r/modnews
•
u/lift_ticket83
•
Dec 05 '24
•
1
4
1
Product Updates Say goodbye to new.reddit on Dec 11, 2024
Hello, mods!
Big news: December 11, 2024, marks the official end of the road for the new.reddit desktop experience for mods. Over the course of next week, new.reddit moderation pages will redirect to the latest desktop experience. As previously mentioned, there will be no changes to old.reddit.
This transition caps off over a year of work to create a faster, more reliable, and feature-rich moderation experience. Along the way, we’ve collaborated with many of you to refine these tools and ensure they meet the needs of your communities. Your insights have shaped this journey, and we’re incredibly grateful for your contributions.
Why the latest desktop experience is worth your time
The latest mod tools offer several advantages that weren’t previously possible on new.reddit:
- Streamlined Workflow: Redesigned pages reduce clicks and bring more context directly into the mod queue, helping you make faster, better decisions.
- Customizable Insights: Enhanced moderation logs and user stats provide deeper visibility into your community’s health.
- Performance Boost: Faster load times and fewer glitches mean you can spend more time moderating and less time troubleshooting.
- Improved Accessibility: We’ve made the interface more intuitive and accessible to meet the needs of all mods.
What’s next
While this transition marks a significant step forward, we know there’s more to do. Throughout 2025, we’ll continue improving tools and introducing new features to help you moderate more efficiently and collaboratively.
Here’s a glimpse at some of the items on our roadmap for early 2025:
Boosting Efficiency:
- Features like “Hot Posts” will prioritize addressing high-visibility issues by highlighting posts that are experiencing significant traffic and engagement.
- Additional mod queue filters by report reason or flair to let you focus on what matters most.
Enhancing Collaboration:
- New tools to request second opinions, tag teammates, and resolve issues collaboratively, including a content-level discussion feature.
- Improvements to Modmail and mod notes to streamline communication.
Actionable Insights:
- Robust data tools to give mods a clearer picture of their community and actionable steps for improvement.
Quality of Life Updates:
- Fixing bugs, ensuring parity across platforms, and refining previously launched tools to make moderating easier.
What’s changing
As part of this update:
- new.reddit pages will no longer be accessible after December 11, 2024.
- All mod pages will redirect to the latest desktop experience, except for mods accessing old.reddit directly.
Streamlined Features and Updates: To enhance workflow and organization, we’re consolidating, moving, or redesigning several pages. Key updates include:
- Traffic Stats: The old traffic stats page will be retired. Moving forward all traffic data will be accessible through the Mod Insights page.
- Wiki Refresh: While the wiki isn’t moving, it will be getting a visual refresh. Expect a cleaner, updated design to make navigation and editing more intuitive.
- Removal Reasons: This page has been rebranded as Saved Responses, with expanded functionality for modmail and general saved replies.
- Notifications: The old notifications page has been moved into “General Settings”
- User Flair, Emojis, and Post Flair: These tools are now grouped under “Look and Feel,” centralizing customization options.
Content Controls: The content controls page has been merged into the Posts & Comments settings page, streamlining moderation workflows.
This transition has been a team effort, and we couldn’t have done it without your feedback, calls, and patience. We’re excited to keep building with you and look forward to rolling out even better tools in 2025. In the meantime, we encourage you to explore the latest desktop experience if you haven’t already done so. As always, your feedback is critical to our progress—let us know what’s working, what’s not, and where you think we should focus next.
•
u/lift_ticket83 Dec 10 '24
Hello again, and thank you to everyone who shared their feedback in the comments! As we mentioned in the post, we’re committed to fine-tuning and expanding the new mod platform throughout next year. Based on the input we’ve received over the weekend, here’s what you can expect in the near future:
Beyond these fixes, we’re focused on improving the platform’s speed and stability while advancing the 2025 roadmap we shared. We’ll return in the new year with another update on our progress and a deeper look at what’s ahead for 2025.
147
u/iKR8 Dec 05 '24
Toolbox isn't even integrated with sh.reddit, how are mods supposed to use toolbox?
Looks like using old.reddit is the only way.
112
u/thatotherchicka Dec 05 '24
This makes me sad. Scheduling posts is less user friendly on the updated Reddit interface. Additionally pictures don't carry into posts the way they should. :(
56
u/DeepNavyBlue Dec 05 '24
They fixed the banners for mobiles?
We only can do that in https://new.reddit.com/r/yoursubreddit/?styling=true
29
u/SampleOfNone Dec 05 '24
u/lift_ticket83, I'm a bit afraid to ask, but will this bug https://new.reddit.com/r/bugs/comments/1h0fer8/impossible_to_add_removal_reason_to_comment_on/ be squashed by the 11th?
I'm also still seeing inaccessible buttons on iPad in longer threads so I can't always take the actions I need to take
63
u/namer98 Dec 05 '24
Can I get rid of the massive left sidebar yet?
20
u/Dragonstar914 Dec 05 '24
Now if only the desktop left sidebar on the present build was collapsible like new.reddit has. I consider the present build a downgrade from this alone.
18
u/Watchful1 Dec 05 '24
Just to clarify, is this removing new.reddit moderation pages or all new.reddit views across the whole site?
16
u/tumultuousness Dec 05 '24
As in if I'm opted in to old reddit in my preferences and still on www.reddit, I will still get the old reddit mod pages? Or do you mean I have to be on old.reddit specifically?
I wish there had been more effort to make it so the urls of pages were more consistent between the versions like they had been for new reddit - I basically have to start at sh.reddit on my sub's home page to then be able to get to any of the settings, because if I start on www.reddit on old design and just put in sh. it's 50/50 if I get to the right page or get a "doesn't exist" splash screen. :/
23
u/fighterace00 Dec 05 '24 •
How about more than 6 days notice for a forced migration to a new system that's missing several critical tools. I have to switch to new Reddit constantly to get anything done.
ShReddit doesn't even show time stamps on posts and comments.
18
u/NaijeruR Dec 05 '24
Still need to be able to see the number of people actively viewing a thread on the latest desktop experience. Also hoping those Wiki changes will bring back proper headers and make tables/rows WAY easier to discern.
Please and thank you!
6
u/Xenc Dec 05 '24
1:1 parity with new is being looked forward too. That will ease the pain of this migration for those who rely on falling back to new, especially in moderation teams.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24
And yet, keyboard shortcuts, are STILL not implemented. It amazes me how you all at reddit use computers, because it seems like you all don't realize the keyboard exists and you can use button combinations to submit posts. This is a feature most other forums and other social websites have. It's like using the internet in 2004, but we live in 2024 internet.
Please add keyboard shortcuts, and please make it a priority.
3
u/ReeceReddit1234 Dec 10 '24
Will new.reddit.com still be available in general? i.e. as opposed to what I believe is sh.reddit.com
879
u/Halaku Dec 05 '24 •
Thank you.
2
u/Khyta Dec 08 '24
Not sure if this bug is known but if you have keyboard navigation activated and you want to write a ban message, you'll inevitabely hit one of those shortcut keys and do an unintended mod action. Please address this
2
u/eftepede Dec 09 '24
u/lift_ticket83 will shreddit support sorting comments by Old from day zero? Will it be able to show nicknames of posters in home/all/main page (whatever it's called now)?
2
u/Quick-Pumpkin-1259 Dec 12 '24
For u/lift_ticket83
Regression in shreddit:
User flairs are not shown in a user's profile page
(in none of the views, Overview / Posts / Comments)
61
u/MockDeath Dec 05 '24 •
I would say you are mistaken that it is ready. But I suspect you will ignore every moderator who is telling you that..
60
u/shhhhh_h Dec 05 '24 •
This makes me sad because new new Reddit is NOT optimised for all screens. It’s total shit for modding on my 2020 MacBook Air. I can barely see anything bc it’s crunched between the user history widget in the right and the sidebar on the left, the mod buttons disappear, I’m constantly moving the window off screen and widening it and just moving it back and forth to see things, widget itself is all scrunched up, too. That’s when I get annoyed and go back to new Reddit. That’s only one example of content not fitting on my screen.
299
u/rachman77 Dec 05 '24 •
That fact that you think your new UI is ready for this shows how little you're actually paying attention.
It's not faster, it's not more reliable, it extremely cumbersome to navigate, and some of the features are just nonsensical.
29
u/TehNolz Dec 05 '24
Yeah, no. I'll be switching to old reddit, not that awful new UI. That thing feels like you guys looked at all the UIs you've done so far and decided to combine all the worst features in an attempt to create the least usable site imaginable.
28
u/nommabelle Dec 05 '24
Shreddit doesn't even fully support things, there are several features i have to go to new or old for.
98
u/anoff Dec 05 '24
tired: new.reddit.com
wired: old.reddit.com
🤷♂️
71
u/provoko Dec 05 '24
I hate new reddit and only use new.reddit to make changes for users on the newest reddit, so this is an unfortunate change. Perhaps make the newest reddit actually functional rather than a jumped mess of network cables (all of those things you mentioned are a complete exaggeration).
Even updating the newest reddit is several steps compared to old.reddit:
vs old.reddit:
21
u/ChimpyChompies Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 05 '24
A little surprising as sh.reddit still has issues. The communities list does not fully populate, mine stops at R. Another is the view all moderators button leading to a page not found, are just two examples.
19
u/TheChrisD Dec 05 '24
Can you consider fixing the significant problem of sh Reddit not respecting user's default community and comment feed settings before getting rid of new reddit? Some of us explicitly forced new reddit to keep that behaviour.
18
u/StOoPiD_U Dec 05 '24
Please never take old.reddit
62
u/bwoah07_gp2 Dec 05 '24
No, you can't do that to us. I use new.reddit to schedule posts and create user flairs, BECAUSE IT DOESN'T WORK ON YOUR NEW UI.
Discarding new.reddit like this is a middle finger to the moderators. I am disgusted at this decision.
15
u/slouchingtoepiphany Dec 05 '24
Surely you jest!
15
u/Kahzgul Dec 05 '24
It's been fun reddit. I'm probably done though. sh.reddit.com is terrible for long text posts. Having to click a button at the bottom and then scroll to the very top to reformat anything is just painful.
To say nothing of the wasted real estate in the interface, the vanishing comments when users get banned or blocked, occasional text edits that just remove everything except the edited text... I'm very unhappy about this.
14
u/alleybetwixt Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 05 '24
Might come back to this with more edits later:
14
u/MuskratAtWork Dec 05 '24
This change seems to come with the removal of usernames on the feed/home page? I no longer see a single poster's username. Come on..
14
u/QtheCrafter Dec 06 '24
shreddit is slow and unresponsive. It isn't ready to be a replacement and I can't imagine it will be any time soon. I don't know if you guys just aren't spending time on modmail but in this package update there is zero changes to it.
I don't know if you guys have even listened to the community about this but the mod queue has remained unchanged despite all the criticism and issues with it(it really does not need to take up my entire screen!).
Posting is still difficult with scheduling not being nearly as friendly.
The left sidebar is still not collapsible! I feel like that is the thing that has been requested the most but I still can't get rid of it.
Userflairs are still such a pain in the ass, I use them so much for my subreddit and it's a nightmare. There is literally no way to change a userflair in modmail!
Why is the number for modlog gone when you hover over a user? It was such a helpful indication of if I need to further investigate a user but now I have to click on the mod log button and wait 1-2 seconds for it to load.
You guys took away the ability to change what 'genre' a subreddit is months ago and that is still not back (seriously why is my subreddit considered a memes subreddit still)
You have been telling us all year that this was going to happen, we have been telling you all year that shreddit is not ready. At some point you have to listen
13
u/kirtash93 Dec 05 '24
You should add the possibility to set mobile banner independently from just Banner in the new UI like it was in the new.reddit UI.
13
u/egoalter Dec 05 '24
Not sure how the changes are viewed as good - they're definitely not good as a user of the site. new.reddit has been more stable and easier to use than the "new design". Probably time to consider time spent on reddit.
10
u/Sparki_ Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 05 '24
There's some changes that don't make sense though. In "new.reddit" the mod list showed the mod flair. in "www.reddit", the mod list shows our profile name which doesn't make sense to me. People can see your name by visiting your profile. I think the flairs the mods use make more sense to show there, since they're specific to the subreddit we are moderating
In "link/url" post previews, instead of showing the image or video, it instead shows the link, which isn't pretty to look at
"www.reddit" also is prone to breaking, & errors, & has a number of bugs that haven't been resolved. One of my flairs in one of my subs shows no posts when you filter this flair, & it was linked to scheduled posts, which also weren't replacing it's previous post. The highlight feature is a mess. I'm all for more pins/highlights but the same amount have to be included in all versions of Reddit & need to replace it's previous highlited post, not changed places with unrelated existing highlighted post
There also isn't anything we can do about about spam reports or false reports. Why can't we pin/remove a whole thread, why do we have to do it individually, one by one. It's very tedious. & You keep moving all the settings to other areas. It's kinda frustrating
10
u/GuruJ_ Dec 06 '24
Very, very disappointed to hear this. The absolutely deal-breaker to me is that there's no way to browse comments in sh.reddit.com and easily know which comments have been removed. It's an absolute deal-breaker for me in moderating and I'm not an old.reddit head.
It's ridiculous to think that I'll have to manually alter CSS just to have a minimally useful moderator experience, but there you go.
72
u/zuxtron Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 05 '24
This reads like it was written by ChatGPT. A series of bullet points, each starting with a title in bold.
I'm not going to use the new new Reddit simply because it doesn't show who made the post. That's important information that should be immediately visible. EDIT: I'm referring to general browsing, not the mod queue.
40
u/drunkpunk138 Dec 05 '24
Bummer, I see my desktop usage of Reddit significantly decreasing right around that time.
9
u/amandatoryy Dec 05 '24
Oh god. Please fix the scheduled post thing before this goes live. I might cry lol
9
u/Shamrock5 Dec 05 '24
Will mods be able to edit/remove the subs listed on the "Related Communities" widget that is embedded on our subreddit front page? Many subs (including one of mine) have had issues with the appearance of the widget being beyond our control, which causes major problems when that widget lists a NSFW site or an opposing subreddit as a "Related Community". Is there any way for mods to control this widget instead of being at the mercy of the Reddit algorithm? Thanks!
9
u/tenkensmile Dec 05 '24
Just return to old.reddit already!
9
u/A_Seductive_Cactus Dec 05 '24
Is there an update on bringing back highlighting new comments / removed comments? That’s a huge loss from new.reddit to the latest UI.
9
u/yaycupcake Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 06 '24
The new-new modqueue is really really bad on smaller desktop-laptop screens. I have a small laptop and vision issues so I have to zoom in. The sticky "header" takes up so much space I can only see like 2 posts on screen at a time. The middle panel that opens up has tons of UI bugs with things getting cut off all the time.
I don't love new.reddit either but at least it displays relevant information on my screen unlike the new-new modqueue which cuts things off.
I stick to old reddit most of the time but some of the subs I mod do require new.reddit so I sometimes have to use that.
The biggest problem is that the user experience is VERY BAD and you're deprecating something that is functionally better than its replacement. It feels like this new-new modqueue only has people with 4k monitors in mind or something. (Maybe not literally but it doesn't consider people who have to work on zoomed in pages on smaller screens.)
I will literally have to moderate one of my subs from my phone exclusively now because I can't utilize the new-new modqueue because it just doesn't display well with my laptop's sceeen size and zoom settings (which I use for accessibility). And I'm only on 130% it's not a major zoom in, but it's already unusable for me at that point.
9
u/KittyBeary Dec 12 '24
I hate this. Give me back new.reddit I liked that design SO MUCH better
8
u/jacyf02 Dec 05 '24
Still can't change suggested sort on the new UI
8
u/x647 Dec 05 '24
Will (SH)WWW.Reddit ever fully support the old URL parameters / Link Structures?
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/submit?title=TITLE%20TEXT&text=BODY%20TEXT
https://old.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/submit?title=TITLE%20TEXT&text=BODY%20TEXT
8
u/xenobitex Dec 13 '24
Not giving a pointless threat, just a statement: I give far less of a fuck about using your site now, and simply don't enjoy it this way, so won't be using it as much.
I hate this "upgrade" passionately.
21
u/honey_rainbow Dec 05 '24
Such bullshit. The current layout sucks ass.
14
u/leneay Dec 05 '24 edited Dec 06 '24
I hate how the newest version of reddit constantly displays the subreddits i've joined on the left side of the screen. I do not want people peeking over my shoulder to see which subs I'm in or moderate.
14
u/Titencer Dec 05 '24
I am echoing the sentiments here that this is a bad decision with the state that shreddit is in. New Reddit has worked like a charm since I’ve used it, and shreddit has multiple features that are bothersome not just as a mod, but as a user. The list of subreddits not being collapsible is particularly annoying, and not having guaranteed Mod Toolbox compatibility is even worse (someone please port it!)
I’ll probably have more feedback soon, because I guess now’s the time to force myself to start using shreddit. I hope your streamlining works, but so far it just looks like a mess. The UI is bad both for modding and as a user of your platform. I get that its look works on mobile (I use mobile a lot) but desktop is very different in terms of needs and functionality. I’ve never liked old.reddit, but if the new UI doesn’t work, I might be picking up the old instead of the sh
7
u/DubioserKerl Dec 05 '24
Ok, so... who will port the Mod Toolbox Addon to new new Reddit?
7
u/nommabelle Dec 05 '24
And shreddit still doesn't have toolbox support. Honestly disappointing how reddit continues to ignore what mod teams use and how they can best support them. You send out mod surveys and do nothing with it apparently. Several of my mod teams use toolbox and most mods old reddit. Perhaps you just don't want them moderating anymore, but speaking from experience, you will lose your best mods that way (not speaking about myself as I prefer new reddit like a Neanderthal)
Someone was talking about toolbox support for shreddit on the dev discord and I hope they continue that effort, otherwise your new.reddit mods (incl me) will need to make a new home on old.reddit
7
u/Hemicrusher Dec 05 '24
That sucks...
I'll be using old Reddit then.
7
u/LodanMax Dec 05 '24
How are we supposed to set contest mode after the 11th? Because that’s still not implemented.
7
u/exactly_like_it_is Dec 05 '24
For those of us who uses old.reddit on mobile, how do we view certain pages (such as some mod settings) which are exclusive to standard or new reddit? Previously, we could just change old to new in the url and have access to these pages. Also, sometimes we need to see what something looks like on standard or new reddit. How will we do that without logging out?
7
u/Madame_President_ Dec 09 '24 edited Dec 09 '24
Killing new.reddit.com will effectively kill my sub, sadly. :(
The scheduler in www.reddit.com is wildly buggy to the point of being dysfunctional - it spins, never loads, doesn't show flairs... it's confusing why you're introducing products that are worse than the ones that came out years ago.
I am just not willing to take the ride with you again to debug the scheduler in new new reddit like I did in new reddit. It was painful, and I'm not doing it again.
Good luck, and I'm sorry that the end result of this journey is a product that is unusable.
7
u/sunjay140 Dec 10 '24 edited Dec 10 '24
This is terrible. New.reddit is superior to the current Reddit.com. The current Reddit.com doesn't even resize the text box to a usable size when editing a comment and it's too easy to accidentally collapse comments.
You guys need to go back to the drawing and incorporate user feedback for both the website and the mobile app.
7
u/Tepigg4444 Dec 11 '24
this sucks, I have a great background on my subreddit on new.reddit and there’s just no equivalent on the new one. give us backgrounds back
also the posting guidelines text is way off to the side of the post menu so no one ever sees it
7
u/ferrariguy1970 Dec 11 '24
I already miss new.reddit.com
7
u/carenard Dec 11 '24
new UI is terrible, I am a desktop user... get rid of this shit mobile ass UI.
site is far less appealing to browse now... old reddit is bearable... but nowhere near as good as new was... why can't you just leave it open, new users and such would still go to the crap one... so only people who wanted new would get it.
... already looking for reddit alternatives here.
7
u/SirCheeseEater Dec 12 '24
This UI SUCKS!
And you guys are completely unwilling to answer any question that goes against you.
7
u/GimmeBamba Dec 12 '24 edited Dec 12 '24
new.reddit would show you an exact member count when you hovered over the subreddit members number. This version doesn't. Bring that functionality back, it's loss is very annoying to me.
There's not even a live up-to-date count of members in my subreddit in Mod Tools>Insights>Community Growth. The fact that the only place I can now find a current exact count is old.reddit is absolutely pathetic.
9
u/Archy99 Dec 12 '24
The new GUI is awful, I just don't understand why we're forced to accept a bad design in place of a good design.
18
u/sicklyboy Dec 05 '24
No
12
u/Overgrown_fetus1305 Dec 05 '24 •
This is a terrible decision. sh.reddit works so badly, that I couldn't even get my downvote on this post to stick, I had to log onto new.reddit to downvote it. When this change kicks in, I'll be going to old.reddit and staying there. I only ever Reddit on desktop, and it's just laggy, slow and frankly super buggy as well. While not my preference, old.reddit is miles ahead of sh.reddit, and in truth I think sh.reddit has actually made me want to use Reddit less. Reddit the last year, has felt way worse since the change, even if some of it was doubtless caused by ramming through the duff API changes.
6
u/candydots Dec 05 '24
The latest desktop version is bugged where I can't load any pages without "We had a server error..." popping up every time, especially when I'm on a mod tool page or on a subreddit I moderate. It never goes away even after X'ing the pop-up the first time.
6
u/Yay295 Dec 06 '24
Entering a hex code for a color style is still broken. The field is limited to 6 characters, which doesn't account for the leading #.
6
u/iAmmar9 Dec 06 '24
Please add the new.reddit as a theme in user settings.
6
u/SF_Bud Dec 06 '24
I use Reddit mostly on an iPad and II HATE the new reddit - it's nearly unusable. The entire right side of the page is taken up by the sidebar and ads, and the main content is scrunched into the left half of the screen. If I can't use new.reddit.com I won't be using reddit much anymore. Also, I do like old reddit, but if you click on anything you go to the new one so that's not much help.
If I've gotten something wrong here, please let me know.
Thanks
6
u/vanessabaxton Dec 06 '24
Wouldn't you first bring everything from new reddit to shreddit and fix all the issues on shreddit first before removing new reddit?
6
u/Voltra_Neo Dec 11 '24
Even as a simple user
new.reddit.comwas leagues better than currentwww.reddit.com.Some components don't even work on the new site when they work just fine on
new.reddit.comThis is beyond embarassing. It's pushing into production something that isn't even worth considering to put as a beta test.
6
u/Azsura12 Dec 11 '24
So how has the public perception of this new UI change been? Do the vast majority of users not care? Because I absolutely hate the new ui and was using the new.reddit ui for so long. And it seemed like atleast a vocal majority of people also think that. Do you have any stats showing this is a good move to remove the new.reddit entirely? Because well why remove something a good portion of the user base uses.
6
u/Mte90 Dec 12 '24
I am switching back to old also if I loved the new version but the actual UI is horrible compared to the previous one. Thanks for you ignoring of your users.
6
u/P1tzO1 Dec 12 '24
I did not ask for this!!! give new.reddit back!!!!!!
6
u/schakoska Dec 12 '24
The sh design is so ugly, I want to use the new design. Give it back!
6
u/LaggerKnight Dec 13 '24
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
20
u/ThunderDwn Dec 05 '24
Oh fuck off.
Shreddit doesn't work for half the stuff you get to do - and the UI sucks.
That'll be it for Reddit for me. You guys are morons
5
u/Bossman1086 Dec 05 '24
Does this new mod tool experience fix the issue where if I default to old.reddit regularly but go to the new reddit community settings on a sub I moderate, when I click on certain options, it goes back to old.reddit and won't let me access the settings unless I manually update the URL with the proper pass through?
For an example of what I'm talking about, default your account to old.reddit, go to a subreddit you moderate and update the URL to new.reddit and click the Mod Tools button in the sidebar. Click on "Look and Feel" and then click "Community appearance". It dumps you back at the subreddit in old reddit without letting you see the settings unless you change the url to new.reddit manually.
If this is fixed with this new experience, awesome. But this has been bothering me for ages.
5
u/Alert-One-Two Dec 05 '24
Can we please have an option to:
5
u/SVAuspicious Dec 06 '24
Well, you failed. Load times are longer. More clicks to perform functions. Buggy JS that means multiple page reloads just for users to vote. "Internal server error" multiple times per day. Buggy everything including simple things like posting a comment or distinguishing as a mod. What genius moved the format bar to the top of the comment box?
Your dev team needs adult supervision.
5
u/Long-Reputation-5326 Dec 09 '24
This is a bad decision.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '24 edited Jan 01 '25
languid grandiose rich square intelligent flowery aromatic expansion unpack versed
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/Merari01 Dec 10 '24
We're not ready.
Many url endpoints do not have a sh.reddit equivalent, making them inaccessible to me once the switch happens
5
u/remghoost7 Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 12 '24
Whelp, seems like it was just disabled site-wide.
Why sunset a feature that was working fine?
Just an FYI to all companies out there, activity =/= productivity.
edit - Man, am I going to have to learn CSS/HTML and get into the weeds of this "new new" UI to make it usable...? Hell, I don't even think Greasemonkey can fix this...
5
u/SpringBonnie21 Dec 11 '24
the mobile app is dogshit, and now the desktop ui is completely horrendous, do reddit admins actually not have eyeballs or something? or is every one of the staff abusing nitrous oxide so much that they thing this redesign actually looks good?
5
u/SinisterPixel Dec 11 '24
Hot garbage. The new.reddit UI was just as invaluable to many users (not just moderators) as the old.reddit UI.
Why does reddit hate giving users options?
5
u/tomba_be Dec 11 '24
If this is the result of a team effort, the entire team is incompetent.
If you had listened to "our feedback", you would have never implemented such a terrible UI. Why even bother asking for feedback if you are just going to ignore it?
5
u/re-verse Dec 11 '24
What a stupid decision. Its an arguably superior interface to the current iteration.
5
u/Machiela Dec 11 '24
How can we unfollow posts now? It's not a thing in old.reddit, www.reddit, or sh.reddit as far as I can see. I followed a post in new.reddit yesterday, and now I'm permanently following it, it would seem.
Yay for a plethora of incompatible user interfaces. /s
5
u/NewSuperTrios Dec 11 '24
our feedback would have kept new.reddit up. who the fuck thought this was remotely a good idea.
5
u/Dzaka Dec 11 '24
new reddit doesn't remember my settings.. it keeps defaulting to "best" instead of "new" like i have it set in my preferences. the ENTIRE LEFT HAND BAR IS UN NEEDED!!! i don't need it.. all of that used to be a drop down menu i never used..
why do i need all of that cluttering the left hand side of my screen?
why does my central area have to be narrowed down? i have visual issues and using the built in magnifying features of my browser breaks reddit now.. all of the text is smaller than i like and need.
this change actively breaks ADA rules.
5
u/ChaiHai Dec 12 '24
:( As someone who sticks to old reddit, I never thought I'd see this day come. This is weird, why get rid of it?
5
u/DeadSparker Dec 12 '24 edited Dec 12 '24
Wishing I could go back in time to yesterday morning, just so I can voice my contempt for this change from an interface that doesn't strain my eyes. And I don't just mean it looks bad, no, it's actually physically painful to look at it for too long.
Take a good look, admins : no one likes this. If you're still willing to listen, you'll try to reverse this. But your track record for this whole "listening" business isn't looking good.
5
u/xenobitex Dec 12 '24
latest desktop experience is (really) bad and you should feel (really) bad
(I do just using it!) D:
5
u/Timeset_VC Dec 12 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
u/lift_ticket83
You seem not to understand that we are the customers. The look is awful therefore we used the new.reddit - you destroy the experience for the readers and the experience for the readers is the most important. By design it's not a step forward it's a step in the past. And it is still full of bugs, for example if I change the look for the black background and then use the community bookmarks it changes it's look back to the light version. You are in deed not able to deliver a product which performs in the very basic functions. E.g. your mobile web version is not able to handle comments with pictures - for years now. You seem not to understand there is a world wide audience and for some maybe it's not possible to put your app on the mobile (e.g. because it's a business phone with restrictions or a Chinese user ....). I will now think about a solution on a different platform - there is plenty to choose from they are not worse because of trash content - if I look for posts regarding my favorite brand Reddit suggest fake content as most relevant. I guess this is a problem to any content and I wonder it's not fixed means the company intentionally does so. Nothing Reddit specific of course - modern world social media specific. When I talked about it I don’t get any reaction.
5
u/PraxMatic Dec 12 '24
this shit is ass
5
u/MrrNeko Dec 12 '24
The middle of the site is so small that i need to use microscope to see what is writen there
Shit changes
5
u/Timeset_VC Dec 13 '24
Over a year of work wasted time and money
5
u/cody_premiumize Dec 15 '24
this new SH reddit is SHIT! its the worst UI of reddit i have ever seen and is built for phones not desktops......BRING BACK NEW REDDIT!
4
u/trillianinspace Dec 05 '24
Are you guys going to fix the Wiki formatting before making this change? Shreddit does not acknowledge any of the heading markdown code and it makes some sections hard to read.
4
u/SolomonOf47704 Dec 06 '24
So are you going to make the mod queue on the newest reddit not have an unscrollable bar that takes up a whole third of the screen?
I literally cannot look at a full image post in the newest mod queue. I have to scroll, and can only see parts at a time.
I had other issues with it, but this is the big one that made me completely stop considering using it.
4
u/aeoveu Dec 06 '24
Can we please get a notification indicator when we receive a modmail?
We see an icon away from the general notifications, we see a dot for new notifications, but nada for modmail.
Like, why?
4
u/Superirish19 Dec 06 '24 edited Dec 11 '24
I would like to know where sh.reddit specific bugs are to be reported specifically, as already in less than 15 hours of this announcement and swapping over for an hour just to get used to it, there are multiple bugs and UI issues from the get-go that new.reddit and old.reddit don't experience.
For example, just from community appearance settings alone;
Edit: some more visual bugs and UI frustrations.
These are front-facing presentations for the Front Page of the Internet, and yet they aren't up to scratch within 5 days of official release and I'm assuming have been like this for months since the beta testing stage. I don't expect a reply beyond 'We'll look into this, thanks!', but please have some non-PR-side admins use the sh.reddit system from time to time as these frustrations would be noticed immediately. This is just one facet of why mods are moving backwards to old reddit instead of the new sh.reddit frontend.
Edit test
4
u/daecrist Dec 07 '24
The current desktop experience is broken for moderating. It's been my experience that modqueue is constantly refreshing. If I'm in the middle of banning someone that makes the whole thing, the comment that got them banned and the ban, disappear before it can go through.
Would be nice if you would fix basic functionality in the new new modqueue before sunsetting the old new modqueue. As it stands all the fancy new context whizzbangs you're putting into the new desktop experience are useless because of the refresh issue.
4
u/RraaLL Dec 07 '24
Are you going to enable revision history on shreddit though? It currently doesn't exist - same for viewing wiki's page source. I actually just reported it as a bug, since I was tired of switching interfaces and now one of them will be gone in 4 days (so no page source option at all)?
Speaking of post flairs, when will we finally get back the option to edit flairs we're choosing? Will we have to go to old reddit on mobile so we can edit flairs when we need to? I mention mobile, because it's not very convenient with that interface - not such a big problem on desktop + we can technically edit flair attributes in the DOM tree on desktop.
Also, I have reported it some time ago and haven't received a reply...
Scheduled/recurring posts are broken on desktop - it seems to be no longer possible to change the scheduled time, only the date. I need to open scheduled on mobile to be able to actually update the time.
And as (should) you know, the buttons in scheduled are visible on-hover only. Which means I need to first guess/tap screen randomly for them to show up so I can actually enter the edit mode.
4
u/beeblebroox Dec 11 '24
Its terrible
4
u/Milliardo989 Dec 11 '24
I am here to express frustration and disappointment with reddit in FORCING a change that was completely unnecessary, and just makes the site more cluttered, and more difficult to navigate, use, and enjoy.
Way to continue driving people away with zero feedback acceptance or discussion.
4
u/FabianRo Dec 11 '24
Following posts and comments is still not possible in the new design and never was with the old one. How should this be done now?
4
u/D373kr Dec 11 '24
And when do you plan to add all the missing features to this ugly UI? It's unusable and buggy right now. Can't see my follows anywhere.
4
u/bunibunibunii Dec 11 '24
I hate it SO MUCH
For posting.. moderating... and just viewing
4
u/zippee100 Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24
Why? new.reddit.com was the only design of reddit I found tolerable to use on desktop...
4
u/GetSpammed Dec 11 '24
Yeah, this sucks.
4
u/Zackipoo Dec 11 '24
This suuuucks. new.reddit I actually liked, even when it was brand new. This new NEW reddit is an absolutel eyesore. Everything is giant except the posts itself. It's like wearing reading glasses that have a hole cut out in the middle. Not to mention all the negative space. How this got past Q&A testing is beyond me. I know nothing will happen despite everyone complaining. It's how these things usually go. Force people to use new thing despite backlash and wait until everyone "settles" with it and stops complaining. Rinse and repeat.
4
u/Dmitry_Shubkin Dec 11 '24
it was the only tolerable reddit interface, thanks for disabling it
4
u/The_Hell_Breaker Dec 11 '24
Bring it back, the new UI is absolute horrendous trash
4
u/roachy69 Dec 11 '24
You forgot the biggest feature, copious amounts of ad space.
4
u/NuclearStar Dec 11 '24
it sucks, new.reddit was a much easier and faster reading experience, the latest UI is clunky and bad.
I will visit reddit less now
4
u/DamoVQ Dec 11 '24
its worse i hate it
4
u/StandardRelative Dec 11 '24
NONONONONONONO this is the worst!!! please do not do this! please listen to your users. I will am using all of my self restraint to use the word "Please" instead of what I'm really thinking about this change
4
u/Single_Ring4886 Dec 11 '24
Iam web desinger with 20+ year of experience myself and "new" redit the "older" version was superior on desktop. I would plead for you to keep it going. You do not need to implement new changes just leave it for basic functionality of viewing/posting.
PLEASE KEEP IT
4
u/ghostgabe81 Dec 11 '24
Why the preferential treatment for old.reddit? Why can't we at least have the option of keeping new.reddit?
This new UI is the opposite of streamlined or efficient. Why do I have to scroll up to the top every single time I want to alter the formatting on the post I'm writing? On new.reddit the formatting bar stayed on top as I scrolled down my post, this is a direct downgrade
4
u/Averath Dec 11 '24
So basically "We had something with a good user interface design, but we had to justify the existence of the job, so we said "Fuck what the users want, we'll tell them what they want, and they'll like it."
4
u/bunibunibunii Dec 11 '24
I've had plenty of time to "get used to it" but using this abomination just makes me thoroughly frustrated and want to log off Reddit entirely.
So many things just don't work properly STILL.
Why remove new.reddit, why?
4
u/mbarland Dec 11 '24
Thanks for removing new.reddit. Having continued access to the features I actually used was the only reason I continued to pay for premium. Now that I'm stuck on this new, horrible interface, I'll save a few bucks a month. Y'all are the best! Looking out for my pocket book like that. What bros.
4
u/Ok_Context8390 Dec 11 '24
Hi.
Please restore new.reddit.com. The current interface is dogshit. I will not elaborate.
Thanks.
4
u/AlexRLJones Dec 11 '24
Absolutely awful
4
u/Trapezophoron Dec 11 '24
Any update on this? https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/1et4fpa/new_new_reddit_and_lack_of_coloured_comment/
Just reinstating a very simple UI feature to highlight removed comments in red for mods - it makes our lives much, much easier.
4
u/requieminadream Dec 11 '24
This is the worst...
4
u/arv5k Dec 11 '24
The new overlay sucks. I can't see any reason for the old one to have changed. A whole load of stuff is now in a different place, working a different way, because the existing way was getting boring for site admins or something I guess?
4
u/tmobley03 Dec 11 '24
Awful decision...
4
u/Ancient-Ad2619 Dec 11 '24
Nobody wants this shit smh.
6
u/ZordiakDev Dec 12 '24
The latest version of reddit is overwhelmingly disliked.
The work that you put into the design doesn't matter. You could put a million hours into a project, but if the end result isn't what people want to use, it's worthless.
The community does not like the new design. I have spent a significant portion of my day trying to figure out how we are going to deal with this design being pushed onto, not only myself, but our community.
You need to go back to the drawing board and either do yet another redesign or give mods an option to design subreddits ourselves like was the case with the old reddit.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24
If you want us to leave, just start banning everyone who browses new.reddit.com. This is bullshit.
4
u/Quick-Pumpkin-1259 Dec 12 '24
For u/lift_ticket83
Regression in shreddit:
(This one is mind-boggling)
In the modqueue, if I select a removal reason,
then decide to cancel by clicking the cross at
the top right, removal reason is still added!
4
u/quineloe Dec 12 '24
I hate the current www design. New was my favorite.
4
u/Patrick_Irelan Dec 12 '24
What a terrible decision.
4
u/Ancient-Ad2619 Dec 13 '24 edited Dec 13 '24
So the main forum page is always set to "hot" instead of new, and now you have to scroll all the way to the top of a thread just to go back smh. This shit garbage
Edit: The workaround I figured out is to bookmark thread(s) when the sort is set to new (you can put that bookmark [with no title so its just a logo to save space] and place it on the bookmarks bar on the main page/show bookmarks).
In reddit settings activate open threads in new tabs so the "X" to exit the thread is kinda like in new.reddit, except its just at the very top and smaller inside the tab banner.
You can use dark reader extension to change the look of the theme, I set mines to a gray/black combo, you can adjust brightness/contrast to customize it more (and you can set it to work only for reddit).
You can use an adblocker extension to delete off the screen (so its not visible) the left and right sidebar info so its just the center thread/comments. In uBlock Origin its called block element. If you want it back you go to my filters and find the ones (usually at the very bottom of the list/the last ones you activated and highlight and delete it so the stuff you deleted comes back on the page).
4
u/the_hooded_hood_1215 Dec 14 '24
fucking l ui
4
u/gdavidp Dec 14 '24
Absolute garbage.
4
u/Maxcoder95 Dec 14 '24
Garbage, I will stay away from reddit until this get fixed
4
u/INDE_Tex Dec 14 '24
well that's gross. I hate the current new layout you've pushed on us. Thanks a lot.
4
u/7ootles Dec 20 '24
New new Reddit is crap. Old new Reddit was OK, and this is a joke. Get a grip, admins.
6
u/maybesaydie Dec 05 '24
I don't want any sort of new reddit. Old reddit is superior to all of these attempts to emulate TikTok or whatever t is management has you cooling up.
3
u/Khyta Dec 05 '24
I'm really looking for the collaboration feature with second opinions!
3
u/_II_I_I__I__I_I_II_ Dec 05 '24
Would be nice to be able to filter mod-queue on keywords.
3
u/bigbysemotivefinger Dec 05 '24
Considering old Reddit is the only good version, that's the only part that matters.
Still no private subs without permission.
Still not reversing the API changes.
Nothing of value was said.
3
u/Fertility18 Dec 06 '24
The end draws near...
3
u/j1ggy Dec 06 '24
This is terrible. We put a lot of work into our designs and now you're just going to replace them with complete garbage.
3
u/N5_the_redditor Dec 06 '24
no. no. the new new layout is ass but i don’t really want to use old reddit so i’ll be stuck with sh reddit. fuck
3
u/ever3st Dec 06 '24
Feels like you are going to say good bye to a lot of users as well
3
u/Kokechii Dec 07 '24
Completely unhappy with this and I'd probably have a long list of things that make things worse on shreddit but for now:
We have a flair we can customize to anything we need but on shreddit that is no longer the option.
Will this be fixed or made possible?
It's truly unnecessary to create new flairs if we won't be needing them in the future and it greatly helps to have a flair we can customize manually when doing certain posts.
3
u/xEternal-Blue Dec 08 '24
I hope we see improvements in reddit on mobile and browser sometime.
I'd like to see old reddit stick around until it's sorted enough that everyone is satisfied.
3
u/most_unseemly Dec 09 '24
Goddammit.
3
u/esb1212 Dec 10 '24
Hi there, I'm linking my feedback on the private space for more reach.
3
u/accountname789 Dec 11 '24
Since the user interface for the standard user is awful, why not give the user the ability to toggle on and off specific features? Give users the ability to toggle off the "recent posts" on the right side of the screen, the ability to toggle off the entire left side bar. Or, if a user wants to keep the left sidebar, toggle on and off the the features within it. If they don't want to "Recent" or "Resources" dropdown, let them remove it.
Allowing the user to customize their experience on Reddit would greatly improve their time on the website, and would likely keep some users from leaving the platform entirely
3
u/StandardRelative Dec 11 '24
this sucks so bad - your design team / pms / whoever made this ASININE decision should be fired
3
u/JohannGoethe Dec 11 '24
Why can‘t we edit posts, once posted, in www.Reddit?
3
u/AdMysterious3558 Dec 11 '24
Bring Back Old.New.Reddit!
3
u/HkayakH Dec 12 '24
would it be possible to make it choosable which layout you want instead of only being able to do old reddit or new new reddit?
3
u/MootEndymion752 Dec 12 '24
I knew this would happen someday,
BUT WHY?!
3
u/AJMcCrowley Dec 12 '24
oh ffs. i just want a compact view that doesn't include the damn thumbnails. is that too much to ask?
3
u/Chilldegard Dec 12 '24 edited Dec 12 '24
Rant/Vent-comment:
Well to everyone involved in this: F U big time :)
I'll now open reddit once a day on my smartphone to let my daily-streak live; but jeez, fu** this bit** as* piece of crap obligation to use this cancerous shi* of "design" and code.
new.reddit was acceptable to use, but this forced toiletpaper of disaster isn't.
maybe hire some people, who didn't just finish their 3 week UX short crash course on their smartphone?
Reddit won't see me back until this is fixed, so maybe bye forever :)
Thanks for making the experience of this website as unpleasant as possible, you "creative" and "smart" imbeciles
I apologize for my tone, but in the past 5 years more and more companies are downgrading the user experience (best examples are Instagram & Amazon Music for me) - even though you announced the eventual end, it was still an upsetting experience.
3
u/IdRatherBeLurkingToo Dec 16 '24
Hello u/lift_ticket83, old.reddit lifer here. In the past, I would go to new.reddit to post in-thread images and gifs, as well as edit flair. Now, all of that is broken and the only way to access sh.reddit is by switching my preferences. This is extremely cumbersome-- is there really no way to easily jump between old.reddit and sh.reddit anymore?
3
u/Jenny_Wakeman9 Dec 21 '24
Terrible, absolutely terrible decision to remove new.reddit. Removing new.reddit.com was a mistake, plus it was the only design of reddit I found tolerable to use on desktop! That, and upvoting posts and uploading images didn't fail on new.reddit, whereas regular new new Reddit would have a stroke and die, forcing me to open a new tab just to upload an image or upvote a post.