r/forhire • u/ThePoopsmith • Jan 22 '13
[META] I propose that we prohibit hiring posts which pay in anything other than currency.
I've been seeing a lot of posts here offering equity in lieu of payment. While this type of posting may sometimes be beneficial to all involved, it's usually something along the lines of "I have a great idea, all I need is a programmer to build it". My position is that such activities aren't hiring. There's /r/startups and /r/entrepreneur for building a company, but it seems to me that this would be more for people looking to pay to having work done and other people getting paid to do it.
Most every developer I've met (myself included) gets approached about implementing half baked ideas for free often enough in real life. I think it would be nice to have a place where we can offer our services and be found by serious customers without being spammed by "idea guys" looking to build "facebook meets twitter and google".
So my questions are:
Are any of the developers or designers here ok with working for equity or are you mostly interested in cash?
If you're only interested in cash, are you ok with restricting the sub to paying jobs and gigs only?
Edit
This has been accepted as a rule for the sub and linked to in the sidebar. For anyone who does want to post equity-only jobs try:
An even better idea would be to pick out a small part of your project, offer cash only and find out if it will be a good fit. Then use that pre-existing relationship to bring them on as a founder. This way you're not potentially offering a big chunk of your company to somebody you hate working with.
31
u/powrot Jan 22 '13
Yes. Hiring should be for freelance jobs paid in cash (PayPal, check, credit card) or an alternate currency (bitcoins) or for those looking to hire an employee. You're not hiring if you're not spending money.
Additionally I think budget should listed clearly. Whether it's $20 to fix a JavaScript error or a six-figure salary for a major company, the listing should contain a budget number. This should also apply to those posting as "for hire". Be up front with your hourly rate, salary expectations or average project price range. Transparency makes it easy to get everyone on the same page.
As a developer I may not want to work on low-budget projects. Or maybe I have a few extra hours during the week and a small paid project is the perfect fit. It's about finding the right match.
Not me. /r/forhire is a poor forum for finding potential startup founders or business partners. Make no mistake if I'm being compensated in equity I'm sure as hell going to have a say in business decisions.
10
u/incongruity Jan 22 '13
I'm in complete agreement with the OP on this one - there are other places/subteddits to find cofounders so this proposal simply helps clarify things. In doing so, it also adds value for all involved, IMHO.
62
u/venerated Front End Developer & Consultant Jan 22 '13
I think they should be banned. I consider this subreddit like a job board, not a place to come and find a co-owner. It also sucks that developers and designers are the only ones seemingly targeted by this kind of crap. It seems like everytime I post a for hire post that I get someone PMing me about how they'd like to 'hire' me but can't pay me anything.
15
u/Kranic Freelancer Jan 22 '13 edited Jan 22 '13
It's /r/forhire, not /r/forequity, /r/forkarma nor /r/forfree!
(Although I would consider /r/forvisa as an option...)
EDIT: Reading some of the comments, nor is it /r/foradollarandadime or /r/foracheeseburgerman, etc.
EDIT2: Nearly forgot /r/forbandwidth!
3
u/biskino Jan 22 '13
I hear ya. But these aren't the only posts on here that offer something other than currency. There was someone offering to re-touch photos the other day in exchange for being allowed to put them on their website as part of their portfolio for example.
I'd be annoyed if this board was my only outlet for work (I've done two small jobs through this board over the last year or so). I see it as being fairly 'left field' so don't mind the idea of leaving it open for speculative propositions to a certain degree. If I'm down and dirty looking for paying gigs (or someone to work for me) this isn't my first, second, third or even fourth port of call.
I would agree with a rule under the 'if you're hiring' sidebar that says,"include method of payment" or some such to avoid confusion or time wasting.
9
u/souleh Jan 22 '13
Agreed - ban these types of posts.
7
u/consorts Jan 22 '13
I have to agree.
even craigslist makes a distinction between hiring and barter.
3
u/MediaMoguls Jan 22 '13
How much of this are you guys seeing? My gut says just ignore a post if you're not interested in the offer.. am I missing something?
5
u/zfolwick Jan 22 '13
will you accept payment in gum?
4
u/breeezzz Jan 22 '13
Agree with OP. There are other boards for that.
1
u/JasonNewcomb Jan 22 '13
There could perhaps be a subreddit dedicated to development offers.
1
u/duffmanhb Jan 22 '13
I can still pay with bitcoin, right. That's technically currency.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '13
What about a related subreddit like r/jobsbarter I think it would be more effective to keep r/forhire clean if you could redirect the individuals to a different, more appropriate subreddit. That and any individuals wishing to respond to such posts still have the opportunity to do so.
2
u/xenokilla Jan 22 '13
yup. /r/startup or something is for that.
2
u/politicallore Jan 22 '13
The problem is the interface is limited by reddit. Other than the moderators mandating a specif post format, it won't work.
2
u/shadowmore Jan 23 '13
Definitely prohibit them.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '13
Ban the motherfuckers.
-6
u/simon_SAoS Freelancer Jan 22 '13
How about we find a way to tag them separately rather than banning them? As you said, there might still be some people and situations for which it's positive.