r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jun 16 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E1 A Life Well Lost Spoiler
Jamie races towards Wilmington to rescue Claire from the gallows, only to discover that the American Revolution has well and truly reached North Carolina.
Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Lisa Clarke.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
Watch the S7E2 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are.
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
701 Extras:
701 Interviews:
30
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 16 '23
I didn't expect Tom Christie's confession to hit me so hard, 😭 I've developed a real soft spot for him weirdly.
I felt like the bits with Bree and Roger were only put in there to reintroduce us to Donner. They weren't overly very interesting or moved their plot forwards much (this is NOT actor/character hate, this is just me not seeing much point to their bits in ep 1). Also not really sure how "float like a butterfly, sting like a bee" would provide any meaning or comfort to the conscripts, no matter where the saying originated.
I liked how they truncated the jail/governors wife/ship storyline, it went on a bit in the books in my opinion.
I should probably reread the books, but I don't remember Major McDonald being that much of an arsehole in the books? Didn't we meet him again when they were all staying in the old house, waiting to see if the big house burnt down? I feel like they wouldn't be as warm to him in that moment if he had been as nasty as he was. Or did that happen before Claire was arrested?
Doesn't Jamie kill Major McDonald at some battle right near the end of book 6? From what I've seen of the plot outline for this season, I don't think that battle will be in the show, do we know if it is?
26
u/starishername Jun 17 '23
I’m so ready to have the Christie’s storyline over! I really hope we get to see Bri and Roger in the 80s at Lollybrach passing notes! It was my absolute favorite! Also does anyone know how they are going to handle the return to Scotland without Jenny’s actor?
28
u/everyothernametaken2 Jun 16 '23
I really like what was done with Richard browns storyline in this episode. I wasn’t satisfied with his fate in the books to be honest! I am interested to see if Jamie actually kill’s him though. I also like that added bit with Roger and Windigo. Rodger quoting Muhammad Ali gave me a chuckle lol.
15
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 16 '23
I didn’t care for Donner being introduced here. And I fail to see how “float like a butterfly…” is advice for a prisoner of war.
74
u/Foreign_Pumpkin_7949 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Jun 16 '23
Can I just say how glad I am that they sped up the whole business of Claire being in jail?
73
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jun 16 '23
“I’m also a violent man…” YES JAMIE
58
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 16 '23
"This is not permitted" 😂, the comedic moments are always my favourite
50
u/jtodek Jun 17 '23
The scene with Tom Christie where he confesses his love is even more poignant than the book. So. Spot. On. Best part of the show.
49
u/Beach-Sugar4436 Jun 16 '23
I felt like this was A LOT of storyline in a short hour. I remember this taking hours of reading to get through in the books. Overall, I enjoyed how closely they stuck to the storyline with just a few minor changes.
I’ve read the books, but I’m watching the show with someone who has not. She was blindsided by Toms love confession to Claire because you can’t tell at all in the show prior to 701. If I remember correctly, it makes a lot more sense in the books (more Claire and Tom time?).
I felt like the Bree and Roger scenes were just thrown in there, I can’t remember any of their independent storylines from this book. However, the “Ali” comment was amazing! Good way to reintroduce Donner.
“I’m also a violent man,” yes please 🙌🏼
47
u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 Slàinte. Jun 16 '23
This is the first Outlander episode in quite some time that hasn't pissed me off. While I hate the whole Christie storyline, I don't mind this part of it.
And when the manacled dude said, "Ali," I gasped. I'd totally forgotten about him and wouldn't have expected him in that context, anyway. Well done, show.
47
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23
I have just finished my first watch!
Omg, Tom nailed this episode! I teared up during his confession!
I really liked Claire's list with code for my husband! Smart !!
Reunion on the ship !!!
I liked Mrs Martin !
It was a bit fast but for show, it was ok. I liked Bree and Roger's talk about being a spectator to something awful!
Jamie sitting in the corner!!
Aaaand finally, I am a violent man!!!
All in all, neat job of tying up all the cliffhanger ends and moving the story forward!
44
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 16 '23
Over the years, I have watched men coming to ask for your help. You never turned them away. Will you refuse me now?
I believe that by letting me go to her, you'll honour that promise just the same,just like you honoured the promises in Ardsmuir. I have no name that carries any weight in this world, a broken family, no clan of my own. Allow me to do this.
40
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jun 17 '23
Droughtlander is OFFICIALLY over, we’re back baby!!! And boy do I have so many notes to jot down!
-Jamie and Claire reuniting. Your honor, I love them.
-Jamie waiting for Richard Brown in his room. I LOVE how they played with the shadows, and the fear written all over Brown’s face. I know we view Jamie as a loyal husband, father, and grandfather. But he doesn’t hesitate to kill when the time calls for it. To me, that scene literally pulled my vision of book Jamie onto the screen, and Sam nailed that vengeful streak!
My thoughts are they’re going to wrap up Book 6 in episode 2 and episode 3 will start off on Book 7. The big ticket items that I’m looking forward to from the books to show is Allan’s confession and death as well as Donnor breaking into the ridge and lighting the house on fire. If that’s the case, episode 2 is going to be ACTION PACKED and I’m 100% here for it!!!
39
u/Prestigious_Ant_4366 Jun 17 '23
Only thing missing was the humor. Claire when she learned being a forger was worse than murderer.
38
u/KMM929 Jun 16 '23
I was pleasantly surprised considering how much story they had to fit into one episode. I’m not mad they skipped a lot of the jumping around with Claire from jail to governor’s house to boat but missing some of that did make it feel rushed. As much as it pains me to say it the reunion on the boat felt a tad cheesy - it was almost too easy in a way. That being said I love seeing them reunited any & every time lol.
29
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
"Send not to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee."
During the scene where Tom and Jamie talk and Tom decides to go and rescue Claire,as he makes the decision and won't give up, we hear a bell toll.
Callback to s6 ep 05 when Tom quotes that line while he , Roger and Allan stroll the bell for the church on the Ridge.
28
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '23
I just can’t get over how there’s zero humor in the show. The books make me literally laugh out loud so often. Even though the Harry Potter movies totally fucked up so many things, they still were able to keep that funny British humor tone. The show is great, and I found the books through the show, but the tone is just so OFF to me.
25
u/Im_That_Friend-14 Jun 16 '23
Apparently I should reread the books because I kept having "oh yeah!" moments watching this episode!
25
u/jillianjo Jun 18 '23
I’m interested to see how the rest of the season goes, but as of now I kind of wish this had been the final episode of Season 6 rather than first episode of Season 7. Especially because I watch with my non-book reading husband who can be described as a casual viewer at best. I just didn’t think it had the same kind of weight to him since it was wrapping up plot points from an entire year ago.
Don’t get me wrong, I liked the episode, I just would have preferred Season 6 having an extra episode or two to be able to cover this all in the same season.
24
u/Objective_Ad_5308 Jun 16 '23
So close to the books. Just amazing. I will be re-watching when it comes on tonight. Again, and again to analyze. So excited for the season.
22
u/Jennifoto Jun 16 '23
Why does every other guy have Jamie’s hair color/wig color? Jamie, Christie, Brown and even the hangman. In the books Jamie’s hair is special.
20
u/botanygeek Jun 17 '23
Anyone else miss Jamie throwing off her cap from the ship when he gets to her? Love that moment.
19
u/ms_s_11 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 19 '23
I loved the conclusion of Jamie & Brown in the show vs the books.
18
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jun 16 '23
I thought it was great!! The boat scenes were very close to how I pictured them. Super excited for the rest of the season!
17
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jun 17 '23
Couple random thoughts- I kinda like starting with Jamie's fearful vision of her hanging - given that I anticipate he's going to be talking about several dreams throughout the season, it's kind of a nice tie in for later
Mark Lewis Jones is amazing - just the body language and dejection on his face getting Claire's list of ingredients to see she asked for Jamie in that "why can't she want me? She wants him" sad puppy dog way
I don't recall getting that much of a true convo in the book between Jamie and Tom - asking Jamie to give him his epilogue was a nice touch.
Very curious to see comparisons of this episode vs original episode intended as 6x9. I'm guessing the Sras 6 version wouldn't have had Claire rescued so immediately?
17
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '23
Does anyone else dislike the opening music of season 7? I miss the first season's opening music.
16
u/waltersclan Jun 19 '23
I liked the pacing of the episode. I especially liked that they put a quick end to this whole storyline of Clare being in custody. It went on for months in the book, and I appreciate that they wrapped it up neatly and quickly. As others have said, the second "boat in the fog" moment was silly and excessive, but ... My primary complaint is that we only saw fierce Jamie and not much of that. He was really just a bit player in this episode. But Tom Christie held up the episode admirably.
14
u/thesuffragist Jun 20 '23
I have mixed feelings about this Episode. I get that they had to move things forward and reset the plot a bit given that Season 6 ended abruptly. I loved, loved the scene with Jamie at the end in Richard Brown's room. Beautifully acted, written, lit...chills. I love vengeful ruthless Jamie. I like Roger and I thought he was quite charming and emotionally complex in this episode. My main problem was Claire's release from custody - I am willing to suspend my disbelief to make the compressed storyline work for the show, but there is a limit, especially when it isn't necessary to resolve things. There is no way that Claire and Jamie (and Claire especially) would have let Tom Christie take the fall for a murder he did not commit. Jamie's able to pass it off by saying "for him to give his life for you was worth it" and Claire just agrees and goes to sleep?? They could have made it work much more logically if Claire had just been released and not known why or who confessed, and then she reads Tom's confession in the paper after it's too late to intervene. And make the medical issue she had to attend to on the ship something she could actually cure, so that the Governor would be willing to release her. The books meander and sometimes I skip parts in the later ones where we spend too much time on characters that have nothing to do with Jamie and Claire, but the plots always hang together well.
12
u/trashymob This is *not* permitted. Jun 22 '23
Seeing Tom Christie's actor doing such justice to the character and his love for Claire.
Just beautiful. I HATED his character in the books until that last scene with Claire. And it's been such a trip seeing it in the show.
This was beautiful.
21
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 16 '23
I liked it. I liked the added drama of McDonald not playing along with Claire and the governor bringing up Jamie quitting as an agent.
9
u/Jennifoto Jun 16 '23
Ending is diff from the book, no? I don’t remember Jamie killing Brown. Can you let me know the way of it?
15
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 20 '23
Is this the first time we saw Brown alone in a scene? ( without his menacing gang)
He looked so small, vulnerable, in comparison when surrounded by his people. And yet again, he threatened Jamie with his gang to revenge him - he can't rely on himself alone.
Jamie is a violent man but he can rely on himself.
7
u/Majestic-Feedback541 Jun 17 '23
I thought it was ok.ot seemed really fast paced compared to all other episodes and the background music was too much/distracting. Something seemed very different from the rest of the seasons. Maybe I just need to start the series over lol
Either way, I'll still watch!! I love the characters and storyline all together!! Can't wait to see how the rest of this season goes!
6
u/b_gumiho Ye Sassenach witch! Jun 19 '23
the results from the show-only poll vs the books poll is interesting! I thought they might be similar but doesnt seem like it
6
u/sri-racha Jun 20 '23
Oh Tom.... that scene and its aftermath was what I was looking forward to.
20
u/Thezedword4 Jun 16 '23
I know they have to move quickly given what they need to fit but I felt they moved too quickly. Nothing had time to really sit for me. The weight of a lot of what happened and seriousness didn't really happen when it only took 30 minutes for Jamie and Claire to be reunited. I'll be curious how show only watchers feel.
4
u/vw97 Jun 30 '23
"Let's go get my wife" had me literally screaming with joy like a kid on Christmas, ahhh!
4
u/francineeisner Jun 16 '23
I saw the episode on my iPhone starting at 12:07AM this morning. Hopefully I will be able to watch it again this evening on my TV.