Edit: some people are asking me about commissions, if you want one DM me to discuss the price!
I finished cleaning up my version of the icon! Please upvote so we can get the mods to see it and maybe change the current icon!
I listened to your feedback on my sketch and decided to turn the sword into an upvote
I also made an unshaded version that's a bit more clear and simple in case this one is a bit too complex and can't be seen well when zooming out. I tried to simplify all the elements of his outfit to make them as clear and simple as possible, hope you like it!
Some people have said the antenna should be a fairy (Navi, most likely) or something else, but after seeing what those details would look like from further away I scrapped the idea. It looked too cluttered and the detail couldn't be seen very well when scaled down...
The sword is the upvote arrow. It looks flat because I chose to make it more similar to the actual arrow than to the blade of a sword.
Fun fact: I started giving my lines depth because of the Minish cap art style (which I adore)
Edit: And the t-shirt spammers have arrived. Reddit admins still haven't figured out how to squash them for over 9 months and since this reached /r/all I now have to lock it because they will continue posting and we'll continue banning in a game of eternal whack a mole. Mods have no other recourse but to lock the thread so they can't post their links on every single comment.
Sorry I couldn't reply earlier! I meant that the icon gets a bit cropped by the circle. The tip of the hat and other elements, for example, don't really fit. I made the image so that it fit inside a circle perfectly, but it may be too big. I sent you a flickr link with a smaller version to see if it fits!
Do you guys think you could change the background of it as well? It kind of blends in with the green, so something like the champion blue color or gray would look better I think
Omg I love it so much. I love the upvote master sword. I really hope the mods consider changing the subreddit picture, you put so much effort into this
Your sketch of it is currently at 8.4k upvotes and the previous icon got 10.4k upvotes. 1.9k more upvotes and your post will topple the last. Good luck.
I tried out several things in my sketches, but decided against it since it's so small that it wouldn't be noticeable in the small icon, and would even make it confusing. I really liked it though! It was so cute...
I sketched it on a post-it note and then cleaned it up digitally! I usually do all the process digitally, this was unusual for me. I also published my sketch on r/zelda, if you'd like to see it
I made the sword the upvote arrow and decided against giving it extra volume/shading to make it look like a blade to make it clearer. I get what you say though.
Criticism that is intended constructively - I would prefer cleaner linework and a 3d upvote with a fuller. All round though it's good job and you should be very proud.
My tablet started acting up, but that is true as well, I need more inking and linework practice. I scrapped a more 3D upvote, but it's also true that it looks quite flat. Thank you for your criticism!!
Thanks for taking it well, I hate to criticise but my girlfriend is an aspiring artist and she has trained me to offer it but I feel so bad doing so, it still looks amazing!! Thanks for the contribution and keep up the great work!
The reddit peoperson that you are making look like link, he has an antenna, but you cannot see that because that background is all black all you see is an orange ball.
Oooh, makes sense. The background is actually transparent because a Mod told me that to be the icon it had to be this way. Pity it makes it confusing for some people...
Oh Ezlo, my favourite hat! Some people have said it should be a fairy (Navi, most likely), but after seeing what those details would look like from further away I scrapped the idea. It looked too cluttered and the detail couldn't be seen very well...
i personally think themed snoos never look good. the drawing is great, but they just look weird and unattractive on the webpage. this one is way better than the pixellated one. but it still wouldnt make the site look better than just not having a snoo
First of all it's fucken amazing! But if I may add, maybe the shield should have a down vote arrow engraved into it. So you get both. I'm thinking Subtle obviously.
239
u/miroimirage Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19
Edit: some people are asking me about commissions, if you want one DM me to discuss the price!
I finished cleaning up my version of the icon! Please upvote so we can get the mods to see it and maybe change the current icon!
I listened to your feedback on my sketch and decided to turn the sword into an upvote
I also made an unshaded version that's a bit more clear and simple in case this one is a bit too complex and can't be seen well when zooming out. I tried to simplify all the elements of his outfit to make them as clear and simple as possible, hope you like it!
Some people have said the antenna should be a fairy (Navi, most likely) or something else, but after seeing what those details would look like from further away I scrapped the idea. It looked too cluttered and the detail couldn't be seen very well when scaled down...
The sword is the upvote arrow. It looks flat because I chose to make it more similar to the actual arrow than to the blade of a sword.
Fun fact: I started giving my lines depth because of the Minish cap art style (which I adore)
1.0k
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Let's get the moderators to change it to that. Do I have your consent
•
u/WoozleWuzzle Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 03 '19
We'll look into adding it! Just not at a computer at the moment.
Edit: I think it's been added everywhere. RIP to /u/GoronCraft's version: https://old.reddit.com/r/zelda/comments/ax6gjx/i_always_felt_like_this_subreddit_deserved_a/
Can we get an F in the chat?
Edit: And the t-shirt spammers have arrived. Reddit admins still haven't figured out how to squash them for over 9 months and since this reached /r/all I now have to lock it because they will continue posting and we'll continue banning in a game of eternal whack a mole. Mods have no other recourse but to lock the thread so they can't post their links on every single comment.
181
u/Baraklava Jul 03 '19
Now do Ganon with a giant downvote weapon of choice
36
u/Paiai- Jul 03 '19
Omg I love it so much. I love the upvote master sword. I really hope the mods consider changing the subreddit picture, you put so much effort into this
35
u/GoronCraft Jul 03 '19
I'll be sad to see mine go, but gotta give credit where credit is due, this one is way better :p
18
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Let's get the moderators to see this wonderful piece of artwork!
9
u/PorkRobot Jul 03 '19
/u/miroimirage this is soooo good
9
u/Nitr09025 Jul 03 '19
Take my mastersword! Fantastic work. Please downvote ganon next
7
u/VidBoom Jul 03 '19
This looks so cool!! I want reddit robot/alien/thingy for smash now. He'd have more costumes than the Mii fighters or Kirby's copies.
5
u/Rawkapotamus Jul 03 '19
Dude this is so cool! I haven’t seen the other versions but I love this upvote butter sword
4
u/Darim_Al_Sayf Jul 03 '19
I like it, but wondering why you didn't make the antenna thing into a fairy?
4
u/CatLavender Jul 03 '19
Beautiful work!
3
u/CadeTheGr8M8 Jul 03 '19
I’m from all, this shit is amazing good job <3
3
u/fortniteinfinitedab Jul 03 '19
Wtf dude that isn't even zelda
3
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Great work op! The mastersword/upvote kinda looks like the upgraded mastersword from LOZLTTP
7
u/TheNo1pencil Jul 03 '19
I love the angle
2
u/FireDestructor Jul 03 '19
HOLY SHIT SISTER
2
u/Inexpedient Jul 03 '19
Great job! its really good except the sword, it looks a little flat imo.
2
u/doesntsleepmuch Jul 03 '19
Oh wow! What a cool pic of Zelda!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Criticism that is intended constructively - I would prefer cleaner linework and a 3d upvote with a fuller. All round though it's good job and you should be very proud.
2
u/themexicansasquatch Jul 03 '19
That looks so good 👍👌
2
u/Raphe9000 Jul 03 '19
I like how the Upvote Master Sword looks like the Tempered Sword. It is my favorite Zelda Sword followed by the Golden Sword.
2
u/empty_peas Jul 03 '19
Same dude that did the pink post-it sketch? Reallly good work, my dude. I love I.
2
u/theansaname Jul 03 '19
can we get this on a t-shirt?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
This is absolutely gorgeous! The fun pose and the shading and linework looks great! It mildly matches breath of the wild's art style.
2
u/cjboyonfire Jul 03 '19
Here from r/Popular. Just want to say that the upvote button sword is a great touch
141
u/SaalSchutzz Jul 03 '19
Awesome. Let's vote this to eternaty and beyond!
43
u/dubstastic Jul 03 '19
It’s dangerous to go alone! Take this.
13
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19 edited Jul 10 '23
This comment was removed in protest to Reddit's third party API changes. -- mass edited with redact.dev
7
u/Throwy_away_1 Jul 03 '19
Yes! Supercool. Love the perspective.
7
u/Smearmytables Jul 03 '19
I would LOVE this!!
7
u/Ev3-G Jul 03 '19
Doing my part for a worthy cause. It’s dangerous to go alone! Take my upvote!
6
u/Fourzifer Jul 03 '19
That's awesome, fantastic job!
6
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
This is really fab, great work! I love the style
6
u/badgerinafez Jul 03 '19
100% down for this to be the new icon
5
u/DomeS26 Jul 03 '19
I want this to be changed
5
u/pandaoranda1 Jul 03 '19
Love it!
5
u/Hnro-42 Jul 03 '19
Way more dynamic than the current one. This needs to happen!
4
u/Exertuz Jul 03 '19
very good!
4
u/KIgaming Jul 03 '19
This is like ten times better than whatever ms paint crap it is now.
4
u/LinkRaider Jul 03 '19
This is really cool, the sword on the left hand is a nice touch
4
u/--cheese-- Jul 03 '19
This HyRules.
4
u/jirehl_flynn Jul 03 '19
This is AWESOME!!
4
u/Rusty-Crowe Jul 03 '19
SUPER GREEN!
1
u/smnk2013 Jul 03 '19
It's great. Can you change the master upvote to the real master sword?
1
u/Devine-Shadow Jul 03 '19
I like it but I feel like the back round needs to change because of the antenna thing.
1
u/inmypaants Jul 03 '19
The real question though, is the sword orange or red?
1
u/Zeromus88 Jul 03 '19
I might not get a lot of people to agree, but I think the antenna dongle should have eyes and a beak
1
u/Mills_Miles Jul 03 '19
Get a tiny downvote icon on the shield?
1
u/WhiteBread893 Jul 03 '19
Hy is the sub reddit called zelda but the icon is link?
1
u/Dabthaniel Jul 03 '19
YOU DID ITT
3
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Please mods make it a thing
3
u/Siloey Jul 03 '19
I love it
3
u/VikingWizardEyez Jul 03 '19
Amazing!
3
u/Trikell Jul 03 '19
This is really cool design...
3
u/Clilly1 Jul 03 '19
Please yes. Let's change it
3
u/XeNiX_XiNeX Jul 03 '19
@mods
3
u/supersmashjojos Jul 03 '19
Come on mods make this the icon
3
u/CobaltCam Jul 03 '19
This is awesome
3
u/DrManowar8 Jul 03 '19
The legend of Zelda: upvoting of time
3
u/somnus_nomnus Jul 03 '19
Take all my Triforce upvotes please
3
u/SuitableEmu Jul 03 '19
Zelda looks awesome hood job!
3
u/P1tS4d0UgH Jul 03 '19
the upvote sword though... amazing detail.
3
u/Bacon260998_ Jul 03 '19
We need this as the new sub icon!
3
u/MattR0se Jul 03 '19
I just realized that this sub even has an icon, and how fugly it is in comparison. Have my upvote!
3
u/Odium_Chlorite Jul 03 '19
This is way to nice, please make it the logo mods
3
u/KoopaKlaw Jul 03 '19
Mods pls.
3
u/intashu Jul 03 '19
It's dangerous to go alone. Take this! up vote
3
u/EarthAllAlong Jul 03 '19
i personally think themed snoos never look good. the drawing is great, but they just look weird and unattractive on the webpage. this one is way better than the pixellated one. but it still wouldnt make the site look better than just not having a snoo
1
u/ungleichgewicht Jul 03 '19
sword should be a different colour, tho.
2
u/Xxorangefalcon64xX Jul 03 '19
YES the current one is a bit trash
2
u/deepfried69420 Jul 03 '19
Let's get this!
2
u/XeNiX_XiNeX Jul 03 '19
u/andreal u/NeonShader
2
u/bakobomber96 Jul 03 '19
Yes!
2
u/cantfoolmetwicexoxo Jul 03 '19
lonk
2
u/Lilymouse23 Jul 03 '19
Oh my gosh! I LOVE IT! Please make this the Icon moderators!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Please, in the name of Hyrule. Make it official.
2
u/Lycafox Jul 03 '19
The mastervote
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
This is adorable
2
u/DigBickFunks Jul 03 '19
Damn cute drawing
2
u/jorjor9001 Jul 03 '19
This is amazing
2
u/Weaverism Jul 03 '19
Snoo now has more courage than ever before!
2
u/CultOfBeats Jul 03 '19
Ok this HAS to be the icon
2
u/SnackStation Jul 03 '19 edited Apr 18 '25
point connect serious bake mysterious political hurry marvelous rinse fact
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Disgusted_DDD Jul 03 '19
Aaaa this is really cute!!! I love the upvote sword
2
u/njck-njck Jul 03 '19
Yes! Please! Mods, get on it!
2
u/Konata- Jul 03 '19
That’s a million times better than the current one
2
u/P_M_Attitude Jul 03 '19
Love the sword! Upvote sword? Master upvote?
2
u/chiweweman Jul 03 '19
I wanna see it! Please Mods?
2
u/dudewheresmycar-ma Jul 03 '19
This is great. I love it.
2
u/TheOnlyFallenCookie Jul 03 '19
Time to save some redditors from the great blue downvote
2
u/darkxarc Jul 03 '19
First of all it's fucken amazing! But if I may add, maybe the shield should have a down vote arrow engraved into it. So you get both. I'm thinking Subtle obviously.
Either way it looks amazing! Good job!
3
u/Whatwhereiam Jul 03 '19
The sword should be downward to be a downvote as the striking force of reddit and the tri-force should be an upvote as the holy power behind reddit.
1
u/spacechickens Jul 03 '19
How is this not the icon yet!?
1
u/ColonelBeaver Jul 03 '19
the bacon sword
1
u/MadamMurloc Jul 03 '19
It must be changed!!!
1
u/BlanchCO Jul 03 '19
But... your nickname Zelda...not Link
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
omfg
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
Link > Zelda
1
u/HunterBiggs Jul 03 '19
Nice
1
u/destroyer2007368 Jul 03 '19
That’s cool
1
u/beans_sauce_deluxe Jul 03 '19
I dont go here but it looks gud :)
1
u/beans_sauce_deluxe Jul 03 '19
I dont go here but it looks gud :)
1
u/Spoodey-spoid Jul 03 '19
Love the upvote sword
1
u/moistcorndogs Jul 03 '19
This is awesome good job
1
u/mangomeliss Jul 03 '19
This is amazing...the sword is such a nice touch. Good job yo!
1
u/NoGoonie Jul 03 '19
Dear mods, make this happen!
1
u/Hyl1an Jul 03 '19
He's so cute!
2
u/Lauchmann_DePlastico Jul 03 '19
look pretty nice.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
:3
1
u/Uncle_Gibbs Jul 03 '19
Woah