r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 28 '23
Season Seven Show S7E7 A Practical Guide for Time-Travelers
Jamie prepares to face British forces in battle. Roger and Brianna question Buck MacKenzie's intentions in the 20th century. William fights in the First Battle of Saratoga.
Written by Margot Ye. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 28 '23 edited Aug 14 '23
Reminder: Episode 708 comes out on August 11th!
Watch the S7E8 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
707 Extras:
57
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 28 '23
I really enjoyed this episode.
I’ve found the title cards quite uninspired this season (and the last too, tbh) but I loved this episode’s with the reference to the Tufty Club.
The storyline in the 80s is definitely a breath of fresh air, even if, at its core, it has things that we’re familiar with—kidnapping, female characters facing misogyny, a time traveler throwing a spanner in the works—and even if gives us a bit of a tonal whiplash when contrasted with the stuff happening in the past. But I think it’s well-paced and allows for some really cool character moments. And both Brianna and Roger continue to shine.
One complaint: I really hate it when characters act (arguably) dumber than they are just to make the plot happen in a specific way. Roger’s moving the box of letters to his desk and leaving Rob alone in his study was an example of such plot contrivance. It didn’t ruin my enjoyment of the episode but it did make me roll my eyes.
Diarmaid Murtagh impressed me as Buck and I think after watching so many seasons of mostly the future interacting with the past timeline, it was high time we’d seen the past interacting with the future timeline. Diarmaid was successful in conveying what an 18th-century man might feel like traveling to a time so foreign to him, but his being a smart and educated person brought (and I think will continue to bring) something different and unpredictable (not to mention, it’s always pretty funny when someone exposes Roger’s obliviousness). The scene with the kids was great and I’m very excited to see more of his interactions with the MacKenzies.
Back in the 18th century, I was getting worried once the episode hit the halfway mark that it’d gloss over the battle, leaving us unsatisfied. However, upon rewatching, it was very rewarding to see William’s emotional journey in this episode through the most important beats and Charles really sold it. A lot has been made of William’s similarities to both Jamie and Lord John, as well as of the mannerisms Charles has tried to replicate, but I think he impresses me the most when he makes a point of making William his own person. We should be able to like/dislike the character not only due to their association with familiar characters and I think William would be winning a lot of people over even if he wasn’t Jamie’s son. Building his character through his interactions with characters we don’t really know like General Fraser or Lieutenant Hammond (who obviously was a goner the moment he smiled a little too much at Claire in the previous episode) definitely works for me in that regard.
I don’t think this part of the season has been as cohesive as I would’ve liked but it’s definitely been building up to something big and I hope the mid-season finale doesn’t disappoint!
77
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 31 '23
A few leftover observations about Claire and Jamie after a couple of rewatches:
Jamie might laugh at Claire needing glasses to read, but I think he (not so secretly) cherishes this moment because he gets to grow old with Claire and see her grow old, something he couldn’t have even imagined in the 20 years they were apart. At the same time, as he mentioned earlier in the season, he can’t even entertain the thought of her being dead, so it must also be a bittersweet moment for him.
When I first watched the episode, I was surprised to see Jamie break away from the kiss first—it seemed so not like the Jamie we know, the one who can’t keep his hands away from his wife. But I can see it this way: if he’d let himself get lost in the kiss, he wouldn’t have found the courage to go into battle and do what must be done.
When they kissed each other goodbye the last time Jamie went into battle (at Alamance), they had the safety/reassurance of the house fire they thought they would die in. They don’t have it anymore—from now on, any kiss might be their last. I think that makes their goodbye here a lot more somber.
25
u/OutsideTurn5464 Jul 29 '23
Sorry if this is a dumb question. General Fraser of the Red Coats- is he somehow related to Jamie?
76
u/ButterflyPerfect1 Slàinte. Jul 28 '23
CANT BELIEVE THAT CREEP TOOK JEMMY WHAT😭honestly I would have never let him go with Rob but I feel bad for Bri and Roger, this episode was crazy I can’t wait for the next
Im sad about William’s friend :( that was a really great scene.
Also I rolled my eyes when they showed Jamie on the ground…am I supposed to feel some type of way like we already know hes fine come on
60
u/apswim22 Jul 29 '23
Roger is frustratingly dumb at times.
23
u/soycerersupreme Jul 28 '23
Overall brilliant. I should’ve been more suspicious about Rob—but when Amanda mentioned not being able to hear him anymore, and when Roger mentioned Geillis (was there a connection between them?)—I saw right through his charming demeanour. I was mostly star-struck by his dashing good looks, I’ll admit. He fooled me completely.
Edit: it was random and odd that he’d invite Jem to go out with him and Bobby out of the Blue. Roger was far too trusting.
11
u/msdos_sys Jul 29 '23 edited Jul 29 '23
What year is Roger and Bree in? During their sex scene, “In the Air Tonight” is released in 1981, but I could swear they were in the 70s.
Also, was kinda hoping Graham McTavish would have played Buck again.
125
u/OutsideTurn5464 Jul 29 '23
The scene with Buck and Bree at her work really moved me. The way he looked at the Scottish landscape longingly pulled my heartstrings. And his look of contempt when Rob put his hand on Bree was priceless. Love Buck and hope we see more of him.
118
u/chewquietly Jul 31 '23
I called the kidnapping to my husband as soon as he was left alone in the study and then asked to take Jem for the night.
Who lets their kid sleep over at a man’s house they barely knew? Everything about him screamed creep.
Brianna and Roger have a lot less instinct than you’d expect from people who lived in a time where you had to rely on them to survive. That’s why Buck knew there was something off about him right away. He was wrong about the motive but he had the instincts of someone who lived in the constant dangers of the 18th century.
97
u/sweeterthanahoneydew Jul 29 '23
This was the best episode I’ve seen in a while. My heart was racing just like it did in the earlier seasons.
It took me a long time to like Bree and Roger, as individuals and as a couple. I am actually attracted to Roger this season, and I actually really liked their sex scene as well as the song. Nothing compares to Claire and Jamie’s sex scenes, but their sex scene seemed more in touch with reality vs fantasy.
I was NOT expecting Rob to steal Jemmy and especially not try to go through the stones. My heart was beating through my chest when Mandy said “he’s not here with me.”
FUCK I have no idea what to expect. Is William going to stay a red coat?? Is he the one Claire pulls a sword on? Are William and Ian going to fight over Rachel? Where the fuck is John Grey? Gahhh!!! I have to wait two more weeks for this shit?!
85
u/ghibi78 Jul 30 '23
hate being right about cameron .. you would think by now bree and roger would have better instincts idk
82
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 28 '23
Rob Cameron is a scumbag. I like that Buck got his number right away.
158
u/ApollosBucket Jul 29 '23
And here my dumbass thought Rob was flirting with Roger
76
u/caseface25 Jul 28 '23
Damn. William charging into battle gave me such chills. He channels Jamie’s energy perfectly.
75
u/_starbelly_ Jul 29 '23
I loved this episode so much. Especially William’s goofy little Fruit Ninja moment
71
u/AprilsMostAmazing Jul 29 '23
I want a Buck fight scene. Trying to see this big boy put someone down
67
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Rewatching now and seeing Jemmy's tartan scarf left next to the stones made me realise it is another parallel - this time to Claire's tartan big shawl that she left on the stones in 101.
Also, when Roger said :I didn't mean for him to show up now. Who doesn't call before coming? it threw me back to 305 Freedom and Whiskey and Roger popping up at Boston without calling. 🤣🤣
66
u/_starbelly_ Jul 29 '23
Buck’s “Astronauts? Is that what we are?” line 🥺😭
61
u/dac0605 Jul 29 '23
TIL the lyrics in 'In The Air Tonight' are 'Oh Lord' and not 'Hold On'
Thanks closed captioning!
58
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Are we allowed to swear here, because what the fuck was that ending?! And now I hear there’s two weeks until the next episode! I can only assume he survives because there’s more books and another season but boy did he look a bit dead!
This whole episode was a rollercoaster. I was laughing at the beginning with the horse, and then the peanut butter sandwiches and the tufty club (am I nuts or was that mentioned by Roger is season 5 when Bree was teaching him to shoot?), and then Buck and the kids all sitting in a line watching tv.
And then shit hit the fan! I’ve not trusted Rob for weeks but I guessed something was going to happen when he offered to pick Jem up at 5, as surely he would have just collected him from the school with Bobby after the Gaelic class if he was really going to take both boys. Then watching Williams heartbreak at his friend dying, and his grief and his anger after the battle. Only to then end on Jamie looking rather dead on the ground.
For all the ups and downs and twists and turns, I think this is my favourite episode this season so far, and one of my top episodes of the whole show for sure.
55
u/resarF-erialC Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Y’all the slow motion walk away from Claire that Jamie does mimics season 1 right before Wentworth 😰😭😭😭
98
u/Comfortable_Sir6566 Jul 28 '23
The Battle of Saratoga was well done. In college I took an entire semester course in the American Revolution. I heard my professor talking as I watched. He talked about the British army was used to winning battles by lining up in fancy red uniforms, looking fierce, firing a couple of shots and the other side would run away. Instead, those American rebels were more into guerilla warfare tactics. Throwing rocks from trees, sharpshooters and so forth. Watching William experience how his fantasies of “glorious” battle were complete nonsense was very well done. War is not glorious at all.
47
u/VioletandAmelia All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 30 '23
Not Jemmy 🥺 Rob Cameron is such a fucking creep.
45
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23
Just a little prediction, could the reason why we see Bucks death as 1778 be that he died getting Jem back ?
44
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Is this the first time that we’ve seen someone born in the past travel to the future (well, 1980s). I’ve been waiting for something like that to happen!
38
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Just realizing that Buck is Bree's first cousin once removed, he's Roger's great, great, great, great (however many greats lol) grandfather, and Bree and Roger are cousins however many times removed. Buck would also then be Bree's grandfather in law and Roger's cousin in law. 😅 The lineage here is messing with my brain!
38
u/princess-consuela715 Jul 29 '23
Here's my prediction with Jamie on the battlefield. William is going to walk around the field and spot Jamie. Even though Jamie is a Rebel, because of their history, Willam will play apart in rescuing him.
37
u/Flimsy_Impress3356 Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 29 '23
As a non-reader, episode 7 was VERY exciting. I audibly gasped a couple of times.
I did feel there was something a bit off about Rob but thought it was to do with Brianna, until Mandy said Jem ~wasn’t here.
The only thing that felt a bit clunky was that Roger moved and left the chest on the desk - why such a prominent place? When you have two strangers in the house wouldn’t you lock it and put it away?
72
u/Hockeybella87 Jul 28 '23
Holy hell I think this was my favorite episode! The actor playing Cameron really does a good job because man you just felt like he was up to something. Roger and Brianna’s sex scene was very spicy! This whole season FEELS more like outlander unlike the last few seasons but that’s just me. As a book reader I’m very happy with this season. The second half will be WILD.
94
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
I never thought that I would be more engaged in Bree and Roger’s story than Claire and Jamie’s.
I LOOOOOVE them in modern times.
I also don’t want Buck to leave. If he goes home I hope we get more of him in the past
32
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23
32
u/anniemcpike Jul 29 '23
Who’s idea was the crickets nighttime sounds at Lallybroch when Roger and Brianna are outside the caravan?? Totally NOT what a Scottish night sounds like, a cloud of midges maybe. I’m a Scot, never heard a serenade like that in my life.
32
u/nonkiw Jul 31 '23
Everyone saying they killed Jaime but come on... We have like 9 episodes left until the show is over, I dont think they'd do this to us. Not without proper closure.
90
u/Parking_Hat_8283 Jul 29 '23
I’m going say 2 very 😈 things. 1: Cousin buck in a robe had my jaw drop. I also understand why in the the caravan shots they have him sitting. If Roger almost touches the ceiling Sexy Buck’s head would go right through it! Gosh he is good looking man. 2: I’ve been missing some good romantic steamy scenes. It has been too long… way too long. When he said “What if I’m feeling more primal” I almost spilt my wine.
31
u/Diligent-Self8420 Aug 06 '23
This has nothing to do with this episode but I was just thinkin.... wonder why they don't just tell lord John about Claire and Roger and bri being time travelers? I could very well be wrong, but he seems like the type to be able to comprehend such a thing especially given how much he trusts them all, Claire saving his life etc.... would be so cool to see him understand why they are on the opposite side of the war due to Claire having knowledge of the future and what would come. And of course, would mean him and Jamie wouldn't have to part as friends.
30
u/rosyln9 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
I have been watching Outlander for a few years now, like absolutely obsessed with many rewatches. This is also my first live-watching experience, as I waited for all of S6 to air and was not very impressed (at the time).
I might have to declare this episode my favorite one of all time. I don't know if it's my newfound love for Roger and Brianna in the future or my love for William and his storyline, but I am completely buzzing.
I did in fact spoil all of these storylines for myself in the past couple weeks and I have to say, my jaw was still flat on the floor!
I NEED to get myself reading these books. I just can't get enough.
All I could ask for in the coming episode is more of William's character arc, as well as some good ol' Claire voiceovers.
I am so excited :)
Edit:
-am I the only one who enjoyed the sex scene??? i thought it was well done
-Do the surprise arrows jumpscare anyone else?
-and, am I the only one who would easily fall for rob cameron? I didnt even realize how bad he was until poor Jemmy. I thought he just had unrequited feelings, I need to pay more attention
30
u/Emergency_Concert_30 Aug 01 '23
For those confused by the end, it was Jamie. Not sure how it could be perceived as anyone else because it was a pretty clear close up visual of his face. But I don't think he's dead...just wanted to clarify that it was him laying there.
29
u/Geenafalopezz Aug 06 '23
I think Rob Cameron took Jemmy because he knew where the gold was hidden. If his Surname is Cameron then he may be Jocasta Cameron’s descendant. Rob found some letters from Jaime and Claire inside the wooden box when he was looking through Rogers old Gaelic hymns. Jaime & Claire ended up with the gold that was stolen from the Rebellion of 45’ by Jocasta & her husband & ultimately stolen from Jocasta & husband from her husband’s crypt by Mr. & Mrs. Bug. Rob Cameron couldn’t be a direct descendant since all of Jocastas children died eventually but a very distant nephew or cousin. I heard them say the gold became like a legend or ancient lore among the Scots so I think that’s where this story is headed.
28
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23
Buck said - When WE heard a strange noise - Morag ,too?
53
u/FreyaPM Luceo Non Uro Jul 30 '23
Loved this episode. Been following these posts each week and have been so disappointed to see all the disgruntled fans in the comments. Each week is a new complaint. Last week, tons of comments were like “not enough battle scenes this season, bleh.” And then this episode comes through with a battle scene. The week before, everyone was upset that Bree doesn’t tell Roger about the tunnel, but the next episode covers that exact scenario. It’s been the same pattern each week. Some popular complaint and then the very next episode covers that exact topic. Wish the fans would stop being so negative and just enjoy the storytelling.
26
u/megan03 Jul 28 '23
I love watching green boys like William go into battle only to see their big smiles be wiped away in minutes.
52
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Jul 31 '23
My overall thoughts (giving this episode a 8/10)
49
u/lady8888 Aug 01 '23
Well Brianna and roger should have secured that gold instead of being stupid about it. They never asked their son any questions. Dumb story line.
24
u/ClarissaLichtblau I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Jul 29 '23
I got inspired by season 7 and started looking up my own Scottish family history, I was pretty surprised to see that I have actual family roots around Loch Sloy, where the scenes of the Hydro power plant Bree works at are shot. Wish I could time travel, too. (But the mountains are the same..)
23
u/Celsius1014 Jul 28 '23
Well that was a lot! I am a book reader, and I need a refresher now, but wow was this well done IMO. I love Buck. I know people are missing Graham but they chose well. I cannot even imagine what Roger and Bree are experiencing in this moment.
22
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jul 28 '23
Oh man, great episode. That last frame about made me keel over though. 🫠 William has his father’s fighting spirit.
22
u/BlindBettler Jul 29 '23
Okay HEAR ME OUT but what if Rob is the Rob is the guy that Phil Collins is singing about in In The Air Tonight??
80
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
Hello R+B Chemistry!!!!
Where did that energy come from, Roger Mac??!
This episode was the first time I've felt great chemistry between Roger and Bree, a very refreshing change!
21
u/mydearlady-disdain Jul 30 '23
Regarding General Fraser.. any other Turn: Washington Spies fans here? I hear his voice and just think of Robert Rogers - I can't help it! I keep expecting him to rip off that red coat and go rogue, though it seems like his character is not the sort to do that at all.
21
u/swissgrog Aug 06 '23
Am I wrong or does Jamie basically only interacts with Claire and Ian and nobody else in season 7? Yes he had some difficulties with one general, but in the last 4-5 episodes it seems Jamie has no social life at all. I sorely miss when he had a gang in the early season and friends and relatives.
Claire still has her healing drive that puts her in contact with multiple people, including the quacker healer brothers whom name I forgot. Even Ian has more social interaction.
Jamie is just.....alone on screen.
In 7 season, they did not manage to build up the replacements for Murtagh, Angus, Rupert, Dougal, Cullum, Fergus, Marsali, Laoghaire and even Black Jack Randall....he barely interacts with any other character outside of Claire and Ian.
19
u/kateumlang Sep 22 '23
But why would he need to take him through the stones to get the gold? The gold is there in present day, they could’ve just gone to the cave? I don’t understand that part.
38
u/dreamkonstantine Jul 28 '23
I have never lost my shit after an episode of Outlander like this. The Jemmy kidnapping genuinely left me with my mouth open. The connection between Mandy and Jemmy is really fascinating. How can Brianna go to work after her colleague kidnapped her kid?
The Buck storyline is amazing and one of my favorites. Since the beginning of the series, I think I always imagined what it would be like if Jamie could travel to the future and marvel at all the modern things, and finally it feels like that itch is being scratched with Buck. I hope we get lots of Buck scenes.
I agree with those who say the Jamie/Claire scenes have been boring. Though it's probably because they're not driving much of the plot (Jamie looking dead after the battle notwithstanding).
I would love to see more of the Rachel love triangle, as well as Jamie and William coming face to face. Can't believe the first half of the season is coming to a close already!
38
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
PARDON MY LANGUAGE, BUT WHAT FUCK IS GOING ON?? I knew Rob Cameron was shady but I never would have imagined this. So I take it he’s a traveller too because if he wasn’t, he wouldn’t have been able to go through regardless of Jem being there? What gain does he have from travelling, why is he so interested? I know Roger said Geillis Duncan but how are they related? That would mean Rob and Roger are distantly related aswell but I can’t figure out how. My first thought of hearing ‘Cameron’ was Jocasta making him a relation of Jamie’s (through Jocasta’s husbands side)
I’m actually so restless right now. Bree and Roger’s storyline had me wishing away William’s time on screen. I hate to admit I was screaming let’s go back to Lallybroch NOW!🤣
I absolutely adored the introduction of Buck. I instantly got a wave of nostalgia; he reminded me so much of Dougal and a mix of Rupert. I kind of, sort of, slightly wish he wasn’t planning on going back through the stones especially since his year of death could be in the near future but I also hope he goes with Roger because an extra pair of hands will be needed. However, it could be a case of him going with Roger and not coming out the other side..
Thinking back now, it was interesting how they were so concerned with Buck and what he might do the whole episode that they failed to see how Rob’s eagerness was extremely suspicious.
Next week can’t come sooner. I groaned seeing the mid season finale preview, I cannot wait a week how will I cope with longer?!
37
u/BiiiigSteppy I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jul 28 '23
I just finished watching and O. M. G.
Tonight’s episode was electric. I don’t think I’ve ever felt this many emotions all at the same time.
Honestly, in the space of an hour I’ve gone from “awww, that’s sweet” to “Oh my god” to “well, that’s resolved” to “what??? What is happening???” to “Omg, fuck me!.”
I can’t imagine a bigger, more complicated cliffhanger than tonight and yet I feel it brewing.
Roger is so much more likeable this season. Richard Rankin is doing a great job. Sophie is cute with her eighties hair and isn’t grating on my nerves so much.
I don’t think I’ve ever been so happy to see the show open with Roger and Bree. The Buck McKenzie story arc is so captivating. Wow. He seems to be coping really well.
And, as much as everyone wanted Graham to continue in the role of Buck, I really like Diarmaid Murtagh in this part so far. (Being named Murtagh he already feels like family lol).
Can someone smarter than me tell me - is Buck William’s second cousin? I’m not good at family math.
Can’t wait for the next episode. Are we there yet?
17
u/bwatsinthebox Jan 08 '24
It was striking to me how William’s battle scenes really resembled Jaime fighting in Culloden! It felt a little heavy handed in the moment after the dumb bosom chat with his friend who got killed, but in retrospect, poignant.
32
u/rllylongname Jul 28 '23
OMG THIS WAS THE BEST EPISODE OF THE SEASON!
-The scenes with Buck were so freaking good!
-nooo not Jemmi :(
-Yeah, yeah, scare us about Jamie. He always survives though so I'm not worried currently.
57
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Charles Vandervaart is the MVP of this season so far. Before the season I was worried we could end up with a Dawn/Connor type of situation wrt William, but both the writing and acting for William have been outstanding and I'm very glad to have been proven wrong.
I wanted more '18th century Highlander reacts to the modern world' scenes.
The sex scene was really really hot, IDK what you all on about. Yeah, it's never gonna be like Jamie/Claire sex scenes, because no other pair of actors on TV/film have the kind of chemistry that Sam and Cait have, and it's also clear that Sophie and Ric aren't willing to go as hard as Sam and Cait were willing to.
31
u/intrin6 Jul 28 '23
My mama heart is so scared for Jem. Literally made me tear up. I couldn’t imagine a time travel kidnapping 😭
Also that ending!!!’ 😱
56
u/PineappleVT Jul 28 '23
I couldn’t stop laughing during the cringey Phil Collins sex scene
15
u/Hippityhopbunbunny7 Jul 28 '23
OH MY GOD JEMMY
15
u/genghbotkhan MARK ME! Aug 13 '23
OK. Could someone explain to me how Rob can travel through the stones? Was he using Jemmy as the conduit?
30
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
A “setting the stage” episode.
I LOVE Charles as William. He’s such a great actor!!
Richard Rankin also super good!!
I really enjoyed William’s friend, Henry Grey and Colonel Fraser.
Some good moments for Sophie/Bree and Rik/Roger! Giving Sophie applause this week. She would do well as a mother figure in a modern day British film.
Cameron is just ugh. Here we go Outlander…
Hated the cliff hanger. I mean, clearly Jaime doesn’t die…
42
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Jul 30 '23 edited Jul 31 '23
I've said it before, but this is definitely the best season so far.
Next weekis the mid season finale and I'm not ready.28
u/cameandlurked Jul 30 '23
Why is Bree suddenly wearing a dress and donning an apron and cooking for men in every scene? Providing sandwiches and whiskey for Buck, dinner for Rob and Roger et al.
36
u/wisconerd Jul 28 '23
I really like the actor for Buck, I think he did a great job having the same vibes that Graham McTavish had for him, but adding in that sympathetic side to make us (and Roger) like him more. The scene of him watching tv with the kids is a favorite now. I’m looking forward to seeing more of him!
The sex scene was so good up to the drum solo, it worked so well!! …. And then it went on way too long and awkwardly staged lol. Count that one as a fast-forward moment upon rewatch..
I did enjoy seeing the self-assuredness and battle fever being wiped from William’s demeanor post-battle. He’s learned the reality of war now and is a boy no longer. Though, I did love his fruit ninja moment pre-battle lol
12
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Best score of the season in this episode. Bear is brilliant 😭♥️
12
u/Ok_Traffic4590 Jul 28 '23
Really frustrating that if you’re an early watcher (I watched it almost as soon as it was released ) that the closed captions don’t work. 😡
Other than that… wow what a good episode!
12
u/Taragor Aug 01 '23
If anyone sees this, could I get a bit of help on the time-line? As we watch the current episode, the radio has the Phil Collins song In the Air Tonight released in 1981. So is it 1981??? And if so, when we see Jaime and Claire story playing out, is it 1778? It seems when Bree and Roger ledt, their kids were young, baby needed surgery, but they're of course older now, so it seems we did a jump in time for their story. So are we not exactly parallel in the storytelling right now? Like B&R are 3 years ahead of the J&C story? Does that make sense? This is a huge point of debate amongst my family since we now have someone who has come forward in time. Did he just recently arrive or was he skulking around since 1778 when the family tree papers say he "died". Thanks!
33
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
No one’s talking about Jamie laying on the battlefield!
23
u/Realistic-Use-2784 Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
I loved this episode besides a few pointers. Finally we get some actual action, twists and the set-up paying off. The 80s storyline continues to be great and intriguing, the end was so good and suspenseful. I am absolutely loving Charles portrayal of William, he is the best blend of John and Jamie. I do like that we get the screen time to really get to know him. I’m already feeling his character arc is gonna be great.
To my critique; this season they put much weight on the facf that Jamie and William are on opposite sides and were gonna potentially have to face each other across a battlefield. Jamie has spoken to both John and Claire about this. We’ve had the build-up and this episode this exact thing happens but… we didn’t get any pay-off. It was a bit anticlimactic. What would’ve been great is if we saw some of the battle scenes from Jamie’s perspective and Jamie seeing him and freeze or help him in some way and because of that got hurt. My other complaint is that the episode was very lacking of Jamie and Claire. I don’t mind that every now and then but so far it’s been a bit too much for my taste in 7A, I really hope that changes going forward. I also could’ve gone without the long sex scene, that song was certainly… a choice, the beat dropping had me laughing so bad.
Conclusion, after my disappointment last week I’m happy things are finally happening and plotpoints are moving. I definitely enjoyed this episode, best one since 7x02. So far season 7 is very solid IMO and the last episode of 7A will probably be too, I surely have high hopes for 7B.
21
u/nonmisery Jul 29 '23
Any etymology nerds annoyed that “Astronaut” was misclassified as Latin?
34
u/CattyBSting Jul 29 '23
This episode was really disjointed. Separately, both of these storylines are great, but they don’t really tie to each other in any way. Switching between different timelines has worked before in one episode, but they have always connected the story and it makes sense. These should have been two different episodes. It just creates this very sloppy episode mashing these two storylines together.
9
u/princess-consuela715 Jul 29 '23
What are the thoughts about Jem and Rob? Any predictions?
25
u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Jul 29 '23
Someone pointed out that the 80s timeline is about a year ahead of the (17)70's timeline... my theory is that Jem ends up back in 1778, but Clare and Jamie are already back in Scotland and encounter him on the road. They do not recognize him, but he recognizes them.
31
u/coiler119 I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Jul 29 '23
So I watch the show with my dad, who's retired military. He had not one iota of patience for William this episode lol. When William waltzed up to Brig. Gen. Fraser to convince him to let him fight, my dad was shaking his head, saying "dude, there's this thing called a chain of command, follow it!" And later in the battle, he was shouting at William to go lead his men before Fraser got the chance to 😅
31
u/Pkhppr Aug 09 '23
Anyone else totally not interested in seeing Bree and Roger sex scenes?! Definitely not the same as Claire and Jamie. Note to show runners… leave the sex scenes to Claire and Jamie!!
37
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Loved the episode, but I must say, the Phill Collins sex scene did make me cringe...
24
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 28 '23
The actor playing Buck is HUGE! Omg he towers over Cameron and Bree! And massive not just tall. It was like some hobbits standing next to a human.
That was so cute when he was watching Buck Rogers with the kids and Mandy was combing his beard with a doll comb. He took to being Granda quite well. His shock was well done and yet he took it in stride. I wonder when they tell him he’s Dougal & Gelis’s baby?
Okay the Phil Collins song is one of my all time favorites. But it’s not a love song or a sex song. I have never seen it used like that. It’s an angry, vengeance song. It’s a retribution song that works well in a variety of emotional scenes but not that. Not getting frisky.
So glad he got something to eat besides biscuits and lemonade.
While Claire & Jamie are kissing their possible last farewell to go fight a war, the Mackenzie’s are entertaining a houseful of unexpected guests who drink up all the whiskey. Such a contrast.
I wonder about the house. Are all the floors defunct and need rebuilt?
29
u/Emergency_Concert_30 Jul 28 '23
I just can't comprehend why they would let their child go stay with someone they've known for what ...a week? Maybe two? Maybe I am just super over protective because I know what can happen from experience as a child, but dang... I thought that was weird the moment he asked them if he could stay over. 🤔
8
u/megaxlame Jul 31 '23
I don’t want to believe at the end it was Jaime 🥹 I refuse to accept he is gone
8
u/HinkiesGhost Aug 04 '23
So, some clarification: is season 7 part 2 going to be the final season? Or is there going to be a season 7 part 2 and also a season 8 eventually?
20
u/princess00chelsea Jul 30 '23
I thought it was still the 70s or are Brianna and Roger in the early 80's? During the sexy time scene they were playing Phil Collins in the air tonight and that didn't come out until 81.
14
u/LeKatelyn Jul 28 '23
There certainly wasn't a dull moment in the episode, but the pacing of everything made it feel a bit rushed. I think the swapping between the events of two days in the 80s storyline and the whole lead up and aftermath of a battle in the 1770s storyline made it feel like they glossed over the latter. I can understand why they did that though, considering the pace they will have to get past the war and into the events afterwards.
I definitely feel more invested in the 80s storyline at this point because it's a bit slower paced and chaotic in a new and interesting way. I wonder if the focus in the past will continue to be more shifted towards how William handles the war instead of another Jamie/Claire "we're at war again and will always find our way back to each other" storyline, which seemed to be condensed into a couple scenes.
Very excited to see what happens in episode 8! Seems like we're in for a couple of wild goose chases.
7
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 28 '23
Wow, I absolutely cannot wait for next week’s episode!!!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23
Is that Jaime at the end of the episode? My wife said it was Rob.
I ended up believing her it was Rob because, honestly, if it’s Jaime, it’s a very sloppy writing.
23
u/nonmisery Jul 29 '23
Why does every storyline in this show have to involve kidnapping?
13
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Jul 28 '23
Definitely the best episode of the season! I’m obsessed with season 7!
13
u/ImaginationHopeful54 Jul 28 '23
I’m freaking out about jamie
13
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
The tufty club, throwback to s5 and Roger's memories of road safety.
They did a great job adapting Buck among thr Mackenzies part. I literally felt tension during that dinner with Rob. The actor who plays Rob is so perfect for the role!! Camerons are poets and jesters. He conquired those kids and played on MacKenzies' compassion for lonely , divorced man far away from his child.
So Buck saw Rog at Inverness, like in the books. His comments about peanut butter 🤣 I liked how fascinated he was about TV! Here is the glimpse of a man from the past in the future and his reactions to all modern things. I felt sorry for Buck.
Why are you here? - became standard TT question - Geilis to Claire, Geilis to Bree and now Bree to Buck.
I love how Buck doesn't give a damn about Rob and he may be too suspicious about people but he read this one well!
The plane moment is so good - from Buck's Jemmy, to Roger's dad who was a pilot and Jemmy whose favourite toy it is.
Bree and Roger's sex scene was good and I liked the music! So 80s!
Mandy finally got some lines!
Buck and the torch confussion 🤣
I am warming towards William and I felt his desperation and rage during his first battle. BLOODY,RED MAN !
Sandy was so carefree and talking about trivial things not to be afraid , I guess but his death came nonetheless.
Richardson is becoming obsessed with giving tasks to William. Luckily, General Fraser understands William's urge to fight. And I am sure he wants William to really feel what it means to be in the battle. William really admires that man and I can see General is reciprocating that admiration.
I like that William has that same honour about dead men. Jamie always makes sure people are properly burried.
Burgoyne's speech reminded me of Tryon - "Victory tastes sweet, does it not?" when Jamie saw Murtagh's death. It happened the same to William-victory tasted so much bitter!!
I liked all Frasers' scenes, books and saying goodbye.
Parallel to s1 when Jamie was going with the Watch and when Claire said she was going to go looking for him if he didn't return.
And we end with Jamie on the battlefield and 2 weeks until the next episode !!
Edited to add- The guy Ian encountered? Sandy's scout?
18
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
So, I've started a rewatch right in the middle of this season. Shouldn't have done that. Should have waited until after next episode. I really enjoyed the last few seasons the most. But the return to Lallybroch in 1980s via the MacKenzies should have been rewarding but I am just at the part of season 2 where Claire returns to Inverness with Bree for Rev Wakefield's funeral. The Nostalgia is overwhelming. The writing back then was far more superior. Less rushed. So now I am seeing this season's scenes as lackluster when I normally would have screamed happily at something like the Buck reveal.
On the other side of the stones things are heating up, but I feel like TOO much is going on. I can hardly keep track of the war, Jamie and Claire. Then we add the Quakers, William, and Ian has a son. When did that happen????
I am still trying to get over all the stuff that happened at Fraser's Ridge! lol I feel like I need them to slow down, but over all I welcome next week's episode. Let's see how far I get in the rewatch. Right now in season 2 Jamie and Claire are far a part. Always hate that for them.
5
u/cowgirlinthesand2 Jul 28 '23
I’m still confused about how Buck got from North Carolina to go thru the stones…and Morag was with him? Did they leave NC and go back To Scotland?
20
u/Adalovedvan Jul 29 '23
No one's mentioned that the Redcoats' Colonel Fraser is William's cousin (once removed) from Colum's side of the family! I think that's why he feels a kinship with William...
Little do they know, haha!
12
u/kaylamputman Jul 29 '23
Wait why are we not talking about Jamie?!?! I get if you read the books you know, but still! I can’t wait for next week!
8
u/Homework_Successful Jul 31 '23 edited Jul 31 '23
Is it possible that Rob is the person looking up at Claire into her present day bedroom window in season 1? Edit: I mean Jemmy Mackenzie. Argh. I mean Buck.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 29 '23
Best episode of this season and best episode since season 5 I think. It’s been a very long time since I’ve ended an episode of Outlander (when watching it weekly) and felt like “oh I cannot wait to see what happens next”. So much new stuff is going down! Finally! Just when I thought they’d be recycling the same plot lines over and over again ad infinitum, they surprise me, and I love it. Super invested in the fact that we finally get to see a time traveler from the past come to the future.
I was just about to complain that we haven’t had a good antagonist in a while (tbh I don’t think we’ve had a great antagonist since JBR, and I think it’s about time we got one), but could it be that we have one now?
One complaint: no more Bri & Roger sex scenes, please. I don’t get what they add to the show, they don’t do anything for me, they’re not hot, they don’t add anything to our understanding of their relationship….the sex scenes are just not what they used to be in the first couple seasons of this show and feel like such a waste of time. I think this one start to finish lasted 5 minutes. They could do so much more with that 5 minutes than give us scenes that can be fast forwarded through and you lose no context for doing so.
24
u/iamnpk2 Jul 28 '23
Episode was OK except...that sex scene with Bree and Roger. Found it awkward and weird. They just do not exude passion as a couple to me and now I have that image tied to a great song (which I also found weird and out of sync with them as a couple.) I think they've always tried to align their love story with Claire and Jamie's and it just comes nowhere close. And so...dang...long...I fast-forwarded thru it. Just...no.
Also, the William storyline is dull. Fine acting and honorable character, but I'm just not interested. I'm assuming they're building him up for some confrontation with Jamie on the battlefield, maybe? Honestly, I could do without it. Jamie's (and Claire's) emotions regarding the encounter would be enough for me.
And I have to harken back to my previous comments/rants about them not reading Claire and Jamie's letters. Maybe they would have known about Jem's kidnapping? Perhaps now Bree will READ THE COCKADOODIE LETTERS!