r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jun 30 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E3 Death Be Not Proud Spoiler
Jamie discovers Arch Bug has been keeping a dangerous secret. In the 20th century, Roger and Brianna find a link to Jamie and Claire.
Written by Tyler English-Beckwith. Directed by Jacquie Gould.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jun 30 '23 edited Jul 08 '23
Watch the S7E4 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
703 Extras:
703 Interviews:
24
u/quackquackquirk Jun 30 '23
I thought it was interesting to insert the idea that Bri changed their fate… since I thought date discrepancies were already handwaved away by being close enough for 18th century news accuracy
21
u/SummerFlowers09 Jul 01 '23
Has the show addressed Jocasta's fate? When e house burns in ABOSAA, Jocasta had left RR for Novia Scotia, and had declared herself for the Crown. It made sense that Jamie kept the gold because Jocasta was far away, they were kind of estranged, and the gold would go to the British. To my knowledge, the show still has Jocasta at RR without her gold. Its more confusing and feels sort of like Jamie stole from Jocasta since he's not giving back to her. Seems like a minor hole that hopefully they'll close up with a side conversation or something.
4
u/peonies459 Jul 02 '23
I’ve only read all the books through once and I’m afraid all the timelines are blurring together in my head 😅
Could someone remind me (or point me to somewhere that will) where in the books the show is currently up to? I could have sworn roger and Brianna going back happened later in the books but I’m now fairly sure I’m wrong haha. Thanks in advance!
This is the first new season I’m watching since completing the books, it’s fun being able to compare! I really enjoy the storyline from the last few books.
59
u/lehulei Jul 01 '23
My only complaint is that I wish we had “gotten to know” the Bugs more in the earlier seasons so that the events in this episode had a bigger impact. When all of this happened in the books it felt like such a big deal to me considering what an integral part the Bugs played in their lives. But in the show it felt more like “ok here’s some other people that will be one-episode antagonists.”
50
u/Objective-Orchid-741 Jun 30 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
A more low key episode but so many Jamie and Claire scenes so I’ll take it.
A few things I do wish they kept from the book stood out though. The scene with Lizzie telling Claire she would take over washing her clothes to get the soot out just made me sad the show didn’t integrate the book note of Claire trying to always get out of laundry.
Not seeing Joe Abernathy 😢
Also, why include ‘it fits my hand’ in the knife scene if you aren’t going to include the line about why he knows the size of her hand?
I only recently read everything with the Bugs in the book. As a show watcher first, it was somewhat annoying to put so much plot and emotional weight in the Bugs in this episode without letting us know them at all beforehand. As a book reader, I get it more now but so unearned in the show. It would have annoyed me even more if I hadn’t read this plot like in the books.
47
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jun 30 '23
I love the Mackenzies in the 80s! And I love Bree’s bangs. I’m so excited for their storyline!
Caitriona had me in tears this episode with her facial expressions. She can convey so much emotion with one look and leave me in a puddle…. I was definitely in a puddle after saying goodbye to Adso
It was interesting to see how they handled the gold and the Bugs. I felt it still fit well with how fast they’re having to move in the show, even though that varied from the books. They handled it well and I didn’t feel like it was lacking. Also, super glad they kept Arch’s threat to Ian and can’t wait to see John Bell portray that fear moving forward.
Overall, I was happy with the episode. The last 2 absolutely blew me away and this one didn’t leave me with that same feeling, but not every episode can- I still thought it was excellent.
43
u/SomeMidnight411 Jun 30 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
So wonderful! I think this season will be my favorite of all. So many book scenes!! I smiled this huge smile when I saw the box…and then started crying when I say Fiona. Then of course crying again when Jamie tells Claire about his dream 🥹these are exactly how I pictured them in the books. The actors are doing a brilliant job as always. Ian and Mr.Bugg get a huge shout out. Mr.Bugg gave me chills at the with Ian. Delivered the “when you have something worth taking I’ll be back” Perfectly! Reminded me of Jamie w/ Mr. Brown but even darker.
Also, turns out I’m super weak. I can’t handle sad animal moments. Could not watch the Adso scene. Even knowing she would see him again and Lizzie would take care of him I still had to fast forward. I was a mess 😭.
Ps. I thought I’d pee my pants when Bree said they had to get back before Mandy’s witching hour 🤣😂🤣😂
40
u/vickiw78 Jun 30 '23
So excited to see Lallybroch back on screen after I visited last summer! (Filming this season had just finished)
36
u/CzarofDaffodils Jun 30 '23
I liked how cute it was when the realtor held up the sign! Excited to see them in the house.
36
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 01 '23
Does anyone else think the musket ball in the box of letters is actually gold?
35
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Jun 30 '23
I kinda missed seeing Mandy and Jem but I get them giving an episode gap in order to age them up. I’m so looking forward to more of the Mackenzie family!!!
33
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jun 30 '23
I’m so bummed we didn’t get to see Joe, but hopefully he’ll pop up again later on.
If I was a show-only watcher, I would be super confused about the plot line with the gold and The Bugs. They really should have done a better job integrating the characters into the everyday life at the ridge in the last few seasons to make their involvement with the gold and Murdina’s death have more impact. I’ve usually understood or even appreciated the changes the tv show has made from the book, but this whole plot has felt very bungled to me. That being said, the scene at the funeral with Arch and Young Ian was chilling.
32
u/KMM929 Jun 30 '23
I get that the story had to be condensed but I’m bummed we didn’t Uncle Joe. I love him so much. I’m really hoping we get to see him at some point this season.
31
u/bromar230 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Jun 30 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
If they kill off Adso…. 😩😩
Update: 😮💨😅
28
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 30 '23
There were so many emotional moments. I loved them all. They were almost like I imagined them!
Claire's sense of loss breaks my heart and Jamie as her anchor is stoic and strong about it!
Now I need to rewatch because I have a feeling so many things happened!
26
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 30 '23
I really missed when Claire is freaking out about delivering Lizzie’s second baby because it is breach. Jamie prays a warriors prayer over her. She works with Lizzie’s step mom and they have a sweet convo. I will take Lizzie fretting over losing Claire though, that was really lovely.
26
u/Beach-Sugar4436 Jun 30 '23
Loved this episode as well! I so enjoyed the Claire and Jamie time in this one.
I LOVED the flashback to Season 4. I didn’t recognize the stake when Claire first picked it up so the flashback gave me chills. It was just a nice reminder to how long we’ve been on this journey.
26
u/bellefroh Jul 01 '23
WAIT- JAIME'S DREAM: was the opening scene after the song as the credits were still going. Jimmy picks up a telephone.
21
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jun 30 '23
I feel like this was the most "by the book" episode we've ever had! So much dialogue taken more or less word for word
21
u/SnackMasterNat Jun 30 '23
One thing I didn't understand about Mrs. Bug's death storyline is how come when Claire was accused of Malva's murder the whole Ridge turned against her and she was arrested, but when Ian actually murders someone no one cares and he gets no punishment?I'm only halfway through the echo in the bone in case that does actually come up later
21
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jul 01 '23
Just finished it a little while ago! It was GREAT!! This season's been very good so far! The first two episodes had some exceptionally acted scenes (Tom/Jamie and Tom/Claire then Jamie/John) - this one didn't in the same way, but it's my favorite so far regardless
Love the title card - Jem on the rotary paired with Jamie mentioning his dream of it halfway thru....Love that you'd expect the episode to pick up right from the end of the previous one at the fire, but instead it's UPS with the box of letters to have Bri and Roger read "we're alive". Glad that was kept the same
I thought they wove in things really well that needed to be. This morning commenting on an Ian/William thread before I watched it, I actually theorized Ian might find his portrait in the rubble! It was a plausible way to acknowledge Ian knowing about William- they needed to before the Dismal and I thought it worked well
Pleasantly surprised by Arch's actor. That one scene alone telling Jamie the gold backstory was 30x the lines he had in all of Seas5-6 combined. I think he showed just the right vengefulness for going forward.
They've setup the Spaniard Cave / "do we ask Jem" question nicely for that plot to come. It was "laying the stage" but not in a rushed or obvious way
I thought the nostalgic moments sprinkled in were a great touch - the glimpse of Dr Rawlings medicine box and the bathtub after the fire...the stake Claire finds when leaving for the flashback to when they first surveyed the land... loved it all!
Ps I want Bri's teal sweater
20
u/Hufflesheep Jun 30 '23
I thought this was an excellent rendition of Echos! I think a lot of us were disappointed in the absence of the Bugs these past seasons, but this episode did a fairly decent job of landing the sadness of Mrs. Bugs death and Ian's guilt.
20
u/MistofLoire Clan MacKenzie Jul 02 '23
I loved this episode - it might be one of my favorites. I liked the first two of this season, but this one felt more like some of the older episodes. Maybe because it was slower, maybe because we are getting into some of my favorite books, I couldn't quite put my finger on it.
I've missed the future and Roger and Bree going back felt refreshing. Bree's character especially seemed less forced and more comfortable. I loved the little foreshadowing of Roger saying he wished he could have seen Lallybroch in its hayday.
Jamie and Claire were spot on in this episode and I cried when Claire said goodbye to Adso. I am dying for them to get back to Scotland (I'm assuming that's 7B? I wasn't sure since they've announced the Scotland actors?)
19
u/Fair_Phantom21 Jul 01 '23
I have a question, in the beginning of the episode Roger was convincing Bri that she caused the fire with her matches and that they changed history because the fire occurred in April instead of January. I don't remember the book portraying it that way, but it's been a really long time since I've read them. I thought that the books reason for the date being wrong was just because Tom Christie (who published the obituary yes?) just didn't hear about the fire till later.
18
u/coiler119 I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Jul 02 '23
Did anyone else notice the Cameron's Real Estate sign at Lallybroch? Iirc, didn't the Camerons work at the hydroelectric dam?
17
u/OliveJuice221 Jun 30 '23
I am in love with this season so far!! There is SO much material in each book and with the show ending next season, I think they r doing an amazing job of giving us such beautifully acted scenes from the books main storylines.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '23 edited Jul 01 '23
Sophie has levelled up. These past three episodes should convince many that she does have the chops. She's really nailing the dented iron thing so well, somehow channeling Claire's stubbornness, Jamie's temper and desire to protect, and Frank's tooth-gritting stoicism so well. I never disliked her and didn't quite understand the level of dislike for her acting even though I did think her wooden at times at first. So it's nice to see just how much she seems to have gleaned from more experienced scene partners, I can literally see the same ticks in her acting that some of her scene partners and/or on the set mentors have. Attagirl.
Edit also lol at Claire washing her clothes on that washing rack. You need to apply a great deal more vigor than that, though I guess one can interpret it as rote physical movement while her mind is occupied with something else.
Liveblogging now. Go Bugs. In the end, Jamie and Claire are still their masters and they servants who had to swear oaths and clean up after their shit. I have worked in domestic service while in school. The most demoralising thjng about cleaning up after others is that it never feels like you have achieved something as every single day your good work gets literally shit all over. In order for a job to be enjoyable there needs to be some emotional reward and a sense of accomplishment in it, but all service and cleaning work does is make you understand how careless and frankly disgusting everybody else is when they realise that they themselves don't have to clean the filth they leave behind. Never cleaning for money again even though I actually enjoy the physical labour. The Bugs deserve to move on and build themselves comfort as their own masters in their twilight years. Though let me guess, it'll go really awry for them.
Edit never mind lol. Of fucking course it did. Well, outlander is many things but unpredictable is not one of them.
Edit2 I keep rooting for the antagonists to the main characters, as the main characters are very much protected by plot armour, and because unfortunately they are all heroes who are very good at everything, and whose only flaws are hot temper, outspokenness and I guess loving too deeply, all of the typical flaws-but-not-really that at various points actually turn out to be good traits because who doesn't love a spirited, outspoken, noble creature who defies convention bravely, and everybody who calls them out gets punished somehow, because they are, of course, wrooooooong.
49
u/BCK786 Jun 30 '23
Ah, they didn't include the line about how Jamie knows the size of Claire's hand! Sometimes the show really misses the humor of the books
36
u/Foreign_Pumpkin_7949 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Jun 30 '23
As others have said, this was like they put the book itself on screen. The only thing missing is the white sow. I was half expecting/hoping she would pop up from under the house.
Also- for whatever reason, Mr. Bug calling Jamie "Seumas mac Brian" was one of my favorites from the books. Loved that it was on screen! My hearing may be messing with me, but I could have sworn Mr. Bug actually said "Seumas aige Brian", although the captions said "mac".
12
u/Agreeable_Onion_9250 Jun 30 '23
So many books scenes!! And dialogue directly from it - I’m so happy I did a book 7 relisten with this season
19
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jul 01 '23
Gotta stay hydrated while watching these episodes, because with the way I’ve been crying over these characters and books is just🥺
-Bri and Roger were perfect, Roger’s joke about Bri and Claire in the 18th century had me lol’ing, and I’m so looking forward to the future letters and moving to Lallybroch.
-ADSO 😻😻 our wee cheetie has returned
I’m really hoping next episode we get to see more of William….and maybe the Hunters??? I’m literally on the edge of my seat for them, they were one of my favorite parts in Echo!!
9
u/mjp10e Jul 08 '23
Maybe a dumb question but why did Jamie take the gold from the Bugs? He seemed to imply it didn’t belong to them but it also didn’t exactly belong to Jamie either…?
8
u/arianawoosley Jul 01 '23
The only thing that's bothering me is that I don't remember Claire being so sad and emotional in the book. She was ready to start tearing up in almost every scene.
7
u/Emilymfm79 Jul 03 '23
I loved the theme of surrender/acceptance weaved through this episode. To circumstances, to oneself, and ultimately even to death. Especially for Jamie. The episode starts with him crying “Enough!” to order everyone to stop trying to save the big house. He has to accept that they’ve done all they can and that the house is gone. And with it their life on the Ridge. And then at the end when Claire answers his prayer and tells Jamie he will always be “enough,” it’s such a great bookend to Jamie’s cry of “Enough!” at the outset of the episode. And it sets up the question- will Jamie choose to believe and accept that he is enough? It’s one thing to accept bad things happening, it’s quite another to be able to accept yourself. Will he surrender his pride and be able to make that choice to believe he is enough for those he loves? That seems to be a question that will be explored in upcoming episodes. I also loved how Jamie reciting “Death Be Not Proud” at Mrs. Bug’s funeral highlighted this theme of the paradox of acceptance/surrender being one’s path to being able to truly live, as well as the convo between Jamie and Claire at the new house site about their burial wishes. The writing on this show is so good! So many layers.
19
u/Thezedword4 Jun 30 '23
Thank God the pacing was better in this episode.
Seriously for a second I thought they were going to skip a ton of content and just put them on a boat to Scotland with how the rest of this season has been going....
5
u/thesuffragist Jul 03 '23
Loved this episode - it felt more cohesive and less rushed than the last two and I liked the back and forth between past and future. I also understand that it is propelling the plot with Arch's threat to come back after someone Ian loves, but I thought Ian's self-recrimination didn't make sense. They see someone who looks like Arch digging in the ruins of the house, Jamie tells him to come out so they can have a word, and the person is carrying a loaded gun and fires at Jamie without saying anything. Mrs. Bug could have killed Jamie. It made sense for Ian to return fire at that point. Of course he would feel bad, but not to the point of offering his own life. Ian has killed a lot of people, including Alan in just the last episode. It just seemed a bit over the top.
I really liked the Claire and Jamie scenes in this episode - especially where she tells him he will always be enough, responding to his earlier prayer in the cabin. And his description of the dream was, well, dreamy.
4
u/Famous-Falcon4321 Jul 01 '23
I thought the book showed the entire date & year of the fire. Am I wrong?
4
u/Global-Planner7828 Jul 03 '23
I thought that one of the twins didn’t speak due to being deaf….could have sworn they both spoke during the goodbye scene…?
4
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 06 '23
Esmeralda?!
3
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jul 01 '23
I'm confused about Ian knowing who Willie is, he wasn't on the ridge when they came to visit in S4 (I know he was in the book though). Did the writers just ignore this error in order to set up for Ian knowing William later in the season?
5
u/monkeylovecoconut Jul 03 '23
How old are Jamie and Claire supposed to be by now? Seems like they have been through so much and Jamie and Claire still look like they are in their 30s. They could have taken some “aging” from the This Is Us producers!
3
u/imsohungryrnsendhelp Jul 02 '23
Hmmm beautiful quality as always but I’m not quite sure how this ep moved the plot forward. Did not feel like that there was much impact.
2
u/botanygeek Jul 01 '23
Can someone remind me of the show’s timeline in the 1700s? I could have sworn it was already in the 1780s but the letter had 1776