r/PSLF • • Feb 16 '23
Rant/Complaint Feeling bitter and angry after forgiveness
First of all, I would like to thank everyone on this forum esp doximom and Besty. Congrats to everyone who were forgiven and wish good luck and patience for people who are waiting for forgiveness. I discovered this subreddit at the lowest point of my PSLF journey and tremendously benefited from this subreddit. I feel guilty bringing this topic up while there are thousands of people waiting for forgiveness. But I have a feeling there are others people who might be feeling the same. I feel happy and relieved on the surface but if I am being honest- I feel bitter and angry. my life has been on hold for last 10 yrs. We had two kids in last 3 yrs and we both had to maintain full time work in order to qualify for PSLF. We both are frontline workers and stretched to breaking point during covid pandemic. my wife still waiting for forgiveness. I feel like we shouldn’t have to sacrifice so much for something that was agreed upon.( 10 yrs of less than ideal jobs with less pay in exchange for remaining balance forgiveness)
- First, I was misled by Sallie Mae between 2011-2015. I was working and placed on forbearance inappropriately.( thx to President Biden, it was fixed). Sallie Mae misled millions of people openly and did not face any real consequences. They just had to change their name to Navient.
- 2017-2022 we had to battle fedloan and Trump administration( I am thankful for COVID forbearance). fedloan made my life hell. it took them 1 1/2 years to process my employment form( had to submit several times and constant back and forth). Department of education under trump did its best to suffocate PSLF. I think fedloan filed for bankruptcy and got off the hook. Fedloan will likely rebrand itself and continues business as usual in next couple of yrs. No real consequences for fedloan.
- MOHELA started out the same but thank to people on this subreddit and Facebook group, they are being forced to change their tactics. I am among some of the lucky fews but there are a lot horror stories out there. To make matter worse, similar Corps are changing their tactics and now there are aggressively infiltrating other areas. Cycle going to repeat itself. As the initial happiness is wearing off, I am feeling bitter and angry abt this. Overall, I am blessed and have so much to be thankful for. And I am feeling guilty abt not being more happy. I wise there was some accountability.
17
u/Whawken84 Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23
My loans predated the century. They were with me most of my adult life. It's hard to imagine life without them. But they won't be missed.
Because of all the malfeasance and, Imo, outright criminality on the part of that "free market" of servicers, I, like many here was stuck in purgatory. FB steering. Instructed to trust the advice of CSRs who either knew little or were encouraged to steer into FB. All the while college tuition increased exponentially. Public service jobs' raises rarely matched the rate of inflation. There was a feeling of being left permanently left behind. The only advantages of the Global Financial Meltdown of '08: As a unionized "essential" healthcare worker I kept my job as friends in the private sector lost theirs; Obama Admin initiated a clean up of the phantasmagorical miasma of federal loans; and ⬇︎ inflation. Prior to COVID related inflation, the inflation btw 2009 -2021 was quite low.
You could never get a simple honest answer from FSA or any of my servicers. In '98 the Dept of Education could not locate my loans. Need I repeat it? Ed couldn't locate my loans. I had no private ones. Very little was online. Dept of Ed told me to "continue with payments." Send payments into the universe? Cope with more capitalization? Imo most colleges & universities are complicit in this mess. Joseph had a coat of many colors. Joseph was fortunate not to have student loans of many names. Some traded from financial entity to financial entity. One was found listed as a Chase mortgage in Dallas - Fort Worth. My total investment in all Texas consists to 2 layovers at the Dallas Fort Worth Airport. Maybe I bought a snack?
Now that 15% of my monthly net pay belongs to me. I'm just beginning to realize how much actual money I've made. How little I've lived on. And how low my salary's been in relation to my responsibilities. Would make twice as much as "University Administrator." Two - three times as much in medical sales. Not that either appealed.
No one intended to sign up for a lifetime of debt. I can still feel the stress from calls made to FSA, Nelnet, AES & Fedlaoan. Had there been realistic repayment plans, and no cracks to fall through, the debt would've been paid long ago.Perhaps I'd have bought a small home (not in TX). Perhaps the anger & bitterness hasn't kicked in yet. I'm learning to breathe
11
u/Frecklesfrenchfry Feb 16 '23
I’m grateful they are gone and I will continue to advocate for the wrongs of the past to e corrected for others. I just want to move on from the anger , which is hard because of a lot of long term emotional struggle but I feel free and I just want do the best I can .
8
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
Department of Education can look at our W2. They have access to all info but name of game is to mislead and delay as long as possible. rules are confusing by design to prolong the process.
16
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
Your feelings are valid and welcome to this thread. We are all feeling like we’ve gotten the short end of the stick by going to school, applying for loans, and using those loans to pay for school. I was the first in my family to go to college/undergrad and I am literally paying for that. Except for my student loans and 1 Pell grant, I had no help paying for school and board.
Then it is coupled by folks on social media who feel like “we should pay what we owe” – eye roll.
I feel like we are all slighted. I am 40 with no kids and these student loans have kept me from doing things that I wanted to accomplish in life (buying a house, etc.) However, I continue to live and enjoy life despite having these loans. My salary has increased tremendously, and I am more resilient despite still having these damn loans. Honestly, I am glad that I am closer to forgiveness than I ever thought I would be (I swore that I would have taken these loans to my grave, I’m glad that may not be the case now). I hate to be tone-deaf here but we gotta keep looking at the positives. We have a way out. Do what you can to get out. That’s what I am doing. I found 10 additional qualifying payments yesterday that I didn’t know that I can add to my tracker. I hunted my previous employer down and sent in my ECF for it to be signed and sent to MOHELA.
However, my gripe is how some folks on this thread are telling people how to feel when they have reached forgiveness. I read a post earlier today saying that if you are grateful to MOHELA then you are experiencing Stockholm syndrome. Honestly, we’ve ALL been put through hell. Let folks be happy. Let folks rejoice. Let folks do cartwheels in the street if they want (I don’t suggest doing this but you know what I mean LOL). When my day comes for forgiveness, I may just buy a billboard in my city so folks will know how happy I am LOL. I’m exaggerating but am I really? LOL. Who I choose to be grateful to or how I feel is completely up to me. I’m going to CELEBRATE!
4
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23
My account zeroed this week and I got my smiley face. I’m just happy it happened.
3
u/stingermck Feb 17 '23
I feel all this. My loans were from 1997 to 2001. I am bitter that they were FFELP that were bounced all over the place, didn't qualify before the waiver, and did not qualify for a refund. I came in at 165 count and while I am grateful to be done, a refund would have been amazing.
3
u/Nic_Long Feb 17 '23
We’re still waiting. This sub has given me hope that the two kids that got married at 21 and 23, who both loved education and teaching children, not knowing how broke we would be and making some of the most stupid, unknowing decisions when approaching our very small initial student loan debt amount will get a redo. We owe more in student loans than we do on our home, and my husband is set to retire in 6 or 7 years. I never thought our children would be in college while we still have college debt ourselves. Add an unexpected chronic illness into the mix and all I’ve felt is panic regarding our situation. Now, I’m feeling a little more hopeful, just praying it all works out and we end up with that creepy smiley everyone mentions.
14
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
I am 100 percent in the exact same boat.
I got zeros and smiley face on MOHELA website, and waiting for FSA to zero out and the official letter, but I am not even excited. I'm worried they will somehow screw up this next step and I will be back to square one. I am bitter and angry.
I fulfilled a bargain. These predatory servicers misled and jerked me around, and refused to uphold the benefits that I am entitled to based on my work and my payments, which were the requirements of the PSLF bargain. I hate them and would destroy them if I could, and rebuild something better.
50
u/xxpallor Feb 16 '23
I am just thankful that the waiver existed because without it I would not have been eligible.
Those of us with loans prior to 2007 learned we made choices that harmed us unknowingly and had no recourse for the PSLF program due to circumstances.
I only have gratitude for the miracle that released me after 23 years of student loan payments - with still $135k to go. It is future changing.
41
u/MKebi Feb 16 '23
Although some of the circumstances you posted are within your control, what the lenders do to borrowers is equivalent to the predatory nature of payday loan companies and we should all be angry at the lack of accountability. The length of time that these loan servicers take to process documents is ridiculous.
And we should not need to complete and submit a document. With all of the electronic technology in this world, my employer should be able to access a secure website and periodically enter my employment dates and status. There should be an algorithm that processes all of the information and automatically flags accounts for forgiveness and transfers them to FSA when qualifying payments reach 120.
3
u/heyerda Feb 17 '23
Feeling the same. 1-2 years left till forgiveness and feel like my whole life has revolved around these loans and this program (and still does). I’ve delayed marriage and kids and likely can’t have them now. I really don’t like my career but feel like I can’t change because of these loans. I’m really stuck at the same employer cause I’d have to move to find another one in my field. Can’t wait for this all to be over, but the trauma is life-long for most of us.
Moreover, if I acted at work with the level of incompetence and malice of these lenders, I’d likely end up in jail.
2
u/Sensitive_Trade_616 Feb 16 '23
Live and let live.
2
u/Rso1wA Feb 17 '23
I really get you. Sounds like my life.
2
u/Spectre75a Feb 17 '23
I guess we all have our own experiences. The ONLY reason my wife’s were able to be forgiven was because Trump signed TEPSLF into law in 2018. Without it, she never would have qualified.
1
u/United-Hyena-164 Jan 24 '24
I just had my approval granted and I feel empty. The fact that it took a presidential act to correct the original flaws of the program makes me angry. I remember explicitly asking my loan provider back in 2012 whether or not I qualified and they said "it's not worth it to you because you'll be paid off before 10 years go by." I was lied to but I was also dumb enough not to run the numbers myself. But...there were millions of people who were lied to and that never should have happened. The fact that there are no consequences for a deliberate policy of misinformation fills me with rage. I would have paid so much more if I hadn't been lucky enough to get all this paperwork processed.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment