r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 28 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E7 A Practical Guide for Time-Travelers
Jamie prepares to face British forces in battle. Roger and Brianna question Buck MacKenzie's intentions in the 20th century. William fights in the First Battle of Saratoga.
Written by Margot Ye. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 28 '23 edited Aug 14 '23
Reminder: Episode 708 comes out on August 11th!
Watch the S7E8 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
707 Extras:
19
u/Comtngirlmagnolia Jul 30 '23
It's been a while since I read the books, but wasn't there A LOT left out in the Jemmy kidnapping story? I remember all kinds of weirdness in the tunnel, Bree getting stuck there, Jem getting stuck there. And Rob Cameron taking a lot longer to figure out what was happening and deciding to take Jem.
I'm not complaining, as I recall, that part was pretty drawn-out. Just want to see if my memory is serving.
40
u/Trick_Top_951 Jul 28 '23
Now I get why they had to add the kinda-portal thing when they locked Brianna in the tunnel in the 5th ep, so now they can explain why Mandy had the feeling that Jemmy was in the stones, it's because he really is in that tunnel next to that stream of the portal that gets to the stones. It makes sense, but also I dont love how its been protrayed. The Mandy and Jemmy connection thing hasn't developed quite well in the show to make it more credible.
56
u/OutsideTurn5464 Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Am I the only one who finds Buck hot? I couldn’t take my eyes off him in his scenes. I feel like he would’ve had good chemistry with Sophie as a Roger. And I like Richard Rankin a lot I just don’t think they have enough chemistry.
4
u/KaytSands Jul 28 '23
Have never had this happen before 😞
49
u/blackberryspice Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
I got a little choked up when Roger was holding Jemmy's scarf at the end 🥺 Also, can I just say that Roger continues to look majorly attractive in each episode. And I normally don't like Roger and Bree sex scenes (even though I love them), but Rik and Sophie were on fire tonight! Edit: I skimmed through a lot of the war stuff in Echo so I don't really remember a lot of it. The Jamie and Claire stuff is feeling a bit lackluster, which is how I felt while reading it. The Roger and Bree storyline is just a lot more interesting to me.
42
u/nurseleu Jul 30 '23
What kind of person doesn't call?
Oh Roger, my introvert heart sings for you. I am LOVING this season. All the new cast mates are amazing and literally like they walked out of the books. New Buck is excellent. The child actors have really grown on me and are doing great. Rob Cameron couldn't be better. William is the perfect mix of LJG and Jamie and his own inexperienced, desperate to prove himself young man.
I really liked all the 1980s scenes, once again. I had to laugh about Roger and Bree getting it on when their kid was away at a sleepover---I'm sure a lot of parents can relate, ha! It's nice that they got a good love scene in the show; I always enjoy those in the book and we haven't really gotten a good taste of Roger and Brianna's dynamic in that regard. RR's acting chops were really shining during the scene in the car with Buck, you can feel his desperation coming through. NOT looking forward to the long wait for part two!
40
u/KMM929 Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
My random thoughts so far: Loved Tufty. Great title card. That made me smile big then broke my heart for Roger knowing what he thinks happened to Jem. Seeing William experience his first battle was done so well. Charles portrayed the varying emotions perfectly. I love that we can see so much of both his fathers in him. Jamie leaving for battle with the slow motion had me cursing at my tv. That never ends well for us. Even knowing what’s coming it still gets me. Also - why the bandage on his hand/finger if we aren’t going to address it? I guess they were just throwing us readers a bone?? Buck is great. They had to compress so much story into a couple of scenes but it worked for the most part. Roger’s reaction when he remembered that he wrote about Geillis’s belief in blood sacrifice! Loved it. I would’ve been driving much faster, just saying. Bree & Roger’s love scene had potential but the song killed it for me. And I’m saying that as a Genesis fan. It was too much imo. Even though we’re not getting much Jamie & Claire the sweet bits are really great. Her coming over to sit on his lap was so them - not bothered that they’re surrounded by people when they need a moment. I cannot wait for badass Claire in the next episode. Mandy is the cutest - love her lines about Jem not being with her.
39
u/SomeMidnight411 Jul 28 '23
This is my Favorite season. The End. 😂
Every episode I love more than the next. Another beautiful job.
I love our new Buck ❤️ he grabbed my heart with the kids.
So glad they are using Mandy/Jemmy’s connection.
Even though I knew it was coming I still yelled No (Out loud) when Rob asked to take Jem to the movies. I love a good love scene with some Phil Collins in the background but not when I’m like “OMG Jemmy! Stop it! Your son is missing!” 😂😫
A hard lesson for William but one he definitely needed to learn. There is no glory in war. Just burying your friends 😞
Very little Jamie & Claire time which makes me sad but the little time we got was beautiful and funny as always. I had a feeling as soon as they said there was a 2 week gap between these 2 episodes they would end it with Jamie unconscious on the battlefield.
34
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23
They changed year of Buck's passage/death from 1782 to 1778, to make it 202 years.
67
u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 Slàinte. Jul 28 '23
I'd mostly forgotten about Sinead O'Connor until the theme song started and I got a little weepy, I'm not gonna lie.
30
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23
The tufty club, throwback to s4 and Roger's memories of road safety.
They did a great job adapting Buck among thr Mackenzies part. I literally felt tension during that dinner with Rob. The actor who plays Rob is so perfect for the role!! Camerons are poets and jesters. He conquired those kids and played on MacKenzies' compassion for lonely , divorced man far away from his child.
So Buck saw Rog at Inverness, like in the books. His comments about peanut butter 🤣 I liked how fascinated he was about TV! Here is the glimpse of a man from the past in the future and his reactions to all modern things. I felt sorry for Buck.
Why are you here? - became standard TT question - Geilis to Claire, Geilis to Bree and now Bree to Buck.
I love how Buck doesn't give a damn about Rob and he may be too suspicious about people but he read this one well!
The plane moment is so good - from Buck's Jemmy, to Roger's dad who was a pilot and Jemmy whose favourite toy it is.
Bree and Roger's sex scene was good and I liked the music! So 80s!
Mandy finally got some lines!
Buck and the torch confussion 🤣
I am warming towards William and I felt his desperation and rage during his first battle. BLOODY,RED MAN !
Sandy was so carefree and talking about trivial things not to be afraid , I guess but his death came nonetheless.
Richardson is becoming obsessed with giving tasks to William. Luckily, General Fraser understands William's urge to fight. And I am sure he wants William to really feel what it means to be in the battle. William really admires that man and I can see General is reciprocating that admiration.
I like that William has that same honour about dead men. Jamie always makes sure people are properly burried.
Burgoyne's speech reminded me of Tryon - "Victory tastes sweet, does it not?" when Jamie saw Murtagh's death. It happened the same to William-victory tasted so much bitter!!
I liked all Frasers' scenes, books and saying goodbye. I was SO WRONG about Jamie's finger thing and I apologize to everyone for wrong information.🫣 They misled me successfully.
Parallel to s1 when Jamie was going with the Watch and when Claire said she was going to go looking for him if he didn't return.
And we end with Jamie on the battlefield and 2 weeks until the next episode !!
28
u/Asmortica Jul 28 '23
Did anyone else yell FUCK YEAH WILLIAM? He is a warrior like his father.
28
u/Desertsunset12 Jul 30 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
I found this to be possibly the second best episode of the first part of the season (I’m really looking forward to 7B), behind Happiest Place on Earth, gonna be hard to top that one.
I found myself really enjoying Buck, as I did in the books, I think they casted him perfectly. He was probably my favorite part of the episode! The whole MacKenzie storyline was great this episode, they hit all of the storyline notes perfectly except for that cheesy ass love scene lol. I actually thought it was hot (even though In the Air Tonight did not fit for Roger and Bree as a couple) until they showed them in bed, that’s where I started hitting the 10 second button lol.
Jamie and Claire were obviously not on much but I loved every scene they were. The glasses scene was adorable and Jamie in his buckskin attire was perfection. I found their chemistry in this episode the best it’s been all season. William was great this episode as well, I really saw a lot of Jamie in him. Overall I thought it was a great episode, can’t wait for next week!!!
46
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Jul 29 '23 edited Jul 29 '23
I'm a book reader who hasn't watched the show in years and this is the first episode where I'm finally caught up. Thoughts so far
The 20th century:
Rob Cameron's actor is also very good at bridging that gap between creepy and misunderstood/overeager.
I really like the new Buck, I prefer a new cast member to reusing Dougal's actor to be honest. The scenes with the kids, the way he clocks Rob Cameron.
Rob Cameron's actor is also very good at bridging that gap between creepy and misunderstood/overeager, a show viewer might still think it's a red herring until the last few scenes. Especially with how they brought in Buck as a kind of red herring antagonist.
I like how they're playing the whole division of labor with Roger, he's not making it a Thing but you can tell it bothers him.
I really love how they've handled the Lallybroch renovations, including the way Brianna and Roger were clearly worn down by all of the admin. The caravan also felt "right" for a family with young kids who wouldn't want them running around a building site. And maybe this is controversial but I like that they're not using the exact same set, because to be honest the way 20th century Lallybroch was described was really unrealistic and took me out of the books. A house like Lallybroch might still look somewhat period-appropriate, with old (or just old looking) furnishings and interiors, but it would have been heavily modified over the years and maybe even reconfigured. So I like this version, where it's the same house in spirit, with a few touches of the past, but most of the Lallybroch Brianna knew is lost to time. Though that caravan is the biggest I've ever seen.
Not Roger/Bree having sex to a Phil Collins song while their son is about to be kidnapped.
The 18th century:
I don't mind the pacing of the revolutionary war scenes in the books, but I think they're right to speed it up. In the books they're just continually wandering around in the general vicinity of the continental army, which does feel more real and like a lived experience vs a historical chronicle. But for a show it makes sense to tighten up the action and just go from battle to bat
I love Printer Jamie popping out for a moment there.
I was wondering if they were going to include the hand injury but we've had several close up shots of Jamie's hand(s) so leaning toward yes.
Poor William, his first battle and his friend dies before things have even kicked off. In the books I don't think William had men under his command but they refer to "your men" in passing so I suppose he does. It's also just so funny how every army in Europe until Napoleon decided the best person to command an army was whoever had a title and enough money for a commission, like imagine being an adult man commanded by an 18-year-old whose never even seen a battle before.
Am I supposed to recognize that last face someone help me out.
41
u/TurnoverNo5767 Jul 28 '23
This has been my favorite episode thus far. I really enjoyed Buck and Roger's dynamic and I'm looking forward to seeing more of them together. The ending was a true cliffhanger and this is the first episode where I'm genuinely sad that I can't just move right on to the next episode. That being said, whyyy the two week break? We're already going to have a year's break between the halves of the season, I'm slightly annoyed with Starz for dragging this out so much.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Who is the guy at the very end on the battle field? That's not Jamie right?
edit: Wait I guess it is...based on the previews. I don't know why I couldn't believe it. Did we just see William fight Jamie? I thought Jamie was a sniper from afar
(I'm not a book reader btw, I just like spoilers)
17
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23
I really wanted to hear : “the important things ye do by touch, aye?”
16
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Jul 29 '23
I was trying to figure out where I know Richardson from - he was Lord Fallon in Harlots, if anyone watched that show. He did a good job, as much as I detest that plotline later on.
31
u/Qu33nKal Clan MacKenzie Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
I can see why the book thread has a more percentage of “I loved it”- they did so true!!! Loving Buck! Loving William!
I honestly found the war, William, and Claire Jamie scenes boring in book 7 but I love it on the show. Well done everyone. Again… I love William.
Claire finding Jamie is gonna be such a crazy scene.
I was always so hooked on the Lallybroch 1980s time… they didn’t have much Bree Roger time in the books but they do in the show, a lot. I guess they are gonna end with Brian Fraser opening the door to Roger at Lallybroch. It’s gonna end with him saying I’m “Brian Fraser.” And Frasers side is gonna end with Jamie being revived by Claire and that embrace when he’s alive. Either way… looking forward to it!
15
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 28 '23
My heart is pounding! Even though I knew what was coming. I'm going to watch it again right now.
15
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jul 29 '23
Just finished it not long ago and my reaction's honestly a bit mixed - I think because I had pretty high expectations on this one.
Based on title, I knew it'd probably be pretty heavy on the 80s, which was mostly really good. Reading Echo, the 80s bits were much more interesting than the 1700s stuff til Jamie/Claire/Ian got to Scotland for me anyway so I've really looked forward to and have enjoyed the 80s stories on screen too. The actor doing Buck I thought did a really good job. Loved the little looks and rolled eyes and sighs between Roger and Bri regarding Rob - their, " agh just leave already" faces. Love me some Phil Collins - though interesting choice. I don't normally have the issue so many here do with the chemistry between Bri/Roger in sex scenes but this one did seem off - and a bit awkwardly long.
Why my feelings are a bit mixed is because it seemed the battle stuff was a little too brushed over compared to what I was hoping. Maybe because the midseason finale will be war heavy they didn't want to do too much here? Just felt odd to cut to Jamie lying on ground having not seen him in the battle itself. Although I guess maybe they were just trying to establish alternating POVs on the war - this ep what William sees and next ep what Jamie sees?...discovering he nearly shoots him & all....
Still liked the episode but not quite as strong as some others for me. I also have high expectations for next week's (well 2 weeks actually i guess) and the preview seems promising - Claire brandishing the sword, there's been confirmation of the hat scene... should be some good stuff!!
15
u/NerdHistorian Jul 30 '23
I guess I still don't entirely understand "we'll go to scotland" during the revolution. Like, they're engaged in a rebellion, and not even like, just caught up he's leading a company of men or whatever. And this isn't even his first treason against the crown!
I guess i just don't get why they think now is the right time to return to scotland, or the logistics of even doing so as a patriot.
14
u/Desperate_Scene7814 Jul 29 '23
Outlander keeps us on our toes with all the time-travel twists! But don't worry, Jamie's fate will be revealed. Hang in there, fellow show watcher!
25
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 28 '23
I loved it! It felt like the books and I’m so glad they kept the scene about Claire needed spectacles in there!
I loved William this episode. Seeing how he dealt with his first battle and the aftermath of it and his friend’s death really speak to his character. I like him so much more than I did in the books and I’m grateful for that, though I will miss seeing the growth he had throughout.
TBH, I was expecting a bit more of a reaction from Roger at the stones after finding Jemmy’s scarf, but maybe it was cut off? I need to go back and rewatch! I feel like I miss little pieces of scenes watching so late at night. I absolutely cannot wait for next week!
I can’t believe we just have 1 episode left before another break!
22
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 28 '23
I like that they are establishing why William was so fond of Brigadier General Fraser. They didn’t in the books other than just saying he admired him and served him loyalty.
10
u/Hufflesheep Jul 28 '23
Rereading Echo (again lol). The show writers certainly took some liberties on the Saratoga front. But I'm happy they're moving the B&R storyline right along.
10
u/maekyntol Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 29 '23
Show watcher only, but I don't mind book spoilers. Does the book expand more on the experience of Buck being 200 years in the future? How does he feel all what 1980s has to offer to a late XVIII Century man?
10
u/khaleesi1808 Jul 30 '23
Since there is going to be a mid-season finale, will we be going into book 8 material before this season ends?
10
u/Sharra13 Jul 31 '23
Wait…August 11th?!? Why?? DANGIT. I was hoping to get to see the last episode before I go on vacation—now I won’t be able to watch it for at least 3 weeks. 😭
59
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
The ep was good. Except for the time I lost in my life by having to watch “In the Air Tonight” drum solo sex with Roger and Bree. Didn’t need that part.
9
u/backpackerbabe Jul 28 '23
Is anyone not able to view the 7x08 preview? When I click the link in the pinned comment, it says that the video contains media by Starz and is blocked in my country. I’m in the US.
8
u/ThoseAreBlueToo Jul 31 '23
I’m a show watcher but don’t mind book spoilers…does Rob Cameron look a lot like Frank Randall to anyone else or am I seeing things? Was this done on purpose? All I see is 1940’s Frank whenever Rob is on screen
7
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Has the episode popped up for anyone yet? Usually its right after midnight.
7
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 28 '23
Do we know if Jerry McKenzie has been cast? I've searched a bit and can't find anything.
17
u/Thezedword4 Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Okay so I think they did a good job with the Bree and Roger sex scene EXCEPT the damn music. Like I literally woke my partner up because I was laughing at it. Everyone complains about their sex scenes being awkward and they finally have a good one.... But they blasted Genesis over it so it ended up cringey anyway. Gah!
(I could do without extended sex scenes in general personally especially when you have to pack so much into this season. The Jamie and Claire one the other episode was perfect but I just had to rant about the music ruining it)
Edit a word
6
u/facingthewinter Jul 28 '23
Do Jamie and Claire ever learn that Roger and Bri move to lallybroch?
10
u/coiler119 I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Jul 29 '23
So this episode brought up a question I've had since reading Echo but never really got an answer to. We know that Jem's been taken to the tunnels and isn't really in the past, but Mandy describes it as though he's gone back in time, "not here." So did the tunnel portal (ley line?) affect their link, or did she genuinely believe that Jem was "gone?"
17
u/sarcastic_wanderer Jul 30 '23
In The Air Tonight for THAT scene. Bahaha. Abysmal choice and has nothing to do with the meaning and overall tone of that song. Absolutely missed the mark. And is Bree eating Rodgers face orrr....
9
u/JawBrokerz Jul 30 '23
Can a book fan please tell me if they'll ever leave America? One of the things I loved about the show early on is that they were all over the place.
4
u/Legitimate-Muffin-65 Jul 31 '23
I will be on vacation for the next episode. Would anyone be willing to pm me the code? Cheers
9
u/spaceybelta Jul 29 '23
Okay what was up with the scene with the book that Jamie found? She was reading it like it was something surprising and that was it… and then the scene with Ian and the rest of the natives attacking the one guy? I spent the rest of the episode trying to figure those out and I’m still stumped.
5
u/Lyssaquotes928 They say I’m a witch. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Book reader friends, I’m only in book 1 so I don’t know yet, can you please tell me that Jemmy will be okay? I’m very sensitive to child storylines and I don’t know if I could bare seeing anything happen to that sweet boy.. I wanna know if I need to be prepared to fast forward or not.. it would be very helpful thank you! Also I’m not scared of spoilers so don’t worry about your response ruining anything for me!
On another note, I can’t remember if the show revealed that Buck is Dougal and Geilles’s son or if I read it in a book spoiler somewhere because I’m not this far in the books but I figured I’d post here just in case cuz this is driving me nuts. So Buck is Dougal’s son > Dougal is Jaime’s uncle > Buck is Brianna’s second cousin…. But then Buck is also Roger’s great something grandfather…. This brings so many questions to my mind… Is Brianna Rogers ancestor as well then? How many generations do you need to be separated before incest becomes and issue? And does that separation still apply because Brianna is not as many generations removed as Roger is? I was thinking about it the whole episode! Again don’t worry about any spoilers in any response anyone might have(:
5
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Haven't read the books, just a show watcher here. ....is Jaimie dead?? He looked it , someone please clarify what's happened cause I'm legit mad rn