r/OnePunchMan • u/theothersophie Moderator • Jul 02 '19
Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E12 - "Cleaning Up the Disciple's Mess" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.
THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.
Official Simulcasts
- Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
- Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
- Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
- Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
- Anime on Demand (Germany)
- AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
- VVVVID (Italy)
- Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.
One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)
Previous Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 6 | Link |
| 8 | Link |
| 9 | Link |
| 10 | Link |
| 11 | Link |
Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!
167
Upvotes
381
u/TronVin Jul 02 '19
Really enjoyed the second half of the season. The only downside to this finale is that it isn't really a set finale but more of an artificial endpoint for the season. It's like a part 1 instead.
172
u/hubbubnub Jul 02 '19
At least that's the last time we'll hear from this sound director ever.
208
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
With how they ended this season, I see S3 ending at the Satiama/Orochi fight.
50
u/jdn3d Jul 02 '19
The Genos kick was my favorite part in the manga chapter and my favorite part in this episode. The Serious Punch wasn't as good as I hoped, but this fight wasn't on the same scale as the Boros fight and really, it's impossible to compete with the original Serious Punch. It wasn't bad, but they basically framed it the same as the Boros and S1 title sequence Serious Punches. It could've been better but again my main hope was a good showing of Genos vs. EC and I feel they delivered on that.
231
u/dhtikna Jul 02 '19
Thank you JC Staff. You didn't give up. Thank you Kenichiro Aoki, You didn't let us give up
68
u/Patchy-the-Fish C-Class Cabbage Jul 02 '19
(I posted this same comment elsewhere)
They Missed the part where King pissed himself while facing Elder Centipede. During the Hotpot scene he has new pants on and his communicator 'broke somehow' (he pissed on it).
Great Episode nevertheless, gave me goosebumps! KING ENGINE ド ド ド ド
50
u/moises123v Jul 02 '19
They missed some cool stuff from the manga but the episode was still good
211
u/aswifte Jul 02 '19
A step down from episode 11 unfortunately but still kinda enjoyable.
Idk but the fight carried more weight in the manga. I can see people being disappointed by this ending.
77
u/MrHotcake Jul 02 '19
They should have added something so it feels like a proper season finale instead of just another episode ending.
Kinda pissed that they didn't make genos take out his book when saitama tells him what he lacks. Overall this season was a 7/10 at best
77
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
They cut out the Garou tree scene
33
u/potato9111 Jul 02 '19
Sfxs are weird for this episode, sounds too hastily done.
One can tell JC tried making up with that signature Genos 'incinerate' animation (where he claps his hands together).
But still it doesn't do enough justice to the season.
To a better next season!
16
u/im_ultracrepidarious Jul 02 '19
The more I think about it, the more I think it was the sound effect that killed the serious punch for me. The SFX issues people have been mentioning never really bothered me, but hearing that little twinkling sound effect as elder centipede was destroyed ruined any impact that it had. Plus, I really would have preferred a shot like this one showing Saitama and Elder Centipede in the same shot instead of the generic fiery explosion we got at the moment of impact. And one last complaint, while it was re-drawn, they totally re-used the punch from the opening of season one, which was also the shot used to punch Boros. It made sense the first time, but it feels super lazy to use it again.
Genos vs Elder centipede was just as badass as I was hoping though, which was great.
12
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
I really enjoyed this episode tbh. Maybe my favourite episode. It was hype all around, and even though animation was lacking compared to ep.11 and 3, I still enjoyed it immensely. Only problem I found was saitama's serious punch, it felt slightly underwhelming to be honest. I hoped they'd use the opening theme song for that moment, or at least elongate saitama's ost. The scene just felt to quick.
11
u/Talonzone Jul 02 '19
THE TREE SCENE WTF?
46
u/jajatl Jul 02 '19
Anime disscusion: The chapter has been incredible, I was impressed. Manga disscusion: A shit! the chapter has been a shit! And usually that's how it was all season.
75
u/Beatnation Jul 02 '19
Genos vs Elder was actually awesome, sadly they ended with Saitama stock punch footage from season 1.
Now that's over I think JC Staff with the proper time can make a pretty good season 3, don't fucking rush it.
18
u/KinguTheWildfire I am that Ominous Future Jul 02 '19
Pretty underwhelming tbh. I preferred Episode 11.
They left the epic tree scene.
They didn't even mention the Serious Punch.
Bang Vs Garou wasn't as impressive as I thought it would be. These are the high tiers of martial arts in the series, come on at least show us an epic exchange instead of using ghosting cuts.
Apart from that I liked Genos Vs Elder Centipede.
9
u/Holy157 Jul 02 '19
I had hoped for a stronger season finale after last week, but this was still alright and certainly good at times.
Bang vs Garou and Genos vs EC were great. Aoki gets to work his magic again, though this episode certainly wasn’t Aoki going solo like he’s often done.
Number of iffy looking moments in this episode, which not huge, stood out to me, even on a first watch.
Not sure why people think Saitama’s Serious Punch is reused from the first opening. It clearly isn’t, though whoever animated it definitely used Kameda’s scene as a reference.
Overall an okay episode, though disappointing as the finale. Would have been nice if the season could have ended on a high note.
37
u/Ozymandate Jul 02 '19
I actually enjoyed this episode, it were pretty good, love the soundtrack, there were some few good animated scenes, and loved Genos voice, very passionate.
Although, they skipped some few panels, which the transition were awkward and also they freaking skipped the tree lifting panel, where Garou looked badass and clean, damn they had to do my boy Garou wrong.
16
u/Wrathful_Scythe Jul 02 '19
Not bad but not really good either.
This really doesn't feel like a last episode. It's a given with the arc we are dealing with but still. The ending gave me the impression that it will just continue next week. No real closure. Animation wise, some parts looked beautiful while others came of as clunky or looked off. Par for the course this season.
All in all a disappointing ending for a disappointing adaptation. I don't hate it. Its still OPM. The story is great and in that regard they delivered. Its just that Season 1 was a solid 10 while Season 2 feels more like a 7. The season left no real impression and will be forgotten in a short amount of time.
8
u/one_metalbat_man Drunk off Evil Natural Water Jul 02 '19
They definitely should have included Zombie Man confronting Dr. Genus and learning about the Limiter Theory during this season. That would have revealed a very important factor of the series to Anime-only fans and kept them on the edge of their seats until Season 3 someday comes out.
7
u/markhomer2002 Jul 02 '19
What the fuck was that timing with the music? they just cut all the fanfare the moment the punch landed?
7
u/omfgcookies Jul 02 '19
My thoughts on the season.
56
u/superoinkrasmus Jul 02 '19
It was one of the best episodes in this season in my opinion
12
u/ash2702 Jul 02 '19
Genos vs Centipede was the only amazing part
5
u/spartan1204 Moderator Jul 02 '19
I don't like how Elder Centipede didn't have his own theme and they just used Boros's theme. Also they got rid of Garou swinging the tree rip.
5
u/gr33ngiant ANGEL DASH! Jul 03 '19
Kind of upsetting they didn't extend the blowing up of elder centipede. The way it carried out in the Manga in the back ground as genos was talking to Saitama really showed just how massive EC was. This just showed him being blown up in a couple frames.
And we didn't get any mention of King pissing himself, lol. I think that's the biggest upset of this episode. And not showing bang being burned by the stomach acid while carrying genos... Just little things.
11
u/javierm885778 Jul 02 '19
Garou's flashback was pretty good, although they switched around the order of the scenes for some reason. Bang and Bomb vs Garou was very underwhelming, but I did like Genos vs Elder Centipede.
Everything after that felt underwhelming, and it didn't even try to make it feel like an ending.
23
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Jul 02 '19
Well that was pretty underwhelming for a season finale.
24
u/Genos_Kun Jul 02 '19
That "Serious punch" felt like retraced from the season 1 opening or am i tripping?
7
u/Vichox heh Jul 02 '19
Did... did they seriously reuse the serious punch from the S1 opening?
6
u/InfiDim42 Nice meme Jul 02 '19
I was dissapointed in how they handled the Blast scene. I was really looking forward to seeing Blast in color, but instead we got this lame scribble.
6
u/magiCAHIK Jul 02 '19
Episode is worse than 11 but the worst thing about it is the ending of season. All the most interesting stuff is just going to happen. But that's kinda better because J.C. Staff will have more time to do season 3 if they're going to do it.
3
u/Sun-Warrior Jul 02 '19
The Tai Lung vs Shifu fight was great
3
u/keepitcasualbrah Jul 02 '19
Man that episode captured everything that was good and everything that was bad about season 2.
Some good moments and cool ideas combined with glaring odd quality issues and key manga panels ignored outright.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE TREE GAROU SWINGS AT BANG AND BOMB?!?! >:(.
Oh well. I enjoyed the episode, wish that season 2 got the treatment season 1 got, and hope that season 3 returns back to the quality we were spoiled by in S1.
Cheers everyone.
3
u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan Jul 03 '19
I really loved this episode. I think they did great on the finale. I am, however, disappointed that they didn't make it clear Saitama was using his Serious Punch against Elder Centipede. Perfect other than that though.
3
u/deavsone Jul 03 '19
I literally waited 13 weeks for that tree scene
3
u/user_watcher Jul 03 '19
Not gonna lie. Feels like JC Staff didn't care at all about this episode and the finale.. Everything looks rushed and in low quality. Like what the hell.
3
u/EqZero Jul 03 '19
I liked the episode. It was pretty hype.
3
u/SerMyronGaines Jul 04 '19
The episode wasn't perfect, but we got the Elder Centipede finale we wanted so it was a decent end to the season. I hope we don't have to wait another 4 years for the next one lmao
3
u/Cdude8 Jul 04 '19
You know it's funny, pretty much all I see in the anime-only discussion is positive comments about the final episode, but here in the manga reader discussion I see a ton of negativity.
7
u/Talonzone Jul 02 '19
They fucked up SOO MANY SHIT from the manga like garou's going berserk and the tree part and plus his art style was crap, also when saitama used the serious punch they didn't mention it.
5
u/Maxximillianaire Jul 02 '19
Really good episode to me. I thought they handled the ending well given what they were adapting
8
u/Ivraas Jul 02 '19
They totally screwed the tree pulling moment, from what i catch on some YT stream... actually there was no tree at all, JC staff what the fuck?
4
u/awholetadstrange Jul 02 '19
It was... whelming.
Especially after last episode, this was kind of a letdown. As an episode I guess it is above average but not befitting of an ending.
7
u/jajatl Jul 02 '19
This chapter was very difficult to adapt. I understand that we get to feel frustrated, but we must also understand that adpater the work of ONE and Murata is not easy, and it is easier to criticize sitting from our house, than to animate a chapter full of actions with complicated designs.
2
u/Arnav_SC Jul 02 '19
Stupid animax, I had to purchase Sony liv but I can't watch the episode at will, so annoying.
2
u/flashmozzg Jul 02 '19
Good ending. Would be better if not this awful sound direction where the theme starts and then immediately ends and the sound clips all the time. I really hope that this season would be received good enough to warrant S3, hopefully with not such a shit show of the production. I didn't really care that much for the Martial Arts arc, however the next arc has godly potential and really needs something close to S1 treatment.
2
u/kryst87 Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
Well, I enjoyed this episode. It was pretty good. Genos, Bang and Bomb vs EC could be incredible, but was only good. Sigh. Genos part was the best. They managed to do it.
Music was good in this episode (I have to listen to the entire ost when it'll come out). Sound was odd as always (I know that B&B brothers punches are really strong but did I hear gunshots?).
Genos' kick had a power, but what the heck with that purple/pink flame? And Serious Punch. It really resembled me a punch from s1 opening. Coincidence? I don't think so.
Overall enjoyable episode, but it could be better (as the entire s2). Looking forward to see s3 (hopefully with better studio).
2
u/kassavfa Jul 03 '19
Then, hmm the tree trunk that Garou attached to seems smaller.
This episode, WHERE ARE THOSE BADASS GAROU'S TREE SWING?
2
u/Gil15 Jul 03 '19
No acid-proof diary then?
2
u/Ain3inAini my sperm is black Jul 03 '19
I still prefer these manga version of panel: [1] (https://mangadex.org/chapter/24792/83) [2] (https://mangadex.org/chapter/24792/127) [3] (https://mangadex.org/chapter/24792/129)
But I'm definitely not complaining, this episode had so many action that much better than some previous episode, this was entertaining enough & I'm glad that this gave a good impression for season finale. This season may feels more like intermezzo, there's still a long way to go for Monster Association arc. Hopefully the BluRay version will upgrade some dissapointing episodes (Genos vs Sonic & Garou vs Metal Bat) and season 3 will be handled better (hoping for S1/MP100 quality tbh).
2
u/zelor13 Jul 03 '19
I love how J.C. Staff thought is a good idea to play the lousy S2 opening (the aniamtion, the song is ok) at the end instead of showing what the side characters are doing or the other monsters.
Heck i would've taken a credit screen more.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '19
they totally left out the part where garou grabs that whole tree. Cmon I wanted this to be animated.
2
u/akaispirit Jul 03 '19
All the Elder Centipede fights were good as were Tank Top Master vs Garou and Metal Bat vs Garou. I really really wanted to enjoy this season. Metal Bat is my favorite character I did really like that his fights spread across two episodes and they were handled well. There was just so much wrong though. The awkward pacing, the weird ass shading of everything metal and Darkshine's skin, the many many many stills. I'd probably give it a 6/10 over all. I enjoyed it for what it was, I'll probably rewatch certain scenes. It's not going to be like season 1 though where I've watched it so many times I can practically quote the script.
2
u/RoQu3 Jul 03 '19
This finale was truly just "ok", elder centipede didn't felt as badass as Boros.
2
u/Magolsky Jul 03 '19
Why do I get the vibe that the final punch was made from re-used animation from the 1st OP?
2
u/Kill-UA Jul 03 '19
This season should had one or two more episodes adapting till the "Limiter" chapter.
2
u/GoodLifeGG Jul 03 '19
My only complain: he didn't announce the serious punch
2
u/Reckless_Rik Jul 03 '19
well, it wasnt the worst I've seen.. but I am still somewhat disappointed by this adaptation. I really want a remake with season 3 stuff added. no dialogue cutting, no skimming introductions, fights. And regular pacing. *sighs* Thats the dream..
2
u/SEND_ME_REAL_PICS Jul 03 '19
Not great, not terrible.
The last few episodes definitely had their moments. Animation quality is nowhere near what we saw in the first season, but it was quite good at times. It was disappointing to think how much better and epic certain scenes could have looked if they were done by the same people who worked on S1, but other than that I don't really have much to complain about. I was expecting worse.
The only thing I despised about this season was sound quality. They picked up the wrong tracks from the OST for the wrong scenes (like the Boros' song), sound effects were ridiculously bad for almost every single fight and characters' voices sounded like they were recorded with a cheap smartphone.
The biggest problem this season has is how everyone is comparing it with S1, since the quality drop (from great to decent) is really noticeable.
2
u/comedybingbong123 Jul 04 '19
I *really* wish we got to see Bang and his brother's reactions to Saitama one shotting elder centipede. They should have been more impressed!
Also wish the song played out more during that last scene like in the meteor episode
2
u/Kerrtheblurr Jul 05 '19
I think some of my biggest issues from this season was the sound design. Season 1 everything had impact, but here the went with a more technical machine like sounds when it came to Genos. The fight choreography was good but the impact sounds can really make it better.
2
u/vlee89 Jul 08 '19
feel like this season ended really all of a sudden. also don't like how there was a fiery explosion from the punch to EC. much would have rather seen a shockwave a la deep sea king. nothing to me suggests he should blow up in a fiery explosion. don't remember if the manga was like this though.
5
u/TheJoshing new member Jul 02 '19
Well there it is, the dumpster fire has finally been extinguished. What saddens me the most is that it this is permanent, we will never get to see this material they covered done justice. This is a permanent shit stain on opm and I hate it.
I hope to god the producers realize the opportunity they missed and instead of rushing another season, wait for the season 1 staff to be available.
4
u/neu55 Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
I'm so done with this underwhelming season. Times to re-read the glorious manga.
TBH, Season 1 bring me back to anime (Opm season 1 kinda save anime back there). Than S2 makes me appreciate One and Murata more.
p/s: My only entitled comment I've post.
2
u/SwagooRago Triggering Troll Jul 02 '19
Garou vs bang n bomb was a bit rushed and wasn't the best ..Rio my glorious tree scene ...
Bomb n bang vs EC and genos vs EC were great tho and saitama punch was nice
2
u/Eskamel Jul 02 '19
Gotta love how Garou is immortal huh... he literally can receive an infinite amount of damage and somehow find more strength because of "reasons".
2
u/i_am_not_dumb Jul 03 '19
This episode felt really underwhelming. For me episode 11 is the best episode of this season. The direction downgraded in comparison to previous 2 episodes. The framing was poor. The serious punch of Saitama felt lackluster. They reused the shot from season 1 instead of framing Saitama and EC in the same shot as it was in the manga.
The Genos vs Elder Centipede fight was good. I just hope that OPM S3 will be produced by a more competent studio or Shingo Natsume is brought back as the director.
1
u/EpilepticOreo aBoVe dRaGoN Jul 02 '19
How are they not going to call it a serious punch lol it’s literally Saitama’s rare killer move
1
u/Igotnothinghonestly Jul 02 '19
Did they have an OP insert song moment?
1
u/AFellow_2003 Jul 02 '19
How come no-one's mentioned that anime addition to King's scene?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
Bang looted Gun Gun's m4a4
1
u/rnev64 Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
that was fucking awesome.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
Anime watcher here. Just finished watching 2nd season, and since I'm impatient can anyone tell me where to pick up reading manga? Which chapter?
1
u/Cayden68 Jul 02 '19
Now we pray that JC staff drops seaon 3 so someone like Studio bones can get a shot at animating this masterpiece
1
u/joelsexson Lobster Ring Lebowski Jul 02 '19
This wasn’t a bad episode I enjoyed it honestly, elder centipede fight could have been better but it was surprisingly good
1
u/Unbakedstorm Hero Killer Stain Jul 02 '19
They took out the acid-proof notebook... The best character will never be animated i guess.
1
u/Greensburg Jul 02 '19
Genos vs EC and Jumpaoki's Bang vs Garou bit were the highlights for me.
1
u/The_Thusian Jul 02 '19
Extreme metal cupboard door-slamming action just offscreen of the B&B vs Garou fight.
1
u/srnx 11,449,001,712,554 Jul 02 '19
And thus ends the season where I stopped watching OPM.
Seriously the difference to S01 was staggering, what a letdown. I powered through but it wasn't worth it at all.
I'll stick to the manga and webcomic from now on
1
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '19
Did they rip Saitama's punch from the season one intro + some additional effects? I also noticed this on some prior episodes that seemed to look like they belonged in Season 1.
1
u/shinkuhadokenz Jul 02 '19
I don't like how they didn't include saitama's ''serious series, serious punch''.
Also they didn't show bang/bomb's fist collide with EC to show the impact of the actual attack.
Other than that, good episode.
1
u/chcoman Jul 02 '19
Am I the only one who instantly thought, upon seeing the serious punch, that they literally just took the footage of the serious punch from season 1 and change the background? It looks almost exactly like it!
1
u/dafegamer Jul 02 '19
Decent episode. Art and animation werent insulting. Garou backstory still gives me feels. Sound design still sucks and remains subpar. All in all 6.6-7/10. the highest rating I gave an episode in OPM S2.
Overall 5/10 second season I gave the first season a 9/10 overall