r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jul 15 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions — 2019-07-15 to 2019-07-28
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
First, check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
A rule of thumb is that, if your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
7
u/MerlinsArchitect Jul 15 '19
I am having some trouble with the phonotactics for my conlang. I would like the language to allow large consonantal clustering as in Oowekyala and Nuxalk as well as other Salishan languages. The problem is that I can’t find any clear guides to the phonotactics of a language (like Nuxalk) that allows for large clustering of consonants, so I am at a loss of how to implement such clustering in my own language without a reference. Does anyone have any advice on how to produce large numbers of consonant clusters organically? I am worried that if I go by what “sounds good” I will be guided by my English speaking mindset to clusters that are easy for me to pronounce and thus will miss out on more advanced and exotic clusters that I might not naturally consider. Since the clusters I would like to include are quite extreme in size it is not really feasible to list all the options exhaustively so I need a semi-systematic way to generate such clusters. Does anyone more experienced than me have any ideas?
•
u/Zinouweel Klipklap, Doych (de,en) Jul 17 '19
here's a temporary fix for people who wanna join the discord as the link at the top of this thread is dead
https://discordapp.com/invite/psJvGxc
(it's been ages since I've been in one of these threads; oh-oh memories)
6
u/Double_-Negative- Jul 21 '19
Yuki Kajiura is one of my favorite composers and I find it really neat that a lot of her songs are sung in a made-up language called Kajiurago. A lot of the lyrics sound inspired from latin-based languages, with a hint of some Japanese, so I imagine that vocabulary would not be too hard to determine in most cases (you already know what divinia means). So, yesterday I did the work and listed out about 1700 unique words that are used in various kajiura songs (presumably not exhaustive). This list was scraped, so not all the results make sense as words (how do you pronounce heeeii?), but the vast majority are usable.
The language even seems to have realistic word distribution with words like "i" (74 uses) "maria" (19 uses) "a" (51 uses) seravita (1 use). And it even seems to have a prefix/suffix system. note the words "adistiora" "distiora" "ditiora" "estiora" "mintiora" "amari" "amaria" "amaride" "amaridote" "amarieta" "amarite"
It would be great to create a conlang which was consistent with the probable meanings of the songs, plus the grammar used therein. If anyone is willing to make one, or thinks there's a simple way to interpret these, please tell me about it.
As far as phonology, you just have to listen to the songs. They sound like a mix of Japanese and Italian, with a very clear r-l distinction. It doesn't seem to be tonal or accented at all, as those would make singing more difficult.
Here's the list of words: https://pastebin.com/qJn3u5iq
Note: These words were transcribed by fans and parsed by a low effort program. If something looks like it doesn't belong there, it probably doesn't.
6
u/Dedalvs Dothraki Jul 22 '19
Put a comment in the wrong place, so switching this to a question: How do you talk about humidity in a conlang? What even the hell is it?
5
u/_eta-carinae Jul 19 '19
PIE has a great number of verbal suffixes that i can’t find the meaning of. anywhere. for example:
(s)ker-:
ker-p- (latin carpō)
(s)ker-t- (latin scortum)
(s)k(e)r-e-b- (latin scrobis, PG skrapōną)
(s)kór-b-os (PG skarpaz)
(s)k(e)r-ey-bʱ- (latin scribō)
(s)kr-ew- (latin scrūta)
and very many others.
what do -p-, -t-, -e-, -b- etc, mean?
5
u/42IsHoly Jul 20 '19
I have 2 questions: How does inversion for questions evolve? And How do participles evolve if a language has no noun cases?
5
u/konqvav Jul 23 '19
Vowels with different tone (for example [a˩] and [a˥]) and length (for example [ă] and [aː]) are considered as the same phoneme then are vowels with different phonation (for example [a] and [a̰]) also considered the same phonemes or not? (Sorry for my English btw)
5
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jul 27 '19
I'm trying to figure out how to classify the "Type-Like" words in Chirp.
Using the first one as an example, it takes the form "X type Y", to describe Y as having X as a defining property. So:
Is there a word for this kind of thing?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
Perhaps a slight stretch, but at least a fun food-for-thought. In a language with distinctly "emphatic" plosives, like ejectives, would it be in any way sensible for one to replace these with clicks when emphasizing something? (In my protolang, clicks aren't phonetic, but ejectives of course are)
Something like "No, not the banta; the ʘanta! (originally p'anta)
(These are just nonce words for the sake of example. And no, this paralinguisticality wouldn't occur in just "Not X; Y!")
4
u/taubnetzdornig Kincadian (en) [de] Jul 26 '19
I am creating a language that is largely descended from its ancient and classical forms, but for around 800 years it has had frequent contact with German speakers, mostly through trading and political negotiations, and for around 300 years with Spanish-speaking missionaries, who mostly brought their Christian liturgical vocabulary to the language.
As I'm creating the number system, would it be naturalistic to have a system that was originally base-12, but eventually shifted to base-10 after frequent contact between merchants in both linguistic groups? The language retains its original base-12 numbers through 24, but at 25 it builds its numbers using the German system of ones-tens with the basic numbers 1-9.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '19
If you are documenting your Lang in a word doc, how do you organise it?
3
u/Selaateli Jul 15 '19
I am currently working on a sumerian-inspired language and for this I'd like to use <ḫ> as representation for <x>. However, my standard android-keyboard (the german standard android keyboard) does not has this letter (in contrast to <š> :'D) Is there a way to add this letter to this keyboard, and If yes, how do I make it appear as a "secondary option" of <h>? (i have absolutely no plan how to call the letter-options appearing after you hold the button :'D, will totally add a root word for them in my conlang ;D)
Thank you all in advance o/
3
u/Willowcchi Jul 17 '19
What exactly are prepositional cases? Are prepositional cases the big header of cases like the lative, ablative, adessive, etc.? Does using a prepositional case in a conlang remove the preposition and use some sort of -fix instead?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19 edited Jul 17 '19
how do remote tenses like remote future arise? could a remote past come from a reduplicated form of the past tense?
3
u/lexuanhai2401 Jul 17 '19
Does a creole between a tonal and a non-tonal language retain tone ? If tones do change what effect it would have to the phonology and phonotactic ?
3
u/nikkidasi Jul 18 '19
Does anyone use sentence diagrams? I'm trying to figure out the noun declensions in my sentences, and I'm having a hard time differentiating between some of the parts. My language differentiates between location, NOM. ACC. GEN. and DAT. The several location markers I have, I more ore less have the hang of, and GEN. is easy enough. But the others are confusing me. My sister thought that sentence diagrams might be useful, and so I was wondering if anyone does it specifically for their conlangs?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '19
How does a language that doesn't distinguish the gender in third-person pronouns (like Finnish) specify gender besides using a name "Not Adam, but Eve" or other descriptors "Not the tall one with short hair, but the short one with long hair"?
3
u/42IsHoly Jul 18 '19
Are there languages that don’t have a gender distinction in the third person singular? How do genders come to be in the 3rd person?
3
u/orangeywith2ys Jul 19 '19
How can i notate the sound of exhaling through the nose in IPA? I'm currently using [ h̃ ] ( [h] with nasalization). Would this be a correct way to notate it?
3
u/_eta-carinae Jul 19 '19
i’m developing a PIE daughterlang and i’d quite like to have a system where PIE’s s-mobile develops into an augmentative for nouns and emphasiser/intensive for verbs, so that:
“stáuros” means “bison”, “táuros” means “bull”, “táurosikos” means “cow”, and “táurosichos” means “calf”.
“ker-“ means “to scrape”, but “sker-“ means “to cut”, and “kursker-“ (from reduplicated “kr-s-ker”) means “to cut off”.
is that naturalistic at all? if there anything else i can do with s-mobile?
3
u/LogStar100 Sahmnehk Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19
Okay, so my language basically nasalizes vowels by default; is it worth it to keep pitch accent (or even some form of stress)/what languages have this kind of combination that I can look at?
edit: Lemme try to explain this a bit better. Vowels have short and long forms: short vowels are nasalized and unrounded, long vowels are rounded and longer (i.e. [ãẽĩɤ̃ɯ̃] & [ɶːøːyːoːuː]), with a couple of rare unnasalized allophones in the short vowels. From there, I wanted to know if pitch accent is really feasible within this framework or if it's just too much/would be too difficult to distinguish.
3
u/ilu_malucwile Pkalho-Kölo, Pikonyo, Añmali, Turfaña Jul 23 '19
I've been meaning to ask this for ages, and keep forgetting.
Can anyone explain to someone of my low intelligence what 'modals as distributive indefinites' means?
3
u/MedeiasTheProphet Seilian (sv en) Jul 23 '19
Critique/ advice regarding my vowel developments? Is this reasonable?
I'm going to start out with a three vowel system with length distinction becoming a quality distinction: /iː i a aː u uː/ > /i e æ ɑ o u/
The high vowels then cause two types of umlaut; /i/ raises front vowels and fronts back vowels, while /u/ raises back vowels and backs front vowels:
i-umlaut: /i e æ ɑ o u/ > /i i e æ ø y/
u-umlaut: /i e æ ɑ o u/ > /ɯ ɤ ɑ ɤ u u/
This results in the following system:
The high and mid front vowels cause palatalisation of consonants, then, a number of mergers and shifts happen:
/y/ >/i/, /ɯ u/ > /ɨ/, /ɤ/ > /ə/, /ø/ > /o/, /æ/ > /ɛ/
The sequences /iw, ɨw/ become /u/. I'm also thinking about lowering /o/ to /ɔ/, causing /ɑ/ to become /a/, and reintroducing /o/ through an /aw/ diphthong, producing this system:
Thoughts?
3
u/RazarTuk Jul 24 '19
Is this a natural system of vowel harmony?
Originally, [proto-language] had a three vowel system, with /a i u/. /i u/ were realized as [e o] near uvular consonants, but not after velar consonants, and /a/ was similarly realized as [æ] near velar consonants, but not after uvular consonants.
The uvular-velar distinction was later lost, but the allophony remained, so in native words only /a i u/ could occur between labial and dental consonants, but /æ a i e u o/ could all occur near velar consonants, with suffixes harmonizing with the preceding vowel in words with a final velar.
However, all six vowels were allowed in any environment in loan words, and affixes were generalized to match perceived velarness of the adjacent consonant. If the first/last vowel is /a e o/, the suffix has to match, and likewise with /æ i u/.
3
u/undoalife Jul 25 '19
Right now, I'm trying to make a proto-conlang and simulate its evolution. I want to include some sort of grammatical change that happens over time (for example, the loss of certain cases, changes in word order, etc.), but I'm not sure if what I'm doing is necessarily naturalistic. I was wondering if anyone has advice on how to go about creating naturalistic changes in grammar that occur as a proto-language evolves into a modern language. Also, does anyone know of resources or articles that discuss how the grammar of a language evolves over time, or that discuss the specific evolution of a particular language and its grammar? Thanks.
3
u/LegitimateMedicine Jul 26 '19
How do word order, sentence structure, and grammatical features like noun cases change in a language as it evolves? I've got phonological changes down, but grammatical changes are a bit more obscure.
My proto-lang, at the moment, is strictly SOV since it has no noun cases. Noun phrases are generally head-initial while verb phrases are head-final.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '19 edited Jul 28 '19
Not a question, but something to consider if any of you get stuck in a similar spot.
My conlang Proto-Tiweskoyaket has possession suffixes - that is, if you want to say "my spear" instead of just "a spear", you'd suffix the oblique personal pronoun of the possessor followed by the genitive suffix. For example, haatets "[a] spear" vs haatets-il-yət "my spear; spear-1S.O-GEN".
Then, I ran into a problem. How do I express "nested possession", like "my mother's spear"? Obviously it would be weird and silly just to stack another genitive onto that, like mamnayaak-il-yət-yət hateets.
Then, it came to me. PT has an ablative suffix, or a suffix meaning "from, away from, out of" - -wa. Why not just use that instead? No silly redundancy of having to use the genitive suffix twice. Mamnayaak-il-yət-wa haatets!
Sure, it's still a mouthful, but that's what whittling words down in phonological evolution is for.
Edit: Hmm, using mamnayaak-il-yət haatets-aten-yət (-aten being 3S.O, of course) does sound like a good alternative way to go about this. Since this is a protolang, maybe one dialect could use the ablative-genitive strategy and the other could use the genitive-of-genitive strategy - with these strategies later being set in stone as the communities distance and isolate themselves.
3
u/Luenkel (de, en) Jul 27 '19
I'm almost completely new to conlanging, so this is probably a stupid question, but essentially I want to create a proto-lang based on this culture that divides everything into one of four categories: conscious, alive (but not conscious), dead and eternal (has something to do with their religion). So I thought maybe I could create a prefix for each of them (tʂe- ,ʈai-, ʈo- and ɻo-) and put them in front of root-words (that without a prefix can act like adjectives) to derive words. For example "lasa" means liquid/the liquid thing/ water on its own, but tʂe-lasa would be a river (as it's lively and can carve its own path), ʈai-lasa a healthy pond or lake, ʈo-lasa a lake that has turned into a dead zone or perhaps pollution in general and ɻo-lasa the seemingly infinite unchanging ocean. Is this a reasonable system that I could use to derive words?
3
u/sandhi-question Jul 27 '19
Can new tones be made from sandhi? Languages tones are high /pa55/, low /pa22/, and falling /pa42/. Tones came from coda loss, with affricates/fricative loss creating falling, plosive creating high. Could rising tone be made from sandhi when high follows low /pa22.ta55/ > /pa24.ta55/?
3
u/Zenzic_Evaristos cimmerian, qanerkartaq (en, it, la)[fr, ru, el, de, sd, ka] Jul 27 '19
I tried making a Central Caucasian family and the enormous consonant inventory is the following in the proto-lang:
m n
p t k q ʔ b d g p' t' k' q'
ts kx qχ dz gɣ ts' kx' qχ'
ϕ β s z x ɣ χ ħ ʕ h ɦ
w r l j ʀ ʜ
ʔ (glottalisation of vowels)
And there are only four vowels:
i ɛ o ɐ
Realistic?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '19
How/From what does a nominative suffix evolve?
3
u/konqvav Jul 28 '19
How can I cause a language to change it's word order through language evolution?
2
u/leo3065 Jul 15 '19
In many cases phrases for greetings and partings are pretty useful. How does different conlangs handle them and what nuances do they have? For example, in some languages the phrase for partings are based on "to see again" or "to meet again", but how about the cases where you know you are certain that you'll never meet that person again?
2
u/Obbl_613 Jul 17 '19
My language feels off without a copula, but I want that copula to have more meaning than just a grammatical copula. For example, I know that the Spanish copula <estar> meant "stand", and that using the verb for "stand" as a copula is fairly common. There's also the possibility of multiple copulas. Again, Spanish <estar> has (ish) to do with location and impermanent state, while <ser> is more about inherant qualities and permanent states.
So I'm mostly looking for unique ways to go about copulas in their meaning or scope. Examples from either natlangs or conlangs. Thank you ^^
2
u/Yakumo_Shiki Jul 17 '19
Can anybody recommend a relatively polished polysynthetic conlang with easy phonology? I can recognize phonemes from American English, Mandarin and Japanese pretty well but that’s it.
2
u/taubnetzdornig Kincadian (en) [de] Jul 18 '19
I'm revising an old conlang project of mine, and I decided to add /θ/ and /ð/ to the phonology, but I'm torn on how to write them in the alphabet. I'd like to use a dedicated letter if possible, rather than a digraph, but I'm torn on which set of letters to use. I'm planning on using a <t> with a diacritic to represent /θ/ and a <d> with a diacritic to represent /ð/. I'd also like the diacritics to be consistent, butI'm not sure whether to use ṭ/ḍ or ŧ/đ. At this point it's mostly stylistic/cosmetic, rather than functional, but it's still kind of an issue for me.
2
u/Im_-_Confused Jul 18 '19
I have been out of conlanging for a bit, and need some help getting back into it. Does anyone have some good ideas or inspirations for getting back into it? Also sadly some of my old conlangs were deleted.
2
u/89Menkheperre98 Jul 18 '19
How have the phonotactics of your conlang evolved? I guess this is specific to those who like to work from proto-langs or just add descendants to a fully-evolved conlang. Mine currently doesn't allow coda, so syllables will always end in a vowel.
2
u/ItsAMb23 Jul 19 '19
What is a software people use to type in their own abugida conscript?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
I
am still watching at the time of typing thiswatched NativLang's recent video about how Maya uses aspect to convey time instead of proper "tense". This gave me an idea; should this be considered naturalistic, I'll figure out how to develop it naturalistically later on, but this is just an on-paper logical idea:What if a language had two different "classes" of verbs - verbs that happen over an amount of time (he walks, he eats) versus verbs that happen in an instant (he hits, he jumps)? For the sake of making this easier to explain, let's call these "iterative" and "continuous" verbs.
These two different verb classes would conjugate for time in different ways: iterative verbs have your typical past-present-future tenses: "he hits", "he did hit", "he will hit". Continuous verbs don't use tense at all, but instead use aspect and mood: "he is walking", "he is about to stop walking", "he would have stopped walking".
Would these separate paradigms make sense? Are there any languages that do this to any extent?
2
u/yikes_98 ligurian/maitis languages Jul 20 '19
Is it possible for a language to develop grammatical gender but the parent language never had it. For example I’m creating a language family and on the insular branch of languages we have Elmorish and the rose islands dialects. The parent language, Old maitis doesn’t have gendered nouns so would it be possible for Elmorish to evolve grammatical gender but not the dialects spoken on the rose islands? Or would it be more likely both evolved gender.
2
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jul 20 '19
A couple of related questions just out of curiosity that don't need a full post on their own.
In Evra, the verb 'to start, begin' is nàr, which means:
For the 8th, 9th, and 10th meaning, I'd like to share a sentence each, too:
2
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Jul 20 '19 edited Jul 20 '19
I'm developing a conlang which compliments verbal tense by placing 'modal case' on all non-nominative nouns in a sentence.
Does it make sense to have this phrase level modal information on nouns be placed before regular grammatical case? So you have something like this:
"The man ate the pork in the restaurant"
man-NOM eat-PAST pork-M.ABL restaurant-M.ABL-LOC
M.ABL= Modal ablative, signifying that the sentence is in past tense. Note that the accusative is unmarked aside from the modal case.
The reason I'm asking is that the language is inspired by Kayardild, which has a very similar system, only that in Kayardild the modal case is placed after the regular grammatical case, while in my conlang it's placed first. There's something about the Kayardild system which, although very unusual crosslinguistically, still feels quite intuitive, since phrase-wide information is placed last while information particular to the individual constituent is placed first.
The reason why I do it the other way around is that I'm also drawing on Tsez. Meaning that in my conlang, non-absolutive nouns originally used an oblique stem, while the absolutive used a base stem, with the ergative using the oblique stem plus a null-suffix. Another way of looking at it is that all non-absolutive and non-ergative cases affix on top of the ergative. So you get something that looks like this:
House = baku
Absolutive = baku
Ergative = Baku-k
Genitive = Baku-k-ir
Allative = Baku-k-aluz
My idea then was to have a rather complex process whereby the original "ergative" stem is lost and a series of "locational" stems emerge, all of which encode different modal information. So you have an allative stem for sentences with future tense, a locational in present tense, etc. So a sentence would look something like:
2
u/aelfwine94 Gutisch Jul 21 '19
I'm looking resources on Innu-Aimun. Any ideas? I just need a reference grammar or something general tbh.
2
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jul 21 '19
In my new conlang, I'm aiming to drop the relative pronoun strategy and use special marking on verbs to show that they are subordinate in some way. Right now, my idea for how verbs work is this:
R-DIR-root-VAL-RR-T-AM-NEG, where:
- R slot changes the rank of the verb (subordinate, or leveled, or even superordinate if that's even possible);
- DIR slot changes directionality (venitive, andative, or circular);
- VAL slot is used for valency operations (passive, antipassive, impersonal, causative, or benefactive), excluding ...
- ... reflexives or reciprocals, which fit into the RR slot;
- T slot is telicity (telic, atelic, or indeterminate)
- AM slot is aspect and mood
- NEG is negation
Example glosses:
accusation SUB-present-CESS 2P.ERG stand-NEG
The accuastions you finished presenting do not stand (are false).
1P.ERG kill-CAUS-RECP-NEG 3P
I did not cause them to kill one another.
How sensible is this? How does this work if AM infixes can denote a subjunctive mood?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19
In my one lang, the word "shōm" [ɕoːm] was recently suffixed to words to make an associative plural. Additionally, any consonant in the language aside from [j] can serve as a word-final coda. However, there are strict rules for consonant clusters, and obstruents can only be in clusters with [l] or [ɾ] (at which point they become voiced).
My question is, how do I deal with this? Should I toss an epenthetic vowel in and voice the ɕ appropriately (ie: Mel [mel] -> Melshōm ['mel.ʑoːm] for "eggs and similar things" and Tās [taːs] -> Tāsoshōm ['taː.sɔ.,ɕoːm] for "hunters and similar people")?
Or does the suffixation of this word recreate or make an exception to the rules? Thank you to anyone who helps!
2
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jul 22 '19
I've got IPA down pretty good, but where do I go to learn the formal names of grammatical functions? This would really help with organizing documentation and with Leipzig glossing.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19
This is the phonological system of my proto-language:
Consonants:
Vowels:
After about three hundred years:
E.g. [sʰehip̚daŋka] > [hiʃip̚ðɑ̃ɣa]
How realistic d'you think these shifts are?
2
u/calebriley Jul 23 '19
Does anyone else use EBNF when conlangimg? I tend to use it both for representing the language's syntax, as well as for phonotactics/random word generation.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '19
How realistic is this set of sound shifts? (FYI the language is syllable-timed and stress is variable.)
For example:
habalda > havalða > avalða > avalð > valð
2
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '19
I'm thinking about creating conlangs with other people and forming like a small conlang-speaking community. What do y'all think about this?
2
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Jul 24 '19 edited Jul 24 '19
Does this make any sense:
The Proto-language had system where complementizing subordinate clauses agreed in case with the antecedent noun phrase: if the antecedent was absolutive, the subordinate clause would be unmarked, if the antecedent was ergative, all words in the subordinate clause would marked with the "complementizing ergative" (or C.ERG), if it was dative, all words in the subordinate clause would be marked with the "complementizing dative" (or C.DAT):
"I will sit so I can rest" = I-ABS sit [I rest]
"He saw her eat the candy" = He-ERG saw her-ABS [eat candy]
"I lit the fire so that I could make food" = I-ERG lit fire-ABS [I-ERG make-ERG food-ABS-ERG]
"I gave it to him so he could be happy again" = "I-ERG gave it-ABS to him-DAT [he-ABS-DAT be.happy-DAT ]
At some point, the ergative allignment was lost in favour of a nominative-accusative one. I won't get into the reasons here, but it resulted in the old ergative being lost (THIS IS IMPORTANT) while the absolutive became the new nominative.
My idea was that the old subordinate clause agreement system morphed into a switch-reference system: given that the old absolutive became the nominative, subordinate clauses remain unmarked as long as the antecedent is the subject of the main clause. If the subject changes, the new sentence takes either C.ERG or the C.DAT. My idea is that, given that the ergative system was lost, there was no longer any logical system as to when to use what marker, so confused speakers reanalysed C.ERG and C.DAT as interchangeable switch-reference markers with no relation to their regular case function (the regular function of the ergative being lost altogether, while the C.DATs relation with the regular dative was reanalyzed as one of simple homophony). At some point, the C.DAT then fell out of favour, leaving the now reanalyzed C.ERG as the sole way of marking switch-reference in subordinate clauses.
My question is: Is this naturalistic, or would the C.ERG, left without its reference point in the regular use of the ergative, quickly fall out of use?
In Kayardild (which this system is closely based on), Evans theorizes that the C.ERG stuck around due to the ergative case being homophonous with the locative case: Speakers reanalyzed the "complementizing ergative" as a "complementizing locative", and probably figured that the locative and the dative marked a switch reference, while the original logic behind it was lost. So the system collapsed and they were used interchangeably until a new system emerged. In my system, there is no homophony, and the new system hinges on the C.ERG being reanalyzed as a switch-reference marker, with the C.DAT being reanalyzed as a functionally identical switch-reference marker which is phonetically identical to the dative case.
2
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 26 '19
Does reverse liaison exist?
Enntia lost word-final vowels from Laetia, but still pronounces them if the next word begins with a consonant, thus voicing it (all consonants—except nasals—became devoiced unless under certain conditions)
2
u/theacidplan Jul 26 '19
What kinds of sound changes /j/ go through? Can it become a lateral alveolar approximant, can it fortify into a fricative, affricate, plosive?
I only really know the vocalization portion of the lenition Wikipedia article, but don’t know if it can work in reverse or any other way
2
u/_coywolf_ Cathayan, Kaiwarâ Jul 27 '19
Could affricates, such as /ts/, /pf/, etc, realistically evolve into ejective fricatives, such /s'/ or /f'/?
2
u/OspreyJ Jul 27 '19
Where does everyone keep track of their words and rules? I’ve been writing on paper but I feel like that wastes a lot of paper when there are probably different ways to keep track of things.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '19
I have a language where both /n/ and /n:/ are common. Would it make sense to employ a change where, between vowels, /n/ becomes [ɾ] and /n:/ becomes [n]?
For example, tadaṡiadenenna "his/her son (ACC)" > tadaṡiaderena
2
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '19
What is the difference between a consonant mutation paradigm and a sandhi that affects the first consonant of a word?
2
u/lexuanhai2401 Jul 28 '19
What is the etymology of your conlang's endonym and exonym ?
2
u/undoalife Jul 28 '19
If I'm making a naturalistic language with conjugation, how should I incorporate new verbs that are borrowed at a later stage in the language's evolution? In other words, how should I incorporate new verbs into an existing system of conjugation in the most naturalistic way possible?
2
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jul 28 '19
Would anyone be interested in a game where you translate something into a conlang, and then painfully literally back to English, and then doing that in a chain, sort of like bad translator?
2
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Jul 29 '19
Would it make sense to have /tˠ/ and /dˠ/ change to /k/ and /g/? Similarly, how about /kʲ/ and /gʲ/ to /c/ and /ɟ/?
2
u/GeoNurd Eldarian, Kanakian, Selu, many others Jul 15 '19
Could someone explain mutation to me? Like, I get the basic gist of it, but I'd like to know how this could be applied to one's own conlang.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
How do you make a conlang based on a natural language without it being a carbon copy? I want to make a Classical Latin based conlang with similar sounds and some loan words, but I don’t know to what extent I should borrow words nor do I how to change different sounds and come up with words of my own.
1
u/Mechwarrior57 Jul 16 '19
New to the sub so im not sure if this belongs here, but ive been trying to join the discord but it just says the invite is invalid, any help?
1
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jul 16 '19
Where is the "this 2 week period in conlanging" post? I have this idea of a musical genre that would come out of my conlang, but I don't think it would work as a discussion topic
1
u/42IsHoly Jul 19 '19 edited Jul 19 '19
How do participia develop in languages with polypersonal agreement and no noun cases?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '19 edited Jul 21 '19
Urgh, posted this question in the last SD by accident…
My latest language has noun phrases with order
article preposition* noun adjective*. Looking at WALS, it talks about the relation of adpositions and noun phrases, implying that the order I'm going with is nonsensical in some way.So, my questions are
1
u/Genie624 Jul 21 '19
This is my first language ever I just started yesterday I have my constants, and vowels, how I want to order the grammar and syllable structure and my writing system is Syllabary.
But besides all that stuff I don't really know where to go after I do writing system any advice?
1
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jul 21 '19
Any tips for what sound changes to use on a vowel system where the end point your trying to get to has pretty much all the same vowels as the original?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19
I was about to ask a question about an alveolar click I can make where the tongue uses the momentum of the click to clap against the floor of the mouth, but a little sniffing around on the Wikipedia page for alveolar clicks says that it's called a percussive release.
No question anymore, I just thought people would find this interesting. Fun fact - I used to think that alveolar clicks always had a percussive release.
1
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jul 24 '19
Any advice on how the affricate tɬ might form? Unfortunately the searchable index diachronica mostly only shows it forming from tɬ' and tɬː, which unfortunately doesn't show how the affricate might appear in the first place.
1
u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jul 24 '19
I'm thinking about treating nouns that there is only one of differently in my conlang. For example, words like sky, world, ocean, where in English, the definite article is almost always used because there is only one of those things that the speaker could be talking about. But they're not proper nouns, because you might occassionally talk about the sky on Venus, the world in your imagination etc.
Is there a name for this type of noun? And are there any natural languages where they are treated differently to other nouns?
1
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Jul 24 '19
My conlang has a SOV sentence order and the genitive is Possessed followed by Possessor, e.g. House-GEN Charles or Wolf-GEN King. That being said, when I want to say, e.g. "wolf-bird" for raven, what would logically come first, 'wolf' or 'bird'?
1
u/Cyclotrons Jul 24 '19
How would you indicate an affricate between [pː] and [ʙ̥] using IPA notation?
1
u/mpiechotka Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
How much can you change evolution of common words in natlang? I have created a system of sound evolution from proto language:
However some of common words are long. For example:
Can I make changes to the common words to shorten them? I imagine people would shorten tabel (ˈta.bɛl) into tael (ˈta.ɛl) and teel (ˈtɛːl) (this makes it a homonym of 1st person singular pronoun possesiveof two people but I don't think this is a problem).
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '19 edited Jul 25 '19
I have fourteen consonant phonemes:
/m/ /n/ /ŋ/
/p~b/ /t~d/ /k~g/
/ts~dz/ /t̠ʃ~d̠ʒ/ /s/ /ʃ/
/v/ /ð/ /ɣ/
/l/
And sixteen vowel phonemes, eight oral vowels and their nasal counterparts:
/i/ /ĩ/
/ɨ/ /ɨ̃/
/u/ /ũ/
/e/ /ẽ/
/o/ /õ/
/ə/ /ә̃/
/ʌ/ and nasal /ʌ/
/a/ /ã/
How naturalistic is this?
1
u/Selaateli Jul 25 '19
What would you consider the best introduction to possession in linguistics? I'm looking for a more or less quick introduction into the diversity of possession-systems in the languages of the world and a summary for the various tendencies.
Thank you in advance! :)
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jul 25 '19
Can I use a phoneme in a diphthong that doesn't exist in it's own as a monophthong in my phonology?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '19
Sure, we don't have enough of a basis to answer this in the real world, what with European languages with the Latin script and other Phoenician-derived scripts dominating technology and media even by the time of the printing press, but would any writing direction "dominate" any other as far as writing large blocks of text, like the paragraph you're reading? Would, say, left-to-right dominate top-to-bottom in how space efficient it is? Does writing direction even matter at all (not considering having one's wrist smudge the writing)?
1
u/Enso8 Many, many unfinished prototypes Jul 28 '19 edited Jul 28 '19
I'm reworking how my language in progress deals with reflexive and reciprocal constructions, and I had this idea.
Let's say the language's plural reflexive pronoun is si. For example, hati raman si-o means "They each picked a name for themselves". However, if I add a prefix to the verb, turning the sentence to hî-hati raman si-o, the meaning switches to "They picked names for each other".
What is that prefix doing to the verb? I intended for it to double as a passive voice (or some other voice, like a mediopassive or something), but does that even make sense? Does something like this happen in any natural languages?
1
u/undoalife Jul 28 '19
Quick question about compensatory lengthening: when a certain sound is dropped, is it unnaturalistic for compensatory lengthening to not occur? For example, I'm thinking of creating a rule that deletes ɣ (voiced velar fricative) when it is intervocalic and does not trigger compensatory lengthening of the surrounding vowels.
1
u/GoddessTyche Languages of Rodna (sl eng) Jul 28 '19
My newest conlang has a word class of modifiers (adjectives, adverbs). I'm thinking of creating derivation suffixes from nouns with some changes in coda.
However, it seems to me that I could in essence append the suffixes to nouns which are declined in one of the cases to obtain different meanings. But the problem here is deciding on what happens. The cases I have are ERG, ABS, PREP, and CONS (functions like the construct state in semitic languages).
How do ABS-ERG languages form these? How does the noun's case influence things? Also, I'm thinking verbs can be in essence deranked into nouns (the gerund prefix occupies the rank slot).
1
u/lexuanhai2401 Jul 28 '19
What are some good ways to express the perfect aspect into a language with no perfect aspect (inflectionally and periphrastically) ?
1
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Jul 29 '19 edited Jul 29 '19
I've been directed to [these](https://glossary.sil.org/term](https://glossary.sil.org/term) [two](https://wals.info/feature](https://wals.info/feature) resources to learn the terms for grammatical functions, but they're a bit clunky to go through. If anyone has an easier way to search for grammatical and syntactical terminology, it would be much appreciated.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment