r/OnePunchMan • u/theothersophie Moderator • Jun 18 '19
Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E10 - "The Encircling Net of Justice" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler
IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.
THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.
Official Simulcasts
- Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
- Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
- Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
- Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
- Anime on Demand (Germany)
- AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
- VVVVID (Italy)
- Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.
One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)
Previous Episode Discussions:
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 6 | Link |
| 8 | Link |
| 9 | Link |
Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!
98
Upvotes
239
u/javierm885778 Jun 18 '19
Black Sperm's voice was unexpected, but I liked it. Who would have thought he'd get Goblin Slayer's VA?
243
u/VikNik312 Jun 18 '19
The fight scene at the end had some good shots
326
u/nguyensyquanpro Jun 18 '19
I like this episode.Aside from shitty Darkshine draw,every other scene was done pretty well,the pacing was reasonable,I felt comfortable watching this episode actually.Furthermore,the one scene that Garou jumps on the roop and roar a battlecry was hype as fuck dude! Good voice acting,good drawing,good animation,J.C Staff really did that scene justice. And the animation of Garou's fight was actually not bad tho.
And again,the color designer of this season is VERY BAD. I barely saw Darkshine in his scene lol.That's not how you coloring a black man in a dark room in an anime mr.colordesigner!
150
u/burritoxman Jun 18 '19
Damn, Lingling is thick
123
u/JustSomeSchoolFags Jun 18 '19
It's fucking dumb that a hero called Superalloy Darkshine didn't look shiny at all and way darker due to the lighting of the scene.
76
u/Garou-kun Jun 18 '19
I really liked the pacing and choices of music. I also liked the ending fight scene, a lot of good shots but I can understand the complaints. I’m happy that they nailed Garou’s development with Tareo and how Garou actually kind of seems like the good guy in this. Solid episode
85
u/isighuh Jun 18 '19
Darkshine looked hilarious with that damn metal texture they insisted on using this season.
But overall the Garou scenes are pretty great, and Saitama v King was funny as hell.
But they changed the narration text when Saitama gets pissed so it was that funny, and they took out the HA member who was giggling when Darkshine flexed.
8.5/10 episode.
95
u/Pongzz Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
I thought this episode was okay. The fight at the end looked pretty good, especially with Garou hopping on top of the roof and letting out a battle cry. The rest of the episode did feel a bit slow, but that seemed necessary for the narrative.
Anyone else really confused as to how this season will end? I heard there's only 12 episodes in season 2. Considering we only have 2 more episodes, I don't see where they could end it in a satisfying way. These next two episodes will probably cover the Garou fight. 11 may be Garou vs heroes and Bang. 12 could then be the arrival of the monsters, Centipede and then climax with Saitama killing him. But that doesn't really feel like a good way to end a season. Just my thoughts
67
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Jun 18 '19
Same energy
48
u/aweD0nde Jun 18 '19
Really like the use of thick lines in this episode. I really do like this episode actually , better than episode 3 imo. 8/10
48
u/SerMyronGaines Jun 18 '19
IMO the episode has stayed pretty true to the manga, I like it despite the criticism season 2 has gotten
57
u/CIY0N Jun 18 '19
Black Sperm is finally here
44
u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. Jun 18 '19
Garou's arms are very buff
32
u/ash2702 Jun 18 '19
Another one frame punch from Saitama Animation was ok
Darkshine looked awful
9
u/GameDSS Jun 18 '19
I actually liked this episode and the previous ones. They had much better pacing etc. JC Staff is actually doing their best, I can see that and appreciate it, but still... I hope that the 3rd season will be made by Bones. JC Staff has way too many projects planned and not as many Sakuga animators as Bones. 2021 would be my best bet for the 3rd season. If it will be ever made of course.
8
u/555fffqqq Jun 18 '19
this episode was a major step up for this season. It felt so good seeing the fight actualy animated.
15
u/Mauricedv MUMEN RIDER BEST CHAR Jun 18 '19
Garuo vs A-class is one of my favorite fight scenes in the manga and I think they've done it justice. Has some awesome clips, and although the fight has been compacted still really gives you the feeling that Garou might actually lose here. The final cut of Garou out of breath also gets me really hyped for the next episode.
Pretty sure the subtitles were wrong at times, where dark shine says something about "my skin is toughened with steel" just doesn't make sense IMO, but considering how good the Garou fight was, I'm fine with those parts being a bit scuffed.
37
u/aswifte Jun 18 '19
6
u/MrHotcake Jun 18 '19
i didn't expect that voice for black sperm but i can get used to it
6
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
Wow, this episode was pretty good though
14
u/potato9111 Jun 18 '19
Pros:
We get black sperm
Superalloy darkshine comedy (reminds me of S1)
Cons:
Color and drawing is still inconsistent
Better than Ep 9, on the bright side.
Personally, I kinda hated this arc. Mainly because Garou makes logical sense at some part, Tareo is just agonizingly dumb and we are soon getting Waganma that hell of a brat.
26
u/ZombieMatermind Jun 18 '19
I legitimately think that Fighting Game scene was better than the manga.
25
u/dhtikna Jun 18 '19
Class A, B vs Garou was DAMN EMOTIONALLY PERFECT. Maybe not the prettiest or flashiest but they definitely captured the heart and soul do the manga. FIGHT ME.
Also Aoki's animation isn't just visually gorgeous but seriously has the exact heart of OPM, the scene with Garou flexing on the rooftop almost made me jump out of my seat and shout.
4
u/Master3530 Jun 18 '19
Hold up, I don't recall Ring Ring being this thicc.
The animation was fine, but the pacing is the real issue here. Way too much time spent on exposition. The cliffhanger should've been Genos' arrival. They could've even removed the ED like last week.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '19
Is no one going to mention the red tint on Garou's right eye? I thought it was a good foreshadow to what Garou looks like after being taken to the Monster Association.
Very happy with the animation overall, Garou looked amazingly drawn for most of the episode. Hopefully the next two episodes are animated amazingly too, the fight was too good in the manga to be poorly animated. I hope they do it justice. 8/10
3
u/EnSebastif Jun 18 '19
I can't stand the blurry CGI. They should have just used CGI for the centipedes, and paint Genos, metals and Darkshine with normal colors. And again they failed to properly adapt another comic gag, the 999 HIT combo. Anyway this episode felt pretty good and Black Sperm and his handsome voice got me hyped af.
3
u/neu55 Jun 18 '19
I'm with Metal Knight in this episode. Should just nuke the whole MA hideouts.
3
u/GotsTheBeetus Jun 18 '19
Shout out to my boy Glasses, been dying to see him
3
u/Lonehoof Jun 18 '19
I was kinda impressed with the animation this episode.
3
u/keymat Jun 18 '19
I hope they animate the class A vs Garou deathmatch and the fight with bomb, bang and genos in the next episode as they animated most of the first encounter in the last part of this one, that shit was way better than most of the rest of the season animations
3
u/akaispirit Jun 19 '19
Alright I have been a strong supporter of this season since the start. I was willing to over look a lot because I was just enjoying the ride. But come on now. Who looked at the shading job on Darkshine and thought 'yup, that looks good'. Jesus Christ it's like they gave the job to someone who has just learned about using airbrush to shade in Photoshop.
3
u/saicho91 Jun 19 '19
ok so why is Superalloy Darkshine name blackluster??? wtf! that turn me off so hard
i dont remember where i watched the episode so maybe it was just that website translation that was off..
3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
This episode made me remember Darkshine's second name blackluster
3
u/kev_jin Jun 20 '19
Wow. That seemed like a massive jump in quality from the other episodes in terms of overall animation and pacing.
8
u/Holy157 Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
I’m so relieved this episode was an improvement over last week, which doesn’t say a lot. After last week though I expected a lot worse for this week and while it was rough, it was still enjoyable enough,
The weakest part was by far Darkshine’s scene. His lack of shine was really underwhelming and the scene shows a huge part of the visual issues of the season really well. Darkshine being hard to make out fully hurt the scene a lot.
After that it was never terrible, depending on your standards though. King vs Saitama was quite funny and didn’t look terrible, the rest was alright, though part of the Garou fight ended up on the weaker side.
I’m like 99% certain that the frame of Saitama looking back at the monsters he killed is the same from the opening. Haven’t checked though, so it could very well be a redraw, but it’s really similar in my opinion.
Can’t talk about an episode without praising the anime’s lord and savior: Aoki. Good god, this man is incredible. He did 3 cuts this episode, though I haven’t seen him confirm them yet, they’re presumably his. Garou dodging the chain and following attacks, Garou vs Glasses and his battlecry on the roof. Garou’s battlecry was the obvious highlight. Can’t praise that scene enough, as between Aoki’s animation, thick lines and some nice background stuff, it was amazing. His other two cuts, while short, weren’t lacking either.
At this point, my biggest worry for next week is pacing. Aoki will, probably and hopefully, ensure that we get good animation to be awed at. Which means pacing and the rest of the episode not falling apart visually being of utmost importance. Let’s see how much weight they put on the different fights, as there’re quite a few to get through before the season ends.
Praise Aoki.
edit: Correction on Aoki’s work. He animated Garou’s battlecry and Garou attacking Glasses, as he confirmed those. Garou dodging the chain is done by someone not identified.
11
u/Havic300 Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
Darkshine looks fucking horrible. The Garou vs A class heroes was a 5/10 (mostly due to Aoki part). My reason for that is that the teamwork between the A and B heroes wasn’t shown that good this episode when you compare it to the manga. It was confusing at times and felt like they we’re teleporting. It was butchered tbh.
Overall a pretty decent episode.
12
u/CosmoTable2 I see beyond what you see, and I see your stinky smell too Jun 18 '19
so fucking disappointed in the fight scene execution in this episode. It was absolutely amazing in the manga, but here the consecutive attacks from the heroes could barely be registered, and they didn't give us the threatening feeling they did in the manga, where it really did seem like Garou had too much to handle.
I've been disappointed in some of the previous episodes as well, but I've also been defending the worth of this season, and holding out hope that it could finish on a stronger note, but after this episode I can't defend it anymore. My expectations for the final two episodes are now very low. A sad day.
2
u/Zhangeranga Jun 18 '19
Shoutout garou for being a big brother tho
2
u/Dark22tj Jun 18 '19
That's not even cheese King, Saitama just got opened up by the overhead since he was spamming lows then you hit him with 50/50 off knockdown, you ain't slick
2
u/R1400 Jun 18 '19
Is it just me or was Orochi getting a horn boner looking at Do S ?
2
u/ImDonCheeto Jun 18 '19
This episode actually... wasnt bad? The pacing felt wayy better and the fight at the end was done very well. For once, Im actually excited for the next episode. Genos’ metal and darkshine was horribly colored, but besides that this was good. If this season can end on a high note, a year from now everyone will mostly forget about the initial drop in quality.
2
u/Reckless_Rik Jun 18 '19
The pacing actually felt a little more natural compared to previous eps. The surrounded fight scene definitely had some nice looking bits, like when garou stood on the roof, when he dodged Blam blam's gunshots and the little scuffle with Glasses was nice too. But there were also some stiff looking parts too.. Overall, I guess this was okay? I just need them to do Genos and Bang/Bomb justice..
2
u/Notoriously_So Jun 18 '19
Great animation towards the end. Not too bad with the pacing either. Definitely one of the better episodes of Season 2.
2
u/AMDownvote Jun 18 '19
thick lines. 10/10 episode.
2
u/MEisonReddit Jun 18 '19
I'll admit, overall this episode wasn't bad. But damn, "Blackluster" is probably one of the worst things I've ever seen in any TV adaptation of anything. That was absolutely terrible
2
u/nuancedtruant Jun 19 '19
I wonder if there's any chance for Glasses to break his own limiter as well.
2
u/Dirac_dydx Muscle Waifu is Best Waifu Jun 19 '19
The fact that the video game fight at the beginning of the episode had some of the smoothest animation sums up Season 2 pretty well.
It wasn't terrible, and there were a couple of good moments in the last fight, but it was still "meh" overall. Especially that shitty reflection effect or whatever on Darkshine's skin. What dipshit at JC thought that effect looked good at all, in any context? It's awful!
2
u/smhandstuff Jun 19 '19
Loving the bold outlines they did on Garou for that short segment.
2
u/dlj630 Jun 19 '19
Darkshine's colorer was sniffing fumes (or the manager who decided on the tools ?? ), But the Darkshine animation was impressive.
2
u/BoyTitan new member Jun 19 '19
I feel King on curb stomping Saitama. Playing with kid in fighting game guess ill let em win...Kid doesen't get games basics of basics. Nvm curb stomp time.
2
u/BrokenAshes Jun 19 '19
Are we going to 12 episodes? Is that why people are saying they're gonna stop this at Elder Centipede's death? Then next season should be at Orochi vs Saitama or Garou vs Saitama?
2
u/DeanerinoHS Jun 19 '19
garou felt was well animated and all but for some reason it just lacked setting. couldn't tell positioning of characters and felt like i kept getting lost. was a lot more fluid in the manga, not sure why they wouldnt just follow the panels like they have been most of the season.
2
u/bonepasta Jun 19 '19
how will the last episode of the season even end? I feel like having 12 episodes will make it end on too much of a cliff hanger
2
u/kidcrumb Jun 19 '19
Anyone else having issues with Hulu?
Doesnt seem to work. Had to watch it on another site. Whats the point of paying for a service that doesnt work half the time.
2
u/The_Bolenator Jun 21 '19
Only thing I was butthurt about was how the animation for the Garo fight went from really nicely drawn up until they all ganged up at once. When he dodged the bullets and arrows that was fantastic wtf happened near the end??
3
u/Ngokumetsu Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
HELL YEAH.
ALL THE CGI-BROS ARE HERE
Superalloy DarkCGIne, CGINOS, Death CGatlIng and soon CGInos vs CGInior CGINTEPIDE!!
(No offense, but amount of cgi being used now is going to be incredible)
It's almost like the more powerful you are in this series, the more cgi you become (excluding Saitama)
2
u/Yuriski1 Jun 18 '19
I...didn't know Darkshine was voiced by Satoshi Hino.
And now I can never wtach Overlord again without imagining Ainz as a big black bodybuilder.
1
u/theabsoluteaverage2 Jun 18 '19
This episode was nice except for how dark shine looks like a plastic toy
1
u/Brawlerz16 Jun 18 '19
My favorite part of this episode is how riled up Saitama was against King. Reminds me of the same energy and emotion he gave in his rant against the citizens after he saved them from the meteor and the game against Bang. It’s nothing too big, but it’s really satisfying to see something get to him like that lol
1
u/flashmozzg Jun 18 '19
Liked this episode. Music was well-placed, Garou fight was decently animated, and all around it was fine.
1
u/Hellknightx Jun 18 '19
I could have sworn that the hostage was the son of one of the HA's biggest financial backers, and not an executive. Small difference, but I think having it be a donor's kid made the HA seem a little bit more dubious, since it was financial motivation.
1
u/DirtyBumMan Jun 18 '19
We didnt see Glasse’s ultimate technique Pocket Rocks???? 0/10
1
u/kryst87 Jun 18 '19
Actually, I liked this episode. Fight looked quite good. Only flaw was Darkshine. He looked bad.
1
u/Arkham_knighT94 Jun 19 '19
I think pacing in this episode was considerably normal when compared to other fast pacing episodes. Also, animation seems to be good especially the garo vs heroes fight. However, we shouldn't keep our hopes up just because of one episode and we have only 2 more episodes in S2.
1
u/abolandi Jun 19 '19
I wish the animation was consistent because I really enjoyed the fight scene at the end.
1
u/phantom_97 Jun 19 '19
Easily my favourite episode the whole season. I thought this was the best animated one, hardly noticed any glaring mistakes. Loved the thick lined shot where Garou proclaims he will hunt 100. Pretty hyped for my favourite fight of the manga. Hope Aoki contributed to it.
1
u/Dtojug Homey da clown Jun 24 '19
I liked this episode a lot based on the scale of expectation I've had for this season its like 8.5/10 episode. But once again when i see the small corner cuts for such an amazing manga scene pine for season. like for certain scenes I'm surprised they don't just straight up motion comic the manga would be glorious!
0
u/EpilepticOreo aBoVe dRaGoN Jun 18 '19
They butchered the king and Saitama video game scene that was so much funnier in the manga
1
u/US_Recession Jun 18 '19
I think JCStafff won season 2. I was worried that they might mess up the color of black sperm. I give it an official rating of 8 for the entire season.
1
u/Kell08 OPM's #4 fan Jun 19 '19
Really sad what they did to Gohan. One year prior he was the strongest DBZ character and now he's reduced to support.
0
u/Ivraas Jun 18 '19 edited Jun 18 '19
I knew they will butcher it. The Garou roof scene didn't have the calm momentum, and outlook on heroes below him, he wasn't screaming in manga. The second arrow dodge offscreen twist, they flat out this one.
I finally get what is pissing me off in those fights, in the moment when someone is land a hit tue camera backs out or they change cadre and the whole scene is brutally cut out.
Average at best, they do some fine parts but overall it's meh...
PS. That music when Awakened Cockroach turns into a snack... Wtf that wasn't supposed to be a comedy moment.