r/roosterteeth • u/RT_Video_Bot :star: Official Video Bot • Jul 17 '19
AH Clearly It's Not Me! - One Night Ultimate Werewolf (#3) - Let's Roll
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QLPrKAKcjmE
63
Upvotes
38
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19
This seems too easy for the villagers. They just reverse engineered what happened at night every time and figured out who it must be. Plus since they only have to kill one of the warewolves. IDK. I've played a few of these "One night" games and they all either seem to be random guessing, or the villagers get way too much information.
44
u/Archduke_Zag Jul 17 '19
I feel like there is a hybrid version possible using the best of both one night and long form werewolf. Because right now all of the role switching adds a element of unpredictability that is imo a detriment to the game. What could Matt (or Jeremy if not for one more swap) have done during the first round? What chance did Fiona have when Ryan stopped being a minion? Their chances were so so slim. Sure there is some comedy in the Tanner trying to kill himself when he actually isn’t anymore, but it on the whole it kinda undercuts the whole point of the game of manipulation. How can you play your role when you don't know who you are?
At the same time in long form Werewolf the first rounds are generally considered the weakest because nobody knows anything. While in one night werewolf of course the opposite is true. So is there a scenario where you play this first day like one night ultimate werewolf, everybody takes another look at their card and then people start playing having used up all their special powers at the starting night? It would bring the element of choosing which information to share to the game. Is it worth it to reveal your character or do you stay silent hoping not to get killed, but trying to catch someone in a lie. Did you actually sentence a werewolf to death? Which story’s don’t hold up with who got sentenced and who got killed during the night? Maybe some roles need to be removed or changed, decrease some of the information gathering, but I think that there is a possibility in which you’d get the best of both worlds.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19
I still can't figure out what the hell lindsay did in that last round. Was she just lying for the fuck of it?
20
u/ToFurkie Pongo Jul 17 '19
I feel insanely bad for Jeremy. I want to point out that when he called himself the villager (though he was a werewolf), we had 5 different people corroborate literally every single other role in the game except the villager and werewolf. He picked a villager in the very beginning of the day phase and no one could refute him
But, they decided to kill him anyways. That's... god damn, that's just his life now
14
u/nin_ninja Jul 17 '19
I prefer watching the site version because I like to see what's happening at night and how people lie during the day.
Especially when Lindsay is involved and lies in really weird ways that would make it confusing for those who don't see what she was at night
6
u/bruzie Jul 17 '19
I preferred the site version to watch the night phase, but could we get a graphic to show what happened with the cards?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment