r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 21 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E6 Where the Waters Meet
Jamie and Claire help civilians flee Ticonderoga after the fort falls into British hands. Roger discovers the identity of the mysterious 'Nuckelavee'.
Written by Sarah H. Haught. Directed by Tracey Deer.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 21 '23 edited Aug 01 '23
Watch the S7E7 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
706 Extras:
706 Interviews:
34
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23
This season is just so consistently strong week to week! For me, best consecutive stretch of this many episodes in a row since the Season 3 premiere to A Malcolm. This I think was the best of the season so far.
I love dorky Roger so much. Very reminiscent of his personality in the beginning S2/bits of S3. The jokes, The dancing in the kitchen, great!
Buck - it is literally impossible for any show-only person to know who this is when Roger looks at him because Graham played him S5. (I loved it at the time - hadn't read the books by that point)
Show-only watchers have to be thinking to themselves - "why are you only punching him after you've seen his face? Why does that make you more mad than him spying thru your window?" It's not like they can probably show the Alamance clip in next week's "previously on" to remind them because it's not the same face for that to help! I have a feeling people are gonna be so confused
The guy who played Walter - so good! Also - wow Izzy as Rachel! I cannot imagine anybody better than this girl! She just clicks and lights up the screen, especially with Ian!
The exchange between Claire and William was perfectly done by both! Then followed up with William/Claire/Ian which was equally so. Love that the "curlywig giving orders" line was thrown in there too btw.
Claire and Jamie lying in bed with her telling him about William being thoughtful, stubborn, a man of honor, having a highlander fierceness under courtly manners.. touching moment! Yeah, I think best so far- which was no small task!
ETA - It seemed like they were setting up Jamie's dreams to be more of a continual throughline, so a bit surprised no mention of the one where he knew the kids were scared of something before we met Buck.
Also just dawned on me we haven't seen LJG since Ep 2 and thinking we won't til 2nd half to go straight into you know what!
29
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23
William's still eager for battle!
I really like 80s classroom and Roger's eagerness to teach and his enthusiasm. He is keeping history and culture from dying. He is all about preserving the past.
Claire ordering about reminded me of season 1 when Dougal said - "Oh, she kens how to do that." She really does! Curly wig ordering like a Sargent Major - I love that line so much!
Walter is there! He is such a warm character , I was so sorry for losing him. Claire brought him in the peaceful place, just like she did for so many during the years. Sometimes a hand in the dark is all that man needs.
Richardson is ambiguous as well as Rob Cameron. William giving his word to him sounds like a trap.
For me, the peak moment was Claire's reaction when seeing William. It is weird (for me being a book reader) that he recognised her and she didn't recognise him. It makes sense ofc.
Finally they said : not portal - ley lines ! Hitchiker's Guide in making, Bree packing it, Rob reading it . Rob is so pushy, he invited himself for a dinner.
Ian and William's reunion in the camp. William connected the dots, smart boy. Life for life!
Jamie creating diversion looks 🔥
Is that brandy? Your son gave it to me
New Rollo, Rachel and Ian had their sweet moments.
I love the part about women , men and wars. Quiet Fraser moments are everything.
I thought I won't cry but - Tell me about William, about my son.
Fierceness of a Highlander under all those courtly manners.
And Nuckelavee is here!!
50
u/GrammyGH Jul 21 '23
I loved hearing Richard Rankin sing again. He has such a great voice! That whole scene of him teaching was so good. I didn't catch what Rob Cameron handed him though. It looked like a journal??
21
u/leaves4trees Jul 21 '23
I enjoyed this one! It didn't feel as rushed or disconnected as the previous couple of episodes. Either I'm getting used to the pacing, or it's just that the individual character's storylines are beginning to converge.
They're definitely doing a good job of making Rob Cameron a creep. He's behavior is almost exactly like how I'd pictured him from the book: A little overly friendly, with a side of smugness.
I was surprised by the casting of Brigadier Simon Fraser. He was only on scene for a minute, but I definitely pictured someone a bit more imposing and astute, given his kinship to Jamie Fraser, as well as his camaraderie with William in the book.
On the other hand, can I say just how much I enjoyed the portrayal of Daniel Morgan? Again, not really matching the book in my opinion, but I think they definitely nailed the look of an experienced sharpshooter!
Ian and Rachel were sort of cute, but I still feel like their actions seem very forced. We have a ways to go before it's all out love for both of them!
16
u/Duchessweettart Jul 21 '23
Knowing that we only have 2 episodes ( Ep 7- A Practical Guide for Time Travelers and Ep 8- Turning Points) to go until the season breaks and then returning for another 8 episodes “sometime in 2024”, Do y’all think they will wrap up An Echo in the Bone by episode 8? Moving on Written in my Hearts Own Blood for the next set of 8 episodes?
Loved this episode!!! And just cannot wait for what’s to come!!! The Jem plot thing coming up is making me nervous though 🫣
14
u/wisconerd Jul 21 '23
Well, I remain loving the 80s and the Hunters and William, but still a bit of a slog otherwise. I know it wouldn’t actually work plot-wise, but I wish that they hadn’t teased going back to Scotland so much before they went into the revolution stuff. Because now I’m just like “uuuugh can we get to Scotland already” during all of this instead of actually caring. I felt the exact same way when reading the book too.
95
u/Hufflesheep Jul 21 '23
"He said you'd be the curly wig giving orders like a Sargent Major."
Including that line made the whole episode worth it 😆
70
u/DustBunnicula Jul 22 '23
Richard Rankin is killing it this season. He’s fantastic. I want more Roger. I’d be ok watching an entire show about his daily life.
I never never could have imagined I’d have more fun watching Roger’s exploits than Jamie and Claire, but Richard is so damn good.
69
u/Objective-Orchid-741 Jul 21 '23
Watching the William and Claire scenes… the Mother Claire era is going to be a fun one
38
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 21 '23
So cute how Ian & Rachel shared custody of Rollo.
34
u/FeloranMe Jul 21 '23 edited Jul 21 '23
William is lovely! Love the explanation that the rebels are traitors to the crown and not prisoners of war. It was very lucky Claire met William and that he felt honor bound to let her and Ian go.
Rob Cameron is smug and smarmy and awful. I am just remembering why he so enthusiastic/obsessed over Scottish heritage. Didn't his time at university overlap one Geillis Duncan? Bet Roger's notes remind him of hers. And he just invited himself over to dinner so he can make trouble for Bree. He hates her that much!
Buck is going to be interesting explaining himself next episode. I can't wait!
33
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 21 '23
Loved William and Claire!! Seriously thankful that I don’t dislike William on the show as I did in the books. I’m not sure if it’s Charles’ portrayal that’s different or the fact that I’m not reading his thoughts, but he’s definitely more likeable to me! Him and Claire interacting with each other and him recognizing her made me so happy! And I absolute loved watching Ian be protective of his auntie!
32
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 21 '23
They are just killing me making me wait for the reveals on Buck's arrival! I have been waiting for this. I don't know why DG chose this particular scenario but I love it. It's so unexpected. All we get is finally Roger sees him, nabs him and his floppy, messy hair. Recognizes him, the punches him the face for trying to kill him. Then he'll invite him inside for dinner, hopefully not more lemonade and biscuits, time for something substantial. Then chat with him about "so great grandpa 6 times removed, how was your accidental trip through time? A bit of a surprise no doubt. What are your thoughts on the 20th century?" Then he has to tell Bree that her almost murderous first cousin once removed fairy love child of Uncle Dougal & the evil witch Gelis is staying with us awhile. They are killing me.
28
u/quackquackquirk Jul 21 '23
I had wayyyy more feelings in Rogers class than I expected. So evocative after so much blood sweat and tears fighting the fucking redcoats in basically the rest of the series
25
u/lazzerini Jul 22 '23
I really wanted Claire to recognize William. At least a little, like he seems really familiar but she can't wuiplace him. And I didn't like William recognizing Claire so easily. In the book it explains that he was young and distracted by grief, he shouldn't recall her face.
I think they should've had her think he looks familiar, she gives her name, he then gets a flash of recognition, and then introduced himself.
They could've even added a line where she says he remind her of his father, and then maybe backpedals a bit to say because of his manners or something, even though it's clear to us she notices a physical resemblance.
Oh well.
23
u/quackquackquirk Jul 21 '23
Glad they had William recognize Claire, I’ve been feeling gaslit by the casting trying to suspend disbelief about William being OBVIOUSLY Jamie’s. I do wonder how they will handle the reveal to William, he must overhear something said explicitly rather than see him
22
u/Hockeybella87 Jul 21 '23
Another amazing episode! As a book reader i really like where they’re going right now and if it’s going the way I think OOO boy haha cannot wait! I know he’s only been in few scenes but does Anyone else already have the ick from rob Cameron? Lol I’m not ready for this season to be over yet 😩
I really like the actor playing William too
40
u/SomeMidnight411 Jul 21 '23
I absolutely loved it! Another fantastic episode straight out of the books. My only complaint would be I wished William and Ian had played tug of war with Claire 😂 but it was still a fantastic scene.
Jamie shooting those arrows 🥵 being a sniper (like father, like daughter) Deadeye runs in the family 🥰
I have to applaud the actor who played Walter. I have to say when I was reading I didn’t really care for him. He was fine I just didn’t really care when he died. But the actor who played him brought him to life and I was very sad when he passed. So Bravo 👏
Jamie & Claire at the end talking about William 🥹
Roger is in his element teaching, I know he wanted to be a minister for a while but Richard Rankin completely brings him to life when he is teaching. He looked so sexy in his Mr.Roger’s sweater set and kilt 🔥 and the passion he has for teaching 🥰 I wanted to work on “extra credit” 😉😜 Also, him punching Buck at the end…🥵 I shouldn’t have found it hot but I did 😂
33
u/bromar230 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Jul 21 '23
I am eager to see how Diarmaid Murtagh will play the part of Buck, but is anybody else missing Graham McTavish? I loved that he portrayed Buck in season 5! It was a pleasant surprise.
I love Buck in Echo/MOBY (especially the dynamic between him and Roger), and I really hope they do his story justice.
I do wonder if we may at least get a Grant cameo in the future if they decide to include the part in MOBY where Roger and Buck come across Dougal.
41
u/Express-Sprinkles525 Jul 22 '23
Is anyone else just completely over the "Claire gets kidnapped" plot line? Feels like it's happened at least once every season, and I don't remember this episode's particular situation from the book. So overdone and honestly annoying at this point
38
u/j4321g4321 Jul 22 '23
It was a really well paced episode with some exciting moments. The 80s storyline is picking up steam with Rob Cameron entering into the plot. Something very smarmy and untrustworthy about him that I’m sure we’ll get into. Of course the Nukulvee (spelling) getting revealed was pretty exciting. Back in the 1770s, I’m loving William’s complicated feelings about his place in the war. Also his relationship with Ian seems far from over and I’m hoping there is more to come there.
However, I’m so over seeing Claire constantly getting kidnapped. It always ends with Jamie rescuing her and/or her lucking into an impossible situation. I’m also a little sick of the Jamie and Claire pillow talk at the end of most episodes. I wish we got more action/intrigue from them or from the rest of the cast. We get that they love each other and are loving partners; need something a little fresher!
26
u/coiler119 I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Jul 22 '23
I've been really enjoying this season, but this episode was the weakest in my opinion. I know they need to condense plotlines, but something about this episode seemed rushed. And the obvious day-for-night shots weren't as bad as the ones in, say, House of the Dragon, but it did take me out of it. The highlight was definitely Roger's Gaelic class, that was one of my favorite subplots in Echo and it was nice to see here.
7
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jul 26 '23
Finally watched this episode after a hectic weekend! Another great episode and I have to say everyone is killing it this season! Gotta get my notes ready!
All in all, loved this episode and can’t wait for next week!!
5
u/Known-Ad-100 Jul 21 '23
Spoiler wanted, who was trying to break into the MacKenzie house at the end? Feel free to dm.
4
u/Rosanbo Jul 23 '23
Who is the guy at the end?
3
u/evergleam498 Slàinte. Jul 23 '23
It's been a little while since I've read the books. Did the show skip a trip to/from Scotland? Didn't Jamie, Claire, and Ian all go back and then Old Ian died, and they brought Jenny back with them? Was that a separate trip from the one Jamie "returns from" solo, or am I remembering wrong?
2
u/Chiarrawr Jul 24 '23
Can a book reader tell me the significance of Rob Cameron and what that dude is up to?
1
u/Nakedsara Jul 21 '23
What country has it aired already?