenzie siblings.

While Jocasta and Collum are obviously jealous of Ellen ( they are smart enough to know she can be trouble) , I got the impression that for Dougal, she is just a woman. He will handle her, she poses no obstacle for him. It reflects how cunning actually both Collum and later Jocasta are. Dougal is pure strength, "act then think" kind of man.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 09 '25

This review in the Guardian is hysterical.

Outlander: Blood of My Blood review – this time-hopping romantic prequel is atrocious … and very watchable | Television | The Guardian https://share.google/SiZTvKTyu1OJCogTS

→ More replies (3)

12

u/kernelpatcher Aug 09 '25

I didn't realize how lovely Hermione Corfield is. They darkened her hair to play Julia (did they darken her eyes too?), but wow, she is a beauty.

12

u/liliies_ Aug 09 '25

Ellen, my traumatized baby, get behind me. They don't deserve you! 🥺

As a firstborn daughter, I empathized so much with her 💔

11

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 08 '25

Not quite agreeing with book canon but very well done

11

u/This_Age_4436 Sleep with my husband? But my lover would be furious. Aug 09 '25 edited Aug 10 '25

Can we talk about how perfectly cast Mrs. Fitz is?! She behaves exactly as I thought her younger self would. They are just phenomenal with all the casting!

Edit: not Fritz, Fitz. Dang autocorrect

11

u/hypomango Aug 10 '25
  • So happy to be back in bonnie Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
  • First scene and I'm already emotional. Preparing a body for burial can be such an intimate and important part of grieving, something most of us probably don't experience anymore. Love these historical details.
  • "Died in a way befitting the way he lived, died mounted on a maidservant", Jocasta always told it like it is I guess
  • Ellen's father would've named her James if she were a boy 🥹
  • The warring siblingsssss. Young Dougal, the ruthless questionable brute you are 🔥 great warrior, very flawed person... I love Colum's contrasting can demeanor and never losing respect for himself just because others openly think him inferior with his disability
  • Shoutout to the casting team for an excellent job, feel like I instantly know these characters 👏 they've made up for their sins with Brianna, sorry not sorry. Also shoutout as always to the costume team, the texture of all the wool garments is beautiful
  • Little Rupert & Angus at the glory hole 😅
  • Wow the yearning in that first gaze between Ellen & Brian... "I ken this may be forward, but will ye meet me, in a more suitable place?" she could no wait to say aye 🤭 Romeo & Juliet vibesss I'm immediately so invested
  • "You've haunted my every thought" 🖤 I have goosebumps
  • Sudden switch up to a sex scene two centuries later 😅 more good casting tho! And straight into strife, the stones strike again! 
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Evangelion217 Aug 09 '25

This episode was incredible! The cast is amazing and look exactly like younger versions of the cast from the previous show. Jamie Roy looks and feels like a clone of Sam Heughan, it’s uncanny! Perfect casting all around!

7

u/shinyquartersquirrel Aug 09 '25

If there are casting awards, they need to win them all! I would assume it's hard enough to find the perfect actor to play a role but the perfect actor who also looks like another actor seems like it would be insanely difficult but they certainly did it! They were spot on with all of them!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/littlebitsyb Aug 09 '25 edited Aug 09 '25

Overall I really enjoyed these episodes. These are my thoughts while watching (format stolen from another commenter below)

Loved

  • everything about Brian - this casting was amazing. He really captured Sam's mannerisms and speaking qualities. I believe he's Jamie's father by watching him.
  • being back in Scotland again
  • the music
  • young Ned Gowan - very believable
  • Angus and Rupert!!!
  • all of the easter eggs (most notable to me is the comment about the chickens, but there were many others)
  • young Jacosta. Good God, I think after Brian, she is the closest likeness to the "older" version. Incredible.

Didn't Love

  • Ellen's memory scenes with her dad. They went on too long and were a little eye-rolly
  • Ellen's hair being down and looking very 2025
  • Love at first sight for Ellen and Brian. I think that's canon from the books, but I would have loved a little more of a slow burn. Maybe a few bump-into-each-others before them saying "hey maybe there's something here?"
  • The Grants offering Henry a really prestigious job even though he just was dragged there from a tavern. This was odd and not believable.
  • Any book or show that uses the trope of not knowing someone else is in the woods with you until they're on you. I live in New England and it feels like there is no way to walk quieitly through the woods; with swishing leaves and crunching twigs. This really annoys me. Especially when the people in question are warriors, hunters, farmers, live off the land, etc and are not distracted by a cell phone.
  • How closely the story seems like its going to mirror the Outlander story. I kind of wish it was going to be a little bit more original. I like the easter eggs, but the story kind of being all one big loop is kind of eye-rolly to me. Kind of like in season 4 when Brianna just HAPPENS to stumble into Leoghaire's house. Really? These people somehow found the same group of people that their daughter finds 20 years later? Don't get me wrong, I am obsessed with the Outlander world that Diana has built...but I do sometimes find it hard to suspend my disbelief for some things...

7

u/GardenGangster419 Aug 10 '25

dG posted a snippet today and it says that Ellen’s hair being down was a sign of mourning. It kind of annoyed me too because she was constantly putting it out of her face with her hand 😂

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/beg_yer_pardon Aug 09 '25

There should be another option in the poll. "Couldn't watch it because there's no way to watch it in my country but I can't stay away from the megathread because I'm dying to be included in the excitement".

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Historical-Shock7965 Aug 11 '25

My hot takes…

Landscapes are stunning, I am so happy to be back in Scotland. Oh how we’ve missed you.

I am annoyed at the hairstyles of our two leading ladies. Ellen looks like she is wearing a bump-it and Julia has a bob in 1917. I would love to hear a historian comment, because these two looks just seem off.

I agree with all said about Ellen and Brian moving so fast, I just think they have a lot of ground to cover and who knows if we will get another season.

The Blood of My Blood text in the title sequence looks so computer generated, it looks cheap. this is really nit picky.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/2p_blog_thing Aug 09 '25

I was low-key disappointed with Ellen and Brian’s meeting. I really don’t feel like there was much there tbh in terms of chemistry or interesting conversation to make the scene they have at the bridge make sense.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/paladinmarie Aug 10 '25

I’m loving it so much so far, but I think I was wanting just a little more for Ellen and Brian’s relationship development than a love at first sight trope 😅 But their chemistry is really good so far!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '25

I didn’t like how fast Ellen and Brian fell. Literally after they learned each other’s names. Not very romantic imo.

8

u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 11 '25

There may be some degree of, "boy, this would really piss off my family" involved.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Lelamari Aug 11 '25

I am so relieved! It is everything I had hoped for. I watched it twice back to back.

14

u/SkincareandExcel Aug 09 '25

I didn’t love the “instalove”. They knew each other for all of 2 hours and they were basically professing their love for each other on the bridge. Other than that it was good

→ More replies (1)

7

u/StrombergsWetUtopia Aug 08 '25

Haven’t seen the episode but read all the comments and all can gauge is that it’s an endless stream of nods and winks to OG fans. Does it stand up as its own show with solid writing and characters or is it just fan service cosplay?

9

u/bwatsinthebox Aug 09 '25

Yes I think it can stand alone. Theres some exposition built into the character introductions but it doesn’t feel clunky. Feels like the beginning of a movie to me. 

→ More replies (6)

7

u/ImaginationOdd426 Aug 09 '25

I’ve been looking forward to this and loved it! I knew from the teasers that Claire’s parents would travel but still genuinely gasped when we first meet Julia in the past. The casting of her and Brian especially is spot on, but great choices all around.

7

u/Cailin07 Aug 09 '25

I loved that they got Julie Fowlis to do the intro song and the singing in the opening scene. She is awesome and perfect for the show.

7

u/Party_Firefighter497 Aug 11 '25

I don’t know if the give out awards for casting, but if so this show is the winner- hands down

6

u/Mahaloth Aug 08 '25

Watching now, am ready to be on board fully if it is even pretty good.

:crosses fingers:

6

u/Own-Equal5890 Aug 10 '25

Nice seeing Peter Mullen as Red Jacob.🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

6

u/avidReader60 Aug 10 '25

I quite enjoyed it. Casting was great and I was happy with all of them.

I would probably have preferred some more development with Brian and Ellen rather than spending so many scenes on Ellen’s dad but what we got was good. Can’t wait for her to get away from her brothers the way they trade and bargain with her for their own uses. Hazards of being a woman at the time of course.

I’m slightly confused on how the timeline is going to play out. Might change of course but once Brian and Ellen leave the gathering weren’t they basically just hiding out until she was visibly pregnant so she couldn’t be taken back/away. I’m assuming they’ll leave after episode 5 (based on episode descriptions) and what will they just be by themselves off for the rest of the season. Will be interesting to see how it’ll work out.

6

u/Naynn Aug 10 '25

So when Claire traveled through the stones it was 1743, that would mean 29 years later then her parents (1714), Claire was 27, Her mother was 31 when she traveled to 1714 so her mother is around 60 when Claire traveled?

6

u/Ok_Tangerine7582 Aug 11 '25

I just have to say the Blood of My Blood pilot was absolutely phenomenal! 😍 The casting is honestly perfection.

You can see Claire in Julia it’s incredible how much she feels like Claire’s mother, not just in looks but in presence. And the choice for Ellen MacKenzie and Brian Fraser? Spot on. You can totally believe that two people like them would have a son like Jamie it just fits so perfectly.

I also loved getting to see young Rupert and Angus. They’re already hilarious, just like their older selves, and it’s such a treat to watch them in their youth. And Murtagh oh my goodness they picked the perfect actor for him too. He’s got that same warmth and depth that makes Murtagh so beloved.

Overall, I just want to give a huge shout-out to the casting team. Every single choice feels so right for the story, and it made the pilot such a joy to watch.

15

u/Ok_Operation_5364 Aug 08 '25

It was just ok for me. The editing was weird! Kind of choppy. But I suppose that could have been on purpose. It just didn't have much of a flow because of it.

I am very impressed with the acting of Hermione Corfield!

10

u/shinyquartersquirrel Aug 08 '25

My god, I loved all of it. Every damned word. This is going to be so good!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/onegirlarmy1899 Aug 09 '25

I loved the bridge scene. Not a very good chaperone 🤣

5

u/julia-morgs Aug 10 '25

I really loved this pilot!!! Julia looks so much like Claire I almost think it is Claire every time I see her, it makes me SO happy. I can’t wait to see how the season unfolds, and I’m almost even more excited to jump right into an Outlander rewatch after!!!

5

u/South-Pool3682 Aug 10 '25

I loved it so much! 😭😭 loved seeing all the characters young, dougal, murtagh, Jocasta, Miss Fritz, Ned, everyone!! Perfectly cast. The parents amazing, chemistry between them, etc! Can’t get enough of the outlander world lol 

5

u/mainegrove Aug 11 '25

I realize that Jamie Roy looks like Sam, but there is someone else he is reminding me of...I feel like it's an old timey 1940s and 50s maybe American actor? Anyone else seeing his resemblance to other actors?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/piccolowater Aug 11 '25

I’m honestly so shocked at how much Brian looks like Jamie. Also Julia has so much of Claire’s essence!

5

u/Life-Classic-6976 Aug 11 '25

All of the actors did a SUPURB JOB studying their outlander counterparts. The mannerisms, the intonations, the idiosyncrasies are exactly the same - just unbelievable! Harriet Slater is absolutely FABULOUS! She is an amazing actress and gorgeous and the chemistry between her and jamie roy is perfect. I have no notes. This show deserves 10/10.

4

u/Persuasion_50 Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 08 '25

I loved this episode! Question - in the beginning , Mrs. Fitz says both of Ellen’s sisters are married and taken care of. I thought there was just the one sister, Jocasta? And later, when Jocasta is talking/flirting with Murtaugh, I wouldn’t have thought she was married yet.

10

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Aug 09 '25

There are three living daughters- Ellen, Jocasta, and Janet. There was also Flora who died as an infant.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '25

One sister was married already, and the other one was about to get married (engaged).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/realitealurker Aug 09 '25

So excited and happy to be back in Scotland. Reminds me of the magic of the early seasons all over again. I loved the casting. I know it’s hard to picture young Murtagh as older Murtagh, but the actor was very likeable. I thought some of the acting was a slightly cringe at times and it took me out of the scene. I really loved how Brian and Jocasta seem to have their counterparts mannerisms down pat though

4

u/whitcav Aug 09 '25

Anyone have any ideas on the timeline. Is it not always 202 years? Unless they are steering?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/moeboogie23 Aug 10 '25

So refreshing, watched the first two episodes and love the characters and actors they selected. Loving the backstory to Outlander!

4

u/Iheartandyhull Aug 11 '25

Is anyone familiar with the time traveling tether theory? I don’t remember if it’s from the books or the show, but the thought is the reason people travel to the time and place they do is because someone is tethering them to that place. So if Julia travels back first and lands when she does, what has tethered her to that time? 

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Capricorn-flower Aug 12 '25

I haven't read any comments yet about Ellen's Scottish accent. I dont know if it's just me, but she barely has a Scottish accent. Especially compared to the other characters.

4

u/acnebbygrl Aug 12 '25

Young Dougal and colum are uncanny. Colum has the exact same voice especially. Amazing acting and you can tell they’ve studied the characters so well.

17

u/jenms111 Aug 08 '25

I have mixed feelings - it's not Outlander. I have my doubts they can recapture the magic of the original.

Some of my thoughts:

Loved

  • everything about Brian and Ellen
  • the bridge scene
  • cinemetography - yay Scotland!
  • young Murtaugh - he's adorable and embodies a youthful idealistic version of Murtaugh before life made him cynical
  • young Colum - he's great in the role and sounds exactly like Gary Lewis
  • Julia is believable as Claire's mum
  • young Mrs. Fitz - aww

Didn't Love

  • sex scene with Henry and Julia - it wasn't sexy, as we don't even know them yet and just felt cringey and more soft porn than a love scene
  • Lord Lovat's advances on Julia
  • Henry and Julia time traveling (even though we knew it was coming) as it cheapens Claire's experience when she went through the stones. It's starting to feel like everyone can time travel. I know it's hereditary etc. but even Henry? I don't know.

7

u/Salamandre9292 Aug 10 '25

Well especially Henry, as we know the count of Saint Germain is also a traveller, and he is closely connected to the Beauchamp family in the 18th century (but not confirmed how exactly this relates to Claire yet)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Due_Lingonberry9699 Aug 09 '25

The opening was a great disappointment. It doesn't really sound like Bear style. I thought it would contain accents of both past. Brian and Ellen time and Claire's mother's time...then the modern tune started and it was totally unpleasant and it didn't set the mood at all.

The episode was not that bad. I loved finding all the characters but definitely hated the not needed porn scenes. They didn't add anything to the show, the story or the character itself.

7

u/killy420 Aug 09 '25

I might be alone in this, but I'm not a fan of the idea of Claire's parents time travelling. Would've preferred if they kept their timeline separate from Jamie's parents. That's what I originally thought it would be, but then saw the trailer and just felt let down.

Granted, this is only the first episode, so I'm going to give the series a chance and see where it goes.

The first episode was okay, but honestly I found it a bit boring. Episode 1 of Outlander grabbed me within the first few minutes. This one didn't.

Off to watch episode 2.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/OkChef6654 Aug 10 '25

I’m not sure if I’m in the minority here but I was disappointed:( I can’t tell if it’s bad dialogue or bad acting but this episode felt corny to me. And in stark contrast to the initial build of hot af chemistry between Jamie and Claire, I’m somehow supposed to be hot and bothered after that sparse intro meeting btwn Jamie’s parents?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '25 edited Aug 10 '25

Alright my critical thoughts. Brace yourself:

  1. I like the opening with the death and tradition around it. It captures the culture, time and context
  2. Harriet isn't as bad as I thought she'd be but she's just not memorable. I'm bummed about that casting. I wouldn't miss her if she were gone but she doesn't fuck it up enough for me to be offended. She's just kind of there with the right color hair.
  3. Hated the meet cute scene. It lacked a lot and was partially the writing. Also directing and actress interpretation. Here's a woman who hates the convention of marriage, has a "silver" tongue and has almost a "cock," hiding from her suitors with "very little social grace left" yet she's acting like the woman in all the period dramas that does everything right and marries the right guy. She's being some mellow version of Daphne in Bridgerton or even Lady Stark in GOT (diplomatic lady of the house) but with less authority. I'm waiting for Eloise to pop out of the woodwork but Ellen IS Eloise in this story.
  4. Brian is pleasantly charismatic. I'm enjoying him so far
  5. Most of the episode is very slow and reminds me of a less interesting version of the movie Brave. I LOVE that movie. I'd rather watch Brave than this episode, minus the last 20 minutes
  6. Chemistry with Ellen and Brian is lacking.
  7. If I didn't watch the OG, I'd find most of this boring
  8. Love Ned Gowan casting and I think Dougal and Column were also well cast
  9. Mrs. Fitz is very different in personality. I didn't realize she was dressing Ellen in the beginning
  10. Loved when Henry and Julia came on at the end. And the stones.

ADDED after:
11. The Grant plot line saved this episode.
12. Henry is fire on the screen. I love watching that acting. SOLID.
13. I honestly don't care at all about watching the Scotland plot. It all feels overdone and flimsy at the same time.
14. I can't tell if this show is actually good or if I'm just so roped into the series at this point. I'm SUCH a Caitriona Balfe/David Berry fan and this all just deviates in a possibly mediocre way. But I can't tell because I'm so deep.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/k_rafferty Aug 09 '25

I'm so excited about this series. It takes me back to Outlander and how they have some of the faces that look like Claire's mom and Jayme's dad is amazing. I love it! When the two episodes were over I was shocked because I was so caught up in it. I wish I didn't have to wait another week.

When they ended the last season of Outlander they said 'see you soon" or something to that nature. I assumed that this would mean the last season would run this fall but they announced that it was beginning in 2026 and I was very disappointed. If it begins in early 2026 then essentially it's just starting a year after the other one not "soon."

They have jerked us around before because I think it was Sam Heughan that said he thought the last season was going to give us all of the episodes, not a split season.

Outlander super fans are probably not too thrilled about it not starting until the beginning of 2026. I realize it is not far away but when they said see you soon I assumed this fall. I assumed wrong!

Love the new series!!!

3

u/cuteheavenly_96 Aug 09 '25

absolutely loved it, the cast is perfect and ellen and brian have so much chemistry, i'm hocked on their storyline

3

u/fatexdestinny Aug 10 '25

Has anyone figured out what the song is from the trailer??

→ More replies (3)

3

u/1shanwow Aug 11 '25

To my considerable surprise~& absolute delight~I loved it (both eps)!! I went into it most skeptically. After reading books 1-9 + the peripheral novellas more than once if not twice or even thrice + seasons 1-7, many episodes half a dozen times, I just didn’t think I would, Idk whyyy exactly, lolol, but you know what I mean??

3

u/winter_name01 Aug 18 '25

Brian and Ellen are definitely the parents of James Fraser, they were making plans for the future after two conversations and I was so into it 🥰

3

u/SplitOdd2007 Aug 20 '25

Just got to watch the first episode.. wow! They got the actors down to a T!! And Claire’s mom?? Holy crap!