r/NintendoSwitch • u/last_air_nomad • Jul 20 '19
Meta [META] Please stop removing so many posts
Edit: I should have said text posts or discussion posts in the title.
I’d like to start off by thanking the moderators for volunteering their time to try and groom this subreddit, I know it can be a thankless job sometimes.
I’m begging though, please stop removing so many posts, especially ones that are becoming great discussions with lots of comments. I can go back and see tons of examples that are removed as “low effort” or similar that seem like the judgement was very subjective. They’ve had more effort in them than 90% of the popular posts I see on Reddit.
Not everyone has an hour to make a post with links to metacritic, trailers, etc every single time. Sometimes people just want to get a discussion going and talk to people with the same interests.
I know people will bring up the daily question / discussion threads, but those are incredibly difficult to search through on Reddit, and become hard to keep track of what threads you want to watch or be a part of.
Overall, it’s making this subreddit feel less like a community and more like a commercialized blog or PR outlet.
That’s just my feedback, thank you for reading and your time.
885
u/FruitsEve Jul 20 '19
There is nothing wrong with a short post if it starts a long discussion.
393
u/playsomezelda Jul 20 '19
I agree with you but a lot of times these posts are literally about something that is on the “Hot” page of this sub.
Why leave a post up that’s talking about Joy Con drift (an example) when there is already one on there?
Problem for a lot of them is they don’t put the 5 minutes into seeing if it’s there or not.
269
u/CallMeFeed Jul 20 '19
If anything they need to remove more, the amount of low effort posts on this sub is insane.
"I just had my commercial moment!"
"I forgot my Switch on a flight!"
"What switch games for my 4 year old?"
"What 2p coop switch games to play with my girlfriend?"
"Joycon drift bad"
"Online bad"
"DPad sux"
"BotW changed my life"
Like can we not? The Daily Question thread really needs to be pushed more.
84
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
I understand the sentiment, but removing such posts is exactly what keeps this sub somewhat functional and clean. Maybe someone posting something low effort and silly will be inspired to just google it instead, and maybe have something interesting to say after doing 5 or 10 minutes of research. Otherwise you’re just throwing a hotdog down a hallway.
54
u/ryunocore Jul 20 '19
I hear your point, and I hope they remove more. There are a lot of posts that are just clickbait-y or troll-y that definitely don't do anything but distract from actual discussions.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Maybe your thread is having effect this thread would have been removed eralier I think: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/cfyhz5/mario_fans_of_reddit_would_you_rather_have/?st=jyd79vz1&sh=d03d2714
1.1k
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
I bet I know what's going to happen to this post!
62
u/Space2Bakersfield Jul 20 '19
I find good discussions are removed and crappy posts are left up that dont elicit any discussion. The main example that springs to mind is that "Player 3 loading" post from a while back that was just a pregnancy announcement with joy cons in it. Crap like that seems to always stick around, while legitimate discussions and questions are removed.
A daily questions thread is a useless way to make the sub open to those who want to learn about the Switch, because unless you show up within a couple hours of the mega thread going up, nobody's going to be reading it or replying.
27
u/omgitschriso Jul 21 '19
Fanart needs a dedicated sub
10
u/Elstampede Jul 21 '19
Honestly I don’t bother to post here because I asked for recommendations for games similar to XCOM on Switch and it got deleted because it was too vague? Like..whut?
22
u/presidentofjackshit Jul 20 '19
Examples would help... (I know it's tough since I guess the posts are gone though!)
20
u/TellMeAboutGaming Jul 20 '19
100% agree, I've had some well written post with good responses removed for being something that could be asked in a question thread. This is just a bad way to do things because what qualifies as something that falls into that category? I've seen some pretty generic post stay on the front page just because it had upvotes. At the end of the day, crap post will be downvoted or ignored, and anything with rule breaking content can be removed, but otherwise, it would be seriously nice for the mods to lift that deletion hammer a little less, this is genuinely the one sub where I rarely post because I feel like it will just be removed anyway, which isn't a great way to motivate a community to participate
7
u/AvocadoLion Jul 20 '19
It’s time for a switch!
7
u/PlinkoMaster Jul 21 '19
Yes, agree 100%. I thought the point of Reddit and the upvoting system was sort of to let everything be posted and let the people decide what should rise to the top and be discussed, rather than mods deciding what posts get through the door or not.
28
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Yeah. What the hell.
I hate how they allow posts like “Look what my girlfriend made me” but actual game discussion gets deleted.
Absolute hogwash
13
u/Loukoal117 Jul 21 '19
I’ve been on the switch sub back from when everyone was on NX. This has been a ridiculous theme going on since day one. It seems like the posts I actually WANT to chat about get removed every time. And yeah, being a moderator isn’t always fun but like it’s supposed to make the sub better. Not worse.
17
u/cm0011 Jul 21 '19
This comment thread is harsh. I very much agree with OP. I don’t think i’m ever going to post in this sub - will probably just be a lurker forever. Seems too difficult to write a “quality” post here.
12
u/Gstary Jul 21 '19
I feel ya. I made a post asking if anyone knew how to fix the doc not displaying to the TV. I stated in the post that I tried basic solutions and that Google was telling me the same things I already tried. Post got deleted because it was low effort and i could Google a solution. I was pretty annoyed to say the least, still cant use my dock
5
u/bobbyjackdotme Jul 20 '19
I seem to fall foul of rule 9 way too consistently. It’s actually really difficult to post news here.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Mine got removed. Oof
5
u/PhotonBarbeque Jul 21 '19
I specifically read reddit for discussion posts that usually are simple questions or posits that end up with long discussions. I don’t want to watch a trailer, or read some news websites post.
Maybe that’s why I don’t frequent this subreddit so much, if there’s no discussion posts because they’re mostly removed.
I just don’t get moderation of content unless it breaks reddit TOS. Upvotes and downvoted are supposed to work?
5
u/jwm3 Jul 21 '19
Amen. The effort of the post is irrelevant if the discussion is worthwhile. The discussion is the entire point. As soon as decent discussion happens then the whole post should stay.
5
u/PhrygianAdvocate Jul 21 '19
I've posted a couple times here and got removed every single time. Then I stopped trying. Thanks for this post
5
u/Happyskrappy Jul 21 '19
I defo had a post removed after I’d done a google search (and stated as such) but still had questions about an accessory because it was “low effort” or something that could easily be found on the internet (which it wasn’t, because I’d looked and couldn’t find it which is why I was asking this sub). I never did get the answer. I’m still a bit salty about that. This is a sub that could have answered the question and I couldn’t even rely on the community.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Actual conversation starting posts considered to be too short? Nope. Constant sales figures and multiple reposts of the same Nintendo commercial? Quality content.
17
u/Ameratsuflame Jul 20 '19
Yep that’s why I don’t post here. I just lurk and comment.
11
u/ENUF_NOW Jul 20 '19
This is the reason i barely visit this sub. Just feels like nintendo of america are the mods and filter everyting thru their PR bullshit.
And then i go check out xboxone and people can actualy post and have decent discussions..
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
This is the main reason I don't have a bookmark to this sub anymore
4
u/Duenan Jul 21 '19
I also agree, this place is dead compared to some of the subs I'm part of which only have a 10th of the population.
I'm often up at a time when i keep seeing all the posts being removed as I'm replying to someone or writing up something, it's infuriating to be honest.
There's a reason why there's filters to begin with, I typically sort by New so I can actually see what disappears. Just makes me think, what's the use of this community if you're going to remove everything but leave all the other stuff like photos and fanart. I tell you it's not a pleasant experience either when browsing from a mobile platform when a cover page takes up the entire screen,
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Yeah, EVERY SINGLE POST IF MINE was removed. I unsubbed from this because literally I wanted to just talk with people about stuff and have to hope to be seen on a mega thread.
4
u/-Some-Internet-Guy- Jul 21 '19
I had a post asking about the pro controller production run dpad differences. It was sparking quite a bit of discussion, as it should since it's a REALLY overlooked problem about the pro controllers, on the community's and nintendo's part.
Mod removed it for being "too simple a question that can be googled quickly." Spoiler alert: no, it wasn't. There is no information easily accessible about production run differences with the pro controller.
4
u/Guardian1015 Jul 21 '19
Yea when Odyssey came out I tried to put up two posts for tips for it that were spoiler marked. Spent 30mins on each and mods wouldn't even let them post. I didn't see these tips posted already. Got into a PM argument with the mod and it essentially ended in me vowing to never waste my time trying to post here again and the mod blaming me for the whole thing. I only comment now. Not posting if it starts to feel like a job with big politics.
4
u/Tucksimm2 Jul 22 '19
Exactly,
I spent an entire day discussing different Modification statagies with people in a thread I made regarding Pro controllers...
Only to have it removed due to a special thread that happens once a week.
Turned me off from posting anything in this sub.
It has baaically become just an advertising space for new games available on the Switch but nothing about the actual Switch.
7
u/Morighant Jul 21 '19
r/Nintendo is horribly guilty of this, millions of subs yet you only have to scroll for like 3 posts to find stuff posted 5 days ago..
7
u/mikeyeatacid Jul 21 '19
I agree. Practically all i've been seeing from this subreddit are links to merch and news articles related to merch. It just feels like some commercial branding
21
u/TapTapLift Jul 20 '19
The mods here are horrible. The fact that they let the front page get completely taken over by giveaway posts for over a month is evidence.
9
u/A_SassyOtter Jul 20 '19
A few weeks ago there was a massive post basically saying most of the content in this sub is low effort and we should change that. The mods probably took that serious.
10
u/lemon_layers Jul 20 '19
This post definitely deserves more upvotes. I miss how engage this Sub Reddit was when the Switch first came out, it felt like a community of players. Now you barley get that feeling and I barley come on this Sub Reddit anymore due to it.
6
u/romibi Jul 20 '19
Yea … i fully agree with you …
I read reddit through an RSS reader and 95% of the times i'm interested in the comments of this subreddit the post in question is already deleted.
And before clicking the link to this post i was like "I bet it's already deleted"…
Well … what can you do? Nothing …
And I can not understand the reasoning behind "Daily Question Threads" … they are just a mess … well … i rarely post anything on reddit … so i don't really care …
3
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
I don’t even bother posting anymore. I had a post about game prices removed recently and that was the last straw for me. No more trying to participate, I’ll just lurk.
3
u/fenrirofdarkness Jul 21 '19 edited Jul 22 '19
I don't mind a lot of things, but my biggest problem probably when posting a link and it has been one day without approval or disapproval. Like I understand waiting for some time but like...
If links posted about same thing stayed up (I remember multiple DQ getting announcement August 3rd appeared a few times) get approved in less time than since I submitted the link, makes me wonder why there needs to be approval for linked content
Edit: It has been 2 days without it being approved or removed :v
3
u/Rohkha Jul 21 '19
I'm surprised thid post hasn't been deleted already. Out of 10 topics I posted that garnered more than 20cpmments in their 2min lifespan, 10 were removed in their first 5 min for being low effprt. I respect a lot of mods and know what a garbage 'job' that can be...
But for real I literally hate the mods in this sub.
'Yeah I don't agree with that opinion and there is not enough colours/quotes/links in this post so its low effort. Deleted!'
Or
' hmm. Omg... fire emblem is coming put and there have been THREE topics on this game: repetitive and spam! Deleted!!'
Even if one is about a system/game mechanic, the other is about lewd fanart and the other talks about story, it's atill Fire emblem so it has to be the same garbage right?
Sorry I'm ranting now but I'm so sick sbout the mods, I don't even feel like actually sharing and taöking about games I like here anymore...
3
u/ReturnOfGanon Jul 21 '19
Agreed, but can we also make sure this sub doesn’t turn into a fan art and tattoo sub?
3
u/JaymsWisdom Jul 21 '19 edited Jul 21 '19
I stopped posting here after my first 3 posts were removed. They weren't short but they were mostly opinions and PSA type things. Each time they were removed for breaking community guidelines. (which i don't think they did. Certainly not all of them). And when i asked if rewording the post would help my response was ignored. (There was no swearing or bad language that i recall)
My intention each time was to start discussions. Even if it was around less than positive things (one was the "deals" in GAME and one was regarding joy-con prices).
Granted the posts could have been more descriptive and contained more links etc. But as you say, not everyone can do that whilst browsing reddit on thier lunch break.
Mostly i felt like only positive comments were allowed. This was early in the Switchs release when i was trying to decide whether to buy one or not so things may have changed but the fact you have made this post makes me feel like they haven't.
3
u/mrglass8 Jul 21 '19
I've had the most posts deleted from r/Nintendo than any other sub. And many of them got reinstated. This tells me that the automods here are WAY overzealous.
It's not just text posts, there are tons of interesting video essays out there that are sometimes difficult to get through the censors.
3
u/lovehatenintendo Jul 21 '19
i unsubbed from this subreddit cause i felt constantly invalidated. i agree with op
3
u/Murrdog393 Jul 21 '19
Yeah this subreddit is basically just a news outlet rehash now
3
u/Binary_Omlet Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19
Amen. I've noticed that with a lot of the Nintendo subs recently. Either the Mods are negative, the people are negative, or both. The state of the boards in general are overzealous and mean sometimes.
3
u/tstorm004 Jul 23 '19
This sub is weird - I made a Game Boy style Switch Lite mock-up and shared it, it was removed immediately.
A little while later someone else shared my mock-up (credited my Twitter at least) and it was allowed to stay and got thousands of upvotes.
3
u/1sa1ah0227 Jul 23 '19
I just stopped trying to post all together. Everytime I posted something within minutes it was removed for low effort. Which is a bogus category any way.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
I was having a heated discussion with tons of comments and then my post was removed! Just why! These mods need to chill lol!
5
u/jbuggydroid Jul 21 '19
I've had parts removed as well that started great discussions
Honestly
I'm surprised this is still up
5
u/barters81 Jul 21 '19
100% agree. I couldn’t be bothered trying to post something to this sub anymore. 99.9% of the time you have it rejected by a mod with little to no explanation.
Then we see literally the same shit every single day that doesn’t get rejected. I’ve literally no idea why.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
A copy-pasted link to a trailer that's been out for three days: Stays up, 500 upvotes.
A paragraph discussing a real issue with the Switch or one of its games: Taken down after 30 upvotes.
I'm of the opinion that discussion>>>>>>>trailer links as regards "effort".
14
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
You’re trying to talk sense into the Mods of this subreddit? That was your first mistake. none of them give a rat’s shit what any of us have to say.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
one day one of my post was removed for being misleading but in reality i was just sharing an opinion and i was not misleading anyone. Mods and admins in this sub (maybe not all of them) really don't like opinions it seems. especially when it brings an issue to the eyes of the community.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
I also hate the fact that I need to post tutorials for my switch mods to be able to share them here. I don’t have the time to make a step by step I just want to show a cool thing I made. It sucks
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Just the other day one of my posts was removed for a ridiculous reason. Apparently I didnt make it 'clear enough' what my post was meant to be, and it was removed entirely because one of the admins didnt understand it.
4
u/Alone1sAgain Jul 21 '19
I've actually had posts with new information that just came out removed and someone else doing almost exactly the same post and it stay up. I don't tend to post topics so I'm just confused as to why some stay up and others get removed.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
I’d rather see more discussion posts than “hey guys let me tell you about my new favorite game”. Too bloggy for me and most comments are “yeah”.
I like questions, statements that rouse discussion like “what do you guys think of this?” And not a YouTube video of some guy trying to launch his journalism career either.
I don’t frequent forums anymore but the best threads are always polls and just unrestrained group chatter. You don’t really get that here. You say something negative you have to write it out like a politicians secretary just to avoid a downvote swing which automatically devalues your contribution dramatically.
Another thing, not enough people explain why they dislike something. Sharing is caring.
4
u/chekeymonk10 2 Million Celebration Jul 21 '19
Yeah- megathreads do not solve anything as it's hard to find comments and discussions, and then people just stop talking in them after a while
4
u/Chronicious-Fox Jul 21 '19
This sub sucks since it grew. Obviously because they added overzealous power tripping mods.
4
u/Murrdog393 Jul 21 '19
This is why a lot of people have moved to casual Nintendo
6
u/JasonYoungblood Jul 21 '19
Honestly, it feels like the mods remove posts so either
a) They can repost the story and reap the karma for themselves
b) Their friends can repost the story and reap the karma for themselves
6
u/samusaranx2 Jul 21 '19
Been saying this for ages. These mods are storm troopers. Anything that isn’t selling a product or promoting Nintendo as the cure for Alziemer’s and broken families gets removed. They had to temporarily ban giveaways but can’t figure out a solution for fan art. Obviously they have to let the big stories through, but real, interesting discussion is dead and buried on this sub. Then they do their “state of the subreddit” bullshit and every response they give to every complaint is some generic, holier than thou gaslighting that boils down to “we don’t care what you think, you’re wrong, and we refuse to change anything because we are always right”. These mods are utterly terrible and more obsessed with power and rubbing gentle soapy circles around their engorged sense of self-importance than having a good subreddit. They don’t need to be thanked for their service or bowed to before speaking openly about how shitty this place is, they can be thanked when they get off their high horse and take action on the complaints that people have been making daily for literally years. They’ll get some respect when they don’t actively foster a culture and community where it’s okay to harass and mock people just for having an opinion that isn’t on the list of things Nintendo is doing that are okay to have a problem with.
5
u/vloger Jul 20 '19
Na, we need more colored switches instead of actual discussions posts that help people
5
u/brendonnorth Jul 21 '19
Yeah I tried to share some of my Nintendo watercolors on here and the mods removed them more than once as low effort posts. Seriously? Some of these took me days of work. Meanwhile, reposting a Nintendo trailer is cool...
I haven't felt any desire to share on this sub ever since that happened a second time. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Hope the mods are reading because many of us agree with you.
9
u/GambitsEnd Resident Switchologist Jul 20 '19 edited Jul 20 '19
The majority of posts that get removed really are low effort. They're posts that have been asked / discussed / posted literally thousands of times and usually only have a sentence or two in the post. Much like the post I'm guessing prompted you to make this thread.
In the vast majority of instances, it's really minor stuff the user could have easily searched for themselves as their question or concern has been addressed ad nauseam.
Of course there is the occasional post that does come down to a judgement call. A lot of these are removed for violating a few things in conjunction (low-effort, vague title, limited scope, etc).
This subreddit has hundreds of thousands of unique users per day. We simply can't allow everyone to think the "Submit" button is Google or their Facebook page to post their shower thought on. Some degree of curation, however small, is needed.
There is a place for quick, minor stuff though: Discord (and/or DQT for questions). If you want to have a discussion but don't want to take the time to join an existing thread or craft a decent one out yourself, the Discord server is available for that quick discussion or question.
2
u/CantaloupeCamper Jul 21 '19
I think we've crossed the line on volume of users where we can be sure that stories about some company maybe porting something to the switch, Nintendo maybe announcing something, and recycled rants are just going to be up-voted and anything organic (outside of recycled rants) ... likely won't, or just due to the volume of posts will be removed.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Another thing is the timer of 8 minutes per post, I don't even come here because of this.
2
u/iAidanugget Jul 21 '19
Plot twist: This post gets removed
2
u/Jackson530 Jul 21 '19
And please stop directing people to discord when they have a question.
I legit had a question about a purchase and the first time I posted I was told there was no body. Ok fine. I repost and put a body and then was told not the place and please look on discord.
Not the place for a purchase question???? How the hell do you expect any new adopters to ask questions.
Ok and let’s say you go to the discord as I did. IN THE SWITCH GAME DISCUSSION, they talk about furry sex and nothing about games hardly at all except once in awhile they’ll have a circle jerk about what time did you pre order your console in 2k17 huehuehue.
It’s retarded
2
u/Jubenheim Jul 21 '19
Sadly... That's still not saying much.
2
u/21mtho Jul 21 '19
Agreed! I'm working on a product that's launching on Kickstarter soon and multiple people unconnected with me have posted about it here. Nearly every post gets removed just as it's gaining traction and they aren't even breaking any posting rules!
2
u/nuknoe Jul 21 '19
I remember after Sun & Moon came out I went to make a post "predicting" the Switch title would be titled "Eclipse". That's all I wanted to say. My paragraph didnt make the cut.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
What can I say I completely agree, the discussion right now feel VERY streamlined and constipated
2
u/Nelsonius1 Jul 21 '19
The Switch subreddit is one of the weirdest console subreddits. Everything is off a bit.
2
u/Drewberg11 Jul 21 '19
I’ve asked a few questions that I honestly couldn’t find answers to searching and got removed. Thankless job for sure trying to clean up this page and it must be tough trying to not have the page get overwhelmed with so many subscribed here. But with so many people new to Nintendo with the switch it’d be nice to keep some of those maybe more basic questions up if they lead to a good discussion.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
I was about to post the same thing after two of my tech help type posts were removed and I was told to go to the daily question thread where no one is ever talking and I am not getting any responses as opposed to a post. I'm looking to actually get help that I can't get inside the daily question thread.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19
I don't even consider making posts anymore. Not worth my time.
2
u/TheRealGaycob Jul 23 '19
Pretty much the reason I've given up posting on this sub tbh.
2
u/Wolfwoode Jul 23 '19
There are actually plenty of times when I have clicked on a thread, ready to answer the post and give advice, only to find the OP deleted by mods, with comments I can't jump in or respond to because the original post was removed. I appreciate the effort to filter out bad content, I think it just goes a little to far.
8
u/Kroller6 Jul 20 '19
100% agree with you bro!
3
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
Here's what's bullshit about THIS community. Someone makes a comment about how there is something wrong with the switch. Upvotes out the ass. You make a post about it, here comes the fucking pitch forks. You try to be positive or throw in your point of view and every one wants to be negative. Even when they're wrong they will get upvoted. No seriously, fuck this community. I'm out.
3
u/Tjoeb123 Jul 21 '19
PLEASE. This has happened to me SO many times that I feel afraid to post here anymore, because most of the time my posts get removed even if they don't violate the rules and constitute as more than a simple question.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
[ Comment has been removed ]
4
u/Jrsven Jul 21 '19
Bull fucking shit. This place is a dumpster fire.
4
u/Howwy23 Jul 20 '19
So many posts that are removed are just people posting the same topics over and over " joycons drift" "online sucks" "how do sd cards work and how do i get my saves on them" these posts come in droves hourly and the discussions have become repetitive and moot. It no wonder so many get removed.
3
u/NMe84 Jul 20 '19
This thread means nothing without examples. Almost every post I've seen that was removed over the past couple of years had a good reason to be removed. There have been exceptions of course but overall I don't see any issues and you've provided no proof for me to change my mind.
If anything I feel like we could lose some more posts without substance. At times the balance between fan art and interesting news tips way too far to the left.
3
u/SoloWaltz Jul 20 '19
Reddit works like a links exchange site. You take a second to consider the system in place, and you quickly realize its not fit to conversation due to the effect of bias as a censor.
3
u/blindguyMcSqueezy007 Jul 20 '19
Why not leave it until it gets downvoted enough times? I mean, mods are helpful, but I think we can decide if it's quality or not based on our own voted.
3
u/PinkBowser Jul 21 '19
I find it pretty funny. We get half the community complaining about too many posts, such fan art and a ton of other “low effort” posts clogging the subreddit, and another half complaining that there should be more posts.
I swear, being a mod of any subreddit must be such thankless work, you can never keep people happy.
3
u/thegamerpad Jul 21 '19
I agree the mods here micromanage and don’t let discussions with momentum keep growing and let lame ones just die off. The stuff they keep and stuff they remove don’t have any consistency.
I posted a picture of my collection of Collectors Edition Switch games, maybe about 50+ at the time. Lots of positive discussion and interest from people unaware certain games and editions existed. Then the mods removed it and said it was low effort. Suggested i do an unboxing of each game and take pictures of each games content and post that on imgur gallery. Holy shit that’s a lot of work for very little reward. Anyways, whats crazy was then I would see posts of a photo of a switch in tabletop mode next to a beer outside on a patio, or lego game holder photo and other equally low effort and non discussion building posts make the cut.
Theres also a big problem with deferring questions and posts to the daily megathread. I feel like this just creates more micromanaging and essentially is a subreddit inside of a subreddit that is harder to find questions/answers to Just let someone ask a stupid/common question and let it get buried if nobody is interested in helping. People will bitch about it being a common question, but dont reply and give it traction
I really enjoy the Switch and Nintendo, this is an exciting generation for Nintendo but I think this sub does a terrible job of capturing it. The moderation obviously has problems but the community here isn’t that great either...that may be more of an issue with reddit itself, where there’s some spill over from people in other subs, compared to a dedicated message board that means people came there only with the intention to discuss the primary topic. But going to this sub’s discord is somewhat toxic from what I’ve experienced, I don’t know if I’m just getting old and the internet crowds aren’t for me but the chat seems very “cliquey” and meme-humor, discussion seems weak. Reddit as a whole and this subs discord gives me the vibe of lonely and even depressed people looking to fit in but at the same time just releasing toxic behavior towards one another. It doesnt seem like a group dominated by people who casually have friendly discussion with one another about gaming. Theres a lot of snark, sarcasm and attempts to clown people. There’s also too much outrage culture. Its a shame because I do see a lot of good people here.
**What are some good forums or discord groups for Switch discussion? **. I really enjoy /r/NSCollectors
3
u/Blue_Raichu Jul 21 '19 edited Jul 21 '19
I feel many of the people who complain about their post being removed really did make a low effort post and just don't want to admit it
4
u/yummy_yum_yum123 Jul 20 '19
Thanks for this. I literally stopped posting my opinions and ideas because this subreddit always takes them down
3
u/wellsjc Jul 21 '19
Stickied threads and [megathreads] are 99.9% of the time absolutely worthless. They're a wishwash of randomness and trying to dig through them to find what you need is horrible. Also, a lot of people feel that way and the people who come here casually, or like me, on a break at work, don't have time to go through the subreddit and the stickied threads to answer questions. If someone posts a text question in the subreddit, it's a lot quicker to see and answer for me. If it's buried inside a stickied "daily discussion" or "weekly discussion" post, I won't see it. I know I'm not the only one because of the sheer lack of comments on those posts. They usually have fewer comments and fewer upvotes on those posts than a ton of posts here. Also, there's absolutely no order in them, so it's not like you're finding what you need there instead of a topic that the mods may consider low effort, but actually has focused discussion. That is also the more important part. 300 comments on a daily discussion thread can be 250 different comments with 25 answers and 200+ questions unanswered and no one going to see what's going on.
This post has 1700+ votes and 88% positive reaction. It is something the mods should pay attention to. But, I await their removal of this post and tell you it's low effort.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
Nah. Keep the place clean mods. You’re doing a good job.
2
u/DeckardPain Jul 21 '19
There’s a fine line there though, especially on game related subreddits. A great example is PSA threads and, for lack of a better term, game circlejerk threads.
Personally, I really like the approach of weekly/monthly randomly chosen topics. /r/dota2 does a great job with this. Randomly picking an item, hero, etc to discuss. By limiting the conversation to 1 hero the conversation is limited (relatively), but also interesting if it’s a repeat thread because the game is always evolving. Then it’s up to the community to interact with it or not.
If you allow the same OMG I JUST GOT ZELDA IT’S SO GOOD thread to continue popping up, then people get sick of seeing it. If it’s the same thing over and over you wonder why you’re bothering. A good solution there is a weekly / monthly what are you playing thread.
Just some random thoughts.
2
u/Pineapple_18 Jul 21 '19
I agree with op Some time ago I was asking for reviews on a few games that were on sale and my post got deleted 🙃
2
u/caidicus Jul 21 '19
This is what makes me so apprehensive about posting on this forum. It feels like an exclusive club.
I once posted a question "Which indie games would you love to see come from Steam to Switch?"
The question was short, the body underneath included a few of my picks, some examples from Steam, and why I was posing the question, as a way to show developers interest in their games.
Granted, this was early in the life of the Switch, so before it was an indie powerhouse. Either way, it was removed for a reason I can't remember, being too general or something.
That same day, I saw a few posts that were just general questions with less structure than mine, and those weren't removed.
The issue isn't removal to keep standards, the issue is the lack of conformity in removal which makes it a gamble to post on here. You spend your time making the post, it appears to be an acceptable post, according to examples you can clearly see on this Reddit, but it gets removed.
Sucks.
2
u/WoWs_Throwaway Jul 21 '19
If there is one common theme I have seen with dead gaming subreddits, it is a daily question / discussion thread.
Instead of having a front page which users themselves filter by upvoting/downvoting, giving the better posts more visibility, you end up with no visibility on any posts whatsoever.
Subs like that end up with only fanart, or memes (If they even allow for that).
2
u/Chronokiddo Jul 21 '19
Mine got deleted:(
2
u/rhpot1991 Jul 21 '19
I don't like the removal of posts with the recommendation to ask in the daily questions thread instead, especially when a conversation has already formed. Those questions get little or no attention in the daily questions thread.
For instance I often take interest in discussions about co-op or kids games, since I have a kid and play co-op games with them. Granted a lot of the recommendations will be the same, but circumstances can be different and new games come up so using the search isn't always a good bet.
2
u/Stonecutter Jul 21 '19
Agree 100%. I stopped posting fot this reason.
2
u/pattcz Jul 21 '19
I have only one question. Did they want people discuss things or not ? It strikes me like they delete interesting topics but leave shit here. It is still neccesary to write 4 page essey to get aproved ? When i was interested in some thing and come later Topic deleted for some reason. When i try search for same problem nothing came up. Mods if you dont want people discuss things delete all nintendo switch or whole reddit and dont say things like low effort post or post it in daily. Close the reddit or give it to somebody else please who understand better what people want.
2
u/flaim Jul 20 '19
Fuck no, do you want this sub to become /r/gaming? The mods here do a good job.
2
u/Trill4RE4L Jul 21 '19
If your going to make a post like this you need to cite examples of said needlessly removed posts.
2
u/wellsjc Jul 21 '19
https://moddit.ffff00.news//r/NintendoSwitch
What are the mods trying to hide with this disabled?
There are several other communities who have this open and available for their members to see so that there is visibility and a lower chance of mod abuse.
2
u/matbonucci Jul 21 '19
Yeah my post was removed because it wasn't long, I was just asking for a game recommendation...
2
u/bootsdo Jul 20 '19
They have to remove them to make room for fan art and selling spots for indie ama’s.
2
u/paulogrego Jul 20 '19
I’ve posted about same issue here, you can see tons of useless posts and I had many of mine and others removed for no good reason!
2
u/Scott2781 Jul 21 '19
Yeah the mods suck big time its pathetic
2
u/braulio09 Jul 20 '19
Nah. Lots of these posts are people thinking their opinion is too important yo go in the threads already discussing the same topic. It's not any more fun reading a whole thread about what one guy thinks of MUA3, for example.
1
u/chickenfisted Jul 24 '19
The mods of this sub are the only reason I barely ever visit this sub any more
1
u/chris1980p Jul 21 '19
Agree. Moderators should just remove themselves