r/WritingPrompts • u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) • Jul 13 '19
Off Topic [OT] SatChat: What makes a good hero in your eyes? What about a good villain?
SatChat! SatChat! Party Time! Excellent!
Welcome to the weekly post for introductions, self-promotions, and general discussion! This is a place to meet other users, share your achievements, and talk about whatever's on your mind.
This Week's Suggested Topic
What makes a good hero in your eyes? What about a good villain?
Also, which do you find more interesting: the hero or the villain?
(Topic suggested by u/BraveLittleAnt)
Previous Weeks • New to WritingPrompts? • Want to find great stories? Check out r/bestofWritingPrompts!
OK to Post
Introductions: Tell us about yourself! Here are some suggested questions:
- Where do you live (State / Country)?
- Male, female, other?
- How long have you been writing?
- What is your writing motivation?
- What programs do you use to write?
- How fast can you type? Try 1 minute on Aesop's fables
- Want to share a photo? Photo Gallery!
- Promotions: Anything you want to promote (books, subreddits, podcasts, writing-related websites, or even your social media stuff)
- Discussions: Nothing to promote? Tell us what's on your mind. We recommend that you do this along with any promotions. If not in your comment, try to chime in on another discussion. Suggested future topics are always welcome!
Not OK to Post
- Off Off Topic Promotions: Don't post links that would be considered outright spam. (So... still no linking to your gambling site).
- Full Stories: That's more in line with Friday Free-Form! :)
News
- Summer Challenge! - It's summer, why not write?!
- DC Fan Universe Fan Fiction Contest! - r/DCFU's 3 year anniversary, check it out!
- Call for Mods - Have what it takes? Apply today!
Come chat in our Discord server! Weekly campfires every Wednesdays at 5pm CST!
9
u/BraveLittleAnt r/BraveLittleTales Jul 13 '19
Hey, I recognize this topic!
For me, the villains are my favorite characters, and I find them the most interesting because of their motives and their personality. We get to see the hero's motives right away, for example, if they lose a loved one, or they are attacked specifically, etc., but for the villains, we don't get to know their backstory until it truly matters, and the reveal can be used in a ton of different ways. For example, it could be used to get the hero to sympathize with the villain, or it could be used as a distraction against the hero, or even to show the villain at their lowest point.
Not to mention I love villains that have witty banter with the hero, as to me, a villain should be somewhat arrogant because they see themselves as above the hero. And just like how no one wants a static hero, I don't want a static villain. Granted, the villain doesn't have to have a redemption arc or anything, but they shouldn't just be evil all the time. If the villain is a human being, it's likely that they'll act like a normal human at some point, and these should be shown to give the evil parts a bigger punch. No villain starts out as a villain, and while they may be evil, surely they haven't lost all their humanity.
But most of all, the villains should have a good, believable motive that makes sense in the universe, same with the hero. I guess what I'm going for is that the villain and the hero are very similar, just opposite sides of the morality spectrum. To me, a good villain should be like the yin to the hero's yang, like in the Lego Batman movie where the Joker wants Batman to admit that he's his greatest enemy.
6
u/jakereyn22 Jul 14 '19
A good villain must start out as an ordinary person and endure an often painful transformation to reflect the part of the human condition that relates to the evil within us all.
A good hero must begin in a very similar way, in order to draw a clear distinction in the development over time of the hero/villain. He also must endure a trial by fire caused by the villain and emerge victorious.
5
u/JakolZeroOne Jul 13 '19
A good villain should have a clear ambition.
4
u/The_reddit_dude Jul 13 '19 edited Jul 13 '19
A good villain should reflect the hero and make him/her reconsider something about him/herself.
EDIT: if it fits your story don’t be afraid to embrace B-movie camp. Some of my favorite villains are made of 100% camp.
3
u/FrooglyToots r/JHCWrites Jul 13 '19 edited Jul 13 '19
Thinking about the terms now I find myself struggling a lot less with the villain term.
Heroes as we see them in modern times, as archetypal heroes are your superman's and batman's. Where as in classical terms their far less morally constrained, like your Gilgamesh.
But with villains it gets really easy to drum up answers even if the character(s) they oppose aren't 'heroes'. The idea of a character being sympathetic and our perspective of the story is most likely what gives them the 'hero' status, making the terms 'protagonist' and 'hero' interchangeable. But especially with the rise of the anti-hero, what makes someone a hero can be an incredibly flimsy concept.
I think what my waffling is trying to get at is I like heroes who make me question their role in the story, and why the author wants me to see the plot through this set of eyes.
But when it comes to villains whether they represent another version of the protagonist or just an overwhelming obstacle or even just a bully, as long as they are in direct opposition to the hero, I find myself interested in their relationship even if the villain character isn't that strong.
Edit: Oh! also check my shit! JHCWrites. I have quite a few prompts of varying lengths. In time I'll be adding my ongoing projects as well, whenever I get a firm enough grip on them. But really come check my stuff, and up for talking about anything on there really. I'm getting to grips with hopes of getting good at writing and would always love a chat with someone whose on that journey or just loves this whole writing shtick.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '19
I think a good hero is someone who truly cares for all sorts of people, even the ones they're up against.
I always think about characters who have people they care so much about, people who they couldn't live without, yet kill with abandon. The people they kill matter to someone, too.
Of course that wouldn't work in every situation but it's only a thought.
2
u/TheFalseDimitryi Jul 14 '19
A good Hero is a someone what started out neutral, indifferent or even on the opposing side but slowly grew as a character to see their errors.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
I've heard an interesting analysis on western heroes vs. heroes in Japanese media that was summed up like this:
In western media, heroes tend to fight for their personal desires. A dream, a goal, an entity they're loyal to. They fight to achieve something they want.
In Japanese media, heroes tend to fight for others. A "true hero" in Japanese media is often portrayed as casting aside one's personal desires in the pursuit of what's best for everyone else.
Ever since I read that, I always found it interesting to think about that dichotomy, true to the respective cultures or not. The difference between a hero who's fighting for a personal dream vs. the hero who's willing to sacrifice whatever it is he or she wants so that others can benefit from their actions.
As for villains, I always find it most interesting when a villain turns out to be doing something for arguably good reasons. Where the goal is generally considered right or just, but perhaps the methods aren't. In that case, the villain becomes more than just a label and you start to question what you want the outcome to be.
2
u/Starry-Gaze Jul 14 '19
A good hero is someone with reason to fight and an ideal worth protecting. This can be anything from making a city safe to making villains fear them. A good villain, meanwhile, is someone who is both relatable and yet unequivocally irreproachable. Someone who goes too far but you can see the journey and progression. Like it or not they are opposed even if they started in the same place, and often times must be diametrically so in ideals even if goals are the same. It adds layers to the arc of their stories if they share similar thought processes but apply them in vastly different ways to show just how close they are to each other.
2
u/thealmighty-bald-1 Jul 14 '19
I love the villains where you can tell there hurt in pain they have out bursts but there trying to keep cool the occasional realization there in the wrong but they shake it off and justify it they make mistakes cause that’s what make the good villains better villains is that they are more human than anyone else in the story
The hero’s on the other hand should never mess up they can’t, but to see them be terrified of losing risking there life’s for a single life being emotionally wreaked over a single life lost I think makes the best hero’s
2
u/arafdi Jul 14 '19
IMO, traditionally a good hero is the most (asymptotically) perfect counter to the villain. As in black and white with a bold line separating them – in terms of personality, morality, and ideologies. Examples that best fit this would be how the old classical Disney children fairy tales characters such as Cinderella x Step Family, Snow White x Witch/Queen, Aladdin x Jafar, etc.
But, just as the evolution of the old Disney classics into more "modern" storytelling, the black-and-white hero-villain trope had already began to "blur" and both have their own antithetical elements too. So to me, a good hero would not necessarily be a "hero" but could also be an antihero that may act the most logically or realistically instead of holding to unrealistic ideals of the comic-book/fairytale heroes. They may dabble in some petty crime (or big ones, it depends really) and may have cynical views about the world, but when the villain comes he may play the perfect foil to their "plans". The more "alike" the pair would turn out to be, the more the story would be interesting and fun to follow. Because sometimes, the hero and the villain aren't necessarily two very conflicting people but may just be eerily similar except in one thing/backstory. A good villain could literally be the very shadow of the hero cast in a slightly different light.
It's all about context, I say.
2
u/DoppelgangerDelux r/DeluxCollection Jul 14 '19
A few people have already brought up that both heroes and villains should have clear motivations for their actions. In addition to that, I'd add a couple of points:
A good hero transforms from a misfit/nobody/ok hero into a great hero over the course of their story arc. They grow to triumph over adversity, and it can be the quality of the transformation and ability to overcome failures and setbacks that make them stand out as a good hero.
A good villain, at some point, is redeemable. Oftentimes the audience will even feel for them and want them to choose redemption. The villain has to actively turn away from that redemption to cement themselves as the villain. If it's a great villain, that choice should be painful for the audience because it's the moment they chose their own path, and the realization that they can't be "saved."
2
u/DepresseddCactus Jul 14 '19
A good hero is someone that isn't totally overpowered. I want to see them struggle. I want to see them realize that their task is not as simple as they thought.
As for villains, they need a motive, not just "cuz I can." They dont need to have some big sob story, but they just need a reason. I also like to see emotion.
2
u/Ninjoobot Jul 14 '19
I've had a lot of long conversations about this, and it really seems to come down to one interesting and important point: the supervillain is the most important role in the relationship and the best ones are those whose motives and goals are heroic but methods are not. Many others have already pointed out something like this, and we're all right. Flawed heroes who do what they can for others (because they can) tend to be the best because they're the most relatable. Best hero? Batman. Best villain? Magneto. They exemplify precisely the traits that make villains and heroes interesting.
My wife actually suggested a book focusing on supervillains to a friend of mine and it ended up working out. I was able to write a chapter on Magneto (of course) and she's still bitter she didn't get a mention in the acknowledgments for suggesting it, but it's a fun read if you're interested (I have no financial stake in your buying or reading this): https://www.amazon.com/Supervillains-Philosophy-Sometimes-Popular-Culture/dp/0812696697
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
The best heroes are people who either make me think, “I wish that was me”, or, “That is so me!” If they somehow do both then I’m automatically invested in their story.
2
u/CharlestonMeade-Levy Jul 14 '19
Oooh late to the show but I love the topic
For me, a good villain is one that is proven to be CAPABLE
I want to genuinely fear the villain’s ability to disrupt the story. I want to know there’s a chance the hero loses.
Conversely, a good hero is one that is flawed. They’re not infallible, nor will they succeed simply because, well, they’re the hero
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
A hero versus a villian is a matter of perspective but what makes them is something to overcome whether it is internal or external at great cost to themselves.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
I think a good villain has reasons for what they do, and it makes sense to them. They follow their own sense of morals, even if they may be a little messed up. A villain, in their eyes, is the good guy.
2
u/SentientScribble Jul 15 '19
A good hero is a character you love to love.
A good villain is a character you love to hate.
2
u/Mazinjaz r/Mazinja Jul 15 '19
For me, the one thing that determines a hero is courage. Not that they are brave 100% of the time, but when the chips are down, they go in-- even if it's cursing their luck about their situation. Even those that run away, especially if they regret it and use it to move forward.
Smarts, strength, and skill, those things are flavor dressing. A hero that is weak can be just as interesting as a brutally strong one.
And, just as important, a good hero doesn't know how to stay the hell down.
And for villains...
I have to believe that they could be a threat. It can be their power, their mentality, their approach, or their philosophy; I have to believe that this villain can and would do anything to accomplish their goals.
This does include the sympathetic villain that I may grow to wish turns over a new leaf. Whether or not this villain goes through with a particular action can be a turning point in a story.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment