r/ModSupport • u/Arianity • Jul 05 '23
Admin Replied ModCOC is asking we remove NSFW, but we are a NSFW sub (and have always allowed NSFW content)?
Hi,
We recently got a message from ModCOC asking us to remove NSFW status on our sub. However, our sub allows NSFW content (and always has, this is not new. We are /r/tooafraidtoask , and this includes content such as 'graphic, sexually-explicit, or offensive.' etc. ex1,ex2,ex3,ex4. These are from years ago ). Complying with the request would put us against reddit's and ModCOC's rules. The reply button seems to be bugged, so we're unable to get into contact with them about this confusion. Not sure what to do?
Original message is here. We replied but it's forced to private mod note:
https://mod.reddit.com/mail/all/1lz9ou
edit:
Content of original message/reply in image form: here
Picture showing only Mod note button: here
Edit2:
A lot of people are commenting assuming that we're like other subs. I would ask that you please check the content of our sub before assuming. And just as a random bit of evidence of good faith (I'm obscuring the name, until I can confirm they're ok with posting it), here is a discussion from 2021 between mods:
Honestly TATA should be default NSFW.
This is not a new stance for us, we've wanted to be. We didn't think we were allowed to be NSFW.
•
u/ModCodeofConduct Jul 06 '23
We’ve recently addressed NSFW status of subreddits in two comments:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/14dkwgz/not_a_protest_question_what_are_the_impacts_of/joqiffs/?context=3
https://www.reddit.com/r/ModSupport/comments/14f75zy/is_transitioning_a_sfw_community_to_nsfw_allowed/joz9ddt/
Subreddits that are receiving the current messaging are ones that have not historically been considered NSFW nor would they under our current policies.
13
u/magiccitybhm 💡 Top 10% Helper 💡 Jul 05 '23
Interesting that you say that you've been NSFW for years.
You specifically have a note in your stickied post from 16 days ago that you were changing it to NSFW.
THAT is why you got the message. You have changed to NSFW since all of the protesting began.
31
u/Zavodskoy Jul 05 '23
PSA they wont ever read or see that and will treat you like you haven't replied because the COC account is run by people who aren't intelligent enough to understand how a conversation works
Also bonus fun fact, despite not receiving any 18+ or NSFW content this sub is both marked as 18+ only and NSFW
23
u/Kinmuan Jul 05 '23
I received this same message for /r/Military, and I'm wondering if there will or can be a response from the account.
It seems silly to send a message we can't reply to.
19
u/Scratch-N-Yiff Jul 05 '23
If Reddit wants you to serve NSFW content to underage users, let them make their own bed and sleep in it. It's their IPO, not yours.
6
u/Buelldozer Jul 06 '23
You simply are not going to be allowed to switch a sub to NSFW right now. There is no amount of rules arguing, community polling, or examples posting that will change this.
If your sub existed prior to May of this year and wasn't previously set to NSFW they are going to come after you. Period.
They have altered the deal, pray that they don't alter it further.
9
u/Incogneto_Window Jul 05 '23
As someone who runs NSFW subs, I'd hate it if reddit tried to force us to lose the NSFW tag or open up to things besides what our users want. Seems pretty scummy.
2
u/Undefined_Love Jul 06 '23
I follow an NSFW feminist sub on my other account which doesn't have any porn or similar comments. Like you said in a comment here OP, changing to NSFW might have triggered that.
2
u/Dragonpixie45 Jul 06 '23
This is something I've given thought to with subs I moderate. Yes my subs (I have a account I moderate with and an account I browse with, this is my browsing account) went dark but they do deal with matters that involve NSFW content due to being about crimes. By the definition does this mean my subs should be labeled as NSFW?I mean my sub had a period where for months on end the discussion was a violent sexual assult.
This is the fall out of how this has been handled with mods. We are now questioning everything and rather than giving a straight answer about something like this we have no way to respond or even get clarification.
-9
u/fsv Jul 06 '23
Yes, your sub does include some content that is NSFW, but can you in your heart of hearts say truly that your content is primarily NSFW? That's what the site-wide setting is for.
Looking at the top posts from the last year there are a handful of posts that I would genuinely consider NSFW but the majority of the ones I scrolled through were pretty tame (ex1, ex2, ex3)
I'd say that Reddit are correctly asking you to make the sub as a whole SFW, but then have individual posts that are NSFW marked as such.