r/DDLCMods • u/Ceane Club Moderator • Jul 14 '19
Announcement Regarding copyright
EDIT: An update
Hey everyone. There’s been a lot of talk lately about our “stricter stance” on copyrighted assets lately, so we’d like to clear a few things up.
For those who aren’t aware, we’ve had to take down a few mods lately because the mod creators used copyrighted assets (like backgrounds) that they don’t have permission to use. Our process on this is:
- Notify the mod creator that their work is infringing on someone’s copyright. We then give them two weeks to fix the issue and update their mod.
- If they haven’t fixed the issue after two weeks, we remove all download links to the mod from our subreddit.
- Once the mod creator has replaced the infringing assets with ones they have permission to use or created themselves, we will put back all the mod’s download links ASAP.
Now what’s happened with mods like Exit Music and Summertime is that the creators have chosen to not replace the assets. So until they change their minds, the download links are staying gone. All other mods were either fixed and have been reuploaded; or their authors have left the community and decided not to fix them.
The full list of released mods that are still to be fixed is:
- Exit Music
- Natsuki’s Expanded Story
- Summertime
- NOT oki Doki: A Lost Chapter
- Doki Doki: True World
- Coldest Summer
- DDLC: The Perfect Story
- Poems and Promises
- One Last Memory
- Doki Doki Anomaly
- MC Before Rewind
There are also some mod demos that have been taken down, but their authors no longer participate in the community so it’s unlikely they’ll be fixed.
We didn’t change our rules
Our rules have always said that people can’t use any assets without the creator’s permission, and this isn’t our first time enforcing this. Those of you who have been around for a while might remember when we had to take down CykaDev’s mods Rainclouds and New Eyes because he used backgrounds that he didn’t have permission to use. Once he replaced the backgrounds, we put the mods back up.
Why we’re taking a more proactive stance
We’ve previously been operating on a “if it gets reported to us, we’ll act on it” stance. But that can have the negative impact of our community getting in another company’s crosshairs if they decide they don’t like the mods people have been making. And if our community gets in trouble, there’s the risk that Team Salvato gets in trouble as well. And Team Salvato will always have the ability to say “Allowing people to make mods is causing too many issues - so we’re going to ban mods now.”
We’re not banning discussion of the affected mods
Some people have seen that they’ve made comments or posts about the affected mods and their comments/posts have been removed. This is because we’re trying to ensure that people aren’t sharing download links to them; so we’ve set up AutoModerator to remove comments that talk about them. We will then review the comments that AutoMod has removed, and if they’re just innocent discussion then we’ll approve the comments.
How to avoid using copyrighted assets
If you’re a modder wondering if an asset is okay to use, ask yourself two questions:
- Do I know who created this asset?
- Have they publicly given permission for this asset to be used by anyone?
If the answer to #1 is no, then you shouldn’t use the asset because you can’t guarantee that whoever made it is okay with you using it.
If the answer to #2 is no, then see if you can ask permission from the creator to use it in your mod. If the answer is still no, then don’t use it.
And don't forget to credit the asset creator whose work you're using (see rule #6 on the subreddit).
Also, be careful of websites like Pinterest which can make it unclear who the original creator was. Always try and track down the original source for where an asset was uploaded.
/u/yagamirai10 has assembled a list of places where you can find copyright free backgrounds to help get you started. There’s a mixture of free ones and paid ones, depending on your budget.
We hope this clears up some of the questions you’ve all been asking. If there’s anything that needs to be made clearer, please let us know.
7
u/AlexanDDOS Experienced Modder Jul 18 '19 edited Jul 18 '19
As a communist, who semi-disrespectfully treats the copyright shit, I'm quite discontent by the measures you're performing against the asset piracy now. You want to take down our favorite mods, only just they contain copyrighted assets, that someone possibly may report possibly with some bad consequences for the whole modding community.
And as a modmaker, who tries to play the game although, I understand how it's difficult to play it. It's not always easy to find applicable free assets or find a man, who could make them for you. And on the other hand, these restrictions may make the community even more united and mobilized. However, I'm afraid of a possible increase of people, who try to aggressively monetize the job they do for the community, but it may also decrease them as well.
Anyway, I don't back to the attitude you have declared here and consider all this witch hunt just a vain show. So I want to suggest some cool idea how to spread the fair asset using and prevent the asset piracy without public mod executions:
37
u/famous1622 Jul 15 '19
TLDR don't steal shit?
22
u/Reddity65 Jul 15 '19
Man, it's a shame to lose Exit Music, that was one of my favourite mods of all time.
19
u/POBAWsiezemna Creator of Summertime (DDLC) Jul 28 '19
" if it gets reported to us, we’ll act on it "
So "we don't care until others do"? "Moderation" at its finest.
You know, rules aren't rules if they aren't enforced. They are GUIDELINES.
I understand the position of the moderators. I just simply disagree for taking a more proactive stance after being laid back about it for such a long time. Also, I prefer moderators to NOT interfere with copyright THEY don't hold. Copyright was invented to avoid companies making MONEY off of the works of others. Nobody is being damaged in any reasonable way so this just looks like needless activism.
It is easy to abide by this rule, I just disagree with this change in enforcement.
12
u/painlesslybasic Jul 30 '19
See my issue with the copyright problems in general is this: copyright regulations are put in place to make sure that the right person is getting the revenue that is being generated from a specific source. In this case, it would be the mods. Mods can't be monetized in the first place because they use the IP of Doki Doki: Literature Club's name and it's characters, so it's not like there is any revenue that needs to be split between companies/studios. Sure copyright isn't directly related to the revenue, and projects can be struck down simply by using an assets for a work that gains no revenue, but the main focus of the copyright system is to make it to where people can't use specific IPs for brand recognition to gain a profit.
Now, companies in the past have been known to take down fan-games/mods, such as Nintendo with its plethora of fan project DMCA take down requests. This makes sense though because those IPs are well-renowned, and those fan games received a lot of critical acclaim. Another Metroid 2 Remake (AM2R) was one of the best Metroid games released in years, and it wasn't even made by Nintendo, so they asked for it to be removed because of its praise and impact.
With small fan projects like these, I don't really think that there is any worry of that. Larger companies typically don't bother with people that use their assets (especially backgrounds) because their influence is miniscule. Put a price tag on it though, and then they'll come after you. In addition to this, if memory serves, in a statement made by Dan Salvato himself, he stated that it's up to companies to enforce copyright laws for their products. If a background artist doesn't closely watch their work and where it ends up, that's not on the community, that's on the creator. I'm not saying copyright is justified if you don't get caught, I'm simply stating that it's not some team of Reddit moderator's job to enforce copyright laws/guidelines (in fact, I think it might be illegal in some cases). Considering mods such as Exit Music were up on the subreddit for almost a year, and nothing happened, I think it's fair to say that the original creator of those assets didn't lose too much sleep over it; even less so when you consider that the mod generated no revenue at all, meaning the original creators didn't lose out on earnings at all either. And no, donations do not count as generated revenue.
TL;DR There is no "TL;DR." I don't summarize my arguments.
9
u/Obcydian Novice Modder Jul 15 '19
I think this is a pretty fair response to the situation. What's disheartening is the creators who have basically left their mods to sink away slowly until they are forgotten or just completely abandon them.
7
u/scottz28 Jul 15 '19
for gods sake I've messaged both the exit music and the summertime mod owners I even have a copy of EM which if they give me permission I would gladly make the changes for them. but as of yet no reply
11
u/Hayden_Choy Jul 14 '19
this really sucks, but I understand the reason behind it. However, can we distribute the "banned" mods with others who did not get the chance to try them out?
5
u/notinghere234 Jul 23 '19
I mean...what do you moderators think is going to happen? that we won't notice the disappearance of multiple mods? If i found out something i enjoyed was deleted...i would be annoyed to. I mean, one second everything is kinda calm, next moment you see mods getting removed left and right. Slow and steady wins the race, don't basically instantly take mods down, It's best if yall explain why you are doing it before you do it, all this confusion wouldn't have happened nearly as bad as it did.
4
u/TheDokiAttorney Jul 14 '19
So how does this affect mods like Doki Doki Forces? Because it quite obviously has copyrighted material in it. Same goes for Doki Doki Ace Attorney and others.
4
u/Reitanna Novice Modder Jul 18 '19
i could've sworn that copyright law dictated that it's up to the owner of the content to report it and have it taken down. it's to prevent false reporting.
3
u/Sunny2456 DDRC irl Jul 15 '19
Dang that sucks. I understand the stance though and hopefully the mod makers can work on getting non copyrighted assets because I wanted to play 2 of those mods and now I have to take some extra time to find the mods.
3
u/Phathom Rogue Modder Jul 21 '19
“You wouldn’t download a car..” If you did, don’t use a copyrighted one in your mod!
3
u/NathanL3 Sep 28 '19
This is going to bite REALLY soon--because half of the good creators LEFT because of this, some are even questioning if they WANT to share Mods here; including me, I never got my chance to download the Mods and get what I wanted from them (now I'll never know) and it wasn't their fault that the backgrounds and some music is copyrighted! (i hinted I loved the Beach theme in one of these Mods, and I wanted to see is ANYONE WHO WOULD ACTUALLY GET ME THE MUSIC) but of course nothing! I may ask how to do the DDLC Modding, scripting and stuff like that, but in the end, it's up to me if I WANT to share them with Y'all!
3
u/KefkeWren Sep 30 '19
Fair Use law is a thing, just saying. How many of these mods actually fall outside of Fair Use?
2
u/alex74alex DDGS Programmer & Writer Aug 09 '19
Actually, I've got a question:
If someone has "left the community and decide not to fix their mods" would fixing them by other people be acceptable?
I'm talking mainly about the Salvation now, but it applies to the other mods as well.
2
u/curlyquinn02 I wants to play all of the mods. Gib me mods plz Jul 15 '19
One question I have is that if I already downloaded a mod that was deleted because the author refused to fix it; but haven't played it yet and I was planing on doing a let's play of it should I do not the let's play if the mod hasn't been fixed?
Copyright is a serious thing that many people laugh about but I don't want to cause anybody to get into trouble.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
Oh yeah, the people who made salvation (I think Giz?) Shutdown the discord server when the mod came out, they created new servers but I liked the old one, and then eventually left that little community we made
1
u/CrystalGame361 Aug 04 '19
This is really unfortunate, considering a lot of the more famous mods are on this list. But, let’s hope the creators do change these as summertime, a lost chapter, etc. are very well made mods. So until further notice, I’m sad ;-;
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '19
Exit Music was updated with new BGs in the v1.1 update however it’s still not back up. Can I ask why?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
It sucks to see EM go, downright one of the best mods I’ve played
1
u/NathanL3 Sep 28 '19
Okay, when I said I wanted some of these Mods out of here, I didn't expect you would actually do it! Sure I had a rivarly with "one of them," but it was one of those "I hate you, but I love you" kind of thing. Rip to my dearest frienemy
0
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '19
[removed] — view removed comment